United States Court of Appeals

Ms. Anisha Sasheen Dasgupta Federal Trade Commission Office of the General Counsel 600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

Mr. Matthew Michael Hoffman Federal Trade Commission Office of the General Counsel 600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

Dear Ms. Dasgupta, and Mr. Hoffman, Enclosed is a copy of the judgment issued as the mandate and a copy of the court’s opinion.

Mr. Benjamin Atlas Mr. James A. Barta Mr. Kathleen W. Bradish Mr. Frank H Chang Mr. Kirk Cooper Mr. Orlando Economos Mr. Michael Egge Mr. Steven Engel Mr. Donald Falk Mr. Gregory George Garre Mr. Adam Gershenson Mr. Chad Golder Ms. Brianne Jenna Gorod Ms. Sharonmoyee Goswami Mr. Seth David Greenstein Mr. Jeffrey Matthew Harris Ms. Kathleen R. Hartnett Mr. Luke Hasskamp Mr. Lee Hepner Mr. David Johnson Mr. Stephen Blake Kinnaird Mr. Jeffrey A. Lamken Ms. Sara Ellen Margolis Mr. David Marriott Mr. John Mercer Masslon II Mr. Michael H. McGinley Mr. Michael David Pepson Mr. Alfred Carroll Pfeiffer Jr. Ms. Anna M. Rathbun Mr. John Reeves Mr. Antony Ryan Mr. Nicolas Sansone Mr. Bilal Sayyed Mr. Benjamin M. Seel Ms. Marguerite M. Sullivan Mr. Zachary Tripp Ms. Katherine Van Dyck Ms. Christine Varney Mr. Jesse Weiss Mr. Michael J. Zaken

... it needed to “affirmatively show[]” why 15 As explained above, the Commission majority erroneously viewed the Open Offer as a remedy to be properly considered only “at the remedy stage, following a finding of liability.” Nonetheless, ...

The Commission determined that none of Illumina’s proposed efficiencies were cognizable.