CompassCare v. Hochul

22-1076 | U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit

Interested in this case?

Request a Demo Track this case, and find millions of cases like it, let us show you how.
Filed May 13, 2022
Terminated Jan. 2, 2025
Nature of Suit 3440 Civil Rights - Other
Original Case 19-cv-01409
Last Updated: 2 weeks, 4 days ago Show Interactive Timeline
Filing Date # Docket Text
1/24/2025
  • Motion for Judgment
JUDGMENT MANDATE, ISSUED.[3639876] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 01/24/2025 04:08 PM]
1/2/2025
  • Motion for Judgment
JUDGMENT, FILED.[3639009] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 01/02/2025 01:49 PM]
1/2/2025CERTIFIED ORDER, dated 01/02/2025, to NDNY (SYRACUSE), ISSUED.[3638988] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 01/02/2025 09:10 AM]
1/2/2025OPINION, affirming in part, vacating in part and remanding for further proceedings consistent with this opinion, by BDP, MP, SALM, FILED.[3638984] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 01/02/2025 09:03 AM]
1/2/2025NEW CASE MANAGER, Atasha Joseph, ASSIGNED.[3638982] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 01/02/2025 08:53 AM]
9/27/202499ATTORNEY, Andrea Oser for Kathy Hochul Letitia James Roberta Reardon, [98], ADDED.[3634748] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 09/27/2024 10:18 AM]
9/23/2024NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 09/23/2024 by CM/ECF. [3634476] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 09/23/2024 02:51 PM]
5/12/2024FRAP 28(j) LETTER, dated 05/12/2024, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, RECEIVED. Service date 05/12/2024 by CM/ECF.[3622938] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/12/2024 10:09 AM]
1/5/2024FRAP 28(j) LETTER, dated 01/05/2024, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, RECEIVED. Service date 01/05/2024 by CM/ECF.[3602056] [22-1076] [Entered: 01/05/2024 11:23 AM]
12/14/202393CASE, before BDP, MP, SALM, HEARD.[3598244] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 12/14/2023 12:04 PM]
12/11/202392ATTORNEY, David Andrew Cortman for National Institute of Family and Life Advocates First Bible Baptist Church CompassCare, in case 22-951 David Andrew Cortman for National Institute of Family and Life Advocates First Bible Baptist Church CompassCare, in case 22-1076 , [91], ADDED.[3597392] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 12/12/2023 09:18 AM]
12/7/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee National Institute of Family and Life Advocates, CompassCare and First Bible Baptist Church in 22-951, Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 12/07/2023 by CM/ECF. [3596469] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 12/07/2023 10:59 AM]
11/28/202390ATTORNEY, Jonathan Caleb Dalton for National Institute of Family and Life Advocates First Bible Baptist Church CompassCare, in case 22-951 Jonathan Caleb Dalton for National Institute of Family and Life Advocates First Bible Baptist Church CompassCare, in case 22-1076 , [89], ADDED.[3593810] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 11/28/2023 03:07 PM]
11/17/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 11/17/2023 by CM/ECF. [3591164] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 11/17/2023 10:19 AM]
11/1/2023NOTICE OF HEARING DATE ACKNOWLEDGMENT, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. Service date 11/01/2023 by CM/ECF. [3586555] [22-1076] [Entered: 11/01/2023 02:07 PM]
11/1/2023ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[3586419] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 11/01/2023 10:57 AM]
10/11/202386CASE CALENDARING, for argument on 12/14/2023, B Panel, SET.[3579887] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 10/11/2023 12:26 PM]
9/12/202380CASE CALENDARING, for the week of 12/11/2023, PANEL B, PROPOSED.[3567738] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 09/12/2023 03:52 PM]
8/28/2023
  • Reply
REPLY BRIEF, on behalf of Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, FILED. Service date 08/28/2023 by CM/ECF. [3562035] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 08/28/2023 04:00 PM]
8/21/2023ORAL ARGUMENT STATEMENT LR 34.1 (a), on behalf of filer Attorney Jacob P. Warner, Esq. for Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 08/21/2023 by CM/ECF. [3559182] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 08/21/2023 02:38 PM]
8/14/2023ORAL ARGUMENT STATEMENT LR 34.1 (a), on behalf of filer Attorney Ms. Laura Etlinger, Esq. for Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, Attorney Ms. Laura Etlinger, Esq. for Appellant Kathy Hochul, Roberta Reardon and Letitia James in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 08/14/2023 by CM/ECF. [3555994] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 08/14/2023 11:40 AM]
8/7/2023
  • Reply
REPLY BRIEF, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 08/07/2023 by CM/ECF. [3552947] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 08/07/2023 08:16 PM]
7/20/202369ATTORNEY, Arijeet Sensharma for New York Civil Liberties Union American Civil Liberties Union, in case 22-951 Arijeet Sensharma for New York Civil Liberties Union American Civil Liberties Union, in case 22-1076 , [66], ADDED.[3544588] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 07/20/2023 02:20 PM]
7/20/202368ATTORNEY, Aditi Fruitwala for New York Civil Liberties Union American Civil Liberties Union, in case 22-951 Aditi Fruitwala for New York Civil Liberties Union American Civil Liberties Union, in case 22-1076 , [65], ADDED.[3544582] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 07/20/2023 02:14 PM]
7/17/202367NEW PARTY, Amicus Curiae American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union in 22-1076 and Amicus Curiae American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union in 22-951, ADDED.[3542659] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 07/17/2023 04:07 PM]
7/13/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union, FILED. Service date 07/13/2023 by CM/ECF. [3540921] [22-951, 22-1076]--[Edited 07/20/2023 by BM] [Entered: 07/13/2023 12:50 PM]
7/13/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union, FILED. Service date 07/13/2023 by CM/ECF. [3540912] [22-951, 22-1076]--[Edited 07/20/2023 by BM] [Entered: 07/13/2023 12:37 PM]
7/13/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of American Civil Liberties Union and New York Civil Liberties Union , FILED. Service date 07/13/2023 by CM/ECF. [3540834] [22-951, 22-1076]--[Edited 07/20/2023 by BM] [Entered: 07/13/2023 10:57 AM]
7/6/2023BRIEF, on behalf of Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, FILED. Service date 07/06/2023 by CM/ECF. [3538233] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 07/06/2023 10:48 PM]
4/18/2023
  • Order
SO-ORDERED SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, setting Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951 Brief due date as 07/06/2023, FILED.[3501149] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/18/2023 03:37 PM]
4/12/2023LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-1076, informing Court of proposed due date 07/06/2023, RECEIVED. Service date 04/12/2023 by CM/ECF.[3498078] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/12/2023 11:46 AM]
4/6/2023SPECIAL APPENDIX, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 04/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3495717] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/06/2023 06:51 PM]
4/6/2023JOINT APPENDIX, volume 2 of 2, (pp. 184-417), on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 04/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3495716] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/06/2023 06:50 PM]
4/6/2023JOINT APPENDIX, volume 1 of 2, (pp. 1-183), on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 04/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3495714] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/06/2023 06:49 PM]
4/6/2023BRIEF, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 04/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3495713] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 04/06/2023 06:48 PM]
3/9/202345ATTORNEY, Kevin Theriot for National Institute of Family and Life Advocates First Bible Baptist Church CompassCare, in case 22-951 , [43], ADDED.[3481259] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/09/2023 05:00 PM]
3/9/2023
  • Order
SO-ORDERED SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, setting Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951 Brief due date as 04/07/2023 FILED.[3481239] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/09/2023 04:52 PM]
3/9/2023NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 03/09/2023 by CM/ECF. [3480777] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/09/2023 10:51 AM]
3/7/2023CERTIFIED ORDER, dated 03/07/2023, to NDNY (SYRACUSE), ISSUED.[3479496] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/07/2023 03:20 PM]
3/7/2023
  • Order
ORDER, lifting the stay of appeal(s) in 22-951, 22-1076, FILED.[3479488] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/07/2023 03:15 PM]
3/6/2023LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-1076, Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, informing Court of proposed due date 07/07/2023, RECEIVED. Service date 03/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3478720] [22-1076, 22-951] [Entered: 03/06/2023 03:45 PM]
3/6/2023LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, informing Court of proposed due date 04/07/2023, RECEIVED. Service date 03/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3478705] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 03/06/2023 03:34 PM]
3/6/2023LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-1076, Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, informing Court of proposed due date 08/29/2023, RECEIVED. Service date 03/06/2023 by CM/ECF.[3478624] [22-1076, 22-951] [Entered: 03/06/2023 02:41 PM]
6/3/2022CERTIFIED ORDER, dated 06/03/2022, to NDNY (SYRACUSE), ISSUED.[3326207] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 06/03/2022 10:46 AM]
6/3/2022
  • MotionGranted
MOTION ORDER, granting motion to hold appeal in abeyance [27] filed by Appellant-Cross-Appellee National Institute of Family and Life Advocates, CompassCare and First Bible Baptist Church. The parties further request that they be allowed to file revised scheduling notification letters within seven days of the Court’s decision Slattery v. Cuomo, No. 21-911 by SJM, FILED. [3326183][33] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 06/03/2022 10:35 AM]
5/31/2022SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO MOTION [27], on behalf of Appellee-Cross-Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-951, Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 05/31/2022 by CM/ECF.[3323636][29] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/31/2022 01:44 PM]
5/26/2022
  • Motion
MOTION, to hold appeal in abeyance, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED. Service date 05/26/2022 by CM/ECF. [3322259] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/26/2022 02:54 PM]
5/26/2022LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, informing Court of proposed due date 08/10/2022, RECEIVED. Service date 05/26/2022 by CM/ECF.[3321813] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/26/2022 10:14 AM]
5/17/2022NEW CASE MANAGER, Brenda Mojica, ASSIGNED.[3316191] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/17/2022 09:57 AM]
5/16/202219CURED DEFECTIVE NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, [3315518-2], [13], on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED.[3315813] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/16/2022 03:37 PM]
5/16/2022DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Notice of Appearance as Additional Counsel, [9], on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, FILED.[3315267] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/16/2022 09:01 AM]
5/15/2022FORM C, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. Service date 05/15/2022 by CM/ECF.[3315219] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/15/2022 12:24 PM]
5/15/2022FORM D, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. Service date 05/15/2022 by CM/ECF.[3315218] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/15/2022 11:54 AM]
5/13/2022ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. Service date 05/13/2022 by CM/ECF.[3315117] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 05:20 PM]
5/13/20229NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant-Cross-Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-951, Appellee CompassCare, First Bible Baptist Church and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in 22-1076, FILED. Service date 05/13/2022 by CM/ECF. [3315109] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 05:04 PM]
5/13/20228ATTORNEY, Laura Etlinger, [7], in place of attorney Barbara D. Underwood, SUBSTITUTED.[3315088] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 04:44 PM]
5/13/2022NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. Service date 05/13/2022 by CM/ECF. [3314975] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 03:39 PM]
5/13/20226NOTE: See lead case, 22-951, containing complete set of docket entries.[3314883] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:44 PM]
5/13/2022CAPTION, to reflect party designation changes in re: cross appeal, AMENDED.[3314879] [22-951, 22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:41 PM]
5/13/2022ELECTRONIC INDEX, in lieu of record, FILED.[3314867] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:32 PM]
5/13/2022DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT, dated 04/01/2022, RECEIVED.[3314865] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:31 PM]
5/13/20222PAYMENT OF DOCKETING FEE, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, district court receipt # ANYNDC-5902976, FILED.[3314862] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:30 PM]
5/13/2022NOTICE OF CIVIL CROSS APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Kathy Hochul, Letitia James and Roberta Reardon, FILED. [3314856] [22-1076] [Entered: 05/13/2022 02:27 PM]