Information

Search millions of cases and get court filings, fast docket alerts, and case analytics.

Request a Demo or create your account.

Lawyer? Your firm may have a group account, ask us and we'll let you know.

Click below for detailed party information:

Patent Owner

Spero, Yechezkal

Petitioners

Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.Porsche Cars North America

alt+h	Toggle this page.
alt+u	Toggle Upcoming Events view.
alt+e	Export the docket to Excel.
Filtering / Searching the Docket
ctrl+f	Filter the docket.
ctrl+shift+f	Search docket and documents.
alt+s	Toggle between "Show Only" filtering modes.
alt+d, ctrl+f	System ctrl+f
escape	Clear while in docket filter.
Interactive Timeline
alt+t	Show / re-center case timeline.
alt+↑	Zoom in
alt+↓	Zoom out
alt+←	Pan left
alt+→	Pan right

Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. Spero, Yechezkal

IPR2023-00328 | Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Interested in this case?

Request a Demo Track this case, and find millions of cases like it, let us show you how.

Filed Dec. 16, 2022

Terminated July 15, 2024

Judges Aaron Moore, Jason Melvin, and Jon Jurgovan

Case Type Inter Partes Review

Status Final Written Decision - Appealed

Challenged Patent 15/961,861

Patent No. 10,894,503 assignments

Tech Center 2800

Art Unit 2844

Last Updated: 29 minutes ago

Filing Date	#	Filing and Exhibits
Entries matching. Show All.
10/30/2024	10-30-2024-Patent_Owner	Event: Notice of Appeal Patent Owner Notice: notice of appeal 45: Notice of Appeal
8/28/2024	08-28-2024-Board	Board Order Denying Director Review of Final Written Decision 44: Director Review denial on FWD
8/15/2024	08-15-2024-Board	Board Exhibit 3103: Ex. 3103
8/14/2024	08-14-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Request for Director Review - Final Written Decision 43: Patent Owners Request for Director Review IPR2023-00328
7/15/2024	07-15-2024-Board	Event: Final Written Decision (Some, Not All Claims Cancelled) Board Final Written Decision: original 42: Final Written Decision: original
6/13/2024	06-13-2024-Board	Board Other: Hearing transcript 41: Other: Hearing transcript
4/12/2024	04-12-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Notice: Exhibit list 40: Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List Petitioner Exhibit 1072: EX1072 - Petitioner's Demonstratives
4/12/2024	04-12-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Exhibit list 39: Updated Exhibit List & Demonstrative Patent Owner Exhibit 2029: Exhibit 2029 - Demonstrative
4/9/2024	04-09-2024-Board	Board Notice: Other 36: LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Patent Owner) Board Notice: Other 37: LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Petitioner)
4/9/2024	04-09-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Reply to Opposition 38: Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition to MTE
4/2/2024	04-02-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Opposition 35: Patent Owners Opposition to Motion to Exclude IPR2023-00328 Patent Owner Exhibit 2027: Ex. 2027 2023-08-14 Letter to Fitzsimmons re objections to evidence Patent Owner Exhibit 2028: Ex. 2028 2023-11-02 Letter to Fitzsimmons re objections to evidence
3/26/2024	03-26-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Motion: Other 34: Petitioner's Motion to Exclude
3/12/2024	03-12-2024-Board	Board Order: Other 33: Order Setting Oral Argument
3/5/2024	03-05-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Other: other 32: Patent Owner Request for Oral Argument IPR2023-00328
3/5/2024	03-05-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Other: other 31: Petitioner Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.'s Request for Oral Argument
2/16/2024	02-16-2024-Board	Events: Petition Institution (Granted), Motion for Joinder (Granted) Board Notice: Other 29: Institution decision and grant of joinder, IPR2023-01320
2/16/2024	02-16-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Other: other 30: Patent Owners Sur Reply to Petitioners Reply to Patent Owner Response 2023-00328 Patent Owner Exhibit 2026: Ex. 2026 Condensed Jiao Deposition Transcript
1/25/2024	01-25-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Other: other 28: Errata to Ex 2006 IPR2023-00328
1/18/2024	01-18-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Notice of deposition 27: Notice of Deposition of Jianzhong Jiao 2023-00328
1/16/2024	01-16-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Other: other 26: IPR2023-00328 Patent Owner Objection to Evidence
1/8/2024	01-08-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Pet Reply to PO Resp 25: Petitioner's Reply Petitioner Exhibit 1051: EX1051 - Jiao Reply Declaration Petitioner Exhibit 1052: EX1052 - Turk Deposition Transcript (IPR2023-00328) Petitioner Exhibit 1053: EX1053 - Turk Deposition Transcript (IPR2023-00315) Petitioner Exhibit 1054: EX1054 - Turk Deposition Transcript (IPR2022-01586) Petitioner Exhibit 1056: EX1056 - Spatial Light Modulators Petitioner Exhibit 1057: EX1057 - Turnbull US6132072 Petitioner Exhibit 1058: EX1058 - Allen US5754217 Petitioner Exhibit 1059: EX1059 - Handschy US6195136 Petitioner Exhibit 1062: EX1062 - Schellhorn US4907044 Petitioner Exhibit 1063: EX1063 - Leighty 1985 Petitioner Exhibit 1064: EX1064 - Lowrie 1985 Petitioner Exhibit 1065: EX1065 - Surface Vehicle Recommended Practice Petitioner Exhibit 1066: EX1066 - 49 CFR 571.108 Petitioner Exhibit 1067: EX1067 - SAEJ387.1987 Petitioner Exhibit 1068: EX1068 - The International System of Units (SI), Bureau International des Poids et Mesures, 7th Edit Petitioner Exhibit 1069: EX1069 - Surface Vehicle Standard Petitioner Exhibit 1070: EX1070 - Second Turk Declaration (IPR2023-00315)
1/4/2024	01-04-2024-Petitioner	Petitioner Notice: Other 24: Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 2 and 3
1/3/2024	01-03-2024-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Updated Mandatory Notice 23: Updated Mandatory Notice - IPR2023-00328 - 10894503
11/21/2023	11-21-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Notice: Notice of deposition 22: Petitioner's Notice of Deposition
10/19/2023	10-19-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Other: other 21: Petitioner's Objections to Evidence
10/12/2023	10-12-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner PO Response to Pet 20: Patent Owner Response to Petition Patent Owner Exhibit 2006: Supplemental Turk Declaration Patent Owner Exhibit 2007: Jiao Deposition Transcript Patent Owner Exhibit 2008: IPR2023-00318 Petition Patent Owner Exhibit 2009: IPR2023-00318 Jiao Declaration Patent Owner Exhibit 2010: SPIE Etendue concerns for automotive headlamps using white LEDs Jiao 2003 Patent Owner Exhibit 2011: Bass Handbook of Optics 3rd Edition Volume II 2010 Patent Owner Exhibit 2012: SAE Studies for Headlamp Optical Design Using LEDs Jiao 2004 Patent Owner Exhibit 2013: SAE Optical Transform Limitations in Headlamp Photometric Performance Jiao 2005 Patent Owner Exhibit 2015: SPIE High-efficiency reflector optics Volume 6670 Jiao 2007 Patent Owner Exhibit 2016: Navigant Energy Saving Estimates of Light Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications 2008 Patent Owner Exhibit 2017: WIPO Patent Publication WO005147A1 Flaaten Patent Owner Exhibit 2018: Jiao Deposition Transcript Condensed Patent Owner Exhibit 2020: Bass Handbook of Optics 3rd Edition Vol V_Excerpts 2010 Patent Owner Exhibit 2021: TI How DLP Technology Works Patent Owner Exhibit 2022: TI Intro to DMDs Patent Owner Exhibit 2025: Jiao Deposition Transcript
10/6/2023	10-06-2023-Board	Board Order Denying Director Review of Institution Decision 19: Order Denying Director Review Board Exhibit 3101: Ex. 3101 Board Exhibit 3102: Ex. 3102
9/20/2023	09-20-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Notice of deposition 18: Notice of Deposition of Jianzhong Jiao 2023-00328
8/30/2023	08-30-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Other: other 17: Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 1-2
8/28/2023	08-28-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Notice: Updated Mandatory Notice 16: Petitioner’s Updated Mandatory Notices
8/9/2023	08-09-2023-Board	Board Exhibit 3100: Ex. 3100 Request for Director Review
7/31/2023	07-31-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Rehearing request: Institution 15: Request for Rehearing IPR2023-00328
7/31/2023	07-31-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Other: other 14: Petitioner's Objections to Evidence
7/17/2023	07-17-2023-Board	Event: Petition Institution (Denied and Granted) Board Institution Decision: Grant 12: Institution Decision: DECISION Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 Board Order: Other 13: Order: Scheduling Order
6/9/2023	06-09-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Updated Mandatory Notice 11: Updated Mandatory Notice - 0114IPR - 10894503
6/7/2023	06-07-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Updated Mandatory Notice 10: Updated Mandatory Notice - 0114IPR - 10894503
5/16/2023	05-16-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Other 9: Patent Owner's Sur-Reply
5/9/2023	05-09-2023-Petitioner	Petitioner Other: other 8: Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Preliminary Response
4/19/2023	04-19-2023-Patent_Owner	Event: Preliminary Response Patent Owner POPR: filed 7: Preliminary Response to IPR2023-00328 Patent Owner Exhibit 2001: Ex 2001 Turk Declaration Patent Owner Exhibit 2002: Ex 2002 Turk CV Patent Owner Exhibit 2003: Ex 2003 Best Practices Patent Owner Exhibit 2004: Ex 2004 IPR2023-00197 - The '197 Petition Patent Owner Exhibit 2005: Ex 2005 IPR2023-00335 - The '335 Petition
4/18/2023	04-18-2023-Patent_Owner	Patent Owner Notice: Mandatory Notice 5: Notice : Mandatory Notice Patent Owner Notice: Power of Attorney 6: Notice : Power of Attorney
1/19/2023	01-19-2023-Board	Board Notice: Notice filing date accorded 3: Notice: NOTICE OF FILING DATE ACCORDED TO PETITION AND TIME FOR FILING PATENT OWNER PRELIMINARY RESPONSE Board Notice: Other 4: Notice: ERRATUM
12/16/2022	12-16-2022-Petitioner	Petitioner Notice: Power of Attorney 1: Petitioner's Power of Attorney Petitioner Petition: as filed 2: Petition for Inter Partes Review Petitioner Exhibit 1001: EX1001 - US10894503B2 Spero Petitioner Exhibit 1002: EX1002 - 503 Prosecution File History Petitioner Exhibit 1003: EX1003 - Jiao Declaration Petitioner Exhibit 1004: EX1004 - Jiao CV Petitioner Exhibit 1005: EX1005 - Beam US6144158 Petitioner Exhibit 1006: EX1006 - Thominet US20010019486A1 Petitioner Exhibit 1007: EX1007 - Stam WO2001070538A2 Petitioner Exhibit 1008: EX1008 - Kobayashi US6049749 Petitioner Exhibit 1009: EX1009 - Braun WO2002004247A1 Petitioner Exhibit 1010: EX1010 - Karlsson WO1998054030A1 Petitioner Exhibit 1011: EX1011 - Harbers WO2001001038A1 Petitioner Exhibit 1012: EX1012 - Gotou US5588733 Petitioner Exhibit 1015: EX1015 - Westermann_History and Scientific Back up Petitioner Exhibit 1016: EX1016 - Adaptive Front Lighting Systems (AFS) Petitioner Exhibit 1017: EX1017 - Hogrefe_Adaptive Light Pattern - A New Way to Improve Light Qualit Petitioner Exhibit 1018: EX1018 - Lowenau_Adaptive Light Control - A New Light Concept Controlled by Petitioner Exhibit 1019: EX1019 - Manassero_Adaptive Headlamp - A Contribution for Design and Develo Petitioner Exhibit 1020: EX1020 - Hamm Petitioner Exhibit 1021: EX1021 - Kalapodas US20130258688A1 Petitioner Exhibit 1023: EX1023 - Manassero 1999 Petitioner Exhibit 1024: EX1024 - Westermann 1999 Petitioner Exhibit 1025: EX1025 - Diem Petitioner Exhibit 1026: EX1026 - Kobayashi_Development of the Phase-I AFS Front Lighting System Petitioner Exhibit 1028: EX1028 - Woerner Petitioner Exhibit 1030: EX1030 - NHTSA Survey Petitioner Exhibit 1032: EX1032 - Amended Complaint Petitioner Exhibit 1033: EX1033 - 551 Reexam File History (Part 1 of 3) Petitioner Exhibit 1033: EX1033 - 551 Reexam File History (Part 2 of 3) Petitioner Exhibit 1033: EX1033 - 551 Reexam File History (Part 3 of 3) Petitioner Exhibit 1035: EX1035 - District Court Statistics Petitioner Exhibit 1036: EX1036 - Nelson US5523193 Petitioner Exhibit 1038: EX1038 - Hornbeck US4662746 Petitioner Exhibit 1039: EX1039 - Hornbeck US5061049 Petitioner Exhibit 1040: EX1040 - Enomoto US5933183

Supplemental Search

Search for PTAB Motions

PTAB Analytics

TTAB Analytics

Basic Search

Filters

Party Search

Advanced

Selected Courts

Recently Selected Courts

Find PTAB Decisions

PTAB Analytics

Special PTAB Alerts

Orange Book

Directly Search Federal Courts

Search Trademark ...

Search millions of cases and get court filings, fast docket alerts, and case analytics.

Request a Demo or create your account.

Lawyer? Your firm may have a group account, ask us and we'll let you know.

Patent Owner

Petitioners

Keyboard shortcuts

Filtering / Searching the Docket

Interactive Timeline

Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. Spero, Yechezkal

IPR2023-00328 | Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Interested in this case?

Event:

Event:

Events:

Event:

Event:

Alert Sharing

STEP 2 of 2

Choose your membership type

Flat-Fee

Pay-As-You-Go Monthly

Add your payment information

Login or Join

Enter your corporate Email

Thousands of your peers are saving time and gaining a competitive advantage with Docket Alarm.

Join Docket Alarm to perform smarter legal research.

Download this document and millions of others instantly with a Docket Alarm membership.

Join Docket Alarm and start performing smarter legal research.

Start tracking this docket instantly with a Docket Alarm membership.

Join thousands of your peers and start performing smarter legal research.

STEP 1 of 2

Millions of Documents | 15 Seconds to Signup

Hi !

Welcome to Docket Alarm

Welcome to Docket Alarm!

Explore Litigation Insights andManage Your Cases

Reset Password

What is PACER?

Why do I need it?

What will I be charged?

Do other courts have fees?

Basic Free Access

Welcome

Thank you

Check Firm Account

Explore Litigation Insights and
Manage Your Cases