IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`SECOND DECLARATION BY PETER RYSAVY FOR INTER PARTES
`REVIEW OF UNITED STATES PATENT NOS. 8,135,342 AND 8,879,987
`
`Dated: May 17, 2016
`
`
`
`
` Page 1 of 51
`
`

`
`Table of Contents
`
`
`I.
`
`INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 4
`
`A. EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND........................................... 5
`B. MATERIALS CONSIDERED. ................................................................................ 5
`
`II. THE ‘342 AND ‘987 PATENTS ...................................................................... 6
`
`A. MEANING OF DIFFERENT CLAIM TERMS IN THE ’987 AND ’342 PATENTS ......... 6
`a. “Receiving Said User Information …” ........................................................ 6
`b. “Means For Connecting …” ........................................................................ 8
`c. “Means For Downloading …” ..................................................................11
`d. “Means For Relaying …” ..........................................................................12
`e. “Means For Operating …” ........................................................................16
`f. “User Information”....................................................................................18
`B. SIMILARITY OF CLAIMS AND CLAIM TERMS ....................................................20
`
`III. THE TEE, ACHARYA, AND BENCO PRIOR ART ..............................29
`
`A. SPECIFIC DISCLOSURES OF TEE, ACHARYA, AND BENCO ................................30
`a. Receiving … In A Manner That Uniquely Associates (’987, element 6.3) 30
`b. Wherein Two Users Interconnect To Said Peripheral Device, Said Two
`Users Controlling Said User Information (found, for example in ’987, element
`6.8) 31
`c. Means For Connecting (’987, element 7.2; ’342, elements 11.2, 58.2, and
`68.2) ...................................................................................................................32
`d. Means For Downloading (’987, element 7.3; ’342, elements 11.3, 58.3,
`and 68.3)............................................................................................................35
`e. Means For Relaying (’987, element 7.4; ’342, elements 11.4, 58.4, and
`68.4) ...................................................................................................................35
`f. Means For Operating (’987, element 7.5; ’342, elements 11.5, 58.5, and
`68.5) ...................................................................................................................37
`g. Respective Peripheral Devices Used to Access And Operate Software
`(’987, element 7.8) ............................................................................................38
`
`IV. THE SOIN AND WANG PRIOR ART .....................................................39
`
`A. COMBINING SOIN WITH WANG .......................................................................40
`B. SPECIFIC DISCLOSURES OF SOIN AND WANG ..................................................40
`a. Two Users Interconnect (’987, element 1.7) ..............................................40
`b. Receiving … In A Manner That Uniquely Associates (’987, element 6.3) 40
`c. Means For Connecting (’987, element 7.2; ’342, elements 11.2, 58.2, and
`68.2) ...................................................................................................................42
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 2 of 51
`
`

`
`d. Means For Downloading (’987, element 7.3; ’342, elements 11.3, 58.3,
`68.3) ...................................................................................................................44
`e. Means For Relaying (’987, element 7.4; ’342, elements 11.4, 58.4, and
`68.4) ...................................................................................................................45
`f. Means For Operating (’987, element 7.5; ’342, elements 11.5, 58.5, and
`68.5) ...................................................................................................................47
`g. User Accesses A Respective / Said Peripheral Device (’987, elements 7.7,
`14) 48
`h. Respective Peripheral Devices Used to Access And Operate Software
`(’987, element 7.8) ............................................................................................49
`
`
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 3 of 51
`
`

`
`I. INTRODUCTION
`
`1. I have been retained as a technical expert by counsel on behalf of
`
`RPX Corporation, to opine on U.S. Patent Nos. 8,135,342 and 8,879,987 (“’342
`
`patent” and “’987 patent,” respectively) and related technologies, in association
`
`with proceedings before the United States Patent and Trademark Office
`
`(“USPTO”).
`
`2. I am the same Peter Rysavy who previously submitted a declaration
`
`regarding the ’342 and ’987 patents, which I signed on April 30, 2016 (“April 30
`
`Declaration”).
`
`3. I reserve the right to modify or supplement my opinions, as well as
`
`the basis for my opinions, based on the nature and content of the documentation,
`
`data, proof and other evidence or testimony that Sockeye Licensing TX LLC or
`
`Wildcat Licensing LLC or its experts may present, or based on any additional
`
`information provided to me or found by me in this matter.
`
`4. I am being compensated for my time expended in connection with
`
`this case at the rate of $400 per hour, plus expenses. My compensation is for my
`
`time, and is in no way dependent or based on the content of my opinions or
`
`testimony offered in this matter, the outcome of any issues in this matter, or the
`
`timing of when issues in this matter or this matter as a whole are resolved.
`
`
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 4 of 51
`
`

`
`A. Educational and Professional Background
`
`5. I hereby incorporate the Educational and Professional Background
`
`Section of my April 30 Declaration (paragraphs 3-11). My CV was submitted as
`
`Appendix 1 to my April 30 Declaration.
`
`B. Materials Considered.
`
`6. In connection with my work on this matter, I have reviewed the
`
`following materials and references in forming my opinions:
`
`Michael D. Harold, U.S. Patent No. 8,135,342, System, Method and Apparatus
`For Using a Wireless Cell Phone Device To Create a Desktop Computer and
`Media Center, issued March 13, 2012 (“’342 Patent”)
`
`Michael D. Harold, U.S. Patent No. 8,879,987, System, Method And Apparatus
`For Using A Wireless Device To Control Other Devices, issued November 4,
`2014 (“’987 Patent”)
`
`Lai King Tee et al., U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2006/0203758 A1,
`filed September 27, 2005, published September 14, 2006 (“Tee”)
`
`Shrikant Acharya et al., U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0036509
`A1, filed June 2, 2004, published February 17, 2005 (“Acharya”)
`
`Ravipal Soin et al., U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0091359 A1,
`filed February 25, 2004, published April 28, 2005 (“Soin”)
`
`Tiejun Ronald Wang et al., U.S. Patent Application Publication No.
`2006/0077310 A1, filed June 24, 2005, published April 13, 2006 (“Wang”)
`
`David S. Benco et al., U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0135393
`A1, filed December 19, 2003, published June 23, 2005 (“Benco”)
`
`Applicant’s Response to Office Action During Prosecution of ’342 Patent, filed
`May 31, 2011
`Random House Webster’s Computer & Internet Dictionary (2000) (excerpts)
`U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/844,645, filed Sep. 15, 2006.
`U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 11/889,941, filed Aug. 17, 2007.
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 5 of 51
`
`

`
`7. I note that, since signing my April 30 Declaration, I have also
`
`reviewed U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/844,645, filed Sep. 15, 2006
`
`(“’645 Provisional Application”) and U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 11/889,941,
`
`filed Aug. 17, 2007 (“’941 Application”). My opinions expressed in my April 30
`
`Declaration are unchanged after reading the ’645 Provisional Application and ’941
`
`Application.
`
`8. I may also reference other background materials throughout this
`
`declaration.
`
`II. THE ‘342 AND ‘987 PATENTS
`
`9. I hereby incorporate Section II of my April 30 Declaration
`
`(paragraphs 15-49). As noted in paragraph 15 of my April 30 Declaration, in
`
`reviewing the ’342 and ’987 patents I have noted no meaningful differences aside
`
`from the claims. Accordingly, unless otherwise noted, references and citations to
`
`the ’342 patent other than the claims, apply equally to the ’987 patent, and vice
`
`versa.
`
`A. Meaning of Different Claim Terms In the ’987 and ’342 Patents
`
`10. In this and the following paragraphs I discuss the meaning of
`
`additional claim terms that appears in certain claims of the ’342 and ’987 patents.
`
`a. “Receiving Said User Information …”
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 6 of 51
`
`

`
`11. The term “receiving said user information in a manner that
`
`uniquely associates the user information with one or more peripheral devices
`
`and uniquely associates each peripheral device with one or more users” appears
`
`in the ’987 patent claim 6. This term is ambiguous, as the ’987 patent does not
`
`mention either (i) uniquely associating user information with peripheral devices or
`
`(ii) uniquely associating peripheral devices with one or more users, much less
`
`“receiving said user information in a manner that” performs both recited unique
`
`associations. But, as noted in paragraph 43 of my April 30 Declaration, the ’987
`
`patent does use the word “associated” to describe a relationship or association
`
`between two items. ’987 patent 12:29, 13:40, 13:51.
`
`12. The patent also describes a user “specify[ing] the devices to
`
`which the wireless cell phone will connect.” ’987 patent 3:54-60. This specifying
`
`creates an association between the user’s wireless device and the specified
`
`peripheral devices, as well as an association between the user and the specified
`
`peripheral devices. These associations are reflected when the wireless device, upon
`
`receiving user information from a remote server, transmits that user information on
`
`to the specified peripheral devices. ’987 patent, 4:21-39. A skilled artisan would
`
`understand that, in the process of receiving the information, the wireless device
`
`must somehow associate that information, and thus the user, with the peripheral
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 7 of 51
`
`

`
`devices specified by the user, to insure that the information is properly transmitted
`
`to those peripheral devices.
`
`13. Thus, the first part of this term, “receiving … in a manner that
`
`uniquely associates the user information with one or more peripheral devices,”
`
`encompasses receiving the user information in a way that associates the user
`
`information to specific, user-selected peripheral devices, allowing for transmission
`
`to those devices. Similarly, the second part of this term, receiving … in a manner
`
`that … uniquely associates each peripheral device with one or more users,”
`
`encompasses receiving the user information in a way that, by allowing transmission
`
`to the selected peripheral devices, reflects the user association to the specific, user-
`
`selected peripheral devices.
`
`b. “Means For Connecting …”
`
`14. The term “means for connecting a user of said wireless device
`
`to user information stored for the respective wireless device on a server in a
`
`communications network” appears in, e.g., the ’987 patent claim 7. Similar terms
`
`appear in claims 11, 58, and 68 of the ’342 patent and my analysis here also applies
`
`to the overlapping aspects of those claims. I understand that construing this term
`
`requires identifying specific structures in the patent that perform the recited function
`
`of “connecting a user of said wireless device to user information stored for the
`
`respective wireless device on a server in a communications network.”
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 8 of 51
`
`

`
`15. I first note that patent does not discuss user information stored
`
`for a specific wireless device. I also note that the structure for performing the
`
`“connecting” function does not depend on who or what the information is “stored
`
`for.” In other words, the language “stored for the respective wireless device” does
`
`not impact the structure for performing this function, especially given the ’987
`
`patent’s lack of any description in this regard. Thus, I confine my analysis to
`
`locating a structure or structures “for connecting a user of said wireless device to
`
`user information stored … on a server in a communications network.”
`
`16. The ’987 patent describes the following structure that connects a
`
`wireless device to user information stored on a server: the combination of a
`
`“digital baseband” and “TCP/IP services.” E.g., ’987 patent 6:63-68, Figs. 1,
`
`3A-3D.
`
`17. The ’987 patent does not define or explain the term “digital
`
`baseband.” A POSITA would have understood “digital baseband,” as used in the
`
`’342 and ’987 patents, to refer to a combination of hardware and software
`
`configured to down-convert a signal and further process it to extract
`
`information being received (receive path) or process information into a signal
`
`and then up-convert the signal for transmission (transmit path). All practical
`
`wireless systems that I am aware of – including cell phone, Wi-Fi, and other
`
`networks – use an approach of up-conversion and down-conversion when sending
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 9 of 51
`
`

`
`or receiving signals. Thus, as part of transmitting a signal, a device’s wireless
`
`interface first processes the information intended for transmission, including steps
`
`such as coding for error correction and modulation, into a modified signal and then
`
`up-converts the modified signal to a higher frequency for wireless transmission.
`
`Conversely, when receiving a wireless signal, a device’s wireless interface first
`
`down-converts the received signal to a lower frequency for processing to extract the
`
`information being communicated. Typically this information is then handed off to
`
`the device’s operating system or a specific application. The device component that
`
`performs the up-conversion / down-conversion just discussed is often referred to as
`
`a transceiver. The device component that performs the aforementioned processing
`
`is often called a baseband processor. Devices referred to as modems often combines
`
`these two device components, although strictly speaking, modulation/demodulation
`
`is typically a baseband process. Accordingly, within the industry, POSITAs would
`
`have used the terms modem and transceiver interchangeably. They would also have
`
`understood that the term baseband used in isolation to imply the presence of a
`
`transceiver, or to include a transceiver, simply because a baseband processor in
`
`isolation cannot transmit or receive radio signals.
`
`18. A POSITA would understand “TCP/IP services” as referring to
`
`services for carrying out communications using the TCP/IP suite of protocols,
`
`which are the basis of Internet-based communications. The TCP/IP suite of
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 10 of 51
`
`

`
`protocols would have been understood to include Internet Protocol (IP) at the
`
`network layer and both Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and User Datagram
`
`Protocol (UDP) at the transport layer for transfer of user information. Thus, this
`
`term encompasses interface hardware and/or software configured to carry out
`
`data transfer over a network such as the Internet, or otherwise using portions
`
`of the TCP/IP suite of protocols for data communications across a network.
`
`c. “Means For Downloading …”
`
`19. The term “means for downloading said user information to
`
`said wireless device” appears in the ’987 patent claim 7. The same or similar terms
`
`appear in claims 11, 58, and 68 of the ’342 patent and my analysis here also applies
`
`to the overlapping aspects of those claims. I understand that construing this term
`
`requires identifying structures in the patent that perform the recited function of
`
`“downloading said user information to said wireless device.” The ’987 patent
`
`describes the following structure that downloads user information from a server to
`
`a wireless device: the combination of a “digital baseband,” “TCP/IP services,”
`
`and a “desktop browser.” E.g., ’987 patent 6:63-67 and 7:4-12, Figs. 1, 3A-3D.
`
`“Digital baseband” and “TCP/IP services” would be understood the same as
`
`described above in paragraphs 17. -18.
`
`20. The ’987 patent does not define the term “desktop browser,”
`
`although it appears frequently. It does describe the desktop browser as accessing
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 11 of 51
`
`

`
`“browser-based applications” in a system used “to send messages and data to, and
`
`receive messages and data from the browser-based applications and or services.”
`
`’987 patent 7:5-9. This follows the patent’s statement that the invention provides
`
`access to “browser-based” web sites and applications through the wireless device.
`
`’987 patent, 3:17-19 and Abstract. The term “desktop browser” would have been
`
`understood to refer to a conventional Internet browser, although the “desktop
`
`browser” in the patent is depicted as being part of a “cell phone desktop operating
`
`system” for example in Fig. 3A of the ’987 patent. The patent also states that the
`
`wireless device is not limited to cell phones but could be a “Blackberry, Palm, or
`
`other communicator” device. ’987 patent 14:29-31. Given the lack of a specific
`
`definition and the inconsistent usage of this term, a POSITA would have understood
`
`“desktop browser” to encompass software configured to access any browser-
`
`based web site, e.g., a web browser.
`
`d. “Means For Relaying …”
`
`21. The
`
`term “means for relaying the downloaded user
`
`information, at the control of said user, to a peripheral device” appears in the
`
`’987 patent claim 7. The same or similar terms appear in claims 11, 58, and 68 of
`
`the ’342 patent and my analysis here also applies to the overlapping aspects of those
`
`claims. I understand that construing this term requires identifying structures in the
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 12 of 51
`
`

`
`patent that perform the recited function of “relaying the downloaded user
`
`information, at the control of said user, to a peripheral device.”
`
`22. I first note that the patent does not use the term “relay” or
`
`“relaying.” It does, however, discuss transmitting downloaded user information
`
`from the wireless device to the peripheral device, and I understand this transmitting
`
`as being the claimed relaying. I note that even though the user may control the type
`
`or use of content, the type or use of content streamed (e.g., selecting a specific video
`
`or pausing or fast-forwarding a video) does not impact the “relaying” structure.
`
`23. The ’987 patent describes the following structure that transmits,
`
`under control of a user, the downloaded user information to a peripheral device: a
`
`“desktop browser”; “TCP/IP services”; a “device driver” for peripheral
`
`communications hardware configured to implement at least one of the USB,
`
`IEEE 1394, or IEEE 802.11 protocols; and “peripheral communications
`
`hardware and software” configured to implement at least one of the USB,
`
`IEEE 1394, or IEEE 802.11 protocols. E.g., ’987 patent 7:4-18, 8:60-9:12, 9:59-
`
`67, Figs. 1, 3A-3D. “Digital baseband” and “TCP/IP services” would be understood
`
`the same as described above in paragraphs 17. -18. “Desktop browser” would be
`
`understood the same as described above in paragraph 20.
`
`24. The patent identifies “device drivers” as used to transmit user
`
`information to the peripheral devices, but does not identify specific device drivers,
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 13 of 51
`
`

`
`for example at 7:9-14. The ‘987 patent uses the word “driver” consistently with how
`
`the term would have been used in the industry, namely as software that sits between
`
`the operating system and hardware devices. The context suggests that these device
`
`drivers are drivers for the peripheral communications hardware. This makes sense,
`
`because any device capable of processor-based network communications would
`
`necessarily have device drivers for the network interface. Moreover, the ’987 patent
`
`shows the device drivers as located between the TCP/IP services and the peripheral
`
`communications hardware and software,
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 14 of 51
`
`

`
`Thus, in the context of the ’987 patent the “drivers” that make up in part the
`
`structure for relaying could be any driver for peripheral communications hardware
`
`configured to carry out one of the protocols specified by the ’987 patent, i.e., USB,
`
`
`
`IEEE 1394, or IEEE 802.11.
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 15 of 51
`
`

`
`25. The ’987 patent also mentions “peripheral communications
`
`hardware and software” as part of the transmitting function, for example at 7:9-14.
`
`The phrase “peripheral communications hardware and software” does not connote
`
`a clear structure unless the communications protocols are specified. The ’987 patent
`
`includes several separate disclosures, including specific protocols, as well as
`
`disclosure of (Box 480) the peripheral communications hardware and software.
`
`Together, these disclosures would have informed a POSITA that the “peripheral
`
`communications hardware and software” would be hardware and software
`
`configured to implement at least one of the particular USB, IEEE 1394, or IEEE
`
`802.11 protocols.
`
`e. “Means For Operating …”
`
`26. The term “means for operating said peripheral device from
`
`said wireless device” appears in the ’987 patent claim 7. The same or similar terms
`
`appear in claims 11, 58, and 68 of the ’342 patent and my analysis here also applies
`
`to the overlapping aspects of those claims. I understand that construing this term
`
`requires identifying structures in the patent that perform the recited function of
`
`“operating said peripheral device from said wireless device.” In paragraph 61 of my
`
`April 30 Declaration, I explained how the patent does not discuss “operating” the
`
`peripheral devices, but that a POSITA would have understood it to mean controlling
`
`the peripheral device from the wireless device. I further explained how control
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 16 of 51
`
`

`
`could take two forms: either the wireless device generally operating the peripheral,
`
`as part of a “traditional desktop computing environment” configuration or explicit
`
`control through a (remote) command interface of the peripheral device.
`
`27. For the wireless device as CPU form of operation, the
`
`corresponding structures are essentially the same as for the “means for relaying …”
`
`element discussed above: the TCP/IP services, device drivers for peripheral
`
`hardware communications configured to implement at least one of the USB, IEEE
`
`1394, or IEEE 802.11 protocols, and “peripheral communications hardware and
`
`software” configured to implement at least one of the USB, IEEE 1394, or IEEE
`
`802.11 protocols. These structures allow the wireless device to communicate with,
`
`and thus control, the peripheral devices.
`
`28. For the explicit control form of operation, the ’987 patent
`
`discloses several different structures, each of which could be used to operate a
`
`peripheral device, such as a display, from the wireless device. On the wireless
`
`device itself, the patent describes a “keypad.” ’987 patent 11:59-60. The patent also
`
`describes a keyboard and mouse connected to the wireless device, also allowing
`
`users to operate peripheral devices. ’987 patent 13:58-62. Thus, the structure in the
`
`patent for carrying out this “operating …” function could be either the wireless
`
`device keypad or a keyboard connected to the wireless device or a mouse connected
`
`to the wireless device.
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 17 of 51
`
`

`
`f. “User Information”
`
`29. In paragraph 37 of my April 30 Declaration, I provide examples
`
`of “user information” in the context of the ’342 and ’987 patents. Neither the
`
`claims nor the specification define a particular meaning for “user information.” The
`
`specification, however focuses on Internet- or web-accessible information and data.
`
`Thus, in reading the ’987 and ’342 patents, a POSITA would have understood “user
`
`information” to generally encompass at least any data, documents, or information
`
`accessible to one or more users over a network, e.g., through a web browser via the
`
`Internet. This is consistent with the ’342 and ’987 patents’ discussion of user
`
`information downloaded from the Internet. The only application that the patents
`
`disclose for accessing the user information is a web browser. Even for media
`
`applications, the patents refer to browser-based Internet media applications. For
`
`example, the ’987 patent describes transmitting various types of information to
`
`peripheral devices and then states that “[a]ll of these transmissions may be made
`
`through the wireless cell phone device's browser interface.” ’987 patent, 6:31-50.
`
`30. A POSITA would have understood that the “user information”
`
`downloaded from the Internet would include either users accessing “user
`
`information” uploaded by the user or “user information” uploaded by others. For
`
`example, the ’987 and ’342 patents discus “information … stored on a remote server
`
`700, upon which the user’s (or another’s) data, work space or environment
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 18 of 51
`
`

`
`information resides.” ‘987 patent, 14:23-27. A POSITA reading the patent thus
`
`would have envisioned user information on services such as Hotmail and YouTube.
`
`In the case of Hotmail, the server would store and make available (by web browser)
`
`emails both sent by the user and sent by others. In this vein, the ’987 patent also
`
`describes how songs may be stored in a “user’s personal space on the Internet” or,
`
`alternatively, “attached in an email,” presumably sent by another user. 13:65-14:3.
`
`In the case of YouTube, a user could access videos that he or she uploaded or videos
`
`uploaded by others, in both instances accessing the information from Internet web
`
`servers using a web browser.
`
`31. In any event, the type or source or originator of the “user
`
`information” does not impact the claimed structures or methods in a technologically
`
`meaningful way. In other words, whether the information was originally uploaded
`
`by User A or User B, the claims are carried out in the same way. For example, the
`
`“user information” could be email from a Hotmail or other browser-based email
`
`account, a video previously uploaded by a user or third-party to YouTube (officially
`
`launched in December 2005) or another video-sharing site, or results from a web
`
`search. For all of these information types, the claimed acts and structures would be
`
`the same, and nothing in the ’987 patent suggests otherwise. All of these different
`
`types of “user information” would be downloaded, transmitted, etc. in similar
`
`fashion.
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 19 of 51
`
`

`
`B. Similarity of Claims and Claim Terms
`
`32. I note that the elements recited in ’342 patent claims 11-19, 58-
`
`67, and 68-76 largely overlap, as can be seen in the following side-by-side table:
`
`Claims 11-19
`
`Claims 58-67
`
`Claims 68-76
`
`Claim 11:
`11.1 A wireless device
`for facilitating user
`connectivity, comprising:
`
`Claim 58:
`58.1 A wireless device
`for facilitating user
`connectivity, comprising
`
`Claim 68:
`68.1 A wireless device
`for facilitating user
`connectivity, comprising:
`
`11.2 means for
`connecting a user of said
`wireless device to user
`information stored on a
`server in a
`communications
`network;
`
`58.2 means for
`connecting a user of said
`wireless device to user
`information stored on a
`server in a
`communications
`network;
`
`68.2 means for
`connecting a user of said
`wireless device to user
`information stored on a
`server in a
`communications
`network;
`
`11.3 means for
`downloading said user
`information to said
`wireless device;
`
`58.3 means for
`downloading said user
`information to said
`wireless device;
`
`68.3 means for
`downloading said user
`information to said
`wireless device;
`
`11.4 means for relaying
`the downloaded user
`information, at the
`control of said user, to a
`peripheral device; and
`
`68.4 means for relaying
`the downloaded user
`information, at the
`control of said user, to a
`peripheral device, said
`peripheral device being
`connected to a separate
`system; and
`
`58.4 means for relaying
`the downloaded user
`information, at the
`control of said user, to a
`peripheral device, said
`peripheral device being
`connected to another
`device selected from the
`group consisting of a
`portable PC, tablet
`computer, desktop
`computer and media
`center; and
`
`11.5 means for operating
`said peripheral device
`
`58.5means for operating
`said peripheral device
`
`68.5 means for operating
`said peripheral device
`
`
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 20 of 51
`
`

`
`Claims 11-19
`
`Claims 58-67
`
`Claims 68-76
`
`from said wireless
`device,
`
`from said wireless
`device,
`
`from said wireless
`device,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`68.6 whereby the
`downloaded user
`information on said
`peripheral device creates
`an environment selected
`from the group
`consisting of a desktop
`computing environment,
`a media center
`environment, a portable
`PC computing
`environment, a tablet
`computer computing
`
`
`
`11.6 wherein said
`peripheral device,
`controlled by said user
`from said wireless
`device, is connected to a
`separate system, and
`
`11.7 wherein said
`peripheral device
`comprises a hub,
`
`58.6 whereby said
`peripheral device is
`selected from the group
`consisting of a keyboard,
`a monitor, a mouse,
`speakers, a wireline hub,
`and combinations
`thereof.
`
`
`
`11.8 whereby a plurality
`of components connected
`to said peripheral device
`are accessible
`therethrough.
`
`
`
`
`
`Claim 59:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 58,
`wherein the downloaded
`user information on said
`peripheral device creates
`an environment selected
`from the group consisting
`of a desktop computing
`environment, a media
`center environment, a
`portable PC computing
`environment, a tablet
`computer computing
`environment and
`combinations thereof.
`
`SECOND RYSAVY DECLARATION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Page 21 of 51
`
`

`
`Claims 11-19
`
`Claims 58-67
`
`Claims 68-76
`
`Claim 12:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 11,
`further comprising:
`
`Claim 60:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 58,
`further comprising
`
`environment and
`combinations thereof.
`
`Claim 69:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 68,
`further comprising:
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireless communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`information transmitted
`from said wireless
`device; and
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireless communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`information transmitted
`from said wireless
`device; and
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireless communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`information transmitted
`from said wireless
`device; and
`
`means for employing, at
`said peripheral device,
`said downloaded user
`information.
`
`means for employing, at
`said peripheral device,
`said downloaded user
`information.
`
`means for employing, at
`said peripheral device,
`said downloaded user
`information.
`
`Claim 13:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 11,
`further comprising:
`
`Claim 61:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 58,
`further comprising:
`
`Claim 70:
`The wireless device
`according to claim 68,
`further comprising:
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireline communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`information transmitted
`from said wireless
`device; and
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireline communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`information transmitted
`from said wireless
`device; and
`
`means for receiving, at
`said peripheral device, a
`wireline communication
`containing said
`downloaded user
`informatio