Page 1 of 10
`
`CSL EXHIBIT 1032
`
`CSL V. Shire
`
`Page 1 of 10
`
`CSL EXHIBIT 1032
`CSL v. Shire
`
`

`

`
`inical and,Experimenta
`
`Iiditorvin-chief: Mark Peaknran
`
`Associate editors: Marina Botto, Danny C. Douek and Matthias von Herrath
`
`EDITORIAL BOARD
`
`I). Iiarouch Boston
`R. Boyton London
`T. J. Braciale Clurrlollesville
`V. Cerllndolo Oxford
`J. W. Cohen 'I'ervaert Muustricltt
`1. Coleman Lourluu
`Ii, Y. Derrkers Illmcn
`J. Dillner Ala/mo
`
`II, M. IJockrell London
`I. Dransfreld Edinburgh
`1. C. W. Edwards London
`A. Fischer Paris
`I. S, Friedland London
`A. Godkin Curdijf
`M. Goldman Brussels
`5. '1‘. Iiolgate Southampton
`
`R. Hohlfeld Muuir‘li
`J, I). Isaacs Newcastle
`1). R. W. Iayne Cambridge
`P. Klenermann Oxford
`M. Larché Lourimr
`M. Marius Hurmovcr
`K. Mills Dublin
`R. Pujoliliorrell Barcelona
`
`1. Sabroe Slufliclrl
`1". P. Schena Bari
`W. Schwaeble Leicester
`S. Sriskandan London
`1. Viney Seattle
`'1'. Vyse Landon
`
`Aimsand scope. Cliniculztml Experimental Immunology provides an international
`forum for the publication oforiginal research on all aspects ot‘clinical immunol-
`ogy. It is amongst the foremost journals in this field, attracting high-quality
`papers from all parts of the world. Its articles cover clinical studies in patients
`receiving immune-based therapies, in relation to autoimmunity, primary and
`secondary imrnunodcticiencies. complement disorders and allergies. Other sub-
`jects include:
`irnruunopathogenesis of communicable and parasitic diseases;
`rheumatic. renal and endocrine disorders; immunological disorders in other
`organ systems; malignancy and transplantation. Studies using animal models and
`laboratory experimentation also form a prominent feature of the Journal’s
`reports, as do papers on the physiological mechanisms of immunity. In addition
`to research reports, the Journal publishes general review articles and commis-
`sioned Editorial Reviews which highlight a particular topic in the issue. Occa—
`sional reports from learned societies and committees are also included making
`Clinical and [Experimental Immunology vital reading for anyone working in clini-
`cal immunology. Tire journal also features a Fast track category, enabling papers
`of immediate interest to reach their audience as quickly as possible.
`Information for subscribers. Clinicer and Experimental Immunology is pub-
`lished in 12 issues per year, in 4 volumes of3 issues each. Subscription prices for
`2007 are: Premium Institutional: £1,266 (Europe), US$13.39 (The Americas),
`£1,392 (Rest ot'World); Customers in the UK should add VAT at 6%; customers
`in the EU should add VAT at 6%, or provide a VAT registration number or
`evidence ofentitlernent to exemption. Customers in Canada should add 7% 651'
`or provide evidence ofentitlement to exception. The Premium institutional price
`includes orrliue access to the current content and online back files to January lst
`1997, where available. For other pricing options or more information about
`online access to Blackwell Publishingjournals, including access information and
`terms and conditions, please visit www.blackwcllpublishing.com/cei
`Delivery Terms and Legal Title. Prices include delivery of print journals to the
`recipient’s address. Delivery terms are Delivered Duty Unpaid (DDU); the recip-
`ient is responsible for paying any import duty or taxes. Legal title passes to the
`customer on despatch by our distributors.
`
`is available orrline at Blackwell Synergy. Visit www.blacl<well—
`This journal
`synergycortr to search the articles and register for table of contents email alerts.
`Access to this journal is available free online within institutions in the deve10p—
`ing world through the I’IINARI initiative with the WIIO. For information, visit
`www.1‘realthinternetworkorg. Blackwell Publishing is a CarbonNeutral company,
`For more information visit www.blacluvellpublishirtgicorn/carbonneutral
`Back issues. Single issues from Current and recent volumes are available at the
`current single issue price from Blackwell Publishing Journals. Earlier issues
`may be obtained from Periodicals Service Company,
`11 Main Street,
`Germantown, NY 12526, USA. Tel: +1 518 537 4700,13ax:+1518 537 5899, Email:
`psc@periodicals.com
`Periodical II) Statement. CLINICAL AND EXPERIMEN'I'AL IMMUNOLOGY,
`(ISSN 0009-9104) is published monthly. US mailing agent: (13 Worldwide (US)
`lnc., 8701 Bellanca Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90045. Periodical postage paid at Los
`Angeles, CA, and additional mailing offices, POS’I‘MAS'I‘I’R: Send all address
`changes to CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENIAL IMMUNOLOGY, Blackwell 1’1le
`lishing lnc., Journals Subscription Department, 350 Main St., Malden, MA
`02148-5020.
`
`Publisher. CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL IMMUNOLOGY is published by
`Blackwell Publishing Ltd: 9600 (iarsington Road, Oxford ()X4 2DQ, UK.
`Journal Customer Services. For ordering information, claims and arty enquiry
`concerning your journal subscription please contact your nearest ollice:
`UK: Email: cuslomerservices®oxon.b1ad<wellpub|ishing.com; Tel: +44 (0) 1865
`778315; Pax: +44 (0) 1865 471775
`
`Page 2 of 10
`
`USA: Ismail: subscrip@bos.blackwellpublishingcom; Tel: 711 781 388 8206 or
`1 800 835 6770 (Toll free in the USA); ll'dX: +1 781 388 8232
`
`Asia: Email: suhs@blackwcllpublislringasia.eom; Tel: ml 3 8.359 1100; Fax:
`+613 83591120
`
`Production Editor: Maureen Riach (email: ceiGtioxonhlackwellpublishingcom).
`
`Editorial correspondence. Editorial correspondence should be directh .to
`Sharon 'I'obin, Clinical mu] Experimental
`Immunology, British Society tor
`Immunology, 'I'riangle House, Broomhill Road, London SW18 :tIIX, UK (Tel:
`+44 (0)20 8875 2441; Fax: +44 ((1)20 8875 2122; Iimail: cei®imnrunologyxrrg).
`
`Manuscript submission. For intormation regarding manuscripts submission.
`see Information for Contributors at the back ofthc journal.
`
`Paper. Blackwell Publishing‘s policy is to use permanent paper front mills that
`operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been rnanufztctured from
`pulp that is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices.
`Furthermore, Blackwell Publishing ensures that the text paper and cover board
`used in all our journals has met acceptable environmental accreditation stan—
`dards.
`
`
`Copyright and Photocopying. o 2007 British Society for IntmunologytAll rights
`reserved. No part ofthis publication (apart from articles marked ‘(1nlrnef1pen’)
`may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by any means Without
`the prior permission in writing from the copyright holder. Authorization to pit-()-
`tocupy items for internal and personal use is granted by the copyright holder for
`libraries and other users registered with their local Reproduction Rights
`Organisation (BRO), eg. Copyright Clearance Center (CCC), 22.7. Rosewood
`Drive, Danvers, MA ()l923, USA (www.copyright.corn), provided the
`appropriate fee is paid directly to the IIRO.
`'I‘his consent does not extend to other
`kinds of copying such as copying for general distribution, for advertising and
`promotional purposes,
`for creating new collective works or
`for
`resale.
`OnlineOpen articles are made available in accordance with the terms of the
`Creative Cormnons Deed, Attribution 2-5 (further details Available from
`www.creativecornmonsorg), which allows Open Access dissemination ol the
`al‘thlC) but does not permit connnercial exploitation or
`the creation oi
`derivative works. Special requests should be addressed to Blackwell Publishing
`at: journalsrights®oxorrblackwellpublishing.com.
`Disclaimer. The Publisher, the British Society for Immunology, and the [Editors
`cannot be held responsible for errors or any consequences arising from the use
`of information contained in this journal; the views and opinions explcaht‘d do
`not necessarily reflect those ofthe Publisher, the British Society for Clinical and
`Experimental Immunology and Editors, neither does the publication ofadver—
`tisernents constitute any endorsement by the Publisher, the Britiin Society for
`Clinical and Experimental Inrtnunology and Iiditors ofthe products advertised.
`Citatiorts. Clinical and Experimental Immunology is indexed by ASCA, Cam-
`bridge Scientific Abstracts, Current Awareness in Biological Sciences (CABS),
`Current Contents, Index Medicus, ISI/BIOMBD, Science Citation Index and
`ADONIS.
`
`ISSN 0009-9104 (print)
`ISSN 1365-2249 (online)
`
`For more submission instructions, subscription and all other information visit:
`www.hlackweiiptthislrirrg.corrr/cei
`Printed in Singapore by (1.0.5. Printers I’te Ltd.
`Cover illustration: Indirect irnmtlnoihlorescence staining for Clcl protein and
`CD14. See Moosig P, Datum Ii. Knorr-Spahr A e1 :11, Reduced expression of
`CIq-mRNA in monocytes front patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.
`Clin llxp lmntunol 2006; 146: 409—16.
`
`Page 2 of 10
`
`

`

`Clinical and Experimental Immunology
`
`REVIEW ARTICLE
`
`doi:10.1111/j.1365-2249.2oo6.o3256.x
`
`C1-inhibitor concentrate home therapy for hereditary angioedema:
`a viable, effective treatment option
`
`
`
`ll. J. Longlrurstf 5‘. Cart“ and K. Klrait“
`‘liurls um] The [tuition NHfr'
`'l'rusl. Department
`of[Ir/mtilloputlmloim Lt/lIl/llll. UK, ‘lr’mls Hill]
`The London NIH 'I‘rrrsi. lh’purlmcul u]
`Paediatric Rt‘trltfilllul)’ J\lL'llit'fllt', loin/mi, UK,
`will
`(ii't’llf ()rruoud Street Ilus/ulul. fruition, UK
`
`Accepted for publication 13 t)clober Z006
`{,(H'I‘c‘s'litllitlcncci l’r Hilary Longhurst, litit‘ls’
`and the London NI [8 'l‘rt.st, Department of
`lmmunopathology, 51753 Bartholomew (Ilosc,
`London l1(',l;\ 7lili, LlK_
`
`Summary
`
`Economic and political factors have led to the increased use of home therapy
`programmes for patients who have traditionally been treated in hospital.
`Many patients with hereditary angioedema (ll/\E) experience intermittent
`severe attacks that affect their quality of life and may be life—threatening.
`These attacks are treated with (ll—inhibitor concentrate which, for most
`
`patients, is infused at the local hospital. Home therapy programmes for HAE
`are currently being established. This paper reviews the extent of use of these
`programmes and summarizes the advantages and potential disadvantages of
`the concept so far.
`
`lZ—mail:
`l’lilary,l.t>r‘.glr urstm‘bartsandthelondonarhs. til:
`
`emergency
`deficiency,
`C1 inhibitor
`Keywords:
`angioederna, home therapy, quality of life
`
`treatment,
`
`hereditary
`
`Re use of tlris article is permitted in accordance
`with the (.reative (Lorrrmons Deed, Attribution
`7 5, which does not permit corrrmercial
`exploitation.
`
`OnlineOpen: This article is available free online at www.blackwelI-synergy.com
`
`
`
`Economic and political factors have contributed to the
`increased use ofhome therapy programmes for patients who
`would have been treated previously in hospital. One group of
`patients who may benefit from home therapy is those with
`HAfl. This paper uses published data iMedline) to assess the
`use of (ll—lNl’l concentrate home therapy in patients with
`llAli, and includes evaluations of both the recommenda—
`tions for patient
`selection for home therapy and the
`documented benefits of self-administration of (Ll-lNH
`
`replacement therapy.
`
`Methods
`
`Data have been collected from a Medline search of the
`
`English language literature to identify papers that included
`inforrrration on the use of Cl—lNl'l concentrate as home
`
`Introd uction
`
`is an atttosornal dominant
`l’lereclitary angioedetna (HALL)
`condition resulting from partial deficiency of Cl
`inhibitor
`((‘LI-INI I) II]. It
`is a rare disease, thought to affect between
`one in 10000 and one in 50000 people worldwide
`Acquired arrgioedema MAE), which is also due to (,‘llilNl-l
`deficiency,
`is plrenotypically similar to HAE, although it
`is
`associated typically with lymphoprolilerative disease, or with
`attloanlibmlies to Cl-lNH |3l_
`Patients with ()1 ~lNH deficiency have reduced amounts of
`functional (IlrlNH, which at times of physiological or psy—
`chological stress is insufficient to control local inflammatory
`pathways. The complement and contact systems are actii
`vated, atrd excess bradykinin is generated [4].
`it
`is
`this
`increased bradykitrin production that is believed to be the
`main factor iii the development ot‘local oedema l4]. Dedema
`may occur at any site, but most commonly affects the sub—
`cutaneous tissue, causing swelling of the limbs, face, trunk or
`genitalia ll]. Oedema can also aftch the mucous membranes
`of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, causing abdominal pain,
`often with diarrhoea and/or vomiting, and the mucous
`membranes of the larynx, causing laryngeal oedema, which
`may lead to death by asphyxiation [5e7l.
`
`therapy in patients with HAE. The search included the years
`from 1985, the year that pasteurized Cl—lNH concentrate
`replacement therapy was introduced, to August 2006. The
`keywords used for
`the search were ‘Cl—inhibitor’,
`‘CI—
`inhibitor concentrate’, ‘Cliesterase inhibitor“, ‘CI—esterase
`inhibitor concentrate’,
`‘(Il—INH’,
`‘(Il—lNll
`concentrath
`‘(31 151’ and ‘CI El concentrate; combined with ‘Clrinhibitor
`inhibitor
`
`deficiency’,
`
`‘Cllil
`
`deficiency’,
`
`‘Cl-eslerase
`
`© 2006 The Authorla)
`Journal corrrpilation © 2006 British Soctety for Immunology, CII'I'r/ca/ and Experimental Immunology] 147: lift 7
`
`11
`
`Page 3 of 10
`
`Page 3 of 10
`
`

`

`1-1.1. Longhurst eta).
`
`Author
`
`Publication
`
`Table 1. Papers detailing the use of C1 inhibitor (Cl-INH) concentrate home therapy in patients with hereditary angioedema (HAE)*.
`No. of
`Home therapy programme
`patients
`entry requirements
`
`Outcome
`
`Decreased lime to onset of
`relief and attack duration (on-
`demand group)
`Decreased frequency of attacks
`(prophylaxis group)
`
`Reduced consumption of ClelNH
`Prevention of severe attacks
`Reduced hospitalization
`Reduced absence from school
`or work
`
`Regimen
`Cl-lNH on
`demand
`(n = 31)
`Cl-INH every
`5—7 days
`(It = 12)
`Cl-lNII on
`demand (first
`line for
`children) or
`prophylactically
`(interval
`not stated)
`Cl—lNH on
`demand
`
`Not stated but short onset—lo-
`treatment time assoriaied with
`less severe and shorter duration
`of attacks
`Improved Qol,
`Reduced frequency of attacks
`Reduced frequency of life,
`threatenng attacks
`No adverse events
`Reduced frequency of attacks
`‘Largely symptom free’
`Reduced attack frequency and
`Optimal oral prophylaxis
`severity
`(1 HAE,
`Attack frequency > 1/weck
`Limited duration ofl)enefit in
`1 AAE)
`Proven Cl—INH deficiency
`patient with AAE
`
`Journal compilation © 2006 British Society for Immunology, C/inica/ and Experimental Immunology, 147: 11~17
`
`Levi et a],
`
`Basic & Clin
`lmmunol 2006
`
`43
`
`Rusicke er (1LT
`
`[AC1 2006
`Abstract
`
`'li‘ansfusion 2005
`
`Attack frequency > 1/3 weeks
`(on-demand treatment),
`> 1/10 days (prophylaxis)
`Proven (ll-[Nil deficiency
`Completion of education
`programme
`Not stated
`50% of clinic IAIAE
`cohort included
`
`f 31 HAE,
`12 AAE)
`
`163
`(HAE and
`AAE, exact
`numbers
`not stated)
`
`Attack frequency > l/month
`
`Kreuz e1 til.
`
`Blood 2004
`Abstract
`
`lntolerant of, or resistant to
`danazol
`
`Kreuz ct alrl‘
`
`Bork 8c Witzke
`
`liiomed Progress
`199‘)
`lACI I9 8 8
`
`Not stated
`
`(ll—INH every
`3—4 days
`Ci-INH every
`4~5 days
`
`"l’atients suffered from HAE unless otherwise stated. [Reporting on the same cohort.
`
`‘HAE’, ‘hereditary
`deficiency’, ‘hereditary angio(o)edema’,
`angioneurotic (o)edema’ and ‘HANE’. These groups ofkey-
`words were then put together, alone and in combination,
`with the search terms ‘home’, ‘self—administration’,
`‘self—
`administered’, ‘otttpatient’ and ‘home—based’. The articles
`were retrieved and analysed. Pertinent articles known to the
`authors but not appearing in the Medline search results were
`also analysed.
`
`Results
`
`We found six relevant papers: two case series [8,9] with tWO
`and 43 patients, respectively;
`two further papers [10,11]
`which included information describing patients on home
`therapy (although this was not the main focus of the papers);
`and two further case series, which were available in abstract
`form only [12,13]. The papers are detailed in Table 1.
`Patients were treated with Cl—INH, given either on
`demand at the onset of an attack or as regular prophylaxis.
`Cl-INH was self-administered or
`infused by a family
`member at home. The results showed that where prophylac-
`tic Cl-INH was given, patients experienced improved
`quality of life (QoL) and reduced severity, duration and
`
`frequency of attacks. In addition, Cl-INH had an excellent
`safety profile.
`
`Discussion
`
`Treatment of hereditary angioedema
`
`Frequent or severe HAE attacks are disabling for the patient.
`Consequently, such attacks are an indication for regular pro-
`phylaxis, usttally with attenuated androgens such as danazol
`that
`increase hepatic production of Cl—INH [14,15].
`However, attenuated androgens may cause unacceptable side
`effects such as virilization [16] or hepatic abnormalities [17],
`or may be contraindicated otherwise, for example in women
`who wish to become pregnant [18]. Fibrinolytic agents such
`as tranexamic acid or epsilon aminocaproic acid are alterna~
`tive prophylactic agents, although the evidence base for their
`use is less certain [19,20]. Despite prophylaxis, many patients
`continue to experience intermittent severe attacks that
`interrupt
`their activities of daily living and may be
`life—threatening. These attacks are treated with Cl-INl-I con-
`centrate, which in most cases brings about a response within
`30-90 min [21]. Licensed Cl-lNl-l products are available in
`
`12
`
`© 2006 The Authods)
`
`Page 4 of 10
`
`

`

`Germany, Austria, Switzerland, France, Hungary, Argentina,
`Japan (Ber-inert PW, ZLB Behring, Marburg, Germany) and
`the Netherlands
`(Cetor’D,
`CLB, Amsterdam,
`the
`Netherlands). In other European countries, including the
`United Kingdom, and in the United States, Cl-INH is used
`on a named-patient basis, or is completely unavailable.
`Cl-lNI-I infusion is administered traditionally in hospital,
`usually in the emergency department. However,
`this
`approach can lead to delays in administering treatment.
`Emergency department staff may be unfamiliar with HAE
`and patients may not be triaged as urgent. Delays may occtir
`in locating CI—INH, which is not a routine stock item for
`most hospitals. Such delays necessitate higher Cl-INH doses
`to control the attack, unnecessary hospital admissions and,
`occasionally,
`severe adverso incidents,
`including death
`[5,8,22]. Death rates from HAE—related laryngeal oedema of
`30—40% have been reported. Although the majority of
`deaths occur in undiagnosed patients,
`there remains an
`avoidable mortality in those who are diagnosed [1,5].
`Children with Cl-INH deficiency are not usually consid-
`ered for home therapy in the United Kingdom, as there are
`no paediatric home therapy programmes. Fortunately, HAE
`is usually mild in preadolescence. However, prophylactic
`options are limited: long-term attenuated androgens present
`significant risks, including growth retardation, and are not
`recommended [23,24]. Our literature search revealed that
`one German centre does provide home therapy for children
`severely affected with HAE, suggesting that this option is
`feasible for
`selected cases. Rusicke etal. describe how
`on-demand CI-INH therapy is their first-line therapy for
`children, with regular prophylaxis for those who experience
`very frequent attacks [13]. More than 50% of their cohort of
`325 patients infuse at home, although the proportion of
`these who are children is not stated. The authors claim that
`severe attacks are prevented, and hospital time and absence
`from school is reduced (although detailed figures are not
`supplied).
`Recently, consensus documents providing recommenda-
`tions on the management of I-IAF. have been published by
`expert panels in Canada and the United Kingdom [18,25].
`Both the Canadian and UK documents recommend offering
`patients the option of home therapy. In spite of a recent
`increase in interest in home therapy in those countries where
`Cl-INH is available [9], there is little published literature on
`this topic and a relative lack of information available for
`health—care professionals.
`
`Home therapy in hereditary angioedema
`
`attack per month, repeated hospital admissions result in
`severe disruption to everyday life, affecting the ability to
`work and carry out domestic duties, impairing patients’ con-
`fidence to travel too far from the local hospital and creating
`anxiety. For these patients, or for patients living in remote
`areas where access to a hospital may be difficult, home
`therapy (self-infusion or infusion by a family member) is
`usually the best option and is likely to result
`in greatly
`improved QoL.
`
`Patient selection for home therapy in hereditary
`angioedema
`
`The available data suggest that patients included on CI—INH
`home infusion programmes must
`fulfil certain criteria
`[8—13]: patients must have proven Cl—INI-I deficiency as
`determined by typical symptoms, low Cl—INH protein or
`function and low C4 complement. Genetic diagnosis is not
`widely available, but may be useful where diagnosis is
`unclear. Oral prophylaxis must be optimized. Patients must
`have sufficiently frequent attacks; the recommended fre-
`quency varies between centres, but is usually a minimum of
`one attack every 3 months [18]. However, patients with less
`frequent attacks may also benefit from home therapy and
`should be considered on an individual basis. Patients should
`
`be motivated to comply with the home therapy programme
`and be fully informed as to the risks and benefits. Cl—INH
`should be stored at 2—8°C, although limited data suggest that
`lyophilized Cl-INH concentrate may be stable at room tem-
`perature (25°C) for up to 6 months [26]. Twenty-four—hour
`access to help and advice should be available, including the
`option of emergency hospital treatment [18].
`Training programmes in the United Kingdom and the
`Netherlands include practical aspects of CI—INI-I administra—
`tion: hygiene and cannulation techniques,
`as well
`as
`indications for CI—INH infusion and management of
`emergencies [9,18]. Attacks should be severe enough to
`warrant Cl-lNI-I treatment — usually severe abdominal pain
`or orofacial oedema — but not so severe as to require
`hospitalization; for example, attacks causing symptoms of
`laryngeal obstruction. H0wever,
`if airway obstruction is
`imminent, treatment may be expedited by home administra-
`tion of Cl-INI'I concentrate while awaiting the arrival of
`ambulance transport to hospital. Patients should be advised
`to consult a physician if the symptoms of an attack are atypi-
`cal, as the onset of an appendicitis or GI infection may
`present with symptoms similar to abdominal attacks of I IAE.
`
`The need for home therapy in hereditary angioedema
`
`As C1~INH can be difficult to obtain at short notice, practi-
`tioners are strongly recommended to ensure that patients
`have a supply of Cl-INH to keep in the refrigerator at home
`[5,18,25,26]. For the majority of patients, who have infre-
`quent attacks, Cl—INH is taken to the local hospital for
`infusion. For those patients experiencing more than one
`
`Government directives supporting home therapy
`
`In many countries, the relationship between patient and
`medical professionals is changing. Nurses and paramedics
`are taking on tasks that were previottsly the responsibility of
`doctors, and many patients expect to take an active role in
`their own management. Facilitated by the internet,
`the
`
`© 2006 The Author(s)
`Journal compilation © 2006 British Society for Immunology, Clinical and Experimental lmmuno/ogy, 147: 11—17
`
`13
`
`Page 5 of 10
`
`Page 5 of 10
`
`

`

`H. J. Longhurst etal.
`
`growth of self-help groups such as the UK Primary immu—
`nodeficiency Association (PiA) and HAP,
`International
`(HAEI) has enabled patients to ‘network’ on a far wider scale
`than previously. Patients are increasingly aware of initiatives
`that can improve their QoL and, as a result, many patients
`are requesting the option of home therapy. Initiatives such as
`the UK NHS Plan and ‘Expert Patient’ programmes seek to
`give patients the knowledge and confidence to take a more
`active role in their own management [27,28].
`
`Established home therapy programmes
`
`Intravenous home therapy programmes exist for a variety of
`conditions,
`including intravenous immunoglobulins for
`antibody deficiency [29,30] and intravenous antibiotics for
`patients with a variety of underlying conditions [31—36].
`These programmes have helped establish the feasibility and
`cost-effectiveness of home therapy. However, perhaps the
`closest parallel with Cl-lNl-I home therapy programmes is
`haemophilia home therapy. Like C1~INH, clotting factors for
`haemophilia can be used prophylactically or as an emergency
`treatment.
`
`Home therapy has been available in haemophilia since the
`19805 and is now considered ‘routine’. Most paediatric
`patients are receiving home therapy by 18 months of age, as
`it is impractical for them to attend hospital several times a
`week for treatment or preventative therapy [37]. For children
`at high risk of bleeding, regular prophylaxis with clotting
`factors can be given; for others, prompt treatment of any
`bleeds or prophylaxis of high-risk events is preferable.
`Current UK guidelines [38] suggest regular prophylaxis for
`those who have declared themselves phenotypically severe
`(by virtue of two of more haemarthroses) and, for the others,
`access to coagulation factors for administration at home, a
`local hospital or a haemophilia centre.
`
`Benefits of home therapy
`
`The results of our Medline search included a recent paper by
`Levi et (11., who reported the experiences of 31 patients with
`Cl-INH deficiency who were trained to self—administer
`Cl-INH [9]. Patients, who all suffered from frequent, severe
`angioedema attacks, self-administered 1000 units ofC1-INII
`concentrate shortly after the onset of severe abdominal, oro-
`facial or laryngeal attacks. Twelve patients, who had very
`frequent attacks (> 1 every 10 days) were treated additionally
`with prophylactic C1 -INH concentrate every 5—7 days. Mean
`follow—up was 3-5 years (range 0-9—5-1). All patients were
`trained successfully, and reported very low levels of technical
`failure with venepuncture (< 200). There were no adverse
`events of sufficient severity to require medical assistance.
`Self-administration of
`regular prophylactic CI-INH
`concentrate resulted in a significant reduction in attack
`frequency, with seven of 12 patients reporting complete
`freedom from attacks. Patients self-treating attacks reported
`
`a significant reduction in time to start of symptomatic relief,
`and in time to complete resolution of the attack, compared
`with the five ‘historical control’ attacks immediately prior to
`entry into the self-administration programme. HistOI‘iCi11
`control attacks did not respond significantly differently to
`Cl-lNH concentrate compared with attacks in control
`patients who did not self-administer. The authors attributed
`the reduction in time to onset of relief and attack duration to
`the reduced attack-to-treatment time associated with self—
`administration. These observations are in accordance with
`
`Bork’s observational study, which reported that abdominal
`attacks treated with Cl—INH concentrate within 2 h of onset
`
`showed significant reduction in time to onset of relief com—
`pared with attacks where treatment was delayed [11]. This
`study did not report separate outcomes on the subgroup of
`25 patients who self-infused. However, Rusicke etal. [l3]
`commented on the reduced attack-to-treatment time asso-
`
`ciated with home therapy. Reduced attack frequency was also
`reported by Bork etal. [11], Kreuz etal. [12] and Rusicke
`at al. [13] in patients who infused prophylactically.
`Reports from other home therapy programmes also
`indicate major benefits. Immunoglobulin home therapy iS
`associated with greater patient independence, convenience,
`comfort and economic benefit
`[39,40]. A recent study
`showed that home therapy significantly improved health,
`school/social
`functioning (in children) and significantly
`reduced emotional distress and limitations on personal time
`[40]. In a similar study, home therapy with immunoglobulin
`significantly improved QoL [41]. Patients in both surveys
`preferred home— to hospital—based therapy [40,41]. For
`patients with haemophilia, home therapy is associated with
`reduced pain and disability, improved QoL and reduced hos-
`pitalization and time offwork or school [38] . The availability
`of home therapy has also been associated with improved life
`expectancy [42]. Two of the case series in our analysis men-
`tioned improved QoL for HAE patients with access to home
`therapy, although formal studies are lacking [12,13].
`A major issue for patients with HAE is the delay and
`difficulty in accessing emergency care. Better awareness of
`HAE among medical staff and better liaison with emergency
`departments is important, but can be difficult when medical
`staff change frequently, as is the case in most emergency
`departments. Patient education is
`important
`to ensure
`prompt attendance at hospital at an early stage of the attack.
`However, travelling time is likely to be a limiting factor. For
`those patients with rapid—onset attacks, or who live far from
`the hospital, the resulting delay may pose a significant risk.
`Access to emergency treatment can often be expedited only
`by self-infusion/home therapy.
`
`Home therapy for acquired angioedema
`
`Interestingly, the Levi study group included three patients
`with AAE, whose benefit did not differ significantly from
`those with HAE. Cl—INH concentrate appears effective in
`
`14
`
`© 2006 The Author(s)
`Journal compilation © 2006 British Society for Immunology, Clinical and Experimental Immunology, 147: 11—17
`
`Page 6 of 10
`
`Page 6 of 10
`
`

`

`the management of acute attacks of AAE, even when
`Cl-INH antibodies are present, although some patients may
`require higher doses or become resistant to treatment [1,3].
`Bork and Witzke reported a patient with frequent AAE
`attacks who was treated with CI-INH 1000 units every
`Sdays [8].
`'I‘reatment was initially successful, but after
`10 months
`the patient became progressively resistant
`(Table 1). Despite reservations about its durability, CI—INH
`home therapy remains an option for patients with AAE.
`
`Funding and resources
`
`is currently considered an expensive treatment
`Cl—INI'I
`option (approximately £290l€425
`for 500 units). Home
`therapy has the potential to increase overall use of Cl-INH
`by treating attacks
`that would previously have gone
`untreated, although published data do not suggest that this is
`the case when compared with optimum hospital—based
`treatment [9].
`However, untreated attacks are costly in social, pharmaco-
`economic and QoL terms. HAE is a lifelong condition, which
`usually becomes symptomatic in adolescence. Attacks may
`be precipitated by emotional stress, minor infections or
`oestrogens [18,43]. Consequently, young adults are particu—
`larly at risk of frequent attacks and the lifetime economic
`cost of disrupted education and employment is likely to be
`considerable. Additionally, under-treated attacks — where the
`patient presents late A have major direct costs, as higher
`doses of Cl—INH are required and hospital admission is
`more probable [I 1]. Studies in antibody therapy and hae—
`mophilia show that home therapy is the most cost-effective
`option for delivering this type of care [44—46]. Cost—benefit
`studies in HAE are required urgently.
`Funding of treatments is coming under increased scrutiny
`in both insurance—based and taxation-based health—care
`
`systems. CI-INH is unlicensed in several countries. In the
`United States it is not Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
`approved, but can be administered for compassionate use.
`Without FDA approval, HAE sufferers must pay the entire
`cost of the therapy themselves. Licensing studies are under
`way for both plasma-derived and recombinant CI»INH and
`for other therapies for acute attacks of HAE. Access to
`Cl-INH, whether hospital- or home—based,
`is
`likely to
`remain suboptimal until
`licensed products are available.
`Even if licensed, the manufacturing costs of plasma-derived
`CI—INH are likely to be out of reach for many middle- and
`low—income countries.
`In the long term,
`recombinant
`Cl—INH or inhibitors of the bradykinin—lmllikrein pathway
`may provide a solution [47—49]. In theory, kallikrein- or
`bradykinin—pathway inhibitors also provide an option for
`patients with AAE who are resistant to Cl-INH.
`
`Safety of Cl—inhibitor concentrate
`
`Products used for home in fusion need to demonstrate a high
`standard of safety with respect to immunological or allergic
`
`Home therapy in hereditary angioedema
`
`reactions. Cl—INH is extremely well tolerated [1,50,51], and
`our analysis did not reveal any treatment—related adverse
`events [843]. However, because it
`is a plasma product,
`CI-INH raises particular concerns for patients and physi—
`cians regarding virus transn‘lission, particularly viral hepati—
`tis and HIV [52]. It is a regulatory requirement in Europe
`[53] for plasma donors to undergo a comprehensive health
`screen. Each donation is then screened using serological
`methods for the pre