`
`
`
`Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
`Argument Index – May 2020
`
`VIA VIDEOCONFERENCE
`LIVESTREAM VIEWING LINKS FOR EACH PANEL PROVIDED BELOW
`
`Beginning: 5/11/2020
`Ending: 5/15/2020
`This list is subject to frequent changes.
`
`
`
`05/11/2020 1:00 pm
`M4 Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Lake Harmony Estates Property Owners' Association
`05/11/2020 1:00 pm
`M4 Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Lake Harmony Estates Property Owners' Association
`05/11/2020 1:00 pm
`M4 Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Lake Harmony Estates Property Owners' Association
`05/11/2020 1:20 pm
`Office of the Governor v. Lindsey Wanner and The Fairness Center
`SUBMITTED
`The Links at Gettysburg Land Company, Inc. v. Board of Supervisors of Mount Joy Township
`SUBMITTED
`The Links at Gettysburg Land Company, Inc. v. Board of Supervisors of Mount Joy Township
`SUBMITTED
`The Links at Gettysburg Land Company, Inc. v. Board of Supervisors of Mount Joy Township
`Mark Kiddo, et al. v. American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Local 2206; et al. 05/11/2020 1:40 pm
`SUBMITTED
`Allen C. Bender, et al. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Transportation, et al.
`SUBMITTED
`Amy Westerman v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`SUBMITTED
`Monroe Township v. Eric Sollenberger, Courtney Sollenberger, and 1181 Creekside Manor
`Patricia J. Kabel v. Manheim Township School District
`05/11/2020 2:10 pm
`SUBMITTED
`Chad Ross v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`SUBMITTED
`Zachary N. Gordon, Esquire v. Selinsgrove Borough
`SUBMITTED
`Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry v. Chester Darlington
`SUBMITTED
`D. B. v. Department of Human Services
`
`
`Panel 1 – Argument Session Begins at 1:00 p.m. – Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/AZXUpl0AA78
`
` 902 CD 2019
`1-05-2020
`1197 CD 2019
`1a-05-2020
`1424 CD 2019
`1b-05-2020
`1453 CD 2019
`2-05-2020
`1006 CD 2019
`3-05-2020
`1007 CD 2019
`4-05-2020
`1008 CD 2019
`5-05-2020
` 468 CD 2019
`6-05-2020
` 77 CD 2019
`7-05-2020
`1019 CD 2019
`8-05-2020
`1434 CD 2019
`9-05-2020
`1037 CD 2019
`10-05-2020
` 408 CD 2019
`11-05-2020
`12-05-2020 866 CD 2019
`13-05-2020
`1583 CD 2019
`14-05-2020
`1449 CD 2019
`
`Panel 2 – Argument Session Begins at 1:00 p.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/o6O0UsBzENY
`
`15-05-2020
`16-05-2020
`17-05-2020
`18-05-2020
`19-05-2020
`
` 1167 CD 2019
` 739 CD 2019
` 1264 CD 2019
` 738 CD 2019
` 974 CD 2019
`
`Eastern University Academy Charter School v. School District of Philadelphia
`Shree Santram, LLC and Riddhi Siddhi, LLC v. City of Wilkes-Barre Zoning Hearing Board
`Julian Mihaita, et al. v. Department of Labor and Industry, Office of UC Tax Services
`Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. 2012 Mazda 323 Sedan VIN #JM1BL1VF8C1514566
`Anthony Abbonizio, et al. v. City of Philadelphia and Thomas P. Carney, Inc.
`
`SUBMITTED
`05/11/2020 1:00 pm
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`
`

`

`05/11/2020 1:20 pm
`Conrad Weiser Area School District v. Wyomissing Area School District
`05/11/2020 1:20 pm
`Conrad Weiser Area School District v. Wyomissing Area School District
`05/11/2020 1:40 pm
`United Blower, Inc. v. Lycoming County Water and Sewer Authority
`05/11/2020 2:10 pm
`Harrisburg Area Community College v. Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission
`SUBMITTED
`D&R Sports, Inc. v Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
`SUBMITTED
`Friendship Community, Inc. v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`Rostislav Krasnov, D.D.S. v. Bureau of Professional and Occupational Affairs, State Board of Dentistry SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`Pinnacle Health Hospitals v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review,
`SUBMITTED
`Hazleton Area School District v. Central Columbia School District
`Borough of Gettysburg v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters, Local 776, Police Labor Organization SUBMITTED
`
`SUBMITTED
`Colleen DeLuca v. Mountaintop Area Joint Sanitary Authority and Thomas G. Keiper
`05/12/2020 1:00 pm
`Frank T. Perano, et al. v. The Berks County Tax Claim Bureau
`SUBMITTED
`Susan M. Hartman v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`05/12/2020 1:40 pm
`In Re: Mary Stitzer, Individually and in her Capacity as Treasurer of East Union Township, et al.
`05/12/2020 1:40 pm
`In Re: Mary Stitzer, Individually and in her Capacity as Treasurer of East Union Township, et al.
`SUBMITTED
`Barbara A. Triebel v. Berks County Tax Claim Bureau and Chad G. Hurst
`SUBMITTED
`Colleen DeLuca v. Mountaintop Area Joint Sanitary Authority and Thomas G. Keiper
`SUBMITTED
`Brenner Car Credit v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`SUBMITTED
`Ricardo Suriel and Damaris Espinal v. Berks County Tax Claim Bureau v. Saul E. Sibri
`05/12/2020 2:10 pm
`Brian Ganoe v. Commonwealth of PA, Department of Transportation, Bureau of Driver Licensing
`05/12/2020 2:30 pm
`Gentex Corporation v. Department of Revenue
`Cheri Ann Leinberger, et al. v. Anthony G. Stellar, as Trustee of the Deborah E. Stellar Revocable Trust 05/12/2020 2:50 pm
`SUBMITTED
`P.L. v. Department of Human Services
`Pennsylvania Manufacturers' Association Insurance Company v. Johnson Matthey, Inc., et al.
`05/12/2020 3:10 pm
`
` 846 CD 2019
` 884 CD 2019
` 1383 CD 2019
` 654 CD 2019
` 25 FR 2018
` 1553 CD 2019
` 1113 CD 2019
` 1277 CD 2019
` 757 CD 2019
` 1460 CD 2019
`
`26-05-2020
`26a-05-2020
`20-05-2020
`21-05-2020
`22-05-2020
`23-05-2020
`24-05-2020
`25-05-2020
`27-05-2020
`28-05-2020
`
`Panel 1 – Argument Session Begins at 1:00 p.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/0YBr0WXiwMM
`
`29-05-2020 1024 CD 2019
`30-05-2020
` 1097 CD 2019
`31-05-2020
` 985 CD 2019
`33-05-2020
` 1339 CD 2019
`33a-05-2020
` 1340 CD 2019
`34-05-2020
` 485 CD 2019
`35-05-2020
` 1405 CD 2019
`36-05-2020
` 956 CD 2019
`37-05-2020
` 662 CD 2019
`38-05-2020
` 648 CD 2019
`39-05-2020
` 1091 CD 2018
`40-05-2020
` 1620 CD 2017
`41-05-2020
` 1047 CD 2019
`32-05-2020
` 330 MD 2015
`
`Panel 2 – Argument Session Begins at 1:00 p.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/hqkNZJRMeEk
`
`42-05-2020
`43-05-2020
`44-05-2020
`45-05-2020
`46-05-2020
`47-05-2020
`
` 807 CD 2019
` 715 CD 2019
` 934 CD 2019
` 1171 CD 2019
` 1046 CD 2019
` 719 CD 2019
`
`Ruth L. Kneebone v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Township of Plainfield, et al.
`Suburban Realty, L.P. v. Stroud Township Zoning Hearing Board, et al.
`Briar Hill North Association, Inc. v. Helen M. Kuzmack, et al.
`In Re: 2018 Upset Tax Sale Lorraine S. Everett v. Monroe County Tax Claim Bureau, et al.
`Bennington Investment Group, LLC v. Department of Environmental Protection
`Franke E. Beishline, et al. v. Commonwealth of PA, Department of Environmental Protection; et al.
`
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`05/12/2020 1:00 pm
`SUBMITTED
`
`

`

`Pennsylvania State Corrections Officers Association (David Panfil) v. Commonwealth of PA, DOC
`Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board v. The Honorable Frank Burns
`Muncy Valley Hospital v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`Lancaster County Children and Youth Social Services Agency v. Department of Human Services
`Children and Youth Services for the County of Berks v. Department of Human Services
`
`1054 CD 2019
` 714 CD 2019
` 624 CD 2019
`1312 CD 2018
` 661 MD 2018
`
`Blue Pilot Energy, LLC v. Public Utility Commission
`Howard Podejko, et al. v. Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
`PPL Electric Utilities Corporation v. Public Utility Commission
`E. W. v. Department of Human Services
`SEALED
`
` 150 CD 2018
` 649 CD 2019
`1259 CD 2019
` 880 CD 2019
` 775 CD 2019
`
`City of Erie v. General Teamsters Local Union No. 397 (Kelly Kirsch)
`Scott Zimmerman v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`Betty Bell, an adult individual, and Propel Schools, et al. v. Wilkinsburg School District
`Edward J. O'Donnell v Allegheny County North Tax Collection Committee, et al.
`Indiana University of Pennsylvania v. Jefferson County BAA v. Punxsutawney Area Sch. Dist., et al.
`
`48-05-2020 1057 CD 2019
`49-05-2020
`1159 CD 2019
`50-05-2020
` 730 CD 2019
`51-05-2020
`1255 CD 2019
`52-05-2020
`1061 CD 2019
`
`En Banc – Argument Session Begins at 9:30 a.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/zoQ0Wl6kSlc
`
`53-05-2020
`54-05-2020
`55-05-2020
`56-05-2020
`57-05-2020
`
`En Banc – Argument Session Begins at 9:30 a.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/N9_U_yqPtoA
`
`58-05-2020
`59-05-2020
`60-05-2020
`61-05-2020
`62-05-2020
`
`Panel 1 – Argument Session Begins at 11:00 a.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/xg1m4DEekEg
`
`63-05-2020
`64-05-2020
`65-05-2020
`66-05-2020
`67-05-2020
`68-05-2020
`69-05-2020
`70-05-2020
`70a-05-2020
`71-05-2020
`72-05-2020
`
` 80 CD 2019
` 671 CD 2019
` 574 CD 2019
`1001 CD 2019
`1222 CD 2019
`1058 CD 2019
`1060 CD 2019
`1000 CD 2019
`1009 CD 2019
` 920 CD 2019
` 642 CD 2019
`
`Smart Communications Holding, Inc. v. Bruce Wishnefsky
`Zelienople Borough v. Zelienople Borough Zoning Hearing Board and Thomas G. Myers
`Davaun Barnett v. Penn Hills School District
`In re: The Ellwood City Community Health Foundation, a Pennsylvania Nonprofit Corporation
`Linda Kovac v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board (GGNSC Murrysville LP)
`Karen Brockman, et al. v. Robinson Township Zoning Hearing Board v. Robinson Township, et al.
`In Re: Merger of: Universal Volunteer Fire Department into Point Breeze Volunteer Fire Association
`Robert J. Cummins, d/b/a Bob Cummins Construction Company v. Bradford Sanitary Authority
`Robert J. Cummins d/b/a Bob Cummins Construction Company v. Bradford Sanitary Authority
`Casey Ball Supports Coordination v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`Catherine A. Conley, an Individual v. County of Allegheny
`
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`05/12/2020 1:20 pm
`
`05/13/2020 9:30 am
`05/13/2020 10:10 am
`05/13/2020 10:50 am
`REMANDED
`05/13/2020 11:40 am
`
`05/14/2020 9:30 am
`05/14/2020 10:10 am
`05/14/2020 10:50 am
`05/14/2020 11:40 am
`05/14/2020 12:10 pm
`
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`05/15/2020 11:00 am
`DISCONTINUED
`DISCONTINUED
`05/15/2020 11:20 am
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`05/15/2020 11:40 am
`
`

`

` 695 CD 2019
`1579 CD 2019
`
`Catherine A. Conley, an Individual v. County of Allegheny
`Horvath Towers V, LLC v Indiana Township Board of Supervisors, et al.
`
`72a-05-2020
`73-05-2020
`
`Panel 2 – Argument Session Begins at 9:30 a.m. - Livestream Link: https://youtu.be/8fM0vyud-kg
`
`74-05-2020
`75-05-2020
`76-05-2020
`77-05-2020
`78-05-2020
`79-05-2020
`80-05-2020
`81-05-2020
`82-05-2020
`82a-05-2020
`83-05-2020
`84-05-2020
`
`
`Total: 91
`
`1381 CD 2019
`1300 CD 2019
` 228 CD 2019
`1757 CD 2019
`1368 CD 2019
`1414 CD 2019
`1237 CD 2019
`1215 CD 2019
` 822 CD 2019
` 823 CD 2019
`1299 CD 2019
` 466 CD 2019
`
`05/15/2020 11:40 am
`SUBMITTED
`
`SUBMITTED
`Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William and Nancy Clementi
`05/15/2020 9:30 am
`City of Pittsburgh v. Fraternal Order Of Police, Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1
`Penn Hills Sch. Dist. and Municipality of Penn Hills v. Kamaksh, Inc. v. Adelita Real Estate Dev., et al. SUBMITTED
`The City of Clairton, PA v. Zoning Hearing Board of the City of Clairton, PA, et al.
`05/15/2020 9:50 am
`SUBMITTED
`Anna Oakes, et al. v. Jeff Richardson, Individually and Richardson Inspection Services, LLC
`SUBMITTED
`Fraternal Order of Police, Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1 v. City of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
`In the Matter of : Condemnation by the Franklin Township Sewage Authority of Property of William Ott SUBMITTED
`SUBMITTED
`Citizens of Upper Woodmont Group v. Upper Yoder Township Zoning Hearing Board, et al.
`SUBMITTED
`Three Rivers Transportation v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`SUBMITTED
`Three Rivers Transportation v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review
`SUBMITTED
`City of Pittsburgh v. Fraternal Order Of Police, Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1
`SUBMITTED
`Borough of Duncansville v. Gregory M. Werstil
`
`