`
`Commendable
`
`Full Successful
`
`Sco re
`500 ts.
`490 to 499 pis.
`480 to 489
`ts.
`460 to 479
`ts
`440 to 459
`ts.
`400 to 439
`ts.
`380 to 399
`ts.
`290 to 379
`ts
`
`Bonus
`$10,000
`$9 ,500
`$9,000
`$8,500
`$8,000
`$7 000
`$6,000
`$4000
`
`Administrative Judge Performance Bonus Range- Recommendation
`Rating
`
`Patent Trial Appeal Board (PTAB) - Administrative Patent Judge (APJ)
`
`FY 2019 Ratings with Recommended Bonus and Pay Adjustments
`
`APJ Pay Adjustment %
`Outstanding : 3.1% - 5.0%
`Commendable : 1.4% - 3.0%
`
`Fully Successful : 0% -1 .375%
`
`Administrative Patent Judge
`
`Total Points
`
`Overall Rating
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended
`
`Bonus
`
`Pay Adj.
`
`Increase( %)
`
`Pay Adj. Increase
`
`Pay Adj. Salary
`
`Amount
`
`for 2020
`
`COMMENTS
`
`b)(6)
`
`$176 ,900 b)(6)
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`
`Page 1 of 7
`
`(b)(6)
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 101 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3881
`
`
`
`Page 1 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Administrative Patent Judg e
`
`Total Points
`
`Overall Rating
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended
`
`Bonus
`
`Pay Adj.
`
`Increase(%)
`
`Pay Adj. Increase
`
`Amount
`
`b)(6)
`
`II
`II
`
`$176,900 (b)(6)
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176, 900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,90 0
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176,9 00
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`
`Page 2 of 7
`
`I
`
`for 2020
`
`b)(6)
`
`Pay Adj. Salary
`
`COMMENTS
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 102 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3882
`
`
`
`Page 2 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Administrati ve Patent Judge I Total Points
`
`r Overall Rating
`
`(b)(6)
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended
`
`Bonus
`
`Pay Adj.
`
`Increase (%)
`
`Pay Adj. Increas e
`
`Pay Adj. Salary
`
`Amount
`
`for 2020
`
`COMMENTS
`
`$176,90 0 (b)(6)
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$ 176,900
`$17 6,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`
`Page3o f7
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 103 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3883
`
`
`
`Page 3 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Administ rative Patent Judge
`
`Tota l Points
`
`Overall Rating
`
`Curren t
`Salary
`
`Recommended
`
`Bonus
`
`Pay Adj .
`
`Increa se (%)
`
`Pay Adj . Increase I Pay Adj. Salary I
`
`Amou nt
`
`for 2020
`
`b)(6)
`
`$176,900 (b)(6 )
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,9 00
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176 900
`$ 176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 900
`S176,900
`$ 176 900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$ 176 900
`$ 176 900
`$176 900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 900
`
`Page 4 of 7
`
`COMMENTS
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 104 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3884
`
`
`
`Page 4 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Administrative Patent Judge I
`
`Total Points
`
`I Overall Rating
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended I Pay Adj.
`
`Bonus
`
`Increase (%)
`
`I Pay Adj. Increase I Pay Adj. Salary I
`
`Amount
`
`for 2020
`
`b)(6)
`
`$176.900 (b)(6)
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$ 176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,900
`$176 ,900
`$ 176,900
`$176,900
`$17 6,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$ 176,90 0
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$174,500
`$176,900
`$17 6,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 ,900
`$176,900
`
`Page 5 of 7
`
`COMMENTS
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 105 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3885
`
`
`
`Page 5 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Admin istrative Patent Judge
`
`Total Points
`
`I Overall Rating
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended I Pay Adj.
`
`Bonus
`
`Increase(%)
`
`I Pay Adj. Increase I Pay Adj. Salary I
`
`Amount
`
`tor 2020
`
`b)(6)
`
`$176,900 b)(6)
`$176,900
`$174,500
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$172,776
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$174 500
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$174,500
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176 900
`$176,900
`$176,900
`
`Page 6 of 7
`
`COMMENTS
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 106 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3886
`
`
`
`Page 6 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`
`
`Administrative Patent Judge
`
`Total Points
`
`Overall Rating
`
`(b)(6)
`
`(b)(6)
`
`Current
`Salary
`
`Recommended
`
`Bonus
`
`$ 176,900 (b)(6)
`
`I
`
`Increase (%)
`
`Pay Adj.
`
`$176 ,900
`
`$176,900
`
`$165,812
`
`$176 ,900
`
`$164 ,500
`
`I Pay Adj. Increase I Pay Adj. Salary I
`
`Amount
`
`for 2020
`
`COMMENTS
`
`Notes:
`•Pay Adjustments - Awaiting OPM issuance of guidance and approval for range of basic pay to the Execut ive Schedule Pay Table for 2020 . OHR anticipates a 1.375% increase bringing the Judge cap to
`$179 ,332. If OPM issues a different % amount , OHR will adjust the 2020 recommended adjustments accordingly. Salaries will be capped at new ATJ limit regardless of recommended salary percentage
`increase .
`
`Under Secretary and Director
`
`bL ~ ~~ s-;-zv;c:;
`
`Date
`
`Page 7 of 7
`
`Case: 20-1399 Document: 78-2 Page: 107 Filed: 12/22/2020
`
`Appx3887
`
`
`
`Page 7 of 7
`
`Apple v. GUI Global Products
`IPR2021-00472 GUI Ex. 2019
`
`