`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 1 of 57
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A-1
`EXHIBIT A-1
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 2 of 57
`
`Fish & Richardson P.C.
`45035.0002LL1 ‐ Dish Network Corporation
`Fees and Costs Detail ‐ worked 1/15/2021 ‐ 7/31/2021
`Prepared on 8/12/2021
`
`Work Date
`1/15/2021
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`Associate
`Principal
`
`Tkr Name
`Ballanco, Mike
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`1/18/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Principal
`
`1/19/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Ballanco, Mike
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`Park, Min Woo
`Utreja, Raj
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Narrative
`Review court order reopening case (0.3)
`final preparation for conference with Judge Jackson in Realtime matter (0.4); status
`conference with Judge Jackson in Realtime matter (0.8); confer with Dish re Judge
`Jackson lifting stay in Realtime matter (0.2); review and revision of status and strategy
`memorandum (0.7)
`Attend status conference re stay (1.0); prepare for same (0.8)
`Communicate with experts about case status in view of stay lifting (0.8)
`Draft case summary for client (3.5)
`Conduct call with litigation team re case strategy in view of stay being lifted (1.8);
`review and draft edits to strategy memo re case moving forward (0.7); search for and
`review case law re recent adaptive streaming case holding patent ineligible under 35
`U.S.C. 101 (0.4)
`Prepare for and attend hearing with Judge Jackson (1.6)
`Prepare case summaries per attorney request (1.1)
`Review status of action items prior to stay (1.5); draft task list re same (1.0); review
`case history in Realtime v. Adobe (1.1)
`Conduct several calls with litigation team members re trial strategy (2.2); analyze
`current status of invalidity contentions (0.5); analyze current status of discovery (0.6);
`prepare for team call tomorrow (0.5); review case memo created at the stay to
`determine strategy for remainder of discovery (0.7); attend JDG call re future
`coordination (0.6); work on summary of trials before Judge Jackson during COVID and
`correspond with RBCordell re same (0.3)
`Update notice of scheduling conflicts regarding oral arguments and updated
`certificate of interest (1.4)
`Confer with team re next steps following lifting of the stay (1.0); review status of final
`invalidity contentions and outstanding issues (1.4); confer with ARRIS re same (1.0)
`
`Attend team meeting to discuss tasks and upcoming deadlines (1.5)
`Review the 610 patent and Realtime's infringement contentions (7.3)
`Strategize with team re upcoming discovery tasks and deadlines (0.9)
`Confer with trial team re post stay case status and strategy moving forward (1.5)
`
`Participate in team meeting re case strategy (1.6)
`Review, analyze document production re damages (1.9); work on strategy re same
`(1.6)
`Meet with technical expert (0.3); meet with ARRIS re invalidity contentions (1.0)
`
`Participate in team strategy call (1.5); prepare for same (0.9)
`Research system prior art for final invalidity contentions (1.2)
`Conduct team call re litigation planning (1.6); work on analysis re initial disclosures
`(0.5); conduct call with Mr. Hanft re update to relate dockets (0.1); conduct call with
`expert Al Bovik (0.4); conduct call with ARRIS to discuss planning re invalidity
`contentions (1.0); conference with RBCordell re strategy (0.4); review filings and
`updates re update as to stay status (0.7) review ex parte reexamination status (0.4)
`
`1/20/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Associate
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Ballanco, Mike
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Identify and compile documents for attorney review (1.1)
`Finalize and file amended certificate of interest (0.2)
`Update cover pleading for final invalidity contentions and recirculate to team (0.7)
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Review the 610 patent (3.6); review Realtime's infringement contentions (4.9)
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Principal
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`1/21/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Strategize re finalizing invalidity contentions (0.2); research USPTO assignment records
`for the 610 patent (1.9); research adaptive bitrate streaming (1.2); review and analyze
`pre‐stay case record (2.2)
`Work on damages analysis and strategy (3.1); work on list of documents to collect re
`same (1.7)
`Complete final infringement contentions (2.5)
`Conduct analysis into state of initial disclosures (0.6); analyze needs for evidence re
`non‐infringement defenses (1.4); review ex parte reexamination status and instruct
`team re document collection re same (0.5); draft update for ex parte reexamination s
`tatus report re setting of trial date (1.3); work with discovery team regarding access
`for case members (0.8); collect damages related documents for the case and
`conference with DTishman re same (1.2)
`
`Work in finalizing invalidity contention cover pleading and additional charts (3.0);
`confer with team re same (0.6); review outstanding discovery and drafts (1.1);
`summarize same for team (0.5); confer with team re next steps and responsibilities
`(1.0); develop interim timelines (0.4)
`Review Realtime's infringement contentions ( 3.6); review document production to
`identify evidence to support noninfringement for DISH TV (3.7)
`
`Billable Hrs
`
`Fees
`217.50
`
`2,457.00
`
`
`0.3
`2.1
`
`1.8
`0.8
`3.5
`2.9
`
`1,431.00
`
`636.00
`
`
`2,782.50
`
`2,392.50
`
`1.6
`1.1
`3.6
`
`1,320.00
`
`291.50
`
`
`2,862.00
`
`5.4
`
`
`
`4,455.00
`
`1.4
`
`
`
`1,015.00
`
`3.4
`
`
`
`2,295.00
`
`1.5
`7.3
`0.9
`1.5
`
`1.6
`3.5
`
`1,012.50
`
`
`4,927.50
`436.50
`
`
`1,755.00
`
`1,272.00
`
`
`2,782.50
`
`1.3
`
`
`
`1,033.50
`
`2.4
`1.2
`5.1
`
`1,908.00
`
`
`954.00
`
`4,207.50
`
`1.1
`0.2
`0.7
`
`291.50
`
`
`145.00
`
`472.50
`
`8.5
`
`
`
`5,737.50
`
`5.5
`
`
`
`2,667.50
`
`4.8
`
`
`
`3,816.00
`
`2.5
`5.8
`
`1,987.50
`
`
`4,785.00
`
`6.6
`
`
`
`4,455.00
`
`7.3
`
`
`
`4,927.50
`
`Exhibit A‐1 Dish Attorney's Fees.xlsx, Detail, 8/13/2021
`
`Page 1
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 3 of 57
`
`Work Date
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`
`Tkr Name
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Principal
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`Confer with trial team re supplement to initial disclosures in D. Colo case (0.3)
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Paralegal
`
`Other
`eDscovery Anlst
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Faeth, Edward G.
`Spanoudakis, Dennis
`
`1/22/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Participate in team meeting re discovery strategy (1.0)
`Work on strategy re interrogatories (1.1); work on subpoena to RPX (0.9)
`Coordinate completion of case proof chart (1.8); coordinate team meeting re task list
`(0.7)
`Finalize final invalidity contentions (2.4); edit discovery requests (1.0); coordinate
`source code review (1.0)
`Work with litigation team regarding damages document collection (0.7); analyze
`invalidity charting and status of invalidity contentions (0.6); conduct review of cover
`pleading (0.4); review dockets in cases Judge Jackson stated that he took to trial
`during the pandemic (0.5)
`Prepare documents for production (0.7)
`Review and update documents into the litigation database (0.6)
`Work on collecting production documents (0.5)
`Process and prepare ARRIS_DISH0010553‐ ARRIS_DISH0016835 for production to
`opposing counsel (1.2)
`Continue finalizing invalidity contention cover pleading (1.5); identify additional
`motivations to combine and related language (1.0); update charts and work with
`ARRIS re same (1.2); draft additional common and individual ROGs, RFPs, and RFAs
`(2.5); work with team to develop same (0.8)
`Review document production to identify documents to support noninfringement of
`accused products (7.1)
`Prepare summary of written discovery to‐date and prepare spreadsheet to track 30b6
`topics (0.8)
`Revise 610 patent invalidity chart based on RealServer system art (Exhibit B45) (7.2)
`
`Narrative
`Participate in team meeting and strategize re upcoming discovery deadlines (0.8)
`
`Billable Hrs
`
`Fees
`388.00
`
`
`
`0.8
`
`Prepare spreadsheet summarizing current discovery, including interrogatories,
`requests for production, and requests for admission (1.3)
`Revise 610 patent invalidity chart based on RealServer system art (Exhibit B45) (2.4)
`
`1.3
`
`
`
`630.50
`
`2.4
`
`
`
`1,164.00
`
`0.3
`
`
`
`351.00
`
`1.0
`2.0
`2.5
`
`795.00
`
`1,590.00
`
`
`1,987.50
`
`4.4
`
`
`
`3,498.00
`
`2.2
`
`
`
`1,815.00
`
`0.7
`0.6
`0.5
`1.2
`
`185.50
`
`
`159.00
`
`132.50
`
`312.00
`
`7.0
`
`
`
`4,725.00
`
`7.1
`
`
`
`4,792.50
`
`0.8
`
`
`
`388.00
`
`7.2
`
`
`
`3,492.00
`
`1.1
`
`
`
`874.50
`
`Principal
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Paralegal
`eDscovery Anlst
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Spanoudakis, Dennis
`
`1/23/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`1/24/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Principal
`
`1/25/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Principal
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Participate in meeting with damages expert re damages (0.6); participate in call with
`Baker Botts re financial document collection (0.5)
`Review, revise discovery requests (1.8); review, analyze documents re damages and
`work on proof chart re same (1.2); participate in team meeting re same (0.7)
`
`Finalize invalidity contentions (3.2); edit discovery requests (2.9)
`Search for deposition outlines of Realtime witnesses and begin preparations for
`deposition (0.8); advise team regarding prior analysis into license agreements for
`production (0.7); work with team to finalize invalidity contentions (0.8); investigate
`updates to invalidity positions in view Realtime's positions during IPR (1.2);
`correspond with DISH re current invalidity contentions status (0.3)
`
`Prepare documents for production (0.3)
`Process and prepare AR RIS_DISH0016836‐ARRIS_DISH0016873 for production to
`opposing counsel (0.6)
`Organize updated invalidity charts and coordinate same with ARRIS (1.0); confer with
`team re additional cover pleading edits (1.1)
`Review document production to identify evidence to support noninfringement re
`DISH TV and products with Sling functionality (4.2)
`Work on deposition preparation outlines re damages (1.2)
`Correspond with litigation team re need to update contentions re section 112
`positions in view of positions taken by Realtime during IPR (0.7)
`Update invalidity charts with additional combination language (2.0); work with ARRIS
`to finalize same (1.6); work with Fish team to finalize the invalidity contentions cover
`pleading (1.0)
`Work on deposition preparation outlines re damages (0.2)
`Finalize invalidity contentions (1.2)
`Analyze invalidity contentions and updates thereto (1.7)
`Draft additional common and individual RFAs (2.2); work with team to finalize same
`and remaining discovery (0.8); confer with ARRIS re final invalidity contentions and
`work with team and ARRIS to serve (1.2)
`Review Realtime's infringement contentions re set‐top boxes and SlingTV (3.5); review
`document production to identify evidence of noninfringement (4.7)
`
`Prepare subpoenas for RPX to testify at deposition and produce documents (4.1);
`prepare initial disclosures (3.6); review and analyze all interrogatories, requests for
`admission, and requests for production (1.8); strategize with team re discovery and
`dep osition preparation for damages witnesses (0.4)
`Review, revise interrogatories and request for production (1.7); review, revise
`subpoena to RPX (1.4)
`Work on deposition preparation outline re financial documents (1.4)
`Finalize discovery requests (1.0)
`
`3.7
`
`
`
`2,941.50
`
`6.1
`3.8
`
`4,849.50
`
`
`3,135.00
`
`0.3
`0.6
`
`79.50
`
`156.00
`
`
`2.1
`
`
`
`1,417.50
`
`4.2
`
`
`
`2,835.00
`
`1.2
`0.7
`
`954.00
`
`
`577.50
`
`4.6
`
`
`
`3,105.00
`
`0.2
`1.2
`1.7
`4.2
`
`159.00
`
`
`954.00
`
`1,402.50
`
`2,835.00
`
`8.2
`
`
`
`5,535.00
`
`9.9
`
`
`
`4,801.50
`
`3.1
`
`
`
`2,464.50
`
`1.4
`1.0
`
`1,113.00
`
`795.00
`
`
`Exhibit A‐1 Dish Attorney's Fees.xlsx, Detail, 8/13/2021
`
`Page 2
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 4 of 57
`
`Work Date
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`
`Tkr Name
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Paralegal
`
`Other
`Associate
`
`1/26/2021
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Gilman, Chad
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Narrative
`Conduct review of licenses for potential production and work with damages expert on
`efforts to determine final list for production (3.3); analyze existing discovery regarding
`interrogatories, requests for admission and requests for production and draft edits to
`same (2.3) confer with team and review invalidity contentions cover pleading and
`draft edits to same (1.4); correspond with DISH re outgoing contentions and discovery
`updates (0.4)
`Finalize documents for production (0.6)
`Prepare materials for expert review (1.6)
`Online research re RPX Corporation Agent for Service (0.6)
`Review served invalidity contentions and correct error in cover pleading (1.2); work
`with ARRIS to resolve and re‐serve (0.4); meet with team re upcoming deadlines and
`responsibilities (0.6); continue editing discovery and amended disclosure drafts (0.9);
`work with ARRIS and internal team to finalize discovery for service (0.5)
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Draft a deposition outline for 30b6 witness on technical topics re DISH TV (6.8)
`
`Principal
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Paralegal
`eDscovery Anlst
`Associate
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Spanoudakis, Dennis
`Ellis, Michael
`
`1/27/2021
`
`Prepare for and participate in weekly team meeting and prepare minutes for same
`(0.6)
`Review and analyze DISH and Realtime productions for documents to support
`damages theories (2.3)
`Revise subpoenas for RPX to testify at deposition and produce documents (2.9);
`review and analyze protective order and prepare summary of options for source code
`inspection based on same (1.7)
`Confer with trial team re source code review (0.3)
`Draft correspondence re production of licenses (0.9)
`Participate in internal team meeting re strategy (0.9)
`Review, revise subpoena to RPX (1.2); draft correspondence to client re same (0.2);
`correspond with RPX outside counsel re same (0.1)
`Work on deposition preparation outline re financial records (2.2); work on deposition
`preparation outline re marketing (0.9); work on deposition outline re Realtime
`licenses (0.9)
`Coordinate weekly team meeting (1.0)
`Finalize outgoing discovery requests (2.5)
`Conduct meeting with litigation team and discuss tasks for discovery this week (0.8);
`conduct review of RPX subpoena and correspond with DISH re same (0.7); correspond
`with litigation team re strategy for RPX documents and for related damages theories
`(0.6); work with team on source code review request from Realtime (0.7); draft
`agenda for bi‐weekly meeting call (0.6)
`
`Identify and compile agreement information for attorney review (2.1)
`Process and prepare documents for case team analysis (0.4)
`Work with team and ARRIS to finalize RFAs (1.2); assist team in locating additional
`licenses (0.5); assist team in sending client update email (0.4); provide additional edits
`on initial disclosures (0.6); review status of third party subpoenas (0.3)
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Draft a deposition outline for 30b6 witness on technical topics re DISH TV (4.6); draft a
`deposition outline for 30b6 witness on technical topics re Sling products (2.8)
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Review and analyze DISH and Realtime productions for documents to support
`damages theories (3.8); review and analyze case docket and litigation history (2.2)
`
`Revise RPX subpoena (1.0); revise initial disclosures with recent addresses of listed
`entities (1.2); prepare report email same (0.2)
`Revise initial disclosures (0.4); revise subpoena to RPX (0.3)
`Work on analysis of licenses for production (2.8)
`Edit requests for admission (1.5)
`Meet with counsel fr Google re Realtime/Google litigation (0.6); prepare or same (0.2)
`
`Analyze current status of initial disclosures and correspond with team re same (0.6);
`conference with RBCordell re case status and strategy (0.4); prepare for and conduct
`call with DISH re status of litigation (0.6); draft strategy summary memo for litigation
`team re action items moving forward this week (0.7); review correspondence re
`licenses and prepare for sending notice letters re production (0.4); conduct call with
`Google's counsel and follow up with BVLivedalen re strategy after the call (0.9)
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Myers, Teresa
`Ballanco, Mike
`Ellis, Michael
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Review and update agreement information (0.9)
`Online research re company headquarter addresses (0.6)
`Review Realtime response to notice of oral argument (0.1)
`Make additional edits to initial disclosures; review prior system art (1.2)
`Draft deposition prep outline for Sling and DISH set‐top box‐related issues (8.1)
`
`Confer with trial team re source code review (0.3)
`Review, analyze licenses for production (1.2)
`Work on document collection analysis re financial documents (2.6); review, revise
`initial disclosures (0.6); draft correspondence to client re same (0.5)
`
`Principal
`
`1/28/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Other
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Billable Hrs
`
`Fees
`6,105.00
`
`
`
`7.4
`
`0.6
`1.6
`0.6
`3.6
`
`159.00
`
`
`424.00
`
`159.00
`
`2,430.00
`
`6.8
`
`
`
`4,590.00
`
`0.6
`
`
`
`291.00
`
`2.3
`
`
`
`1,115.50
`
`4.6
`
`
`
`2,231.00
`
`0.3
`0.9
`0.9
`1.5
`
`351.00
`
`
`715.50
`
`715.50
`
`1,192.50
`
`4.0
`
`
`
`3,180.00
`
`1.0
`2.5
`2.8
`
`795.00
`
`1,987.50
`
`
`2,310.00
`
`2.1
`0.4
`3.0
`
`556.50
`
`
`104.00
`
`2,025.00
`
`7.4
`
`
`
`4,995.00
`
`6.0
`
`
`
`2,910.00
`
`2.4
`
`
`
`1,164.00
`
`0.7
`2.8
`1.5
`0.8
`
`556.50
`
`2,226.00
`
`
`1,192.50
`636.00
`
`
`3.6
`
`
`
`2,970.00
`
`0.9
`0.6
`0.1
`1.2
`8.1
`
`0.3
`1.2
`3.7
`
`238.50
`
`
`159.00
`
`72.50
`
`810.00
`
`5,467.50
`
`351.00
`
`
`954.00
`
`2,941.50
`
`Exhibit A‐1 Dish Attorney's Fees.xlsx, Detail, 8/13/2021
`
`Page 3
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 5 of 57
`
`Work Date
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`
`1/29/2021
`
`Other
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`1/30/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`1/31/2021
`
`Principal
`
`Tkr Name
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`Myers, Teresa
`Ballanco, Mike
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`Tishman, Daniel
`Shartzer, Adam
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`2/1/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Principal
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`2/2/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Associate
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Narrative
`Coordinate source code review (0.9); coordinate document review (0.8)
`Gather and review recent licenses reached by DISH (0.8)
`Online research re company headquarter addresses (0.3)
`Discuss Realtime response to notice of oral argument with team (0.1)
`Review systems prior art and associated discovery (2.1); confirm production of same
`(0.4); review Realtime's final infringement contentions (1.1); rank systems prior art
`(1.0)
`Draft deposition prep outline for 30b6 witness re topics related to DISH TV (7.6)
`
`Review and analyze DISH and Realtime productions and DISH's iDiscovery database for
`documents to support damages theories (8.2)
`confer with trial team re availability of source code in DC, possible LA review option
`(0.4); confer with opposing counsel re source code review (0.1)
`Review, analyze licenses for production (5.5); participate in teleconference with
`damages expert re same (0.6)
`Work on document collection re financial documents (1.1)
`Identify witnesses for 30b6 topics (2.8)
`Meet with Mr. Tishman to discuss licenses for production and parameters re same
`(0.6); correspond with damages expert team re licenses (0.4); review recent order on
`section 285 sanctions and circulate to team for use with 285 letter to Realtime (0.6);
`correspond with DISH re initial disclosures (0.5); work on source code review logistics
`(0.4)
`Review and update documents into the litigation database (0.6)
`Draft deposition prep outline for 30b6 witness re topics related to DISH TV (7.5)
`
`Confer with opposing counsel re source code review (0.1)
`Draft email to client re production of licenses (0.7)
`Review draft correspondence re license production (0.3)
`Draft correspondence to third parties re production of license agreements (1.3)
`
`Continue reviewing system art and identifying deficiencies in RealSystem production
`(1.8); review draft gripe letter (0.3); confer with team re next steps and responsibilities
`(0.7); confer with team re system art recommendation and marking defense (0.4);
`review correspondence re same (0.3); research Arctic Cat case law (1.3); confer with
`ARRIS counsel re division of discovery responsibilities (0.2); draft Arctic Cat analysis
`and circulate internally (0.3)
`
`Draft deposition prep outlines for the 30b6 witnesses re DISH TV and set‐top boxes
`(10.1)
`Prepare for and participate in weekly team meeting (0.7)
`Prepare letter to opposing counsel re Realtime's discovery deficiencies (2.2); prepare a
`list of witnesses and notices of deposition (1.3); conduct miscellaneous production
`search (1.6); work on 30(b)(6) objections (1.5)
`Draft notice letters to third parties re production of license agreements (1.2);
`participate in teleconference with counsel at Baker Botts re collection of cost
`documents (0.2); correspond with client re same (0.2); work on collection of financial
`documents from iDiscovery (0.7)
`Review, analyze RPX license re damages assessment (1.1); work on identification of
`witnesses for corporate deposition (0.7); participate in team meeting re case strategy
`(0.9)
`Coordinate weekly team meeting (0.8); prepare agenda for same (0.5); coordinate
`system prior art investigation (1.0)
`Draft correspondence to Realtime re licensed products (1.9); research licensed
`products (1.0); meet with ARRIS re 30b6 strategy (0.5)
`Prepare email to client re 30b6 witnesses (0.9)
`Review, edit technical 30b6 outline for DISH DBS (2.9)
`Plan for trial strategy and correspond with team (0.4); meet with litigation team to
`discuss case strategy (0.9); conduct call with ARRIS re coordination (0.5); prepare
`emails for DISH regarding discovery and license productions (0.8); meet with ARRIS
`todiscuss discovery coordination and invalidity expert report (0.5); review
`correspondence and respond to DISH re deposition assignments (0.5); work on
`document review access re IDS (0.4) investigate Sling TV encoder productions (0.5)
`
`Identify and compile documents for review and production (1.6)
`Review Arctic Cat and related case law (2.9); review marking order in Echostar case
`(0.3); draft supplemental interrogatory response re marking (1.3); review license
`agreements for coverage of the 610 patent and applicable products (0.5); review
`original complaints of licensee's re same (0.6); work with team to finalize
`supplemental interrogatory and amended initial disclosures (0.2)
`
`Principal
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Draft deposition prep outlines for the 30b6 witnesses re DISH TV and set‐top boxes
`(6.8)
`Work on document production strategy (1.1); revise, approve letters to third parties
`re production of licenses (0.7)
`
`Billable Hrs
`
`Fees
`1,351.50
`
`660.00
`
`
`79.50
`
`72.50
`
`3,105.00
`
`1.7
`0.8
`0.3
`0.1
`4.6
`
`7.6
`
`
`
`5,130.00
`
`8.2
`
`
`
`3,977.00
`
`0.5
`
`
`
`585.00
`
`6.1
`
`
`
`4,849.50
`
`1.1
`2.8
`2.5
`
`874.50
`
`2,226.00
`
`
`2,062.50
`
`0.6
`7.5
`
`0.1
`0.7
`0.3
`1.3
`
`5.3
`
`159.00
`
`5,062.50
`
`
`117.00
`
`
`556.50
`
`247.50
`
`1,033.50
`
`230,349.00
`
`3,577.50
`
`
`10.1
`
`
`
`6,817.50
`
`0.7
`6.6
`
`339.50
`
`
`3,201.00
`
`2.3
`
`
`
`1,828.50
`
`2.7
`
`
`
`2,146.50
`
`2.3
`
`
`
`1,828.50
`
`3.4
`
`
`
`2,703.00
`
`0.9
`2.9
`4.5
`
`715.50
`
`2,305.50
`
`
`3,712.50
`
`1.6
`5.8
`
`424.00
`
`3,915.00
`
`
`6.8
`
`
`
`4,590.00
`
`1.8
`
`
`
`1,431.00
`
`Exhibit A‐1 Dish Attorney's Fees.xlsx, Detail, 8/13/2021
`
`Page 4
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 6 of 57
`
`Work Date
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`
`2/3/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Paralegal
`
`2/4/2021
`
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Tkr Name
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`Dean, Caitlin
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`Dean, Caitlin
`Dean, Caitlin
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Narrative
`Coordinate 30b6 deposition preparation (1.0)
`Coordinate document collection, production (1.5)
`Edit interrogatory response re failure to mark (0.5); draft email to opposing counsel re
`licensed products (0.5); draft email re license defense (1.2); draft declarations re
`licensed products (1.0)
`Work on discovery issues regarding witnesses and document productions (2.4);
`conduct conference with Mr. Gratton re DISH witnesses and deposition planning (0.5);
`conduct conference with team regarding damages case (0.6); work on source code
`review and obt aining updated code (0.5); analyze production documents (1.2);
`develop strategy regarding Microsoft products for purposes of marking defense (1.4)
`work on damages data collection and correspond with DISH re same (0.7); coordinate
`with team re interview of Kip Wilcoxson (0.2); draft edits and updates to initial
`disclosures and circulate to litigation team and to DISH (0.6) discuss 285 letter with
`team (0.2); edit and revise Paddy Rao declaration re products to be removed from
`case (0.3)
`Identify and compile documents for review and production (2.7)
`Review and edit discovery deficiency letter (0.6); review Microsoft software license
`agreements (0.8); draft notice letters re same and work with staff to send (1.0)
`
`Draft deposition prep outlines for the 30b6 witnesses re DISH TV and set‐top boxes
`(8.2)
`Revise letter to opposing counsel re discovery deficiencies (0.6); research publicly
`available sources for evidence of recent Realtime settlement agreements and/or
`licenses for same (1.1)
`Correspond with team re case status (0.3)
`Work on RPX subpoena declaration (2.3); revise RPX subpoena to incorporate edits
`from DTTishman (0.8)
`Confer with AIShartzer re case strategy (0.3)
`Review documents for production (0.4); participate in teleconference with client re
`same (1.4); correspond with client re financial document collection (0.4)
`
`Review, analyze potential license defenses (0.7); review, revise declaration re RPX
`subpoena (0.6)
`Coordinate document review, production (0.6)
`Edit letter to Realtime re discovery (0.4); draft additional declarations re licensed
`products (0.7); draft email to client re same (0.3)
`Meet with client re discovery (1.0); meet with witness re upcoming deposition (1.0)
`
`Develop plans to get Realtime to agree to drop products licensed through the RPX
`agreement (1.3); review and revise declarations (0.3); correspond with DISH team re
`same (0.4); conference with BVLivedalen re document production (0.5); conduct
`document rev iew and instruct team re production this week (0.6) conduct call with
`Kip Wilcoxson to investigate DBS issues (1.0); conduct call with Max Gratton re
`damages data collection (1.0); investigate status of RPX subpoena and factual record
`(0.7) confer with RBCordell re case strategy (0.3) conduct analysis into potential
`additional license defense regarding DISH Technologies LLC and correspond with
`litigation team re same (1.6)
`
`Identify and compile documents for review and production (2.9)
`Prepare for source code review (0.6)
`Review Adobe litigation and use of RealSystem prior art (1.5); confer with team re
`same (0.2); work on RealNetworks document and deposition subpoenas (1.1); draft
`subpoenas for the 610 patent inventors (1.3)
`Draft deposition prep outlines for the 30b6 witnesses re DISH TV and set‐top boxes
`(4.5)
`Strategize with team re upcoming written discovery and depositions (1.9)
`Revise RPX subpoena declaration (0.2)
`Work on objections to 30b6 Deposition Notice (6.8)
`Review financial documents for production (1.9); work on strategy re document
`production and collection (1.8)
`Work on draft declaration re RPX (1.2); analyze licenses re license defense (0.9)
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Draft non‐infringement summary (0.4); revise technical deposition outlines (1.2)
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Continue investigation of license defense (0.3); review RPX declaration and draft edits
`to same (0.7); confer with litigation team regarding team communications (0.5); meet
`with Mr. Hanft to discuss case strategy (0.4); analyze ex parte reexamination deci
`sions by the USPTO (0.8); report out ex parte reexamination non‐final office action
`rejection all pending claims (0.3); review infringement contentions by Realtime and
`report out to Mr. Hanft and Mr. Gratton (0.6); confer with litigation team re license
`terms and whether they create an additional license defense for the case (0.9)
`
`Billable Hrs
`
`Fees
`795.00
`
`1,192.50
`
`
`2,544.00
`
`1.0
`1.5
`3.2
`
`8.6
`
`
`
`7,095.00
`
`2.7
`2.4
`
`715.50
`
`1,620.00
`
`
`8.2
`
`
`
`5,535.00
`
`1.7
`
`
`
`824.50
`
`0.3
`3.1
`
`0.3
`2.2
`
`160.50
`
`1,658.50
`
`
`351.00
`
`1,749.00
`
`
`1.3
`
`
`
`1,033.50
`
`0.6
`1.4
`
`477.00
`
`1,113.00
`
`
`2.0
`
`
`
`1,590.00
`
`7.7
`
`
`
`6,352.50
`
`2.9
`0.6
`4.1
`
`768.50
`
`
`159.00
`
`2,767.50
`
`4.5
`
`
`
`3,037.50
`
`1.9
`0.2
`6.8
`3.7
`
`921.50
`
`
`107.00
`
`3,638.00
`
`2,941.50
`
`2.1
`
`
`
`1,669.50
`
`1.6
`
`
`
`1,272.00
`
`4.5
`
`
`
`3,712.50
`
`Paralegal
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`
`Identify and compile documents for review and production (1.7)
`
`1.7
`
`
`
`450.50
`
`Exhibit A‐1 Dish Attorney's Fees.xlsx, Detail, 8/13/2021
`
`Page 5
`
`
`
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-2 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 7 of 57
`
`Work Date
`2/5/2021
`
`Tkr Current Elite Title
`Associate
`
`Tkr Name
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Principal
`
`2/6/2021
`
`Paralegal
`Associate
`
`2/7/2021
`
`Principal
`Associate
`
`2/8/2021
`
`Principal
`Associate
`
`Principal
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`Dean, Caitlin
`
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Shartzer, Adam
`
`Afful, Adjoa K.
`Ellis, Michael
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`Tishman, Daniel
`Ellis, Michael
`
`Park, Min Woo
`
`Utreja, Raj
`Utreja, Raj
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`
`Dean, Caitlin
`Mosteller, Matthew
`Cordell, Ruffin B.
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`
`Tishman, Daniel
`Tishman, Daniel
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`Livedalen, Brian J.
`
`Narrative
`Prepare for and confer with ARRIS re RealNetworks re prior art and steps to
`authenticate RealSystem art; confer with internal team re same; send RealNetworks
`publications and evidence to co‐counsel (0.6); queue same for production (0.5);
`fin