Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 1 of 11 PageID #: 18155
`
`Exhibit 8
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 2 of 11 PageID #: 18156
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`DTX
`No.
`48
`49
`
`50
`51
`
`52
`53
`54
`
`56
`
`57
`
`58
`
`62
`77
`
`83
`84
`
`Description
`
`Email from Rick MacPherson to John Pavlish re Chem mod
`Email from John Pavlish to Carsten Heide Re: Mercury Control
`Approach - 15Sep11.xlsx
`Mercury Control Approaches - 15Sep11.xlsx
`Email from John Pavlish to Alan Kelley, cc'ing Marc Sylvester re
`Competitor List
`Hg_Commercial_Installations_Jan2010_publicR1.xls
`Competitor Review.xlsx
`Email from John Pavlish to Marc Sylvester re Re: GRDA (SEA and
`Chem Mods)
`Email from Marc Sylvester to Alan Kelley, John Pavlish, Keith
`McGee, Rick MacPherson, Jim Trettel re Re: Dynegy Visit
`Email from Keith McGee to Marc Sylvester and Alan Kelley, cc'ing John
`Pavlish re Re: ME2C IP
`Email from Pat Mongoven to Will O'Neal and John Pavlish RE Draft
`Notes fm NRG
`Meeting Minutes
`Letter from Marcus Sylvester to Mark Curtis re ME2C Mercury
`Capture Program Pricing
`Email from John Pavlish to Marc Sylvester re Draft Report for Joppa
`ME2C Mercury Control Performance Test Results at Joppa Unit 5 & 6
`
`88
`102
`
`103
`104
`
`105
`
`106
`
`112
`122
`
`Email from Marc Sylvester to John Pavlish re Re: ME2C Advantages
`Email from Lucinda Hamre to John Pavlish re Recent IRS Ruling -
`Determination of Eligibility Under IRS Section 45 - "Refined Coal"
`IRS PLR-141020-11 re Refined Coal
`Email from John Pavlish to Marc Sylvester re Re: ADA - Clean Coal
`Solutions
`Email from Keith McGee to Marc Sylvester, Allan Kelley, and John
`Pavlish, cc'ing Jim Trettel re Re: Section 45 Tax Credit
`Email from John Pavlish to Marc Sylvester, cc'ing Alan Kelley, Keith
`McGee, and Jim Trettel re Re: Section 45 Tax Credit
`Email from John Pavlish to Keith McGee re Re: T45
`Email from Keith McGee to Rick MacPherson and Allan Kelley, cc'ing
`John Pavlish re T45 strategy
`Email from Alan Kelley to Marc Sylvester and Keith McGee, cc'ing John
`Pavlish re ME2C IP
`Email from Nick Lentz to John Pavlish re M sorb SDS
`Email from Nick Lentz to John Pavlish re T45 information
`Email from Marc Sylvester to Alan Kelley, Rick MacPherson, and John
`Pavlish, cc'ing Marc Sylvester re North Dakota Prospect Update
`Email from John Pavlish to Marc Sylvester re RE: DTE
`Q2 Management Meeting: August 24-25, 2017 | Hyatt Regency
`Pittsburgh, PA,” ME2C, August 24-25, 2017
`Senior's Expert Report, Exhibit C-6
`February 4, 2021 Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled
`“Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for NOx and Hg Reductions –
`November 25, 2020” (Bates number CERT_0003545)
`1489 August 14, 2020 Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled “Evaluation
`of Powerton Station Coal for NOx and Hg Reductions – June 1, 2020”
`(Bates number CERT_0003601))
`1490 August 11, 2015 Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled “Evaluation
`of Labadie Coal for NOx and Hg Reductions – May 26, 2015” (Bates
`number CERT_0005738)
`February 9, 2021 Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled
`“Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for NOx and Hg Reductions
`– December 3, 2020” (Bates number CERT_0010003)
`
`123
`
`158
`160
`180
`
`181
`297
`
`440
`1488
`
`1491
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`ME2C-RC-00126176
`ME2C-RC-00148291
`
`ME2C-RC-00148292
`ME2C-RC-00153533
`
`ME2C-RC-00153534
`ME2C-RC-00153535
`ME2C-RC-00156091
`
`ME2C-RC-00181280
`
`ME2C-RC-00181995
`
`ME2C-RC-00192547
`
`ME2C-RC-00211122
`ME2C-RC-00212573
`
`ME2C-RC-00212578
`ME2C-RC-00212595
`
`ME2C-RC-00185200
`ME2C-RC-00152755
`
`ME2C-RC-00152766
`ME2C-RC-00154710
`
`ME2C-RC-00165185
`
`ME2C-RC-00165189
`
`ME2C-RC-00168468
`ME2C-RC-00168952
`
`ME2C-RC-00181991
`
`ME2C-RC-00209975
`ME2C-RC-00210045
`ME2C-RC-00162350
`
`ME2C-RC-00184093
`ME2C-RC-00206975
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`Y
`
`Y
`
`Y
`
`Y
`
`Y
`
`Y
`
`Date
`
`5/28/2009
`9/15/2011
`
`9/15/2011
`4/26/2012
`
`4/26/2012
`4/26/2012
`7/19/2012
`
`12/4/2014
`
`2/6/2015
`
`6/24/2016
`
`3/1/2018
`10/11/2012
`
`10/21/2014
`Sept. 2012
`
`8/26/2015
`3/28/2012
`
`3/9/2012
`5/22/2012
`
`7/31/2013
`
`8/1/2013
`
`9/18/2013
`9/19/2013
`
`2/6/2015
`
`1/24/2018
`1/24/2018
`4/4/2013
`
`5/19/2015
`8/24/2017
`
`2/4/2021
`
`8/14/2020
`
`8/11/2015
`
`2/9/2021
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`ME2C-RC-00126176
`ME2C-RC-00148291
`
`ME2C-RC-00148292
`ME2C-RC-00153533
`
`ME2C-RC-00153534
`ME2C-RC-00153535
`ME2C-RC-00156091
`
`ME2C-RC-00181279
`
`ME2C-RC-00181992
`
`ME2C-RC-00192547
`
`ME2C-RC-00211119
`ME2C-RC-00212571
`
`ME2C-RC-00212578
`ME2C-RC-00212579
`
`ME2C-RC-00185198
`ME2C-RC-00152755
`
`ME2C-RC_00152756
`ME2C-RC-00154710
`
`ME2C-RC-00165184
`
`ME2C-RC-00165188
`
`ME2C-RC-00168467
`ME2C-RC-00168951
`
`ME2C-RC-00181989
`
`ME2C-RC-00209975
`ME2C-RC-00210045
`ME2C-RC-00162348
`
`ME2C-RC-00184091
`ME2C-RC-00206969
`
`CERT_0003545
`
`CERT_0003601
`
`CERT_0005738
`
`CERT_0010003
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`1
`
`APP. 258
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 3 of 11 PageID #: 18157
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`1493
`
`1673
`
`1674
`
`1675
`
`1676
`
`DTX
`No.
`1492 October 27, 2014 Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled
`“Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station for NOx and Hg Reductions –
`August 12, 2014” (Bates number CERT_0040881)
`Final Report prepared by the EERC entitled “Evaluation of Labadie Coal
`for NOx and Hg Reductions – May 26, 2015” (Bates number
`CERT_0003937)
`John Pavlish - August 25 and 26, 2022 Depositions - Exhibit 18
`1502e
`John Pavlish - August 25 and 26, 2022 Depositions - Exhibit 19
`1502f
`Jay Gunderson - September 21, 2022 Deposition - Exhibit 1
`1508
`Jay Gunderson - September 21, 2022 Deposition - Exhibit 2
`1508a
`2016 EERC Proposal
`1662
`1663 Agreement between CERT, LLC and the EERC
`1664
`Blanket Service Agreement between CERT, LLC and the EERC
`1665
`2021-2022 EERC Proposal
`1666
`2019-2020 EERC Proposal
`1667
`2017 EERC Proposal
`1668
`2018-2019 EERC Proposal
`1669
`2017-2018 EERC Proposal
`1670
`2020-2021 EERC Proposal
`1671
`2015 EERC Proposal
`1672
`CERT Operations RCB, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011
`to 7/32/2022
`CERT Operations III, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011 to
`7/32/2022
`CERT Operations III, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011 to
`7/32/2022
`CERT Operations, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011 to
`7/32/2022
`CERT Operations IV, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011 to
`7/32/2022
`CERT Operations V, LLC Vendor Transaction History from 1/1/2011 to
`7/32/2022
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 7, 2013
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 29, 2013
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 25, 2014
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg
`Reductions - August 12, 2014
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 2, 2015
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 4, 2015
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 2, 2016
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`July 21, 2016
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 17, 2017
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`July 13, 2017
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 11, 2018
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`July 10, 2018
`
`1677
`
`1689
`
`1690
`
`1691
`
`1692
`
`1693
`
`1694
`
`1695
`
`1696
`
`1697
`
`1698
`
`1699
`
`1700
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`Date
`
`10/27/2014
`
`5/26/2015
`
`3/7/2016
`7/1/2011
`
`2/3/2021
`5/23/2019
`10/12/2016
`1/8/2019
`8/14/2017
`4/28/2020
`4/29/2015
`
`3/7/2013
`
`8/29/2013
`
`2/25/2014
`
`8/12/2014
`
`2/11/2015
`
`8/4/2015
`
`2/2/2016
`
`7/21/2016
`
`1/17/2017
`
`7/13/2017
`
`1/11/2018
`
`7/10/2018
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`CERT_0040881
`
`CERT_0003937
`
`CERT-0042449
`CERT-0042455
`CERT-0042456
`CERT-0042462
`CERT-0042468
`CERT-0042474
`CERT-0042480
`CERT-0042483
`CERT-0042489
`CERT-0042495
`
`CERT-0042501
`
`CERT-0042515
`
`CERT-0042522
`
`CERT-0042542
`
`CERT-0042554
`
`CERT-0042567
`
`CERT-0041705
`
`CERT-0041878
`
`CERT-0040452
`
`CERT-0040881
`
`CERT-0040652
`
`CERT-0041676
`
`CERT-0041393
`
`CERT-0040336
`
`CERT-0040709
`
`CERT-0040365
`
`CERT-0041308
`
`CERT-0040308
`
`2
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`CERT-0042454
`CERT-0042455
`CERT-0042461
`CERT-0042467
`CERT-0042473
`CERT-0042479
`CERT-0042482
`CERT-0042488
`CERT-0042494
`CERT-0042500
`
`CERT-0042514
`
`CERT-0042521
`
`CERT-0042541
`
`CERT-0042553
`
`CERT-0042566
`
`CERT-0042573
`
`CERT-0041733
`
`CERT-0041906
`
`CERT-0040480
`
`CERT-0040909
`
`CERT-0040680
`
`CERT-0041704
`
`CERT-0041421
`
`CERT-0040364
`
`CERT-0040737
`
`CERT-0040393
`
`CERT-0041335
`
`CERT-0040335
`
`Y
`
`APP. 259
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 4 of 11 PageID #: 18158
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`1/3/2019
`
`6/25/2019
`
`12/17/2019
`
`6/9/2020
`
`12/3/2020
`
`5/27/2021
`
`11/23/2021
`
`8/8/2011
`
`1/5/2012
`
`7/2/2012
`
`12/19/2012
`
`6/13/2013
`
`12/10/2013
`
`CERT-0041619
`
`CERT-0041280
`
`CERT-0009945
`
`CERT-0009974
`
`CERT-0010003
`
`CERT-0009916
`
`CERT-0009887
`
`CERT-0040024
`
`CERT-0039691
`
`CERT-0039886
`
`CERT-0039719
`
`CERT-0006638
`
`CERT-0006523
`
`CERT-0041646
`
`CERT-0041307
`
`CERT-0009972
`
`CERT-0010001
`
`CERT-0010030
`
`CERT-0009943
`
`CERT-0009914
`
`CERT-0040049
`
`CERT-0039718
`
`CERT-0039913
`
`CERT-0039746
`
`CERT-0006666
`
`CERT-0006551
`
`CERT-0006695
`
`DTX
`No.
`1701
`
`1702
`
`1703
`
`1704
`
`1705
`
`1706
`
`1707
`
`1708
`
`1709
`
`1710
`
`1711
`
`1712
`
`1713
`
`1714
`
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 3, 2019
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 25, 2019
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 17, 2019
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 9, 2020
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 3, 2020
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 27, 2021
`Evaluation of Antelope Valley Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 23, 2021
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 8, 2011
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 5, 2012
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`2, 1012
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 19, 2012
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 13, 2013
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 10, 2013
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 2, 2014
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 26, 2014
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 20, 2015
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 12, 2015
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 3, 2016
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 27, 2016
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 13, 2018
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 11, 2019
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 5, 2019
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 4, 2020
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`30, 2020
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 28, 2021
`Evaluation of Big Cajun II Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`22, 2021
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 19, 2011
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`15, 2012
`
`1715
`
`1716
`
`1717
`
`1718
`
`1719
`
`1720
`
`1721
`
`1722
`
`1723
`
`1724
`
`1725
`
`1726
`
`1727
`
`1728
`
`6/2/2014
`
`11/26/2014
`
`5/20/2015
`
`11/12/2015
`
`5/3/2016
`
`10/27/2016
`
`8/13/2018
`
`2/11/2019
`
`8/5/2019
`
`2/4/2020
`
`7/30/2020
`
`1/28/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`9/19/2011
`
`3/15/2012
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0006667
`
`CERT-0006494
`
`CERT-0006580
`
`CERT-0006465
`
`CERT-0006609
`
`CERT-0006436
`
`CERT-0006696
`
`CERT-0006552
`
`CERT-0004357
`
`CERT-0004301
`
`CERT-0004329
`
`CERT-0004273
`
`CERT-0008503
`
`CERT-0040196
`
`CERT-0039943
`
`3
`
`CERT-0006522
`
`CERT-0006608
`
`CERT-0006493
`
`CERT-0006637
`
`CERT-0006464
`
`CERT-0006723
`
`CERT-0006579
`
`CERT-0004384
`
`CERT-0004328
`
`CERT-0004356
`
`CERT-0004300
`
`CERT-0008530
`
`CERT-0040223
`
`CERT-0039970
`
`APP. 260
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 5 of 11 PageID #: 18159
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`7/30/2012
`
`1/28/2013
`
`7/23/2013
`
`1/15/2014
`
`7/1/2014
`
`12/30/2014
`
`2/11/2019
`
`8/5/2019
`
`2/4/2020
`
`7/30/2020
`
`1/28/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`12/12/2013
`
`CERT-0040252
`
`CERT-0042800
`
`CERT-0004814
`
`CERT-0004698
`
`CERT-0004784
`
`CERT-0004727
`
`CERT-0004756
`
`CERT-0003713
`
`CERT-0003657
`
`CERT-0003685
`
`CERT-0003629
`
`CERT-0008531
`
`CERT-0005617
`
`CERT-0040279
`
`CERT-0042828
`
`CERT-0004842
`
`CERT-0004726
`
`CERT-0004813
`
`CERT-0004755
`
`CERT-0004783
`
`CERT-0003740
`
`CERT-0003684
`
`CERT-003712
`
`CERT-0003656
`
`CERT-0008558
`
`CERT-0005651
`
`CERT-0005794
`
`DTX
`No.
`1729
`
`1730
`
`1731
`
`1732
`
`1733
`
`1734
`
`1735
`
`1736
`
`1737
`
`1738
`
`1739
`
`1740
`
`1741
`
`1742
`
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`30, 2012
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 28, 2013
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`23, 2013
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 15, 2014
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July 1,
`2014
`Evaluation of Marshall Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 30, 2014
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - February
`11, 2019
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - August 5,
`2019
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - February
`4, 2020
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July 30,
`2020
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - January
`28, 2021
`Evaluation of Coleto Creek Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July 22,
`2021
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 12, 2013
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June 4,
`2014
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 2, 2014
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May 26,
`2015
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 19, 2015
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May 12,
`2016
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - August
`13, 2018
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 11, 2019
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - August
`5, 2019
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 4, 2020
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July 20,
`2020
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - January
`28, 2021
`Evaluation of Labadie Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July 22,
`2021
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 27, 2013
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 17, 2013
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 11, 2014
`
`1743
`
`1744
`
`1745
`
`1746
`
`1747
`
`1748
`
`1749
`
`1750
`
`1751
`
`1752
`
`1753
`
`1754
`
`1755
`
`1756
`
`6/4/2014
`
`12/2/2014
`
`5/26/2015
`
`11/19/2015
`
`5/12/2016
`
`8/13/2018
`
`2/11/2019
`
`8/5/2019
`
`2/4/2020
`
`7/30/2020
`
`1/28/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`3/27/2013
`
`9/17/2013
`
`3/11/2014
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0005766
`
`CERT-0005652
`
`CERT-0005738
`
`CERT-0005589
`
`CERT-0005709
`
`CERT-0005795
`
`CERT-0005681
`
`CERT-0004021
`
`CERT-0003965
`
`CERT-0003993
`
`CERT-0003937
`
`CERT-0008559
`
`CERT-0042574
`
`CERT-0005530
`
`CERT-0005358
`
`4
`
`CERT-0005680
`
`CERT-0005765
`
`CERT-0005616
`
`CERT-0005737
`
`CERT-0005822
`
`CERT-0005708
`
`CERT-0004048
`
`CERT-0003992
`
`CERT-0004020
`
`CERT-0003964
`
`CERT-0008586
`
`CERT-0042602
`
`CERT-0005559
`
`CERT-0005386
`
`APP. 261
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 6 of 11 PageID #: 18160
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`9/2/2014
`
`2/24/2015
`
`8/18/2015
`
`2/9/2016
`
`8/2/2016
`
`1/24/2017
`
`7/18/2017
`
`1/16/2018
`
`7/12/2018
`
`1/8/2019
`
`6/27/2019
`
`12/19/2019
`
`6/11/2020
`
`CERT-0005560
`
`CERT-0005301
`
`CERT-0005472
`
`CERT-0005330
`
`CERT-0005501
`
`CERT-0005244
`
`CERT-0005443
`
`CERT-0005216
`
`CERT-0005415
`
`CERT-0005273
`
`CERT-0005387
`
`CERT-0003853
`
`CERT-0003909
`
`CERT-0005588
`
`CERT-0005329
`
`CERT-0005500
`
`CERT-0005357
`
`CERT-0005529
`
`CERT-0005272
`
`CERT-0005471
`
`CERT-0005243
`
`CERT-0005442
`
`CERT-0005300
`
`CERT-0005414
`
`CERT-0003880
`
`CERT-0003936
`
`CERT-0003908
`
`DTX
`No.
`1757
`
`1758
`
`1759
`
`1760
`
`1761
`
`1762
`
`1763
`
`1764
`
`1765
`
`1766
`
`1767
`
`1768
`
`1769
`
`1770
`
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 2, 2014
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 24, 2015
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 18, 2015
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 9, 2016
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 2, 2016
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 24, 2017
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`July 18, 2017
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 16, 2018
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`July 12, 2018
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 8, 2019
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 27, 2019
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 29, 2019
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 11, 2020
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 8, 2020
`Evaluation of Laramie River Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 1, 2021
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 14, 2011
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 8, 2012
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`27, 2012
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 17, 2013
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`28, 2013
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 21, 2013
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`15, 2014
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 11, 2014
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 18, 2014
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`7, 2015
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`17, 2015
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 26, 2015
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 15, 2015
`
`1771
`
`1772
`
`1773
`
`1774
`
`1775
`
`1776
`
`1777
`
`1778
`
`1779
`
`1780
`
`1781
`
`1782
`
`1783
`
`1784
`
`12/8/2020
`
`6/1/2021
`
`9/14/2011
`
`3/8/2012
`
`7/27/2012
`
`1/17/2013
`
`5/28/2013
`
`11/21/2013
`
`5/15/2014
`
`11/11/2014
`
`12/18/2014
`
`5/7/2015
`
`6/17/2015
`
`10/26/2015
`
`12/15/2015
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0003881
`
`CERT-0008587
`
`CERT-0040169
`
`CERT-0039775
`
`CERT-0039858
`
`CERT-0042744
`
`CERT-0006061
`
`CERT-0005884
`
`CERT-0006031
`
`CERT-0005853
`
`CERT-0005943
`
`CERT-0006090
`
`CERT-0006120
`
`CERT-0005823
`
`CERT-0005913
`
`5
`
`CERT-0008614
`
`CERT-0040195
`
`CERT-0039802
`
`CERT-0039885
`
`CERT-0041771
`
`CERT-0006089
`
`CERT-0005912
`
`CERT-0006060
`
`CERT-0005883
`
`CERT-0005972
`
`CERT-0006119
`
`CERT-0006149
`
`CERT-0005852
`
`CERT-0005942
`
`APP. 262
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 7 of 11 PageID #: 18161
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`4/14/2016
`
`8/13/2018
`
`2/11/2019
`
`8/5/2019
`
`2/4/2020
`
`7/30/2020
`
`1/28/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`10/13/2011
`
`3/30/2012
`
`9/24/2012
`
`3/18/2013
`
`9/9/2013
`
`CERT-0006001
`
`CERT-0006150
`
`CERT-0005973
`
`CERT-0004133
`
`CERT-0004077
`
`CERT-0004105
`
`CERT-0004049
`
`CERT-0008615
`
`CERT-0039609
`
`CERT-0039803
`
`CERT-0039914
`
`CERT-0042631
`
`CERT-0004669
`
`CERT-0006030
`
`CERT-0006177
`
`CERT-0006000
`
`CERT-0004160
`
`CERT-0004104
`
`CERT-0004132
`
`CERT-0004076
`
`CERT-0008642
`
`CERT-0039636
`
`CERT-0039830
`
`CERT-0039942
`
`CERT-0042659
`
`CERT-0004697
`
`CERT-0004525
`
`DTX
`No.
`1785
`
`1786
`
`1787
`
`1788
`
`1789
`
`1790
`
`1791
`
`1792
`
`1793
`
`1794
`
`1795
`
`1796
`
`1797
`
`1798
`
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - April
`14, 2016
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 13, 2018
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 11, 2019
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 5, 2019
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 4, 2020
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`30, 2020
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 28, 2021
`Evaluation of Limestone Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`21, 2021
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - October
`13, 2011
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - March 30,
`2012
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - September
`24, 2012
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - March 18,
`2013
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - September
`9, 2013
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - March 3,
`2014
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - August 28,
`2014
`Evaluation of Allen Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - February
`19, 2015
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 22, 2016
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 16, 2016
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`11, 2017
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 28, 2017
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`27, 2018
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 18, 2018
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`10, 2019
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 3, 2019
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`1, 2020
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 25, 2020
`Evaluation of Powerton Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`18, 2021
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 12, 2011
`
`1799
`
`1800
`
`1801
`
`1802
`
`1803
`
`1804
`
`1805
`
`1806
`
`1807
`
`1808
`
`1809
`
`1810
`
`1811
`
`1812
`
`3/3/2014
`
`8/28/2014
`
`2/19/2015
`
`2/22/2016
`
`8/16/2016
`
`7/11/2017
`
`12/28/2017
`
`6/27/2018
`
`12/18/2018
`
`6/10/2019
`
`12/3/2019
`
`6/1/2020
`
`11/25/2020
`
`5/18/2021
`
`9/12/2011
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0004498
`
`CERT-0004640
`
`CERT-0004440
`
`CERT-0004469
`
`CERT-0004611
`
`CERT-0004582
`
`CERT-0004412
`
`CERT-0004554
`
`CERT-0004385
`
`CERT-0004526
`
`CERT-0003573
`
`CERT-0003601
`
`CERT-0003545
`
`CERT-0042998
`
`CERT-0040108
`
`6
`
`CERT-0004668
`
`CERT-0004468
`
`CERT-0004497
`
`CERT-0004639
`
`CERT-0004610
`
`CERT-0004439
`
`CERT-0004581
`
`CERT-0004411
`
`CERT-0004553
`
`CERT-0003600
`
`CERT-0003628
`
`CERT-0003572
`
`CERT-0043025
`
`CERT-0040140
`
`APP. 263
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 8 of 11 PageID #: 18162
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`2/13/2012
`
`8/9/2012
`
`2/7/2013
`
`8/5/2013
`
`2/3/2014
`
`7/23/2014
`
`1/20/2015
`
`7/14/2015
`
`1/7/2016
`
`6/28/2016
`
`12/20/2016
`
`6/13/2017
`
`12/5/2017
`
`CERT-0039637
`
`CERT-0040141
`
`CERT-0042829
`
`CERT-0005187
`
`CERT-0004987
`
`CERT-0005158
`
`CERT-0004843
`
`CERT-0005129
`
`CERT-0004872
`
`CERT-0005100
`
`CERT-0004929
`
`CERT-0005071
`
`CERT-0004958
`
`CERT-0039663
`
`CERT-0040168
`
`CERT-0042856
`
`CERT-0005215
`
`CERT-0005015
`
`CERT-0005186
`
`CERT-0004871
`
`CERT-0005157
`
`CERT-0004900
`
`CERT-0005128
`
`CERT-0004957
`
`CERT-0005099
`
`CERT-0004986
`
`CERT0005043
`
`DTX
`No.
`1813
`
`1814
`
`1815
`
`1816
`
`1817
`
`1818
`
`1819
`
`1820
`
`1821
`
`1822
`
`1823
`
`1824
`
`1825
`
`1826
`
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 13, 2012
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 9, 2012
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 7, 2013
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 5, 2013
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 3, 2014
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`23, 2014
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 20, 2015
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`14, 2015
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 7, 2016
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`28, 2016
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 20, 2016
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June
`13, 2017
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 5, 2017
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`30, 2018
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 20, 2018
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - May
`7, 2019
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 29, 2019
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`April 23, 2020
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 15, 2020
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`April 12, 2021
`Evaluation of Rush Island Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`22, 2021
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 16, 2011
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 31, 2012
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`5, 2012
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 13, 2012
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 5, 2013
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 27, 2013
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 24, 2014
`
`1827
`
`1828
`
`1829
`
`1830
`
`1831
`
`1832
`
`1833
`
`1834
`
`1835
`
`1836
`
`1837
`
`1838
`
`1839
`
`1840
`
`5/30/2018
`
`11/20/2018
`
`5/7/2019
`
`10/29/2019
`
`4/23/2020
`
`10/15/2020
`
`4/13/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`8/16/2011
`
`1/31/2012
`
`7/5/2012
`
`9/13/2012
`
`3/5/2013
`
`8/27/2013
`
`2/24/2014
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0005016
`
`CERT-0004901
`
`CERT-0005044
`
`CERT-0042941
`
`CERT-0003825
`
`CERT-0003741
`
`CERT-0003797
`
`CERT-008671
`
`CERT-0039998
`
`CERT-0039664
`
`CERT-0040224
`
`CERT-0040280
`
`CERT-0042772
`
`CERT-0006407
`
`CERT-0006235
`
`7
`
`CERT-0004928
`
`CERT-0005070
`
`CERT-0042968
`
`CERT-0003852
`
`CERT-0003768
`
`CERT-0003824
`
`CERT-0008698
`
`CERT-0040023
`
`CERT-0039690
`
`CERT-0040251
`
`CERT-0040307
`
`CERT-0042799
`
`CERT-0006435
`
`CERT-0006263
`
`APP. 264
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 9 of 11 PageID #: 18163
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`8/11/2014
`
`2/9/2015
`
`7/31/2015
`
`1/26/2016
`
`7/19/2016
`
`8/13/2018
`
`2/11/2019
`
`8/5/2019
`
`2/4/2020
`
`7/30/2020
`
`1/28/2021
`
`7/22/2021
`
`6/9/2011
`
`CERT-0006351
`
`CERT-0006264
`
`CERT-0006322
`
`CERT-0006178
`
`CERT-0006293
`
`CERT-0006379
`
`CERT-0006207
`
`CERT-0004245
`
`CERT-0004189
`
`CERT-0004217
`
`CERT-0004161
`
`CERT-0008643
`
`CERT-0040079
`
`CERT-0006378
`
`CERT-0006292
`
`CERT-0006350
`
`CERT-0006206
`
`CERT-0006321
`
`CERT-0006406
`
`CERT-0006234
`
`CERT-0004245
`
`CERT-0004216
`
`CERT-0004244
`
`CERT-0004188
`
`CERT-0008670
`
`CERT-0040107
`
`CERT-0039774
`
`DTX
`No.
`1841
`
`1842
`
`1843
`
`1844
`
`1845
`
`1846
`
`1847
`
`1848
`
`1849
`
`1850
`
`1851
`
`1852
`
`1853
`
`1854
`
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 11, 2014
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 9, 2015
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`31, 2015
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 26, 2016
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`19, 2016
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 13, 2018
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 11, 2019
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 5, 2019
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 4, 2020
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`30, 2020
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`January 28, 2021
`Evaluation of W.A. Parish Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - July
`22, 2021
`Evaluation of Cayuga Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions - June 9,
`2011
`Evaluation of Cayuga Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 12, 2011
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`June 23, 2011
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`December 5, 2011
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 24, 2012
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 21, 2012
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 15, 2013
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`November 7, 2013
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`May 6, 2014
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 29, 2014
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`April 23, 2015
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`October 15, 2015
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`March 31, 2016
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`September 29, 2016
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`February 18, 2020
`Evaluation of Chesterfield Station Coal for Nox and Hg Reductions -
`August 11, 2020
`
`1855
`
`1856
`
`1857
`
`1858
`
`1859
`
`1860
`
`1861
`
`1862
`
`1863
`
`1864
`
`1865
`
`1866
`
`1867
`
`1868
`
`12/12/2011
`
`6/23/2011
`
`12/5/2011
`
`5/24/2012
`
`11/21/2012
`
`5/15/2013
`
`11/7/2013
`
`5/6/2014
`
`10/29/2014
`
`4/23/2015
`
`10/15/2015
`
`3/31/2016
`
`9/29/2016
`
`2/18/2020
`
`8/11/2020
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`
`CERT-0039747
`
`CERT-0041565
`
`CERT-0041051
`
`CERT-0040910
`
`CERT-0040738
`
`CERT-0040451
`
`CERT-0041165
`
`CERT-0041934
`
`CERT-0041849
`
`CERT-0041647
`
`CERT-0040394
`
`CERT-0041022
`
`CERT-0040852
`
`CERT-0039063
`
`CERT-0039119
`
`8
`
`CERT-0041591
`
`CERT-0041078
`
`CERT-0040937
`
`CERT-0040767
`
`CERT-0040423
`
`CERT-0041193
`
`CERT-0041962
`
`CERT-0041877
`
`CERT-0041675
`
`CERT-0040422
`
`CERT-0041050
`
`CERT-0040880
`
`CERT-0039090
`
`CERT-0039146
`
`APP. 265
`
`

`

`Case 1:19-cv-01334-CJB Document 725-5 Filed 05/01/24 Page 10 of 11 PageID #: 18164
`Midwest Energy Emissions Corp. and MES Inc. v. Arthur J. Gallagher Co., et al.
`C.A. No. 19-1334 (CJB)
`Defendants' Trial Exhibit List
`
`Description
`
`Date
`
`Beginning Bates No.
`
`Ending Bates No.
`
`Objections
`
`Admitted?
`
`2/4/2021
`
`7/29/2021
`
`7/12/2011
`
`1/3/2012
`
`6/11/2012
`
`5/2/2011
`
`10/31/2011
`
`4/25/2012
`
`10/18/2012
`
`4/9/2013
`
`10/3/2013
`
`3/26/2014
`
`9/15/2014
`
`CERT-0039201
`
`CERT-0039312
`
`CERT-00