Appellants, Younesse Alami, Simon M. Adell, Matthew Anderson, Matthew Asher, Daniel Baker, Marie Baker, Matthew and Christina Bare, Andre Bauer, Peter Bierce, Brandon Blount, Barbara Brass, Richard T. Brewer, Sigrid Anne Eilertson, Reginald P. Brown IV, Mary Cahill, Ryan Cockrell, Kevin and Virginia Conlon, Anne Marie Crevar, Christina Cross, Darryl J Damico, Labar Daniel, Stephen Darwak, Lindsay Davenport, Mary Dickerson, Maxwell Streeter, Kathleen Dougherty, David Dressman, Anna Dressman, Michael Elder, Christopher Scott Farley, Michele Ghastin, Timnah Giller, Virginia Geller, Ryan Gih‘eatlr, Sonya Gih‘eath, Kimberly Glenn, Shaun Halsor, Josephine Rex, Arthur Halvo‘rson, Andrew Halvor‘son, Linda Hancock, Laura Hyatt, Mike Harrel, Nathan Herring, James Hicks Jr., Laurie Hicks, Preston G Hipp, Colin Jones, Matthew F. Jones, Robert C. Jones, Robin Joseph, Molly Keeler, John Kenny, Mandi Walters, Abigail King, Aaron Kless, Laurie Kramer, Robert Kramer, Allison ICreutzer, Benjamin Levitt, Richard Levitt, Jesse Lutz, Nikou Manouchehri, Thomas Naselaris, Zoe Naselaris, Beau O'Steen, Cori O'Steen, Lance Parr, Brandon Perdue, Amanda Lee Raymer, Hadassah Rothenberg, Daniel Ryan, Kimberly Bowlin, Kevin Schnittker, Ginger Scofield, Indedit Singh, Avtar Singh, Alecia Stevens, Lee Stevens, Justin Swan, Merrick Teichman, John Van Vlack, Jr, William Waterhouse, Jennifer Waterhouse, Anne Wotheil, Bryan Young, AJB Trust, Anthony & Jacqueline Bradley, Trustees, Tinhorn Family Trust, Helene Kenny / Bridget Kenny Revocable Trust, Wilhelmina M. Wieters Life Estate Childrens Trust, 33 Bogard Street LLC, 249 Cumming, LLC, 253 Coming Street LLC, 259 East Bay LLC, 259 East Bay 10 B LLC, 272 D Coming St. LLC, Café International, Inc, Comer At Old Canton, LLC, Geer Interests LLC, Kit Properties LLC, Lambert-Weiss LLC, The Naws LLC, New Lease Capital LLC, One Henrietta LLC, Periwinkle Partners, Ulf, Porch Properties LLC, Westbury Properties, LLC, and Westendorff Hardware

Of whom Defendants, Yotmesse Alami, Simon M. Adell, Matthew Anderson, Matthew Asher, Andre Bauer, Peter Bierce, Brandon Blount, Reginald P. Brown IV, Mary Cahill, Ryan Cockrell, Kevin and Virginia Conlon, Anne Marie Crevar, Darryl J Damieo, Stephen Darwak, Lindsay Davenport, Mary Dickerson, Maxwell Streeter, Kathleen Dougherty, David Dressman, Lindsay Davenport, Kathleen Dougherty, David Dressman, Anna Dressman, Michael Elder, Christopher Scott Farley, Michele Ghastin, Ryan Gih‘eath, Sonya Giheath, Kimberly Glenn, Shaun Halsor, Josephine Rex, Laura Hyatt, Nathan Herring, James Hicks Jr., Laurie Hicks, Preston G Hipp, Cohn Jones, Matthew P. Jones, Robert C. Jones, Robin Joseph, Molly Keeler, John Kenny, Abigail King, Aaron Kless, Laurie Kramer, Robert Kramer, Allison Kreutzer, Jesse Lutz, Thomas Naselaris, Zoe Naselaris, Beau O'Steen, Cori O'Steen, Lance Parr, Brandon Perdue, Hadassah Rothenberg, Daniel Ryan, Kimberly Bowfm, Kevin Schnittker, Ginger Scofield, Alecia Stevens, Justin Swan, Merrick Teichman, John Van Vlack, Jr, William Waterhouse, Jennifer Waterhouse, Anne Wohlfeil, Bryan Young, Helene Kenny / Bridget Kenny Revocable Trust, 259 East Bay LLC, 259 East Bay 10 B LLC, Corner At Old Canton, LLC, Kit Properties LLC, The Naws LLC, One Henrietta LLC, Periwinkle Partners, LLC, Porch Properties LLC, Westbury Properties, LLC, and Westendorff Hardware LLC are Respondents.

I hereby certify that on April 29, 2019 I served a copy of the Respondent’s Initial Designation of Matter to the following: Sean K. Trundy Sean Kevin Trundy, LLC 1212 Wappoo Road Charleston, SC 29407 by placing a copy of said docunients in the United States mail with sufficient postage thereon on April 15, 2019 and again on April 29, 2019 (with a signature page included.)

Charleston, South Carolina Date: April 29, 2019 Nancy Bloodgood, Esquire

Bloodgood & Sanders, LLC 242 Mathis Ferry ROad, Suite 201 Mt.

SC Court OfAPPQaIS Charleston Development Company, LLC, Charleston Housing Company, LLC and NotSo Hostel, LLC, Appellants, v._ Younesse Alami, Simon M. Adel], Matthew Anderson, Matthew Asher, Daniel Baker, Marie Baker, Matthew and Christina Bare, Andre Bauer, Peter Bierce, Brandon Blount, Barbara Brass, Richard T. Brewer, Sigrid Anne Eilertson, Reginald P. Brown IV, Mary Cahill, Ryan Cockrell, Kevin and Virginia Conlon, Anne Marie Crevar, Christina Cross, Darryl J Damico, Labar Daniel, Stephen Darwak, Lindsay Davenport, Mary Dickerson, Maxwell Streeter, Kathleen Dougherty, David .Dressman, Anna ,Dressman, MichaelElder, Christopher Scott Farley, Michele.

Ghastin, Tirnnah Giller, Virginia Geller, Ryan Gilreath, Sonya Gilreath, Kimberly Glenn, Shaun Halsor, Josephine Rex, Arthur Halvorson, Andrew Halvorson, Linda Hancock, Laura Hyatt, Mike Hartel, Nathan Herring, James Hicks Jr., Laurie Hicks, Preston G Hipp, Colin Jones, Matthew F. Jones, Robert C. Jones, Robin Joseph, Molly Keeler, John Kenny, Mandi Walters, Abigail King, Aaron Kless, Laurie Kramer, Robert Kramer, Allison Kreutzer, Benjamin Levitt, Richard Levitt, Jesse Lutz, Nikou Manouchehri, Thomas Naselaris, Zoe Naselaris, Beau O’Steen, Cori O'Steen, Lance Parr, Brandon Perdue, Amanda Lee Raymer, Hadassah Rothenberg, Daniel Ryan, Kimberly Bowlin, Kevin Schnittker, Ginger Scofield, Inderjit Singh, Avtar Singh, Alecia Stevens, Lee Stevens, Justin Swan, Merrick Teichman, John Van Vlack, Jr, William Waterhouse, Jennifer Waterhouse, Anne Wohlfeil, Bryan Young, AJB Trust, Anthony & Jacqueline Bradley, Trustees, Hartshom Family Trust, Helene Kenny / Bridget Kenny

“The fact that the City has taken no action cannot affect the plaintiff‘s rights, since the same act may furnish the basis for both criminal and civil redress.” Momeier v. John McAlister Inc., 203 SC.

The Respondents write, “the plaintiffs in Momeier applied to the Zoning Board for a variance to allow their commercial business in a residential area before going to circuit court.” (Respondents’ Brief, p. 11).

[O]ne of the defendants about the year 1933 endeavored to purchase a residence on Rutledge Avenue known as the Ficken property, with the intention of moving the entire business there.

TEDB énuth Carolina (fllnutt of appeals

www.5ccourts.org April 24, 2019 Ms. Nancy Bloodgood, Esquire 242 Mathis Ferry Road Suite 201 Mt.

Pleasant SC 29464 Re: Charleston Development V. Younesse Alami Appellate Case No. 2018-001766 Dear Counsel: Upon reviewing your designation of matter, the following deficiency has been noted under the South Carolina Appellate Court Rules (SCACR), and must be corrected within ten (10) days of the date of this letter or your designation of matter will not be considered: 0 The document has not been signed as required by Rule 267(b), SCACR.

Very truly yours, cc: Sean Kevin Trundy, Esquire Mary Lee Briggs, Esquire Daniel Carson Boles, Esquire

Gregory Kenneth Voigt, Esquire Mallary Lauren Scheer, Esquire Michael Ashley Whitsitt, Esquire Stafford John McQuillin, III, Esquire Christopher L. Murphy, Esquire David B. Marvel, Esquire Beau O'Steen Cory O'Steen Allison Kreutzer Robert Kramer Laurie Kramer