throbber
To:
`
`Subject:
`
`Sent:
`Sent As:
`
`MILTON SPRINGUT(trademarks@mosessinger.com)
`U.S. Trademark Application Serial No. 97037743 - PLANTS WITH
`BENEFITS - 020075-0202
`September 12, 2023 02:04:08 PM EDT
`tmng.notices@uspto.gov
`
`Attachments
`
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-product-fresh-water-greens-living-basil-plant-
`with-roots-b07z5pwbbd-16944863273541
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-search-16944864183271
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-search-16944865664171
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-search-16944866101711
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-search-16944866829511
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-product-produce-organic-oregano-b079jy4syg-
`16944867098291
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmagazine-com-articles-3724-immunity-inside-and-out-
`16944869875341
`screencapture-www-kroger-com-pl-fresh-herbs-06122-16944872212371
`screencapture-www-kroger-com-search-16944872547881
`screencapture-www-kroger-com-search-16944873035871
`screencapture-msutoday-msu-edu-news-2021-cbd-marijuana-and-hemp-16944874769411
`screencapture-www-kroger-com-p-plant-therapy-set-of-6-diffusible-10ml-essential-oils-
`blends-1-3-oz-wellness-0068091201083-16945367648801
`screencapture-medlineplus-gov-herbalmedicine-html-16945375460811
`screencapture-www-nbcnews-com-better-health-health-benefits-fresh-herbs-how-eat-them-
`ncna901706-16945376251591
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-departments-365-products-16945376961441
`screencapture-www-amazon-com-s-16945377648271
`screencapture-www-kroger-com-b-ourbrands-16945378054441
`screencapture-www-wholefoodsmarket-com-search-16945381437071
`screencapture-www-bachremedies-com-en-us-about-16945397949401
`screencapture-www-cbsnews-com-baltimore-news-wjz-tours-marylands-largest-cannabis-
`farm-ahead-of-legalization-of-recreational-sales-weed-md-16945409705971
`screencapture-mjbizdaily-com-aurora-cannabis-buying-vegetable-grower-for-ca45-million-
`sells-sky-greenhouse-16945410665901
`screencapture-www-actahort-org-books-1263-1263_37-htm-16945413645991
`
`United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)
`Office Action (Official Letter) About Applicant’s Trademark Application
`
`U.S. Application Serial No.  97037743
`
`Mark:   PLANTS WITH BENEFITS
`
`Correspondence Address:  
`Milton Springut
`MOSES & SINGER LLP
`405 LEXINGTON AVENUE
`
`

`

`THE CHRYSLER BUILDING
`NEW YORK NY 10174
`United States
`
`Applicant:   Costa Farms, LLC
`
`Reference/Docket No.  020075-0202
`
`Correspondence Email Address:   trademarks@mosessinger.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION AFTER FINAL ACTION DENIED
`
`Issue date:   September 12, 2023
`
`Applicant’s request for reconsideration is denied.   See 37 C.F.R. §2.63(b)(3).  The trademark
`examining attorney has carefully reviewed applicant’s request and determined the request did not:  (1)
`raise a new issue, (2) resolve all the outstanding issue(s), (3) provide any new or compelling evidence
`with regard to the outstanding issue(s), or (4) present analysis and arguments that were persuasive or
`shed new light on the outstanding issue(s).  TMEP §§715.03(a)(ii)(B), 715.04(a).  
`
`Accordingly, theTrademark Act Section 2(d) Refusalmade final in the Office action dated February 8,
`2023 is  maintained and continued.  See TMEP §§715.03(a)(ii)(B), 715.04(a).  
`
`Applicant has submitted the declarations of two employees in support of the arguments that, while the
`marks are similar, the goods and services are distinct, the trade channels differ, and consumers are not
`likely to view the goods and services as emanating from the same source. While carefully considered,
`the arguments have been found to be unpersuasive. 
`
`In support of its arguments, applicant states that wellness information and related products are not
`generally associated with live plants and flowers, and further, that CBD and its association with
`cannabis distinguishes it from ornamental flowers and plants. This argument is unpersuasive because
`the evidence of record shows that cannabis can be considered an ornamental flower, and many
`ornamental flower growers also grow live plants and flowers. 
`
`Moreover, "live plants" include live oregano, thyme, rosemary, and other plants sold in grocery stores
`alongside CBD. The attached evidence from Whole Foods and other sites discusses the value of live
`plants and other plant-based products in maintaining wellness. 
`
`The assertions made in the declarations submitted by applicant do not refute the evidence of record. T
`herefore, applicant's arguments are unpersuasive.
`
`If applicant has already filed an appeal with the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, the Board will
`be notified to resume the appeal.   See TMEP §715.04(a).  
`
`If applicant has not filed an appeal and time remains in the response period for the final Office
`action, applicant has the remainder of that time to (1) file another request for reconsideration that
`complies with and/or overcomes any outstanding final requirement(s) and/or refusal(s), and/or (2) file a
`
`

`

`notice of appeal to the Board.  TMEP §715.03(a)(ii)(B).
`
`
`/Shaila Settles Lewis/
`Shaila Settles Lewis
`Examining Attorney
`LO114--LAW OFFICE 114
`(571) 270-1527
`Shaila.SettlesLewis@USPTO.GOV
`
`
`
`

`

`PS
`er
`
`WHOLE FOODS Finda StorePQserch Ea era eeBrowse Products OrderOnline Recipes WeeklySales
`Sign in with your Amazon accountto build
`x
`your shopping list
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Home / Products / Produce / Fresh Vegetables / Living Basil Plant With Roots
`
`
`
`Fresh Water Greens
`
`
`
`
`cee
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Living Basil Plant With Roots
`Find a store to see pricing
`Use current location
` y or
`(US stores
`state
`To add this product to yourlist, login.
`
`only
`
`Q |
`
`Addtolist
`
`INGREDIENTS
`
`Basil
`
`NUTRITION FACTS
`
`oe 660 0
`Dairy-Free
`Engine 2
`Paleo-
`Sugar
`Vegan
`Vegetarian
`Friendly
`Conscious
`
`.
`”) @
`Whole Foods Keto-Friendly
`Diet
`
`Prices and availability are subject to change without notice. Offers are specific to store listed
`above andlimitedto in-store. Promotions, discounts, andoffers availablein stores may not be
`available for online orders. The information provided on this website, including special diets
`and nutritionalinformation,is for reference purposesandnot intended as medicalor healthcare
`information or advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or
`different information than shown on our website. You should notrely solely on the information
`presented here and youshould always read labels, warnings, and directions before using or
`consuming a product. The information provided on this website should not be relied upon to
`make health-related decisions,
`
`

`

`Legal Corporate Policies
`
`Shopping
`Myer
`Cremertard
`Delivery and Pickup [7
`Meals and Catering
`Eate!
`certa}
`Screed
`Poeuneed
`Coe
`
`Need Help?
`MeeClmeiad
`
`(Caanmer
`
`ST Cit
`
`Product Data By
`§ pinto
`elnformation
`
`WESCUpweCae CU
`
`Peeserties]
`Quality Standards
`Community Giving
`Cuesarrat)
`
`Ls
`PA UtRees
`pea
`pera
`EMCURTie
`‘Careers
`ETc)
`
`‘Copyright 2023 Whole Foods Marke!
`
`Cod el COLOaEAeeLeeeMece PC CLUES)
`ETUCCreeLng
`
`

`

`Find a store >
`
`De | an
`
`Home / Products / All Search Results
`
`Browse Products
`Find a store
`
` (US stores
`
`ot
`
`Use currentlocation
`
`Q
`
`
`
`Sort
`Relevance
`
`bd
`
`
`
`Seeall products
`
`Category
`
`All Search Results
`Produce
`Prepared Foods
`Pantry Essentials
`Breads,Rolls & Bakery
`Body Care
`Frozen Foods
`Showall +
`
`Filters
`
`Featured
`[[] 365 by Whole Foods
`Market
`
`Dietary Preference
`LJ
`“ag
`(1)Gluten-Free
`(DF) keto-Friendly
`[J vegetarian
`[FJ organic
`
`
`
`
`
`Brami
`Rosemary
`La Panzanella
`Kenter Canyon Farms
`
`
`
`Croceantini Rosemary Crisps, 4.5 ozOrganic Rosemary Garlic & Rosemary (150g), 5,3 oz
`Addtolist Addtolist Addtolist | Addtolist |
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`rina
`seats
`-
`
`vine
`
`
`
`
`
`flackers'
`
`€
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Dairy-Free
`Sugar-Censcious
`Paleo-Friendly
`Whole FoodsDiet
`Kosher
`Low-Fat
`Engine 2
`
`Doctorin the Kitchen
`Firehook
`JENNIFERS HOMEMADE
`365 Everyday Value®
`Rosemary Salt Crackers, 5.5 oz
`Rosemary, 0.56 ounce
`
`Rosemary Breadsticks, 5 oz Organic Rosemary Flackers, 5 oz
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`
`Wantdelivery and
`pickup?
`Orderonline [4
`
`Planning an event?
`Shop catering &
`entertaining
`
`Need help?
`See our FAG's
`
`
`
`Rosemary
`
`
`mies
`
`satan
`
`Ye
`
`is
`
`
`
`Carr's
`Simply Organic
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Rosemary Crackers, 5 oz
`
`
`Organic Rosemary, 1 eachRosemaryEssential Oil, 1 each Seasoning, Rosemary, 0.46 oz
`
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`Tarai
`
`
`
`Gas
`
`AVALON ORGANICS
`Rosemary Conditioner, 1102
`
`Morton & Bassett
`Organic Rosemary,0.8 oz
`
`Lark Ellen Farm
`Almond Pate - Lemon Rosemary,
`soz
`
`Whole Foods Market
`Lemon Rosemary ChickenBreast
`
`Addtolist
`
`Add to list
`
`Addto list
`
`Addtolist
`
`|“a=ewy
`
`m |vs
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Weleda
`Whole Foods Market
`Mary's Gone Crackers
`Rosemary
`Rosemary Hair Oil, 1 each
`Sea Salt & Rosemary Crostini, 6
`Organic Superseed Rosemary
`Raisin Pecan Crackers, 5.3 oz
`oz
`Cracker, 5 oz
`
`Add tolist
`
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`HAND IN HAND.
`AURA CACIA
`AURA CACIA
`Nancy's Fancy
`Salted Caramel Swirl
`Rosemary Essential Oil, 2 fi oz
`Rosemary Essential Oil, 0.5 fi oz
`Rosemary Lemon Hand Soap,10
`Butterscotch Budino, 1 each
`floz
`
`
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`
`
`
`
`
`Back to Nature
`Kreyol Essence
`PACIFICA
`Wasa
`OF
`Organic Rosemary & Olive
`Rosemary Mint Haitian Black
`Rosemary Purify Clarifying
`Thins Rosemary & SeaSalt, 6.7
`ounce
`Crackers, 6 oz
`Castor Gil, 2 oz
`Shampoo, 12 H oz
`
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Addto list
`|
`Addtolist
`
`a
`=
`
`=
`Ea
`CRUNCHMASTER:
`Nntia A
`
`
`
`

`

`SS
`
`
`
`PACIFICA
`Whole Foods Market
`Crunchmaster
`Simple Mills
` eed
`Family Size Rosemary Almond
`Organic Rosemary Sourdough
`Rosemary & Olive Oil Multi:
`Scalp Love Rosemary Mint
`
`
`Bread, 24 ozSerum, 2 fi oz Flour Crackers, 7 oz
`Crackers, 3.54 oz
`Add tolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`
`‘au
`,
`
`Zi
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mary's Gone Crackers
`Organic Real Thin Garlic
`Rosemary Crackers, § oz
`Addtolist
`
`ALA MAISON
`Rosemary MintLiquid Soap, 16.9
`floz
`
`Addtolist
`
`Rustic Bakery
`Organic RosemaryOlive Oil
`Flatbrd Bites, 4 oz
`Addto list
`
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Volume &Thick Shampoo
`Rosemary Mint, 32 fl oz
`Add tolist
`
`oe3Ea
`
`Ci
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mitica
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Valencia Almonds With
`Volume &Thick Conditioner
`Volume & Thick Conditioner
`Volume &Thick Shampoo
`Rosemary, 4 oz
`Rosemary Mint, 16 fl oz
`Rosemary Mint, 32 fl oz
`Rosemary Mint,16 f oz
`Addto list
`Add tolist
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`
`|
`Addto list
`
`

`

`SinMails
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Back to Nature
`California Olive Ranch
`Simple Mills
`PopArt Snacks
`Almond Flour Crackers,
`Rosemary Truffle Popcorn,4 oz
`Rosemary & Olive Oil Har
`Roasted Garlic, Dijon & Rosemary
`Whole Wheat Cracker, 8.5 oz
`Marinade & Sauce, 10 fi oz
`Rosemary & SeaSalt, 4.25 oz
`Add tolist
`Add tolist
`
`Addto list
`
`|
`
`|
`
`Add tolist
`
`@
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mitica
`AVALON ORGANICS
`Alexia Foods
`Culture Pop Soda
`Rosemary Toketti Di Pane
`Avalon Organics® Volumizing
`Watermelon Lime & Rosemary
`Crispy RosemaryFries, 16 oz
`Carasau Crackers,7 oz
`Rosemary Shampoo,11 fi oz
`Sparkling Soda 4pk, 12 fl oz
`
`Add tolist
`Add tolist
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`|
`Addto list
`
`sis 8 |
`WOWOvEHA
`
`|
`
`Brew Dr. Kombucha
`Clear Mind Kombucha- Green
`Tea with Rosemaryand Mint, 4pk
`120z Cans
`
`Add tolist
`
`

`

`MoreResults
`The below productsare also sold in store.
`
`Mrs Meyer's
`RosemaryLiquid Dish Soap
`
`AURA CACIA
`Whole Foods Market
`Organic RosemaryEssential
`Lemon Rosemary Chicken
`Breast
`oil
`
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`
`PACIFICA
`Rosemary Detox Scalp Scrub
`
`Back To Nature
`Rosemary Garlic Dipper Crisps
`
`Whole Foods Market
`PATAGONIA PROVISIONS
`LemonRosemary Chicken
`Organic Rosemary Garlic
`‘Crackers
`Family Meal
`
`
`Add tolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Add to list
`|
`|
`Add tolist
`
`RAINCOASTCRISPS
`RosemaryRaisin Almond Crisp
`
`Simply Organic
`Borsari
`Organic Citrus Rosemary
`Tuscan Rosemary Sage
`Seasoning Salt
`Finishing Salt
`
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Prices andavailability are subject to change withoutnotice. Offers are specific to store listed above and limited to in-store. Promotions,discounts, and offers available in stores may
`notbe available foronline orders. The information provided onthis website, including special diets and nutritional information, is for reference purposesandnot intended as medical
`or healthcare informationor advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different informationthan shownonour website. You should notrely solely on
`the information presented here and you should always read labels, warnings,and directions before using or consuming a product. The information provided on this website should
`not be relied upon to make health-related decisions.
`
`
`
`

`

`Coesetts}
`eeu
`eeACH]
`Environmental Stewardship
`
`PAeetCy
`OurValues
`prtid
`CCesl)ey
`Careers
`
`Meserry
`Cree etat
`Drea atseel
`Meals and Catering
`Per ea iBarred
`Cakeaa
`Cees
`s and Ideas
`
`Teele)
`
`

`

`Find a store >
`
`De | an
`
`Home / Products / All Search Results
`
`Browse Products
`Find a store
`
` (US stores
`
`ot
`
`Use currentlocation
`
`Q
`
`
`
`Sort
`Relevance
`
`bd
`
`
`
`Seeall products
`
`Category
`
`All Search Results
`Produce
`Prepared Foods
`Pantry Essentials
`Breads,Rolls & Bakery
`Body Care
`Frozen Foods
`Showall +
`
`Filters
`
`Featured
`[[] 365 by Whole Foods
`Market
`
`Dietary Preference
`LJ
`“ag
`(1)Gluten-Free
`(DF) keto-Friendly
`[J vegetarian
`[FJ organic
`
`
`
`
`
`Brami
`Rosemary
`La Panzanella
`Kenter Canyon Farms
`
`
`
`Croceantini Rosemary Crisps, 4.5 ozOrganic Rosemary Garlic & Rosemary (150g), 5,3 oz
`Addtolist Addtolist Addtolist | Addtolist |
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`rina
`seats
`-
`
`vine
`
`
`
`
`
`flackers'
`
`€
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Dairy-Free
`Sugar-Censcious
`Paleo-Friendly
`Whole FoodsDiet
`Kosher
`Low-Fat
`Engine 2
`
`Doctorin the Kitchen
`Firehook
`JENNIFERS HOMEMADE
`365 Everyday Value®
`Rosemary Salt Crackers, 5.5 oz
`Rosemary, 0.56 ounce
`
`Rosemary Breadsticks, 5 oz Organic Rosemary Flackers, 5 oz
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`
`Wantdelivery and
`pickup?
`Orderonline [4
`
`Planning an event?
`Shop catering &
`entertaining
`
`Need help?
`See our FAG's
`
`
`
`Rosemary
`
`
`mies
`
`satan
`
`Ye
`
`is
`
`
`
`Carr's
`Simply Organic
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Rosemary Crackers, 5 oz
`
`
`Organic Rosemary, 1 eachRosemaryEssential Oil, 1 each Seasoning, Rosemary,0.
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`Tarai
`
`
`
`Gas
`
`AVALON ORGANICS
`Rosemary Conditioner, 1102
`
`Morton & Bassett
`Organic Rosemary,0.8 oz
`
`Lark Ellen Farm
`Almond Pate - Lemon Rosemary,
`soz
`
`Whole Foods Market
`Lemon Rosemary ChickenBreast
`
`Addtolist
`
`Add to list
`
`Addto list
`
`Addtolist
`
`|“a=ewy
`
`m |vs
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Weleda
`Whole Foods Market
`Mary's Gone Crackers
`Rosemary
`Rosemary Hair Oil, 1 each
`Sea Salt & Rosemary Crostini, 6
`Organic Superseed Rosemary
`Raisin Pecan Crackers, 5.3 oz
`oz
`Cracker, 5 oz
`
`Add tolist
`
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`HAND IN HAND.
`AURA CACIA
`AURA CACIA
`Nancy's Fancy
`Salted Caramel Swirl
`Rosemary Essential Oil, 2 fi oz
`Rosemary Essential Oil, 0.5 fi oz
`Rosemary Lemon Hand Soap,10
`Butterscotch Budino, 1 each
`floz
`
`
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`
`
`
`
`
`Back to Nature
`Kreyol Essence
`PACIFICA
`Wasa
`Organic Rosemary & Olive Oil
`Rosemary Mint Haitian Black
`Rosemary Purify Clarifying
`Thins Rosemary & SeaSalt, 6.7
`ounce
`Crackers, 6 oz
`Castor Gil, 2 oz
`Shampoo, 12 H oz
`
`Add tolist
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Addto list
`|
`Addtolist
`
`a
`=
`
`=
`Ea
`CRUNCHMASTER:
`Nntia A
`
`
`
`

`

`SS
`
`
`
`Whole Foods Market
`Crunchmaster
`PACIFICA
`Simple Mills
` eed
`Family Size Rosemary Almond
`Organic Rosemary Sourdough
`Rosemary & Olive Oil Multi:
`Scalp Love Rosemary Mint
`
`
`Bread, 24 ozSerum, 2 fi oz Flour Crackers, 7 oz
`Crackers, 3.54 oz
`Add tolist
`Addtolist
`Addto list
`Addtolist
`
`‘au
`e
`
`Zu
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mary's Gone Crackers
`Organic Real Thin Garlic
`Rosemary Crackers, § oz
`Addtolist
`
`ALA MAISON
`Rosemary MintLiquid Soap, 16.9
`floz
`
`Add to list
`
`Rustic Bakery
`Organic RosemaryOlive Oil
`Flatbrd Bites, 4 oz
`Addto list
`
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Volume &Thick Shampoo
`Rosemary Mint, 32 fl oz
`Addto list
`
`am3EZi
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mitica
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Valencia Almonds With
`Volume &Thick Conditioner
`Volume & Thick Conditioner
`Volume &Thick Shampoo
`Rosemary, 4 oz
`Rosemary Mint,16 f{ oz
`Rosemary Mint, 32 fl oz
`Rosemary Mint, 16 fl oz
`Addto list
`Add tolist
`
`
`
`|
`Addto list
`|
`|
`Addtolist
`
`

`

`al
`AS
`TRUFFLE
`
` 10\
`
`os
`
`Back to Nature
`California Olive Ranch
`Simple Mills
`Pop Art Snacks
`Rosemary Truffle Popcorn, 4 oz
`AlmondFlour Crackers,
`Roasted Garlic, Dijon & Rosemary
`Rosemary & Olive Oil Harvest
`
` Rosemary & SeaSalt, 4.25 oz Marinade & Sauce, 10 fi oz Whole WheatCracker, 8.5
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Add tolist
`
`@
`
`
`
`AVALON ORGANICS
`Mitica
`Culture Pop Soda
`Alexia Foods
`Crispy RosemaryFries, 16 oz
`Watermelon Lime & Rosemary
`Rosemary Toketti Di Pane
`Avalon Organics® Volumizing
`Sparkling Soda 4pk, 12 fl oz
`Carasau Crackers,7 oz
`Rosemary Shampoo,11 fl oz
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`|
`Addto list
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`Brew Dr. Kombucha
`Clear Mind Kombucha- Green
`Tea with Rosemary and Mint, 4pk
`120z Cans
`
`Addtolist
`
`

`

`MoreResults
`The below productsare also sold in store.
`
`Mrs Meyer's
`Rosemary Liquid Dish Soap
`
`AURA CACIA
`Whole Foods Market
`Organic RosemaryEssential
`Lemon Rosemary Chicken
`oil
`Breast
`
`Addtolist Addtolist Addtolist
`
`
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`PACIFICA
`Rosemary Detox Scalp Scrub
`
`Back To Nature
`Rosemary Garlic Dipper Crisps
`
`Whole Foods Market
`PATAGONIA PROVISIONS
`LemonRosemary Chicken
`Organic Rosemary Garlic
`‘Crackers
`Family Meal
`
`
`
`Add to listAddtolist Add tolist
`Add tolist
`|
`|
`
`RAINCOAST CRISPS
`RosemaryRaisin Almond Crisp
`
`Borsari
`Simply Organic
`Tuscan Rosemary Sage
`Organic Citrus Rosemary
`Finishing Salt
`Seasoning Salt
`
`
`Addtolist Addtolist
`
`
`
` ited to in-store. Promotions, discounts, andoffers available in stores may
`Prices andavailability are subject to change withoutnotice. Offers are specific to store listed above and lin
`notbe available foronline orders. The information provided onthis website, including special diets and nutritional information, is for reference purposesandnot intended as medical
`or healthcare informationor advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different informationthan shownonour website. You should notrely solely on
`the information presented here and you should always read labels, warnings,and directions before using or consuming a product. The information provided on this website should
`not be relied upon to make health-related decisions.
`
`
`
`

`

`Weekly Sales
`Peweettacy
`Delivery and Pickup [7
`Neeeee kencut
`Cease
`Cakeai
`Ceeeinned
`s and Ideas
`
`eu} reer) enc sccd
`
`ReleeLe ed
`
`(Cosel)
`
`iy om)
`
`| PUReurl
`feel en
`
`|
`
`§ pinto
`
`Ceesetts]
`eeeui
`eeACI]
`CUEShacd
`
`PCARees
`OurValues
`prtid
`CCcesfs)iey
`Careers
`ETcolo)
`
`‘Copyright 2023 Whole Foods Market
`
`IP, Inc.
`
`odleMOUutaol 7
`an amazon company
`
`econ eT YLT)
`
`

`

`Find a store >
`
`Browse Products
`
`Order Online
`
`Recipes WeeklySales
`
`Finda Store
`
`Res
`WHOLE FOODS
`
`Home/ Products / All Search Results
`
`Browse Products
`
`Find a store f Use current location
`a
`
`
`Seeall products
`
`Category
`
`2 results for "fresh thyme"
`
`
`
`Sort
`Relevance
`
`w
`
`Filters Dietary Preference
` Engine 2
`
`All Search Results
`Produce
`Snacks, Chips, Salsas &
`Dips
`
`Vegan
`
`Keto-Friendly
`=
`|_] Vegetarian
`[_] organic
`—
`[_] Dairy-Free
`
`Sugar-Conscious
`Paleo-Friendly
`Whole FoodsDiet
`
`
`
`|
`‘Wantdelivery and
`pickup?
`Orderonline [4
`
`PRODUCE
`Fresh 'n Nova
`
`Organic Thyme
`Gourmet HummesThyme, 8 oz
`
`Addtolist
`|
`|
`Add tolist
`
`Prices and availability are subject to change withoutnotice. Offers are specific to store listed above andlimited to in-store. Promotions, discounts, and offers available in stores may
`not be available for online orders. The information provided on this website, including special diets and nutritionalinformation,is for reference purposesandnot intended as medical
`or healtheare informationor advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different information than shownon our website. You should notrely solely on
`the information presented here and youshould alwaysread labels, warnings, and directions before using or consuming a product.The information provided on this website should
`not berelied upon to make health-related decisions.
`
`€
`

`

`Planningan event?
`Shopcatering &
`entertaining
`
`Need help?
`See our FAQ's
`
`WHOLE
`FOODS
`
`WESC hmeCHn
`
`Peesacres]
`Quality Standards
`ferSe:|
`SiCuearieat
`
`PNT
`Pa itRees CC
`‘Our Values
`eed
`PMunaeatteenesttsi
`‘Careers
`ETceloia)
`
`|
`
`Shoppin:
`ReesNase}
`Cecacy
`Delivery and Pickup [3
`eeetercut]
`PreealtBates
`rekon:
`SeerEe}
`Breede
`Coeeee
`
`Need Help?
`Visit customer care >
`
`(Woiae |amer)
`
`@00@eo00
`
`| Sracurl
`
`

`

`Finda store >
`
`De | one
`
`Home / Products / All Search Results
`
`Browse Products
`
`Find a store f Use current location
`earch
`by
`ZIP code, city or state
`(US stores
`only
`
`Q |
`
`/
`
`’
`
`Seeall products
`
`Category
`All Search Results
`Produce
`Pantry Essentials
`Supplements
`
`Featured
`[J] 36sby Whole Foods
`Market
`
`12 results for "oregano"
`
`Sort
`
`Relevance
`
`Vv
`
`
`
`
`
`er
`=
`
`Filters
`lO0DO0OOO000H
`
`Spicely
`366 by Whole Foods Market
`Simply Organic
`PRODUCE
`Organic Mediterranean Oregano,
`Oregano, leach
`Oregano, 0.75 oz
`Organic Oregano
`0.45 oz
`Dietary Preference
`
`Vegan
`Add tolist Gluten-Free
`Add tolist
`
`
`
`
`Add tolist
`Add tolist
`|
`Keto-Friendly
`Vegetarian
`Organic
`Dairy-Free
`Sugar-Conscious
`Paleo-Friendly
`Whole FoodsDiet
`
`aante,
`
`Oregano
`ee
`
`€
`

`

`LJ Kesher
`[ tow-Fat
`(J) Engine 2
`
`Wantdelivery and
`pickup?
`Orderonline [7
`
`Planningan event?
`Shopcatering &
`entertaining
`
`Need help?
`See our FAQ's
`
`id
`
`
`
`GREEN GARDEN
`Frontier Co-op
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`Solaray
`OIL OF OREGANO,60 softgels
`Organic Freeze Dried Oregano,
`Organic OreganoLeaf, 0.36 oz
`Organic Seasoning, Oregano,
`
`0.35 oz 0.48 oz
`AddtolistAddtolist Addtolist
`
`
`
`
`
`
`|
`Add tolist
`
`ie
`
`j nN
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Gata Herbs
`TONNINO TUNA
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`365 Everyday Value® Oregano
`Organic Shelf-Stable Tomatoes,
`Gaia Oil Of Oregano, 120 vegan
`OreganoYellowfin Fillets In Olive
`liquid phyto-caps
`Oil, 6.7 oz
`Diced (with Basil, Garlic, &
`(0.32 02)
`Oregano), 14.5 oz
`
`
`
`Addtolist
`Addtolist
`|
`Add to list
`|
`Add tolist
`
`More Results
`The below productsare also sold in store.
`
`SPICELY
`Organic Oregano
`Mediterranean
`
`Addtolist
`
`
`
`|
`Add tolist
`|
`Addto list
`|
`Add tolist
`
`Gaia Herbs
`Oil of OreganoLiquid Caps
`
`365 by Whole Foods Market
`Oil of Oregano, 1 each
`
`NORTH AMERICANHERB& SPICE
`Oil Of Oregano
`
`Garden OfLife
`SEGGIANO:
`‘Organic MYKIND Immune
`Organic Pizza Sauce with Wild
`Oregano
`Drops Oil of Oregano, 1 each
`
`Add tolist
`
`|
`Add tolist
`
`

`

`Prices andavailability are subject to change without notice. Offers are specific to store listed above andlimited to in-store. Promotions, discounts, and offers available in stores may
`not be available foronline orders. The information provided on this website, including special diets and nutritional information,is for reference purposes andnot intended as medical
`or healthcare informationor advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different information than shownon our website. You should notrely solely on
`the information presented here and youshould alwaysread labels, warnings, and directions before using or consuming a product. The information provided on this website should
`not be relied upon to make health-related decisions.
`
`MARKET
`
`Shopping
`Seariy
`eteaaceslacy
`Deseaehates
`Meals and Catering
`
`PeRl atory
`Gift Cards [7
`SpecialDiets
`Ss and Ideas
`
`Mission in Action
`tyreaEelelite)
`Quality Standards
`Community Giving
`Environmental Stewardship
`
`8 pinto
`
`About
`Perlaed
`‘OurValues
`Departments
`Information and Potential Suppliers
`
`Careers
`retlu)
`
`Need Help?
`eems ed
`
`(eoonitaamer)
`
`oe ry)
`
`2) ©
`
`|
`
`Pro
`
`Seu ort |
`ey
`
`

`

` Find a store >
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`WHOLE FOODS | BrowseProducts FindaStorePQsein|caer eerOrderOnline Recipes WeeklySales
`
`Naa
`
`Home / Products / Produce / Fresh Herbs / Organic Oregano
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`PRODUCE
`
`Organic Oregano
`
`“f Use current location
`Find a store to see pri
`
`Search by ZI stores only) ty or state (US
`
`
`
`
`
`To add this product to yourlist, login.
`
`|
`
`INGREDIENTS
`Organic Oregano
`
`6o 2 00 0 90
`Dairy-Free
`Engine2
`Gluten-Free
`Paleo-
`Vegan
`Vegetarian
`
`» oO ©
`Whole Foods Keto-Friendly
`Organic
`Diet
`
`You mayalsolike
`
`
`
`

`

`KENTER CANYON
`Kenter Canyon Farms
`
`Organic Poultry Herbs Herb Basil doz Organic
`
`Add tolist
`|
`|
`Add tolist
`Prices and availability are subject to change withoutnotice. Offers are specific to store listed
`aboveandlimitedto in-store. Promotions, discounts, and offers available in stores may not be
`available for online orders, The information provided on this website, including special diets
`and nutritional information,is for reference purposes and not intended as medical or healthcare
`information or advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or
`different information than shownon our website. You should notrely solely on the information
`presented here and you should alwaysread labels, warnings, and directionsbefore using or
`consuming a product. The information provided on this website should notbe relied uponto
`makehealth-related decisions.
`
`rT
`
`About Whole Foods Market
`‘OurValues
`preted
`aCL
`Careers
`elu)
`
`UEsyd
`
`Need Help?
`Visit customer care —>
`
`(oniaaMe)
`
`@o0@ea00
`
`| Pe Bomuri
`freeeae eg
`
`|
`
`ereeRereAceas
`
`SCO AOLCello}
`
`§ pinto
`Deeee CeMCs PCMCC CMECACECMter
`One soc
`
`
`
`
`
`WEESie rawateal
`
`eeeeet}
`Ceeee
`Community Giving
`Cuachatiu}
`
`ETkeelieT
`
`Shopping
`Beeaero
`Browse Products
`Delivery and Pickup [7
`Meals and Catering
`PUreeMaea litaerere,
`Gift Cards [7
`pyree etacd
`Beea Ces
`Peete
`
`

`

`MCeae Naa
`aE TSfel
`TOUELaL
`Der PL ery eltaes Oa) ci]
`Reyes Free Newsletter Subscription
`
`ee
`TTPVEVout(e)
`IMMUNE SUPPORT”.
`PPP UTTy
`dee
`
`LEARN MORE
`
`0
`
`ne
`
`Immunity Inside and Out
`
`ee)
`
`Bright GAR Snap-Enteric Gastric Acid Resistant, snap-
`
`etertog
`
`7World of Innovativeot
`Capsules
`Bright-Poly NOP Organic
`
`World’s first full NOP Organic
`Vegetable Capsules
`
`Tim Person
`‘Trendsandtips for natural supplements thathelp us stay well.
`VitaminC. Echinacea. Zine. These supplementsare someof the hottest tickets on the Immune Health Express. What was
`once perhaps rightfully regarded as a seasonal buy has recently shotinto the fast lane of year-round hotsellers for
`several reasonsthat we'll discuss downtheroad.
`“Immunity is one of the fastest growing segmentsin the natural products
`industry,” says Jay Levy, director of sales at Wakunaga of America Co.,
`
`October 22, 2013
`
`enteric and pH sensitive
`
`Bright Pharma Caps Inc,
`

`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`September 2023
`
`July 2023
`
` ae
`August 2023
`
`
`seins
`tgdher ons
`
`June 2023
`
` Top Supplements and New Research
`
`
`
`
`Well-known category
`leaders have some extra company with up-and-coming immunehealth
`supplements.“While the focus continues to be on foods and supplements
`that are high in antioxidants, other nutrients such as herbs, probiotics and
`phytosterols are gaining awareness among consumersfor their immune
`supportive properties,” Levy says.
`Probiotics. Though consumersstill usually associate them with digestive
`benefits, the growth of probiotics andprebiotics in the immunehealth
`spaceis a majortrend to note. DanLifton, CEO of QualityofLife Labs,
`Purchase, NY, says their overall popularity has gotten a boost from the
`|avosrroru|ie)awg
`high-profile promotion of yogurt products by key consumer packaged
`goodsplayers.
`CRN:FishOil Study
`A large shift has taken place very recently with the realization that pro- and
`Demonstrate "Amazing Lack
`prebiotics can impact immunehealth in otherareas besides the
`of Understanding" About Why
`Consumers Use Supplements
`gastrointestinal tract, according to Dallas Clouatre, Ph.D., consultant for
`R&Dto Jarrow Formulas, Inc., Los Angeles, CA.
`Maggie Jaqua » August 28,
`2023
`Probiotics can strengthenthebarrier functionofintestinal walls and
`stimulate the body's productionof naturalkiller (NK) cells andTcells, Levy
`Natural Products Industry
`says. One studyinto the effects of probiotic strains on Clostridiumdificile found specific immunomodulatory benefits (1).
`News Briefs: IFF, GC Rieber
`Someadditional applicationsforprobiotics in the immunehealth categorywill be discussed later.
`VivoMega, VantageNutrition,
`and More!
`Antioxidants. Often associated with heart health, aged garlic extract (AGE) contains compoundslike S-allyl cysteine that
`WholeFoods Magazine Staff
`+
`provide antioxidant benefits for immune health. Later, we'll hear about research that foundit could help reduce the
`duration of colds.
`Oreganooilhas antioxidant and antibacterial properties, thanks to a phenolit contains called carvacrol. “Studies suggest
`that the oxygen molecules in carvacrol team up with the waterin the bodyto create heat thatkills bacteria,” says Levy.
`Hot Products: August 2023
`Researchersrecently foundthat oregano,in combination with sage, modulatedinnate immunityin an animal model by
`HOT PRODUCTS
`WholeFoods Magazine Staff «
`benefiting nitric oxide status and phagocytic activity (2),
`Like vitamin C (which wewill discuss morein the context of recovery), zine
`is essential for building immunity, and offers direct antiviral activity, says
`PERFECTION
`
`cannotbe EXCEEDED,—Michele McRae, C.N., senior director of research, formulation and quality for
`butit can be
`RainbowLight Nutritional Systems,Inc., Santa Cruz, CA.
`In fact, zinc plays a part in many immune system reactions. “It promotes the
`nl
`yr
`REPEATED
`JARAO-DOPHILUS EPS" IS THE #1 SELLING PROBIOTIC
`IN THE NATURAL PRODUCTS CHANNEL...ONCEAGAIN’
`destruction of foreign particles and microorganisms,acts as a protectant
`againstfree-radical damage,acts synergistically with vitaminA, is required
`@THINOGEN®
`for proper white bloodcell function and properT cell levels, and is a
`necessary cofactorin activating serum thymic factor,” says McRae, Thymic
`Your Natural Weight
`factor is a hormonethat has“profound immune-enhancing properties,” she
`
`ManagementSolutio
`Gece
`ke
`
`NEW!
`Te) ae
`Liposomal
`Vitamin C
`
`Adreteie
`
`Ltd., Mission Viejo, CA
`Levy saysthatthe Natural Marketing Institute's 2013 Healthy Aging
`Database showsone-halfof U.S. adults claim to be concerned about
`supportingtheir immune health at somepointin life, with a significant
`spike in concern among thosein their 30s.It is a category with broad
`and consistent appeal, and being knowledgeable aboutit will put you in
`goodstead with customersof all ages.
`So, hop aboard as we take a tour of the supplements and the studies
`that many category leaders are focusing on now.
`
`says. Over 300 enzymesin the body are zinc-dependent, adds Susan Hazels
`
`

`

`of the immune system, according to Chris D. Meletis, N.D., director of
`
`science and research for Trace Minerals Research, Ogden, UT. Vitamin D also exerts massive
`influence,he says, offering
`support to autoimmune responses andcellular integrity. “It is no surprise thatvitaminDlevels drop at the sametime that
`colds and flus increase each and every year,” Meletis says.
`Indeed,“there has beenstrong grewth in thevitamin D category due to emerging research on the link betweenvitamin D
`deficiency and weakened immunity,” says Lifton,
`For much moreon vitamin 0,we turnto Trisha Sugarek MacDonald,B.S., M.S., director of R&D/national educator for
`Bluebonnet Nutrition Corp., Sugar Land, TX. The physiologically active form of vitamin D,calcitriol, functions as a
`hormonein the body by binding with vitamin D receptors.It has been recognizedfor significant and widespread immune
`effects throughoutthe body, she says,affecting both armsof the immunesystem. According to Sugarek MacDonald,
`vitamin D's myriad effects as a potent immunomodulatorinclude increased production of peptides that may inactivate
`viruses; increased production of antimicrobial peptides such as defensin;
`enhancement of regulatory T cells; decreased
`
`inflammation through cytokine modulation and countless others,
`The regulation of inflammation is of central importance to immunehealth,
`and supplementing with antioxidant compounds can be an effective way of
`addressing the issue, Alpha-lipoic acid is one such compound, and
`according to Clouatre, most supplementsinclude equal amounts of the (R)
`and (S) forms of this antioxidant. He adds, however, that the (R) form, also
`called RALA,is the only one made naturally by the body, “RALA promotes
`the synthesis of glutathione and the induction of PhaseII detoxification
`enzymes,” both integral to immune responses, Clouatre says.
`The carotenoid class of compounds canalso deliver antioxidantbenefits.
`Bryan See, regional product managerfor CarotechInc., Edison, NJ, adds
`
`that, “Some carotenoids such as beta-carotene and alpha-carotene

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket