throbber
(.?‘H‘ClllEl"y shown 11’! Flt}. 6 is Very stable 0
`temperature range of -40” C. to 105” C. The
`output of the touch switch circuitry drops at a
`rate of appiroxiinately 40 inV/“C when
`temperature fails heiew 0° C.
`if application
`requires eperatioh at law temperatures (-4-€'_‘:°' C.)
`the foliowing three niethocis they be used to
`increase the output of the switehiincrease the
`oscillators regulateci supply Vnita increase. the
`resistance of resistor 436, and use a 40 higher
`gain il‘fit1S,iSi'0f(' 410, Ail at‘ these methods would
`increase sensitivity at high terhperaturesf’ Colt
`l6:33-4}.
`
`_»’&__Y_3E3i_£1‘_~’»_‘:£_f_J‘_1E_i_!f_Qil '*i:_n§;ii1g.tite
`eriodie out ut sivnai from the oscillator.
`the iriie.t‘0t:t'inti'oller selectivelv rovidin;
`
`See Figures 4, l i; and Ciairnxs
`
`7.29 ,6? 27.
`
`The “ i 83 Patent discioses “The touch £i€t€Ci:iOil
`
`5}.satst}.__9_2itn.1it_fresh:net_e_s__t9__a_gl_t2§e}x
`spaced array of input touch terminals of a
`.li_t"2)i12‘_%t§__~._El‘!5:.3BEE1_£Q£%§h__§§§£{!itt§3_§
`coin risino first and second in ut touch
`
`circuit of the present invention i"eatui'es operation
`at frequencies at er above 5f0kHz and preferably
`at or above 800 i<:l—iz to minimize the effetzts of
`siirfaee eohtaniination for materials such a skiii
`
`terniiiiais;
`
`it also Offers improvements in
`oils and. water.
`detection sensitivity that allow close control of
`the degree of proximity {ideally very ciese
`proximity) that
`required for acttiation ant} to
`enable empioyrneiit of a multiplicity of smali
`size tench terminals in a physiczal close array
`such as a i~:eyho-mil.” Coi. 5:4_‘}~57.
`
`The ‘ E83 Patent discloses “hi 2: first preferred
`ernhedirnent the circuit offers»: enhanced
`
`detection sensitivity to allow reliable operation
`with small (finger size) touch pacts." Coi. 6:l~3.
`
`The ‘ 183 Patent discloses “Although the
`preferrecl frequency is at or {1i‘It‘iV‘t3 K30 kc}-iz, and
`more preferably at or above 800 kHz, it is
`conceivable that frequencies
`low as 50 lqliz
`could he used provided the frequency creates a
`ciitterence in the impedance paths of adjacent
`pads that is .~;ui"l"icient enough to accurately
`distinguish between an intended touch and the
`touch of an adj acent pad. Us of freque1i»:ies as
`tow
`50 kt-la mar aiso he nssihle de ‘iendin
`
`N./»\R—5796l 83RX
`
`Page
`
`*7,
`of 5,
`
`Page 501 of 1714
`
`

`
`upon the type ot gin ' or COV(’.1'¥t"t.~ or the
`thickness thereof used for the tcsueh pad.” C01.
`i 1:19-27.
`
`The ‘ 183 Patent discioses “Upon being powered
`by Voitage regulator ‘:00, osciiiatnr 20%
`genei‘ates a square wave with a frequency of 50
`t~:H;:, and preferably greater than 800 kHz. and
`having .3111 anipiitude of ;;6 V peak. The square
`wave geiiemted by esciiliator 209 is sunpiied. Via
`line 201 to a tinating curnriinn generator 300, 21
`touch pad shield plate 460. a touch circuit. 4%.,
`and aniici“0c<3nti“o1iei'500. Oscillator 200 is
`described below with rei’ei'en<:e tu FIG. ti.
`
`Floating common generatoi‘ 300 receives the 26
`V peak square wave froth osciiiator 200 and
`eutputs Z5, regulated floating eoinihon that is 5
`Veits heiew the Square wave output frnni
`oseiiiator 290 and has the same phase and
`frequency as the received square wttve. This
`floating common output is suppiiieci to touch
`csiteuit 43-00 and miei‘eeontruiiei“ 500 via hue 30E
`
`such that the output square wave from nsciiiiatm
`200 and floating common i'5tEfpt,EE "from floating
`eoninien generator 308 provitzie power to touch
`ci1'cuit4DO and 1T1iC1‘OCO11t1‘0ii(‘;t” 500. Detaiis of
`
`floating cotrunen generator 300 ate diticussed
`heiow with reference to FIG. 7. Touch circuit
`
`400 senses capacitance ttoin a ttmch pad 450 Via
`line 4-5! and outputs a si gn :11 to mierecentreiier
`500 Via line 401upon detecting a capacitance to
`ground at touch pat} 450 that exceeds 3. threshoid
`Value. The details of touch circuit 400 are
`tieserib-ed below with reference to FIG. 8.
`
`Upon i’eeeivnig an iiidiea.tien ftum tench circuit
`400 that a sufficient capacitance to ground
`(typicniiy at Eeast 20 pi?) is present at touch pad
`450, niiere<:oritroTiei' 5630 outputs 21 signal to a
`toad--controiiing ihicrocontroiier 600 Via iine
`50.1, which is pi‘et'ei‘ahiy 3 two way optical
`coupling “nus.” C01, i2:6-33.
`
`The ‘ T33 Patent diseioszes “As will be apparent
`to those skiiied in the :;ut, the V§;tiU(')S of the
`
`N./»\R—5796t 83RX
`
`Page 502 of 1714
`
`

`
`resistors and capacitors with ,(i in osttiiiatot
`may be varied from those disciosed above to
`provide for different oseii.iatoi' output
`frequencies.” Col” i4:22i~25.
`
`The ‘ 133 Patent discloses “A multiple touch pad
`circuit constiucted in accordance with the second
`embodiment is shown in HS. 11.
`in the seeonsfi
`
`enihodimeiit of FIG. ii, components similar to
`those in the first embodiment in FIG. 4 are
`
`tiesighateo} with the same retetehces t_uniiera.is
`and will not be discussed in detail. The rnuitipie
`touch pad circuit is a variation of the ‘first
`embodiment in that it includes an array of touch
`circuits designated as 9001 through 'E3£30inh,
`which, as shown, ineiude both the touch circuit
`
`400 shown in FIGS. 4 and S and the input touch
`terminai pad 451 (FIG. 4). Mieroconttoiier 500
`selects each row of the touch circuits 9991
`
`through 90011111 by providing the signal from
`oseiiiatoi‘ 200 to selected rows of touch circuits.
`
`in this iiiaiiiiei’, nii<:1‘-octet;troiier 500 can
`
`sequentially activate the touch circuit rows and
`associate the received inputs front the columns
`of the array with the activated touch eireuittjs).
`To keep the path length 45E between the touch
`pad 4-5!) and the base to the detection tramsistot
`410 to :1 mininiuni, the detection circuits 903 are
`
`physicaiiy ioeatetl directiy beneath the touch
`pads. To Si,1’1’)piifj assembly, a tiexibie circuit
`board such as V’t311Cit3Ci by Sheiciahii inc. Oi‘Cii’C1.Eii
`Etching 'i"eehhics;, hie. can be med for this
`purpose.
`ideally, the printed circuit will he fixed
`tiirectiy against the surface (typically glass)
`i>e:»3.i'ing the conductive touch pads to eliminate
`an gaps and the need for conductive foam pads
`and spring eontucts which were used to fiii air
`gaps,” Cot, i8:3r-L59.
`
`the first and . eond, touch
`
`See Claim 27.
`
`terininais defining, areas for an operator to
`proviide an input by proximity and touch:
`and
`
`N./»\R—5796i 83RX
`
`Page 503 of 1714
`
`

`
`:1 (ietector circuit coupieti to said
`oscillator for receiving said periodic
`output Sigtlai from said oscillator. and
`coupled to said first anci second touch
`terrninais, said detector circuit being
`responsive to signals from said osciiiator
`Via said niicrocontroiier and [the] gt
`
`presence of an operator's “body capacitance
`to grourid coupled to said first and second
`touch tertninats when proximal or touched
`by {an} f_ti_e_ operator to provi-dc a control
`output signal for actuation of the
`controiied device, said detector s:ircuit
`
`being eon {figured to generate said controi
`output signai when {an} 3; operator is
`proxirnai or touches said second touch
`terminal after the operator is proximal or
`touches said first touch ternrinai.
`
`See Figures 4-,
`
`i
`
`E and Liaitns 8,
`
`:
`
`The " i 83 Patent discloses “Upon heing powered
`by voitage regulator £00, osciiiator 290
`generates a square wave with E1 frequency of 50
`kHz, and pr'eferahiy greater than 800 i<H;:, and
`havin an amplitude of 26 V peak. The square
`wave generated by osciiiator 200 is supplied via
`tine 201 to a floating connnon generator 300, a
`touch pad. shieid piate 4&1), at touch circuit 400,
`and a mieroeontrxflier 509.
`t'}sciiiator 200 is
`tiescribed below with reference to FIG» 6,
`
`Fioatiiig common generator 300 receives the 26
`V peak square wave from oscillator 200 and
`outputs a regulated floating common that is 5
`Volts heiow the square wave output from
`oscillator 200 and has the same phase and
`frequency as the received. square wave. This
`tioating eornrnon output is supplied to touch
`circuit 400 and 1’1’1iC1‘e'_K.?Q11t1‘(Jii=;”;1' 500 via line 30i
`
`such that the output square wave from osciiiator
`200 and tioating eoninion output troifo floating
`common generator 300 provide power to touch
`circuit 400 and niicrocontroiier 50(). Detaiis of
`
`floating contrnon generator 300 are discttssed
`beiow with reference to FIG. '7 . Touch circuit
`
`400 senses capacitance front a touch pad 450 via
`line 45 i and outputs a signal to H1it£?i“0,(_‘.01‘tE1“0iif)1‘
`500 via Eine 40i'upon detecting 2. capacitance to
`ground at touch pad 450 that exceeds £1 thresh oid
`Value. The detaiis of touch circuit 400 are
`described heiow with reference to Fifi. 8.
`
`Upon receiving an indication from touch circuit
`400 that a sufficient capacitance to ground
`(typicaiiy at least 20 pi?) is present at touch pad
`450, inicrocontrolier 500 outputs a signal to a
`lOmii—CGt’1it‘Oiiittg rnicr'ocontroiler ('i(}(} via iine
`501, which is meferahiy a two way opticai
`coupiing bus.” Col. 12:63-33.
`
`The “ 183 Patent discloses “A multiple touch pad
`circuit constructed in accordance with the second
`ernbodirnent is shown in FIG. i i.
`in the second
`
`einboditnent of FIG. ti, components sirniiar to
`
`N./»\R—5796i 83RX
`
`Page 504 of 1714
`
`

`
`the.
`
`in the tirst embodiment in Fifi 4 tire
`
`designated with the sanie references numerals
`and will not be discussed in detail. The multiple
`touch pad circuit is a Variation of the first
`enibodinient in that it includes an array of touch
`circuits designated as 900i through 9GOnrn,
`which,
`shown, include both the touch circuit
`
`and the input touch
`400 shown in l?7l{3S. 4 and
`l‘vllCl‘OCOl'iil'Oilt.’.1‘ 500
`terniiiial pad L‘!-Sl (HO, 4).
`selects each row of the touch circuits 9001
`
`tlimugli 900nm by pmviciing the signals from
`oscillator 200 to selected IOWS of touch circuits»
`
`in this manner, n1ici'oconti'ollcr 500 can
`
`scquciitially acti»'ate the touch circuit rows and
`associate the received inputs from the colunins
`of the array with the activatea;l touch cii‘cuit(_s).
`To keep the path iengtli L‘l5l between the touch
`pad 450 and the base to the detection tiaiisistor
`4-10 to a minitniim, the detection Cll”Cll‘ii'S 90% are
`
`physically located directly beneath the toricli
`pads. To siinplify assernbly, a flexible circuit
`laoard sncli
`venclcd by Si')€i£.l.§ii’ll,,
`lnc. Ol‘ Ciiciiit
`Etching Technicsl inc. can be used for this
`piirpose.
`ldeally, Elle printed circuit will be iixedi
`directly against the surface (typically glass)
`bearing the conductive touch pads to eliminate
`air gaps and the need for coiiductive loain pads
`and spring contacts wliicli were used to fill air
`gaps.” Col. l8:34~59.
`
`J. New Ciaini 38
`
`icsponsivc elect: oma.
`switching circuit as defined in claim 37,
`wherein feedback to the operator is
`provided by an indicator activated by the
`fl’lli3l’€fi;C)Ill;l'Oillt3F alter the operator touches
`the second tnucli terminal,
`
`Ci ms 4,.-,.
`
`_;.
`
`The ‘ l83 Patent discloses “The microprocessor
`also allows the use of Visual indicators such as
`l_,El)s or annunsziators such as :2; bell oi‘ tons’:
`
`generator to confirm the actuation of a given
`touch switch or switches. This is particularly
`useful in cases whcic a scquciice of actuatioiis is
`
`N./»\R—5796l 83RX
`
`Page 505 of 1714
`
`

`
`to the operator pro,v1de,d by 3 Vistlzfi or audio
`indicator activated by the microprocessor in
`response to intermediate touches in :1 required
`sequence can minimize time lost and/'0r
`h'ustr;1‘Lion on the part of the operzator due to
`faiied aetuations from partizfl touches or wrong
`actuations from touching the wrong pad. in a
`given requirefi sequence or combination of
`touches.” C01. 6:31-42.
`
`The ‘ 133 Patent discIo9.e:2. “A furthet‘ option is to
`provide one or more LEDS 2205 or audible
`annumciators for visual or audible feedhaols; to
`
`the opera.to1'. Specifically, in HG. 19 the LED
`2205 will come on when button 220} has been
`
`suocessfuiiy activated to we the operator that it
`is time to move to button 2202.
`‘vVhere required
`a second. LED with 21 different color than the first
`
`(yellow for the first LEE) and red for the second)
`can he provided to provide Visual confirnmtion
`that the second button 2202 has heen activated or
`
`that the Jfequhed combination of the two buttons
`has been activated. Two d.ift"erem: audibie tone
`
`or sound {generators could ztiso he used in lieu of
`the LEDS to provide feedback to the operator,”
`C01. 23:1--12.
`
`The ‘ E83 Patent disclosea “A red LED 2395 on
`
`top of the device shows the completion of the
`two Step tum—on and activation of output relay
`Z310.” Co1.23:2S--30.
`
`R. New Ciaim 39
`
`39. The capaci ve r ‘pensive eiectroniec
`;~;wite:hing circuit
`defined in claim 37.
`
`Claim
`
`wherein sziiti detector circuit
`
`conapares 3 sensed body capaeitamze
`chzmge caused by
`body capacitance
`
`See Figure 3 1; and Claims E, 32”, E6, E87 27, 28.
`
`The " E 83 Patent diescioses “Another method for
`
`N./»\R—5796i 83RX
`
`Page 506 of 1714
`
`

`
`tieci‘eus~;ing a. second touch terminal signal
`on the detector to giouiici when proximate
`to the second touch termiitai to :1 threshold
`
`level to gent:.ra,te the control output signal,
`and
`
`impiememiug capacitive touch .‘~%Vv’lTIChf)H relies: on
`the change in capacitive coupling between a
`touch terminal and ground. Systetris utilizing
`such 21 method we described in US. Pat. No.
`
`4,758,735 and US. Pat. No. :'Z,€}87,825. With
`
`this metliodology the detection circuit consists of
`an oscillator (or AC line Voltage a:ieriVa.tive)
`providing 21 signal to a touch terminal whose
`voitagts is tlleu l’I10l1il.0£'f_’.£i by at (,i§."iC£TtOl‘. The
`touch terminal is clriven in electrical series with
`
`it
`other cotnponeiats thztt function in part
`charge pump, The touch of an opei‘ator then
`provides :2. capa.<:itive short to ground
`the
`operalofia own body capucittahce that lowers the
`amplitude of oscillator Voltage seen at the touch
`te1‘mii1ai.” Col. 15:44-56.
`
`Tile ‘ i83 Patent discloses “The touch tietectioh
`
`circuit of the present invention features operation
`at frequencies at or above 5Gl:Hz and piefmubly
`at or above 800 icliz to miitiinize the effects of
`sm‘t‘a.oe C0lliTEif,Tl'iF1€ti.',iOil for tiuaterials such :1 skin
`
`it also o1°fei's improvements in
`oils 1‘-.hd.Water.
`tietection sensitivity that allow close control of
`the degree of proximity {ideally very close
`proximity) that
`required for actuation and to
`enable erhployrneitl of a multiplicity of small
`size touch torhilnsils in 21 physical close array
`such as a i~:eybo-Md.” Col. 5:4-_‘3~57.
`
`The ‘ 183 Patent discloses “Although the
`pi'e'i’en“e(l tlequeilcy is at or 3.‘-‘Jove M30 kl-lz, and
`inore preferably at or above 800 kHz, it is
`conceivable that frequencies
`low as 50 kHz
`could he used garovitied the litequeilcy creates at
`diffeteiice in the impedance paths of adjacent
`pads that is scufficiem etiough to accurately
`distinguish ‘oetweeti an intended touch and the
`touch of an adj aceitt pad. Us of frequencies as
`Eow as 50 kl-lz may aiso be possible depending
`upon the type of glass or covering or the
`thickness thereof used for the touch pad.” Col.
`11:39-27.
`
`N./»\R—5796l 83RX
`
`Page 507 of 1714
`
`

`
`The ‘ E 83' Patent tiiaeloites Touch eiretiit 400
`
`senses capacitance from a touch pad 456' Via line
`r-1-Sal and outputs a signal to nii.er0c0ntreiler
`0
`via line élillupon tletectiiig 21 capacitance to
`ground at toueli pad 450 that exceeds 3. thre:’~:h0ld
`value. The details of touch circuit 4-00 are
`£i€’.SC1’il‘IF;‘.d below with reference to FIG. 8.” Col.
`12:24-28.
`
`The ‘ 183 Patent cliselcrses “AS will be appareiit
`to those skilled in the art, the Values et’ the
`
`resistors and capacitors utilized in oscillator 2.00
`may be varied train these disclosed aheve to
`pres/ide for different ese,il.latei' output
`frequencies?’ Col. l4:22.-25.
`
`See Claims 27, 32.
`
`The ‘ l83 Patent cliseloses “'l‘lie microprocessor
`also allows the use cf visual intliszators melt as
`LEDS Oi‘ anituntqiategs such as a hell or time
`
`genei'ate1"tcs eenfirin the actuation of at given
`much switch or S‘NilCi’1f5S, This is particularly
`useful in eases where
`St3q1.1t311CC of aettiations is
`required hv:-:i"'01‘e an action oeews. The feedback
`to the operatoi‘ provided by a Visual or audio
`ilidlcfitm‘ activatetl hy the microprocessor in
`respense to intermediate touches in a .i‘equii'ed
`sequence can ininirnize time lost and/'er
`fi'ust1‘ation on the part of the operator due to
`failed aetuatiems from partial tou<:he:~: or wrong
`aetuations from touching the wrong pad in a
`given required sequence or combination of
`touches.” Col. 6:314-2.
`
`The ‘ l83 Patent zliseloses “A furthei' option is to
`provide one or more LED5 2205 or audible
`annuiieiators for Visual or 2-.ud.ihle feeclbaeli to
`
`the epera.t0i'. Specifically, in E316. l9 the LED
`"V3.05 will come on when huttoh C_’t'.7.’.t“)l has heen
`
`successfully activated to we the 0pei'at:3r that it
`is time to move to button 2202. Whei'e required
`:1 second. LED with a cliffeteiit color than the first
`
`( ellow for the lirst LED and red for the second)
`
`wherein feedback to the opetatoi‘ is
`provitied by an indicator activated hy the
`niicrocontroliei‘ after the operator touclies
`the second touch terminal.
`
`N./»\R—5796l 83RX
`
`Page 508 of 1714
`
`

`
`can be provided to provide vima} c¢_mfi1'ma.ti0n
`that the second lmtton 2202 has been activated or
`
`that the raqtiired c<>rr;.bina1'_ion of the two buttons
`has hem activated Two different audible tone:
`
`or sound generators could aiso be used in lieu of
`Ehéf LEDS to provide feedback to the operator.”
`C01. 23:1--E2.
`
`The " 183 Patent disckyses “A red LED 2305 on
`
`top 01” the device shows the C-:=mpieti0:ra of the
`two step tum—0n and a.<:ti,vati0n of Qutput rc‘.lay
`2310.” C01. 23:28-30.
`
`N./»\R—5796i 83RX
`
`Page 509 of 1714
`
`

`
`V. Corwiusizsn
`
`In View of {ha :a.b0v:3., Fatclat Owner submits that the claims
`
`in condition for
`
`afimvance. No new mamer has been addad by this submission. If Examiner should have any
`
`questions, plsase Contact Patent ()wner’s Atiomey, Brian A. Carlson, at 9‘72—732—‘i (301. The
`
`Comniissiozaer is ‘hereby zmthorized to charge any fees due in connsction with this fiiing, or
`
`credit any'cVe1fpay1ne11t, to Deposit Account No. 50-1065.
`
`Respectfufiy submitted,
`
`,"Bri.3m A. Carlson!’
`Brian A. Caflsron
`
`Atbmfrley for Pat'ctm Owner
`N0. _ 7,793
`
`November 19. 2012
`Date
`
`SLA'I‘iEiR MATSEL, L.L.P.
`17950 Pmston Rd. Suite: 3000
`
`Dallas, 'I‘exas 75252
`T61.: 972»-732»1€)O]T
`Fax: 972-7329218
`
`N./»\R—5796i 83RX
`
`Page 510 of 1714
`
`

`
`E iJNF:‘F.}‘> STA"'“"9 KP/—\"F}71N’E‘ AND ’E‘‘;«;.»\.D‘=’—trvIAR‘r< 0§‘«'{—‘-'m’~:
`
`-';'
`
`UNITFI) ETATFSI DFT‘ART,V‘EEj\'T OF CUMIVIERCE
`.
`‘ mt nd Track-Inark Office
`J‘-3. FOR P.
`NT-S
`
`131357
`
`9:‘./oi 2,439
`
`(‘:8/‘: 7'./20’: 2
`
`25962
`
`7590
`
`04/1:)/:2-:33
`
`SLA'1‘ER & MATSIL, L.L.P.
`E7950 PR , TON RD, SUITE 1C:a'J{)
`DALLAS, '1'}; '75252—5'793
`
`Piease fiznzd beiow am‘:/‘Gr aiimtiyed an ()§°fi3ce «:43-mmunicaiiun ssuncerning this appiicaiian (pr prgcaeeiing.
`
`The. time period1“orrs3piy. if any, is 56'. in ‘thf: attached communication.
`
`MAIL DATE
`04/10/201 3
`
`>
`
`DI1I,J‘v’ERY1“\/{ODE}
`P!—‘..PE}'{
`
`PTOL—90A (Rev. 01/07)
`
`Page 511 of 1714
`
`

`
`. Contmi No.
`
`Patent Under E‘-ieexaminetion
`
`Netiee of intent tie Issue
`EX Pa:/te Reexamination Certifieate
`
`90/0i2i439
`iexaminer
`
`5795’i33
`
`. L.iNi-i Ex/i. i\iGLiYEi\i
`
`-~ The MMLING HA TE of this communication appears an the cm/er sheet with the correspandence address v~
`
`i. E] Prosecution on the merits is (or rernaihs) cieseci in this ex pane i'ee..<arninatieri gsmcee-;iing. This proceeding is
`subject to reopening at the initiative of the Office or upon petition.
`(Sf. 37’ CPR t.313(.-3). A Certificate wiii be issued
`in view of
`
`‘
`
`Patent i3wner‘s ci3i'nmtihicatien(s) flied:
`E] Patent i3wner’s faiiure to fiie an appropriate timeiy response to the Office action matted:
`E] Patent i:iwner’s faiiure to timeiy fiie an Appeai Brief (3? CFR 4‘i.3‘i).
`{:1 The decision on eppeai by the {:5 Beard at Patent Appeais an-Ci interferences {:2 C-C‘L.ii'T. dated
`{:1 Other:
`
`" i. Fteexaminetion Certificate wit: indicate the feiiewing:
`Change in the Specificatien: E] Yes E No
`Ghaitge in the Drawihgis):
`E] Yes
`No
`Status of the Ciai:”Yi(S)i
`.
`eriiirrned.
`(1) Patent ciaim(s)
`(2) Patent Ciaint(s) amended (ineiLdis'ig depeitderit er‘: arnemied Ciaim(s)): i8 2.7.28 and 32
`(\) Patent ciairnis) caitceieri:
`.
`(4) Newiy presented oiaimis) eaientabie: 33-39.
`(5) Newly preseitted c;—ti‘ieeied Ciaims:
`.
`(a) Patent ciairitifs)
`previousiy [Ti currently diseiaimed:
`(7') Patent ciaim(s) notsubect tb i'eexamihation: M?’ 19-26 and 29-81.
`
`4 Note the attached statement of reasons fer patentabiiity aha‘/or cem‘irmatien. Any comments eorisidered necessary
`by rsatent owner regarding reasens for petentabiiity and/or iwniirmatioh must be stihinitted premptiy to avoid
`processing deiays. Such sui3missi0n(s) shotiid be iabeied: “Comments On Statement of Reasons for Patentabiiity
`enr.i/er Corii‘irmatieii.”
`
`Note atteetted i\iOTiC-E OF REFERENCES CETED (PTO—8Q2i
`
`Note attache-Li LIST OF REFERENCES CiTED (PTO./SB/'08 or PTO/'88./"O8 substitute).
`
`_ The -cirawihg correction request tiied on
`
`is: E] approved
`
`[:3 disap-pi'oved.
`
`§ 119(a)—(d) or (f).
`Acitriewiedgrnent is made of i‘ e priority ciaim under 35
`a)[] Ali bjfi Sorne*
`e)[:} None
`of the izertiiied castes have
`E] been received.
`E] not been received.
`.
`E] been tiied in Application No.
`[3 been tiie-Ci in i'ee><einihation (_‘.ontroi Ne.
`[:3 been received by the Entei'natienal Sweat: in
`
`.‘\ ru-
`-ii“ Applicatien Ne.
`
`* Certified cepies not received:
`
`8. E] Note atiaished Exaihiner's Anieitdnteitt.
`
`E] Nate a tached Interview Summary (PTO-474).
`
`to. [:3 Other:
`
`.
`
`Aii eerrespendenee relating; to: this i'eeXai'fiiflaTiOfl preceee'irig shouid be directed to the Certtret Reexeminatien Unit at
`the ntaii, FAX. or hahd—carry ettdresses given at the end of this Office actiori.
`
`cc: Requester (iE"'{i3i1‘-151:7-£il‘ty requester‘)
`U3. Patertt and Trademark Qffice
`PTOL-469 (Rev. 67-16)
`Ncstice cat intent ‘Be issue E3: Perte Reexaminetien Certificate
`
`Part at Paper ixie 2t‘.-‘E30327
`
`Page 512 of 1714
`
`

`
`AppLi<:a.t_im1/Con U701 Number: 90/0 .1 2,='-139
`Art Unit: 3992
`
`Naiice fif fimeni $0 issauee: Reexaminatims {femifissaie
`
`This is 3. reexan1i11a,ti0n uf United 813.333 Patent Number §,,'}’9=i3,183 (“the 183’ patc311t”).
`
`in
`
`the }‘€3t§XE1.fIli1'1£i‘ti()I) request fiictd O8,/E ‘.7/203 2 (“Requé:s£”), by Patant Owner, 2: s‘.u‘r3st:mtia1 new
`
`question {SNQ) of patentabiiiiy was raised as ‘to Claims 18 and 27. These claims are thus
`
`reexamined herein. Rcaexaminatioil was met reqixested of claims 1--17, 192.6 and 28-32.
`
`Th:-:1*c3f01‘e‘, c;:iaims. L17, i9~26, and 27531 W111 110: be, 1‘CCXi:‘:11‘1il1€d.
`
`MPEP 224-3. Howcveic,
`
`claims 28 and 32 wiii ba I“€€5X'<‘11’ilif1€d,
`
`as fu1'Eher expiairaed below.
`
`A Pateifit Owner Statement was filed 11/1.9/2012, in which ciaims E8 and 2? were
`
`amended,
`
`weli as c1a'm1s 28 and 32 due to their deapendenciess from Ciairn 27. Furfl1e1'mo1*e,
`
`new clainis 333:9 were added.
`
`Vv"1"€'1ira
`
`the e><a?n'1im3r‘s ciisctmtiun, the néswiy acidfid c}a.in1s 33-39 and the, nonxaquested
`
`amendad claims 28 and 32 are new subject 10 reex zxmination.
`
`References
`
`Boie st 211., US. Pate11tN0. 5,463,388, filed on .Ea11ua1‘y 29, 1993 and issued on October
`
`L (“Boie ‘388"Ta.
`
`Page 513 of 1714
`
`

`
`App1i<:a.t_imt/ConU701 Number: 90/0 .1 2,='-139
`Art Unit: 3992
`
`Staafenw;m' i?fR‘E‘£$S(§FlS fier ,§"::ttent:.z!)iIit_v and/or E'.7n:zj}7rnza£'i0n
`
`tliaims E8, 27, an'1e:'1ded not1—:'equeste.d C1£ii1’1’}':%. 28, 32 and newly added eiaims 33-39 are
`
`patentabie.
`
`The exa1ni11e1*has no opinion as to the cslaims that were next reexa1nined. The following is
`
`an exatn'1fmer’s statement efieasona ‘tint patetttabiiity of the claints found patentable in this
`
`reemmination proceetiingi
`
`There is not taught or disclosed in the print art (.2 c'apa(:iiive ?”:?§p(.I2‘I.§'.5t7€‘ electrorut
`
`SWl'i(3}'ii7'£g 4'f.'!'!"(f'!/ti! havmg a rrzicr0t:(mtraiier ztsirzg the pe:"i0z,ii<: ()lr£fj}i/ifSigllra11[fi”()IG"! the 0.::cii!(zt(2/';
`
`rite rrzi(.’r0c0ztzt.t:'r)Zler .seiec*tit>eZ)> ,g‘)E":’.?“v‘I‘,t2]Z‘,.i”£g’ signal! ompztzfi*eqz,te22<?ie5‘ to L1" ,m'zt:"aIizj; of weal! sized
`
`input muciz rerrm'naZs of {I keypaci, as called for in independent claim 18; 11:3: 5: capctcirive
`
`re5,*:rmm'iws electrnnic ,swit(rlzintg circuit havirig a n’zim*<.>c>m:trailer .=tsin;,> the ;;=e‘ri0tiic ompmi s.r7;,>nai
`
`from the osciilatm", alts: rr:zt'r0(i(2mr()!ler .<;eZet,>tz't.=eE_v ‘z7i'(>via:i.i:«zg ,S‘igilt1I,r (.PZ47£pl:7£f?"€q££8ilt3i€.§
`
`to a
`
`Clmely sgmxced o:r'ra)»' rrfinépztr mum’: tesvmimzls ofa iceypari, the inpztz tnmfh terminals‘ rforngprising
`
`firsif and secoztzcf input mam’: ternziztzaix, as called for in inde,pemie11t claims: 27 anti 37. The
`
`examiner agtee:«: with the discussion articulated by Patent Owner in the S‘.TE3.{§3!'I},€:I11 that Sofie does
`
`not teach or suggest these ciaiin eiements. Rather, Bole discloses that “RF oscillator 408
`
`pmvides an RF signaL for exampie, 100 kiiohertz, to circuits 401, synchronous deteetcsr and fiiter
`
`404 via inverter 410, and guard plane 41
`
`Boie, en}. 3:67—eni. 4:2‘ Beie further discloses that
`
`“[t}he effetzts tn“ electrode—t0—e1e<:tr0de capa.cita.nees, wining :;:»3.p;1<:it:mees anti other extraneous
`
`Page 514 of 1714
`
`

`
`Applicatimt/ConU701 Number: 90i()_12,='-139
`Art Unit: 3992
`
`Page 4
`
`capacitatlccs am: Inillillliltifl by driving ail eiectmrdcs and guard pialle 411 in unison with the
`
`same RF signai from RF os<:i11at0r408." Id. at (301. 4:58-60 {emphasis added); see id. at Fig. 4.
`
`Thus Bake. ciis.<:i08¢s drivirxg the eiec;1i1‘0dc':s 0fe.1e:':<;Uf0de a.1ira.y 100 and guarci pE:1I1e»i11l with a
`
`singla RF signai, Efioie does not teacii or suggest providing signal eutput frequencirss to these
`
`components. A»:cto1‘ding1y, ciaims E8, 27, amended I‘:-311--E‘€q‘dCST€d
`
`claimg 28, 32. and newly
`
`added claims 33-39 are patent:/£319.
`
`Any CO’-f11111€‘.i}iS
`
`<:<;v11;sia;i::rc=L“‘a necessary by PATENT O‘WNER regarding the above
`
`statement must be sub1nitte»:.i promptly to avoid procsssing delays, Such submisgien by the
`
`patiem; ownfir should be Eabeicsdz "Comments on Stateinem. of R.r':asc>ns for Ffltflfliélbiiiiy andfor
`
`C0nfi1‘r1'3ati0n" and WM E36 placed in the reagaminaticrn file.
`
`Page 515 of 1714
`
`

`
`Applicatimi/C011U701 Number: 90/0 .1 2,='-139
`Art Unit: 3992
`
`Ci;rre.s‘p0nxiem.fe
`
`ARE cui‘i'atsp<>t3Liex:c<a 1‘c:i;1iing 10 this i?1l<2i‘ pa,rze.s' 3'r::xa31iii)aEi<>'(1 p1‘o=;¢<;‘Liit3g should be <ii3'ecEcd:
`By Mail to: Mail Stop Inter Parres Reexzinx
`Ann: Cemrai Reexainination Ujnif
`C()11‘:111i1SSi0l1E)1’ for Patcms
`Unitaad Slates Pmem: 5%; Trademzifl" O:"fi(:e
`PD. Box 1450
`/—\1exandria, "v’,/—‘s 22313-1450
`
`By FAX to:
`
`(:57 1) 27 3 3900
`Cellirzil Rv3EE>L€EIIli£1aEiO£1 Unit
`
`By hand:
`
`Custnmer SEfi'ViCEf Vv'ii*.dmV'
`Randoiph Building
`401 D1aE2myS1r<:et
`A1ex:md3'i;4, VA ‘Z2314
`
`submit such CC1-i‘I'(fSp()I1£i€I1é)EE Via the eiectronic filing 35/513111
`Registered users of EFS-—Web1nziy i11[S1'11€E[i‘v’€i§"
`F,FS~We:h, in hit
`.'~;:;"/efmis t0.m)v,/efiie/nw3011:}?/efs—res:istared ‘EFS-Vv'eh nffem the hemafii ofquick
`submissmn EU the p'.1::'iia:ulur area of the Ciifiue that llflifids its act 011 {ha uoxrsspxsndeiics, Also, EFS»W'eb
`suimnissions. am: “soft scaimed” (i.e., eiectroaaicaily uploaded) direciiy into the official fiie for the
`rees>;2m1ii1aiioi1 proceeciiilg, which 0ffer< pariies the opporiuiiiiy in review the <:-amem {if iheir sukmiissiorxs after
`the “soft scan‘nii1g” prosxzss is <:0mpiet'v::.
`
`Any inqufiy catsncemjng this -:.0i1imui1ia:aIia:in OE’ c—:arii<—:r cominimications from the c—:xa.n1ineJ; or as recs the
`stains of lhis procccdin simuid be dirccicd lo the Ccmral Rccxaminaliori Uni! at tclcphonc mam‘bc1f (571) ’ 7}
`“()5I A
`.
`
`
`/'Li11h M. Nguycnl
`P1’ii111Ell'V Examiner, Art U 1 3992
`
`Camfereies:
`/James Menefésl
`
`Primary Examincp.
`
`Unit 3992
`
`./Démiel Rymzm.’
`Supervisory Patent Exaniiner, Art Unit 3992
`
`Page 516 of 1714
`
`

`
`FARYE REEXANHNATEGN CERTEFECATE ( 961415;
`(:2;
`Enimd States Emtent
`Htmrmami «at M.
`
`US0057961 §§3C1
`
`5,796,183 CE
`Apr. 2%? ZGE3
`
`(10; Numiserz
`Certificate issued:
`
`»’
`
`,.
`
`C APA.{.‘l'i‘l VIC RES §’()NSEVE EL §<I(."l‘R()N Ii?
`S‘Wl'1‘(YHlNG (‘.iRC UM’
`
`Iiivcntersz Byron Hourmand, Hersey, 1‘~/Q’ (US);
`John M. VVs3§hek2§Egi, Cadifiac, MI (US);
`Steglwzl R, ‘W. Camper, Fuwlcrville. IVE
`(US)
`
`(73) Aasignee: Nartwm (7m'pm'atim1, Recéd City, NH
`\
`,.
`-"U53
`
`Reexamimstixxn Request:
`No. 90/0l2,43:TuA11g, 1'7, 2012
`
`Reexamination Certificate for:
`Patent No;
`5,796,133
`Issued:
`Aug. 18;, 1998
`Appi. N0;
`E,38."£§01.Z'.68
`Fileadt
`Jan. 31, 1996
`
`Ceriificnis0f(7m*recIi<)r1issued Way ] 1, 1999‘
`C=:1'iiflx:a=.e uf C{?I'[-’;‘C[iL?l1 issued Cu. 11. 201 1
`
`(51)
`
`1m.<:1.
`1103;; 17/96
`{mm 17/94
`
`(2036.01)
`(2095.01):
`
`(52)
`
`‘L=;s.«C:.
`USPC .......... (4 367/‘E16; 307/125;307/139;3m/1:;1
`
`Fieiai uffllassiiicaiioix Search
`None
`for crgmplete :=eeL='ch11lst<)ry.
`See applicaticm
`Refs;-1'em;es Cited
`
`2 439, please refer to the USPTCYS public - atent
`.
`ApphC1i\,i(>I’). Inform;
`Retricsvzal
`(fPA]I%.Ts system under the
`Display R<;*R:r-'s11c¢s
`Primary Exanziyze/* ———— Lmh M. I\‘Vg‘-.1yc1'1
`(57)
`ABS'I'RACT
`-
`5‘ " C
`:s"Ec '1.
`(3.,
`1-
`9,‘;/‘vs:
`:-c
`om
`V71 hug cucaii
`”\ c"f~"("m
`1' <f~(ms1Vc (1 cu >111
`prises an oscfilator providing a periodic amp‘-.\t sigml bzwiug
`a freL{=.Jenc_V L:-J‘ 50 kHz -:)r grealer, an inpul L-:)u:;E3 lerminail
`dcfi11l11g an area for an up “tor provide :u1i11putby proximity
`and tench and dmec
`cuit couplrsd to the osciliator fvr
`
`an 0perat0‘r’s
`touchtc '
`.
`Preferably: 1,1190
`mrc.-1 output
`pr()‘./kia a
`5 lmviuw a lh:quz;t11uy 4)fS001«;H,;
`vidcs 2: pcriudic: uulpui
`or greener. An array 0: much tsrnzxu
`be pr:-vicbad '
`1
`close proxhnity due to the red‘-Jcticvr: in
`stalk that
`:y
`1'es'uit from comaminams by utilizing am oscillator otripuftixlg
`:3 :;ig‘-.13! luwing :3 frequency s>E'5U M125 or greater.
`
`1
`GS{;‘.iLU\TOF~Z E»-gr
`
`FLQATSNG
`GROUND
`{I-§E{:NERATC}R
`
`MIC-R(“—
`CONTROLLER
`
`TOUCH
`CERCUET
`
`M
`
`E\-HERE»
`<I2ON'T'RC3LLER
`....,.,...‘..
`
`Page 517 of 1714
`
`

`
`US 5,7%,i83 Ci
`
`1
`i’ART iI
`.XAl\'HNA'E7I€3N C ERTE i<‘iE{.‘A(i‘ Ei1
`ESSUEEIE) 1.‘,-NEEER 35 U.S.C. M37
`
`RI"
`
`Tlilif I’A(IEN'I IS ‘
`INDICA
`
`JDE‘-D AS
`
`Matter encimied in heavy iirackets [ E apgiearetl in the
`patciiti but has been deleted and is my ledger a part of the
`patent; matter printed in italics indicates adtiitisns made
`tax the patent.
`
`AS A RESULT OF Rh
`l)i:'l‘l3Ri\/iiiwlil) THAT:
`
`A.l\/iiNA'i‘l()N. IT HAS BEEN
`
`Cl aims IS. 27, 28 at:-zi 32 are -zietermined t-:2 be pat-entaivle as
`at-.1-313 ded .
`New claims 33-39 are added and determined
`pater‘-Jabie.
`Claims 1-17, 19-26:
`
`29-31 were not reexainiried.
`
`be
`
`frcuii
`
`tic switehii __
`
`18. A crapacitivc l”(3Sp-t)i‘C\SiV(3 elcctri,
`eorripr Rig:
`an oscillatiir pit, f 2: periodic output signal i‘~.avir\g a
`prcdeiiiied freqneiicx
`r1 mii"r.9rmz/r.9i.I'er Lcsing .r,‘/';'elt1(’r'.v,'.r;.'1.i.r‘ o7..',fp7,',t signal {rant Ike
`05cf1'/aim, zizc anicmi*aizIr0i:’er' se:’ectiveiy pro‘/zdirzg sig-
`nal ozilpzzifreqeicmrics to :2 _/Jizmzliiy Q/is’/rial!
`'
`input
`£0241;/i le.I'mimu',s' oft: kct;£1a<.";
`tire :li1li‘€'.iif'y 0i’s.n-ml! sized input touch terniinais defin-
`ing atijacerii areas cm 3 dieiectric si11“:strat,e i‘-er an opera-
`tor to provide iitpaits by proximity and miiczhg and
`a detector circuit coupled to said oscillator for receiving;
`said periodic output Si"{Eiéii
`i'mii1 sai-Li c,-scillat-Jr. and
`cmipieri to said input i0".lCi1it3I1Iiil1€:iS,
`said detector cir-
`cuit bcirig respimsive to signzzirs frorii said. -zisci zitor via
`said m‘ér0mm‘ro.<'Zcr' and {the} a presence 0 an opera»
`tur’s body capacitaiirse to gruurid cutzpieii to said tuticii
`lS1“:}’1‘i]1:?.iS1 ‘t7S’i’ir'¢l}pt‘I'.)Xi]112li or touched by [an] fizz» operzatcir
`to provide 3 eontml mitpiit signai,
`wherein
`id predefined frequency of said oscillator’ {is}
`airri said sigma’
`0.u.jv.w.*. _;‘}*e:guencies are selected to
`decrease {the} ajirsl iiiipeciance of
`dielectric sub-
`strate reialive In {the} (‘Z .se.<-om! irnpe-ziance oi‘ any cori-
`taniinatc that may Create an electrical path on said
`dielectric substrate ‘new
`11 said adjaeeiit areas defi/zed
`by tlzeplziralizy ofsma/.'l 5
`d inpz,/I to:
`:h ter'JJ'rina/sq and
`wherein said detector circuit compares [the] (e sensed
`body ca_
`‘:tar.ce .~‘:imr
`I
`> tr: gmnrid proximate at int‘.-iii
`touch terminal to is tiircshoid, level t0 prevent iiiadverterit
`geiieratioii of tire control output signal.
`2’/'. A atapsici tive respimsive eiectmt-.i
`3 coritrclied Ii
`' ml device conip "sing:
`an O51Cilia[()I‘ pro
`.cric>dic output signai i"i£i'Vii'1§'; a
`
`'e‘peri.r)dic output .s'igr2ai_fi"0,-2: lite
`Jrrividirzg. '
`(l7’f'{1/'-" (aft .".'[}?/ll
`_
`Dad, the iizpu: mac}: z‘ern:im:l5
`touc/z zei'n'zir1a'.Zs qfia
`,
`'
`‘ ‘
`-uh fermimzls,‘
`C0mp}'fSfWg_fiV.S‘f and Se
`for
`2129 first arid ‘ ‘arid i.
`‘ii! ton-cli tern iiais defiiiiiig,
`an npereinr in prnviiie an input by prnximity and touch;
`and
`a detector circuit enupled to said osciilat-zir for r-eceiviiig
`said periodic output signal from said, oscillator, and
`cziupied to i
`id first and second tiztich terniiiiais.

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket