Id[S^e4gebfa&Yah
`-/)&*/*&/0**
`
`ESbWd Ca& /
` ;[^WV2 5bd[^ *1$ *()1
`
`JC>I98 HI5I9H E5I9CI 5C8 IG589B5G@ D;;>79
`RRRRRRRRRRRR
`
`69;DG9 I=9 E5I9CI IG>5A 5C8 5EE95A 6D5G8
`RRRRRRRRRRRR
`
`5EEA9 >C7&$
`EWf[f[a‘Wd$
`
`h&
`
`JC>AD7 *()/ AA7$
`ESfW‘f Di‘Wd&
`RRRRRRRRRRRR
`
`7SeW >EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`RRRRRRRRRRRR
`
`6WXadW H5AAN 7& B98A9N$ B>G>5B A& FJ>CC$ S‘V
`H95C E& Dt=5CADC$ Administrative Patent Judges&
`
`FJ>CC$ Administrative Patent Judge&
`
`897>H>DC
`8W‘k[‘Y >‘ef[fgf[a‘ aX Inter Partes GWh[Wi
`35 U.S.C. § 314(a) and 37 C.F.R. § 42.108
`
`OKETQUQHV!EQTR/!
`GZJKDKV!2123
`
`Rcig!2!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1112
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`5bb^W >‘U& "qEWf[f[a‘Wdr# X[^WV S EWf[f[a‘ dWcgWef[‘Y inter partes
`
`dWh[Wi aX U^S[_e )o*) aX J&H& ESfW‘f Ca& .$,./$(00 6) "9j& )(()$
`
`qt(00 bSfW‘fr#& ESbWd ) "qEWf&r#& J‘[^aU *()/ AA7$ "qESfW‘f Di‘Wdr# X[^WV
`
`S EdW^[_[‘Sdk GWeba‘eW& ESbWd . "qEdW^[_& GWeb&r#&
`EgdegS‘f fa +- J&H&7& m +),"S#$ S‘ inter partes dWh[Wi _Sk ‘af TW
`
`[‘ef[fgfWV g‘^Wee qfZW [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ bdWeW‘fWV [‘ fZW bWf[f[a‘ & & & S‘V S‘k
`
`dWeba‘eW & & & eZaie fZSf fZWdW [e S dWSea‘ST^W ^[]W^[ZaaV fZSf fZW bWf[f[a‘Wd
`
`iag^V bdWhS[^ i[fZ dWebWUf fa Sf ^WSef ) aX fZW U^S[_e UZS^^W‘YWV [‘ fZW
`
`bWf[f[a‘&r ;ad fZW dWSea‘e Y[hW‘ TW^ai$ iW VWfWd_[‘W EWf[f[a‘Wd ZSe ‘af
`
`VW_a‘efdSfWV S dWSea‘ST^W ^[]W^[ZaaV fZSf [f iag^V bdWhS[^ [‘ WefST^[eZ[‘Y
`
`fZSf U^S[_e )o*) aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f SdW g‘bSfW‘fST^W&
`
`>& 657@<GDJC8
`
`5& I=9 t(00 E5I9CI
`1. Disclosure
`
`IZW t(00 bSfW‘f [e V[dWUfWV fa fWUZ‘[cgWe Xad gbYdSV[‘Y ad
`
`dWUa‘X[Ygd[‘Y eaXfiSdW S‘V’ad ZSdViSdW Ua_ba‘W‘fe [‘ W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UWe&
`
`9j& )(()$ )2."1& IZW t(00 bSfW‘f Wjb^S[‘e fZSf bd[ad Sdf ekefW_e VWhW^abWV
`
`Xad gbVSf[‘Y Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UWe dW^k a‘ S UW‘fdS^ Ua_bgfWd
`
`ekefW_ fZSf fdSU]e S^^ eaXfiSdW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad S ‘g_TWd aX dW_afW
`ekefW_e& Id. Sf )2+)"+.& IZWeW bd[ad Sdf ekefW_e gbVSfWV eaXfiSdW Tk fZW
`UW‘fdS^ Ua_bgfWd fdS‘e_[ff[‘Y bSfUZWe fa WSUZ aX fZW dW_afW ekefW_e& Id. Sf
`)2+1",*3 see also *2,")( "Wjb^S[‘[‘Y fZSf S V[efd[TgfWV ekefW_ fdS‘e_[fe
`
`bSfUZWe fa _aT[^W g‘[fe#& DfZWd ]‘ai‘ fWUZ‘[cgWe Xad eaXfiSdW gbVSfW
`
`[‘ha^hW Seeg_[‘Y fZSf WSUZ VWe]fab Ua_bgfWd ZSe S eWf aX dWeagdUWe
`
`VWfWd_[‘WV [‘ SUUadVS‘UW i[fZ S eWf aX W‘fWdbd[eW ba^[U[We ad S UW‘fdS^ eWdhWd
`
`_S[‘fS[‘[‘Y S _SefWd ^[ef fZSf [e geWV fa ]WWb X[^We a‘ S dW_afW VWh[UW
`
`*
`
`Rcig!3!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1113
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`gbVSfWV fa fZW ^SfWef hWde[a‘& Id. Sf )2,1"-*$ )2.(".-& 5UUadV[‘Y fa fZW
`
`t(00 bSfW‘f$ S^^ aX fZW STahW fWUZ‘[cgWe XS[^ fa Sha[V bafW‘f[S^ Ua‘X^[Ufe S‘V
`
`W‘egdW Ua_bSf[T[^[fk TWUSgeW fZWk Va ‘af SUUag‘f Xad [‘fWdVWbW‘VW‘U[We aX
`
`fZW dWeagdUWe dWcg[dWV Tk fZW VWe]fabe ad fZW X[^We dWe[VW‘f [‘ fZW dW_afW
`VWh[UWe& Id. Sf )2,)",-$ )2-*"-.$ )2.-"*2+$ *2)("),&
`
`IZW t(00 bSfW‘f ea^hWe fZW bdaT^W_ Tk bdah[V[‘Y S ^[ef ad ^[ef[‘Y$ fZSf
`
`[‘V[USfWe qiZ[UZ aX S eWf aX eaXfiSdW Ua_ba‘W‘fe egbbadfWV Tk fZW _S‘SYWd
`)( SdW ]‘ai‘ fa iad] iW^^ faYWfZWd ad SdW afZWdi[eW Ua_bSf[T^W&r Id. Sf
`
`+2+.",*& ;ad [‘efS‘UW$ ;[YgdW ) aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f$ dWbdaVgUWV TW^ai$
`
`[^^gefdSfWe dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ _S‘SYWd )( fZSf [‘U^gVWe S ^[ef[‘Y ). aX ]‘ai‘
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e$ S‘V S dWbae[fadk )0 aX eaXfiSdW Ua_ba‘W‘fe& Id. Sf +2*/"*1&
`
`+
`
`Rcig!4!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1114
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`;[YgdW )$ STahW$ [^^gefdSfWe S dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ _S‘SYWd )( [‘fWdSUf[‘Y
`i[fZ S‘ W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW )*$ S^ea dWXWddWV fa Se q8Wh[UW M&r Id. Sf +2),").&
`
`LZW‘ dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ _S‘SYWd )( dWUW[hWe S dWcgWef Xad S‘ gbYdSVW Xda_
`
`8Wh[UW M$ fZW dWcgWef [‘V[USfWe fZSf fZW VWh[UW iS‘fe fa gbYdSVW fa hWde[a‘
`
`*&( aX eaXfiSdW Ua_ba‘W‘f 5$ S‘V [‘U^gVWe S ^[ef aX fZW Ua_ba‘W‘fe
`
`UgddW‘f^k a‘ fZW VWh[UW$ [&W&$ hWde[a‘ )&) aX Ua_ba‘W‘f 5$ hWde[a‘ *&( aX
`Ua_ba‘W‘f 7$ S‘V hWde[a‘ *&+ aX Ua_ba‘W‘f 6& Id. Sf ,2)*")1&
`
`GWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ _S‘SYWd )( bdaUWeeWe fZW dWcgWef$ S‘V [X Sbbdabd[SfW$
`VW^[hWde fZW dWcgWefWV hWde[a‘ *&( aX eaXfiSdW Ua_ba‘W‘f 5& Id. Sf ,2**"*.&
`
`EdaUWee[‘Y fZW dWcgWef [‘ha^hWe YW‘WdSf[‘Y S bafW‘f[S^ gbYdSVW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘
`
`fZSf i[^^ eSf[eXk fZW dWUW[hWV dWcgWef$ S‘V eWSdUZ[‘Y fZdagYZ S eWf aX ]‘ai‘
`qTSVr Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e& Id. Sf ,2.*"..& 5 ]‘ai‘ qTSVr Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ [e
`
`[‘V[USfWV [‘ ;[YgdW ) Se S VSeZWV ^[‘W TWfiWW‘ Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW ‘af
`Ua_bSf[T^W& Id. Sf ,2-0".)& ;ad WjS_b^W$ fZW bS[d [‘U^gV[‘Y hWde[a‘ )&0 aX
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f 5 S‘V hWde[a‘ )&( aX Ua_ba‘W‘f 7 [e S‘ WjS_b^W aX S ]‘ai‘ TSV
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘& Id. Sf +2.)".+&
`
`>X fZW gbYdSVW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ UaddWeba‘Ve fa S TSV Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘$ fZW
`
`dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ _S‘SYWd SffW_bfe fa X[‘V S eWf ad eWfe aX bafW‘f[S^ gbYdSVW
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xda_ S eWf aX ]‘ai‘ qYaaVr Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e& Id. Sf ,2./"-2+&
`
`5 ]‘ai‘ qYaaVr Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ [e [‘V[USfWV [‘ ;[YgdW ) Tk S ea^[V ^[‘W
`
`TWfiWW‘ S Y[hW‘ bS[d aX Ua_ba‘W‘fe [‘V[USf[‘Y fZSf fZW Ua_ba‘W‘fe iad]
`iW^^ faYWfZWd ad SdW afZWdi[eW Ua_bSf[T^W& Id. Sf +2-*"--&
`2. Prosecution History
`
`
`
`8gd[‘Y bdaeWUgf[a‘ aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f$ fZW 9jS_[‘Wd [eegWV S
`
`GW\WUf[a‘ aX U^S[_e )o*) g‘VWd +- J&H&7& m )(+ ahWd J&H& ESfW‘f Ca&
`
`.$+()$/(/ 6) "q7Sdda^^r#& 9j& )((/& IZW 9jS_[‘Wd Xag‘V fZSf 7Sdda^^
`
`,
`
`Rcig!5!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1115
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`fWSUZWe S^^ fZW ^[_[fSf[a‘e aX U^S[_ )$ S‘V$ [‘ bSdf[Ug^Sd$ i[fZ dWebWUf fa fZW
`
`Ua_bSd[‘Y efWb$ fZW 9jS_[‘Wd Xag‘V fZSf 7Sdda^^ bWdXad_e S Ua_bSd[ea‘
`
`ge[‘Y fZW bdaX[^W aX fZW fSdYWf ekefW_ fa [‘efS^^ Ua_ba‘W‘fe [VW‘f[X[WV [‘ fZSf
`bdaX[^W& Id. Sf +&) IZW 5bb^[US‘f X[^WV S GWeba‘eW& 9j& )((0& >f SdYgWV fZSf
`
`fZW [‘efS^^Sf[a‘ bdaUWee [‘ 7Sdda^^ [‘efS^^e [‘ fZW fSdYWf ekefW_ a‘^k
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW VWX[‘WV [‘ fZW bdaX[^W aX fZW fSdYWf ekefW_$ S‘V fZSf fZW
`
`[‘hW‘f[a‘$ [‘ Ua‘fdSef$ W‘egdWe fZSf gbYdSVWe SdW Ua_bSf[T^W i[fZ fZW
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ aX S Y[hW‘ VWh[UW TWXadW fZWk SdW [_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZSf VWh[UW&
`Id. Sf *"+& IZge$ 5bb^[US‘f SdYgWV$ S^fZagYZ 7Sdda^^ fWSUZWe fZW geW aX S
`
`bdaX[^W Ua_bSd[ea‘ fa [‘efS^^ eaXfiSdW$ 7Sdda^^ V[V ‘af fWSUZ fZW ^[_[fSf[a‘ aX
`
`qUa_bSd[‘Y fZW VWfWd_[‘WV Ua_ba‘W‘f S‘V [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ ebWU[Xk[‘Y Sf ^WSef
`
`a‘W SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f UgddW‘f^k [_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW
`
`i[fZ Sf ^WSef a‘W aX S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW
`
`W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW S‘V S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW
`W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r Id. Sf +",&
`
`IZW 9jS_[‘Wd$ [‘ dWeba‘eW fa 5bb^[US‘fte SdYg_W‘fe$ [eegWV S Caf[UW
`
`aX 5^^aiST[^[fk aX S^^ bW‘V[‘Y U^S[_e efSf[‘Y2
`
`IZW Sbb^[US‘f SdYgWe fZSf 7Sdda^P^Q XS[^e fa fWSUZ qdWUW[h[‘Y
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW aX S Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ dWcgWef&r
`=aiWhWd$ eWW 7Sdda^P^teQ X[Y& +$ [fW_ +*( "b^SU[‘Y adVWd#&
`IZW b^SU[‘Y aX S‘ adVWd
`[e
`[‘ZWdW‘f^k q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘
`dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW aX S dWcgWef&r >f [e XgdfZWd ebWU[X[WV fZSf
`7Sdda^P^Q VaWe ‘af
`fWSUZ ad egYYWef Ua_bSd[‘Y
`fZW
`VWfWd_[‘WV "dWcgWefWV# Ua_ba‘W‘f S‘V Sf
`^WSef a‘W
`SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f fa Sf ^WSef a‘W aX S‘ SUUWbfST^W ad S‘
`g‘SUUWbfST^W ^[ef& 7Sdda^P^Q$ Se [‘V[USfWV [‘ fZW bdWh[age
`SUf[a‘ Ua_bSdWe
`fZW
`dWcgWefWV Ua_ba‘W‘f i[fZ S‘
`SUUWbfST^W ^[ef "a‘W aX S‘ SUUWbfST^W S‘V S‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W
`
`) ESYW ‘g_TWde fa fZ[e 9jZ[T[f dWXWd fa fZW bSYW ‘g_TWd [‘ fZW ad[Y[‘S^
`DXX[UW 5Uf[a‘&
`
`-
`
`Rcig!6!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1116
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`^[ef#3 ZaiWhWd$ ZW VaWe ‘af fWSUZ ad egYYWef Ua_bSd[‘Y S‘
`additional component i[fZ a‘W aX fZW ^[ef [‘ dWeba‘eW fa S
`dWcgWef& IZWdWXadW$ fZW U^S[_e SdW S^^aiST^W ahWd fZW Sdf aX
`dWUadV&
`9j& )((1$ * "W_bZSe[e SVVWV#&
`
`6& >AAJHIG5I>K9 7A5>B
`
`IZW t(00 bSfW‘f dWU[fWe fZdWW [‘VWbW‘VW‘f U^S[_e2 )$ ))$ S‘V *)&
`
`7ZS^^W‘YWV U^S[_ )$ dWbdaVgUWV TW^ai$ [e [^^gefdSf[hW aX fZW dWU[fWV egT\WUf
`
`_SffWd2
`
`)& 5 bdaUWeead%[_b^W_W‘fWV _WfZaV Xad Ua‘fda^^[‘Y fZW
`dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ aX S‘ W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW$ fZW _WfZaV Ua_bd[e[‘Y
`fZW efWbe aX2
`dWUW[h[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW aX S dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘
`dWcgWef dW^Sf[‘Y fa fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW3
`VWfWd_[‘[‘Y Sf ^WSef a‘W VWh[UW Ua_ba‘W‘f dWcg[dWV fa
`[_b^W_W‘f fZW dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ dWcgWef3
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘
`Ua_bSd[‘Y
`fZW VWfWd_[‘WV Ua_ba‘W‘f S‘V
`ebWU[Xk[‘Y Sf ^WSef a‘W SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f UgddW‘f^k
`[_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW i[fZ Sf ^WSef a‘W aX S
`^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U
`VWh[UW S‘V S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad
`fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW3 S‘V
`YW‘WdSf[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ [‘V[USf[hW aX S‘ SbbdahS^ ad S VW‘[S^ aX
`fZW dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ dWcgWef TSeWV Sf ^WSef [‘ bSdf a‘ fZW
`dWeg^f aX fZW Ua_bSd[‘Y efWb&
`
`9j& )(()$ .2,+"-1& LW dWXWd fa fZW efWbe aX U^S[_ ) Se fZW dWUW[h[‘Y
`
`efWb$ fZW VWfWd_[‘[‘Y efWb$ fZW Ua_bSd[‘Y efWb$ S‘V fZW YW‘WdSf[‘Y
`
`efWb$ dWebWUf[hW^k&
`
`7& 9K>89C79 D; G97DG8
`
`IZW EWf[f[a‘ dW^[We gba‘ fZW Xa^^ai[‘Y bd[‘fWV bgT^[USf[a‘e2
`
`J&H& ESfW‘f Ca& -$/-*$(,* "9j& )((*$ q7a^Wr#3
`
`J&H& ESfW‘f Ca& .$,,1$/*+ 6) "9j& )((,$ q9^YdWeekr#3
`
`.
`
`Rcig!7!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1117
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`J&H& ESfW‘f Ca& /$(.*$/.- 6) "9j& )((-$ qE[flW^r#3 S‘V
`
`E7I 5bb^[USf[a‘ EgT^[USf[a‘ Ca& LD 1/’+(-,1 "9j& )((+$ qBSU>‘‘[er#&
`
`>‘ SVV[f[a‘$ EWf[f[a‘Wd egbbadfe [fe Ua‘fW‘f[a‘e i[fZ fZW 8WU^SdSf[a‘ aX
`
`7ZSd^We 8& @‘gfea‘$ EZ&8& "9j& )((.$ q@‘gfea‘ 8WU^&r#&
`
`8& 5HH9GI98 <GDJC8H D; JCE5I9CI56>A>IN
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd SeeWdfe fZW Xa^^ai[‘Y Ydag‘Ve aX g‘bSfW‘fST[^[fk& EWf& ,&
`
`$()(0(/&(1
`#+%--(/*(’ #-%,.1 "%1,1
`m )(+ 7a^W$ BSU>‘‘[e$ S‘V 9^YdWeek
`)"*)
`m )(+
`E[flW^$ 7a^W$ S‘V 9^YdWeek
`)"*)
`
`>>& 5C5ANH>H
`
`5& 7A5>B 7DCHIGJ7I>DC
`
`IZW 6aSdV [‘fWdbdWfe U^S[_ fWd_e aX S‘ g‘Wjb[dWV bSfW‘f ge[‘Y fZW
`
`qTdaSVWef dWSea‘ST^W Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ [‘ ^[YZf aX fZW ebWU[X[USf[a‘ aX fZW bSfW‘f&r
`+/ 7&;&G& m ,*&)(("T# "*()/#3* see Cuozzo Speed Techs., LLC v. Lee$ )+. H&
`
`7f& *)+)$ *),,o,. "*().#& LW bdWeg_W S U^S[_ fWd_ USdd[We [fe qadV[‘Sdk
`
`S‘V Ugefa_Sdk _WS‘[‘Y$r iZ[UZ [e fZW _WS‘[‘Y qfZW fWd_ iag^V ZShW fa S
`bWdea‘ aX adV[‘Sdk e][^^ [‘ fZW Sdfr Sf fZW f[_W aX fZW [‘hW‘f[a‘& In re
`Translogic Tech., Inc.$ -(, ;&+V )*,1$ )*-/ ";WV& 7[d& *((/# "U[fSf[a‘
`
`a_[ffWV#&
`
`1. “list”
`
`IZW [‘VWbW‘VW‘f U^S[_e aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f dWU[fW qSf ^WSef a‘W aX S ^[ef
`
`aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW S‘V S ^[ef aX
`
`]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r 9j& )(()$
`
`* 5 dWUW‘f S_W‘V_W‘f fa fZ[e dg^W VaWe ‘af Sbb^k ZWdW TWUSgeW fZW EWf[f[a‘
`iSe X[^WV TWXadW CahW_TWd )+$ *()0& See 7ZS‘YWe fa fZW 7^S[_
`7a‘efdgUf[a‘ HfS‘VSdV Xad >‘fWdbdWf[‘Y 7^S[_e [‘ Id[S^ EdaUWWV[‘Ye 6WXadW
`fZW ESfW‘f Id[S^ S‘V 5bbWS^ 6aSdV$ 0+ ;WV& GWY& -)$+,( "DUf& ))$ *()0# "fa
`TW UaV[X[WV Sf +/ 7&;&G& bf& ,*#&
`
`/
`
`Rcig!8!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1118
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`.2-+"-.$ /2,0"-)$ /2-1".*$ 02-1".*& EWf[f[a‘Wd bdabaeWe S Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ Xad
`
`fZW fWd_ q^[efr TSeWV a‘ fZW VWeUd[bf[a‘ bdah[VWV [‘ fZW HbWU[X[USf[a‘ Se2
`
`qS‘k efadWV dWbdWeW‘fSf[a‘ aX [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ [‘V[USf[hW aX Ua_ba‘W‘f
`Ua_bSf[T[^[fk&r EWf& 13 see 9j& )(()$ ,2."0 "qIZW fWd_ s^[eft Se geWV ZWdW[‘
`
`[e fZWdWXadW [‘fW‘VWV fa [‘U^gVW S‘k efadWV dWbdWeW‘fSf[a‘ aX [‘Xad_Sf[a‘
`
`[‘V[USf[hW aX Ua_ba‘W‘f Ua_bSf[T[^[fk&r# ESfW‘f Di‘Wd VaWe ‘af UZS^^W‘YW
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wdte bdabaeS^ S‘V SdYgWe fZSf qfZW 6aSdV ‘WWV ‘af Ua‘efdgW S‘k fWd_
`
`[‘ S bSdf[Ug^Sd _S‘‘Wd [‘ adVWd fa Sdd[hW Sf fZW Ua‘U^ge[a‘ fZSf fZW EWf[f[a‘ [e
`
`egTefS‘f[hW^k VWX[U[W‘f&r EdW^[_& GWeb& ,"-&
`
`Jba‘ dWh[Wi aX fZW SdYg_W‘fe bdWeW‘fWV Tk ESfW‘f Di‘Wd$ iW ‘afW
`
`fZSf ESfW‘f Di‘Wd V[ef[‘Yg[eZWe fZW SeeWdfWV bd[ad Sdf a‘ fZW TSe[e aX fZW
`
`q^[efr fWd_& ;ad WjS_b^W$ ESfW‘f Di‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf 7a^W VaWe ‘af V[eU^aeW
`fZW dWU[fWV ^[ef aX qknown SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ for the electronic devicer
`
`S‘V fZW ^[ef aX q]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U
`VWh[UW&r See EdW^[_& GWeb& .")(& >‘ bSdf[Ug^Sd$ ESfW‘f Di‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf
`
`fZW dWU[fWV q^[efr _gef TW ")# bdWh[age^k VWfWd_[‘WV$ [&W& q]‘ai‘r3 S‘V "*#
`
`ebWU[X[U fa fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW [‘ cgWef[a‘$ [&W&$ qXad fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r
`Id. Sf .& ;ad bgdbaeWe aX fZ[e 8WU[e[a‘$ iW SVabf EWf[f[a‘Wdte bdabaeWV
`
`Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ aX fZW fWd_ q^[efr Se qS‘k efadWV dWbdWeW‘fSf[a‘ aX [‘Xad_Sf[a‘
`
`[‘V[USf[hW aX Ua_ba‘W‘f Ua_bSf[T[^[fk&r LW S^ea SVabf$ Xad bgdbaeWe aX fZ[e
`
`8WU[e[a‘ ESfW‘f Di‘Wdte bdabaeWV Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ aX q]‘ai‘r fa _WS‘
`
`bdWh[age^k VWfWd_[‘WV&
`
`2. Other Claim Terms
`
`D‘ fZ[e dWUadV$ ‘a afZWd U^S[_ fWd_e dWcg[dW S‘ WjbdWee Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ fa
`dWea^hW fZW [eegWe bdWeW‘fWV Tk fZW bSfW‘fST[^[fk UZS^^W‘YWe& See Nidec
`Motor Corp. v. Zhongshan Broad Ocean Motor Co.$ 0.0 ;&+V )()+$ )()/
`
`0
`
`Rcig!9!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1119
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`";WV& 7[d& *()/# "Za^V[‘Y fZSf a‘^k fWd_e qfZSf SdW [‘ Ua‘fdahWdekr _gef TW
`
`Ua‘efdgWV S‘V qa‘^k fa fZW WjfW‘f ‘WUWeeSdk fa dWea^hW fZW Ua‘fdahWdekr#&
`
`6& 5AA9<98 D6K>DJHC9HH DK9G 7DA9$ B57>CC>H$ 5C8 9A<G9HHN
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf U^S[_e )"*) aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f iag^V ZShW TWW‘
`
`aTh[age ahWd 7a^W$ BSU>‘‘[e$ S‘V 9^YdWeek& EWf& )+o,)& ESfW‘f Di‘Wd
`
`V[ebgfWe EWf[f[a‘Wdte SeeWdf[a‘e& EdW^[_& GWeb& .o)(&
`1. Overview of Cole
`
`
`
`7a^W [e V[dWUfWV fa S eWdhWd Ua_bgfWd Xad eW^WUf[‘Y bdaYdS_ gbVSfWe
`
`Xad S U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd TSeWV a‘ dWeg^fe aX dWUaY‘[lWd bdaYdS_"e# Xgd‘[eZWV fa
`
`fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& 9j& )((*$ P-/Q& 7a^W VWeUd[TWe fZSf S ]‘ai‘ fWUZ‘[cgW
`
`Xad bdah[V[‘Y S U^[W‘f i[fZ S UaVW gbYdSVW [‘ha^hWe dWY[efWd[‘Y fZW U^[W‘f
`
`i[fZ fZW eWdhWd ea fZSf fZW eWdhWd _Sk Sgfa_Sf[US^^k eW‘V fZW UaVW gbVSfWe fa
`WhWdk U^[W‘f a‘ fZW ^[ef aX dWY[efWdWV U^[W‘fe& Id. Sf )2+("+-& 5^fWd‘Sf[hW^k$ S
`
`U^[W‘f US‘ bWd[aV[US^^k dWcgWef S^^ gbVSfWe$ S‘V fZW eWdhWd i[^^ dWeba‘V
`SUUadV[‘Y^k& Id. Sf )2+/"+0& 6WUSgeW aX Uaef$ Vai‘^aSV f[_W$ ad afZWd
`dWSea‘e$ ea_W U^[W‘fe _Sk ‘af i[eZ fa aTfS[‘ fZW gbVSfW& Id. Sf )2+,"+.$
`
`)2+0",(&
`
`7a^W$ fZWdWXadW$ VWeUd[TWe S eWdhWd fZSf [VW‘f[X[We UaVW gbVSfWe fZSf SdW
`Ua‘e[efW‘f i[fZ TSe[U ekefW_ UZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue aX fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& Id. Sf
`
`)2,-",1& IZW‘$ fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd gf[^[lWe S qdWUaY‘[lWdr bdaYdS_$ iZ[UZ
`
`fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd aTfS[‘e Xda_ S eWdhWd$ fa VWfWd_[‘W iZWfZWd fZW U^[W‘f
`
`Ua_bgfWd ZSe S hWde[a‘ afZWd fZS‘ S UgddW‘f hWde[a‘ aX fZW [VW‘f[X[WV UaVW
`gbVSfWe& Id. Sf )2,1"-,& IZW U^[W‘f fZW‘ eW‘Ve fZW dWeg^fe aX fZW dWUaY‘[lWd
`
`bdaYdS_ fa fZW eWdhWd Ua_bgfWd$ iZ[UZ YW‘WdSfWe S ^[ef aX UaVW gbVSfWe fZSf
`
`SdW Ua‘e[efW‘f i[fZ fZW TSe[U UZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue dWbdWeW‘f[‘Y bdaYdS_e fZSf Wj[ef
`a‘ fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd Xad iZ[UZ S‘ gbVSfW iag^V TW Sbbdabd[SfW& Id. Sf
`
`1
`
`Rcig!;!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!111;
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`)2-,"-1& IZW‘ fZW eWdhWd Ua_bgfWd eW‘Ve fZW ^[ef aX UaVW gbVSfWe fa fZW
`
`U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd ea fZSf S geWd aX fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd US‘ eW^WUf S UaVW gbVSfW
`Xda_ fZW ^[ef& Id. Sf )2-1".*& >‘ dWeba‘eW$ fZW eWdhWd Ua_bgfWd eW‘Ve
`
`SVVdWeeWe aX fZW eW^WUfWV UaVW gbVSfWe fa fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd S‘V fZW U^[W‘f
`Ua_bgfWd Vai‘^aSVe fZW eW^WUfWV UaVW gbVSfWe& Id. Sf )2.*".-&
`2. List of Known Acceptable Configurations
`
`
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf 7a^W$ [‘ Ua_T[‘Sf[a‘ i[fZ BSU>‘‘[e S‘V
`
`9^YdWeek$ fWSUZWe fZW Ua_bSd[‘Y efWb& EWf& *("*0& BadW ebWU[X[US^^k Se fa
`
`fZW q^[ef$r EWf[f[a‘Wd Ua‘fW‘Ve fZSf 7a^W fWSUZWe fZW q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er Tk bdah[V[‘Y S‘ WjS_b^W fST^W fZSf ^[efe UaVW gbVSfWe S‘V
`TSe[U ekefW_ dWcg[dW_W‘fe _WfSVSfS& Id. Sf *)& EWf[f[a‘Wd Wjb^S[‘e fZSf 7a^W
`
`V[eU^aeWe fZSf qfZW 6>DH ^WhW^ )*+$ 6>DH VSfW ?S‘& )$ )11. S‘V _afZWd TaSdV
`
`>8 MNO TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ aTfS[‘WV Xda_ PfZWQ U^[W‘f PQ [e Ua‘e[efW‘f
`
`i[fZ S VWh[UW Vd[hWd X[^W ‘S_WV 56789&8GK$r S‘V$ fZSf$ fZWdWXadW$ fZW
`VWh[UW Vd[hWd 56789&8GK [e qbafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfW Xad fZW U^[W‘f&r Id. Sf
`
`** "U[f[‘Y 9j& )((*$ +2.-",2+(#& EWf[f[a‘Wd S^ea SdYgWe fZSf qfZW VWh[UW
`
`Vd[hWd X[^W ‘S_WV ;<=>?&8GK [e [‘Sbbdabd[SfW Xad fZW U^[W‘f S‘V [e
`
`W^[_[‘SfWV Xda_ XgdfZWd Ua‘e[VWdSf[a‘$ TWUSgeW [fe dWcg[dWV 6>DH ^WhW^ "[&W&
`6>DH ^WhW^ ,-.#$ VaWe ‘af _SfUZ fZW 6>DH ^WhW^ aX fZW U^[W‘f&r Id. "U[f[‘Y
`
`9j& )((*$ +2.-",2+,3 @‘gfea‘ 8WU^& n //#&
`
`ESfW‘f Di‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf 7a^W VaWe ‘af fWSUZ fZW q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘
`
`SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e$r Sf ^WSef [‘ bSdf TWUSgeW fZW S^^WYWV
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e [‘ 7a^W SdW ‘af known& EdW^[_& GWeb& 0"1& >‘ bSdf[Ug^Sd$
`
`ESfW‘f Di‘Wd ba[‘fe agf fZSf EWf[f[a‘Wd dW^[We a‘ 7a^Wte VWeUd[bf[a‘ aX fZW
`
`_SfUZ TWfiWW‘ fZW _WfS VSfS S‘V fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ q[‘V[USfP[‘YQ
`
`fZSf fZW UaddWeba‘V[‘Y UaVW gbVSfWe SdW bafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfW Xadr fZW
`
`)(
`
`Rcig!21!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1121
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`U^[W‘f& Id. Sf 1 "U[f[‘Y 9j& )((*$ +2.*",2)#& ESfW‘f Di‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf fZW
`_SfUZ [e$ Sf TWef$ bafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfW$ S‘V$ fZWdWXadW$ [e ‘af known fZSf fZW
`UaVW gbVSfW [e S‘ qSUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘&r Id.
`
`LW SdW bWdegSVWV Tk ESfW‘f Di‘Wdte SdYg_W‘f& 7a^W VWeUd[TWe fZSf
`
`WSUZ U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd fZSf eWW]e S UaVW gbVSfW X[def Vai‘^aSVe S TSe[U ekefW_
`
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ dWUaY‘[lWd bdaYdS_ ea fZSf fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd US‘ bdah[VW fa
`
`fZW eW^WUf[a‘ eWdhWd fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘$ egUZ Se 6>DH ^WhW^ S‘V
`
`ekefW_ _aVW^& 9j& )((*$ +2,*"-(& IZW eW^WUf[a‘ eWdhWd VWfWd_[‘We iZ[UZ
`
`UaVW gbVSfWe SdW qUa‘e[efW‘f i[fZ fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ aX fZW U^[W‘f
`S‘V iZ[UZ UaVW gbVSfWe SdW [‘Ua‘e[efW‘f thereby eliminating the vast
`majority of the code updates stored in content server 17 . . . from further
`consideration&r Id. Sf +2-.".( "W_bZSe[e SVVWV#& IZW eWdhWd VWfWd_[‘We
`
`fZ[e egTeWf aX UaVW gbVSfWe Tk qUaddW^Sf[‘Y fZW _WfS VSfS [‘ fZW VSfS TSeW )+
`fa fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ aTfS[‘WV Xda_ U^[W‘f ),&r Id. Sf +2.*".-&
`
`IZge$ Xda_ fZ[e VWeUd[bf[a‘$ [f SbbWSde fZSf 7a^W bWdXad_e S Ua_bSd[ea‘
`
`TWfiWW‘ ea_W SebWUfe aX fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ aX fZW U^[W‘f S‘V S^^ aX
`
`fZW UaVW gbVSfWe fZSf SdW efadWV [‘ fZW ekefW_& IZW UaVW gbVSfWe eW^WUfWV Sf
`
`fZ[e \g‘UfgdW [‘ 7a^W SdW fZaeW fZSf _SfUZ ea_W aX fZW TSe[U ekefW_
`
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘3 Tgf 7a^W VWeUd[TWe fZW eW^WUfWV UaVW gbVSfWe Se qbafW‘f[S^^k
`Sbbdabd[SfW Xad U^[W‘f ),&r Id. Sf +2.-",2)& IZWdWXadW$ ‘W[fZWd fZW U^[W‘f ‘ad
`
`fZW eWdhWd S‘f[U[bSfWe fZSf fZW eW^WUfWV UaVW gbVSfWe Sf fZ[e ba[‘f SdW SUfgS^^k
`
`S q]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r 5^fZagYZ fZW
`
`UaVW gbVSfWe Sf fZ[e ba[‘f _SfUZ ea_W Ud[fWd[S aX fZW U^[W‘f VWh[UW$ fZWk SdW
`
`‘af q]‘ai‘r fa TW SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e$ Tgf _WdW^k qbafW‘f[S^^k
`
`Sbbdabd[SfW&r IZW [‘VWU[e[hW ^S‘YgSYW qbafW‘f[S^^kr [e ‘af fZW dWcg[dWV
`
`))
`
`Rcig!22!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1122
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`VWU[e[hW ^S‘YgSYW aX q]‘ai‘rpS V[XXWdW‘UW fZSf EWf[f[a‘Wd VaWe ‘af Wjb^S[‘
`
`bWdegSe[hW^k$ [X Sf S^^&
`
`IZW Ua‘U^ge[a‘ fZSf 7a^W VaWe ‘af fWSUZ S q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er [e Ua‘X[d_WV Tk 7a^Wte XgdfZWd Wjb^S‘Sf[a‘ aX [fe fWUZ‘[cgW$
`
`iZ[UZ dWcg[dWe S XgdfZWd dWUaY‘[f[a‘ efWb fa g^f[_SfW^k eW^WUf fZW UaVW
`
`gbVSfWe fZSf SdW SUUWbfST^W Xad fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& ;ad [‘efS‘UW$ 7a^W
`
`VWeUd[TWe fZSf fZW eW^WUf[a‘ eWdhWd eW‘Ve fa fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd fZW ;IE
`
`SVVdWee [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ aX fZW dWUaY‘[lWd bdaYdS_e UaddWeba‘V[‘Y fa fZW
`bafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfW UaVW gbVSfWe& Id. Sf ,2+-",/& 9SUZ aX fZW dWUaY‘[lWd
`
`bdaYdS_e [e hWdk e_S^^$ S‘V Vai‘^aSVe _gUZ XSefWd fZS‘ fZW SUfgS^ UaVW
`gbVSfW& Id. Sf ,2,0"-*& IZ[e SVV[f[a‘S^ efWb [e ‘WUWeeSdk TWUSgeW 7a^W efSfWe
`
`fZSf qTSeWV a‘ fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ S^a‘W$ fZW eW^WUf[a‘ gbVSfW
`bdaYdS_ +( i[fZ[‘ eWdhWd )* is not sure iZ[UZ aX fZW UaVW gbVSfWe fZSf SdW
`Ua‘e[efW‘f i[fZ fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ are actually needed by the
`client3 Xad WjS_b^W$ fZW U^[W‘f _Sk S^dWSVk ZShW fZW ^SfWef hWde[a‘&r Id. Sf
`
`,2-+"-0 "W_bZSe[e SVVWV#& IZge$ ‘a‘W aX fZW bafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfW UaVW
`
`gbVSfWe _Sk SUfgS^^k TW [‘efS^^WV& 5 XgdfZWd dWUaY‘[f[a‘ efWb [e ‘WUWeeSdk$
`
`Tk WSUZ aX fZW dWUaY‘[lWd bdaYdS_e Vai‘^aSVWV$ fa SUfgS^^k [‘hWef[YSfW fZW
`
`ZSdViSdW$ eaXfiSdW$ S‘V afZWd Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd qfa See[ef
`fZW eWdhWd [‘ VWfWd_[‘[‘Y iZWfZWd fZW corresponding code update is
`appropriate for the client&r Id. Sf -2-"/ "W_bZSe[e SVVWV#& ;gdfZWd$ 7a^W
`
`efSfWe fZSf fZW dWUaY‘[lWd bdaYdS_ qUag^V S^ea VWfWd_[‘W [X fZW
`
`UaddWeba‘V[‘Y UaVW gbVSfW [e Ua‘e[efW‘f i[fZ SebWUfe aX fZW U^[W‘f afZWd fZS‘
`fZW TSe[U ekefW_ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘$ egUZ Se afZWd bdaYdS_e i[fZ[‘ fZW U^[W‘f&r Id.
`
`Sf -20"))& IZWdWXadW$ 7a^Wte dWUaY‘[f[a‘ bdaYdS_e _Sk [‘V[USfW fZSf fZW
`
`qbafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfWr UaVW gbVSfWe iWdW SUfgS^^k ‘af Sbbdabd[SfW Xad fZW
`
`)*
`
`Rcig!23!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1123
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`UgddW‘f Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ aX fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd$ [X afZWd bdaYdS_e i[fZ[‘ fZW
`
`U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd SdW ‘af Ua_bSf[T^W i[fZ fZW qbafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfWr UaVW
`
`gbVSfWe&
`
`IZW EWf[f[a‘ VaWe ‘af Wjb^S[‘ fZW XgdfZWd dWUaY‘[f[a‘ efWb aX 7a^W S‘V
`
`dW^[We ea^W^k a‘ fZW qbafW‘f[S^^k Sbbdabd[SfWr UaVW gbVSfW VWfWd_[‘Sf[a‘$
`
`iZ[UZ$ S^a‘W$ [e [‘egXX[U[W‘f fa fWSUZ ad egYYWef qS ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r See In re Magnum Oil Tools Int’l, Ltd.$ 0*1 ;&+V )+.,$
`
`)+0) ";WV& 7[d& *().# "Za^V[‘Y fZSf TWUSgeW bWf[f[a‘Wd qTWSde fZW TgdVW‘ aX
`
`bdaaX$r fZW 6aSdV q_gef TSeW [fe VWU[e[a‘ a‘ SdYg_W‘fe fZSf iWdW SVhS‘UWV
`
`Tk PbWf[f[a‘WdQr#3 +- J&H&7& m +)*"S#"+#3 +/ 7&;&G& mm ,*&**"S#"*#$
`
`,*&)(,"T#",#o"-#&
`
`IZ[e ^[_[fSf[a‘ [e dWU[fWV [‘ S^^ [‘VWbW‘VW‘f U^S[_e aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f&
`
`5UUadV[‘Y^k$ iW SdW ‘af bWdegSVWV fZSf EWf[f[a‘Wd ZSe _Wf [fe TgdVW‘ aX
`
`VW_a‘efdSf[‘Y Tk S dWSea‘ST^W ^[]W^[ZaaV [fe SeeWdf[a‘ fZSf fZW UZS^^W‘YWV
`
`U^S[_e aX fZW t(00 bSfW‘f SdW aTh[age ahWd 7a^W$ BSU>‘‘[e$ S‘V 9^YdWeek&
`
`7& E>IO9A$ 7DA9$ 5C8 9A<G9HHN
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd S^^WYWe fZSf U^S[_e )"*) iag^V ZShW TWW‘ aTh[age ahWd
`
`E[flW^$ 7a^W$ S‘V 9^YdWeek& EWf& ,*".0&
`1. Overview of Pitzel
`
`E[flW^ [e V[dWUfWV fa S ekefW_ S‘V _WfZaV Xad gbVSf[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ h[S
`
`S ‘Wfiad]$ S‘V bSdf[Ug^Sd^k$ gbVSf[‘Y Ua_bgfWd bdaYdS_e TSeWV gba‘ U^[W‘f%
`
`ebWU[X[U [‘Xad_Sf[a‘& 9j& )((-$ P-,Q$ )2.")*& E[flW^ Wjb^S[‘e fZSf fkb[US^^k S
`
`geWd h[e[fe S‘ qgbVSfWr eWdhWd fZSf Zaefe fZW [_bdahWV Ua_bgfWd bdaYdS_e&
`Id. Sf )2+)"+*& JeWde SdW aXfW‘ Ua‘XgeWV S‘V Vai‘^aSV fZW [‘UaddWUf hWde[a‘
`
`aX fZW dWcgWefWV eaXfiSdW TWUSgeW S ‘g_TWd aX baee[T^W hWde[a‘e SdW
`ShS[^ST^W Xad Vai‘^aSV[‘Y& Id. Sf )2++"+.& ;ad WjS_b^W$ S geWd _Sk TW
`
`)+
`
`Rcig!24!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1124
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`[‘fWdWefWV [‘ S q;dW‘UZr hWde[a‘$ Tgf fZW geWd _Sk ‘af ]‘ai fZW hWde[a‘ aX S‘
`
`abWdSf[‘Y ekefW_ ad iZWfZWd afZWd Ua_bgfWd bdaYdS_e SdW dWcg[dWV Xad
`bdabWd abWdSf[a‘ aX fZW gbYdSVW& Id. Sf )2+.",*& IZge$ E[flW^ eWW]e
`
`Sgfa_Sf[U Vai‘^aSV[‘Y aX S‘ Sbbdabd[SfW hWde[a‘ aX S Ua_bgfWd bdaYdS_
`i[fZagf geWd [‘fWdhW‘f[a‘& Id. Sf )2,/",1&
`
`E[flW^ fZge VWeUd[TWe S _WfZaV Xad [‘efS^^[‘Y Ua_ba‘W‘fe a‘ fZW U^[W‘f
`
`Ua_bgfWd Tk X[def ZSh[‘Y fZW geWd Sf fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd [‘[f[SfW S‘ gbYdSVW
`dWcgWef& Id. Sf /2)-")1& IZW geWd fZW‘ SUUWeeWe S Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ eWdhWd fZSf
`Zaefe Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^We& Id. Sf /2*)"*,& 5 Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^W Ua‘fS[‘e fZW
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xad fZW [‘efS^^Sf[a‘ aX a‘W ad _adW Ua_ba‘W‘fe a‘
`fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& Id. Sf -2)(")*& ;ad WSUZ Ua_ba‘W‘f fZWdW [e SeeaU[SfWV
`S Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^W& Id. Sf -2*("**& IZW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ eWdhWd bdah[VWe
`
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf fZW Ua_ba‘W‘fe h[S S iWT bSYW$ iZWdW fZW geWd US‘ U^[U]
`a‘ fZW [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ fZSf [e ZkbWd^[‘]WV fa fZW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^W& Id. Sf
`
`/2**"*/& 7^[U][‘Y fZW ZkbWd^[‘] USgeWe fZW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ eWdhWd fa
`Vai‘^aSV fZW Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^W fa fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& Id. Sf /2*/"+(& IZW
`
`U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd VWfWd_[‘We fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e S‘V XadiSdVe fZW
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘ X[^W S‘V fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e fa fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd& Id. Sf
`
`/2,(",,& IZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e SdW efadWV [‘ S Ua_bgfWd bdaX[^W egUZ fZSf
`
`iZW‘ S Ua_ba‘W‘f [e VWe[Y‘SfWV Xad [‘efS^^Sf[a‘$ S hWde[a‘ aX fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f
`fZSf [e Ua_bSf[T^W i[fZ fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e _Sk TW eW^WUfWV& Id. Sf -2,(",,&
`
`IZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e [‘U^gVW2 S bdWXWddWV abWdSf[‘Y ^S‘YgSYW$ W&Y&$ ;dW‘UZ$
`
`9‘Y^[eZ$ <Wd_S‘$ WfU&$ fZW ‘S_W aX fZW abWdSf[‘Y ekefW_ aX fZW U^[W‘f
`
`Ua_bgfWd$ S‘k hWde[a‘ ‘g_TWd fZSf _Sk TW SeeaU[SfWV i[fZ fZW abWdSf[‘Y
`
`ekefW_$ fZW Wj[efW‘UW aX a‘W ad _adW afZWd Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX fZW U^[W‘f
`Ua_bgfWd$ S‘V’ad S geWd [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ ‘g_TWd& Id. Sf ,2,+"-*&
`
`),
`
`Rcig!25!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1125
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`IZW Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd S‘S^klWe fZW gbYdSVW dWcgWef S‘V VWfWd_[‘We
`fZW Sbbdabd[SfW hWde[a‘ aX fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f fZSf fZW geWd dWcgWefWV& Id. Sf
`
`/2,1"-.& >‘ bSdf[Ug^Sd$ S‘ gbYdSVW ZS‘V^Wd _aVg^W [‘ fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd
`
`qgeWe fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e fa eW^WUf Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW Ua_bSf[T^k abWdST^W
`i[fZ fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd )(,&r Id. Sf 12-1".)& q;ad WjS_b^W$ fZW gbYdSVW
`
`ZS‘V^Wd _aVg^W )+, eW^WUfe Ua_ba‘W‘fe S‘V’ad hWde[a‘ aX Ua_ba‘W‘fe )(*
`
`fZSf SdW [‘ S ^S‘YgSYW iZ[UZ [e bdWXWddWV Tk fZW geWd$ [&W&$ 9‘Y^[eZ$ ;dW‘UZ$
`<Wd_S‘&r Id. Sf 12.)".-& 5VV[f[a‘S^^k$ fZW gbYdSVW ZS‘V^Wd _aVg^W US‘
`
`abf[a‘S^^k VWfWd_[‘W a‘W ad _adW SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW ‘WUWeeSdk
`
`Xad bdabWd abWdSf[a‘ [‘ SVV[f[a‘ fa fZaeW Ua_ba‘W‘fe dWcgWefWV Tk fZW U^[W‘f
`Ua_bgfWd& Id. Sf 12..")(2*& >‘ a‘W W_TaV[_W‘f$ fZW VWbW‘VW‘Uk
`[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ [e efadWV [‘ fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f VSfSTSeW& Id. Sf )(21")(& 5XfWd fZW
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd _S]We fZW eW^WUf[a‘$ [f YW‘WdSfWe S‘ gbYdSVW dWeba‘eW
`
`_WeeSYW fZSf [VW‘f[X[We fZW ^aUSf[a‘e aX fZW Ua_ba‘W‘fe dWcgWefWV Tk fZW
`U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd& Id. Sf /2-."-1&
`2. List of Known Acceptable Configurations
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd SeeWdfe fZSf E[flW^ fWSUZWe fZW q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r EWf& ,0"-(& EWf[f[a‘Wd Ua‘fW‘Ve fZSf E[flW^te Ua_ba‘W‘f
`
`eWdhWd bWdXad_e fia Ua_bSd[ea‘e fZSf _WWf fZW U^S[_ ^[_[fSf[a‘& 5e fa fZW
`
`X[def Ua_bSd[ea‘$ EWf[f[a‘Wd Ua‘fW‘Ve fZSf fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd efadWe
`
`qVWbW‘VW‘Uk [‘Xad_Sf[a‘r [‘ S VSfSTSeW qea fZSf iZW‘ S hWde[a‘ aX S
`
`dWcgWefWV Ua_ba‘W‘f fa TW [‘efS^^WV a‘ fZW U^[W‘f dWcg[dWe S‘ SVV[f[a‘S^
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f Xad bdabWd abWdSf[a‘$ S‘V fZSf SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f [e _[ee[‘Y$
`fZW SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f US‘ TW [VW‘f[X[WV S‘V bdah[VWV fa fZW U^[W‘f&r Id. Sf
`
`,1& IZge$ EWf[f[a‘Wd SdYgWe$ E[flW^ V[eU^aeWe Ua_bSd[‘Y fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e
`
`)-
`
`Rcig!26!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1126
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`S‘V fZW SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f i[fZ q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad
`[‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r Id.
`
`5e fa fZW eWUa‘V Ua_bSd[ea‘$ EWf[f[a‘Wd Ua‘fW‘Ve fZSf fZW U^[W‘f
`Ua‘V[f[a‘e [VW‘f[Xk _g^f[b^W Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX fZW U^[W‘f& Id. ;ad [‘efS‘UW$
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e [‘U^gVW S ‘S_W ad hWde[a‘ ‘g_TWd
`
`aX fZW abWdSf[‘Y ekefW_$ a‘W ad _adW Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX fZW U^[W‘f Ua_bgfWd$
`
`bdaVgUf [‘Xad_Sf[a‘$ V[efd[Tgf[a‘ UaVWe$ S‘V S g‘[cgW [VW‘f[X[Wd SeeaU[SfWV
`i[fZ S _[UdabdaUWeead& Id Sf ,1"-(& EWf[f[a‘Wd SdYgWe fZSf WSUZ aX fZWeW
`
`qU^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘er [e TafZ S qVWh[UW Ua_ba‘W‘f dWcg[dWV fa [_b^W_W‘f fZW
`
`dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ dWcgWefr S‘V S‘ qSVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f UgddW‘f^k
`[_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r Id. Sf -(& 5UUadV[‘Y fa EWf[f[a‘Wd
`
`fZW‘$ E[flW^ fWSUZWe fZW Ua_bSd[ea‘ aX a‘W aX fZW Ua_ba‘W‘fe [VW‘f[X[WV [‘
`
`fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e$ S‘V S‘afZWd Ua_ba‘W‘f [VW‘f[X[WV [‘ fZW U^[W‘f
`
`Ua‘V[f[a‘e$ i[fZ fZW q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r Id.
`
`;ad TafZ aX EWf[f[a‘Wdte S^^WYWV Ua_bSd[ea‘e$ EWf[f[a‘Wd S^^gVWe fa
`
`q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er [‘
`
`E[flW^ Se V[eU^ae[‘Y fZW dWU[fWV q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er S‘V
`
`q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r IZW EWf[f[a‘ VaWe ‘af Wjb^S[‘$
`‘ad Va iW X[‘V$ how E[flW^ V[eU^aeWe$ fWSUZWe$ ad egYYWefe$ S q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘
`
`SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er ad S q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er
`
`Tk S^^gV[‘Y fa q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r IZW Ua‘U^geadk SeeWdf[a‘ S‘V ^SU] aX XSUfgS^ egbbadf
`
`fZWdWaX [e XgdfZWd Ua‘X[d_WV Tk U^aeWd efgVk aX E[flW^ S‘V EWf[f[a‘Wdte
`
`Ua‘fW‘f[a‘e&
`
`;[def$ iW SdW ‘af bWdegSVWV fZSf E[flW^ egbbadfe EWf[f[a‘Wdte SeeWdf[a‘e
`
`aX S Ua_bSd[ea‘ i[fZ S q^[ef&r EWf[f[a‘Wd SeeWdfe fZSf E[flW^te Ua_ba‘W‘f
`
`).
`
`Rcig!27!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1127
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`eWdhWd eW^WUfe Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW Ua_bSf[T^k abWdST^W i[fZ fZW U^[W‘f& See
`
`EWf& ,0 "U[f[‘Y 9j& )((-$ /2-+"-.#& IZ[e [e ‘af S V[eU^aegdW aX fZW dWcg[dWV
`Ua_bSd[ea‘& ;da_ fZ[e V[eU^aegdW$ Sf TWef$ iW US‘ [‘XWd fZW result aX
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f eW^WUf[a‘ TSeWV a‘ Ua_bSf[T[^[fkpTgf fZ[e efSfW_W‘f VaWe ‘af
`fWSUZ how E[flW^ bWdXad_e fZW eW^WUf[a‘& ;gdfZWd$ fZW U^S[_ dWcg[dWe S
`
`ebWU[X[U Ua_bSd[ea‘ aX fia b[WUWe aX [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ "VWfWd_[‘WV Ua_ba‘W‘f
`
`S‘V a‘W SVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f# i[fZ fZW dWcg[dWV qSf ^WSef a‘W aX S ^[ef aX
`
`]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e S‘V S ^[ef aX S ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W
`
`Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r 6gf EWf[f[a‘Wd VaWe ‘af Wjb^S[‘ Zai E[flW^ fWSUZWe fZW
`
`dWcg[dWV Ua_bSd[ea‘ i[fZ W[fZWd aX fZW dWU[fWV ^[efe aX ]‘ai‘ Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&
`
`E[flW^ efSfWe fZSf fZW gbYdSVW ZS‘V^Wd _aVg^W eW^WUfe Ua_ba‘W‘fe S‘V’ad
`
`hWde[a‘ aX Ua_ba‘W‘fe fZSf SdW [‘ S ^S‘YgSYW iZ[UZ [e bdWXWddWV Tk fZW geWd$
`
`[&W&$ 9‘Y^[eZ$ ;dW‘UZ$ <Wd_S‘& 9j& )((-$ 12.)".-& 5f TWef E[flW^ Ua_bSdWe
`
`S dWcgWefWV Ua_ba‘W‘f i[fZ S U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘$ iZ[UZ [e S^^WYWV fa TW fZW
`
`qSVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f UgddW‘f^k [_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZW W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UW&r ;ad
`
`[‘efS‘UW$ E[flW^ _Sk WjS_[‘W fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e fa VWfWd_[‘W fZSf fZW geWd
`
`bdWXWde ;dW‘UZ ^S‘YgSYW$ S‘V fZge eW^WUfe fZW ;dW‘UZ hWde[a‘ aX S eaXfiSdW
`
`dWcgWefWV Tk fZW geWd& IZWdW [e ‘a V[eU^aegdW [‘ E[flW^ W‘egd[‘Y fZSf fZW
`
`eW^WUfWV ;dW‘UZ hWde[a‘ aX fZW dWcgWefWV eaXfiSdW [e Ua_bSf[T^W ad afZWdi[eW
`
`^[efWV Se S q]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘&r 5YS[‘$ fZW EWf[f[a‘ _WdW^k
`
`efSfWe fZSf fZWdW [e S Ua_bSd[ea‘ i[fZ q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W
`
`ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er [‘ E[flW^$ i[fZagf Wjb^S‘Sf[a‘ ad XSUfgS^
`
`egbbadf&
`
`HWUa‘V$ Xad TafZ S^^WYWV Ua_bSd[ea‘e$ EWf[f[a‘Wd e[_b^k dWefSfWe fZW
`
`U^S[_ ^S‘YgSYW S^^gV[‘Y fa q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad
`
`[‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘er Se V[eU^ae[‘Y fZW dWU[fWV ^[efe& EWf& ,0
`
`)/
`
`Rcig!28!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1128
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`"q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e "sSf
`
`^WSef a‘W aX S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U
`
`VWh[UW S‘V S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW VWh[UWt#$r ,1
`
`"q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad [‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e "sSf
`
`^WSef a‘W aX S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW W^WUfda‘[U
`
`VWh[UW S‘V S ^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ g‘SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e Xad fZW VWh[UWt#&r
`
`CW[fZWd aX EWf[f[a‘Wdte efSfW_W‘fe eZaie iZSf ebWU[X[U V[eU^aegdW aX E[flW^
`
`EWf[f[a‘Wd Ua‘fW‘Ve [e Wh[VW‘UW aX q[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ STagf ]‘ai‘ Ua_bSf[T^W ad
`
`[‘Ua_bSf[T^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r ;gdfZWd$ dW^k[‘Y a‘ fZW @‘gfea‘ 8WU^SdSf[a‘
`
`Se egbbadf[‘Y fZWeW efSfW_W‘fe [e fa ‘a ShS[^ TWUSgeW fZW @‘gfea‘
`
`8WU^SdSf[a‘ dWbWSfe fZWeW efSfW_W‘fe hWdTSf[_ i[fZ ‘a XgdfZWd Wjb^S‘Sf[a‘ ad
`XSUfgS^ egbbadf& See @‘gfea‘ 8WU^& nn )-1$ ).(& IZge$ iW SUUadV fZW
`@‘gfea‘ 8WU^SdSf[a‘ ^[ff^W fa ‘a iW[YZf a‘ fZ[e ba[‘f& See Verlander v.
`Garner$ +,0 ;&+V )+-1$ )+/) ";WV& 7[d& *((+# "6aSdV ZSe V[eUdWf[a‘ fa
`SUUadV ^[ff^W iW[YZf fa TdaSV Ua‘U^geadk efSfW_W‘fe Xda_ WjbWdf i[f‘Wee#3 see
`also +/ 7&;&G& m ,*&.-"S# "Wjb^S[‘[‘Y fZSf WjbWdfe SdW dWcg[dWV fa bdah[VW
`
`egbbadf[‘Y XSUfe ad VSfS Xad fZW[d ab[‘[a‘e#&
`
`IZ[dV$ EWf[f[a‘Wd ZSe ‘af eZai‘ bWdegSe[hW^k fZSf fZW W_TaV[_W‘f aX
`
`fZW VWbW‘VW‘Uk [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ efadWV [‘ fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f eWdhWd VSfSTSeW fWSUZWe
`
`fZW dWU[fWV Ua_bSd[ea‘ i[fZ fZW dWcg[dWV q^[ef&r E[flW^ efSfWe fZSf fZW gbYdSVW
`
`ZS‘V^Wd _aVg^W WjS_[‘We fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e fa VWfWd_[‘W fZW Wj[efW‘UW aX
`
`‘WUWeeSdk Ua_ba‘W‘fe$ S‘V$ [X _[ee[‘Y$ fa egbb^k fZWeW Ua_ba‘W‘fe [‘
`
`SVV[f[a‘ fa fZW dWcgWefWV Ua_ba‘W‘f& 9j& )((-$ )(2-")(& E[flW^$ fZge$
`
`VWeUd[TWe [VW‘f[Xk[‘Y _[ee[‘Y Ua_ba‘W‘fe$ [‘ SVV[f[a‘ fa fZW Ua_ba‘W‘f
`
`dWcgWefWV Tk fZW U^[W‘f& >X fZW _[ee[‘Y Ua_ba‘W‘f [e fZW dWU[fWV qVWh[UW
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f dWcg[dWV fa [_b^W_W‘f fZW dWUa‘X[YgdSf[a‘ dWcgWef$r Se EWf[f[a‘Wd
`
`Ua‘fW‘Ve$ fZW‘ fZW U^S[_ dWcg[dWe Ua_bSd[‘Y fZSf q_[ee[‘Yr ad VWbW‘VW‘f
`
`)0
`
`Rcig!29!qh!33
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2123!.!RCIG!1129
`
`

`

`>EG*()1%(((-.
`ESfW‘f .$,./$(00 6)
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘f S‘V fZW qSVV[f[a‘S^ Ua_ba‘W‘f UgddW‘f^k [_b^W_W‘fWV [‘ fZW
`
`W^WUfda‘[U VWh[UWr i[fZ fZW q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e&r
`
`E[flW^$ ZaiWhWd$ Sf TWef$ Ua_bSdWe fZW U^[W‘f Ua‘V[f[a‘e i[fZ fZW VWbW‘VW‘f
`
`Ua_ba‘W‘fe$ fa [VW‘f[Xk iZWfZWd fZaeW VWbW‘VW‘f Ua_ba‘W‘fe SdW _[ee[‘Y [‘
`
`fZW U^[W‘f VWh[UW& ;a^^ai[‘Y EWf[f[a‘Wdte UZSdSUfWd[lSf[a‘ aX E[flW^$ fZWdW [e
`
`‘a Ua_bSd[ea‘ i[fZ fZW q^[ef aX ]‘ai‘ SUUWbfST^W Ua‘X[YgdSf[a‘e