UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
`WASHINGTON, D.C.
`
`Before the Honorable Theodore R. Essex
`Administrative Law Judge
`
`In the Matter of
`
`CERTAIN MOBILE DEVICES
`AND RELATED SOFTWARE
`
`Investigation No. 337-TA-750
`
`COMPLAINANT APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO RESPONDENT
`MOTOROLA MOBILITY, INC.'S REBUTTAL EXHIBITS, INCLUDING
`REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENTS AND CORRESPONDING
`DEMONSTRATIVES
`
`Pursuant to Order No. 13, Complainant Apple Inc. ("Apple") submits the
`
`following objections to the rebuttal exhibits of Motorola Mobility, Inc. ("Motorola"),
`
`including rebuttal witness statements and corresponding demonstrative exhibits. These
`
`objections are supplemental to any motions to strike or motions in limine that Apple has
`
`filed and are not intended to limit the scope of any such motions. Apple's objections to
`
`Motorola's rebuttal trial exhibits are attached as Exhibit A. Apple's objections to
`
`Motorola's rebuttal witness statements and corresponding demonstratives are listed in the
`
`tables below. Apple expressly incorporates herein the objections listed in Exhibit A to
`
`the exhibits referred to by the questions and answers below. Further, Apple does not
`
`waive any objections to an exhibit because of its failure to object to the use of the exhibit
`
`in a witness statement. The objections use the following abbreviations:
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`Conclusory opinion
`C
`Errata contains new or inconsistent testimony not offered at deposition
`ECNI
`
`(cid:9)
`

`

`NP
`S
`
`U
`V
`W
`FRE 105
`FRE 106
`FRE 402
`FRE 403
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`Exhibit and/or testimony lacks foundation
`F
`Illegible
`L
`Exhibit subject to a motion in limine
`MIL
`Calls for a narrative
`N
`Not substantive evidence / Exhibit should be marked for identification
`NE
`only
`Not produced in discovery
`Counterdesignation outside the scope of the corresponding initial
`designation
`Unable to evaluate the exhibit / Source code exhibit
`Vague
`Wrong document / Exhibit does not match description
`For limited purpose of X only
`Incomplete document
`Relevance
`Relevance substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice; cumulative
`exhibit
`Privileged settlement communication
`Witness lacks personal knowledge
`Leading question
`Improper opinion testimony by lay witness
`Improper expert opinion testimony
`Hearsay
`Authenticity
`Best evidence
`Improper summary
`
`Failure to comply with Commission Rule 210.50(b)(1) ("an
`administrative law judge shall not address the issue of the public
`interest")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 4.4.1.2 (Outside scope of witness's
`30(b)(6) designation)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 4.4.1.3 (Deposition not admissible)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 5 (Not on Notice of Prior Art)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.1 (Legal argument must be presented in
`the briefs)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.3 (Legal experts may only testify as to
`procedures of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.4.1.3 ("A witness statement shall
`contain separately numbered questions which are asked by counsel,
`with each question followed by the witness' own answer to that
`question.")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.5.1 (Expert reports are not evidence)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.7 (No translation provided for exhibit
`
`FRE 408
`FRE 602
`FRE 611
`FRE 701
`FRE 702
`FRE 802
`FRE 901
`FRE 1002
`FRE 1006
`FCCR
`210.50(b)(1)
`
`FCGR 4.4.1.2
`
`FCGR 4.4.1.3
`FCGR 5
`FCGR 9.1
`
`FCGR 9.3
`
`FCGR 9.4.1.3
`
`FCGR 9.5.1
`FCGR 9.7
`
`

`

`FCGR 9.8.1
`
`FCGR 9.8.5.3
`
`FCGR 9.8.7
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`that will be offered to be received into evidence for substantive
`purposes; uncertified translation provided for exhibit that will be
`offered to be received into evidence for substantive purposes)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.1 (Untimely disclosure of exhibit;
`duplicate of joint exhibit)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.5.3 (Pages not sequentially numbered
`in consistent location)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.7 ("Every exhibit list shall consist of a
`table enumerating all exhibits serially by exhibit number and
`identifying each exhibit by a descriptive title, a brief statement of the
`purpose for which the exhibit is being offered into evidence, the name
`of the sponsoring witness, and the status of receipt of the exhibit into
`evidence.")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.8 (Multiple documents within one
`exhibit)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.12 (Improper sponsoring witness)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 10.5.6 (Expert testimony outside the
`scope of the expert report and/or expert deposition testimony)
`
`FCGR 9.8.12
`FCGR 10.5.6
`
`FCGR 9.8.8
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE WITNESS STATEMENT [RX-1859C] OF
`DALE BENGTSON
`
`es/Exhibit (cid:9)
`.,,
`
`Qusiona4IIflwer Nunn ci in (cid:9)
`Witness
`Q. 1-142 (All) (cid:9)
`Q. 32, 52, 54, 63-64, 68-69 (cid:9)
`
`Q. 35, 37, 51, 53 (cid:9)
`
`Q. 42-47, 55-61, 65-67, 71, 106, 108-
`110, 116, 124
`
`I (cid:9)
`
`Q. 48, 62 (cid:9)
`
`Q. 73-75, 121 (cid:9)
`Q. 79-87, 89-94, 96-102 (cid:9)
`Q. 88, 95 (cid:9)
`Q. 107, 115, 120, 123, 128, 135-141 (cid:9)
`
`jeetons
`
`MIL
`FRE 701, FRE 702
`Vague, FRE 611, FRE 701,
`FRE 702
`
`FRE 602
`
`FRE 602, FRE 611, FRE 701,
`FRE 702
`FRE 402, FRE 602
`FRE 402
`FRE 402, FRE 701, FRE 702
`FRE 602, FRE 701, FRE 702
`
`ri
`
`(cid:9)
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1860C] OF DAVID BOLDT
`
`m~e~a
`
`bswe . (cid:9)
`Quests anan (cid:9)
`itnessSttateme (cid:9)
`Q. 7, 14, 16, 17-19, 28, 34, 35, 42, 56,
`60-66, 71, 75, 76, 80-82, 89-98, 140,
`163, 177, 182, 184, 187
`Q. 29, 38, 39, 43-53, 111, 113, 114,
`117, 118, 129, 131-137, 142-144, 156-
`161, 170-176, 185, 186, 188, 191, 194,
`196. 197
`
`,._
`
`t bi (cid:9)
`
`
`
`,-
`
`Oh c
`
`
`
`V. F
`
`V, F, FRE 602, FRE 701,
`FCGR 9.1
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`JRX-1861C] OF JEFF BROWN
`
`F-(~u estion uid Answer NJiber in (cid:9)
`
`Witness Stakrnent
`5-6 (cid:9)
`
`otes/Exhibits
`
`objections
`
`F
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1869C] OF DIANE HACKBORN
`
`Question and Answer Number in
`~?4~sleiize~~t
`
`Q. 8-12, 31, 32, 41, 48-54, 62, 63, 65,
`75-84, 99-102, 104, 105, 107, 112, 113,
`126-131, 143-147, 152, 157-164, 171,
`174,179,181,186-189
`Q.6,7,24,25,30,34,35-38, 110, 111,
`118-122, 125, 132-134, 136, 149, 156,
`165-170, 177, 192, 193, 196
`
`Notts/Exhibits
`
`Objections
`
`V, F
`
`V, F, FRE 602, FRE 701,
`FCGR 9.1
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1894C] AND DEMONSTRATIVES [ LOCKE RDX 13 . 1-13.6 ("RDX-13")]
`OF C. DOUGLASS LOCKE
`
`Question and answer Number in Not/Eh thits
`
`Witness St~ttekt+vnt
`
`b~t~t~t's
`
`Q. 9, 10, 24, 26, 27, 28, 54, 58, 85, 87,
`88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 97, 98,
`99,111,115,116,117,118,125,130,
`131, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141,
`142, 146, 155, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178
`Q. 36, 37, 38, 158, 188
`Q. 44, 45, 46, 130, 131, 135, 146, 156,
`194, 195, 196, 205
`
`Q. 87-99, 174-178
`
`Q. 104, 105
`Q. 116, 118, 125, 131, 137, 140, 142,
`151,155,156,179,183,189,195,197,
`201, 202, 206
`
`FCGR 10.5.6, F, MIL
`
`F, FRE 602
`
`F, FRE 403
`
`FCGR 9.1, FRE 403, FRE
`602, FRE 702
`FRE 602
`
`F, C, FCGR 9.1
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1875C] AND CORRESPONDING DEMONSTRATIVES [MOORE RDX
`("RDX-12")] OF STEPHEN MOORE
`
`Question and Answer Number
`in W ltnesti StatE n1
`
`NotWSlFxbibits
`s.. §
`
`5, 29. 30-35
`26
`
`RDX-12.3C-.4C
`RDX-12.7C-.8C
`RDX-12.70C-.100C
`RDX-12.101C-.130C
`RDX-12.131C-.156C
`RDX-12.157C-.228C
`RDX-12.229C-.274C
`
`36-39, 49-56, 68-73, 77-78
`
`79-80
`
`Objections
`
`F
`FRE 602
`
`NP
`
`W
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1876C] OF CARLA S. MULHERN
`
`Questi©nit td Answer Number in
`W4 iess Statement
`
`Notes/Exhibits
`
`Obct~p~
`
`
`
`23
`
`25
`
`34
`35
`38
`
`39
`
`40
`41
`42
`43
`44
`45
`46
`47
`48
`
`50
`
`51
`
`52
`
`53
`54
`55
`56
`57
`58
`59
`62
`87
`93
`94
`95
`96
`
`RX-905C-916C
`
`RX-905C-916C
`
`10
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE
`402/403, F
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE
`402/403, F
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F;
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 4021403
`FRE 402/403
`FCGR 10.5.6; FCGR 9.1;
`FCGR 9.3; F
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403; FCGR 9.1;
`FCGR 9 . 3; FRE 702;_F
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 702; FCGR 9.1
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`FCGR 10.5.6; F
`
`

`

`st
`
`100
`107
`108
`109
`112
`114
`118
`122
`124
`
`125
`
`126
`
`129
`
`130
`
`131
`
`132
`
`133
`
`134
`135
`
`136
`
`137
`
`138
`
`139
`
`140
`
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 802; F
`FRE 402/403/802; F
`FRE 402/403/802; F
`FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403; F
`FRE 802
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F
`FRE 402/403
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE
`402/403, F
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE
`402/403, F
`F; FRE 602; FRE 402/403;
`FRE 702
`F; FRE 602; FRE 402/403;
`FRE 702
`F; FRE 602; FRE 402/403;
`FRE 702
`F; FRE 602; FRE 402/403;
`FRE 702
`F; FRE 602; FRE 402/403;
`FRE 702
`FRE 402/403
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE 402/403
`FRE 402/403; NE; FCGR
`9.8.12
`FRE 402/403
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F;
`FRE 402/403; FRE 702
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F;
`FRE 402/403; FRE 702
`FCGR 9.1; FCGR 9.3; F;
`FRE 402/403; FRE 702
`
`RX-916C
`
`RX-914C
`
`RX-1206
`
`RX-1203
`
`RX-915C
`RX-1290C
`
`RX-1106
`
`RX-1093
`
`11
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1877C] OF MICHAEL OLLEY
`
`)cr in
`
`Question rnd Answer Ntt (cid:9)
`Witness Statement
` --
`5, 8, 27-29, 82-84
`
`68-69, 72-73, 78, 81
`86-87, 96-98
`
`Notes /tai - (cid:9)
`
`s
`
`--- (cid:9)
`
`Objections
`
`-- (cid:9)
`
`F (cid:9)
`FRE 602
`FRE 611
`
`----
`
`12
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-18781 OF ANDY RUBIN
`
`QuOti o+i and Answer;N (cid:9)
`
`ern (cid:9)
`
`Notcsll' xhibits.
`
`~.
`
`Q. 1-93 (All) (cid:9)
`
`Q. 33, 42,46,49-55,57,58,60,61,70- (cid:9)
`72, 76-92
`
`Objectir w
`
`FRE 402, FRE 403, NP,
`FCGR 210.50(b)(1), MIL
`
`V, F, FRE 602, FRE 701
`
`13
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`(RX-1879C] OF MARTIN SIMMONS
`
`} (cid:9)
`
`Question and Ati veer>:1 (cid:9)
`Witness Statement
`
`.... -.:.r
`
`5-7
`14-19,24
`13, 15, 17, 20-22, 26
`42, 44, 45, 56, 58, 59
`
`er: n'
`
`::::.: (cid:9)
`,.;:N (cid:9)
`
`.
`
`/I xhihifs
`
`Objections
`
`F
`FRE 611
`FRE 701, FCGR 9.1
`FRE 602
`
`[Ell
`
`

`

`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO THE REBUTTAL WITNESS STATEMENT
`[RX-1895C] AND DEMONSTRATIVES [WOLFE REBUTTAL RDX ("RDX-11")]
`OF ANDREW WOLFE
`
`Ø~ tiun illZk (cid:9)
`Witness Statement
`
`in ' y
`O IB C"'t30i1S
`
`Q. 10-18, 24-26, 44, 47, 63, 73, 79, 85,
`98-99, 114, 116-120, 123-125, 129-130,
`134, 136, 137-145, 148-157, 159-168,
`170, 173-176, 180-181, 189-190, 192,
`194, 196, 198, 199-200, 204-210, 220-
`235, 245-246, 253-254, 263-265, 267-
`270,282,291,313-314
`
`Q. 36-38, 41-42
`Q. 62, 315
`Q. 47-48, 50, 52
`Q. 72
`Q. 108
`Q. 83, 90
`Q. 282
`Q. 177-179, 213, 215, 295, 301
`Q. 313-316
`
`RDX-11.2C,
`RDX-11.3 C,
`RDX-11.6C,
`RDX-11.7C,
`RDX-11.8C,
`RDX-11.9C,
`RDX-11.1 OC,
`RDX-11.11C,
`RDX-11.12C,
`RDX-11.13C,
`RDX-11.14C,
`RDX-11.16C,
`RDX-11.17C,
`RDX-11.19C,
`RDX-11.22C,
`RDX-11.30C,
`RDX-11.31 C,
`RDX-11.32C,
`RDX-11.34C,
`RDX-11.35C,
`RDX-11.36C
`
`15
`
`FCGR 10.5.6
`
`FRE 402, FCGR 10.5.6
`FRE 402
`N
`F
`F, FRE 611
`FRE 611
`9.4.1.3
`FRE 802, FCGR 10.5.6
`FRE 802
`
`

`

`Dated: September 12, 2011 (cid:9)
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By .
`
`Mark G. avis
`Brian E. Ferguson
`Robert T. Vlasis
`Edward S. Jou
`Christopher T. Marando
`Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
`1300 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 900
`Washington, D.C. 20005
`Tel: (202) 682-7000
`Fax: (202) 857-0940
`
`Anne M. Cappella
`Jill J. Ho
`Jacqueline T. Harlow
`Erin C. Jones
`Brian C. Chang
`Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
`201 Redwood Shores Parkway
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`Tel: (650) 802-3000
`
`Matthew D. Powers
`Steven S. Cherensky
`Paul T. Ehrlich
`Robert L. Gerrity
`Tensegrity Law Group LLP
`201 Redwood Shores Parkway, Suite
`401
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`Tel: (650) 802-6000
`
`Attorneys for Complainant
`APPLE INC.
`
`16
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT A
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`

`In the Matter of Certain Mobile Devices and Related Software
`ITC investigation No. 337-TA75O
`Complainant Apple Inc.'s Objections to Respondant Motorola Mobility, Inc.'s Rebuttal Exhibits (including exhibits sponsored solely by Carla Mulhem)
`
`95.1898
`
`9/e/2011
`
`RX-1893.1
`
`http;//deoeloper.apple.corn/llbrary/rriac/adocu
`95.1893.13 mentatios/Darwin/Conceptual/kExTConcept/K
`EXTConceptlOgit/iokit_tutorial.htrnl
`
`RX-1094C
`
`Rebuttal Witness Statement of C. Douglas
`Locke
`
`RX-1895C
`
`9/6/2011
`
`Rebuttal Witness Statement of Andrew Wolfe
`
`RX-1o96
`
`4/20/2011
`
`RX-1896.1
`
`905-11
`
`9/6/2011
`
`RDX-12
`
`9/6/2011
`
`RDX-13
`
`9/6/2011
`
`RDX-14
`
`9/6/2011
`
`U.S. Patent Application Publication No.
`2011/0000016
`
`Demonstratives to be used with the testimony
`of Andrew Wolfe as set forth In the rebuttal
`witness statement of 9/6/22
`
`Demonstratives to be used with the testimony
`of Stephen Moore as set forth in the rebuttal
`witness statement of 9/6/11
`
`Demonstratives to be used with the testimony
`of C. Douglas Locke as set forth in the rebuttal
`witness statement of 9/6/11
`
`Demonstrations to be used with the testimony
`of Michael 011ey as set forth in the rebuttal
`witness statement of 9/6/11
`
`%z ISPPth
`
`pvRso
`
`o'ooiwo wrs
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`FCGR 10.5.6, MIL
`
`Invalidity, Non-infringement, DI
`
`Locke
`
`See Apple's objections to the rebuttal
`witness statement of C. Douglas Locke
`
`See Apple's objections tothe rebuttal
`witness statement of Andrew Wolfe
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Non-infringement
`
`Wolfe
`
`,
`Son Apple
` a objections to rebuttal
`wit witness statement of Andrew Wolfe
`
`Non-infringement; lack of domestic
`industry
`
`See Apple's objections to rebuttal
`witness statement of Stephen Moore
`
`Non-infringement
`
`Moore
`
`See Apple's objections to rebuttal
`witness statement of C. Douglas Locke
`
`Non-infringement; lack of domestic
`i ndustry
`
`Locke
`
`See Apple's objections to rebuttal
`witness statement of Michael 011ey
`
`Non-infringement
`
`011ey
`
`RX-5C
`
`5/7/2510
`
`RX.6C
`
`11/2/2010
`
`745-
`748-
`App1e0019077 App1e0019151
`745-
`,8pp1e0019257 ApisleO01OS79
`
`Inv. 337.TA-710 Deposition Transcript of
`Andrew Allen
`Inv. 887-10-710 Deposition Transcript of
`Andrew Allen
`
`PRE 802
`
`FRE 802
`
`F. FCGR 9.8,12, FOE 402
`
`lack of domestic Industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRO 402
`
`lack of domestic Industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`NSS 3rd Quarter of 2009
`
`L
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`RX-ZSC
`
`2009
`
`AI6576123
`
`Al4875
`
`RX-30C
`
`10/2009
`
`745-
`745-
`App1e6409535 Apple6409563
`
`RX-37C
`
`2020
`
`RX.38C
`
`2010
`
`RX-39C
`
`11/24/2000
`
`RX-40C
`
`1/8/2088
`
`RX-41C
`
`N/A
`
`RX-42C
`
`2009
`
`RX.48C
`
`3/11/2009
`
`RX-44C
`
`4/7/2009
`
`Apple7244525
`Apple7244512
`748-
`745-
`App1n7244711
`Aop1e7244665
`785-
`745-
`Aop1e7277106 App1e7277121
`748-
`App1n7480130
`
`Acwle7480155
`745-
`Ayy1e7483563 Apple (cid:9)
`93563
`78-
`AppleOOe 1546
`
`Apple8061425
`788-
`App1e0062008 AppleOOGlO3f
`75_
`App1e0062896 AppieS062418
`
`AppleCare Support Impact Analysis
`
`FRE 802, F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRO 402
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`N90 FQ2'20 Quarterly Cost and Risk Charts
`
`N90 P0210 Quarterly Cost and Risk Charts with
`Gross Margins
`
`502 2009 First Quarter Gross Margin Summary
`
`Executive Summary: 01 '08 Units View
`
`Annual Volume Commitment/ Annual
`Marketing Commitment
`
`N82 iPhone Cost Model Summaryfor 02 '09
`_____________________________________
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`I.
`
`L
`
`L
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9,8.12, FRE 402
`
`lank of domestic Industry/bonding
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`M ulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`Life Cycle Product Matrix- Hardware
`
`L
`_______________________________
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`_______________________________
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`_________________________________
`
`Mulhern
`_____________________
`
`Life Cycle Product Matrix- Hardware
`
`L
`
`F, FCGR 9.3,12, FRE 402
`lack of domestic Industry/bonding
` _______________________________ _________________________________
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`In the Matter of Certain Mobile Devices and Related Software
`ITC Investigation No. 337-TA-750
`Complainant Apple Inc.'s Objections to Respondant Motorola Mobility, Inc.'s Rebuttal Exhibits (including exhibits sponsored solely by Carla Mulhem)
`
`Deite
`
`FME5El3lN
`
`RATO%,EHD
`
`OSOCUMEIO8 )ESkBR'fl0fB Z..
`
`92 Objetheox
`
`832b/ecbpos
`
`tHlPQSt
`
`PS0IME3 W(RPIESS(ea
`
`sitettst
`
`RX-147C
`
`2/3/2005
`
`750-
`750-
`Apple0388552 App1e0388620
`
`Agreement and Plan of Reorganization
`between Apple Computer, Inc., Tickle
`Acquisition Corporation, Fingerworks,Inc.,
`John Elias, Wayne Westerman, Jeffrey White,
`and Frank Lytle dated February 3, 2005
`
`All objections in objections to rebuttal
`
`
`witness statement
`
`F. FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-240C
`
`4/28/2008
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-AFFLE-
`0004930693
`000S950653
`
`Model name spreadsheet
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-242C
`
`5/22/2009
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE- Mobile Devices Supply Chain Quality Materials All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`& Failure Analysis Laboratory
`0005050004
`0003030007
`
`F, FCGR 9812 PRE 402
`,
`. (cid:9)
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding/Non.
`Infringement
`
`EX-244C
`
`01/00/2010
`
`MOTO-AFFLE- MOTO-APPLE.
`0005055205
`0005055244
`
`maxTouch 224 channel Touchscreen Sensor IC
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 0.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding/Non.
`infringement
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`EX-246C
`
`3/15/2010
`
`M070-APPLE' MOb-APPLE-
`0005097663
`0005097663
`
`Chart of Hawkeye information
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-247C
`
`7/00/2010
`
`MOT-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0005102140
`0005181710
`
`8-bit AVR Microcontroller with 16K/32k/64k All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`Bytes in-System Programmable Flash
`
`F. FCGR 9.8.22, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhem
`
`RX-256C
`
`N/A
`
`RX-289
`
`3/4/1999
`
`MOTO-APPLE_
`0005578653
`
`MOTO-APPLE-
`0005578653
`
`M0TO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0007083377
`0007053325
`
`Vibrator location
`
`1, H
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic Industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Certified copy of U.S. Patent No. 5,900,870
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, Pitt 402
`
`invalidity/lack of domestic
`industry/bonding
`
`Locke/Muihern
`
`RX-765C
`
`2007-2010
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Financials
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-0903C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`F. FCGR 9.0.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`RX-0904
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`RX-0903C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`RX-0906C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`RX-0907C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Rebuttal Expert Report of Carla S. Mulhern (ITC NE; FOE 002, FCGR 9.5.1; all objections
`preserved
`Investigation No. 337-TA-7501
`Exhibit ito 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern - Curriculum Vitae of Carla
`S. Mulhem
`Exhibit 2 to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern - Documents Reviewed
`and/or Relied Upon
`Exhibit 3 to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhera - Descriptions of Patents-in,
`Suit
`Exhibit 4to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhem - Apple, Inc. Income
`Statement_FY 2008-PY 2010
`
`NE, FRE 802
`
`.
`All objections preserved n:bj:ct on: to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`All objections preserved In objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FEE 402/403, F
`
`PC0R 9.5.1, FRE 402/403, F
`
`Objections withdrawn
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FEE 402/403, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`
`
`
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`RX-0905C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Exhibit 5 t 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhem - Motorola Mobility, Inc
`Income Statement 032009-032011
`
`All objections preserved In objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`FCGR 93.1, FRE 402/403, F
`
`RX-900C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`RX-910C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Exhibit 6 to 7/27/2021 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern -Apple Products
`Ombodyine Fatceen-Ir-Suit
`Exhibit 7 to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla 5. Mulhem - Rakewell Estimate of All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`Apple Net Sales of Domestic Industry Products
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`FCGR 8.3.3, FRE 402/403, F
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, PRO 402/405, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`EX-911C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Exhibit 8 to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern - Apple Net Sales of iPhone
`Related Products and Services FY 2003- FY 201
`
`All objections preserved In objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE 402/405, F
`
`lack of domestic Industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-912C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`RX-918C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Exhibit 9 t 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern - Motorola Accused
`Products Net Sales 032009-012012
`
`Exhibit 1000 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern - Motorola Accused
`Products Revenue Units 032009-012011
`
`L
`
`L
`
`POSE 93.1, FRE 402/403, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE 402/403, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`In the Matter of Certain Mobile Devices and Related Software
`ITC Investigation NO, 337-TA-7$0
`Complainant Apple Inc.'s Objections to Respondant Motorola Mobility, Inc.'s Rebuttal Exhibits (including exhibits sponsored solely by Carla Mulhern)
`
`PEOPlE
`
`B
`
`YT5JGIPE
`
`PE%,tt4fS
`
`sit (cid:9)
`
`ecrto
`
`'V*EPO5
`
`f5EOP'5 WE0PEE*a
`
`RX-914C
`
`7/27,2011
`
`N/A
`
`RX-915C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`RX-916C
`
`7/27/2011
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`Exhibit SIte 7/27/2015 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhern (cid:9) Motorola Accused
`Products Average Selling Price 032009-01
`_2311
`Exhibit 12to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`
`of Carla S. Mulhern - !Pad Average Selling Price
`03 FY 2010
`
`Exhibit 13 to 7/27/2011 Rebuttal Expert Report
`of Carla S. Mulhem - iPhone Average Selling
`Price FY 201003- FY 201102
`
`L
`
`P0199.5.1, FRE 402/405, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`.
`Ali objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`rved n objections to i
`
`All objections prese (cid:9)
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE 4021403, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`FCGR 9.5.1, FRE 402/403, F
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`RX'956
`
`9/26/2009
`
`WI-
`WI-
`Apple0533453 Apple0533403
`
`Form 10k
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F. FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-985
`
`5/1/1991
`
`00071N327
`
`0007229416
`
`RX'995
`
`10/6/1991
`
`M
`0007129417
`
`00,07129417
`
`Aaron 000disman, 'A Stylus-Based User
`Interface iorText: Entry and Editing," Thesis
`submitted to the Department of Electrical
`Engineering and
`Computer Science for the degrees of Bachelor
`or Science and Master of Science at
`riu1occrh,nattri_ir,vtlt*_„fTri,4,
`Andrew Pollack "Making a Difference; Apple's
`Man at the Front,” New York Times, October 6,
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal vit~l statements
`
`All objections preserved In objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`
`
`F, FCGR 9.5.12. FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`F. FCGR 9.9,12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`03-996
`
`22/5/1995
`
`RX-1011
`
`116/1994
`
`
`
`OX-:1012 l
`
`2/1/1994
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE- The Automatic Recognition Of Gestures, Thesis
`(Ph.D.). Carnegie Mellon University, Dept. of
`0006037955_il 0006037953_I1
`Comp. 36.
`2448
`2164
`"COMPANY NEWS; I.B.MApple
`
`
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`All objections pi'eservedin objections to
`
`
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
` JarivaiT_6J94.
`
`
`
`David Miller and Kenneth Rose, "Combined
`Source-Channel Vector Quantization Using
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`(cid:9) IEEE Transa ctions on
`0006037953_jO 0006037953_10 Deterministic
`Communications, Vol.42, No.2/3/4
`3753
`3744
`(February/March/April 1994),
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 92.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`OX-1023
`
`5/1/1990
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOlD-APPLE-
` 10
`0006037953 10 00060379$3
`-
`3240
`3235
`
`03-1025
`
`8/10/1998
`
`MOOD-APPLE- MOlD-APPLE-
`0007129575
`0007129576
`
`Determining Polygon Orientation Using Model
`Bated Force Interpretation, Proceedings of the All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`1998 IEEE International Conference on Robotics
`Automation
`
`
`"Apple Receives Orders for Over 150,000 iMacs All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness vtitternents
`in First Week- PR Newswire, August 10, 1998.
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`F, FCGR9.8.12. PRE 402
`
`invalidity/lack of domestic
`i ndustry/bonding
`
`invalidity/lack of domestic
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX-1034
`
`3/21/2001
`
`MOlD-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0007129578
`0007129577
`
`Press Release, Apple, I nc., "Mac 053 Hits Stores
`This Weekend," March 21, 2001, available at
`lsttp://www,applecom/pr/library/2001/05/21 All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`Mitc-OSX-
`Hits-Stores-This-Weekend.html (viewed July 20,
`2011).
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, POE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`03-1057
`
`5/14/2002
`
`MOlD-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0007129595
`0007129094
`
`05-1059
`
`1/1112005
`
`6P9
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., "Apple Introduces
`Xserve SU Rack-Mount Server," May 14, 2002,
`available at
`http;//www.npple.comn/pr/Iibrary/2002/05/
`24Apple.Introdccen-)(serve-1U-Rack-Mocnt-
`Server.html (viewed July 20,2011).
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., "Apple Introduces
`Mac minl,"Januarj 11,2005, available at
`http//www.nppin.eocVpr/Ilbra ry/2005/01/llA
`pple-Introduces-
`Mac-mlni.html (viewed July 20, 2011).
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, PRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`1
`
`1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`In the Matter of Certain Mobile Devices and Related Software
`ITC Investigation No. 337-TA-750
`Complainant Apple Inc.'s Objections to Respondent Motorola Mobility, Inc.'s Rebuttal Exhibits (including exhibits sponsored solely by Carla Mulhern)
`
`85-1992
`
`M.E.
`0007129720
`
`0007229722
`
`RX-1063
`
`5/08/2008
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0007129723
`0007129725
`
`RX-1064
`
`8/7/2006
`
`OTO-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`D007129726
`0007129729
`
`RX'1066
`
`6/28/2007
`
` OTO-APPLE_ MOTO-APPLE-
`M
`000712-977,9
`0007J29730
`
`RX-1067
`
`1/9/2008
`
`MOT0-AFFLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`0007129732
`0007129738
`
`RX.lseS
`
`1/30/2008
`
`0007IZ9739
`
`0007129740
`
`RX-1069
`
`3/28/2009
`
` 070-APPLE- MOTO-APPLE-
`M
`0007129741
`00-07129742
`
`95-1070
`
`7/10/2008
`
`OTO-APPLE- l'
`M
`0007129743
`0007129744
`
`RX-1071
`
`5/1/2009
`
`MOTO-APPLE- MOlD-APPLE-
`0007129745
`0007129747
`
`#X-1072
`
`6/22/2009
`
`MOTO-APPLE. MOTO-APPLE-
`0007129748
`0007120748
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., "Apple Introduces
`MacBook Pro," January 20, 2006, available at
`http//www.apple.corn/pr/library/2006/01/10/ All objection preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness staterrients
`pple,
`Introduces.MacBook-Pro.htrnl (viewed July 13,
`2011).
`Press Releate, Apple. Inc.. "Apple Unveils New
`MacBook Featuring Intel Core Duo Processors,"
`May 26, 2006, available at
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
` rebuttal witness statements
`library/2006/05/1eApple.Ursveilt-New-
`Mac800k-Featuring-lntel-Core-Duo-
`
`F. FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., 'Apple Unveil: New
`
`Mac Pro Peaturing Quad 64-bit Xeon
`Procevnor:.";u xt7.:o6.acailable at
`
`/pr/llbrary/2006/08/07Apple-Unveii:-New-Mac
`Pro-Peatoring-Duad-64-bit-Xeon-
`htITA SA.,,,pd
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., (cid:9) Phone Premieres
`This Friday Night at Apple Retail Stores," June
`28, 2007, available at
`httpl//www.apple.com/pr/ilbrary/
`2007/06/28iPhone-Prem,eres-This-Friday-Night
`at-Apple-Retail-Store:.html (viewed July 20,
`7111
`low the
`Fred Vogeintein. "The l.lntold Story (cid:9)
`iPhone Blew Up the Wireless Industry," WIRED
`Magazine, January 9, 2009, available at
`http://WwW.
`wired.com/gadgets/wirelnsn/magazine/16-
`01/flishnnnlvi.w..,'livlvrg'Mill
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., MacEnokAir Now
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`
`F, POOR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`All objection: preserved in objections to
`
`F. P0159 9.8.12, PRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`FRE 802, FRE 901, FRE 802
`
`F. FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of dureestix industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`http//wapple.corn/pr/library/2008/01/50
`MacBook-Air-
`Now-Shipping.html (viewed July 20.2011).
`vnead Carew."Motorola to Split into Two
`Companies in 3008," Reuters, March 28,2008,
`available at
`http://www.reutern.corn/:rticlef2008/OS/27/un
`motocola-i4USWNAS59O62008O327
`idUSWNAS59Oe200803Z7 (viewed July 18,
`,nl II
`Press Release, Apple, Inc., "iPhone 3G on Sale
`Tomorrow," July 10, 2008, available at
`http://www.apple.cow/pr/librai'y/2008/07/lOi
`Phone-3G.on-Sale-
`Torniqrrow hOod lsipwpd Ju0iD1L_
`M95t Blchtel, Motorola Scrambles to Restore
`Its Lost Cellphone Glory," New York Times, May
`1, 2009, available at
`httpl//wesw.nytirnes.comf2009/
`05/01/technology/companles/Olmoto.htrrd
`
`Press Release, Apple, Inc.. "Apple Sells Over
`One Million iPhone 305 Models,' June22,
`2009, available at
`httpl//www.apple.com/pr/library/2009/O6/
`SlApple-SeIls-Over-One-Million-iPhorie-SOS-
`Models.html (viewed July 20, 2011(.
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness staterrients
`
`F, P0089.8.22, P98 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness stateinents
`
`F, POOR 9.8.12, PRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`All objections preserved in objectionsto
`rebuttal witness staternents,
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic ijiduntry/bending
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`P. P0099.8.12, PRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`All objections preserved in objections to
`rebuttal witness statements
`
`F, POOR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`m the Matter vf Certain Mobile Devices and Related Software
`TC/nvesti gaon No. 337-TA-750
`Complainant Apple .nc/" Objections wxes w~*""` Motorola Mobility, /nc's Rebuttal Exhibits (includin g exhibits sponsored solel y by Carla m"m°=
`
`RX-1073
`
`10/19/2009
`
`:;:
`
`http//teck.fottune.cnn.coni/2009/10/10/thedr
`
`All objections preserved in :bj:ttxtts to
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Mullnern
`
`Phone Competition," Fortune, October 19.
`
`RX-1074
`
`10/28/2009
`
`FdOTOdPPLE'
`
`serious-iphone-competition/ (viewed July 19,
`
`Press Release. Motorola vIobilitp, mc,, "Hello
`Humanrr 00010 by Motorola Arrives Next
`Weelc" Octob (cid:9)
`20,2009, available at
`
`All objectiorispreserv:d,nobjectionsto
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic industry/bonding
`
`Muihern
`
`RX-1075
`
`10/29/2009
`
`MOTO-AFFLE. MOTO-APPLE-
`
`"Motorola Reports Third-Quarter Financial
`a