IPR2016-01516, No. 1014-14 Exhibit - Tait (P.T.A.B. Aug. 2, 2016)

A File System for Mobile Computing
`
`Carl Downing Tait
`
`Submitted in partial fulfillment of the
`
`requirements for the degree
`of Doctor of Philosophy
`
`in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences
`
`COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
`1993
`
`LG Electronics, Inc. et al.
`EXHIBIT 1014
`IPR Petition for
`U.S. Patent No. 7,149,511
`
`

`
`a W[r1EHG@J _`S oC:PC ^; EH:=<n`JPJ ~ :=^[Ub<kXo~o?X ?WG 7?A
`
`Carl Downing Tait
`
`© 1993
`
`All Rights Reserved
`
`

`
`
`

!
`" !#$ % &('$)*+ ,.-r1EHG@J _`S oC:PC ^; EH:=<_`: X <>G@:P86 <>?AlMFJ=?X g X <@?Q9XEG>?]E KL6CFAE9;?QCb<kEHJ X <@G>6Fac<@6G>?SK.AR: X <@G>:P8 6<>?AacS9;D6<@:PC^0/bEHCFA9 6Fa U E<><@?QCR<@:PSC

UFEX 8F?Q?QC

KLSbac6OX ?A

SC<>U?Q:=G]AR?X :=^[C21 x6<]S[C?;:=9;DFS[G@<kEHCb<C? AR?qX :P^CDFS[:=CR< UOE[X CS< g7?Q<m8F?Q?QCj?43RDJ=S[G@?A <@US[G@S[6^UJPg+5 US <>SX 6DDFSG>< 9;S8:PJ=?1acJP:=?QCR<YX61me S[G><YEH8J=? SG87 X <YEH<>:=S[CFXTEHG>?.8F?acS9;:PC ^o:PCFacG@?E[Xf:PC^JPga S[9;9;SC2/QECFA DF?QSDJP? oUSu6FX ?1<>U?Xf?.9E[akU:PC ?XX U S[6J ApCS<d8F?BKLSGkac?qA <>S E[aQa ?QD<\:PCRKL?QG@:PSGdDF?QG KLSG>9ECFac? SGd6FX@EH8:=JP:P<fg91U :IXAR:IX@X ?QG@<kE<>:PSCEHG@^[6?qX<>UFE<< S]:IAR?EX;: ?6<a :P?QCb< EHG@:IEH8 JP?>= acS[COX :IXf<>?QCOacgjG>?QD JP:IaWEH<>:=S[C%EHCFA :PCb<>?QJ=JP:P^?QCb< MFJP?DG@?cKL?Q<kakU:=C^?: JP?EAp<@S
`ElMFJ=?;XfgXf<>?Q9 <>UFE<jX 6 DDFS[G><YX 9;S[8 :PJP? acJP:=?QCb<kX`DFEG><@:Iac6J EHG@JPg 1?QJPJ@1n`J=^[S[G@:P<@U9X6/:P9%DJP?Q9 ?QCb<kE<>:PSCFX6/ECFA;ECFEHJ=gXf?X.EHG>?oD G>?Xf?QCR<@?A <>S]Xf6DDFS[G@<<>U :IX.E[X@X ?QG@<>:PSC21
`
`

`
`
`

! "# "!$%'&("*)+-,. ! "0/# "!$%'

-* ! /13245-76%98-)9:; ! /-"< = ,58+-2>" < 1 U?Xf:IX@???A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? C 1DC 57680=/U?qX ?X ???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? 1DC1 } < ac:=?QCR<1|1EHG>: EH8J=?>=fr.S[CFXf:IX <@?QCFacg ~ ?QD JP:IaWEH<>:=S[C ?A??A??A???B??? 1DC1DC y Cb<>?WJPJP:=^[?QCb<FE :PJ=?e G>?cKL?W<kakU:PC^G?A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? H 1 s\6<>J=:PC?uSHK.<@U?]_`:IX@X ?QG@<kEH<@:PSCI???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? HJ K

245),.+-8 LC1 y/CR<@G>SbAR6Oac<>:=S[CM???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? NC1DC {dE9;:PC^ ??A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? OC1 ~o?QDJP: aQEH<@:PSC ???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? [C1QP r1E[akU:=C^ ??A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? SRC1DH 5769%9EHG@g ?A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC>UV WYX 2Z"9\[

Z]$!^"*!$_9-2>`;a3 b"2Z

9" JJ 1 y/CR<@G>SbAR6Oac<>:=S[CM???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC>C 1DC s\DF?QGkE<>:PSC :=Ch<@U?]n`8FXf?QCFac?dSKFEFEH:=JP6G@?Xc??B???A???A??A??A???B???TC.P 1DC1 _`6FEHJ =/~o?EA= r1EJPJTy/CR<@?QG K Eac?d??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC>N 1DC1DC r.6G>G@?QCFacgmS 77?WCFXe?A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC R 1DC1 EO6 G><>U ?QG\_`?Q<YEH:PJ X@??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? H 1DC1QP r.JP:P?WCR<=/e G>:=9EHG@g n <@<kEa U9%?QCR< ???B???A???A??A??A???B??? O 1DC1DH E :PJ=?X g X <@?Q9 =f57?acSCFAEHG@g n <@<kEa U9%?QCR<???A???A??A??A???B??? [ 1DC1DN r.S[CC?qac<>:=S[C
`E<\El_\:IX <YEHCb<d57:P<@????B???A???A??A??A???B???MP 1DC1fO w S[8:=JP:P<fg%EH<\E _`:IXf<kECR<d57:=<>? ?A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MPZC 1 EFEH:=JP6G@? ~o?acS 7?QG@g ???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MPZC 1 1 57?acSCFAEHG@g
`57?QG 7?WG(EFEH:=JP6G@?g??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP :
`
`

`
` 1 1DC eG@:P9EG>g57?QG 7?QG(EFEH:=JP6G@?T?A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP 1 1 r.JP:P?WCR< E E:PJ=6G>? ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP>P 1 1QP ~ ?Eac<>:=S[C<>S%e EG><>:=<>:=S[CT??A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP>P 1 1DH ~ ?XfS[J=6<>:=S[C SKr.SC F: ac<>:=C^ v`D AEH<@?X ???A???A??A??A???B???MPZH 1 1DN ndaQacS9;9;SbAE<>:PSC;SHK EHCFAR?WG>:PC ^;vdXf?QGkX ?A???A??A??A???B???MP R 1 1fO 57?Q9ECR<@:IaQXI???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP R 1QP } 3RDF?QG@:P9;?WCR<YEHJ ~ ?qX 6J=<kX ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP 1QP 1 };3bDF?QG>:=9;?QCb<kX??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP 1QP 1DC ~ ?Xf6JP<YXY??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH>U 1DH e G>S<>S[<fgbDF?jy/9;DJ=?Q9l?WCR<YEH<>: SC@???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH.P 1DH1 s 7?WG b:P? ???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH>H 1DH1DC 57S[6GYac?lr.SbAb? ??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH 1DH1 ~ ?Xf<>G@:Iac<@:PS[COXI??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN>C 1DN r.S[9%DFEHG@:IX SC o:=<>U ~ ?WJIEH<@?A S[G7 ??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN>C 1DN1 e ?QG KLSG>9ECFac? ??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN>C 1DN1DC ~ ?Xf:PJ=:P?QCFa gc???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN 1fO r.S[COacJP6FXf:PSCd?A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN>H = *"*) &("*,7 72
` -"*-) L

P 1 y/CR<@G>SbAR6Oac<>:=S[CM???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN7OP 1DC U? n`JP^S[G>:=<>U9 ?B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TN P 1DC1 _dEH<YEh57<>G@6Fac<@6G>?*: U ? S[G87b:PC ^%EOSG>?Xf< ???A??A??A???B???TN P 1DC1DC 5bE R:=C^;ECFAt'S7EAR:PC^ ZG@?Q?Xe?A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IO P 1DC1 ZG@?Q?j57DJP:=<><@:PC^ ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IOHP 1DC1QP r.S[9;9;SCe G>?cM 3ZG@?Q?X(??A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IOHP 1DC1DH r.gacJ=?]ZG@?Q?X ??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IO>OP 1DC1DN eG@?cKL?Q<Ya U r.SCRM AR?WCFac?\???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IO>OP 1DC1fO idEG>8FE^[?;r.SJPJP?qac<>:=S[C ???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IO P 1 57:=9l6J EH<@:PS[C ~ ?Xf6JP<YXe??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R UP 1 1 ZGYE[ac? _dEH<YE ??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R UP 1 1DC 57:P9 6JIE<>:=S[Cw ?Q<@USbARSJPS[^ge??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R UP 1 1 ~ ?Xf6JP<YXY??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R CP 1 1QP t':P9;:=<kEH<@:PSCFXe??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R NP 1QP y/9;DJ=?Q9;? CR<YEH<>:=S[C ?B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R>RP 1QP 1 _`?X :=^[C s 7?WG b:P? ?A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R[P 1QP 1DC { E5s 7?QG b:P? ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? RP 1QP 1 {`? E :PJ=?X ???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? [P 1QP 1QP w SbAR:NM aWEH<>:=S[CFXo<>S%} 3R: X <@:PC^%E :=JP?X(??B???A???A??A??A???B??? HP 1QP 1DH _`: ?QG@?QCFac?X8F?Q< 1?Q?QC;<@U?j57:P9 6JIE<>:=S[CECFA;<>U?]y/9;DJ=?Q9;? CR<YEH<>:=S[C ? >RP 1QP 1DN } EJP6FE<>:PSCg???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U>UP 1QP 1fO _`:IX@ac6FX>Xf:PSC ???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U.PP 1DH ~o?QJIE<>?A S[G87??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U>H:P:
`
`

`
`P 1DN 5769%9EHG@g ?A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U 2Z+!^"* << H1 r.S[Cb<>G@:P86 <>:PSCFXI??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? UH1DC E6<>6 G>?

SG87 ???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? [H1DC1 i`?WC?QGkEJ?B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? [H1DC1DC } < ac:=?QCR<1|1EHG>: EH8J=?>=fr.S[CFXf:IX <@?QCFacg ~ ?QD JP:IaWEH<>:=S[C ?A??A??A???B??? [H1DC1 y Cb<>?WJPJP:=^[?QCb<FE :PJ=?e G>?cKL?W<kakU:PC^G?A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? CH1 5769%9EHG@g ?A???B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? HK ""*),

b ` << L:P:=:
`
`

`
` 1 t'S7S7Xf? ~ ?qE[An`JP^S[G@:P<>U 9 ??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC7O 1DC 57<@G>:Ia <\~ ?EA :P<>U S[6<uElr1 ???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TC 1 57<@G>:Ia <\~ ?EA :P<>U E;r1@??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U 1QP 57g X <@?Q9s\G>^ EHC:
`EH<@:PS[C ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MPZU 1DH t'S[^:IaQEJ5 <>G>6Oac<>6G@?SHKeG@S[<@S[<fgRDF? ?A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH>N 1DN y/9;DJ=?Q9;? CR<YEH<>:=S[C SHKe G>S[<@S[<fgbD ???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH RP 1 5bE9;DJP?eG@S[^GkEH9 mG>?Q? ?A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IOUP 1DC S%_`: '?WG>?QCb<

aQaRmG>?W?X ?A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IOSPP 1 mG>?Q?j57DJ=:P<@<>:PC ^@??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IONP 1QP r.g acJP?mG>?W?Br.SCFX <@G>6Fa <>:PSC ?A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???IO RP 1DH E :=JP?e G>? KL?Q<kakU:PC ^jy/9;DJ=?Q9;? CR<YEH<>:=S[C;??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U:
`
`

`
` - C1 no<><>G@:P86 <>?X.SHK1} 3b:IX <@:PC^ _\:IX <@G>:=86<>?qA E :PJP?57g X <@?Q9X ??A??A??A???B???TC 1 6S[G@69 r.S[CFAb:P<>:=S[CFX%??A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R 1DC 57<YEH<>?`?QJ Al8Rg }Ea U
`r.S9;DFS[C?QCb< ??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???MP 1 v`D AE<>?>=fs\D ?WC
`y/CR<@?QG EJIXM??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH>C 1QP E :=JP?t': KL?Q<>:=9;?XI??B???A??A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B???TH.PP 1 E :=JP? r1Ea U?]w : X>Xo~\EH<>? LD ?WGkac?QCb<
` ??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? R[P 1DC e E:PG\EHCOA mG>:P^GkE9w : X>X1~`E<>?X

DF?QGYac?QCb<
` ?B???A???A??A??A???B??? R PP 1 mG>?Q? X61.tm~ovzS 7?QGox6GYX <YX SK H C;ndaWac?X>Xf?X ??A???A??A??A???B??? R HP 1QP w :IX@Xo~`E<>?XKLS[J=JPS o:PC ^ ZG@?Q?e G>?cKL?W<kakU?X ??B???A???A??A??A???B??? R NP 1DH 57:
`Q?]EHCFA~o6CC:=C^;:=9;?\SHKor.SbAR? 57?ac<@:PSCFX
`???A???A??A??A???B??? R OP 1DN ~o?E[A 57JP?W?QD x?QCFakU9EHG7 Ulw 8:=<kX X ?qa r.SCC?a <>:PSC2/P R N r1e.v
`F??B??? U>CP 1fO ~o?E[A 57JP?W?QD x?QCFakU9EHG7 Cjw 8:=<kX X ?qa r.SCC?a <>:PSC2/ >R Nhr1e.v
` ??B??? U>CP 1 R ~o?E[A 57JP?W?QD x?QCFakU9EHG7 Ulw 8:=<kX X ?qa r.SCC?a <>:PSC2/ >R N r1e.v
`F??B??? U P 1 ?QG>C ?QJmx6:=JIAx?QCFakU9EG87 ?A???A??A???B???A???A??A??A???B??? U.P
`
`

`
`
`

U: X`AR: X>Xf?QG><YEH<>:=S[C:IX\AR?Ab:IaQE<>?Al<@Sl9 g DFEHG@?QCR<YX6/ oUS X ? X ?Q?Q9%:PC^JPgj6Cb8FS[6CFAb?AhJ=S 7?EHCFAX 6 DDFS[G>< X <>:=JPJ\E9E
`Q?9;? /.AR?X D :P<>?<@U?hK Eac<l<@UFEH< <>U ?Qg 7?;8F?Q?QC <>UFE< EqgKLSG;E<lJ=?E[Xf<<>U :PG><fg g7?EHGYXCS 1_dEHC _`6FakUFEH9%D2/9 g3EA b:IX SG>/oUFEX 8F?Q?WC SHK]:PC EHJP6OEH8J=?
`U?QJPD: <>?qa UC :IaQEJ\EHCFAS[<@U?QG o:IX ? : :PC^?Q<><@:PC^9;?j<@UG>S6^[U <>U? SHKL<@?QCEHGYAR6S6FXjARSbac<@S[GkEJDG@Sbac?X@X61_dECEHJ X SAR?Xf?QG 7?qX <>UOEHC 7 X KLSGj?QCFAR6 G>:PC ^
`9lg CR6 9;?QG>S6FX D :IEHC :IX <@:Ial?43RDJ=S[:=<kX6/ ?qX DF?ac: EHJPJ=g

<@U? W[ U{dE<>:PSCFEHJ r.U S[D:=C

r.S[9%D ?W<>:P<@:PSC21U?lS<>U?WG 9;?Q9j8F?QGYX SKo9 g<>U?Xf:IXacS9;9;:P<@<>? ?.: n\CR6DOEH9 xU :IAR?9/ t'6: X = E?QJP:=D ?r1EH8 G>?QGYE/`57<@? 7?{`S o: a 7+/ ECFA 5bEJd57<>SJNKLS : EG>?<>S 8F? a S[9;9;?WCFAR?AhKLSGj<>U?Q:=G aQEHG@?cKL6JG>? R:=? SHK.<@U?]AR:IX@X ?QG@<kE<>:PSC EHCFA;KLS[Go<>U ?Q:PG EHJ=6FEH8 JP?]acS[9%9;?QCb<kX61U?9EHCFE^[?Q9%?QCR<uSHKy xow xSbaQE
`~\EH<>SCDG>S b:IAR?A ^[?QC?WG>S[6OX MFCFEHCOac:IEJ\X 6DDFSG><6CFAb?QGo<>U?]~o?X : AR?QCb<`57<@6FARg e G>S^[GkE9 AR6G>:=C^j9 g MFGkXf< KLS6G`g7?qEHGkXSK ^GkEAR6FEH<@?jXf<>6FARg 1dEHG@G>g dEHGfS[CS oG>S[<@? ElXf68FXf<kEHCb<>: EHJ DFSG><>:=S[C
`SK.<>U?]6FX ?WG8=LJP? 7?QJ a SbAR? KLSGd<>U?MFJP?X g X <@?Q9 DG@S[<@S[<fgRDF?91x:PJPJ15ba U :PJP:=< X`JIE8 SG DG@SbAR6Fac?qA

<>U?jMFJ=?l<@GkE[a ?X 6FXf?A

:=C

<@U?l<@GkEac?>= ARG>: 7?QC

?43RDF?QG@: =9;?QCb<kX1AR?X@acG>:=8 ?qAl:PC<>U :IXoAR: X>X ?WG><kE<>:=S[C21 b:
`
`

`
` _`:IXf<>G>:=86<@?A MFJ=?jXfgXf<>?Q9XoEG>? E KL6CFAE9;?QCb<kEJ X <>G@6Fac<@6G>?]SHK AR:IXf<>G@:P86<@?A a S[9;D6 <8=:PC ^ /bEHCFAj9 6Fa U]E<><>?WCR<@:PS[CjUOE[X 8F?Q?QCjKLSbac6FX ?qABSCl<@U?Q:PGAR?X :=^[C / / W / ^R /ZC / U / b />P>P0/H /H
` 1.x6<1S[C?d:=9;DFS[G@<kEHCb<C ? AR?Xf:P^[C%D S:PCb<oUFE[XC S[<og7?Q<.8F?Q?QC;?43RDJ=S[G@?Al<>U S[G>S6^[U JPg+5US <>SXf6DDFS[G@<9;S[8:=JP?a JP:P?WCR<YX61 e SG><YEH8J=? S[G7Xf<kE<>:PSCFX;EG>?
`8F?acS9;:PC^
`:=CFacG@?E[Xf:PC^JPgacS9;9;S[C /[ECFAlDF?QS[D JP? oUS 6FXf?`<@U?Xf?`9Ea U :PC?X X U S[6J AlCS[<.8F?`KLSGkac?Aj<>S]EaQac?QD<.:=CRKL?QG>:=S[GDF?QG KLSG>9ECFac?]S[G6FX>E8:PJ=:P<fg91]U:IXdJ=?E 7?X`EC

SDF?QCV76?Xf<>:=S[C KLS[GG@?X ?EGkakU25 oUOEH<$7b:PCOA SHKMFJ=? XfgXf<>?Q9 :IXC ?ac?X@X>EHG@g;S[GuAR?Xf:PGYEH8J=?d<>S%X 6D D SG><d9%S[8:=JP?uacJP:=?QCR<YX

e S[G@<kEH8 JP? SG87 X <kE<>:=S[CFXo:PCb<>G@SbAR6Fac?C? :IX@X 6?qX:PCb<>S MOJP?]X g X <@?Q9 Ab?X :=^[C<>UFE<`UOE 7?CS<`g7?Q<18F?Q?QC E[AR?qV 6FE<>?QJ=gE[A ARG>?X@X ?A+5 U?u<>?akUCSJPS[^gl: Xac6 G>G>?WCR<@JPgjAb: ?QG>?WCR< KLG>S9 C S[C =LDFS[G><YEH8J=? 9Ea U :PC?X5 X <>SGkE^[?]aQE =DFEac:P<fgj: XX 9 EHJPJ=?QG>/ EHCFAlC ?Q< S[G7l8OEHCFA o: AR<>U%:IXAbGkE[Xf<>: aQEHJ=JPgjG>?qAR6Fac?A oU?QC o:=G>?QJ=?X>X:=CR<@?QGkacSCC?a <>:PSC:IXj6FX ?A3:=C E
`9l6 JP<>: =/EaQac?X@X C?Q< SG87+1 :PG>?WJP?X@X JP:PC07X ac6G@G>?QCb<>J=gUFE 7? E

XfD ?W?A3SHK N U>U8:=<kX qX ?a S[CFA3<@S U 9%?Q^7E8:P<YX Xf?acSCFA / 7?QGYX 6FX U <>S;N C>C9;?W^7EH8 :P<kX Xf?acS[COA%KLSGo<fgRD: aQEHJ UFEHGYA= o:PG>?qA acSCC?ac<@:PSCFX61 r.J=:P?QCb<m9;S[8 :PJP:=<fgo:PCb<>G>SbAb6Fac?Xm<>GYEHCFXfDFEHG@?QCFacgDG@S[8J=?Q9X65FKLS[G ?>3E9;DJ=?9/E`a JP:P?WCR< XfUS[6J A8F?uEH8J=?o<>S9;S 7?oEG>S[6 CFABKLG>?W?QJPg o:P<@US[6 <UOE b:PC ^d<>SDG@S b:IAb?oG>?acSCRMF^6GkE<>:PSC;:PCbKLS[G8=9E<>:=S[C;<@Sj<>U?dMFJ=? XfgXf<>?Q9 1r.6 G>G>?WCR<\XfgXf<>?Q9X.G>?V76:=G>?\<>UFE<dacJ=:P?QCb<kX DJ EQgEHC E[a <>: 7?G@S[JP? oU?QC 9;S[8 :PJP:=<fgl: X C?W?AR?A / EHCFA 6FXf6FEHJ=JPg DG>S b:IAR?]G>?AR6Oac?AhDF?QGfKLS[G@9EHCFa ? ? 7?QC<@U?QC21
`
`

`
`C m?Q9;DFS[GYEHG@gAR:IX@acS[C C?ac<@:PS[C :IXJ=: 77?QJ=g91.n`JP<@US[6 ^[U <@U:IX: X DOEHG><@JPgAb6? <@Sl<@U?jac6 G>G>?WCR<Xf<kEH<@?jSHK o:PG@?QJP?qX>Xo<>?akUCSJPS[^g9/ KL6<@6G>?j6OX ?QGYX`9EQg ?WJPJ o<>SAR: X>acSCC?a <`<@?Q9 =DFS[GYEHG@:PJPg <>S;G@?AR6Fa ? <>U ? acS7Xf<kXdEX>X Sba :IEH<@?A o:P<>U
`6OX :PC ^E o:PG>?WJP?X@X J=:PC 7+1dU?WG>?cKLSG>?9/E9;S[8:=JP? acJP:=?QCR< XdaWE[akU?j9l6OX <d8F?;9ECFEH^?A o:P<>U X DF?ac: EHJ1aQEHG@?l<@S 9E:PCb<kE:PC
`DF?QG8=KLSG>9ECFac?jECFA
`E EH:PJ EH8:=JP:=< g 1d_`: X>acSCC?ac<@:PSC EHCFA <@?a U CS[J=S[^[g acS[COX <>GYEH:=CR<YX`9E 77?:=<DFEG><@:Iac6J EHG@JPg%AR: < ac6J=<<>S%E[akU:=? 7?`U :P^[U E EH:=JIEH8 :PJP:=<fg91s`C ?j9;:P^UR<uV 6 ?X <@:PS[C <>U? o: X>ARS9SK\akUS7S7Xf:PC^<>S%G>6C E
`

`]MOJP?jXfgXf<>?Q9S[C Ej9;S[8 :PJP?\a S[9;D6 <>?QG41 UbglCS< f6OX <oG>6 C EjXf:P9;D JP?9/[J=SbaQEHJ'MOJP?XfgXf<>?Q9 :=CFX <@?E[A U?QG@?EHG@?9/US ? 7?QG>/[KL6CFA EH9;?QCb<kEJmEA EHCb<kEH^?X`:=Ch<@U?]AR:IXf<>G@:P86<@?Al9;SbAb?QJ 5 ~o?E[A =/XfUFEHG@:PC^]SHKmMFJ=?X :IX DFS7X>Xf:P8J=?9/ oU :IakUj^[G>?qEH<>J=gjG>?Ab6Fac?X <>U ?dacJ=:P?QCb< X AR?QDF?QCOAR?QCFac?SC JPSbaWEHJ X <@S[GYEH^[? AR? b:Iac?qX61 G>:=<>?Xo9E[Ab? J=SbaQEHJ=JPg EHG@?jE6<>S9EH<@:IaQEJPJPg%9;S 7?Al8FEa 7<>S EkX@EqKL?X ?WG 7?QGoJ=SbaQEH<@?A?QJ X ? oU ?QG>?91Ty/C EAAR:=<>:PSC<>S%X>EqKL?W< g /R<>U :IXoEHJ=JPS \X oG>:P<@?>= X UFEG>:PC ^jSHK MFJ=?X61U:IX AR:IX@X ?QG@<kEH<@:PSC AR?X@acG>:=8 ?qXh< S C? :IAb?E[X;KLS[G ? '?qac<>: 7? X 6DDFSG><
`SHK 9%S[8:=JP?acJ=:P?QCb<kX1 U ?X ?:IAb?E[X o:PJPJF8F?8G>:=? Fg AR: X>ac6OX>X ?qAl:PC 5 ?ac<>:=S[CFX 1 EHCFA 1DC1.tmE<>?QG\akUFEHD <>?QGYX o:PJ=J EAARG@?X>X`<@U? : X>Xf6?X`:=C
`AR?QD <>U21UG@S[6^US[6 <>/mS[6GAR?X :=^[C
`: X <YEHG>^?Q<>?qAhKLS[Gd<@U?>?QC ^[: =C?Q?WG>:PC ^ QS <a ?l?QC R:=G>SC9;?QCb<>/b:PC oU :IakU
`9EHCbgEHD DJP: aQEH<@:PS[COX`6FX ?j9 EHCbg Xf9EHJ=J'MFJP?qX6/'86 <X UOEHG>:=C^ :IXGkEG>?91lU :IX:IX<@U?]X <YEHCFAEGkA ?QC b:PG>SC9;?QCb< KLSG MFJ=?X g X <@?Q9 G@?X ?EGkakU21 "! #%$'&)(+*(U? ac?QCb<>GYEHJm<>U ?X : X`SHK.<@U:IXuAR:IX@X ?QG@<kEH<@:PSC :IX\<>UFE<d< S :IAR?EX : ?6<a :P?QCb< EHG@:IE8JP?>=acSCFX : X <>?WCFacgG>?QD JP:IaWEH<>:=S[C EHCFA
`:PCb<>?QJ=JP:=^[?QCb<MFJ=?jDG>? KL?Q<kakU:PC ^$: JP?EA <>SElMFJ=?jXfgXf<>?Q9 <>UFE<X 6 DDFS[G><YX`9;S8:PJ=?dacJ=:P?QCb<kX.DFEHG@<>: ac6JIEG>J=g 1?QJPJ@/ 6 CFAR?QGo<@U?]acS[CFXf<>GYEH:PCb<kX\AR?X@acG>:=8F?AEH8FS 7?91,.-0/+1324/+5687:9;=<>564?8/24@A5?B 6+?1DCA9AEGFHA IJLK/M1NN./O686QPR13?4?8/2496SUTV@7WN8@X7:9RN.K:5RYZ/6[?T\AGA?4@/2+N.KW136468/6]_^`Oa8bcdMe N.7:/9?87fJgNih.Aj6\klKW1324;/+Y13?.1M68/?46[24/1YX139LY=TV247:?8?8/O9m64/n5/9?87W1 KK:F dodqp 213961Nr?87:A9sP28AN./64687:9;sktIu24/n5/9?[64@R132479;RSTV7:?8@s68?8247WN.?vN.A9687:64?8/9RNrFm24/n57:28/Y d
`
`

`
` "! \#%$'&)(v& (U:IXdXf?ac<@:PS[C 8G>:=? Fg AR?X@acG>:=8F?X <@U? < 1SlDG@:PCFa :PDFEJ : AR?E[X\EH<u<>U? acS[G@?jSHK.<@U:IXdAb:IX =X ?WG><kE<>:=S[C21%UG>S6^[US6<>/ 1?l6OX ? <>U?kacJ=:P?QCb<8= X ?WG 7?QGDB9;SbAb?QJ 5acJ=:P?QCb<kXo:IX@X 6? G>?qV 6?qX <kXd<@SX ?WG 7?QGYXB:=C3S[GYAR?QG <>SEaQac?X@XBSG;6D AE<>? MFJ=?X61 X
`

: X <@S[G@:PC^a S[D:=?XBSK EpMFJP?S[C9;SG>?;<@UFEHC S[C? Xf?QG 7?QG : : X 6FX ?A<@S

:=9;DG>S 7? MFJ=?E EH:PJ EH8:=JP:=< g 1

y K\SC?DFEHG@<>:Ia 6JIEGX ?WG 7?QG : X.ARS oC2/E]acS[DbgjSHK <>U?\G>?QJ=? EHCb< MFJ=?daQEC;6FXf6FEHJ=JPgj8F? KL?W<kakU?A KLG>S9 EHCS<>U?WGoX ?WG 7?QG<>GYEHCFXfDFEHG@?QCb<>JPg 1 , ! #$#" &, , '$ ;+ &,_`?Q<>?WG>9;:=C:PC^ EC ?qV 6:=<kE8JP? <>GkEAR?QS
` 8F?Q< 1?Q?QC E EH:=JIE8:PJ=:P<fgEHCOA acSCFX : X <@?QCFacg SHKAE<kE : XE`KL6CFA EH9;?QCb<kEJFDG>S8JP?Q9 :PClMOJP?\X g X <@?Q9 AR?Xf:P^C21.n U :P^[U JPg =/E EH:=JIEH8 JP?uX g X <>?W9 9EQgX S9;?Q<@:P9;?XoG>?W<>6G@C

:=CFacS[COX :IXf<>?QCb<]AEH<YE AR6 ?l<@S
`X ?WG 7?QGdK EH:=JP6G@?XdS[G]C?Q< SG87
`DFEG><>:=<>:=S[CFX%$.EU:=^[UJ=g= acS[COX :IXf<>?QCb<1X g X <@?Q9 9EQg 8F?`KLSGkac?Aj<>S AR?QCbg X ?QG R: ac?o? 7?QC oU ?QCX S9;?oG>?WDJP: aQE[X.EHG@?E EH:PJ EH8J=?91 U ? D G>S[8 JP?Q9X :=CR<@?QCFX : KLgj:PC;9%S[8:=JP?uacS[9;D 6<>:=C^ 1TU?dDG@?X ?QCOac?dSHKT? EHC ?X>ac?WCR<acJ=:P?QCb<kX : acSCC?a <>?AjS[C?\9;S9;?QCb<>/AR:IX@acS[CC ?ac<>?qA <>U?\C?>3b<>/bacSCC?ac<@?A EH^7E:PCXfS[9;?W<>:P9%?JIE<>?QG DF?QG@UFEHDFX\EH< EjAR: ?QG@?QCb<JPSbaWEH<>:=S[C
` : 9E 77?qX:=<oAR: <a 6JP<.<>S Ea U :P? 7?uE U:P^U;JP? 7?QJFSHK?Q:=<>U?QG acS[COX :IXf<>?QCOacg E EH:=JIEH8 :PJP:=<fg9/[9 6Fa U JP?qX>X8FS[<@U21r.JP:P?WCR<j9;S8:PJ=:P<fg9/TacS[9 8:PC ?A o:P<@U<>U? JP: 77?WJP:PU S7SbA SK<>?W9;DFS[GkEG>gAb:IX>a S[CC?qac<>:=S[C2/X 6 ^[^[?qX <kXj<>UOEH<jEC6CR6OX 6FEJPJPg JPS7S X ?8:=CFAR:PC ^ 8F?Q< ?Q?WCacJP:=?QCb<kXEHCFAXf?QG 7?QGYXd:IX Ab?X :=GkEH8 JP?91yfAR?EJPJPg /?Q:P<@U?QGo<>U ?jacJ=:P?QCb<oS[Gd<@U?jXf?QG 7?WGdXfUS[6J Ah8F? EH8 JP? <@S;<>?WG>9;:=CFEH<@?d<>U? a JP:P?WCR<=/Xf?QG 7?QGG>?WJIEH<@:PSCFX U:=DL&('

*) o:=<>U :P9;D 6C:P<fg91 ZS]G>?Ea Uj<@U:IX ^[S EHJ@/RUS ? 7?QG>/ 1?o9l6OX < <YE 77?uEC? JPS7S 7]E<ZMFJ=?1X g X <>?W9zS[DF?QGYEH<>:=S[CFX/7EHCOA G>?4= <@U:PC 7u<>U?.<>GYE[AR:=<>:=S[CFEJ Eqg XmSHK :P9;DJ=?Q9;? CR<@:PC^<>U ?Q9 1 y C ac6G>G@?QCb<MOJP?uX g X <>?W9X6/ oG@:P<@?dS[DF?QGYEH<>:=S[CFXoEG>?d:=C:P<@:IE<>?A 8bgl<@U?uacJP:=?QCR<41 s`GYAR:PCOEHG>g:P9%DJP?Q9 ?QCb<kE<>: S[CFXFG>?V76:=G>?.acJ=:P?QCb<kXF<>S\8JPSba7AR6 G>:PC ^ oG>:P<@?X'8F?aQE6FX ?1<>U?.S[DF?QGYEH<@:PS[Cj9 6FXf<'8F?X gbCFakUG>SC:
`W?A o:=<>UjS[C ?oS[G.9;S[G@?1X ?QG 7?QGkX1 ?oDG>SD S X ?\:PCFXf<>?EAjE >J E
`QgdS[GX oG>:=<>?>=L8FE[a7X>akU?Q9%?d:PC oU: a U <>U? acJP:=?QCb<\X :P9%DJPg;J=?E 7?X6D AE<>?Xd:PC :P<YXdaQE[akU?91d57?WG 7?QGYX DF?QG@:PSbAR: aQEHJ=JPgD: a 7 6D<>U?qX ?6D AEH<@?XdECFA;DG>SDFEH^ EH<>?j<@U?Q9 <@Sj9l6 JP<>:=DJP?oG@?QDJ=:IaQE<>:PSCX :=<>?X1U? ?QJ=:P9;:=CFEH<@:PSC;SHK18J=Sba 7b:PC^ Ab6G>:=C^ oG>:=<>?XUOE[XdXf? 7?QGkEJ E[A ECR<YEH^[?qXuKLSG`9%S[8:=JP?
`
`
`

`
`PS[DF?QGYEH<@:PS[C 1 r.J=:P?QCb<;E6<>SCS[9 g:IXl:=CFacG@?E[Xf?A 5
`<>U?WG>?
`:IXjCSC?Q?qA<>S XfgRCFakUG@S[C:
`Q? oG@:P<>?S[DF?QGYEH<@:PS[COX o:P<@UzXf?QG 7?WGkX $S[6 G XfgXf<>?Q9 C ? 7?QG;8J=Sba 7 XAR6G@:PC^ oG>:=<>?X;6C JP?X@XhEacJ=:P?QCb< XaQEa U?o: XZKL6J=J 1 U :IX : XDOEHG><@:Iac6 JIEHG@JPgU?QJ=DRKL6JRKLSG.9;S[8:=JP?1acJ=:P?QCb<kX/ oUS]9EQg8 ?uAR: X <kECR< KLG>S[9<>U ?jX ?WG 7?QGYXUFEHCFAbJP:PC ^l<@U?Q:PG oG@:P<@? G@?V76?X <YX61(E6G@<>U?WG>9;SG>?9/ acGkEX U G@?acS 7?QG@gl: XoX :P9%DJP: MF?A8F?aQE6FX ?]acJ=:P?QCb<kX1EHG>?CS JPSC^[?WG\E[ac<@: 7?QJ=gl:=C 7SJ 7?Aj:PCDG@S[DFE^7EH<@:PC^%6D AEH<@?X61~ ?Ab6Fac:PC ^d<>U?\:PCb<>?WGkE[a <>:PSC 8F?Q< ?W?QC acJP:=?QCb<kX EHCFA X ?QG 7?QGkXTEHJIXfS:P9;DG@S 7?X>

': <>U? EH8:=JP:P<fg <>S%X 6D D SG><]EjJIEHG@^[?]CR69 8F?QGSK acJP:=?QCR<YX o:=<>US6<dXf:P^C:NM aWEHCb<`DF?QGfKLS[G>9 EHCFac?AR?Q^GkEAEH<@:PS[C 1U: X: X?XfD ?qac:IEJPJPg]:P9;DFSG><kECR< KLSG9;S8:PJ=?\acJP:=?QCR<YX 8 ?qaQEH6FXf?X ?WG 7?QG.JPS E[A o:=JPJ8F?acS9;?o9;S[G@?\AR: < ac6J=< <>S]DG>?qAR:Iac<41 ndX6FXf?QGkX 9;S 7? EHG>S6CFA /FE]X ?QG 7?QG 9EQg X 6FAAb?QCJPg MOCFA:P<YX ?QJ KoG@?X DFS[COX :P8 JP?lKLSG EhJIEG>^?hCb69 8F?QGdSHKacJ=:P?QCb<kX1

?;9 6FXf< 8F? EH8 JP?;<@S UFECFARJP?%<>U?Xf?<>GYEHCFXf:P<@S[G>gDF?QG@:PSbAXoSHKTU:P^U X ?QG 7?QGoJPS E[A;:PC Ej9;S[8:=JP?\?QC R:=G>S[C 9;?QCb<>1y C <>U ? 1S[GkXf<jaQEX ?9/mS6G J E
`Qg EDDG>S E[akU<>S6D AE<>?;D G>S[DOEH^7E<>:=S[C9E 77?qX`:P<d9%S[G>?AR: <ac6 JP< <@SpMOCFA oUFEH< :IX DG@S [E8JPg<@U?9;S7Xf< G>?qac?QCb< 7?QGYX :PSCSHK]EhMFJ=?91;E6G><@U?QG@9;S[G@?9/<>S%:PCFXf:IX <\S[C El6C :NKLS[G@9;JPg U:=^[U
`JP? 7?QJmSHK acSCFX : X <>?WCFacg S6JIA^[G>?qEH<>J=g G@?AR6Fac?]E EH:=JIEH8 :PJP:=<fg9/EHCOAl<>U: X.acS[C O:Iac<YX o:=<>U;S6G1AR?Xf:PG>?\<>S]DG>S b:IAR?\EU:P^UJPg = E E:PJIE8JP?MOJP?uX g X <>?W9 1 `S ? 7?QG4/ ?%URgbDFS[<>U ?X :
`Q?;<>UOEH<j9;S X < G@?E[A XjaQEHC8F?X>E<>: X MF?A8bg

G@?Q<>6 G>C:=C^ EHCbgE EH:=JIE8JP?a S[Dbg $EHJ=JPS o:PC ^<@U? 6FX ?QG <>S X ?W<><>J=?pKLSG<>U: XhJPS7S X ?QG acS[COX :IXf<>?QCOacg aQEC X 6 8FX <YEHCb<>:IEJPJ=g :P9;DG@S 7?DF?QG KLSG>9ECFac? EHCFA DG@S R: AR?jU:P^U E [E:PJ EH8:=JP:P<fg91\U?WG>?cKLSG>?9/ 1?jEG>^[6 ?l:=ChK E 7S[GdSK EhXf9EHJ=J9;SbAR: M aQE<>:PSC

<@S <@U?;:PCb<>?WG K E[a ? KLS[G G@?E[A S[DF?QGkE<>:=S[CFX <@UFEH< o:=JPJ.EJPJPS EJP?X@X X <@G>: ac<dKLS[G>9SHK G>?EAX61 U? <>GYE[AR:=<>:PSCFEHJuG>?EA3S[DF?QGkE<>:=S[C <>UFE<h: Xl^[6OEHGkECR<@?Q?A <>SG>?W<>6G@C <>U?
`9;S X <6D =L<>S =/A EH<>? 7?QGkXf:PSChSK1E MFJ=? o:=JPJ X <>:=JPJ 8 ?]Xf6DDFS[G@<>?A / E[X ?WJPJ 1n acJP:=?QCR<o6OX :PC ^E;D SG><YEH8J=? S[G7Xf<kE<>:PSC X US6JIA
`8F? EH8J=?j<>S;9%S 7?]EG>S[6 CFAhKLG>?Q?WJPg o:P<@US[6 <oUFE R:=C^j<>SjDG@S R: AR?dG>?qacS[CRMO^[6GYEH<>:=S[C:PCbKLS[G>9 EH<>:=S[C;<@Sj<>U?dMFJ=?X g X <@?Q9 /bEHCOA o:=<>U =S[6 < X 6 ?QG@:PC^ X ? 7?WG>? D ?WG KLS[G@9EHCOac?AR?Q^GkEAEH<@:PS[C 1 } 3b:IX <@:PC^ X g X <@?Q9Xh?W:P<>U ?QG DF?QGfKLS[G>9DFS7S[G@JPg:PC<>U ?X ?a :PGka 69X <YEHCFa ?X6/7S[GoG@?V76:PG@?d<>U?]acJ=:P?QCb<.<>SjDJ EQgEHC6CFAb6JPgEac<>: 7?dG>SJP?d:=CX 6 DDFS[G><@:PC^%9;S[8:=JP:=< g /HSG`8FS[<@U21

?]AR?X@acG>:=8F?d9;?Q<@USbAXKLSG\X 6D D SG><@:PC^ 9;S[8 :PJP?uacJ=:P?QCb<kX :PC E oEQg;<>UOEH<o:IX R:=G><@6FEHJ=JPg:PC b:IX :=8JP?]<>S<>U ?l6FXf?QG>/TEHCFA <>UFE< UOE[X E9;:PC :P9%EHJm:P9%DFE[ac<uS[C D ?WG KLS[G@9EHCOac?91 y/C

DFEG><@:Iac6 =JIEG>/ ?%AR?X@acG>:=8F?jUS <>S UFEHCOARJP? <>U? Ab: < ac6JP<aQE[Xf?lSK\acJ=:P?QCb<kX oU S EG>? <>?Q9%D SGkEG>:PJ=g SGDF?QG>9 EHC?QCb<>J=g 7?QG@gjAR: X <YEHCb<KLG>S9 <@U?">US9;?dXf:P<@? oU?WG>?\<>U?Q:=G MFJP?X1EHG@?dG>?QD JP:IaWEH<>?qA 1 U?X>akU?Q9%? 1? 6OX ?:IXoEjJPS^[:IaWEHJ'?43R<@?QCFX :=S[CSHK<>U?]EHD DG>S E[akU
`AR?X@acG>:=8F?A;EH8FS 7?91
`
`

`
`H ,! -!,

6 ,-EOSG`DF?QGfKLS[G@9EHCFa ?EHCFA+/ <@S;EjJP?X@X ?QGo?43R<@?QCR<4/E EH:=JIEH8 :PJP:=<fg9/7:P<o:IXoU:=^[UJ=gAR?Xf:PGkE8JP?<@SDG@?cKL?Q<kakU MOJP?X :=CR<@SdEacJ=:P?QCb< XmaQE[akU?o8F?cKLSG>?o<>U ?\acJP:=?QCR< Eac<>6OEHJPJ=gjEaQac?X@X ?X <@US7Xf?MFJP?qX615 :PCFac? ?o:=CR<@?QCFA<>S]X 6D D SG>< o:PG@?QJP?qX>XmD SG><YEH8:=JP:P<fg9/DG>?cKL?W<kakU:PC^\8F?acS9;?Xm? 7?QC 9%S[G>?.:=9;DFS[G><YEHCb<>1 :PG@?QJP?qX>XoJP:PC07X\EHG@?lG@?QJIE<>: 7?WJPg%X JPS /mXfS EhaWE[akU? <@UFEH<dUOE[Xd8F?Q?QC
`:PCb<>?WJPJP:=^[?QCb<>J=gBMOJPJP?qA o:P<@UDG@?cKL?Q<kakU?AjMFJP?X\X U S[6J Ah9EG877?ARJ=gj:P9;D G>S 7?`DF?QGfKLS[G@9EHCFa ? :=C <@U:IXoaQEX ?91 y C E[AAb:P<>:=S[C2/ 1?AR?Xf:PG@? E 9;?Q<>U SbA <@UFEH< o:PJ=Jm8F?jDFEHG@<>:Ia 6JIEG>JPg%? ?ac<>: 7?d:PC9ECFEH^:PC^ <>U ? G>?WJIEH<@: 7?QJ=g;Xf9EHJ=JaQEa U?uSHKE D SG><YEH8J=? 1S[G7Xf<kEH<@:PSC21 597b:PJ=JNKL6J aQEa U ?d9EHCOEH^[?W9;?QCb< :IXCS<\E[XoacG@:P<@:IaQEJ oU ?QCE aQE[akU?d: XJIEHG@^[??QCS6^[U <>S US[J A;9;S7Xf<oSHKT<>U?dMFJ=?X<>UFE<dE acJ=:P?QCb<.:IXoE[a <>: 7?WJPgj6FXf:PC^01
`

?uAR?X@acG>:=8 ? EHC :PCb<>?QJ=JP:=^[?QCb<mDG>? KL?Q<kakU:PC ^dEJP^[SG>:=<>U9 <@UFEH<1EHCOEHJPg
`Q?XmMFJP?\EaQac?X@X DFEH<=<>?WG>CFXo:PC EHC EH<@<>?Q9%D<o<>S;D G>?AR: ac< oU: a UMFJP?X\E acJP:=?QCR< o:=JPJmC?W?Ah:=C <>U ? C?EG KL6 <>6G@?91\n`JPJSHK1<@U? SG87 :=C AR?ac: AR:PC ^ oUFE<<>SDG>? KL?Q<kakU:IXdARSC? S[C
`<>U ? acJP:=?QCR<\Xf:IAR?$: D6<><@:PC^%<>U: X86GYAR?QC S[C%X ?QG 7?QGkX S[6 JIAjAR?a G>?EX ?uX>aQEJIEH8 :PJP:=<fg91mndX o:PJ=JR8F?uX US oC2/b8FS[<>U <>:=9;?oECFA X DFEac?G>?qV 6:=G>?Q9%?QCR<YXZKLS[G\<>U ? EJP^S[G>:=<>U9 EHG>?9;SbAb?X <41y Ab?EHJ=JPg9/mS[C ?;9;:P^UR< o:IX U <>S 8F?E8JP?%<>S D G>?cKL?Q<Ya U
`SCJPg DFS[G@<>:PSCFX SHKuE;MFJP? 1y <: X8F?Qg7S[COA <@U?jX@acS[DF?SHKS[6GuEHJ=^[S[G@:P<@U9 <>S UFECFARJP?<@U:IX\aQE[Xf?$US ? 7?QG>/7:P<o: XoEHC :PCb<>?QG@?X <@:PC^EHG@?E KLS[GKL6<@6G>?G>?qX ?EGkakU2/ o:=<>UDG>?WJP:P9%:PCFEG>g SG87EJPG@?E[ARg ARS[C?]8Rg S[G@C?QG C>H 1 "!
`*

'& +$& *(+(Q&q*

r.UFEHD<@?QGC AR?qX>acG@:P8F?X`DG@? b:PS[6OX`G>?Xf?EHGYa U
`:=CAb:IX <@G>:=86<>?qAhMFJP? XfgXf<>?Q9X/ D G>S R: AR:PC ^E
`8FE[a7R^G>S6CFA KLSGjS[6G S oC S[G7 1 r.UFED<>?QG AR?X@acG>:=8F?X <>U? EJP^[SG>:=<>U9X:PC 7S[J 7?Ap:=C?6< ac:P?WCR< EG>:IE8JP?4=/acSCFX : X <@?QCFacg G>?QD JP:IaWEH<>:=S[C2/ :PCFa JP6FAR:=C^?>3bD ?WG>:P9%?QCR<YEHJ.A EH<kE /a S[9;DFEG>: X S[C o:P<@U
`?>3b:IX <@:PC^%X g X <@?Q9X/FEHCFA
`AR?qX>acG@:PD<@:PS[C SHK ElDG@S[<@S[<fgRDF? :P9;D JP?Q9 ?cCb<kE<>:=S[C21oy/Cr.UFED<>?WGP /<>U?\EJP^[SG>:=<>U9X EHCOA :P9;DJ=?Q9 ?QCR<@E<>:PSCSHK :PCb<>?QJ=JP:=^[?QCb< MFJ=?DG@?cKL?Q<Ya U:=C^\EHG@?\AR:IX@ac6FX@X ?A]EHCFAEHCOEHJPg
`Q?A+1.U? S[G7;:IXoXf69;9EG>:
`Q?Aj:PC
`r.UFEHD <>?QG H 1
`
`

`
`N !

n <d<@U? U?EHG@<SHKo? 7?QG>gS[DF?QGYEH<@:PC^ X g X <>?W9 :IX`:=<kX`MFJP? XfgXf<>?Q9 5`<>U ?;XfSHKL< oEG>? <>UFE<EHJ=JPS \X 6FX ?WGkX <>S]X <@S[G@?dECFAlG>?W<>G>:=? 7?DF?QG@9EHC ?QCR<TAE<kE1.y/C%ac?QCb<>GYEHJP:
`Q?AS[DF?QGkE<>:=C^jXfgXf<>?Q9X/MFJ=?;XfgXf<>?Q9XEG>?;6FXf6FEHJ=JPg Xf<>GkE:P^UR<fKLS[G EHGYA <@S :=9;DJP?W9;?cCb<>1;s\C?Xf:P9;D JPg77?Q?QDFXd<@GkE[a7 SHK oU: a U AR:IX 7

8 JPSba7X]EHG>? KLG>?Q?9/ oU:IakU 8JPSba7X8F?QJPSC^
`<>S ?E[akU

MFJ=?9/ ECFA oUS
`9EQg
`EaQac?X@XE XfDF?ac:NMO?AhMFJP? 1 5 S[9;? XfS[G><]SHK AR:PG@?ac<>SG>g Xf<>G>6Oac<>6G@?j:IXd6FXf6FEHJ=JPg X 6 DDFS[G><@?AXfS <>UOEH<dMFJP?qX9EQg8F?lSG>^7EC:
`W?A U:P?WGkEHGYa U :IaQEJPJPg 1E :PJ=?jX g X <@?Q9Xo8FE[Xf?A

<@U:IXdEDDG@S7E[akU EHG>? 6FXf?Ap8bg? 7?QG@gR<@U:PC ^ KLG>S9 w

59= _ s5;<@S vd{dy o:P<@U6CFV76FEHJ=:NMF?A%X 6FaQa ?X>X1y C EAR: X <@G>:P8 6<>?AS[DF?QGYEH<>:=C^ X g X <@?Q9 /FUS ? 7?QG4/ <@U? AR?Xf:P^C EHCFA
`:P9;D JP?Q9 ?QCb<kEH<@:PSCSHKE ^[S7SbAhMOJP?XfgXf<>?Q9 EHG@? Xf:PC^6JIEG>J=g;AR: <a 6JP<1DG>S8JP?Q9 X61 } 7?QC%<>U?Ab?X>acG@:PD<@:PSC >^S7SbAi:IX CS[< 1?QJPJ =/Ab?cMFC?A+1zU?QG@? EHG@?
`CR69%?QG>S6FXB<@GkEAR?>=LS X;<>SacSCFX : AR?QG4/`ECFA DG>?Ab:Iac<YEH8J=g9/AR?Xf:P^C?QGkX UFE 7?\acS9;?6 D o:=<>U%ECb69 8F?QG SKmGYE[AR: aQEHJ=JPgjAb: ?QG>?WCR<TAR:IXf<>G@:P86<@?A MFJP?\XfgXf<>?Q9X1y C Ela ?QCR<@GkEJP:
`W?AB?WC b:PG@S[C9;?WCR<4/ <@U?9;SbAR?QJm: XoX :=9;DJP? 5 E X :PC ^[JP?]acS9;D6<@?QG o:=<>U ECb69l8F?QG SHK Xf<>S[GYEH^?AR? b:Iac?qX E<><kEa U ?A <>S:P<41 x6<E Ab:IX <@G>:=86<>?qAjX g X <>?W9 :PC 7S[J 7?X'9 6JP<@:PDJ=?9Ea U:=C?Xda S[9;9 6C: acE<>:PC ^ b:IE X S[9%?;XfS[G><]SHK\C?W< 1S[G7 / o:P<>U AR: X 7 ARG>: 7?XdacSCC?ac<@?A

<@SX S9;?dSGdEJPJmSHKT<>U ?X ?9Ea U:=C?X%$REjCb69l8F?QG.SK1X g X <@?Q9XXf6DDFS[G@<dAb:IX 7bJP?qX>X SG87 X <YEH<>:=S[CFX1y Ab?EHJ=JPg9/mE6FX ?WG XfUS[6 JIA

CS<C?Q?A
`<>S 7RCS oU?QG>?%EHCbg
`DFEG><>: ac6J EHGdMFJP?j: XX <>SG>?A+1U? MFJ=?
`XfgXf<>?Q9 X U S[6J A38 ? EH8J=?
`<>SJ=SbaQEH<@?
`E

^: 7?QCMFJP? EHCFA39 E 77?:P<%E [E:PJ EH8J=? <>S E6FXf?QG>1]U:IXoKL?EH<@6G>?9/v.U
` %i ' /F:IX`<@U?jDG>:=9EHG@gAR: '?WG>?QCFa ? 8F?Q< ?Q?WC >C ?Q< S[G7i%EHCFA
`
`

`
`OkAb:IX <@G>:=86<>?qAilMFJP? XfgXf<>?Q9X1 y C EC?Q< SG87 X g X <>?W9 /'<>U ?j6FX ?QG: X E EHG>? SHK <>U? 9 6JP<@:PDJ=?9Ea U:=C?X.:PC <@U?j?QC R:=G>SC9;?QCb<>/bEHCOA :IXoG>?XfD SCFX :=8JP?KLS[G.7bCS o:PC ^ oU:IakU;MFJP?qX`EG>? X <@S[G@?AS[C oU:IakU9E[akU:=C?X61.no<o8F?X <4/FX 68 <>G>?W?X SK MFJ=?XKLG>S9 S<>U?WG`9Ea U :PC?X1aQEHC 8F? 9%S[6Cb<>?AJPSbaWEHJPJ=g9/o86<;9 E[akU:PC?4= <@S =L9E[akU:PC ?;9;S 7?Q9 ?QC7<jSHKMFJ=?X o:PJ=JdXf<>:=JPJ\8 ? b:IXf:P8J=?91 w 6J=<>:PD JP?9Ea U:=C?XdEG>?E EH:=JIE8JP?lKLSG 6FXf?9/ oU :IakU9EQg 1?QJPJ.DG@S b:IAb?l9;SG>? DFS 1?QG>/ 8 6< 9 6FakU
`SHK<>U ?jG>?XfD SCFX :=8:PJ=:P<fg;KLS[G9ECFEH^:PC^;<@U:IX\D S 1?QG`K EHJ=JIX`SC

<@U?j6FXf?QG>1]n AR:IXf<>G@:P86<@?A XfgXf<>?Q9G>?WJP:P? 7?X <>U?6FXf?QGoSHK1E J EHG@^[? DOEHG><oSK.<>U :IX86GYAR?QC25 MOJP?]E[aQa ?X>X: X9E[akU:PC ?>= <@GkECFX DFEG>?QCb<>1s`C ?;CFEH<@6GkEJ<@?a U C:IV76? KLSG :=CFacG>?qE[X :=C^<>U?%E EH:PJ EH8:=JP:=< g SHKoMFJ=?XEHCFA :P9;DG@S R:=C^DF?QG KLSG>9ECFac?1:PC EAR:IXf<>G@:P86<@?AjX g X <@?Q9 : XG
`

P 5m9E:PCb<kEH:=C:PC ^dacSD:P?qX SHK ?E[akU MFJP?S[C EBCb69 8F?QGSK.9E[akU:=C?X61.y KTS[C?]DFEHG@<>: ac6JIEGo9E[akU:=C?d:IXoAbS oC /'E acS[Dbg;SK.<>U?MFJP?]aQEC6FXf6FEHJ=JPgj8F?`G@?Q<>G@:P? 7?qAKLG>S9 X S9;?oS[<@U?QG.9E[akU:=C?91mn`COAB? 7?WCj:NK EHJ=J G@?QDJ=:IaQEX EHG@?dE EH:=JIEH8 JP?9/DF?QG KLSG>9ECFac? aQEHC Xf<>:PJ=JR8F?o:=9;DG>S 7?A\8Rg 77?Q?QD :PC^\S[C?oSG 9;SG>?G@?QDJ=:IaQEXZ:=C acJPS X ?D G>S 3R:=

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.

Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

Up-to-date information for this case.
Email alerts whenever there is an update.
Full text search for other cases.
Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.

Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.

Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

Supplemental Search

Search for PTAB Motions

PTAB Analytics

TTAB Analytics

Basic Search

Filters

Party Search

Advanced

Selected Courts

Recently Selected Courts

Find PTAB Decisions

PTAB Analytics

Special PTAB Alerts

Orange Book

Directly Search Federal Courts

Search Trademark ...

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

Still Working On It

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

This document could not be displayed.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

One Moment Please

Your document is on its way!

Sealed Document

We are redirecting youto a mobile optimized page.

Document Unreadable or Corrupt

We are unable to display this document.

STEP 2 of 2

Choose your membership type

Flat-Fee

Pay-As-You-Go Monthly

Add your payment information

Login or Join

Enter your corporate Email

Thousands of your peers are saving time and gaining a competitive advantage with Docket Alarm.

Join Docket Alarm to perform smarter legal research.

Download this document and millions of others instantly with a Docket Alarm membership.

Join Docket Alarm and start performing smarter legal research.

Start tracking this docket instantly with a Docket Alarm membership.

Join thousands of your peers and start performing smarter legal research.

STEP 1 of 2

Millions of Documents | 15 Seconds to Signup

Hi !

Welcome to Docket Alarm

Welcome to Docket Alarm!

Explore Litigation Insights andManage Your Cases

Reset Password

What is PACER?

Why do I need it?

What will I be charged?

Do other courts have fees?

Basic Free Access

Welcome

Thank you

Check Firm Account

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.

Explore Litigation Insights and
Manage Your Cases