Proceeding
`Party
`
`Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`ESTTA130771
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`03/20/2007
`
`Filing date:
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`91176062
`Defendant
`Neuronetics, Inc.
`Neuronetics, Inc.
`One Great Valley Parkway, Suite 2
`Malvern, PA 19355
`
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Denise I. Mroz
`Woodcock Washburn LLP
`Cira Centre, 12th Floor 2929 Arch Street
`Philadelphia, PA 19104-2891
`
`Submission
`Filer's Name
`Filer's e-mail
`Signature
`Date
`Attachments
`
`trademarks@woodcock.com
`Motion to Suspend for Civil Action
`Denise I. Mroz
`trademarks@woodcock.com, dmroz@woodcock.com
`/Denise I. Mroz/
`03/20/2007
`NNIL1MotionSusp.pdf ( 2 pages )(23241 bytes )
`NNIL1ExA.pdf ( 13 pages )(5947467 bytes )
`NNIL1ExB.pdf ( 13 pages )(638172 bytes )
`
`

`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE BEFORE THE
`TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Northstar Neuroscience, Inc.
`
`Opposer,
`
`V.
`
`Opposition No.: 91176062
`
`Serial Nos.:78904768, 78904775, and
`78904747
`
`Neuronetics, Inc.
`
`Applicant.
`
`MoTIoN To SUSPEND PENDING OPPosITIoN PROCEEDING
`
`Sir:
`
`Applicant moves to suspend the above—captioned proceeding pending disposition of Civil
`Action 07-0351 filed by Opposer against Applicant in the United States District Court for the
`Western District of Washington at Seattle and of Civil Action 07-1046 filed by Applicant against
`Opposer in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
`
`Applicant applied to register NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY, NEUROSTAR & Design,
`and NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY & Design (respectively, Application Serial Nos. 78904747,
`78904775, and 78904768, and collectively referred to as the NEUROSTAR Applications) and
`has registered NEUROSTAR (Registration No. 3187054), all for “transcranial magnetic
`stimulation devices consisting of a stimulator and a patient positioning system, namely, a chair
`and headset,” in International Class 10.
`
`Opposer filed a Notice of Opposition on March 7, 2007, against the Neurostar
`Applications, claiming that Applicant’s NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY, NEUROSTAR &
`Design, and NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY & Design marks are likely to cause confusion with
`Opposer’s registered mark NORTHSTAR NEUROSCIENCE.
`
`On March 7, 2007, Opposer also filed a civil action against Applicant, charging
`Applicant with infringement of Opposer’s trademark rights as well as false designation of origin,
`common law infringement, and unfair competition. Opposer also requests that Applicant’ s
`registration for NEUROSTAR be cancelled. Opposer’s complaint in this civil action is attached
`hereto as Exhibit A.
`
`On March 15, 2007, Applicant filed a civil action against Opposer, requesting a
`declaratory judgment of noninfringement of Opposer’s NORTHSTAR NEUROSCIENCE
`trademark. Applicant’s complaint in this civil action is attached hereto as Exhibit B.
`
`

`
`Disposition of the aforementioned civil actions will determine whether Applicant is
`entitled to use and register NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY, NEUROSTAR & Design, and
`NEUROSTAR TMS THERAPY & Design, the marks at issue in the instant Opposition.
`Accordingly, it is respectfully submitted that all further proceedings in Opposition No. 91176062
`be suspended pending the disposition of Civil Action 07-0351 in the U.S. District Court for the
`Western District of Washington at Seattle and Civil Action 07-1046 in the U.S. District Court for
`the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
`
`Date: March 20 2007
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`
`
`Denise I. Mroz
`
`Woodcock Washbum LLP
`Cira Centre, 12m Floor
`2929 Arch Street
`
`Philadelphia, PA 19104-2891
`Tel. 215-568-3100
`
`Fax 215-568-3439
`
`Email tradem:arl<:s woodcoc1«:.com
`
`Attorney for Applicant
`Neuronetics, Inc.
`
`

`
`
`
`1 2
`
`
`
`,,,.,,u-wuuw.-.,........-v-snovaounun-r;.rr’:,;
`
`5E E
`
`.1;-\
`$3’
`,._,....§.$i§i‘:E§ —=---
`
`,.......a..-=
`
`RE?‘
`§%§E=s§‘£§ ‘
`
`£3‘? 23%?
`
`9%
`
`-.e.+aa:a¥2‘»:#‘:§.?:*°5§ae€»$>*‘£*z%.§=»
`
`‘
`
`EG}}rELA§a°§‘”§' Fflfi TRA.BEi‘c§AR§§
`Ei‘§'Rfl’€$E.?\'§€"§:'.E‘€'E',
`FAESE
`fi§353‘$‘§é'§3“§&'§’3'fiP§' C9? €§6R§€'.§§.‘i§é‘,
`CA§V7i'CfE§.:L§£§'§BN 333‘ REGESTRATIGR9
`.1‘-’m"‘=€E’
`€'..‘$?~§‘;‘s’§§}?‘I LEW fi‘€FR§l\F£3E§sE.EN"§‘
`AN}?
`<"_'.’G?‘z~'_§PfE'E’I'E'§€Z%E»3
`
`SURE’ EE3$*’§..3.\N£%
`
`'
`
`Umaa gums ngsrmcw cam? ..
`wagwsaw D§S'¥'R3£’Z‘ as w2Hm‘m“:::=:€
`AT saamg
`ii 3 51 ’3“”di
`
`5%? km :
`‘:~§DR"§‘H$"£‘A.R NEUROS=:§EN{‘.‘E. M8,,
`:was§m'1gtss2 Cfifpfimtism
`
`
`
`
`Pinintifi’,
`
`‘J’.
`
`E
`
`§§EZ§§.{?NETi$S. WC‘, ax Deéawaye
`Camamtiaik
`
`Befensiazzt.
`
`hm
`
`$333-c2m~..amueoaa.wMA
`
`_v.-I Ir-J
`
`yawn lo!
`
`9»! .4‘),
`
`1 F
`
`‘\-
`
`?§;s.E_:rti§‘f?~éq:rt%x5§ar Evieurastficnca, km. giiagas as frhi-Emwg
`
`PARTEEE
`
`S.
`
`E EaE
`
`‘:
`
`ffiaintifffisnhstar Newosaienee, Em. {°‘;I\¥m§§s$.a§”:e is a Washfingmn 2:-mps2'at§:::z's
`
`‘whiz its prinsipai piace ef bmimess at 24‘~§§ Faufia Aveaufig Suite 339, S-e.ata:§a,.\A«’z:<:E:ia-.gt
`
`.
`
`‘33§2i.
`
`2.
`
`Nczrzhstan-“ is infarmed am‘ §‘.x‘:E§z*:ve3 am an Sim basis siiageg ‘.-that afigfsnéaxat
`U
`
`
`~~~‘«~:'‘::'x.'.’.'.:ot»$aoE‘~§=:%.i1't:mi§ss, inc. {“§}:f:£3£ia:an5:°’ Gr “b§:sumna§us"} is 5. migwaafie camaréuzian which maintains
`m.u5mm«:31; grimtipafi piste sf huginess at fin: Gmat Vaiiay Paa°£:.wa3i,,
`
`$355. Ncivriilsiar is fun?-mr infcrmcd ms? ?:s¢§i».~2-was me‘ an timt basis aiiagcs ma: ‘{.}°T¢§'$:m'.’§3.'é?; has
`
`3. Maivfirm Fmnsyivaisia
`
`nu’-5'5‘-‘q'»’-’a'e5’Afi%§'-"1$956F-§’—uu
`5:“Amara’
`
`‘ *JQM?LA§h*'rv 3
`
`am Page: US as
`Fifth Avcmsc, Suite ‘3~E<}B
`‘3§§3=§—?54==E-3‘ Tait 2%5.§3?.¢S§€3E
`
`Scmtéifi. ‘Ext
`
`-wwu/A-;-.-q.-v
`
`I3 : 1 E sH\
`
`n
`
`a 5
`
`n
`
`
`
`
`
`ya,»$61131:!4»-J155%Lil
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`1-“;so»:out:x«d-av-,19'-rd
`
`2'-.1(Y)
`
`

`
`
`
`\
`
`(2-
`
`i»
`‘_.
`:7
`
`*:
`
`M
`
`3
`
`%
`
`Grzeiamcé céinjezaé mafia in Washingisn conggmégag 25¢ ggggsfigcfigj at gggggg gr; mg 3535“ f§g§;_;fi§;-gg
`in 33155 juéiciai district,
`
`NATEERE ex?1% Lmsre
`
`"N
`3-
`
`T3353
`
`3&1 3354313 f0? Efia‘53ma=:3< and tad: mm :':2'?r§ngemen& and mm,-,=;§ gauges
`
`E
`‘
`
`IE
`
`S
`
`%s E
`
`3
`
`aflsizzg mi :25 Befezzdzmt ‘;“~‘z:.«.:s*s:srags:écs“.*-: ass sf §§e&-. marks §\§E.URG3‘?AR.?1‘Q
`of actfara
`,5-’w’$7
`E3455-51'§S33T:*sR T:°‘r‘53 TH‘5.F.fi~.P"f’, NEUEGSTAR 33$ 3353333; arid NEERQETAR TMS -
`and Dwign, mi gm‘: of fhcm Easziieaiésfiy, fin: “‘?*éH.3RiT,'§$T.<%.R §«'27az%c5”}, which
`Wxiisigs §‘§a3n2§fi";=. 2:-ads mama miaei Emflsmmk '§~{€Q§<§'£‘;Z-§3‘§‘AE{ NEURQSCEEPECE, ma each 9:’;
`fiwn iccikztiveizr
`the “r€GR'mS°.?-AR NEURGSC§31x':?§: Ma:;;" at “M3ri2:"‘f§.
`[:eap§:e§
`?=§cr€§1sts£‘5
`r:q1,:w‘:
`that Dnfcndani Msumneficg usage
`§imit‘_§sa :2? ah;
`iygfrigsgingé
`‘£3
`mniiauad in mg mg ififiingingmav.-.«-»...u»-x-
`H : 3'xEEUE{33'§AR Marks, Eeféndazri has daciémd :5: air; 5:: am
`fig
`§"§’=3'5‘-5 €31
`fifiifififiizivxn wit}: pmdum med :2: ma: naumiogégfl as‘ :;as3:c?:s§s2i:=i'u uvrzaiiiéunzg in ::is°:a:: 5
`33 v:§,=§a.2mn 0‘? 1‘3C:'!‘€?§stE:"i;
`rignts.
`Nfiflhaégr geeks gmmg qgég gggfiggggtgvg
`rgigef in pr=‘;:v:§?.fi§
`-
`I
`=
`s
`-
`u
`.
`.
`.
`‘E
`_
`E
`E4 Zififeafiant Fran: tisirag 123:: §§E‘i3R.i?:‘$T.-%¥.‘. Marks, as wcii $3 my damagag Bafandant’s §~2'ofits,i\
` _
`‘facts, aegis, ans cfiaasr msmztaafg as-aé acguiiabia: mi
`_
`
`4”1ymmvx..vnnnrarm-)v\..u,:.A
`
`1
`
`E
`
`5 5 7
`
`3
`
`.=
`
`
`
`3
`
`§“.?_
`E3
`3‘?
`M<::«
`
`15:5.
`
`.......4u..xrA.v-.-
`/zvttaww,1.
`
`infringe‘-mam am‘: unfair cxsmycfiticza in vfiniazim :3?’ Lbs sezmmaza fiaw cf the sign‘:
`
`as’:
`
`\
`22 § ‘eysihizxgtsfi,
`‘I23
`g
`5.
`
`Thés Cam has §§3§"§5€§§§:tiQi1~€w$z{'§1§
`
`‘
`$u¥;3j¢s;:§z:.a:te§* gfihia a¢f:§£3n mxrafianita 23
`
`JEIRZSE#EC’EE€3bi
`;3;_.*€}ZB= "FEi§“§§'éZ
`Feainiiff‘Nsnhmr brisags aiaims fax‘.
`3%.
`{E} izzfréagemwst in xriaiatiaa {sf Smtiegz 32 n
`..
`cf ‘Eh: 'E‘ra§<::r:as**.< Act 01’ §S*¢%a$,, as fimendcé {Em “£.,.a{§§xa-in .A:$"‘§, $5 U.$.C. § E 3 W; {E} $333
`E.
`fissigsmfiexa of erigin anfi unfair fismpcfiiiielsrs
`viaiaéim of Sectiam !€;3{a} sf £222 Lar£h$m mi,
`E5 U.S.L‘, §§:25gg}; {iii} %‘:Es:‘1$§§§?.i‘§$s§ af regisiraaéosa LZi‘§:.‘§$.=‘ 33 323.5. § §i\3§°; anfi {Ev}:
`§
`
`
`
`
`L5.S.C. § 33:33 3:33 3 W9, aszé has 313ppE&mar:n’:'a§ jur§$t§§'=fi@i§ :sv:s' fix: shims arising ms: sf Kata
`
`; iaw gunman: am 22 233:. § 135?'{a}.
`
`CI3MFLJ‘-GMT n 3‘-.
`
`‘€81
`
`34;‘-I~!$.$'§E!,
`
`§}L‘.P.x Fiyscr ‘US Lia?
`i"*’ii?£5': fiwénué, 32:52: ';>'€v%§§
`‘S23E54:-v?€3¢§a§
`E FE}: 335.3$9.-15.559
`\
`
`......,...........n-‘-rrvwrrv\uv-yar«Ivv-nv-
`
`€
`

`
`
`
`EEE
`
`p-1111‘
`
`§ E3§§{é23{i} and (2; as‘
`z.>r:=;m° um: 28 ?...ti‘€.€3.
`if»
`555¥?3==?
`‘’'m‘% if? €533
`5-
`§§
`gmriizsiar is infarmeci and beiiavss and an that ham afiie,-gas that Qgfenéani Neursnezécg §1_3s¥
`2 msaduuura business in was jzxsiieisfl dégtrimz, incmfiing :;cs§::§L=~;:>;§ng siirsizsai L-E333 in this _§'::éEc§a§
`*3§5‘=‘3‘5@’i2 mi 3 51$.‘-sififiiiai pm sf the mrznigt giving 325% 5:9 {ha eiaéms aiiegeci seemed in ibis
`4 *i§$5¥“5¢?-
`3‘€'m'“*5‘3‘i'?-5‘
`55 fimhfis‘ ififfimzsé mé t*§3§5“z?$$ and <35: {E3331 hasis afieges zhéx Dsfesrzdassi
`I spsraies a wefisite at w'w.§.:':e£:ra::afic§.::-ram w§:§s;E§ is ae:c::=;§%%§3§r": E2’: Ei1§3j:.E:§‘§<:ia;§dEstr§z*:£ anfi
`‘ which indicates fleet it 119.3 :mn$uct¢c§ ¢§i}:§caE trims aé £1: fiaivwsiigé csé‘ Wasézingzms.
`£1-2.4."
`,
`.
`i
`$3‘53:£3“M W “"1:er; (‘TI33.. EI3‘35 F5‘3.. 33°‘
`‘A
`u
`.
` .a av‘ az:e&3as.c mi‘;:i§es.§m'rs§‘;.
`
`:€
`
`
`
`
`
`..u.m..w
`
`
`smmmg E*£;4E}1‘?;’EES’i‘3E 3‘iEE3RS$a.‘::€E§§z'€:fE
`Am HS z««m1=a'ms'r.m Nzxraeascxz-mtg mmc:
`
`'3.
`
`Naflhsmr is 2. meéicafi cicvicsz Gizmyaray SE33? <J§$ve3Dp5 311$ pmsridcs inz:o*m:iv&.=
`
`
`
`,,m4..,,,,.,.,....,..,.y....w-.m~............,...........
`
`:&a:'.=::¢::-_:a-‘:4;-an-.vr.r.-.5-;s«;a,;.~.,......»x
`
`3
`
`um:
`
`I-‘.1’!
`
`32'
`Effie fér peapk safifeeizag fzazmz
`.§2ai§?a5$EimuE§‘E§m'§ Eizampiss 2:3 m52»::>:'»: ffinciian and quaiity
`.-.721’
` 333353.253 am §=:§3:r:s3§a'm.
`ésirukt mad ::'fh=':~.* nmmksgicai fiiscases am? &isa:de:z's, §:z::§u=-Eiaag; stroke moses rgcjzwazgyg apimsik, 3
`‘£uTcsr2§§em*‘s innswative m’.'-?m=::§s3g;g' is éesigneé :5 éeiévar tazgeiadg
`35 Eeiaatrisai stimuiaiion inthe min, in 3 prmzess r-zzfstrred:3as:.ts3:*::'i7t:§3.séimtfiafisu. Naxthsm Ems
`iifiasi £33: is-aciesaame: EM mark NQR"§'§'§ST.4.R. NEURDECIENCE since mi 3:352 ms §:.a2'§y as: Esme
`‘
`ES.-;;.~iI%{3*&i. Nsahsm is {sign €31: owns: «sf 3 fcéarai tmdcmsz-R rergfiséz-asisnn fer tits N€3R,':“§§$T;u§
`fly
`.
`33
`§“<!a":‘-UR€3SCiENCE ?‘*:§$3'§C; which was ismécxri r-:1 Azzgsasi M, W35 {R.=~:-.g¢ Na :2 €°¥5;2i&‘;
`53‘?
`3.:
`E?
`“masi§»::a§
`:§r:c‘£?§::a§ gfimufiatian generamrs and acaaesacrizsa
`far app§€ca:§<:szz
`:3? §.'§aca';ifia§
`
`uwn~v.«.w...w.-ma..
`1xm4...,5.-nwuwmz./A,”
`
`23 __ §£§muiai§m'=. sigéraais in :3-“st: cmbrafi bbzifix as’ the brain. namfiy madécai aiasiraflsa meéicafi
`2%
`filvfi afiecfmtizs agrzaiicaiara anti mfiéisai céaczmafié cabfisz.” Agrgéézed >32 §x&§‘g‘gt 3%. is saw: and tflrrzssta=‘.
`sapy vi‘ the r$g§5«€;'&fiQ2‘a
`esziifieaa 3 issuad 5:: Exzasfizaiar
`the flfiitad States: 9mm and
`E5
`By vista: :2? 5:33;: use mrfi r¢g§s::'ai;Sa:a :2?the N{}R'§’I—I$TAR NEHRGSCEEHSE »
`2%
`8.
`13:?
`.Mw5«g Nmhsiar has acaiéired gzraicctafiie Eniciieciuafi gzgsasstv rights in flue mmzamarxn
`35 fE}‘5Ei.3R€}§C.'iE?E'~££.?E Mark. Nortiistar has tsstafiiisfimié ¢pg:s§a§g;s'aE~_:3e zzgmssieaze and gagadwéii
`.
`'mw:?L.-u.~r:»3
`am Péger as :4...»
`WIPE .Fi§:§s .-We;-.§':§ss; Suits '2":-§'.!s3
`$¢&tif¥z.":. W.-*1 92w-'éu‘?‘fi—"é4 311$: EiZ!s:';.S3‘§.48fi§29
`
`3
`
`.
`
`u!
`
`'34
`
`E 5
`
`3§
`5
`
`2 § E
`
`4
`
`'
`
`

`
`
`
`g
`
`E
`
`km}
`
`,5.L
`
`1%: 3“w‘0I~?.THS'§"AR NESRQSCEENSE Marie, and meéicafi grerfizssianais, nr.-Eifiieai ma; paiignfis,
`suszcsmcrs mid ififitfifififii maicmcss and azhers En me ii*.£3¥.s$fi£‘y assmiate as Mark witjsg
`fr=«inr:’&s=;a?ar’s gsrceducts.
`.45-3.".“.*s¢i'wd as Easrxgssit ‘:3-um tmo .-ms w.=~r<«.<::s. copiess :33’ prinmuts in?»
`k
`K
`P§ai:2tiff1‘~€:sri§‘:st%r’s website 3; vszawgriE‘zs%a§§;;rg,e::3m
`its Mark.
`
`:2’:
`
`
`
`S‘? EEURQSTRR Riarks.
`
`Ne:-.-2§astar_is iafeszme-5.? mé ‘beiiswes ;m& an Ehafi ixrasis aiieges that Eafandmt mi
`2!.
`E3
`E? . began using fiia izazfriaging BEEUR<3S'§‘AR Marks in :sann::=*fi};>n wfi}: D‘<?:f&E:.r:<ianE‘5; pmstéwats G1‘
`2% I services an air afimuz May 2395 =- zsbcmz $:we:» years may gig: $3.23 when ‘§£_ss“‘-.§'1£;£a1“ first fmsgazx using 5
`iii; ?zivz3R"§’H3TAR NEURGSQKSNQE §‘\:‘Ia?§<,_, zmé aim? ?°»m:'€,€35s:§ze’
`hm‘: ahtsinsd E ferdaréfi
`
`“mag
`
` lg <:esva:=:..mm -4
`
`‘ Ewriiavas am an that bagis aiieges that D53:-n§am‘: was aware: at s§wui§ haw: ham awasa ~“"3.4-".
`
`Nceriiasmr ares:
`
`its E*€{Z31'i.T§§ST.fi.R NEURSSEEENCE Eviarir; me? mgismfiéen at the time thai
`
`Eaefeiadant adaptefi ma? iisegzm asing Em §:1fi"§';3g§z1g }a§E§_3R§3. "§‘A$9. Maficfi.
`
`"i.'§'s.:: gaszrticsé are hsxiis
`
`ism me: vs LL?
`7§‘§ §‘§:‘t_ijz swaixce. Sssite ‘iifififl
`SEalE§§.. WA §-"3§§'-2~—?S«$*3 E Tat E95.$3.‘3.*‘3§§-W}
`
`E
`
`
`\
`
`\
`
`
`
`,.,...2rnz1xIxu\»)4.rAl)fl
`
`q
`
`«x
`
`
`
`....,..,W;m,,,....,.u-5»-an¢~v4w.v,.w.w,..r...,..,...,;as»r
`
`S :'
`5
`
`.
`
`\
`
`BEEEN§}§2¥'§“’S ENFRWGWG A€‘?2§‘s’§’§'§ES
`Na=s*€h$Ear
`9.
`is irsfsrerrszeé and Eeiievas am§ an in: basis a§§E=g§=S fits’: Efisfansfiassi‘
`.\nun)::uxr.va-.a.u.>».».--u..-.--u.=---z-
`Vfieurenéetics fig E medicai zizvicc ¢cm;é.*:y fies: fiEV£=‘§{t§35 garaciissiz fab: trcaésrsent bf nmméegéaafi
`and gesychiafiris disesdera. Nonhstar is Enferzneé ami hciécves 33$ #33 ‘$333 fiasis. §3§:':g;:3 that
`Ncumnaiies 2:532 :51: NEURQSTAR Mari-:5 ire can:-mzéaz;
`52; Ngumsm '};‘§,«g$ ‘figamgy
`' gfiysicm wizicii
`is 3 grams: :3? gsfeseiucts fm me Ereazgmgzg mt“ majnr r_§§press§:m, gm? :<;§;§g§§5
`3
`figtzaatheé harem as F,3;§'§§‘;i C are: pg-V§;2‘3m:£s fmm.,,,.~uuw.w;...m.w.yny
`E 3 Epmviées siimzziaiicssi is the caring ofthe hrsin.
`3:9. %t§1e Maumnmies vwehsitu at wwwmszu :2
`"cs.w:zi e£=::eL-ribésag This grams: as gnawing ii:
`,
`:3 §2~2EL=?.asTA§2 Marks.
`I/avvanuvrr/auurzzaz
`1&3
`ES.
`Hafflifiiér is énfcrmeé am bciiwea ané fin &‘saa+.. §:as§s aifiegszs aha: fiaifméarst v‘
`i
`gcaznéucteé ciiniéai mafia sf
`pmfim; has given prasznratisgs mam: iis gmzduczzs arm reia~::é§
`‘
`‘
`
`

`
`
`
`§ i E %
`
`..::.'.-.-.-.a'.e
`
`:''""*":.'%¢;“~'.-.-.-
`
`:
`
`fig. 1333 ?'a'W3§$$3 *=“33‘v’§=?¢ 565$. 3&5 ?‘=5m‘=i1star’s fedsrai trademafi; §¥3.giS€f*.-Zs.Z§£’sn pm-maxi cw.5s;:§.m:§*.re
`:5,
`. mic: a:«f’E‘~§s;>:%%a5t'=zr‘s.= rfgms £33 the NGKTHSTASK 1‘~3E%°.JR\’.7.*3{I§I-:‘-‘.-E~ECEI~J£a.e‘?€:.
`
`M-
`
`qtsmw‘
`
`E2.
`
`. Nnrfi‘1.-was‘ E: infasvmmi ami iseiiwas thmi on ztiwa 5:fi§§§ néiggcs ma: E5:;’¢{g;,,‘§a;:§={'5;
`
`kn
`
` firfidfifitfi 3% Similar W N:>t%%ts!a.r‘s grodtscis in that bofiz Eifiafcafiafii and Nf_>?fi*iSis33‘ p,rt;w:‘si§
`prfifiusis ihafi are zéesigmé ta gsmvifia szimuii ta ‘iém $92139: —:>§ the brain :23 trsafi p3y¢h%=mE:.= as
`5 § ;‘s$s.3.1's:Es:gim«1§ ciiaasdars. Ham pa£'£Ec§2§arEy. Na}?-‘.hs£as* is infamsed am? Sefieves am: an gm kasiz
`E3195: ' as aha: Nsusonatéte has dam ::§imE:a§ {dais fr; -aashfiah aw. ?eé’a:~:s_:<,zr:e'£§s:s fieviag is em-..& ta 3
`S
`.
`P? E’
`stirazuii in 3&2: mrtex afzhe Esminé its ‘area: mafia: ziegressicgg, am: Nfiifizstar :23: aisa $9335; siinfisai
`
`‘ht
`
`itiais in which a fisfihsiar ziavica is usefi ‘Eu appiy siitmii =:~cs arise 6:-054:3: 9? fie firms: ta Emsfi
`.
`_
`E
`Est} mqsraspmssiam
`
`I4......,_.,..........,,,,,.....y..v-.«.1»...
`
`
`
`-wrap.-.—-.-....uw,........................-.ru,x;->..u.»»;,,.;.u.«.»....«...“...w4...,
`«.uuw.u”.q.~...www»¢«..,..un......«-.ymawu.
`322$ Nmihstar, and 'i*3ar<:hstar‘s 3‘~$f3R.‘i‘i-§$TAR ?*":"£§.§RC$$G}E'.-NEE Mark, Eézerahy
`€1:=&néas=:§
`infriizgimg §‘%~:sz*:%:s:ar’s rigfits 37:: 3:3 NflR“S’7§-§$“§}fi.R NEU£.€}§C.§§f§«€CE Mark.
`ES.
`Nnsfksiaf is Enfaxmed mad baiiavaa am am §§3"e.§ b§s‘is~§=,E£egr;s zémi at 333.5‘; exam
`1 indiividaai En £51: mgcfiraai as-aricss imusuy wag tzunmssm by 122:2? aimifiariiy of the N§*3U§iGS1‘AR.
`1 Mada: wéth ‘.?a¥<:-:'*.3:.~*asa.s“’s Marks, m§sta§;§§sg am 25:39:: er afinéunmmmi iwge
`Fczaei & mag
`
`.....,,.,Mnw.-w~»..»
`23 iaémizzisn-atien {?£3A} regarding aim NEEERQETAR gimfimi as Z):-izsg «me far Z’*=«iazi3:15ta:".2
`
`ԤԤ
`
`£3-
` marim-s :33‘
`
`Ncarfizstar 35 Ezrformsé and asfieves and are the: basismiiegas 515$ Qefesarfiani
`32515 pmges-nteé isvfomzafim-2 abémfi
`53.3 gsradsgcis an §;;g§§v§:;zsa_§s am gmugsg igz the
`m~e:§§::s§ Em, which is the same fiaié ihai Nenhstar is in ms: mi. Nunhmr targéés.
`2%:
`..v..
`is:
`3: axamgiwa, Ncrfixsfiar rsssazthsra atfisndecz‘ an Ammitan Psyetzizméc Assmiatign uonfemw; émf
`'35 yearm which Ncuronetim pzcsczzzeei sziizzicai €552.23 reéufits.
`Sis prisxniussts is iikziy ii: mam:
`H.
`Qgfesncimwfs use of ihu 2~€EE_FRGS‘§‘A.?. MEERS
`afiamfijfiifizn as $5 assswifltiam, spcmsarshipé, gndafisemrng, Bwmrshig,
`:2»: affiiiaaian hcwrsen
`
`
`
`kl'?~«.?
`
`3&3
`
`gmé act.
`
`:25 §
`35
`
`E§
`
`in B3“ aibmét Novamher :5, 28%, a:>=.ms<.:§ ‘qr E*»§<:s2-ti:s:~.r;E-_..e.r:: 3 amaze ma écsisi
`35.
`iefitfizr E43 Nsusanstias reqwesting fin! Neizrsnatica wage ufiisxg 2&4: NET;-*RGETfi‘*.E mark Smi
`
`i:f.‘2Ee«§F*§.AEN':.. 5
`
`Eisw. Féiéfir :33 LL?
`?='.°°§ .T°i:“;§3_Ave::.ms; Suits: #835
`Sesaiiieg WA $50-<'4«?$4a§ §Te.=£: 2fi§.£;;9.«:§%3$
`
`,....m.;......4.....;-J;-.v;u<razr;.....,....a.uuM—;-..»«M.--4
`
`

`
`
`
`3
`
`...”“‘:(.’-;
`
`E Qwiihdrgw $33 a§+§iica*.i:2:<,5. Ks ragiafie: ah: ma;-§< §°==§EU§~?J3$"s‘s%F..
`
`
`‘The paifica azterrapiasi is rcsgivg:
`
`E
`:20 reseiuiion has, been ‘§’?:.¥£sC§§$1i ami Nmsmsaetics aanéinucs in use thsg
`2 3:233 mafitrzr, ha:
`I 3‘\7EU§iQSTAR Marks.
`
`in
`
`
`
`_
`
`
`15 3,5,2. § 3314
`Q
`Piairziii? Nafihsmf renificges aszé lncsrgzfiratas
`refaénnca mg giiegatianfi
`13’,
`‘
`‘ §::aIa=.gr$.p§z3 2 E3‘-.r0ugh as as iffuéiy sci farm Etaraira.
`7"
`
`8 3
`:3.
`F2aiz::§fn“s ma:m"HsmR wgaasczzwss fviark is diatinstive am '2‘*§<:-rtiasatar
`is a E135 :35-ad Em NBRTEESTAR }e?E§}§:G$§:§E1*~3EE Mark ‘E8 m7§2:§§g::§s.E2, am is: §€§§:‘:E§‘§y 3:5 §:ad3,§cS’5.
`éizzriizfiiar has mqusmé suhsasnisai gmdwiii
`flamugh
`mash sf rt;
`‘§%{C$P_"§“E—§§TA.?1
`E?~?E¥.?E<”.§SC1;‘é‘,2~§C:E Mark, mé abtainsé fsdargi registraiicm far we Marti, as ziesarificd abmrc.
`
`
`
`x
`39.
`§3eBf&%°3C‘.‘éif§E’s use: vzeftisa N;E‘.{.§R€3S’1’.AR Evfaxks in auxwmisgn WEE: flafeacfiasxfs
`§
`E" gpggssafis mdiar ssrvimss and mfiatafi pmmaaiamé §n:Ei‘¥iE§35 Es %fic§.§:;‘ its esmsa sanfngian, mismice,
`M
`€§'8>”'»“6Pi5m's
`ané
`smnstitzstgs
`i:%‘Fr%a:g::ma§‘fi 3? 2’*3m_'f:~.sias"s
`regmsreci
`3°é"£?}?.'fl-EST.-’A.R‘
`§ NEURGSCEENEE Mark, in v§o§as§:2:': of Sumtésm 32, flfififi Lammn fiact, £5
`§ E i H.
`
`E : : é
`
`
`
`\
`
`\
`
`§*:
`
`39
`
`
`
`Efifi
`
`Nfifihsfiar is iiifmmafi ané br.’=§§r.:v¢s am an that ms mega: shat fiefanéana wag
`
`§a:r shmzié Saw: hater: awam af E~§m13siar and the 1*<a'€Z=E.’§‘§{5T:‘<>~f.»E‘.. NEURQSCEEEWQE Mark anédU|IIlVlU99ilVhF.l|IIowwnnAI
`
`me use E$‘sa:§mf by Nm-§%:s%a:' to ifientify Efierthstar arid its prociascm prim as Eiafendanfis am as? ~
`the infringing NEUR£39S'§.AP; Mm-sag.
`
`2%.
`
`Nskfihsfiar is izxfnrzncé and heiisvgs am an that bash efifcges that as 3 msasat sf '
`
`,«aMmw(m,vw¢,m-wmmwwumumwu
`
`
`
`§ E
`
`gEE
`
`3 ‘ffisfmgcfiazzm acts Bfmdemark mfriszgamamt amf unfair =:am§eiE§=la:2: Eegfanéani Ems tscaeiiteai in
`u
`‘"$
`ear‘: mm§4::€:;:;§.=.::e,. 3:. ma axgense ef ans‘. causing Eajury =30 N'£rr'£§'35§§§*,
`
`22.
`
`Nartisstar is infarmzzfi ma baiimrcs amfi an that basis aiiagci that as a mi-suit sf
`
`x
`‘ 59:-?¢ndafi§‘s adspzien 3&5 ass cf the Enfriagiggg }’€E{]_§{',3‘ST¢-:§ Mgsrfiifi, fiefenfimt is aéfie :5
`Ԥ
`
`G33.‘-EEEKE mcggnéézion and Bmiisi a 3':$;51£tat§{i£‘i in tbs markafi. aii :‘.C.-
`
`E§eE:’§mx-3:!‘ nfiwiaeihstar 233;? ‘E5;
`
`A me benefié, and unjust eszwieizmeni, >22? ‘fitfmdmt.
`
`=:m~22?:_»..mr . «S
`
`31*-Ls, Pigaar us 1.-LP ‘
`Avenue, am mag
`'::s:
`amaze; W». §,2sm.r:e‘:s44 rm; 2€2e3.$3§.«%3e3G
`
`

`
`
`
`z53
`
`if
`E2
`As a zwséikit es}? D»::5::z1d§:nt’s unifiwffii ggsrggjzggs, ‘§~§‘c3;-1-E15!-,_gr.§3a_3 £35233 gag’ ggmfggigeg E
`
`23;
`
`._‘§0 5% Si33*53=‘3??‘C§3§3§~’ and 5“‘:‘¢§3%>’§%53" hafri‘.-ed.
`
`if £i§=€§:3r;§a;2§’s Esfifiszgrztrigérsi mé uniawfizi 25?: are
`
`: §¢z'.='::i!'§¢§ ts itafmsiisitké. ftmnsgr éamage and irrcpsmmes igsjurf WE? are susmfimsi by Nozifiastar,........w,um<v-sow.»-naou
`
`- ?31Y9i$§§¥ S15‘???
`u
`
`iifiiiii‘ ram 311$ us: of cazifuazirsgiy 5§m§€z~.r
`
`§§’:§ri=:s,_2’3§e mus sf N-:;rt?2s‘fa§"s EV
`mu
`ENEGRTHSTAR NEi}R‘S$°$SE»?~§€3E1 Mari»: wiii be éfimigisfiefi is: éestnsyad, for whisk éamagé
`
`%§
`
`
`
`
`Q
`
`?«Ec:r:§2star c.<;mm:=é‘. ha: acfiequateiy aamgmzatefi aw: Saw.
`
`pmiimizaary and gmmsnen: injunczéve ra3ia:“ zagains: Efisfasafiam, imiuéirag an 6:9:-5533* m3_§.:}§n§r§g
`
`Qcfcnfisait frcsm usizxg the N'fiUR§E§Tg%_P;. Masks‘
`
`2%,
`
`Nertlrzsmz is infcsrmcé and be.-Eiaws am: an that
`
`afiéaggs that Befanéani has
`
`bfinfifiwé item it? §n§'ri'a1gm1::m cf 3\4's:ri§{:_:éar’s E‘=§i§R°EH.i‘3TfisE NEURGSCEEECE Made, mi‘:E\
`
`.=“e.z:«;<:~§§§a=.gZ:y'. Nortfismz“ -is emitieé ta-vu-um:.avn~v-,»n-
`-w.~uuuuuuuat0»nr:pI)-r-
`
`‘§S5a§=3§2dan2’s use af rim NELERCSSTAR Mark: has sazsseri as 55 §:?‘§:s:§;«' ms sause: mi 35% zziamaga
`r : wfiuraissw, inczuziing is in gmzafiwiiig mputgfim; am? its Marie,
`
`25,
`?§a§:2£§§"*f"s dszmagsa may be arcfiziaci gaursuam ms Setféfiars 35$} of 3:115 Lanham Ac§,
`
`SS ‘i§,$.{§. § EE§?{a} iamsszss, was iazfesrrszatioia gm bejief, Eisa-.:i‘c:s::§am“'s aafieus isaw: ma4.«a.~v4\—u»-at/«'5'awn
`
`x
`
`gnrnmitifitfi wE§if':£§§§€., wiih inteszz and fuifi 3<n$w§¢:§g¢ of the 4%?» N§URC3$CiENCE
`Mark amfi Na:-1hs22r’s rights in aha ‘N‘¢’.‘%R.‘i‘§§S‘E2<§E ‘SE-URQSCEENCE Mark. ‘amanei athar
`
`.
`
`T‘
`
`3 S
`
`3
`
`8*
`
`€21
`
`33
`
`3:9
`
`35
`2
`55
`
`g
`
`3§
`
`ii? ~:h§ng5..
`
`in asidfigiom, Narsfimar is emitieé §4} zceavcf Bef:wz:$Inn<;’s prszxfizs $125: zcasnaflrfie
`
`33 myaiiififis §§8fi§’,. as wezii as team affizés asifion and masafiabis s.:2:3s~::e3:“-*5 fess.
`E9
`
`2%
`
`23
`
`'
`
`
`3.5 15.5.-C. § Eififiiafi
`
`.
`E
`x» <
`Fiainfiff Nafihsmr reaéiegei anti §i":BA'§‘?§cZ‘ef3'\”§¢£ Evy mfesanae fifisiz §§i§:ge.=.ti»z3:a5 5:2‘;
`26..
`Q
`3 M gwagxaphsi iimsugh 35 as if€u§3y get fart}: hcmin.
`g
`2:;
`5
`F
`fle§3na$.&£‘;‘;“s use 5:’ sh: finfrirkgixzg NE‘%'.3RQSTa*§§, Mas-§»;5 in :::;3me;;i§§3:‘§ ssgiti:
`2?.
`24 E
`E §'3fi«:m:iant°5 gasmis and sawiees arm‘ miazaci gssmmczim-mi aczivéfica is §§‘3.-.»ai;,- :9 caum geafflziafl.
`I.
`
`
`
`ENJ-53%
`
` E
`
`.S.
`
`L‘
`
`
`
`co:-° asscsmieza with Nflfihstag; érd is .=5.§5r;3E
`§‘:1§$§a§<:=:, Di‘ dasapzimz as in affiiiaaian, mnszezafiatn.
`Kym
`Pips? €J$E 3.1.-Pmm
`§C<Z=?»»§?LA§N‘? a $*
`FE. Avaszua, zit: ,
`$&£1tie._WA ‘§3i£54$-‘.<‘G<§-€ QTQE: 2€}6.§39.¥:'7Ezi‘>§
`-a
`
`..
`
`3%
`
`u..uw~...,m,,....«.......
`
`

`
`
`
`E E 3a
`
`’€.3e§'e:sz_i;m:’g
`
`3302132 F
`
`E $25k.-3:3 ta zzzmsa cevmfuaizsn as in King erigin, sgmnsmsiaig, GE gggzrmvaé €35’
`|f‘=.JT
`3
`
`jsswices, :3: activities by NC:ri§“.Sm.§',, 33: 5:: vioiaticra sf S-r:Ei{»‘N‘§ :*a3{a} 233° t-‘tin: Lanizsm kc; iii
`a5.$.c;. § 222$}.
`
`? 3
`
`:
`
`28.
`
`1's: afiéiiisbfi, Be.f;~.m§a:1§*s use an" the: EEQSRQSYAR ‘Maris cunsiiizsfds :4 faifie
`
`sicségnaeiicm tsf crigin, {$53 533‘ zraisismigag éascrizsiizsii er“ fazzt.
`
`:31‘
`
`fsise:
`
`fir misieaéingé
`
`mpzaaenaaiian ca? faca which is i§Ec.:&§y ‘:3 came xcsnfusiazz: {§n<:-.i2.§v2§ng rwwerse ctzszfusizrfifls f‘«’-3'5?-9-35‘i‘~;~«-g-..-an”.-u-z-:r
`
`M- 9:‘ d$$§§)i3i3i2~ 33 $3 affiiiaiism, connsctim, es‘ assemiafiaa wifii 2\fs:'&'::.s<.:§s3 31:32 is afiscs 3§§c::§.}' m
`
`amass. zzsnfizsizm ES is the srprigin, spesasorsfixip, etsr a-;;§.smva%
`
`?3e:f::r=z5.a::‘t’s gaads; aawisas, err’
`
`3
`icaazseineparabiaharmmrwkzimNamzsmhashi?3.-fs€€§i,E3§%gammyat5.5132,Sn§3;a£,amsazragmks:
`
`activities, ‘:2! Nasflnsmr,
`
`33% in v§:»§a't.§cm af‘ S¢s*:£§«:>s§ 43$}
`
`§ Uiiia}.
`
`the ma-;-ham M2. 35 UES.
`s.
`
`..........«..»u-1
`
`29,
`
`§3=3f$z1zfim$’5 am 9? {ha 2\§E¥.fi“\’~G$°i“.e%.E’§ Marks hiss sawed smfi wiii cszmimse as
`
`M
`34 iaaid a'a§ua‘a§2 ’;:)~1‘€.‘.‘§‘.5'.-'.$f‘£_';y’ right whicfi ms nu yeaéifiy fiaiaminabie: E‘:'EE'3<2$§ wine; {ii} §r:fe:mfia::t"$
`
`things‘ {_§}t§1a: Qwnmfifigz cf $5: '3*J:’\‘:3R”1‘§~ZE'?A.¥~2. }°~§'?E.§,§I§’.£:3SE§"§§§’<§:"3E Mark aaassifitastaas a usaiguau.-...,,,....,..,...
`
`:3 Vacsiviiies aonfiiaute a sazbsaantiai izztarfaszsrssa WEE}: Ne:r:§zs€a:*°s
`
`g=:m»iwi‘sZ:‘ and ztfiatierrshiy with
`
`its cuaizamcrs, gizysicisns ané csrizsrs in fin‘. rsieciigua? aammunirg, gamma, v<:n§f.=§‘£=_. {E33 gemmi,...w.»;u.-.a-ax.yn-
`
`gubiics, 3:36 the: mafia; am: {iii} E.3:fer:+:¥arai’s activities, mi iim
`
`nzsuiiing :22 Nnfihsmr, art:
`
`ccmfiming.
`
`..<5s.cmn'i§ngEy, Nazi’-‘.X'飒£2u' és enstitiafi ifi vgreiizzsirarg am gamsmenz injanttiye ’£’(:§iE:'f.
`
`3%.
`
`As 3 resuk bf Bei'23:dant’s umwfzzi eerzfiuct, F§ai:1tE:”f ms inczzrravi éamagzs in
`
`_,,,,75,V,,v,flwmmnrz.vnwrn/n;n;»>w an argxnuné in Ex: pmvm at E3} sa;2us§;=:ting Qfi amsmg 43:23am’ §i$*s§s1gg, éiminutian is; @323 Vaéut ¥:§§
`
`and gmcsriwéfii a55m:33teé with E'is3,imif£"s ?‘3~5.3Ei”i‘iri$'i’A_’3:-Z NLELERQEEEENQE Mark- PE§§rzt3f§‘$
`
`aamages may 2:: trebieti pursuant ta Seczims 35%} :35 3:21: Lmham mi, 15 U.$.€.
`
`1:‘; H Wig}
`
`n e
`
`§::c§$s¢, 2:333: igxfermazian am bsafiaf, Eicfi:-33:§a:1t‘s aatisns ?§§\*‘€: ‘mm: somrraittad w§§§?1i§¥5’,‘Wi31§
`
`73%
`
`w,»
`
`KW-3
`
`rum
`
`>1
`
`
`
`
`
`Théil‘-«JLana“l'-.3
`
`,,.,,,..,,.,,.w,......«.-....,.......-,...u
`
`l:
`
`.-;.-..-.-.zx::.
`Nana//J6VaUB%flca95‘
`in addizien. Nezmsm Es‘
`«-11-!-
`ES R antifigfi ta rcc-ezevc? D¢§‘endan§’s gmzsfizs and mss<maE3E: mryaigim if any; as w';§E as €.“«23$tS afihis
`26
`aasim 332:2? rgasaaafiie :1m‘:z'2:ay“s fees.
`
`2%
`
`imam and fuii imewiadge «sf §£ori§1s3ar’s sights. ammg aim
`
`= QGMFLAEMT — 8
`
`vx u.w;-
`
`‘LEA Fiffifir L55 LL?
`‘Ni fiffli :‘w&nu8,, Sum: ?€3€§f,.*
`Sauitfis, WA SSEGA-T854 § Tagfi: 2{§5.83§.:33fl\'.\
`
`
`
`uuouwawvawxno-..w—.-I-van»
`
`

`
`
`
`:3
`
`.51
`
`112ix}
`
`4'3-
`
`U-‘I
`
`>3’;
`
`12:23.3; »v::w£é?sefI: ma RELEEF
`flanaeiimem sea’ Reg§3>fm£Em:
`ES i_?,Z*:‘a,€3.§1§i§
`
`3:.
`
`Fiairszifi’ Esiésrchazar reziisgag am §fi»t:}r§:;<rs5*:§ 53:; refereaza 335 a?ifig§'€'ifi?3S
`
`ii!
`
`Sa
`
`E
`
`.
`
`E
`u.
`, garagmpim i iimmgh 38 as if fully set -fem: izeraiza.
`Nnnhssa: is infcnmfi anfi'he§§(.=.'v§‘:§ am on gm»; §3&:i§s_‘$§§e,'§$S that in Br £'3c§>:3i53‘.§R
`32.
`Fétamarg W, 33835, Bcfenfiani flied an apggiicsaiimi Eu 7... Em-.r ‘ihfi mark NESRQSTAR with €312:
`
`EISFYG éa szomscutéan with pmdzmts ciasigmé E-:3 stimuiaze film fining 5§::ifimEi3«° “i‘:‘fiI§5C»§<EEk§3§
`
`
`
`: magnatic sfimuiatism fiévéscs cansisting sf 3; s':iszm£am:* am‘ .2 patient pesifiuning sysmmd
`nameiy, g ghair aw §g¢;s..is«e.=z.‘* The mags; waa ::s,r§.*n§ua§§y reg§5£es‘ad on flizscamfiar E93, 2935 (kg. é
`g
`m £3‘-‘ace. 3E8'?fi5=§-}.
`-
`33.
`is and wiii be éamgg»-;é 53;’ kid: segistétiaaz sf am
`
`‘F32-.§n?ifE beiieves it
`
`non-..ww......
`
`'mw.vm ~mw
`
`E gq,s;;;j§{o3§'2‘A§i mask xzzé ueienaazsvs ac:-minuaaz us: 9:? she: mark. as aéiagmfi. ahma, :m:§a<$§::g
`\
`
`am the EEG aasma mm; infringas Piaimifi‘-s §°=3§§§’§‘§€$TAi~1 Nauaasczmcfi Mm.
`
`Pursuarst to 35 5.§.§.C. § Eiiéh, Piaitzflfci‘ reagszcats that this: Céun‘ éticmiina fiaafig
`Edi.
`iha ‘i~§EU§.§}STAR mark infringes cs‘ :>‘-;E'.+:rw§::¢ cams fimage ‘T5 ?Ea§:':‘E‘:§’§' and its siqms Ea Rs:
`I:(5If,I
`%
`
`,‘£~2‘€}RTi-iS'1”fi.R NEURQSCEENCE Mark; ami oréer ma cmmiiatian uf ‘SEPTG Eegistratian
`
`3 E $'?§}.":4.
`
`iE i
`
`3?; RELEEIF
`FGURTE $3;
`Sfimman §_~aw Enfriagemeaé m Mair sifam peiétkm
`
`3:5.
`
`Plaintif?Nmfiazar reaifiégas ané Emfirgmraiefi by rafiranme fin‘:
`
`.=.3§’:gai¥=t=n‘5 Eng
`
`-~1r:.:£<’1VA:m.s-
`
`
`
`my5...;MCI(Ml
`
`g
`Em
`
`7». ~.J
`
`bx: W5
`
`39
`
`:
`K‘
`
`;°33rag:'a;s3:3§fi1r:*.=13g§&3*’~§ asiffixiiy satfafihfifimin.
`- -
`.
`r
`-.v
`,-.
`n
`e.
`‘
`a
`n
`3§,
`The famgamg ms :3; Defemi gm gensmuéefi am:-mgemen‘: and unfazr sm‘a’i§j%<:§i§t:§s‘:
`,,.,,;..,<...---,1’,
`
`.
`33 *. £23 vicfiavzgma cf’-the mmmgsn flaw czf aim state cfWaahiizgian.
`I
`
`EJEx!
`
`3
`E
`§
`
`1
`
`34
`:53;
`1;; *
`
`*aiq5$¥é::>£‘é mi éfirfiflfim €*fE
`E‘3e:fe:-swat‘: use 4'32’ fix», I%fE'§.TRC3ETi-°aR Eviariezs €16
`3?-
`;,;N'z}§*z.E1sia:’s mmrnasz {aw rights in $5 N*C3¥{‘f%§S':‘A"R "i‘*§E.UR=f§I€SCiEN§§ Maxkg maxi Es Eiktiy ifs;
`cause gaafgssisn, miséxke and deception azmmg sus€£'§E‘n€:.‘3£ mi the msbiie as $3 the mam,
`
`§‘3<}M?§..fi‘:?~f‘3" - 9
`
`.%:'.-.:¢=:ou:-
`
`Saatm.
`
`MA Piper igfi LL?
`‘Mia Fifth .-Gwgmm. Suit: ‘MW
`*§§S§'M—?‘='}4*§ E
`'§'eE:2v{-@839.-“:13-$33.2
`5
`
`..u:-.am«.w.v.»............u....a.n.u-/.y;aau::
`
`

`
`
`
` gr».ass, image arzei isfiury ta Mcsxfitsmr anti ti-as §::3§3~§i<:. Efifzfifififit knrfrw, :33‘ En {ha vaxargisza 22$
`
`E fifigiié. sgszczas-m-‘ship 9? quaiity af }~§:‘3§“£§’:2‘§&¥’3 gsarzcis am scwimé anti ‘sufiirwfis, *3“-fiI<‘8?e’E:’ imifiiflg
`
`1.
`
`3
`
`faassnabic tare seaauia: £1:-ms iszscwn, I312‘; 5:2 mzmgfizzg esmum was Eiazaeiy :5 mam the gumics
`
`»»
`
`é
`E
`
`EE
`
`:5
`53‘:
`
`‘
`
`.
`-
`sewigesiathéme:iié:a£<§§sv§cain::Z1atz}*_
`33,
`rsanhsm is infmmafi aaé isciicvcs and an ‘Gm ‘basis afieati rim 33% fcmssnifis
`
`.
`
`4gang!irmsasngageé‘in€312sate,masktiifig,‘x':1€'.°v‘3§$§§"!'!E.‘-!'§§,pumhasie3:’éiswihufianBE’pmfimzzsam
`
`my
`
`00
`
`“-321
`
`is
`1‘asr.
`
`azcsrgzfiuat by Defenéant has bean §<:msw§::g* éaiiheratz; wiiifzzi, ssaré with $23.2‘: kzmwimége fiiai it i3 4
`E i
`{E12332'»: cause mfistaice8%‘ac»sizzttiva, aririin éizsmgmfi af§’3®r€§‘§er\Ea$’s righis.
`‘
`323.
`As 2, :>as1a3tafDe§I~:n§az2%:’e %E3‘1§mA’f§.£i£fififi!.i(:€:-, 1\’::s:*tE:s:ar has beat: 32:‘: fifsntinimfi
`ii} its Ea: substantiaiiy and ix-rcparabiy
`if =_".8af*:;m§an:’s aimfs-sir égmgetfitficn am am 3223-.‘
`
`gmnnifisd is ztcziziszue, fizrthar damage am irregzarabie §§3._§i3§'§*‘ wiifi 33¢ siassmifififl ‘=33’ 3°30§'§?%5‘T-EL
`
`§'1‘£*.m:3.g§‘e such unfair am ms: usg car :1 aafifissingiy simiiar mark, 331$ vama af N»sr%hsm1*‘$..............a-w-;«~»--
`
`
`
`I»
`I
`23 .
`
`‘N
`
`SRTHSTAR PEEHRQSCEENEE Mark xvii‘; be £§§n'§§§§§s§‘§1:d
`
`fl$§§I*3”_:'-‘Efi,
`
`‘Ear $2-'§1§f::?‘i ifiiflfigfi
`
`I;
`‘.
`..
`
`2 §.
`
`Nmhstar canrm: be adaqzsamiy mmpansmea’ at iaw.
`
`5;
`
`4%}.
`
`Nafiisstar ix infszrgssafl and bs§i»W<‘.:£ and am ma: mix aiicgns iimi B;$§'»2‘s3€3a.a:<; has
`
`4;, wm:mA.~wgmmm
`
`-
`
`~
`
`': 335-‘, Defasmtfiaxzfs ccniéuuéug vicziafssm mi’ it rigms as set frisriii
`
`iikaiy is mm 3955 mi éamaga m Eaiarixsiari Enaiudiszg Sis: gear-giwifii, rségaiaziazz and E35 Esfizsflna in
`
`aszévsd uniawfai ggima «Jr §3am:fit$ imam its tmiawffii NE» E3 Rigfififii %§fiF‘-“¢» fififi 3135 933555» ‘PF 35
`«.m.-/numw.
`
`an mafia: as ye£s1s:§I.n:>‘¥'!:*$: fisut is; E»: pmvcza at 't:'ia§.
`
`4%.
`
`‘nu
`‘:?*l-1\r£3:2m: 215;: ms zdequata «remaéy 3.: Raw fir, amiifi Ewing irmgaxatsfiy harmed‘
`
`Lmiess ficfcmians is assficrimzd by
`
`89:331.
`REQBESE ma 321333
`
`P7; am}. ‘such ham'm&-'§§’E cmfiinus
`E
`
`
`
`3......{.-x,,,-----:--v
`
`-anpad7-»!‘bI393-we1‘13:9.
`
`;e._;(“-1L42:
`-M£25-
`2::
`E
`W§§EREFG'?~E._NnfiinsiatgmysEm‘miisfasfisiiami
`:33
`L
`T?2:a§ Qefendanz E35 Kaé;'m"£ga§ “in Ezave infiisagcd Na-2:t§1siar‘s NQETEESTARE
`Es:
`25 ENEURQSCEEHQE Mark fin visiazisn at‘feéerai anti Wasfiingmn same iaswa
`
`3
`€R°.!~MPLAiI~£“s‘
`
`
`
`Z...--...7..":':.-.~2:<4“
`
`.. ace
`
`£3-LA. P§;§:r :33 LL?
`_
`3%} §*‘§f:%2 .«‘we*:s.z:=:, Suite '?*}5fi
`Saatiie. ‘:\’$‘x
`‘E-‘$113!-’$»-":'€3£$
`§ Tai; 2$95,§35‘.éEt‘3§'3
`V
`
`E
`
`E
`
`

`
`
`
`<
`
`i s :§ : E§5 :
`
`2.
`
`T313‘; Qafsficiafifi
`
`ii: aéjudgeef.
`
`2:‘: haves W§Z§fi;§§:e’ and §;¢§§33¢§&i'.3§§” ésgfyifiggzj
`
`.3‘-.>r3.§:a€ar'°s
`
`}*~Ei}R’§‘VH§‘§‘AR NE’Z.§RG$C3§.;.z‘fiE3 Mari»: in viaéarisn of f'€:z‘§~Sfa§ an-i Washingmn
`
`esiaiti aw;
`
`3.
`
`Thai Efifanémil be fijufigfiéé fer; ffiavez zzaampgiaé uwfesirsy wizh Eemsm am? used
`
`5 €323: cissiguazian afwrigin in vioiatiera {if fedaérai and Waafiiagaan staic Em-M;
`
`Ia«.auu.x.maau.y.~.wasm««;mwuvgmg.;x
`
`4.
`That flefandam: be asifiégesi an haw.-» wiiifgiéy and afisiiizcmatciy uscé E35335
`,§*55i§33533*3i‘é5 51'? 5?§§§fi
`€315
`tfifiiiiémi ‘-Hfiiriy Wm: 1?*~§<)s’z§:s€s:r
`in viaiatim a.~,f_f:&asaE :9:-2§§
`Washéngmn gaze Haw;
`
`5.
`
`That fisfsnéant. its affiicars, ag;-mas, stnranis,
`
`jgfiayeas 355$ xii pmaszs acting
`
`nu
`
`.2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`:§
`
`
`
`W5‘'00‘
`
`-.1.-ow.-.-ac:
`
`
`AV’-vs-I.-v0('r«-;-;:.
`ciaimirsg 29 as: in aencesi 2»: in mfificipatian wétfi £2 at’ any ef 1‘-mm, be preiimisieriijg am
`
`.,._.._..._...—_.
`:2:
`=§ mrmanenfly
`tnjfiinati
`tam §©5?.£‘&§§'§§s2§
`fmm §n§’.r§ng€3:g_
`3'~Eu:.=::§2sta:’5
`133C%RT§{STAR.‘
`hr
`‘:13 ‘EEURQECEENCE Mark Ea any manner is ifie gzmmetica-2, xziinisai
`‘icsfing,
`c.?§5'2:E?.::.:’:i:2§i,§
`
`_,.,,-:,z
`1-«an gszsrszizast. aiivfiréifiing er gait: vi‘ B<:fr:n§am°s gfirfiiiessié 232:: 5::‘§'»s'§c::3, 313$, in parzimiazg mm;
`
`a: cf-aiming :9 3;: on its bahaif under its éirantisxs €33’ ausi*sm‘ii§, afagi ali g:~s;-sans acting :3:
`
`3.5
`
`using the E-EEUE{{f':$TAE. Marks:
`
`35
`
`3?‘
`
`6.
`
`fin: D:f::':ém';. as nflficers, agants. smmts. smgaiayees and 212‘; persons smug
`
`cs‘ aiaiming is fact an fiis hcfiaif zmécr its fiirguiian -12>? agthssityg and $3 §:a:‘sakxs wing at
`
`33 ggiaiming tr: act in camtcrt «car in pariicipaiian wifiz it 92' any sf fixam,
`
`‘cm mrmanmaiy gsngssm
`
`Z?
`'L‘»!J¥§’i§3&E1CiE‘§$§?.‘§‘<‘3§§£u‘.§i’ag is use sf -:§-s:«_:;\
`and rasizsineé farm :2: zngaging in 3:25:
`\
`_
`A
`V:
`,
`E
`23 €‘§~£EU1?.%TAR Marks :1; any mamer, is: Eh: msmzicn, qiinims aesting, distvibusaztsn, gsuraufzasm
`
`saf ssnfair
`
`ii
`
`aiivérf-Zsing GE‘ saint sf Efiefenfiasvfg gagsmjs gm Eggs;
`‘7
`an
`Tim Bc"s's‘.n&an$ he rtqairad is mm mm: smei gis:.§§v¢:= 23;} star. ska éemra 23:‘ is .=3.
`T53 jfiougtaéeségnaété gmrge tinting :31: gsesradmcy 9? mix wiszm aii Enfrinaging zzxezeriais in thair‘
`
`E4 . sustedy ané ma-Ami {inciufiizsg rmmds régaséizzg mastufaciurss mi rsmxktsting} and 3%? mmflsg
`25 Euxsed Ea mks infréngmg matariaisj 3 wcié as 5:221: evm amt"; eisiiver zmy md 3