throbber
Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`The '715 Patent discloses "a ‘desktop’ and icon configuration" as an example
`
`homeview configured to organize a plurality of content modes. EX-1001, 21:14-
`
`15, 22:10-21; VIA. Figure 2-2 of Pogue (below) discloses the Windows XP
`
`desktop, including the taskbar (outlined in ree), icons (Recycle Bin icon,circled in
`
`Sine), and Start Menu (outlined in grees). EX-1006, 23, 88.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The "content modes" limitation is construed in VII.B. The '715 Patent
`
`discloses "media mode"that "provide[s] access to a media[] player" and "web
`
`mode"that "provide[s] access to internet browsing" as example content modes.
`
`EX-1001, 21:20-35. Poguediscloses that the Start menu includes elementsthat,
`
`whenselected, "open programs" such as "Windows Media Player" (outlined in
`
`purpic) and "Internet Explorer" (outlined in 2:05). EX-1006, 23-24; EX-1007,
`-64-
`
`Page 854 of 1709
`
`Page 854 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`4223. Windows MediaPlayer plays media content. EX-1006, 216. Internet
`
`Explorer provides access to internet content through its internet browsing
`
`capabilities. See VIHI.C.12. Further, shortcut icons for each of these that provide
`
`the same access can be placed on the desktop. EX-1006, 125-126. Thus, Pogue
`
`discloses the "media" and "web" content mode examples disclosed in the '715
`
`Patent.
`
`Accordingly, Pogue discloses a home view (desktop) configured to organize
`
`a plurality of content modes (selectable Windows Media Player and Internet
`
`Explorer icons). EX-1007, 221-224.
`
`b.
`
`"channel view"
`
`The '715 Patent discloses "a ‘photo frame’ channel" as an example channel
`
`view configured to organize at least one of a single content mode and two content
`
`modes. EX-1001, 21:48-51, 54:20-25; VIA; EX-1007, 9225. Pogue discloses that
`
`"[y]ou can view files and folders in a desktop window in any of several ways."
`
`EX-1006, 74. "Filmstrip view ... turns the folder window into a slide show
`
`machine." EX-1006, 74,591. E.g., when viewing a folder with picture files in
`
`Filmstrip view, the "enlarged image" or "slide show"portion (sei below in Figure
`
`7-2) "showsthe currently selected photo." EX-1006, 209; EX-1007, 9225.
`
`-65-
`
`Page 855 of 1709
`
`Page 855 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`eneercrigytty
`
`aeoeea
`
`~~~WS cae
`
`<
`SERS
`So
`fy
`MERE: CA
`
`ii
`
`Thus, Pogue's filmstrip view (of a folder with imagefiles) discloses an example
`
`channel view asrecited in the '715 Patent. EX-1007, 9225-226.
`
`As another example of content modes, the '715 Patent discloses a "connect
`
`mode"that "provide[s] access to features such as" email and an "application mode"
`
`that provides access to "computer applications or programs." EX-1001, 21:20-38.
`
`Pogue discloses a task pane ontheleft of the folder (outlined in !:<) that provides
`
`selectable elements (one-click links) to locations, functions, or tasks. EX-1006,
`
`67-69; EX-1007, 9227. E.g., when selected, the "E-mail this file" (outlined in
`
`ercer: above) link "automatically launches your email program”(1.e., connect
`
`mode) and the "My Computer" (outlined in purpis below) link in the "Other
`
`-66-
`
`Page 856 of 1709
`
`Page 856 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Places" portion (outlined in «:
`
`« above and below) opensthat location, whichis
`
`
`"the doorwayto every single shred of software on your machine"(1.e., application
`
`mode), each of which allowsthe user to access the content therein. EX-1006, 51,
`
`67-69, 213; EX-1007, 227.
`
`Thus, Pogue's "E-mail this file" and "My Computer"links in the task pane of
`
`a filmstrip folder view disclose the example connect and application content modes
`
`that are organized in a channel view asrecited in the '715 Patent. EX-1007, 9227-
`
`228
`
`Accordingly, Pogue discloses the additional limitation of Claim 2 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See VUI.A.1, VHIA.2,
`
`VIIL.C.1; EX-1007, 99225-229.
`
`-67-
`
`Page 857 of 1709
`
`Page 857 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`3.
`
`Claim 3
`
`The '715 Patent discloses a "photo frame" channel in the channel content
`
`modethat can "display a pre-selected image or set of images." EX-1001, 21:41-57.
`
`Pogue discloses a screen saver view that can be composed of photographs(the
`
`photo frame channel is the content organized in the selected channel content mode)
`
`that turn into an automatic slide show (passive viewing) whenever your computer
`
`is not in use. EX-1006, 214, 263; EX-1007, 9230; VHI.A.3.
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitation of Claim 3 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See VIII.A.1-VHIA.2,
`
`VUHI.C.1; EX-1007, 9230-231.
`
`4.
`
`Claim 4
`
`Pogue discloses a home viewthat includes a "taskbar," "[t]he permanent
`
`blue stripe across the bottom of your screen" (sei box below in Figure 2-2). EX-
`
`1006, 88; VHI.C.2. A POSITA would understand this to correspond to the claimed
`
`"header display [that] comprises a lateral frame extending from the left of the
`
`display componentto the nght of the display component."
`
`-68-
`
`Page 858 of 1709
`
`Page 858 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`8 meee Be 333
`
`| Serene
`
`Sean
`
`SS LS,
`
`Further, while not shown in Figure 2-2, the taskbar can be movedto the top
`
`of the display screen, 1.e., above the portion outlined in blue. /d., 92-93. A
`
`POSITA would have understood this to correspond to the claimed "body display
`
`[being] rendered below the header display in the display componentof the
`
`computer system." Additionally, this home view is capable of "organizing a
`
`plurality of visual representations of digital content" as claimed, including the
`
`"icons"(like the "Recycle Bin") or the items and menusin the "Start menu(like the
`
`"All Programs" menu). EX-1006, 23, 30, Figure 2-2 (zrses outlines); EX-1007,
`
`233.
`
`-69-
`
`Page 859 of 1709
`
`Page 859 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitation of Claim 4 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See VIUI.A.1-VIUI.A.2,
`
`VIIIC.1; EX-1007, 9[232-234.
`
`5.
`
`Claim 5
`
`The Shimura-Tsuji Computer can be used in various configurations based on
`
`the physical position of the display componentrotated around a base component
`
`that includes a keyboard about a longitudinal axis, such as Shimura's two axes(resi
`
`dashedlines) of the dual-axis hinge assembly ({u<box) in Figure 2 below or
`
`Tsuji's single axis (sei dashed line) of a single-axis hinge assembly (ius box) in
`
`FIG. 1 below. EX-1007, 9235-236; VUI.B.1.
`
`-70-
`
`Page 860 of 1709
`
`Page 860 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
` Rage ee eeee Rae
`SSNnana
`
`SSAA,
`*.
`marth ar
`
`
`
`
`%
`
`
`
`
`pansppcnstticant?:errHaber
`ona>4
`peeTTIPEPPPPIITLAMAnDTtAscinggy.
`
`
`
`Laan
`
`s
`
`Both of these hinge assemblies were well-knownintheart at the Critical
`
`Date. EX-1007, 99235-237.
`
`Therefore, Shimura-Tsuji combination discloses the additional limitation of
`
`Claim 5 and the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See
`
`VII.A.1-VUIA.2, VHI.C.1; EX-1007, 99[235-238.
`
`6.
`
`Claim 6
`
`a.
`
`Limitation [6a]
`
`-71-
`
`Page 861 of 1709
`
`Page 861 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`As explained in Claim 4, Pogue's taskbar discloses the "header display."
`
`Further, Pogue's address bar (in the taskbar) discloses the claimed "search tool
`
`displayed in the header display" that is "configured to accept search terms entered
`
`by auser. EX-1006, 86-87, 96. Pogue explains that certain taskbar toolbars,
`
`including the address bar, operate the same as the window toolbars "except that
`
`they appear in the taskbarat all times." EX-1006, 96. The address bar (outlined in
`
`veel in Figure 2-15 below) is where you can typeall kinds of search commands,
`
`such as a web address, a search phrase, a folder name, or a program or path name.
`
`EX-1006, 86-87, 95.
`
`
` WwconcerneoEEE
`
`
`
`
`Sa
`
`biog
`LandbY
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses [6a]. EX-1007, 9239-240.
`
`b.
`
`Limitation [6b]
`
`-72-
`
`Page 862 of 1709
`
`Page 862 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Poguediscloses that when a "search phrase" is typed into the addressbar,
`
`"Windowsassumesthat you're telling it, 'Go online and search for this phrase.’
`
`From here, it works exactly as though you've used the Internet search feature."
`
`EX-1006, 86. Asillustrated in Figure 2-16 of Pogue below, once you enter your
`
`search phrase and hit the search button, the computer system "goes online and
`
`submits that request to" the selected search page, such as MSN Search, Google, or
`
`Yahoo. EX-1006, 46-47. Then the selected search page "shows youtheresults of
`
`its search: a list of Web pages containing the text you typed." /d.
`
`-73-
`
`Page 863 of 1709
`
`Page 863 of 1709
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`PEEEEELELSesA
`nant
`
`OoYE Ss
`
`Moet
`Fan
`EMR
`See
`emotng:
`
`
`
`
` Re
`Re}
`&=
`RS
`
`
`
`S“
`
`LLLPOSSIPLETSTYCAMoy
`
`
`
`LEEPLELLLLEPLLLLLELLPLEPLELPLELLLELLELLLLTELTELEY
`
`¥ M
`
`
`
`
`SESS
`
`Miotheg
`
`
`
`Sess
`
`SSSR
`
`Thus, Pogue discloses that entering the claimed "search terms" (Pogue's
`
`search phrase) into the search tool (Pogue's "address bar") "causes the computer
`
`system to navigate to a view ofa first visual representation of digital content,
`
`wherein the digital content includes a search engine"(1.e., the search page in
`
`Pogue's "Internet search feature"). EX-1006, 46-47, 86; EX-1007, 9241.
`
`-74-
`
`Page 864 of 1709
`
`Page 864 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitations of Claim 6 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See VIII.A.1-VHIA.2,
`
`VII.C.1; EX-1007, 9239-242.
`
`7.
`
`Claim 7
`
`The '715 Patent discloses that when a "navigation element" is executed, the
`
`computer system "transitions the ... display to a previous view," which can
`
`include: (1) the "home view"if the "present view"is not the "home view"; or (2)
`
`the "previous view"if the "present view is the home view." EX-1001, 8:10-15,
`
`46:12-20. As discussed in Claim 2, Pogue's desktop discloses a "homeview,"
`
`which can act as "a placemat." EX-1006, 258; EX-1007, 99221-224, 243. A
`
`POSITA would have understood this to mean that if items are placed on the
`
`desktop in a certain location, that specific arrangement(1.e., view) is retained such
`
`that when a user returns to the desktop, that specific arrangement(1.e., view) 1s
`
`displayed. EX-1007, 9243. Additionally, as explained in VIII.C.8, Pogue
`
`discloses that a display of windowsdiscloses a "previous view." Therefore,
`
`Pogue's desktop and display of windowsdiscloses at least two examples of a
`
`"retain[ed] previous view state." /d.
`
`Further, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses a "storage
`
`component"(1.¢., hard disc drive or RAM)configuredto retain the "previous view
`
`-75-
`
`Page 865 of 1709
`
`Page 865 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`state" because it would haveat least long term (hard drive) and short term storage
`
`(RAM) to store the "previous view state." EX-1007, 9244.
`
`Therefore, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses the additional
`
`limitation of Claim 7 and renders it obvious. See VII.A.1, VUI.A.2, VUI.C.1; EX-
`
`1007, 9243-245.
`
`8.
`
`Claim 8
`
`Poguedisclosesat least two examples of the function recited in Claim 8.
`
`See VII.A.3.
`
`a.
`
`First Example Disclosure
`
`Pogue discloses a "present view" (a view of windows), shownin Figure 2-14
`
`of Pogue below (one example window outlinedin :sx}), that is not the "home view"
`
`(the desktop). EX-1006, 65; EX-1007, 247.
`
`Le
`ueHEELEEst
`
`Page 866 of 1709
`
`Page 866 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`EX-1006, 91. Pogue also disclosestransitioning from this "present view"to a
`
`"previous view,” which is the "home view" (desktop). E.g., Pogue discloses that
`
`"It]o minimizeall the windowsin one fell swoop, right-click a blank spot on the
`
`taskbar and choose Show the Desktop [outlined in see] from the shortcut menu."
`
`EX-1006, 92 & Figure 2-15 (below).
`
`
`
`
`Additionally, Pogue discloses that a "Show Desktop" button (outlined in vss!)
`
`with the same functionality can be added to the "Quick Launch Toolbar" in the
`
`Taskbar. EX-1006, 94-96 & Figure 2-16 (below); EX-1007, 99[248-249.
`
`-77-
`
`Page 867 of 1709
`
`Page 867 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`
`
`Therefore, "Show the Desktop" and "Show Desktop" are each "navigation
`
`element[s]" that transition from a "present view" (display of windows) to a
`
`"previous view"that is the "home view" (desktop) upon execution. EX-1007,
`
`9247-250.
`
`b.
`
`Second Example Disclosure
`
`Whenthe display transitions from the display of windowsto the desktop, the
`
`display of windows becomesthe "previous view." EX-1007, 9251. Pogue
`
`discloses that at that point, "the taskbar shortcut menu alwaysincludes an Undo
`
`commandfor the last taskbar command you invoked ... 'Undo Minimize All,’
`
`[outlined in sexi] for example." EX-1006, 92 & Figure 2-15 (below).
`
`-78-
`
`Page 868 of 1709
`
`Page 868 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`;
`
`AS
`
`.
`
`If "Undo Minimize All" is selected, the display will transition to the display of
`
`windowsthat waspreviously displayed. EX-1007, 99]251-252. Accordingly,
`
`Pogue discloses a "navigation element" (Undo Minimize All) that transitions from
`
`a "present view" that is the "home view" (desktop) to a "previous view"that 1s not
`
`the "home view"(display of windows) upon execution. /d.
`
`Second, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses the corresponding
`
`structure for Claim 8, including (1) an I/O controller 214 (outlined in se<}) operating
`
`on a processor that communicates with devices connected thereto, such as an
`
`EC/KBC 118 (outlined in Sine) connected to various input devices (outlined in
`
`green) or a BIOS-ROM 217 (outlined in «::s:2::) running a BIOS program 301
`
`(outlined in purpic), as depicted in FIGs. 13-14 of Tsuji. EX-1005, 963-70.
`
`-79-
`
`Page 869 of 1709
`
`Page 869 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`System
`controlar
`
`
`
`3
`SAARSw 4
`
`—~ 304
`
`:
`:
`
`
`YPPLELLLELLALLIELSELSELEPLLILLSELSELSELLILLILLSALSELSBe
`
`EPPEPEPELPELESELPEPELELPELEPELPEPELELLDnm™meonoy
`.
`Audio controtter
`
`D
`i
`ne BlOS-ROM
`a
`gooey |
`
`
`
`Oo)_ ms a\SOEPEEELEESDPPEEELDEESSDPPPELEESS:
`ge
`:My
`
`YPLLILLLLLLLLLILLSTLLTLLSSISDy
`
`SRFx
`Raceumamunnnamnnunenmeereentien
`=
`1
`
`Sx8shes|Dp
`LEAPED
`
`
`EC/KBC
`Tourh pact
`SISILLSLS
`LALO
`
`a
`segeens
`Be
`RRR tAN Bs SISSIES
`PDA style
`sensing switch
`
`140 controller
`
`D MIC
`JK Speaker
`
`{
`
`—-
`
`200
`
`= 202
`
`8s88
`
`SRR
`
`
`
`VELLLLLLELS
`
`rn=a .o
`
`Card controller
`
`Rotation
`angie sensor
`
`—— 203
`
`
`
`: Gravity sensor
`
`_ one2
`
`
`| PDA style
`=f}
`
`| Sensing switch
`
`
`~~ 208
`Rotation
`angle sensor
`
`=|
`
`
` SPLILTIDTLISLIOTLITTISTIITLODYLLLLLLLLPELEYy
`~~aSELLPISISESLDisplay driver
`
`
`[ * Rotation |
`\« Sealing
`PPLAATAATTATA
`
`"gCAAT TTS
`
`Page 870 of 1709
`
`Page 870 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`A POSITA would have understood that the I/O controller of Tsuji contains
`
`program(s) sufficient to (11) determine whether input received from the input
`
`devices indicates that a navigation element (of Pogue) was executed and (111)
`
`transition the display accordingly (1.e., to Pogue's home view orprevious view)
`
`
`
`through the BIOS program and display driver 303 (outlined in (i<3:¢ &:<), similar
`
`to the display inversion discussed in VIII.B.2.g. EX-1007, 9253.
`
`Accordingly, the Shimura-Tsuji combination renders Claim 8 obvious. See
`
`VIUILA.1-VULA.2, VII.C.1; EX-1007, 9925 1-254.
`
`9,
`
`Claim 9
`
`The "Show Desktop" icon in the "Quick Launch Toolbar" of the taskbar is a
`
`"navigation element." EX-1006, 94-96; VIII.C.8. Further, Pogue discloses a
`
`"header display" in the form of the taskbar. VII.C.4. Therefore, a POSITA would
`
`have understood that the Show Desktop icon ("navigation element") is in the
`
`taskbar that is part of the "header display." EX-1007, 9255.
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitation of Claim 9 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders it obvious. See VIII.A.1-VHIA.2,
`
`VUHI.C.1; EX-1007, 9255-256.
`
`10.
`
`Claim 10
`
`a.
`
`Limitation [10a]
`
`-8]-
`
`Page 871 of 1709
`
`Page 871 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Poguediscloses a "body display" that can "organiz[e] the plurality of visual
`
`representations" of computer content, such as itemsin the Start Menu.’ VIII.C.4.
`
`b.
`
`Limitation [10b]
`
`The '715 Patent discloses that "[t]he maximal display threshold governs the
`
`number of GUI elements displayed per home view page.... The device generates a
`
`new pagedisplay" when the maximaldisplay threshold is exceeded." EX-1001,
`
`33:36-44. That is, a "display page" is a new display of content created when the
`
`current display cannot display any more GUI elements. EX-1007, 99257-258.
`
`Poguediscloses two examples of these "display pages."
`
`a.
`
`First Example Disclosure
`
`Figure 2-6 of Pogue (below) discloses how the "All Programs menu"
`
`appears (outlined below in res). EX-1006, 29-30.
`
`’ Petitioner assumes, for purposesofthis Petition only, that "the plurality of visual
`
`representation of computer content" limitation in claim 10 is intendedto refer to "a
`
`plurality of visual representations of digital content" in claim 4 as its antecedent
`
`basis.
`
`-89-
`
`Page 872 of 1709
`
`Page 872 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Although not shown, when "there are too many programslisted to fit on the screen
`
`... asecond All Programs menu appearsto the right of the first one, continuing the
`
`list." EX-1006, 58. Because this second All Programs menu appears when too
`
`many programsarelisted to fit on the screen(1.e., "display threshold establishing a
`
`maximal numberof visual representations"), the first All Programs menu and the
`
`second All Programs menu (not shown) are two separate display pages. EX-1007,
`
`4259. (The menu displayedto the right of the "All Programs menu"is a Microsoft
`
`Office Tools submenu, not the "second All Programs menu.")
`
`b.
`
`Second Example Disclosure
`
`-83-
`
`Page 873 of 1709
`
`Page 873 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Poguedisclosesthat "scroll bar[s] signal[] to you that the window isn't big
`
`enoughto revealall of its contents ... [p]ress the Page Up or Page Downkeysto
`
`scroll the window by one 'windowful.'"" EX-1006, 67. Each windowfulin the
`
`scrolled content constitutes a "display page" because these scrollable pages are
`
`created when the "display threshold establishing a maximal numberof visual
`
`representations displayed per page" is reached. EX-1007, 9260. These scrollable
`
`pages appearin the All Programs menuasan alternative to the "second All
`
`Programs menu" from the first example. EX-1006, 58. E.g., when "there are too
`
`many programslisted to fit on the screen,” the user can turn on the "Scroll
`
`Programs" option and then "all your programs appear [] on one massive, scrolling
`
`programs list" (outlined in ses) indicated by a "tiny black triangle arrow (at the top
`
`or bottom of the menu)," as shown on page 58 (below). EX-1006, 30, 58.°
`
`® The picture on page 58 of Pogueis a depiction of the "Classic (single-column)
`
`Start menu" that a user can change to from the default (depicted in Figure 2-6
`
`above). EX-1006, 55, 58. Pogue discloses that the "Scroll Programs" feature of
`
`the default Start menu, which includesthe "tiny black triangle arrow (at the top or
`
`bottom of the menu)" is based on the "programs menu of Windows gone by." EX-
`
`1006, 30. Therefore, a POSITA would have understood that the "Classic"
`
`programs menu and black triangle arrows depicted on page 58 of Pogue is similar
`
`-84-
`
`Page 874 of 1709
`
`Page 874 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`SSLAT
`
`xz=
`
` TiEEEpaepanapeaneanpnnnnppannns
`
`
`— $$
`
`ooemv2neG:a..geCLLLLILLLALLTELELLALUTUNELTADTLSEALE
`
`Ceee:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitation of Claim 10 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders obviousthe claim. See VIII.A.1-
`
`VIILA.2, VUIC.1; EX-1007, 9257-261.
`
`11. Claim11
`
`The All Programs menu can be separated into multiple, scrollable display
`
`pages when there are too many programsto list. See VIII.C.10. When this "Scroll
`
`Programs" feature is turned on, "you can scroll the list by pointing to the tiny black
`
`to how the default Windows XP All Programs menu would look with the "Scroll
`
`Programs" feature turned on. EX-1007, 9260.
`
`-85-
`
`Page 875 of 1709
`
`Page 875 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`triangle arrow." EX-1006, 30. Page 58 of Pogue depicts an example of how this
`
`"tiny black triangle arrow" (outlined in ret) may look: <
`
`EX-1006, 58.2 A POSITA would have understoodthat the "tiny black triangle
`
`arrow"is an "indication of visual representations displayed on adjacent display
`
`pages of the home view." EX-1007, 9262.
`
`Whenthe taskbar is at the top of the display screen, the body display extends
`
`to the bottom of the display screen. EX-1006, 30, Figure 2-2 below; EX-1007,
`
`4263; Claim 4. As such, the tiny black triangle arrow will be "displayed within the
`
`° See note 8.
`
`-86-
`
`Page 876 of 1709
`
`Page 876 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`body of the home view"as claimed. E.g., below is an Annotated Figure 2-2 of
`
`Pogue that showsthe "Scroll Programs" version of the All Programs menu
`
`(outlined in «*:::::::) superimposed over the All Programs menuoriginally depicted
`
`(outlined in vex!). The body of the home view is outlined in Sie and, although not
`
`shown in Annotated Figure 2-2, the taskbar can be movedto the top of the display
`
`screen, i.e., above the portion outlined in S!ue. EX-1006, 92-93; Claim 4.'!° In
`
`Annotated Figure 2-2, the tiny black arrow (outlined below in grees) which
`
`discloses the "indication of visual representations displayed on adjacent display
`
`pages" is displayed within the body (outlined in Sie) of the home view.
`
`'0 The solid blue outlines in the superimposed Scroll Programs menu(outlined in
`
`aveece:) depict the bounds of the "body of the home view" were the original All
`
`Programs menuin Figure 2-2 replaced with the Scroll Programs menu.
`
`-87-
`
`Page 877 of 1709
`
`Page 877 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`
`
`
`
`
` ae-=o
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitations of Claim 11 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders obviousthe claim. See VIII.A.1-
`
`VIII.A.2, VII.C.1; EX-1007, 9262-264
`
`12.
`
`Claim 12
`
`a.
`
`Limitation [12a]
`
`The '715 Patent discloses "system cards [that] provide and display
`
`computer system functionality that maybe [sic] frequently accessed during
`
`ordinary computer use[]," which "include nascent cards" such as "'Browsethe
`
`Web' card." EX-1001, 35:19-21; 38:62-64. A POSITA would have understood
`
`that the "nascent card" recited in Claim 12 includes a system functionality that
`
`allows a user to "browse the web." EX-1007, 4265.
`-88-
`
`Page 878 of 1709
`
`Page 878 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`Poguediscloses that "Internet Explorer,"
`
`mon
`
`"the most famous Web browser"is
`
`"built right into the operating system." EX-1006, 337. A POSITA would have
`
`understood that "Internet Explorer" is system functionality that allows a user to
`
`browse the web. EX-1007, 9266. Pogue further discloses that a user can access
`
`Internet Explorer by "[c]hoosing its name from the Start menu," shown below in
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`:
`
`ei
`
`
`
`Figure 2-3 (outlined in vex}). EX-1006, 338, 24.
`:
`=
`:
`3
`g
`=
`
`
` 2 Soka!
`
`BY Sergiy
`
`
`
`Poguealso discloses that users can access Internet Explorer by "[c]licking its
`
`shortcut on the Quick Launch toolbar," as shown below in Figure 2-16 (outlined
`
`below in ius). EX-1006, 338, 96.
`
`-89-
`
`Page 879 of 1709
`
`Page 879 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
` SS
`
`The "Start menu" and Quick Launch toolbar are part of the desktop whichis
`
`a"home view.” See VIII.C.2, VIII.C.6.
`
`Therefore, a POSITA would have understood that these options for
`
`accessing Internet Explorer disclose [12a]. EX-1007, 9265-268.
`
`b.
`
`Limitation [12b]
`
`The '715 Patent discloses that in "one alternative, new visual representation
`
`may be generated" by "a hyperlink directing a computer system to display [a]
`
`linked web page in a new window." EX-1001, 41:4-8. A POSITA would have
`
`understood that a "web page" is an example of a "visual representation of digital
`
`content.” EX-1007, 4269.
`
`Internet Explorer icons on the desktop disclose the nascent card. See
`
`VII.C.12.a. Pogue further discloses that once Internet Explorer 1s accessed, "the
`
`Internet Explorer windowisfilled with tools that are designed to facilitate a
`
`smooth trip around the World Wide Web." EX-1006, 338. An example is
`
`disclosed in Figure 11-1 (below) where "the Address bar[:s<i below], [] displays
`
`-9()-
`
`Page 880 of 1709
`
`Page 880 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`the address (URL) of the Web page [S!xe below] you're currently seeing." EX-
`
`
`1006, 338.
`
`eee
`
`SRESKS
`SARE
`SVENNVVNV
`
`ries
`
`
`
`SSEBSSSSDARRENSSSRADASRRKRRNNENARAN,
`
`A POSITAwould have understoodthis to disclose a "nascent card" (Internet
`
`Explorer icon) "configured to permit generation of additional visual representations
`
`of digital content" (ability to browse web pages on Internet Explorer). EX-1007,
`
`9269-271.
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitations of Claim 12 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders obvious the claim. EX-1007, §265-
`
`272.
`
`-9]-
`
`Page 881 of 1709
`
`Page 881 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`13.
`
`Claim 13
`
`a.
`
`Function
`
`The Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses the function of Claim 13
`
`identified in VIL.A.4.
`
`(1)
`
`Limitation [13a]
`
`Pogue discloses a process for creating a "visual representation" (a web page
`
`that allows a user to access web content) "in response to execution of the nascent
`
`card" (an Internet Explorer icon on the desktop). EX-1006, 337-338; EX-1007,
`
`9265-274; VIILC.12.
`
`(2)
`
`Limitation [13b]
`
`Pogue discloses that the Internet Explorer window (a quick access view),
`
`depicted below in Figure 11-1, includes the "links bar" (outlined below in rex), the
`
`Addressbar (outlined below in Sius), and the favorites menu (outlined below in
`
`aresn). EX-1006, 338.
`
`-9)-
`
`Page 882 of 1709
`
`Page 882 of 1709
`
`

`

`(eee
`
`Mcptatbotsedee
`Mtl
`IDEYTITTASTPEE:
`
`gar
`
`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`ST
`
`The "links toolbar" is "one way to maintain a list of Web sites you visit
`
`frequently." EX-1006, 342. The "address bar" discloses that "[W]hen you type a
`
`new Webpage address (URL) into this strip and press Enter, the corresponding
`
`Website appears." EX-1006, 340. The favorites menu "showsthe list of Web
`
`pages you've 'bookmarked' whenusing Internet Explorer." EX-1006, 582.
`
`Accordingly, a POSITA would have understoodthat the links toolbar corresponds
`
`to "frequently accessed web content," the address bar to a section that "permit[s]
`
`entry of a uniform resource locator," and the favorites menu to a "display of
`
`-93-
`
`Page 883 of 1709
`
`Page 883 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`bookmarked locations," all of which are disclosed by the '715 Patent as being part
`
`of the "quick access view." EX-1001, 40:55-65; EX-1007, 99275-277.
`
`A POSITAwould have understood that the Internet Explorer window in
`
`Poguediscloses a quick access view.
`
`(3)
`
`Limitation [13c]
`
`Pogue discloses numerous waysin which a user can request to display a web
`
`page from the Internet Explorer window. This includes the Address bar as well as
`
`the "Links toolbar,” both of which "let[] you summon ... Web pages with only one
`
`click." EX-1006, 340-342; VHI.C.13.a(2). A POSITA would have understood
`
`that such summoning of a web page with a click generates a mapping to online
`
`digital content that, when executed, displaysa first view of the mapped digital
`
`content (1.e., the summoned web page).
`
`Therefore, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses the function of
`
`Claim 13. EX-1007, 9273-279.
`
`b.
`
`Structure
`
`Second, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses the corresponding
`
`structure for Claim 13. The Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue Computerincludes(1) an I/O
`
`controller operating on a processor that communicates with devices connected
`
`thereto, including receiving input from various input devices and a BIOS program
`
`that operates a display driver. See VII.C.8. A POSITA would have further
`
`-94-
`
`Page 884 of 1709
`
`Page 884 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`understood that the in order to communicate with the input devices, I/O controller
`
`would contain program(s) sufficient to (11) determine whether input received from
`
`the input devices indicates that a nascent card (an Internet Explorer icon) on the
`
`display was selected, and, through the BIOS program anddisplay driver (111)
`
`transition the display to the quick access view (the Internet Explorer window) and
`
`(iv) map to, and displaya first view of, online digital content (a web page)
`
`requested in the quick access view. EX-1007, 9280-281.
`
`Accordingly, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination discloses Claim 13 and
`
`renders it obvious. See VIII.A.1-VUI.A.2, VIII.C.1; EX-1007, 99273-281.
`
`14.
`
`Claim 14
`
`Pogue discloses a "quick access view"(the Internet Explorer window)that is
`
`"configured to permit a user generation of a mapping between digital content" (the
`
`Addressbar or Links toolbar) and a "visual representation" (a web page).
`
`VII.C.13.
`
`Therefore, Pogue discloses the additional limitations of Claim 14 and the
`
`Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders obviousthe claim. See VIII.A.1-
`
`VIILA.2, VHI.C.1; Claim 13; EX-1007, 282-283.
`
`15.
`
`Claim 15
`
`The '715 Patent discloses that "[t]he channel selector is a selectable
`
`display" that, e.g., can be "configured to display a rolodex of available channel[s]."
`
`-95-
`
`Page 885 of 1709
`
`Page 885 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`EX-1001, 32:22-23. "In response to selection from the channel selector view, the
`
`system displays a channel page view." EX-1001, 54:20-21. Example channel
`
`selector logic is depicted in FIG. 25B:
`
`
`
`Scroll wheel |
`
`Mena button
`
`Channel selector
`
`:
`|
`
`Change ta
`selacted channel
`
`|
`
`~MidaeA,
`Gat Menu button:
`Bota A i
`
`Se
`5
`
`
`
`vo R386 |
`i
`Content Maru o
`
`
`
`
`ooBbaE |
`j
`
`VA
`‘Menu butter:
`{Select content |
`
`EX-1001, 54:38-41; FIG. 25B. An "example of a channel [view] mayinclude a
`
`‘photo frame’ channel." EX-1001, 21:48-51, 54:20-25; VLA.
`
`Asdiscussed in Claim 2, Pogue's filmstrip view of a folder with multiple
`
`imagefiles discloses the "channel view." In this view the user can select a
`
`different image to be "enlarged" for the "slide show" portion (outlined below in
`
`red) "by clicking another image icon (bottom row)" from the sequence of image
`
`-96-
`
`Page 886 of 1709
`
`Page 886 of 1709
`
`

`

`Petition for /nter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,880,715
`(IPR2021-00786)
`
`icons in that bottom row (outlined below in Sius). EX-1006, 209; EX-1007,
`
`9284-285.
`
`
`.
`
`§
`
`
`
`
`
`BYssnsnensheanOOE
`
`wanna
`
`
`: i
`
`sinennnpnnannemnnnnnnnnntegeter
`
`
`
`ELECLECOLLEMELEELLLLLIDEASTTLTTTTTTYETLee
`
`.
`
`.
`
`
`
`SSE
`\N
`
`X
`BSS
`Was
`
`Ne
`
`
`
`
`SERS,
`
`
`SS
`x
`Coe SR
`
`s & “ N =
`ser :
`\
`
`
`‘s
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`sctieW
`SEN
`eee i
`=
`=
`SREBAINSIIIIS :
`&
`
`
`The POSITA would have understood this "channel view"(filmstrip folder
`
`view) to include a "channel selector that displays a sequence of visual
`
`representations," (the sequence of image iconsat the bottom outlined in S{us) that,
`
`whenselected, causes a different image to be displayed in the slide show portion
`
`(outlined in sexi). EX-1007, 9286.
`
`Therefore, the Shimura-Tsuji-Pogue combination renders obvious Claim

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket