throbber
To:
`
`Subject:
`
`Sent:
`Sent As:
`
`James Larsen(jim@larsen-ip.com)
`U.S. Trademark Application Serial No. 97060107 - TRUCKVAULT - 0202-
`0009TUS
`August 30, 2023 12:20:40 PM EDT
`tmng.notices@uspto.gov
`
`Attachments
`
`screencapture-www-thereflector-com-stories-the-big-one-is-southwest-washington-prepared-
`32536-16902931159041(1)
`screencapture-securevehiclesolutions-com-16902933054481(1)
`screencapture-www-freep-com-story-money-cars-2020-06-13-console-vault-hidden-safe-
`vehicles-5344304002-16902936348321(1)
`screencapture-taskandpurpose-com-gear-best-car-gun-safes-16902937964871(1)
`screencapture-www-motorbiscuit-com-consider-a-truck-gun-safe-16902939583771(1)
`screencapture-rocklandcustomproducts-com-truck-gun-safes-16902942422601(1)
`screencapture-accessories-ford-com-products-console-vault-floor-vehicle-safe-1-
`16902943956111(1)
`screencapture-www-concealedcarry-com-training-2-edc-every-day-carry-16902945821601(1)
`screencapture-www-motortrend-com-features-celebrity-drive-dusk-dynasty-star-willie-
`robertson-16902947172251(1)
`screencapture-www-motortrend-com-features-celebrity-drive-dusk-dynasty-star-willie-
`robertson-16902947715351(1)
`screencapture-decked-com-blogs-decked-decked-truck-gun-storage-3460-
`16902950400331(1)
`screencapture-www-michigan-sportsman-com-threads-truck-gun-vault-539609-
`16902952538801(1)
`screencapture-www-retrievertraining-net-threads-advice-on-truck-vault-dog-boxes-other-
`accessories-for-a-yukon-xl-suburban-111382-16902953317211(1)
`screencapture-www-refugeforums-com-threads-homemade-truck-vault-917202-
`16902954024361(1)
`screencapture-www-forbes-com-home-improvement-garage-car-accessories-best-vehicle-
`gun-safes-16902928819601(1)
`screencapture-karkraftautomotive-com-truck-bed-cargo-slides-vaults-16897642003801(1)
`screencapture-danasafetysupply-com-troy-products-cp-gb4430-pb-storage-vault-with-two-
`draw-tight-locking-handles-and-push-button-lock-for-trucks-suvs-16897642499181(1)
`screencapture-danasafetysupply-com-troy-products-cp-gb4430-pb-storage-vault-with-two-
`draw-tight-locking-handles-and-push-button-lock-for-trucks-suvs-16897642499182(1)
`screencapture-www-gunsafes-com-Truck-Vaults-html-16897643714111(1)
`screencapture-www-s-scampers-com-are-16897644712991(1)
`screencapture-www-unitedcommercegroup-com-gunsafes-com-announces-the-availability-of-
`br5930-old-glory-battle-ready-tactical-gun-safe-16897653562141(1)
`screencapture-www-consolevault-com-chevy-console-safes-html-16897658611861(1)
`screencapture-alphaoutdoorspecialties-com-products-dakota-badlands-truck-vault-lite-
`16897659185291(1)
`screencapture-truckvault-com-faq-16897662625521(1)
`
`

`

`screencapture-truckvault-com-post-best-truck-bed-storage-system-period-
`16897663393421(1)
`screencapture-truckvault-com-post-all-weather-all-time-truck-bed-storage-any-conditions-
`16897664031091(1)
`Copy of Global Broadcast Database Article1(1).jpg
`Copy of Global Broadcast Database Article2(1).jpg
`Copy of States News Service Article1(1).jpg
`Copy of States News Service Article2(1).jpg
`Copy of States News Service Article3(1).jpg
`TruckVault Website 1(1).jpg
`TruckVault Website 2(1).jpg
`
`United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)
`Office Action (Official Letter) About Applicant’s Trademark Application
`
`U.S. Application Serial No.  97060107
`
`Mark:   TRUCKVAULT
`
`Correspondence Address:  
`James Larsen
`Larsen IP PLLC
`24207 25th Ave SE
`Bothell WA 98021
`United States
`
`Applicant:   Truckvault, Inc.
`
`Reference/Docket No.  0202-0009TUS
`
`Correspondence Email Address:   jim@larsen-ip.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`SUBSEQUENT FINAL OFFICE ACTION
`
`Issue date:   August 30, 2023
`
`Introduction
`
`In a previous Final Office Action dated November 7, 2022 , the trademark examining attorney refused
`registration of the applied-for mark based on the following:  Trademark Act Section 2(e)(1) for merely
`describing a feature, characteristic, purpose or function of applicant's goods.
`
`On May 4, 2023, Applicant filed a Notice of Appeal before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, and
`on June 13, 2023, applicant filed Applicant's Brief on Appeal from Final Office Action. On July 26,
`2023, the trademark examining attorney filed a Motion to Request Suspension of the Appeal and
`Remand of the Application, on the basis that a new examining attorney has taken over the case and
`wished to supplement the evidence of record. The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board granted the
`
`

`

`request for remand and suspended the appeal.
`
`The  trademark examining attorney maintains the FINAL refusal in the summary of issues
`below.  See  37 C.F.R. §2.63(b); TMEP §714.04. 
`
`Upon submission of this Subsequent Final Office Action, the appeal will be resumed. TBMP §1207.02.
`
`Summary of Issues made FINAL that applicant must address:
`
`Section 2(e)(1) Refusal - Merely Descriptive
`
`Section 2(e)(1) Refusal - Merely Descriptive
`
`Registration is refused because the applied-for mark merely describes  a  feature, characteristic, purpose,
`and/or
`function  of Applicant’s goods.  Trademark Act
`Section
`2(e)(1),
`15 U.S.C.
`§1052(e)(1);  see  TMEP §§1209.01(b), 1209.03  et seq.  This refusal is now made FINAL.
`
` A
`
` mark is merely descriptive if it describes an ingredient, quality, characteristic, function, feature,
`purpose, or use of an applicant’s goods. TMEP §1209.01(b);  see, e.g.,  In re TriVita, Inc., 783 F.3d
`872, 874, 114 USPQ2d 1574, 1575 (Fed. Cir. 2015) (quoting  In re Oppedahl & Larson LLP, 373
`F.3d 1171, 1173, 71 USPQ2d 1370, 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2004));  In re Steelbuilding.com, 415 F.3d 1293,
`1297, 75 USPQ2d 1420, 1421 (Fed. Cir. 2005) (citing  Estate of P.D. Beckwith, Inc. v. Comm’r of
`Patents, 252 U.S. 538, 543 (1920)).
`
`Applicant seeks registration of TRUCKVAULT (standard characters) for “storage vaults specially
`fitted for the cargo areas of cars, trucks, vans and sport utility vehicles” in International Class 012.
`
`Generally, if the individual components of a mark retain their descriptive meaning in relation to the
`goods and/or services, the combination results in a composite mark that is itself descriptive and not
`registrable.  In re Zuma Array Ltd., 2022 USPQ2d 736, at *7 (TTAB 2022); In re Fat Boys Water
`Sports LLC, 118 USPQ2d 1511, 1516 (TTAB 2016); TMEP §1209.03(d); see, e.g., DuoProSS
`Meditech Corp. v. Inviro Med. Devices, Ltd., 695 F.3d 1247, 1255, 103 USPQ2d 1753, 1758 (Fed. Cir.
`2012) (holding SNAP SIMPLY SAFER merely descriptive for various medical devices, such as
`hypodermic, aspiration, and injection needles and syringes); In re Fallon, 2020 USPQ2d 11249, at *12
`(TTAB 2020) (holding THERMAL MATRIX merely descriptive of a heat-responsive, malleable liner
`that is an integral component of an oral dental appliance). 
`
`Only where the combination of descriptive terms creates a unitary mark with a unique, incongruous, or
`otherwise nondescriptive meaning in relation to the goods and/or services is the combined mark
`registrable.  See In re Omniome, Inc., 2020 USPQ2d 3222, at *4 (TTAB 2019) (citing In re Colonial
`Stores, Inc., 394 F.2d 549, 551, 157 USPQ 382, 384 (C.C.P.A. 1968); In re Shutts, 217 USPQ 363,
`364-65 (TTAB 1983)); In re Positec Grp. Ltd., 108 USPQ2d 1161, 1162-63 (TTAB 2013).
`
`In this case, both the individual components and the composite result are descriptive of applicant’s
`goods and/or services and do not create a unique, incongruous, or nondescriptive meaning in relation to
`the goods and/or services.  Specifically, the term VAULT describes applicant's identified goods of
`storage VAULTS, and TRUCK describes a characteristic of the identified goods which are specially
`fitted for the cargo areas of TRUCKS.    See also the previously attached internet evidence defining
`TRUCK as a wheeled vehicle for moving heavy articles, thus describing applicant's cars, trucks, vans
`
`

`

`and sport utility vehicles;  see also the previously  attached internet evidence defining VAULT as a
`compartment for the safekeeping of valuables.  When combined in the mark, the term TRUCKVAULT
`is highly descriptive, if not generic, of the identified goods of    storage vaults specially fitted for the
`cargo areas of cars, trucks, vans and sport utility vehicles.   See also the previously attached third party
`registrations treating VAULT descriptively for vault related goods. 
`
`Notably, applicant utilizes the wording  VAULT descriptively to describe its goods. Applicant explains
`on its website that,  "Following in that tradition, we're still making vaults for nearly every truck on the
`market, including, but certainly not limited to the Ford F-series, Chevrolet Silverado, Dodge Ram, and
`GMC Sierra". See the attached TruckVault webpage. Applicant continues, "And though we now make
`TruckVaults for virtually any vehicle on the road, we're staying true to our name by continuing to build
`custom vaults for our original customers - those with pickup trucks who have expensive gear they need
`to keep safe and secure".  See id. ("After the launch of our popular Extreme Series All-Weather vaults
`for open-bed pickups and SUVs we needed a way to prove how rugged durable and water-tight they
`really were"; "We have a line of quick access gun vaults called ShotLock we make them for Shotguns,
`compact carry and 1911 frame Pistols"; "Can it take the heat? We tracked down a truck-sized oven to
`find out. In an effort to simulate the brutal desert heat inside a vehicle at midday, we tested to see what
`kind of effect 150° Fahrenheit had on our vaults").
`
`Furthermore, the attached evidence demonstrates that the wording "truck vault" is commonly used to
`refer to goods of the type applicant provides. Specifically, it is a compartment used "to securely store
`items in a vehicle" like a truck, and is typically used as "gun storage container".  See the
`attached  Motortrend, The Reflector, United Commerce Group, and  Decked  webpages; see also the
`attached State News Service and Global Broadcast Database articles. Companies that sell these types
`of gun storage containers typically refer to them as "truck vaults" on their webpages.  See  the
`attached  Gun Safes,  S&S Canopies & Campers,  Alpha Outdoor Specialities webpages. Indeed,
`consumers frequently refer to these gun storage containers specifically made to fit inside a truck as
`"truck vaults."  See the attached  Concealed Carry, Michigan Sportsman, Refuge Forums, and  Retriever
`Training webpages.
`
`Lastly, third-parties commonly utilize the wording "vault" to refer to storage containers specifically
`fitted for cargo areas of vehicles, the type of goods applicant provides.  See the attached  Kar
`Kraft,  Dana Safety Supply,  Guardian Safe and Vault,  Console Vault,  Forbes,  Secure Vehicle
`Solutions,  Detroit Free Press,  Task and Purpose,  Motor Biscuit,  Rockland Custom Products,
`and  Ford webpages.
`
`Applicant's Arguments Are Unpersuasive
`
`Applicant's main argument is that marks in applicant's prior registrations and applications that featured
`the same literal element for similar goods did not treat the mark as descriptive.  The examining attorney
`notes that the goods in those registrations and applications were not identified as "storage vaults," as
`they are identified in the current application. As applied to the "storage vaults specially fitted for the
`cargo areas of cars, trucks, vans and sport utility vehicles" identified in the current application, the
`wording TRUCKVAULT is highly descriptive if not generic. Moreover, an applied-for mark that is
`merely descriptive or generic does not become registrable simply because other seemly similar marks
`appear on the register.  In re Consumer Prot. Firm PLLC, 2021 USPQ2d 238, at *22 (citing In re
`Scholastic Testing Serv., Inc., 196 USPQ 517, 519 (TTAB 1977)); TMEP §1209.03(a).  It is well
`settled that each application must be decided on its own facts; the USPTO is not bound by prior
`decisions involving different records.  See In re Boulevard Ent., Inc., 334 F.3d 1336, 1343, 67 USPQ2d
`
`

`

`1475, 1480 (Fed. Cir. 2003) (citing In re Nett Designs, Inc., 236 F.3d at 1342, 57 USPQ2d at 1566); In
`re Datapipe, Inc., 111 USPQ2d 1330, 1336 (TTAB 2014); TMEP §1209.03(a). 
`
`Next, applicant argues that the mark is unitary due to being a compound term.  This argument misses
`the mark, however, as a “telescoped mark,” which consists of two or more words combined to create a
`single word that shares letters, is merely descriptive or generic if the individual words are descriptive or
`generic and if the words retain their descriptive or generic meaning within the telescoped mark.  See In
`re Omaha Nat’l Corp., 819 F.2d 1117, 1118, 2 USPQ2d 1859, 1860 (Fed. Cir. 1987) (holding
`FIRSTIER merely descriptive of banking services);  In re Greenliant Sys. Ltd., 97 USPQ2d 1078, 1083
`(TTAB 2010) (holding NANDRIVE, a telescoped mark of the generic term “nand drive,” generic for
`electronic integrated circuits, including flash memory drives);  TMEP §§1209.01(c)(i), 1209.03(d).
`
`For the foregoing reasons, the mark is descriptive of applicant’s  goods and the refusal to register is
`made final.  See  37 C.F.R. §2.63(b); TMEP §714.04. 
`
`Generic Advisory
`
`In addition to being merely descriptive, the applied-for mark appears to be generic in connection with
`the identified goods and/or services. “A generic mark, being the ‘ultimate in descriptiveness,’ cannot
`acquire distinctiveness” and thus is not entitled to registration on either the Principal or Supplemental
`Register under any circumstances.  In re La. Fish Fry Prods., Ltd., 797 F.3d 1332, 1336, 116 USPQ2d
`1262, 1264 (Fed. Cir. 2015) (quoting  H. Marvin Ginn Corp. v. Int’l Ass’n of Fire Chiefs, Inc., 782 F.2d
`987, 989, 228 USPQ 528, 530 (Fed. Cir. 1986));  see  TMEP §§1209.01(c)  et seq.,  1209.02(a).
`Therefore, the trademark examining attorney cannot recommend that applicant amend the application
`to proceed under Trademark Act Section 2(f) or on the Supplemental Register as possible response
`options to this refusal.  See  TMEP §1209.01(c).
`
`
`/Abigail Sue/
`Abigail Sue
`Examining Attorney
`LO117--LAW OFFICE 117
`(571) 272-9283
`Abigail.Sue@uspto.gov
`
`
`
`RESPONSE GUIDANCE
`
`•
`
`Missing deadline to responding to this letter will cause the application to abandon.  A
`response, appeal, or extension request must be received by the USPTO before 11:59 p.m.
`Eastern Time of the last day of the response deadline. Trademark Electronic Application System
`(TEAS) and Electronic System for Trademark Trials and Appeals (ESTTA) system availability
`could affect an applicant’s ability to timely respond. For help resolving technical issues with
`TEAS, email TEAS@uspto.gov.
`
`•
`
`Responses signed by an unauthorized party are not accepted and can cause the application to
`abandon.  If applicant does not have an attorney, the response must be signed by the individual
`
`

`

`applicant, all joint applicants, or someone with legal authority to bind a juristic applicant.  If
`applicant has an attorney, the response must be signed by the attorney.
`
`•
`
`If needed, find contact information for the supervisor of the office or unit listed in the
`signature block.
`
`

`

`Tuesday, July 25, 2023
`
`Login
`
`Register
`
`AboutUs
`
`NewsroomStaff
`
`Careers
`
`Submit Letters to the Editor
`
`Contact Us
`
`
`
`WINDSORa. The Reflector
`
`Overcast
`Battle Ground
`lhe Newspaper With Integrity Since 1909
`intact
`News ~ Sports+ Life ~ Opinion ~ Obituaries ~ Community Advertising ~ Subscribe~ SendUsNews~ Q
`
`The Big One: Is Southwest
`Washington prepared?
`
`Cascadia earthquake sources
`
`BATTLE
`
`ia
`
`30-50 yr
`
`(1068$908,
`
`Subduction zone
`earthquakes (1700)
`Affected area
`Max.Size
`WMA, OR, CA
`mo
`WWA,OR,
`M7
`
`Source
`@ Subduction Zone
`@ Deep Juan de Fuca plate
`
`Se earthquakes
`
`Recurrence
`500-600yr
`
`

`

`
`
`© Crustal faults
`
`WA, OR, CA
`
`M7+
`
`Hundredsof yr’?
`
`
`
`The Cascadia Subduction Zone and the earthquakes nearthe fault over the years.
`
`Posted Monday, August 26,2019 6:05 am
`
`Cameron Kast/cameron@thereflector.com
`
`
`
`The ReflectorJuly
`26, 2023
`Viewthis issue
`
`Browseotherissues teoar a
`problem
`
`
`Five and a half minutes is about howlong it takes to microwaveapotpie orlisten to Billy Joel’s “Piano Man” once
`through,It’s also howlong the intense shaking from the Cascadia Earthquake — often referred to simply as “The Big
`
`One” — is expected to last
`Death ofOregon woman discovered in
`Rideatcarenink0ober canes
`
`Nearly nine years ago, a magnitude 9 earthquake shook the northeastern corner of Japanforclose to six full minutes.
`The March 11, 2011, earthquake with an epicenter near Tohoku destroyed more than 120,000 buildings and,
`according to Japan’s Reconstruction Agency, caused an estimated $199 billion dollars of damage, making it the most
`expensive natural disaster in world history.
`
`Experts say a similar earthquake is “overdue” and should be expected to hit the Pacific Northwest within the next
`century, if not sooner.
`
`Researchers from regional universities, geotechnical engineers and emergency response agencies expect the
`earthquake to wreak havoc whenithits, bringing about the collapse of roads and bridges and renderingelectricity and
`waterinfrastructure useless,
`
`While some effects from naturaldisasters are unavoidable, experts are growing increasingly concerned about the lack
`of preparation by both governing bodies and individuals.
`
`A ticking subduction zone
`The Pacific Northwestsits on the Cascadia Subduction Zone, whichstretches from the north end of VancouverIsland
`in British Columbia to Cape Mendocino, California, a distance of 620 miles. Cascadia is the meeting pointof the
`smaller Juan de Fucaplate and the large North Americanplate. As the twotectonic plates converge, one is forced
`underthe other.
`
`This causes the oceanic crust of the Pacific Ocean to move underthe continent of North America at a rate of about 40
`millimeters (1 4 inches) per year.
`
`The 2011 earthquake in Japan was dueto this sametype offault line.
`Alison Purch an associate geotechnical engineer at Hart Crowser exnlained that the deener an earthanake is
`
`the
`
`
`
`
`
`rr ca
`
`Introducing
`Extended Stay America
`aumeteord
`
`your car si
`
`MORE LOCAL NEWS
`
`
`
`World WarII re-enactors
`provide ataste oflife at Fort
`Vancouver
`World WarIl reenactors brought
`their own equipment and wore their
`own uniforms to provide a glimpse of what Fort
`Vancouver would have looked like during that time
`period on. Saturdav. Julv 22
`
`

`

`oa
`
`
`longerit causes sha.
`ing at the surface. The creates a muchhigherpotential for damage. A 30-second earthquake
`
`
`usually reaches a 7 or bh
`her on the Richter scale, while a two-minute quake reaches an 8 or higher. By four minutes,
`an earthquake is at 9.0.
`
`Along with depth, seismologists use the size of crustal breaksto indicate how powerful an earthquake could be. The
`1989 LomaPrieta, California, earthquake had a magnitude of6.9, enoughto cause more than $6 billion in damage
`and kill 63 people. LomaPrieta sits on one of the most well-knownandstudiedfault lines in the United States, the
`San Andreas Fault. According to the United States Geological Survey, the San Andreas Fault is capable of producing
`an earthquake nolarger than a magnitude 8.3 dueto its close proximity to both the surface (10 to 12 miles deep) and
`the size of crust that can break during an earthquake on the San Andres.
`
`More than 40 miles belowthe earth’s crust, the Juande Fucaplate is moving under North America and melting into
`the earth. However, around 30 miles down, the North Americanplate is stuck, causing pressure to build up
`underneath the surface of the earth. As the Juan de Fuca plate continues to move, the North Americanplate gets put
`under more pressure. Eventually, the pressure will become too muchandthe North Americanplate will snap upward,
`muchlike a breaking rubberband. Since the Cascadia Subduction Zonesits anywhere from7 to 18 miles deeperthan
`the San Andreas,if the entire plate breaks off, an earthquake largerthan a 9.0 is more thanlikely.
`
`“Geology works ona reallylong time scale, and we’ve been around for an eyelash ofthat really long time scale,”
`Pyrchsaid at “Science on Tap,” a seminar on earthquakes at Kiggins Theatre last month.
`
`Pyrch explained howdueto this larger-than-life timescale developing exact data on where and whenan earthquake
`will happenis not possible.
`
`Pyrchsaid the only way to make a predictionis to look at history. On average, a rupture in the Cascadia Subduction
`Zone happens once every 243 years, putting it around 75 years overdue. A large scale earthquake hasn’t happened
`since January 26, 1700, 76 years before the Declaration of Independence was signed.
`
`Seismologists and geologists are able to determine these estimates by lookingat the limestone of the seafloor and
`comparingit with the highly documented tsunami records of Japan. Before 1700, there was about a 780-year gap
`betweenthe Cascadia earthquakes (920 to January 26, 1700)
`
`According to an Oregon State University research teamled by marine biologist Chris Goldfinger, throughout the past
`10,000 years there have beenat least 41 earthquakes on the Cascadia Fault Zone with 19 being a “full margin
`rupture” where the entire zone snaps.
`
`Goldfingersaid there’s a 33% chance ofthis “megaquake”hitting the Pacific Northwestin the next 50 years.
`
`
`
`
`
`“Perhaps morestriking than the probability numbersis that we can nowsay that we have already gone longer without
`anearthquake than 75%of the knowntimes betweenearthquakesin the last 10,000 years,” Goldfingersaid in a
`statement earlier this summer. “And 50 years from now, that numberwill rise to 85 percent.”
`What a quakewill look like
`
`
`
`
`
`Werner citeoar
`to STAY awhile.
`
`Transportation crews!
`onInterstate 5 and |
`nighttime work will hq
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`until the 2060s
`Oneof the largest sources of
`funding to replace the aging
`Interstate 5 bridge over the
`Columbia Riverwill tax travelers a few bucks as they
`cross the water. During its meeting July 18, the ...
`
`
`
`) Death of Oregon woman
`discoveredin Ridgefield not
`currentlylinked to other
`cases
`The death of 32-year-old Joanna
`Speaks, of Oregon, hasn't been connected to the deaths
`of four other area women where the Multnomah County
`District Attorney's Office found links, the ...
`
`
`
`
`apartment complex o
`seeking a propertytal
`city leadersstill have
`plan ...
`
`More Local News >
`
`we give YOu me"
`Pears ).*
`
`ioZe
`
`OBITUARIES
`
`

`

` Death notices, July 26, 2023
`Lf]
`
`‘WhateveryourPen
`
`“for being away from home
`
`:
`
`Carol Maurits, $0, ofVancouver, passed awayon July 18, 2023, in Vancouver, The
`funeral homeis NorthwoodParkFuneral Home & Cemetery, 360-574-4252, Susan
`Chenette, 69, of
`
`More obituaries >
`
`8101 NE ParkwayDr. « 360-253-5771
`(Located nearOlive Garden andT] Maxx)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Pyrehsays the Pacific Northwestis not at all prepared for an earthquake of this magnitude.Sheratescities suchas
`Portland at a 2.5 to 3 ona scale of 10 in termsof preparedness.
`
`“Ourbiggest lack is public education and public preparedness,” she said.
`
`Pyrch says populations around the world that are accustomed to a lack ofelectricity and waterare significantly more
`prepared for a disaster such as an earthquake.
`
`Pyrch offered Mexico and Japan as examples of countries well prepared in 2019. Both countries have earthquake
`early warning systems and a large culture built around the idea that a quake could hit at any moment.
`
`“Tf people are prepared for an event and they knowit’s going to happen and they are educated, they are significantly
`better whenit comes to handling an event,” she said. “As it is, we are not prepared simply because oursociety will
`not be bouncing back as quickly because we depend onall thoseutilities.”
`
`Pyrch’s second problem with preparednessin the regionis infrastructure. If the “Big One” wereto hit this year, she
`believes most of the transportation hubs — land, sea and air — would all be compromised. Alongwiththis, she
`mentionedthat there will be significant landslide damageas well as the explosionof natural gas andliquid fuel lines
`and ruptured waterpipes.
`
`Liquid fuel in Southwest Washingtonis refined in the Seattle-Tacomaarea andis transported througha pipeline that
`is “not seismically sound,”* Pyrch said. She added that fuel for the area is stored near the Willamette River where
`there is an expected movementof 25 feet. The spread offire is also a major concern given that many ofthe water
`lines will likely break, Pyrchsaid.
`
`Pyrch noted howmostofthe electricity in the area is supplied by the Bonneville Power Administration.If its power
`and energy networkfalls due to an earthquake, powerinthe area is expected to go out for anindefinite period of
`time.
`
`“Weare spoiled and we expect everything to work on demand,”she said. “Oursociety does not function without
`running water, electricity and our cellphones and communication networks working.”
`
`In her seminar, Pyrchsaid soils in the Pacific Northwest are subjectto liquefaction, the process ofsoils with a large
`water content losing strength due to a strongly applied force suchas an earthquake. Under this force, sand and mud
`sink into the ground causing the buildings and structures on top of themto follow. Pyrchsaid soil underneathlarge
`economic hubssuchas the Interstate 5 Bridge, the Glenn Jackson Bridge and the Portland International Airportallsit
`onliquefiable soil.
`
`Pyrch expanded on liquefaction damagein a followup interview,explaining that the I-5 Bridgeis “pretty muchtoast”
`ifa large earthquake wereto hit, but the bridge across 1-205 might be salvageable.
`
`“From what I understand there is a chance that it will be repairable,” Pyrchsaid about 1-205, adding that while it
`
`

`

`might be repairable, it will not be a structure people are goingto be able to drive over immediately.
`
`The destructionof these bridges and economic trade hubs suchas the Port of Portland and Portland International
`Airport (PDX) is expected to dramatically impact the surrounding area’s economy.
`
`“Oneofthe points of the (2011) Japan earthquake wasthat their economy took a big hit. In fact, the world economy
`took a big hit,” Pyrch said while explaining that one of the reasonsthe area needsto get ready for an earthquakeis the
`fact that not everybody is going to die in the initial shock ofthe quake. Most people will survive, and building
`infrastructure for that survival period is key to withstanding the earthquake, she said.
`
`Preparing
`
`
`
`Timothy “T.J.” Miller, of Battle Ground, has a degree in powersystems and works for BPA. He echoed Pyrch’s
`statements while pointing to the solar panels and generators he has installed in his earthquake-proof shop.
`
`“The irony ofit is that I work for the power grid and yet I have solar and a generator because I knowthe grid is going
`down,”he said.
`
`Miller has spent nearly his whole life preparing for disaster to strike.
`
`“T don’t really know what made me wantto be a survivalist other than the fact that I have five sisters and my mom
`always said, ‘you're the manofthe house, you’re going to have to protect yoursisters,” he said. “I grewup infear
`that I wouldn't be able to protect (them). It’s an overcompensated thing about me and I can’t help it.”
`
`
`
`
`Miller built a shop on his property for his business, Silenced
`Weapons. The shop doublesas his survival shelter, and he said
`it is structurally sound and can withstand an earthquake.
`
`“This shop is built better than any of the houses aroundhere,”
`he said. “The inspector said if we were to have the subduction
`zone earthquake, all the houses (nearby) would be gone and
`this shop wouldstill be here.”
`
`Millerbelieves a lack of food, water and shelter will be the
`biggest problems facing citizens in the Clark County area if
`disaster were to strike. He suggests bolting downeverything in
`houses and shops and having enough food and waterto sustain
`yourself and dependents.
`
`
`
`Government to pay Camp Lejeune victims
`$21 billion
`CampLejeune Water Claims
`
`“Water, water, water,” Miller said when asked about what he
`.
`we
`I
`feels is the most important thing people cando to prepare.
` Miller
`shop is equipped with a two-yearsupply of food and
`@ranenrad | inke hu Tahania
`Abel fs
`eames
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`Vierewres Ginn wy ren WELEL LUL MILE UU LS WILE, OULUE UL 1s CYUpLLct LuLLUUES a
`sun oven, more than 10,000 gallons of fresh water and a
`systemto brewhis ownbeer.
`
`“Somepeoplesayit’s not a key part ofpreparedness, but I thinkit is,” Miller said as he opened a doorin the back of
`his shop revealing a home brewery where he makes India Pale Ale.
`
`Also in Miller’s shop is an old ambulance from the Los Angeles Police Departmentthat he is renovating to be a
`disaster vehicle complete with a few days worth of food, a fire ax and a truck vault, something he builds to securely
`store items in a vehicle. Also equipped with a truck vault is Miller’s Jeep Wrangler, which has everything from a
`snorkeling systemto an air compressor.
`
`“Tt’s got everything I think people should haveontheircarin case of a disaster,” Miller said before pulling out the
`truck vault containing a flare gun, hiking equipment and enoughfood and waterto survive for a week. Miller said a
`lot of the ideas for his Jeep cameafter he experienced the 1989 LomaPrieta earthquake andrealized howunprepared
`peoplein the area were.
`
`“The only thing that madeit outof the city were the 4-by-4’s,” Miller said.
`
`While Miller and his wife may be prepared if the Cascadia Subduction Earthquake were to strike, a good majority of
`the Clark County and the Portland Metro Area has notstarted preparing. Pyrchbelieves this lack of preparedness can
`be changed by working togetherto build an“earthquakeculture.”
`
`While Miller may have a two-yearsupply of food, Savannah Brehmerof the Federal Emergency Management
`Agency (FEMA)recommends having a minimum of 72 hours, but encourages a supply of up to two weeksoffood,
`water and necessary medicine.
`
`“We also recommend people knowtheir community because if you knowthemin advance,it’s going to help out in
`terms of sharing resources,” Brehmersaid. “Resources may be spread thinin the event of an earthquake.”
`
`FEMA's website outlines a three-step plancitizens should have to prepare themselves fordisaster. First, protect
`yourself before an earthquake. To do this, FEMA recommends practicing what to do during in an earthquake,
`gathering critical documents and building a preparednesskit that lasts at least three days. Second, protect yourself
`during anearthquake and drop, cover and hold on.Lastly, protect yourself after an earthquake by monitoring local
`newsreports, exiting damaged buildings and staying away from damaged areas. If your home has been damagedafter
`a disaster or is no longer safe and you need a place to stay, text SHELTER and your ZIP code to 43362to find the
`nearest public shelter in the area.
`
`Pyrch recommends doing everything possible to secure your home, suchas strappingit to the foundation and
`knowing howto turn off the gas and waterlines leading to your home. “Make sure your homeis safe and somewhere
`youcanbe for two to four weeks without help,” Pyrchsaid. Along withthis, he recommends building emergencylists
`and getting what you need wheneveryou're at the grocery store.
`“Tf van have an evtra five bueke oat that extra callan of water * che caid
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`Eric Frank, the Public Information Officer of the Clark Regional Emergency Services Agency (CRESA),
`recommends doingall of the above and repeating it for your workplace and your vehicle, mentioning hownot
`everyone will be at home whendisasterstrikes.
`
`“T want to make sure I have whateverI need no matter where I am whendisasterstrikes,” he said. “Thoseare the
`messages we spread constantly.”
`
`Building an ‘Earthquake Culture’
`
`During “Science on Tap”and in subsequentinterviews, Pyrchstressed the importance of building a culture around
`preparedness for earthquakes. This culture, dubbed “earthquake culture.” revolves around education about
`earthquakes and the substantial followup damagethey will cause.
`
`“Educate yourself and your neighbors because until we are educated about the problem, we
`
`are not going to make any progress,” Pyrch said. “Untilit is a priority within oursociety and in our communities to
`be ready to handle a large earthquake, we are not goingto be ready.”
`
`To discuss this “earthquake culture” Pyrch uses the example of other countries such as Japan and Mexico around the
`Pacific Ring of Fire that she believes are preparedif disaster were to strike tomorrow. She mentionedactivities such
`occasionalstatewide earthquakedrills.
`
`“They can evacuate a building in under two minutes,” Pyrchexplained.
`
`She later used the exampleofa fire drill at a public high school to show howunprepared the United Statesis in terms
`of a disaster.
`
`“Doadults makeit out in two minutes?”she asked.
`
`Pyrchpressed the need for educating yourself, your family and yourneighbors about the importance ofpreparing for
`an earthquake, something C

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket