UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
`WASHINGTON, D.C.
`
`Before the Honorable Theodore R. Essex
`Administrative Law Judge
`
`In the Matter of
`
`CERTAIN MOBILE DEVICES
`AND RELATED SOFTWARE
`
`Investigation No. 337-TA-750
`
`APPLE INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO RESPONDENT MOTOROLA MOBILITY,
`INC.'S DIRECT EXHIBITS:
`
`Pursuant to Order No. 13, attached hereto as Exhibit A are Complainant Apple
`
`Inc.'s ("Apple") objections to the Direct Exhibits of Motorola Mobility, Inc.
`
`("Motorola"). These objections are supplemental to any motions to strike or motions in
`
`limine that Apple may file and are not intended to limit the scope of any such motions.
`
`Apple expressly incorporates herein the objections to the exhibits referenced in Apple's
`
`objections to Motorola's Direct Witness Statements and deposition designations. Apple
`
`also expressly reserves its right to object to these exhibits based on Motorola's Rebuttal
`
`Witness Statements. Further, Apple does not waive any objections to an exhibit because
`
`of its failure to object to the use of the exhibit in a witness statement. The objections
`
`use the following abbreviations:
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`Conclusory opinion
`C
`ECNI
`Errata contains new or inconsistent testimony not offered at deposition
`F
`Exhibit lacks foundation
`L
`Illegible
`Exhibit subject to a motion in limine
`MIL
`Calls for a narrative
`N
`
`(cid:9)
`

`

`NP
`S
`U
`W
`FRE 105
`FRE 106
`FRE 402
`FRE 403
`
`FCGR 4.4.1.2
`
`FCGR 4.4.1.3
`FCGR 5
`FCGR 9.1
`
`FCGR 9.3
`
`FCGR 9.4.1.3
`
`FRE 408
`FRE 602
`FRE 611
`FRE 701
`FRE 702
`FRE 802
`FRE 901
`FRE 1002
`FRE 1006
`FCCR
`210.50(b)(1)
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`NE
`Not substantive evidence 1 Exhibit should be marked for identification
`only
`Not produced in discovery
`
`Counterdesignation outside the scope of the initial designation
`Unable to evaluate the exhibit / Source code exhibit
`Wrong document / Exhibit does not match description
`For limited purpose of X only
`Incomplete document
`Relevance
`Relevance substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice; cumulative
`exhibit
`Privileged settlement communication
`Witness lacks personal knowledge
`Leading question
`Improper opinion testimony by lay witness
`Improper expert opinion testimony
`Hearsay
`Authenticity
`
`Best evidence
`Improper summary
`Failure to comply with Commission Rule 210.50(b)(1) ("an
`administrative law judge shall not address the issue of the public
`interest")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 4.4.1.2 (Outside scope of witness's
`30(b)(6) designation)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 4.4.1.3 (Deposition not admissible)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 5 (Not on Notice of Prior Art)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.1 (Legal argument must be presented in
`the briefs)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.3 (Legal experts may only testify as to
`procedures of the U.S.Patent and Trademark Office)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.4.1.3 ("A witness statement shall
`contain separately numbered questions which are asked by counsel,
`with each question followed by the witness' own answer to that
`question. ")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.5.1 (Expert reports are not evidence)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.7 (No translation provided for exhibit
`that will be offered to be received into evidence for substantive
`purposes; uncertified translation provided for exhibit that will be
`offered to be received into evidence for substantive purposes)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.1 (Untimely disclosure of exhibit;
`duplicate of joint exhibit)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.5.3 (Pages not sequentially numbered
`
`FCGR 9.5.1
`FCGR 9.7
`
`FCGR 9.8.1
`
`FCGR 9.8.5.3
`
`

`

`FCGR 9.8.7
`
`Abbreviation Objection
`in consistent location)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.7 ("Every exhibit list shall consist of a
`table enumerating all exhibits serially by exhibit number and
`identifying each exhibit by a descriptive title, a brief statement of the
`purpose for which the exhibit is being offered into evidence, the name
`of the sponsoring witness, and the status of receipt of the exhibit into
`evidence.")
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.8 (Multiple documents within one
`exhibit)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 9.8.12 (Improper sponsoring witness)
`Failure to comply with G.R. 10.5.6 (Expert testimony outside the
`scope of the expert report andlor expert deposition testimony)
`
`FCGR 9.8.8
`
`FCGR 9.8.12
`FCGR 10.5.6
`
`Dated: September 2, 2011 (cid:9)
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By: (cid:9)
`
`Lim
`Mark G. D1s
`Brian E. Ferguson
`Robert T. Vlasis
`Edward S. Jou
`Christopher T. Marando
`Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
`1300 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 900
`Washington, D.C. 20005
`Tel: (202) 682-7000
`Fax: (202) 857-0940
`
`Anne M. Cappella
`Jill J. Ho
`Jacqueline T. Harlow
`Erin C. Jones
`Brian C. Chang
`Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
`201 Redwood Shores Parkway
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`Tel: (650) 802-3000
`
`Matthew D. Powers
`Steven S. Cherensky
`Paul T. Ehrlich
`Robert L. Gerrity
`
`

`

`Tensegrity Law Group LLP
`201 Redwood Shores Parkway, Suite
`401
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`Tel: (650) 802-6000
`
`Attorneys for Complainant
`APPLE INC.
`
`

`

`Exhibit A
`Exhibit A
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RDX‐1
`
`RDX‐2
`
`RDX‐3
`
`RDX‐4
`
`RDX‐5
`
`RDX‐6
`
`RDX‐7
`
`RDX‐8
`
`RDX‐9
`
`Demonstratives for use in technology tutorial
`
`Demonstratives for use in claim construction 
`arguments
`
`Demonstratives for use in opening statements
`
`Demonstratives for use in direct testimony, 
`including expert witnesses
`
`Demonstratives for use in rebuttal testimony, 
`including expert witnesses
`
`Demonstratives for use in closing arguments
`
`U
`
`U
`
`U
`
`U
`
`U
`
`U
`
`U
`
`Locke RDX‐1 through Locke RDX‐17 – 
`demonstratives to be used with the testimony of 
`C. Douglass Locke as set forth in the witness 
`statement of August 22, 2011
`
`All objections preserved in 
`objections to Witness 
`Statement
`
`Wolfe RDX‐1 through Wolfe RDX‐46 – 
`demonstratives to be used with the testimony of 
`Andrew Wolfe as set forth in the witness 
`statement of August 22, 2011
`
`All objections preserved in 
`objections to Witness 
`Statement
`
`1
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RDX‐10
`
`RPX‐1
`
`RPX‐2
`
`RPX‐3
`
`RPX‐4
`
`RPX‐5
`
`RPX‐6
`
`RPX‐7
`
`RPX‐8
`
`Foodman RDX‐1 through Foodman RDX‐4 ‐‐ 
`demonstratives to be used with the testimony of 
`Marc Foodman as set forth in the witness 
`statement of August 22, 2011
`
`All objections preserved in 
`objections to Witness 
`Statement
`
`Prior Art made available by Atmel ‐‐ QT60645 
`sensor and E664 evaluation board
`
`U, FCGR 10.5.6, MIL
`
`Invalidity
`
`Brunet/Wolfe
`
`Prior Art made available by Atmel ‐‐ QT60320 
`sensor and E6S evaluation board
`
`U, FCGR 10.5.6, MIL
`
`Invalidity
`
`Brunet/Wolfe
`
`Prior Art made available by Atmel ‐‐ sensor and 
`E616 board
`
`U, FCGR 10.5.6, MIL
`
`Invalidity
`
`Brunet/Wolfe
`
`AT&T EO™ Personal Communicator 440, 
`currently in use as Exhibit RPX‐002 in Certain 
`Mobile Devices, Associated Software, and 
`Components Thereof, Inv. No. 337‐TA‐744, 
`before the International Trade Commission
`
`AT&T EO™ Personal Communicator 880 Serial 
`No. 80‐101073
`
`U, F
`
`U, F
`
`Invalidity
`
`Isaac/Weimer/Vierra/Lo
`cke
`
`Invalidity
`
`Isaac/Weimer/Vierra/Lo
`cke
`
`New version of Droid X 
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`New version of Xoom with WiFi 
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Atrix
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe/Olley/Cranfill/Th
`orenston/Bengtson
`
`Wolfe/Olley/Cranfill/Th
`orenston/Bengtson
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`2
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RPX‐9
`
`RPX‐10
`
`RPX‐11
`
`RPX‐12
`
`RPX‐13
`
`RPX‐14
`
`RPX‐15
`
`RPX‐16
`
`RPX‐17
`
`Backflip
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Bravo
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Charm
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Citrus
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Cliq
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Cliq XT
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Defy
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Devour
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`3
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RPX‐18
`
`RPX‐19
`
`RPX‐20
`
`RPX‐21
`
`RPX‐22
`
`RPX‐23
`
`RPX‐24
`
`RPX‐25
`
`RPX‐26
`
`Droid 2
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid 2 Global
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid Pro
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid X
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid X2
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Droid 3
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Flipout
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Flipside
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`i1
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`4
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RPX‐27
`
`RPX‐28
`
`RPX‐29
`
`Titanium
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`XPRT
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Xoom
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`Wolfe/Locke/Wyatt/Dai
`ley/Olley/Moore/Steiml
`e/Boldt/Cranfill/Thorste
`nson/Bengston
`
`RPX‐30
`
`00/00/1992
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_156969 
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_156969
`
`Steve Jobs Demos NeXT
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Invalidity
`
`Locke
`
`RPX‐31
`
`N/A
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129265
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129265
`
`DVD entitled "Smartskin Videos"
`
`F, U, untimely designation 
`of exhibit, FRE 602, FRE 
`402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Invalidity
`
`Strickon/Hotelling/Hupp
`i/Wolfe
`
`RPX‐32
`
`N/A
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129274
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129274
`
`“How to make pop corn using your Iphone,” 
`available at 
`<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEQP1hrfF
`ak>
`
`FRE 402, FRE 802, FRE 901, 
`F, FCGR 9.8.1.2
`
`lack of domestic industry
`
`Wolfe
`
`RPX‐33
`
`N/A
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129278
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007129278
`
`“Multi‐Touch On The Motorola Cliq,” available at 
`<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kWpx2zFy
`bs>
`
`FRE 402, FRE 802, FRE 901, 
`F, FCGR 9.8.1.2
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe
`
`RPX‐34
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`N/A
`
`http://developer.android.com/videos/index.html
`#v=Oq05KqjXTvs
`
`F, U, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`Non‐infringement
`
`Locke/Kraus/Boldt
`
`RX‐1
`
`10/18/2001
`
` MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_112847 
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_112862 
`
`U.S. Patent Publication No. 2001/0030637 A1
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`5
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐2C
`
`5/3/2004
`
`745‐Apple 10443067
`
`745‐Apple 10443068
`
`email string from Aaron Leiba to Chris Krah RE: 
`Q79 ‐ Multi‐touch Schematics
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 602, 
`FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Krah; Wolfe
`
`RX‐3C
`
`06/00/2005
`
`745‐Apple0000056
`
`745‐Apple0000068
`
`Powerpoint titled "Wi‐Fi Update for Apple iPod 
`Team"
`
`FCGR 9.8.12, FCGR 9.8.7, F
`
`RX‐4C
`
`12/9/2010
`
`745‐Apple0016512
`
`745‐Apple0016560
`
`Investigation 337‐TA‐710, Transcript of 
`Deposition of Boris Teksler
`
`FRE 802, NE, F, FCGR 
`9.8.12, FRE 402, MIL, FCGR 
`9.1, FCGR 9.3
`
`non‐infringement/standing
`
`Teksler/Foodman
`
`RX‐5C
`
`5/7/2010
`
`745‐Apple0019077
`
`745‐Apple0019151
`
`Inv. 337‐TA‐710 Deposition Transcript of Andrew 
`Allen
`
`FRE 802
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐6C
`
`11/2/2010
`
`745‐Apple0019257
`
`745‐Apple0019379
`
`Inv. 337‐TA‐710 Deposition Transcript of Andrew 
`Allen
`
`FRE 802
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐7C
`
`11/30/2010
`
`745‐Apple0019584
`
`745‐Apple0019654
`
`Inv. 337‐TA‐710 Deposition Transcript of Andrew 
`Allen 
`
`FRE 802, F, FCGR 9.8.12, 
`FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐8
`
`1/23/1998
`
`750‐Apple0357909 
`
`750‐Apple0357947
`
`Provisional Application No. 60/072,509
`
`MIL
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe; Elius; 
`Westerman
`
`RX‐9C
`
`8/3/2005
`
`745‐Apple09761763
`
`745‐Apple09761786
`
`Zephyr Algorithms Overview: Apple Input 
`Engineering & HID Software
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/non‐infringement
`
`Mullens/Wolfe
`
`RX‐10C
`
`7/14/2005
`
`745‐Apple09761787
`
`745‐Apple09761833
`
`Multitouch Protocols: Images, Contacts, Paths & 
`Hand Motion
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/non‐infringement
`
`Mullens/Wolfe
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`6
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐11C
`
`8/25/2006
`
`745‐Apple09761932
`
`745‐Apple09761945
`
`Grape Multitouch Binary Protocol, How Grape 
`reports Multitouch Images and Paths over SPI 
`and USB,
`
`FCGR 9.8.12, F, FRE 402, 
`FRE 602, FCGR 4.4.1.2
`
`Invalidity
`
`Mullens/Wolfe
`
`RX‐12C
`
`7/29/2008
`
`745‐Apple09891058
`
`745‐Apple09891067
`
`email string, the topmost dated July 29, 2008, 
`from John Elias to Chris Mullens et al. RE: SITD 
`Optimized Centroid Looking Better
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Mullens; Elias; Wolfe
`
`RX‐13C
`
`11/9/2007
`
`745‐Apple10437434
`
`745‐Apple10437465
`
`Multi‐Touch USPTO Technology Training dated 
`November 9, 2007
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/non‐infringement
`
`Westerman; Wolfe
`
`RX‐14C
`
`3/7/2004
`
`745‐Apple10454440
`
`745‐Apple10454441
`
`RX‐15C
`
`5/25/2004
`
`745‐Apple10454551
`
`745‐Apple10454552
`
`RX‐16C
`
`7/19/2004
`
`745‐Apple10454703
`
`745‐Apple10454704
`
`email dated March 7, 2004, from Chris Krah to 
`Steven Hotelling et al. RE: Great Idea for a Stylus 
`with minimum impact on Zephyr ASIC!
`
`email string topmost dated May 25, 2004, from 
`Chris Krah to Steven Hotelling et al. RE: ESD for 
`Q79 Zephyr
`
`email dated July 19. 2004, from Sheri Stevens to 
`Q79 Input Panel Fujitgu Members et al. RE: 
`Group addresses for Q79 program
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Krah; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Krah; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Krah; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`RX‐17C
`
`7/21/2004
`
`745‐Apple10454718
`
`745‐Apple10454720
`
`email dated July 21, 2004, from Chris Krah to 
`Steve Sfarzo et al. RE: Here's a Q79 vision
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Krah; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`RX‐18C
`
`10/15/2004
`
`745‐Apple10455686
`
`745‐Apple10455686
`
`email dated October 15, 2004, from Joshua 
`Strickon to Chris Krah et al. RE: Real (No 
`Suggestions) Touchscreen Product
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Krah; Hotelling; 
`Strickon; Huppi; Wolfe
`
`RX‐19C
`
`3/4/2004
`
`745‐Apple10457155
`
`745‐Apple10457155
`
`email dated March 4, 2004, from Chris Krah to 
`Steven Hotelling and Wing Kong Low RE: 
`Proposal‐ MultiTouch Panel Test Fixture
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Krah; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`7
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐20C
`
`8/18/2003
`
`745‐Apple10457876
`
`745‐Apple10457877
`
`email from Steve Hotelling to Brian Huppi RE: 
`New Display Investigations
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe; Hotelling; Huppi
`
`RX‐21C
`
`9/3/2003
`
`745‐Apple10457883
`
`745‐Apple10457884
`
`RX‐22C
`
`9/17/2003
`
`745‐Apple10457889
`
`745‐Apple10457890
`
`email string, the topmost dated October 
`September 3, 2003, from Steven Hotelling to 
`Andy Hodge et al. RE: Touch Pads for iPods
`
`email string, the topmost dated September 17, 
`2003, from Steve Hotelling to Chen Wei and 
`Brian Huppi FWD: phone conversation
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Huppi; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement Huppi; Hotelling; Wolfe
`
`RX‐23C
`
`00/00/2001
`
`745‐Apple10458678
`
`745‐Apple10458685
`
`SmartSkin: An Infrastructure for Freehand 
`Manipulation on Interactive Surfaces by Jun 
`Rekimoto
`
`MIL, FCGR 10.5.6
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Hotelling; Wolfe; Ellett; 
`Strickon; Huppi
`
`RX‐24C
`
`11/9/2007
`
`745‐Apple11245977
`
`745‐Apple11246008
`
`Multi‐Touch USPTO Presentation by Steve 
`Hotelling and Wayne Westerman
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Wolfe; Hotelling; 
`Westerman
`
`RX‐25C
`
`2009
`
`745‐Apple4676223
`
`745‐Apple4676375
`
`N88 3rd Quarter of 2009
`
`L
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐26C
`
`10/2003
`
`745‐Apple4827719
`
`745‐Apple4827735
`
`Touch Screen Technologies White Paper. Author: 
`Brian Huppi
`
`FCGR 9.8.1, F, FCGR 9.8.12, 
`FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Huppi; Wolfe; Strickon; 
`Hotelling
`
`RX‐27C
`
`11/1/2005
`
`745‐Apple4844382
`
`745‐Apple4844417
`
`Presentation Entitled Input Planning
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Krah; Wolfe
`
`RX‐28C
`
`6/4/2009
`
`745‐Apple4854482
`
`745‐Apple4854516
`
`N88 Grape Chipset and Function Engineering 
`Requirements Specification Apple Touch 
`Hardware
`
`F, FRE 402, FCGR 9.8.12
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Wolfe; Mullens
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`8
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐29C
`
`6/13/2008
`
`745‐Apple5990241
`
`745‐Apple5990241
`
`email string from Chris Mullens to Adam Gulkis 
`et al. RE: N82 Grape Ox 0049 firmware drop for 
`QA
`
`FCGR 4.4.1.3, FRE 602, F, 
`FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402 
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding; invalidity
`
`Grunthaner; Wolfe; 
`Mullens
`
`RX‐30C
`
`10/2009
`
`745‐Apple6409535
`
`745‐Apple6409563
`
`AppleCare Support Impact Analysis
`
`FRE 802, F, FCGR 9.8.12, 
`FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐31C
`
`6/26/2010
`
`745‐Apple6776425
`
`745‐Apple6776448
`
`iPhone 4 Field Data Summary
`
`FRE 802, F, FCGR 9.8.12, 
`FRE 402
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`RX‐32C
`
`10/28/2008
`
`745‐Apple6891312
`
`745‐Apple6891318
`
`RX‐33C
`
`6/17/2008
`
`745‐Apple6905885
`
`745‐Apple6905892
`
`email string topmost dated October 28, 2008, 
`from John Elias to Chris Mullens et al. RE: Need 
`FW updated code for Eval tool
`
`email string topmost dated June 17, 2008, from 
`Martin Grunthaner to John Elias et al. RE: 
`Centroid demo on bare SITO panel ‐ preliminary 
`results Part II
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Grunthaner; Elias; 
`Mullens; Westerman; 
`Wolfe
`
`Grunthaner; Elias; 
`Westerman; Hotelling; 
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐34C
`
`1/14/2010
`
`745‐Apple6908667
`
`745‐Apple6908668
`
`email string, the topmost dated January 19, 2010 
`from Wayne Westerman to Joshua Schafer et al. 
`RE: Exposing Path Shape/Pressure
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Mullens; Westerman; 
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐35C
`
`8/28/2008
`
`745‐Apple6914840
`
`745‐Apple6914842
`
`email string topmost dated August 28, 2008, 
`from A. Gulkis to Wayne Westerman et al. RE: 
`New Program to Boost iPhone Keyboard Quality
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Grunthaner; 
`Westerman; Wolfe
`
`RX‐36C
`
`5/23/2007
`
`745‐Apple6996871
`
`745‐Apple6996871
`
`email dated May 23, 2007, from Wayne 
`Westerman to mt‐checkins@apple.group.com. 
`RE: MultiTouch: Alternate "Squashed Ellipse" 
`measurement for M82
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity; non‐infringement
`
`Mullens; Westerman; 
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐37C
`
`2010
`
`745‐Apple7244512
`
`745‐Apple7244523
`
`N90 FQ2'10 Quarterly Cost and Risk Charts
`
`L
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`9
`
`

`

`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`RX‐38C
`
`2010
`
`745‐Apple7244665
`
`745‐Apple7244711
`
`N90 FQ2'10 Quarterly Cost and Risk Charts with 
`Gross Margins
`
`RX‐39C
`
`11/24/2008
`
`745‐Apple7277106
`
`745‐Apple7277121
`
`N82 2009 First Quarter Gross Margin Summary
`
`RX‐40C
`
`1/8/2008
`
`745‐Apple7480130
`
`745‐Apple7480155
`
`Executive Summary: Q1 '08 Units View
`
`RX‐41C
`
`N/A
`
`745‐Apple7483563
`
`745‐Apple7483563
`
`Annual Volume Commitment/ Annual Marketing 
`Commitment
`
`RX‐42C
`
`2009
`
`745‐Apple8061425
`
`745‐Apple8061546
`
`N82 iPhone Cost Model Summary for Q2 '09
`
`RX‐43C
`
`3/11/2009
`
`745‐Apple8062008
`
`745‐Apple8062030
`
`Life Cycle Product Matrix‐ Hardware
`
`RX‐44C
`
`4/7/2009
`
`745‐Apple8062396
`
`745‐Apple8062418
`
`Life Cycle Product Matrix‐ Hardware
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`L
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`lack of domestic 
`industry/bonding
`
`Mulhern
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`yes
`
`RX‐45C
`
`N/A
`
`750‐Apple Code 194
`
`750‐Apple Code 196
`
`Apple Source code
`
`RX‐46C
`
`N/A
`
`750‐Apple Code 210
`
`750‐Apple Code 230
`
`Apple Source code
`
`U, FRE 403 (cumulative of 
`JX Apple source code 
`exhibit)
`
`U, FRE 403 (cumulative of 
`JX Apple source code 
`exhibit)
`
`Invalidity
`
`Garst; Locke
`
`yes
`
`Yes
`
`Invalidity
`
`Garst; Locke
`
`Yes
`
`Yes
`
`10
`
`

`

`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`RX‐47C
`
`N/A
`
`750‐Apple Code 235
`
`750‐Apple Code 238
`
`Apple Source code
`
`RX‐48C
`
`N/A
`
`750‐Apple Code 243
`
`750‐Apple Code 248
`
`Apple Source code
`
`RX‐49C
`
`N/A
`
`750‐Apple Code 263
`
`750‐Apple Code 269
`
`Apple Source code
`
`U, FRE 403 (cumulative of 
`JX Apple source code 
`exhibit), 
`
`U, FRE 403 (cumulative of 
`JX Apple source code 
`exhibit), FCGR 
`
`U, FRE 403 (cumulative of 
`JX Apple source code 
`exhibit), 
`
`Invalidity
`
`Garst; Locke
`
`Yes
`
`Yes
`
`Invalidity
`
`Garst; Locke
`
`Yes
`
`Yes
`
`Invalidity
`
`Garst; Locke
`
`Yes
`
`Yes
`
`RX‐50
`
`5/4/2009
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007086539
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007086706
`
`Certified copy of U.S. Patent Application No. 
`09/236,513
`
`FCGR 9.8.12, F, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐51C
`
`8/5/1997
`
`Apple000292
`
`Apple000313
`
`Patent Cross‐License Agreement Between Apple 
`and Microsoft dated August 5, 1997
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402, 
`MIL, FCGR 9.1, FCGR 9.3
`
`non‐infringement/lack of 
`standing
`
`Foodman/Teksler/Lutto
`n
`
`RX‐52
`
`12/24/2009
`
`750‐Apple0002923
`
`750‐Apple0002946
`
`USPTO Office Action RE U.S Patent Application 
`11/677,958
`
`FCGR 9.8.12, F, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/non‐infringement Wolfe/Westerman/Elias
`
`RX‐53
`
`2/24/2010
`
`750‐Apple0002977
`
`750‐Apple0002992
`
`U.S. Patent Application No. 11/677,958 
`Amendments to the Claims
`
`F, FRE 602, FCGR 9.8.12, 
`FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/non‐infringement Westerman/Elias/Wolfe
`
`RX‐54
`
`2/24/2010
`
`750‐Apple0002989
`
`750‐Apple0002992
`
`Applicant's Remarks RE claims 1‐35 of U.S. 
`Patent Application 11/677,958
`
`FCGR 9.8.12, F, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/non‐infringement Wolfe/Elias/Westerman
`
`RX‐55
`
`1/30/1996
`
`750‐Apple0004486
`
`750‐Apple0004486
`
`Certificate of Correction to U.S. Patent No. 
`5,488,204
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`11
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐56
`
`6/24/1997
`
`750‐Apple0010609
`
`750‐Apple0010609
`
`Certificate of Correction for Patent U.S. Patent 
`No. 5,642,108
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐57
`
`12/3/1996
`
`750‐Apple0010892
`
`750‐Apple0010917
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,581,681
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐58
`
`8/6/1996
`
`750‐Apple0011863
`
`750‐Apple0011863
`
`Certificate of Correction for U.S. Patent No. 
`5,543,591
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐59
`
`5/5/1998
`
`750‐Apple0011864
`
`750‐Apple0011885
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,746,818
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐60
`
`8/6/1996
`
`750‐Apple0012028
`
`750‐Apple0012029
`
`Certificate of Correction for U.S. Patent No. 
`5,543,590
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐61
`
`5/6/2004
`
`750‐Apple0012339
`
`750‐Apple0012338
`
`Patent application for Multipoint Touchscreen
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Non‐
`infringement/invalidity/une
`nforceability
`
`Kubota/Wolfe/Hotelling
`/Huppi/Strickon
`
`RX‐62
`
`1/3/2006
`
`750‐Apple0012471
`
`750‐Apple0012474
`
`Power of Attorney for the '607 patent
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/unenforceability
`
`Lutton; Wolfe
`
`RX‐63
`
`10/26/2007
`
`750‐Apple0013414
`
`750‐Apple0013418
`
`U.S. Patent Application No. 10/840,862 Power of 
`Attorney and Statement under 37 CFR 3.37(b)
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/unenforceability
`
`Kubota/Lutton; Wolfe
`
`RX‐64
`
`2/20/2009
`
`750‐Apple0013647
`
`750‐Apple0013664
`
`U.S. Patent Application No. 10/840,862 Remarks 
`& Amendments to the Claims
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity/unenforceability/i
`nvalidity
`
`Kubota/Lutton; Wolfe
`
`12
`
`

`

`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`RX‐65
`
`1/10/2006
`
`750‐Apple0014409
`
`750‐Apple0014427
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,985,801 B1
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐66
`
`5/29/2001
`
`750‐Apple0014725
`
`750‐Apple0014742
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,239,790 B1
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐67
`
`12/6/2005
`
`750‐Apple0014820
`
`750‐Apple0014834
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,972,401 B2
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐68
`
`4/1/1999
`
`750‐Apple0015187
`
`750‐Apple0015549
`
`Hand Tracking, Finger Identification and Chordic 
`Manipulation on a Multi‐Touch Surface by 
`Wayne Westerman
`
`MIL, FCGR 10.5.6
`
`Invalidity
`
`Westerman; Wolfe; 
`Ellett
`
`RX‐69
`
`11/7/2008
`
`750‐Apple0015746
`
`750‐Apple0015807
`
`Patent Application for patent titled "Multipoint 
`Touchscreen"
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity, Non‐
`infringement, 
`Unenforceability
`
`Kubota; Hotelling; 
`Strickon; Huppi; Wolfe
`
`RX‐70
`
`11/26/1996
`
`750‐Apple0016378
`
`750‐Apple0016387
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,579,036
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐71
`
`7/14/1993
`
`750‐Apple0016401
`
`750‐Apple0016412
`
`European Patent Spec. 0 288 692 B1
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐72
`
`9/5/1996
`
`750‐Apple0016413
`
`750‐Apple0016427
`
`European Patent Spec. 0 464 908 B1
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐73
`
`3/22/1988 MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085582
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085615
`
`Certified copy of U.S. Patent No. 4,733,222
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`13
`
`

`

`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`RX‐74
`
`4/24/2003
`
`750‐Apple0018027
`
`750‐Apple0018043
`
`U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 
`2003/0076306
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐75
`
`1/8/1992
`
`750‐Apple0018044
`
`750‐Apple0018045
`
`European Patent Applciation No. 0 464 908 A3
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐76
`
`3/4/1988
`
`750‐Apple0018469
`
`750‐Apple0018470
`
`European Patent Application No. 0 288 692 A3
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐77
`
`1/13/2004 MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085150
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085167
`
`Certified copy of U.S. Patent No. 6,677,932
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐78
`
`2/16/2006
`
`750‐Apple0019421
`
`750‐Apple0019426
`
`U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 
`2006/0032680
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐79
`
`11/15/2005
`
`750‐Apple0019947
`
`750‐Apple0019961
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,965,375
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐80
`
`4/24/2003
`
`750‐Apple0019962
`
`750‐Apple0019989
`
`U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 
`2003/0076301
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐81
`
`4/9/1998
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_121516
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐
`0006037953_121527
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,188,391
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐82
`
`11/18/2003
`
`750‐Apple0020176
`
`750‐Apple0020209
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,650,319
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`14
`
`

`

`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`RX‐83
`
`1/11/2005
`
`750‐Apple0020355
`
`750‐Apple0020372
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,842,672
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐84
`
`12/20/2005
`
`750‐Apple0020408
`
`750‐Apple0020418
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,977,666
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐85
`
`9/6/1994
`
`750‐Apple0020419
`
`750‐Apple0020439
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,345,543
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐86
`
`1/7/1997
`
`750‐Apple0020488
`
`750‐Apple0020531
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,592,566
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐87
`
`9/23/2003
`
`750‐Apple0020532
`
`750‐Apple0020544
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,624,833
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐88
`
`12/3/1996
`
`750‐Apple0020559
`
`750‐Apple0020584
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,581,681
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐89
`
`2/15/2005 MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085168
`
`MOTO‐APPLE‐0007085181
`
`Certified copy of U.S. Patent No. 6,856,259
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐90
`
`2/1/2000
`
`750‐Apple0020620
`
`750‐Apple0020663
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,020,881
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐91
`
`9/2/2003
`
`750‐Apple0021006
`
`750‐Apple0021067
`
`U.S. Patent Application No. 10/654,108
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Hotelling; Huppi; Wolfe
`
`15
`
`

`

`Apple V. Motorola
`337‐TA‐750
`Apple's Objections to Motorola's Direct Exhibits
`
`FINAL RX NO.
`
`Date
`
`BATES_BEGIN
`
`BATES_END
`
`DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION
`
`Objections
`
`PURPOSE
`
`SPONSORING 
`WITNESS(es)
`
`Status
`
`CBI
`
`SOURCE 
`CODE
`
`RX‐92
`
`11/29/1988
`
`750‐Apple0021068
`
`750‐Apple0021079
`
`U.S. Patent No. 4,788,384
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐93
`
`1/31/2006
`
`750‐Apple0021081
`
`750‐Apple0021090
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,992,659
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐94
`
`1/31/2003
`
`750‐Apple0021097
`
`750‐Apple0021112
`
`Japanese Patent No. 2003‐29899 (P2003‐
`29899A)
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐95
`
`1/9/2002
`
`750‐Apple0021263
`
`750‐Apple0021265
`
`European Patent Application No. EP 1014295 A3
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐96
`
`5/3/2005
`
`750‐Apple0021495
`
`750‐Apple0021572
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,888,536
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐97
`
`5/5/1998
`
`750‐Apple0021723
`
`750‐Apple0021744
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,746,818
`
`F, FCGR 9.8.12, FRE 402
`
`Invalidity
`
`Wolfe
`
`RX‐98
`
`4/3/1996
`
`750‐Apple0022900
`
`750‐Apple0022899
`
`RX‐99
`
`12/10/2009
`
`750‐Apple0022912
`
`750‐Apple0022941
`
`RX‐100C
`
`3/7/1996
`
`750‐A