throbber
<G@PK@BMJMFW ME RGD B@JBHSK QDLQHLF PDBDNRMP
`
`9HLH$PDTHDU
`
`9@PBDJJM 3HJMN@LRH’
`>@APHL@ 1MPADRR@(# )
`/LL@ 9@PH@ 0@PAHDPH(
`/LL@ >N@C@’# (
`
`) 9^T_SbY^U Q^T 8YQRUd_\_Wi J^Yd$ ;_^TQjY_^U >cdYded_ TY
`GYSUbSQ U 7ebQ Q 7QbQddUbU HSYU^dYVYS_ !>G77H" 7Qm <bQ^TQ
`Dc‘UTQ\U BQWWY_bU E_\YS\Y^YS_$ BY\Q^$ >dQ\i
`* 8U‘Qbd]U^d _V 7\Y^YSQ\ Q^T 7_]]e^Ydi HSYU^SUc$ J^YfUbcYdi
`_V BY\Q^$ >dQ\i
`+ 9^T_SbY^_\_Wi Q^T 8YQRUd_\_Wi J^Yd$ >G77H E_\YS\Y^YS_ HQ^
`8_^Qd_$ HQ^ 8_^Qd_ BY\Q^UcU$ >dQ\i
`
`5TTbUcc V_b S_bbUc‘_^TU^SU2
`5^^Q H‘QTQ$ B8
`EQTYW\Y_^U <bQ^U\\Y
`KYQ ;& HV_bjQ +-
`*()** BY\Q^$ >dQ\i
`EX_^U2 #+1 (* -(+*(.)+
`;Qh2 #+1 (* -(+ *(.(-
`9%]QY\2 Q^^Q&c‘QTQ4e^Y]Y&Yd
`
`>SKK@PW
`
`1@JBHSK QDLQHLF PDBDNRMP !1/>=" HQ @ 4$NPMRDHL BMSNJD
`PDBDNRMP UGHBG NJ@WQ @ IDW PMJD HL B@JBHSK GMKDMQR@QHQ HL
`TDPRDAP@RDQ%
`6RQ DVRP@BDJJSJ@P CMK@HL HQ QDLQHRHTD RM
`CHT@JDLR B@RHMLQ# @KHLM@BHCQ @LC NMJW@KHLDQ% 6L N@P@$
`RGWPMHC FJ@LCQ# 1/>= @BRHT@RHML B@SQDQ N@P@RGWPMHC
`GMPKMLD !<?5" PDCSBRHML @LC QSAQDOSDLRJW @ CDBPD@QD HL
`AJMMC B@JBHSK BMLBDLRP@RHML% 6L <?5$CDNDLCDLR CHQMPCDPQ#
`D%F% NPHK@PW @LC QDBMLC@PW GWNDPN@P@RGWPMHCHQK !5<?"#
`RGD LDDC EMP RGDP@NDSRHB MNRHMLQ MRGDP RG@L QSPFDPW JDC RM
`RGD QWLRGDQHQ ME T@PHMSQ @JJMQRDPHB 1/>= @FMLHQRQ
`!B@JBHKHKDRHBQ"# QSBG @Q BHL@B@JBDR% 1HL@B@JBDR HQ RGD MLJW
`B@JBHKHKDRHB @NNPMTDC EMP 5<? QDBMLC@PW RM BGPMLHB
`IHCLDW CHQD@QD !127"# N@P@RGWPMHC B@PBHLMK@# @LC#
`HL
`QMKD BMSLRPHDQ# NPHK@PW 5<?% 1JHLHB@J RPH@JQ QGMUDC RG@R
`BHL@B@JBDR PDCSBDC <?5 @LC B@JBDKH@ AMRG HL 127 @LC
`NPHK@PW 5<?# JMUDPHLF RGD PHQI ME AMLD EP@BRSPDQ# QSPFDPW#
`@LC B@PCHMT@QBSJ@P BMKNJHB@RHMLQ HL RGD EMPKDP N@RHDLRQ%
`8MLF$RDPK Q@EDRW @LC NG@PK@BMDBMLMKHBQ G@TD RM AD
`ESJJW RDQRDC WDR% 3DU AMRG &( -&+*) @LC &( -&-) QRSCHDQ
`QGMUDC @L @QQMBH@RHML ADRUDDL /PF,,&4JW$1/>= NMJW$
`KMPNGHQK @LC BHL@B@JBDR QDLQHRHTHRW# RGMSFG HL N@RHDLRQ
`UHRG QDTDPD 1/>= HL@BRHT@RHLF KSR@RHMLQ RGD CPSF
`QSAQR@LRH@JJW PDR@HLDC HRQ NMQHRHTD BJHLHB@J DEEDBRQ%
`=DBDLRJW# @ LDU BJ@QQ ME @JJMQRDPHB @LR@FMLHQRQ ME 1/>=#
`H%D% B@JBHJWRHBQ# G@Q ADDL QWLRGDQHXDC% 1@JBHJWRHBQ @PD
`QRPSBRSP@JJW QHKHJ@P RM B@JBHKHKDRHBQ# ASR DVDPR RGDHP DEEDBRQ
`@BRHLF ML @ CHEEDPDLR @JJMQRDPHB QHRD% 6LESQHML ME B@JBHJWRHBQ
`U@Q EMJJMUDC AW RP@LQHDLR PHQD HL <?5 @LC B@JBHSK% ;LD ME
`
`RGDQD BMKNMSLCQ# PML@B@JDPDR# U@Q @AJD RM HLBPD@QD EDKSP
`092 HL NMQR KDLMN@SQ@J UMKDL# ASR UHRG HLCSBRHML ME
`KHJC GWNDPN@P@RGWPMHCHQK% 6L RGD ESRSPD# B@JBHJWRHBQ K@W
`BMLRPHASRD RM RGD MQRDMNMPMQHQ RPD@RKDLR BGMHBD%
`
`)(. -*+’,# &%,+$ 1/514>6 <27<473 ;2129=8;$ 147/1/512=$ 1/514>6 62=/08!
`54<6$ ;87/1/52;2="
`
`6LRPMCSBRHML
`
`7Q\SYe] cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b !75HG" Yc Q <%‘b_dUY^ S_e‘\UT
`bUSU‘d_b
`!<E7G"
`Y^f_\fUT Y^ SQ\SYe] X_]U_cdQcYc Y^
`fUbdURbQdUc& >^ Xe]Q^c$ UhdbQSU\\e\Qb SQ\SYe] S_^SU^dbQdY_^
`bUWe\QdY_^ Yc ]QY^\i SQbbYUT _ed Ri ‘QbQdXib_YT W\Q^Tc$ [YT^Ui$
`Y^dUcdY^U$ Q^T R_^U$ Ri ]UQ^ _V X_b]_^Uc$ Y&U& ‘QbQdXib_YT
`X_b]_^U !EI="$ SQ\SYd_^Y^$ Q^T )$*-!D="*%fYdQ]Y^ 8 !)"&
`IXUcU X_b]_^Uc bUWe\QdU SQ\SYe] Y_^ !7Q##" V\eh dXb_eWX R_Ti
`S_]‘Qbd]U^dc Y^ _bTUb d_ ]QY^dQY^ Ydc R\__T S_^SU^dbQdY_^ Y^ Q
`^Qbb_g bQ^WU& 5c Y^ _dXUb ]Y^UbQ\ X_]U_cdQcYc cicdU]c$ Q
`cU^c_b QR\U d_ TUdUSd Y_^ S_^SU^dbQdY_^ Yc UccU^dYQ\ V_b ‘b_‘Ub
`bUWe\Qd_bi QSdY_^c& >^ SQ\SYe] X_]U_cdQcYc$ dXYc [Ui b_\U Yc
`‘\QiUT Ri 75HG& IXYc bUSU‘d_b RU\_^Wc d_ dXU ce‘UbVQ]Y\i _V
`<E7G$ gXYSX Yc SXQbQSdUbYjUT Ri Q S_]]_^ cUfU^ dbQ^c%
`]U]RbQ^U T_]QY^ cdbeSdebU$ Q^T Yd Yc Y^S\eTUT Y^ dXU +’7
`ceRVQ]Y\i$ d_WUdXUb gYdX ]UdQR_db_‘YS W\edQ]QdU bUSU‘d_b Q^T
`WQ]]Q%Q]Y^_RedibYS QSYT !<565" 6 bUSU‘d_b !*"& 75HG ]Q‘c
`_^ SXb_]_c_]U + a*)&) Y^ Q k)(( @R \_Sec& 75HG dbQ^cSbY‘dc
`Y^S\eTU cUfU^ Uh_^c$
`dXU VYbcd _V
`dXU] Yc e^dbQc\QdUT& 5^
`Q\dUb^QdYfU c‘\YSY^W _V Uh_^ - Yc bU‘_bdUT d_ _SSeb
`Y^
`[UbQdY^_SidUc$ gYdX Q^ Y^ VbQ]U TU\UdY_^ _V // Q]Y^_QSYTc _V
`dXU UhdbQSU\\e\Qb T_]QY^ !978" Q^T S_^cUaeU^d
`\_cc _V
`Ve^SdY_^ !+"& I_ TQdU$ Yd Yc e^[^_g^ YV dXYc fQbYQ^d ]Qi XQfU Q
`b_\U Y^ _dXUb dYcceUc& IXU 978 Yc ‘QbdYSe\Qb\i \QbWU !.)*
`Q]Y^_QSYTc" Q^T QSS_e^dc Q‘‘b_hY]QdU\i V_b XQ\V _V dXU U^dYbU
`75HG ‘b_dUY^ !,"& 5SS_bTY^W d_ dXU dXbUU%TY]U^cY_^Q\ ]_TU\
`‘bUTYSdY_^$ Yd Yc Qcce]UT dXQd 75HG 978 Yc TYfYTUT Y^ dg_
`ceRT_]QY^c$ cU‘QbQdUT Ri Q c\_d$ bUcU]R\Y^W dXU dg_ \UQVc _V
`dXU dbQ‘‘Y^W cdbeSdebU _V dXU SQb^Yf_b_ec ‘\Q^d KU^ec ;\idbQ‘
`!’487/2/ 6><149>5/" !-"& >^dUbUcdY^W\i$ SU\\ ]U]RbQ^U 75HG
`Uh‘bUccY_^ _SSebc Y^ TY]Ubc$ gX_cU S_]‘_^U^dc QbU \Y^[UT Ri
`S_fQ\U^d TYce\VYTU R_^Tc _V SicdUY^U bUcYTeUc Y^ ‘_cYdY_^ )*1
`Q^T )+) !-"&
`IXU SQ\SYe] cU^cY^W QSdY_^ _V 75HG Yc ‘b_RQR\i ‘UbV_b]UT Ri
`]_bU dXQ^ _^U RY^TY^W cYdU V_b UQSX ]_^_]Ub !." Q^T _^U _V
`dXUcU ]Qi RU \_SQdUT Y^ dXU c\_d RUdgUU^ dXU dg_ 978 \_RUc
`!."& 5^_dXUb 7Q## RY^TY^W cYdU \_SQdUc Qd
`dbQ^c]U]RbQ^U
`T_]QY^ !/"$ Q\dX_eWX UfYTU^SU Y^TYSQdUc dXQd 978 7Q ## cYdU Yc
`bUaeYbUT V_b Ve\\i bUSU‘d_b QSdYfQdY_^$ Qc cX_g^ Ri Uh‘UbY]U^dc
`gYdX 978 TU\UdUT 75HG S_^cdbeSdc !0"&
`>^ ‘bUcU^SU _V
`SQ\SYe]$ dXU 75HG S_]‘\Uh e^TUbW_Uc d_ S_^V_b]QdY_^Q\
`SXQ^WUc dXQd UfU^deQ\\i SQecU dXU QSdYfQdY_^ _V
`dXU
`dbQ^cTeSdY_^ ‘QdXgQic Ri ]UQ^ _V ‘b_dUY^ <a’))$ gXYSX
`cdY]e\QdUc ‘X_c‘X_\Y‘QcU 7 Q^T ceRcUaeU^d\i Y^TeSUc
`Y^dbQSU\\e\Qb 7Q## ]_RY\YjQdY_^ !1"& 5\c_ ‘b_dUY^ <Y Q^T <)*’)+
`
`!&"
`
`1JHLHB@J 1@QDQ HL 9HLDP@J @LC 0MLD 9DR@AMJHQK (&’). ’&!)"-’+($’+*
`
`Amgen Ex. 2017
`Complex Innovations v. Amgen
`IPR2016-00085
`
`

`
`#"(’ &-)40)*2/2,6
`
`TU‘U^TU^d ‘QdXgQic QbU dbYWWUbUT Ri 75HG QSdYfQdY_^ !1"& >^
`QTTYdY_^ d_ 7Q##$ _dXUb ‘XicY_\_WYS U^T_WU^_ec Q\\_cdUbYS
`]_Te\Qd_bc QbU QR\U d_ QSdYfQdU 75HG& 6_dX TYfQ\U^d !BW ## Q^T
`Hb##" Q^T dbYfQ\U^d !<T+#$ AQ+#" SQdY_^c ]Qi Y^TeSU 75HG
`Q\\_cdUbYS QSdYfQdY_^ !)("& 7Q## Q^T dXUcU SQdY_^c QbU SQ\\UT
`di‘U ) QW_^Ycdc$
`Y&U&
`\YWQ^Tc QR\U d_ TYbUSd\i QSdYfQdU dXU
`bUSU‘d_b gYdX ^_ ^UUT _V _dXUb S_VQSd_bc& 7_^fUbcU\i$ di‘U *
`QW_^Ycdc \Y[U ‘_\iQ]Y^Uc$ U&W& c‘Ub]Y^U$ ‘edbUcSY^U !))"$
`Q]Y^_QSYTc
`!U&W&
`dbi‘d_‘XQ^$ ‘XU^i\Q\Q^Y^U$ XYcdYTY^U$
`W\edQ]QdU$ Q\Q^Y^U" !)*$ )+"$ Q^T W\edQdXY_^U !),"$ ^UUT 7Q ##
`d_ QSd$ UfU^ Y^ c]Q\\ Q]_e^dc& IXUcU ]_Te\Qd_bc QbU Q\c_
`SQ\\UT Q\\_cdUbYS \YWQ^Tc$ d_ TYVVUbU^dYQdU dXU] Vb_] 7Q##$ gXYSX
`Yc bUVUbbUT _bdX_cdUbYS \YWQ^T&
`>^ ‘QbQdXib_YTc$ 75HG cdY]e\QdY_^ bUTeSUc EI= cUSbUdY_^ Q^T
`ci^dXUcYc$ Qc gU\\ Qc SU\\ ‘b_\YVUbQdY_^ !)"& 75HG ‘\Qic Q^
`Y]‘_bdQ^d b_\U Q\c_ Y^ [YT^Ui$ gXUbU Y^XYRYdc )$*-!D="*%fYdQ]Y^
`8 ‘b_TeSdY_^ Q^T 7Q## bUQRc_b‘dY_^ Ri S_bdYSQ\ dXYS[ QcSU^TY^W
`\Y]R _V dXU [YT^Ui deRe\U !)"& >^ R_^U$ 75HG Yc Uh‘bUccUT Y^
`Q\]_cd Q\\ SU\\
`di‘U Y^f_\fUT Y^ R_^U ]UdQR_\Yc] Q^T
`]_b‘X_WU^UcYc Q^T dXU ^Ud UVVUSd _V bUSU‘d_b QSdYfQdY_^ cUU]c
`d_ RU Q^QR_\YS !bUfYUgUT Y^ )-"&
`
`1/>= @JJMQRDPHB CPSFQ- B@JBHKHKDRHBQ
`
`IXU cUQbSX V_b ‘XQb]QS_\_WYSQ\ 75HG QW_^Ycdc gQc TbYfU^ Ri
`dXU ^UUT _V Q ]UTYSQ\ Q‘‘b_QSX V_b ‘QbQdXib_YT X_b]_^U !EI="
`Xi‘UbcUSbUdY_^ TYcUQcUc$ ‘bY^SY‘Q\\i cUS_^TQbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXi%
`b_YTYc] Q^T ‘QbQdXib_YT SQbSY^_]Q$ Y^ QTTYdY_^ d_ dXU cebWUbi
`_‘dY_^& J^V_bde^QdU\i$ _bWQ^YS S_]‘_e^Tc QR\U d_ TYbUSd\i
`]Y]YS dXU QSdY_^ _V Q^ Y^_bWQ^YS Y_^ QbU fUbi TYVVYSe\d
`d_
`ci^dXUcYjU& =_gUfUb$ 7Q## Yc ^_d Q S\QccYS \YWQ^T V_b 75HG
`cY^SU Yd QSdYfQdUc dXU bUSU‘d_b Ri ]e\dYcYdU cdUbYS Y^dUbQSdY_^ !."$
`Q ]USXQ^Yc] dXQd ]Qi RU Uh‘\_YdUT Ri QbdYVYSYQ\ ]_\USe\Uc&
`IXU VYbcd ]U]RUbc _V dXU SQ\SY]Y]UdYS ‘XQb]QS_\_WYSQ\ S\Qcc
`gUbU dXU ‘XU^i\Q\[i\Q]Y^Uc CEH-.0 Q^T CEH,./& IXUcU
`]_Te\Qd_bc cX_gUT Q S\UQb Q^T c‘USYVYS QSdYfQdY_^ _V 75HG$ Red
`_^\i Y^ ‘bUcU^SU _V UhdbQSU\\e\Qb SQ\SYe] !)."& CEH-.0 gQc QR\U
`d_ Y^TeSU bYcU Y^ Y^dbQSU\\e\Qb 7Q## S_^SU^dbQdY_^ Y^ fQbY_ec
`]_TU\c !=9@*1+ SU\\ \Y^Uc$ MU^_‘ec \QUfYc __SidUc$ R_fY^U
`‘QbQdXib_YT SU\\c$ Xe]Q^ ‘QbQdXib_YT QTU^_]Q SU\\c" Q^T d_
`bUTeSU EI= cUSbUdY_^ Y^ R_fY^U Q^T Xe]Q^ SU\\c !).$ )/"&
`CEH-.0 gQc Q\c_ QR\U d_ Y^SbUQcU 75HG Uh‘bUccY_^ !)0"&
`B_bU_fUb$ dXUcU TbeWc TYT ^_d cX_gUT Q^i QSdYfYdi Y^ dXib_YT
`‘QbQV_\\YS_\Qb 7 SU\\c Q^T [YT^Ui deRe\U$ Q ‘XU^_]U^_^ ‘b_RQR\i
`TeU d_ TYVVUbU^SUc Y^ dbQ^cTeSdY_^ ]USXQ^Yc]c _b bUSU‘d_b
`Uh‘bUccY_^ Y^ dXUcU dYcceUc S_]‘QbUT d_ ‘QbQdXib_YTc !)1"&
`=_gUfUb$ T_cUc k+(%V_\T XYWXUb dXQ^ dX_cU QT]Y^YcdUbUT V_b
`S_^db_\\Y^W EI= \UfU\c Q\c_ Y^TeSUT bYcU Y^ SQ\SYd_^Y^ \UfU\c !*("&
`;ebdXUb cdbeSdebU ]_TYVYSQdY_^c \UT d_ Q ^Ug WU^UbQdY_^ _V
`SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc$ gXYSX Y^S\eTUc SY^QSQ\SUd$ dXU _^\i SQ\SY]Y]UdYS
`‘bUcU^d\i _^ dXU ]Qb[Ud& 7Y^QSQ\SUd cX_gUT dXU RUcd
`‘XQb]QS_\_WYSQ\ ‘b_VY\U Q^T \UccUb Y^dUbY^TYfYTeQ\ fQbYQRY\Ydi Y^
`QRc_b‘dY_^ Q^T bUc‘_^cU& 7Y^QSQ\SUd RY^TY^W cYdU gQc V_e^T d_
`RU \_SQdUT ^UQb dXU UhdUb^Q\ U^T _V
`dXU cUfU^dX dbQ^c%
`]U]RbQ^U XU\YS !*)"$ Q\dX_eWX dXU bUcYTeUc Y^f_\fUT Y^ dXYc
`Y^dUbQSdY_^ XQfU ^_d iUd RUU^ S\UQb\i YTU^dYVYUT& >^dUbUcdY^W\i$
`SY^QSQ\SUd Q^T cdbeSdebQ\\i cY]Y\Qb SQ\SY\idYSc !cUU RU\_g" cXQbU
`]_cd _V dXUYb RY^TY^W cYdU !**"&
`
`!’&(&#"’ ,+&’&+. )% #&("#"’#$+
`>^ ]_cd S_e^dbYUc SY^QSQ\SUd ]Qi RU QT]Y^YcdUbUT Y^ ‘QdYU^dc
`QVVUSdUT gYdX cdQWU - SXb_^YS [YT^Ui TYcUQcU !7@8" Xi‘Ub%
`‘QbQdXib_YTYc] _b ‘QbQdXib_YT SQbSY^_]Q$ gXUbUQc dXU ecU Y^
`
`‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc] TeU d_ ‘QbQdXib_YT QTU^_]Q _b
`Xi‘Ub‘\QcYQ Yc bUcdbYSdUT d_ SQcUc Y^ gXYSX cebWUbi Yc S_^dbQ%
`Y^TYSQdUT _b V_\\_gUT Ri TYcUQcU bUSebbU^SU&
`>^ cdQWU - 7@8$ SY^QSQ\SUd Yc QR\U d_ bUTeSU EI= Q^T SQ\SU]YQ$
`gYdX Q RUddUb S\Y^YSQ\ _edS_]U !*+"& KQbY_ec cdeTYUc SQbbYUT _ed
`_^ Q _fUbQ\\ Wb_e‘ _V ]_bU dXQ^ _^U dX_ecQ^T ‘QdYU^dc$ cX_gUT
`Q bUTeSdY_^ Y^ bYc[ _V ‘QbQdXib_YT cebWUbi$
`VbQSdebUc$ Q^T
`SQbTY_fQcSe\Qb S_]_bRYTYdYUc$ Qc gU\\ Qc Q^ Y]‘b_fU]U^d Y^
`‘UbSUYfUT aeQ\Ydi _V \YVU Q^T ‘QY^& 7\Y^YSQ\ dbYQ\c SQbbYUT _ed Y^ 7@8
`QbU Ve\\i bUfYUgUT Y^ !*,"& >^ ‘QbQdXib_YT SQbSY^_]Q$ SY^QSQ\SUd
`Yc QR\U d_ bUTeSU SQ\SU]YQ Y^ QR_ed _^U dXYbT _V ‘QdYU^d$ gYdX ]Y^_b
`UVVUSdc _^ EI= \UfU\c Q^T cebfYfQ\ !*-"&
`EbY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc] ]Qi RU dbUQdUT gYdX SY^QSQ\SUd _^\i
`Y^ c_]U 9eb_‘UQ^ S_e^dbYUc Q^T bUcdbYSdUT d_ ‘QdYU^dc Y^ gX_]
`cebWUbi Yc ^_d ceYdQR\U& >^ dXUcU ‘QdYU^dc$ SQ\SU]YQ gQc gU\\
`S_^db_\\UT Ri SY^QSQ\SUd$ gXUbUQc EI= \UfU\c gUbU _^\i ]Y\T
`bUTeSUT Q^T VbUaeU^d\i bU]QY^UT QR_fU dXU e‘‘Ub ^_b]Q\ \Y]Yd
`!*."& J^\Y[U dXU ‘QbQdXib_YTUSd_]i$ SY^QSQ\SUd dbUQd]U^d TYT ^_d
`‘_cYdYfU\i QVVUSd R_^U ]Y^UbQ\ TU^cYdi !*/"& B_bU_fUb$ ^QecUQ
`Q^T f_]YdY^W gUbU S_]]_^ QTfUbcU UVVUSdc TebY^W dbUQd]U^d$
`Q^T ]Qi SQecU TYcS_^dY^eQdY_^ _V dXU dXUbQ‘i !*."& C_ cYW^YVYSQ^d
`bUcYcdQ^SU _b dQSXi‘Xi\QhYc XQfU RUU^ _RcUbfUT !*/"&
`H_]U SQcU bU‘_bdc Q^T _^U dbYQ\ Y^ di‘U ) ]e\dY‘\U U^T_SbY^U
`^U_‘\QcYQ ci^Tb_]U !B9C)" ‘QdYU^dc$ cX_gUT dXU UVVYSQSi Q^T
`dXU cQVUdi _V SY^QSQ\SUd Y^ S_^db_\\Y^W SQ\SYe] \UfU\c Q^T EI=
`Y^ dXUcU ‘QdYU^dc$ Qd \UQcd Y^ dXU cX_bd ‘UbY_T !*0%+("& 7Y^Q%
`SQ\SUd gQc QR\U d_ ^_b]Q\YjU SQ\SU]YQ Y^ Q S_X_bd _V )) B9C)
`‘QdYU^dc dbUQdUT V_b dXbUU ]_^dXc$ gYdX cYW^YVYSQ^d bUTeSdY_^ _V
`EI=$ Red ^_b]Q\YjQdY_^ Y^ _^\i VYfU ‘QdYU^dc !+("& HY]Y\Qb bUce\dc
`gUbU _RcUbfUT Y^ Q S_^db_\ Wb_e‘ _V *( ‘QdYU^dc gYdX c‘_bQTYS
`‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ gX_ cX_gUT Q \_gUb bQdU _V EI=
`^_b]Q\YjQdY_^$ ‘b_RQR\i TeU d_ EI= RQcQ\
`\UfU\c XYWXUb Y^
`c‘_bQTYS Y^ S_]‘QbYc_^ d_ B9C) ‘QdYU^dc !+("&
`>^ ‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ c_]U 75HG ‘_\i]_b‘XYc]c
`gUbU ‘bUfY_ec\i bU‘_bdUT d_ QVVUSd bUSU‘d_b QSdYfYdi$ cY^SU dXUi
`Qcc_SYQdU gYdX TYVVUbU^d cUbe] SQ\SYe] \UfU\c !+)" Q^T
`^U‘Xb_\YdXYQcYc !+*"$ Q\dX_eWX ‘XQb]QS_WU^UdYSc Y^ SY^QSQ\SUd
`dbUQd]U^d gQc ^_d iUc dX_b_eWX\i Y^fUcdYWQdUT& H_]U UfYTU^SUc
`\Y^[ dXU 5bW11(<\i ‘_\i]_b‘XYc] gYdX Q TYVVUbU^SU Y^ SY^QSQ\SUd
`cU^cYdYfYdi !++$ +,"$ gXY\U _dXUb cdeTYUc TYT ^_d V_e^T cYW^YVYSQ^d
`Qcc_SYQdY_^ !+("& 5T]YddUT\i$ dXU ‘QdYU^dc S_X_bdc c_ VQb bU‘_bdUT
`QbU Y^QTUaeQdU d_ TbUg TUVY^YdYfU S_^S\ecY_^c&
`5c bUWQbTc 75HG ]edQdY_^c$ c‘_bQTYS bU‘_bdc Y^ ‘QdYU^dc gYdX
`VQ]Y\YQ\ Xi‘_SQ\SYebYS Xi‘UbSQ\SU]YQ !;=="$ Q WU^UdYS TYc_bTUb
`TeU d_ Y^QSdYfQdY_^ _V dXU bUSU‘d_b$ cX_gUT Q W__T S\Y^YSQ\ Q^T
`RY_SXU]YSQ\
`bUc‘_^cU d_ SY^QSQ\SUd QT]Y^YcdbQdY_^ !+-"&
`7\Y^YSQ\ edY\Ydi _V SY^QSQ\SUd Y^ TYc_bTUbc e^bU\QdUT d_ EI=
`Xi‘UbcUSbUdY_^ !U&W& SQ\SY‘Xi\QhYc$ ‘X_c‘XQdU%gQcdY^W" QbU
`bUfYUgUT !+."&
`;Y^Q\\i$ Yd cX_e\T RU XYWX\YWXdUT dXQd dXU ecU _V SY^QSQ\SUd Y^
`‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc] WQfU bYcU d_ Q ^e]RUb _V
`‘XQb]QS_US_^_]YSc S_^cYTUbQdY_^c& I_ TQdU$ SY^QSQ\SUd
`dbUQd]U^d Yc cdY\\ Uh‘U^cYfU Q^T cebWUbi$ gXU^ ceYdQR\U$ Yc ]_bU
`S_cd UVVUSdYfU dXQ^ SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc$ Uc‘USYQ\\i S_^cYTUbY^W dXU
`‘__b$ YV Q^i$ UVVUSd _V SY^QSQ\SUd _^ R_^U&
`
`1/>= @JJMQRDPHB CPSFQ- B@JBHJWRHBQ
`
`I_ TQdU$ ^_ ‘XicY_\_WYSQ\ 75HG _bdX_cdUbYS Q^dQW_^Ycdc XQfU
`RUU^ TUdUSdUT& >^ Q^Q\_Wi gYdX SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc$ dXU bUSU^d\i
`ci^dXUcYjUT Q\\_cdUbYS Q^dQW_^Ycdc XQfU RUU^ ^Q]UT
`SQ\SY\idYSc& IXU QY] gQc d_ XQfU S_]‘_e^Tc gYdX Q^QR_\YS
`UVVUSd _^ R_^U d_ RU ecUT V_b _cdU_‘_b_cYc dbUQd]U^d& 5 92; 8<
`
`1JHLHB@J 1@QDQ HL 9HLDP@J @LC 0MLD 9DR@AMJHQK (&’). ’&!)"- ’+($’+*
`
`!&#
`
`

`
`%! $./23)15. +5 )/!
`
`75HG Q^dQW_^Ycd gYdX Q gU\\ SQ\YRbQdUT ‘b_VY\U ]YWXd Y^TeSU
`dbQ^cYU^d R\__T EI= bYcUc cY]Y\Qb d_ dX_cU _RcUbfUT Y^ TQY\i
`Y^ZUSdUT bUS_]RY^Q^d EI= dbUQd]U^d !U&W& dUbY‘QbQdYTU"$ gXYSX
`Yc [^_g^ d_ XQfU ‘_cYdYfU UVVUSdc _^ dbQRUSe\Qb Q^T S_]‘QSd
`R_^U !+/"& B_bU_fUb$ dXUcU QWU^dc ]YWXd Q\c_ RU ecUT Y^
`WU^UdYS TYc_bTUbc TeU d_ 75HG QSdYfQdY_^&
`d_
`HdbeSdebQ\\i$
`VYbcd WU^UbQdY_^ SQ\SY\idYSc gUbU cY]Y\Qb
`SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc& IXUYb Yc_\QdY_^ gQc Y^ VQSd _RdQY^UT Ri cSbUU^Y^W
`fQbY_ec ]_\USe\Uc RQcUT _^ dXU cQ]U ‘XU^i\Q\[i\Q]Y^U
`cdbeSdebU !+0"& CEH*),+ gQc dXU VYbcd SQ\SY\idYS ci^dXUcYjUT& >^
`bQdc$ CEH*),+ Y^TeSUT Q cdb_^W EI= Y^SbUQcU$ V_\\_gUT Ri
`Xi‘UbSQ\SU]YQ !+1"& >dc ‘XQb]QS_[Y^UdYSc$ X_gUfUb$ gQc ^_d
`QTUaeQdU d_ Y^TeSU R_^U Q^QR_\Yc]$ TeU d_ Ydc ‘b_\_^WUT
`QSdY_^& ;ebdXUb ]_TYVYSQdY_^c _V
`dXU CEH*),+ \UT d_
`S_]‘_e^Tc gYdX RUddUb ‘b_VY\U$ ceSX Qc H6,*+--/$ gXYSX
`TU]_^cdbQdUT R_^U Q^QR_\YS UVVUSdc Y^ _fQbYUSd_]YjUT bQdc
`!,("& 8ebY^W dXYc cSbUU^Y^W ‘b_SUcc$ dXU cdbeSdebUc _V SQ\SY\idYSc
`TYVVUbUT cYW^YVYSQ^d\i Y^ S_]‘QbYc_^ d_ VYbcd WU^UbQdY_^
`]_\USe\Uc$ c_ dXQd dXU cUS_^T WU^UbQdY_^%SQ\SY\idYS gQc V_e^T
`d_ QSd
`dXb_eWX Q TYVVUbU^d cYdU Y^ 75HG 978 !,)"& 5
`dXU_bUdYSQ\\i ‘_ccYR\U QTfUbcU UVVUSd$ Y&U& ‘QbQdXib_YT Xi‘Ub%
`‘\QcYQ$ gQc ^_d TUdUSdUT Y^ ‘bU\Y]Y^Qbi cdeTYUc SQbbYUT _ed Y^
`Q^Y]Q\c&
`IXU ]_cd ‘b_]YcY^W SQ\SY\idYS$ Y&U& b_^QSQ\UbUd$ gQc bUSU^d\i
`UfQ\eQdUT Y^ ‘_cd]U^_‘QecQ\ g_]U^ Y^ Q ‘XQcU + S\Y^YSQ\ dbYQ\
`Ri S_]‘QbY^W dXYc QWU^d gYdX dUbY‘QbQdYTU$ Q\U^Tb_^QdU$ Q^T
`‘\QSUR_& G_^QSQ\UbUd gQc QR\U d_ cYW^YVYSQ^d\i Y^SbUQcU
`f_\e]UdbYS R_^U ]Qcc TU^cYdi !f6B8"& IXU UVVUSd gQc XQ\V _V
`dXQd _RcUbfUT Y^ g_]U^ dbUQdUT gYdX dUbY‘QbQdYTU !,*" Q^T
`cY]Y\Qb d_ dXQd _RdQY^UT gYdX Q\U^Tb_^QdU& IXU ]QY^ YcceU gQc
`dXU ‘bUcU^SU _V ]Y\T f6B8 TUSbUQcU Y^ ‘b_hY]Q\ VU]eb Q^T Y^
`_dXUb S_bdYSQ\ R_^U cYdUc !,*"$ dXQd gQc QddbYRedUT d_ Q ]Y\T
`Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ TeU d_ ]_bU ‘b_\_^WUT EI= U\UfQdY_^c
`Y^TeSUT Ri b_^QSQ\UbUd Y^ S_]‘QbYc_^ d_ dUbY‘QbQdYTU !,*"& 5
`‘XQcU * cdeTi Y^ Xe]Q^c gYdX H6,*+--/ UfYTU^SUT Q RUddUb 47
`?4?8 ‘b_VY\U !,+"$ Q^T dXYc SQ\SY\idYS ]YWXd RU dUcdUT V_b
`_cdU_‘_b_cYc dbUQd]U^d Y^ dXU ^UQb VedebU&
`
`1MLBJSQHMLQ
`
`C_gQTQic Q ^e]RUb _V Q\\_cdUbYS QWU^dc QSdY^W _^ SQ\SYe]
`cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b XQc RUU^ ci^dXUcYjUT Q^T dUcdUT& IXU cUQbSX
`V_b ‘_cYdYfU Q\\_cdUbYS ]_TYVYSQd_bc !Y&U& SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc" Qb_cU
`Vb_] dXU ^UUT d_ XQfU Q ]UTYSQ\ dbUQd]U^d d_ V\Q^[ cebWUbi Y^
`‘QdYU^dc gYdX EI= Xi‘UbcUSbUdY_^ TYc_bTUbc& IXUcU Uh‘U%
`SdQdY_^c gQc ]Ud Ri dXU VYbcd _^ ]Qb[Ud SQ\SY]Y]UdYS SY^QSQ\SUd&
`EQdYU^dc gYdX cdQWU - 7=8 cUS_^TQbi’dUbdYQbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQ%
`dXib_YTYc] XQT WbUQdUb RU^UVYd gYdX SQ\SY]Y]UdYS dbUQd]U^d& >^
`‘QbdYSe\Qb$ dXYc TbeW gQc QR\U d_ bUTeSU bYc[ _V ‘QbQdXib_YT
`cebWUbi$ S_]_bRYTYdYUc$ Q^T aeQ\Ydi _V \YVU Y^ dXUcU ‘QdYU^dc&
`<__T bUce\dc gQc _RcUbfUT Q\c_ Y^ ‘QdYU^dc QVVUSdUT gYdX
`‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ Q\dX_eWX S_cd Q^Q\icYc Yc cdY\\
`VQf_ebQR\U d_ cebWUbi& IXU ecU _V SY^QSQ\SUd Y^ _dXUb S_^TYdY_^c
`\Y[U SQ\SY‘Xi\QhYc$ ‘X_c‘XQdU%gQcdY^W TYc_bTUbc$
`\YdXYe]
`Y^TeSUT Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ Q^T VQ]Y\YQ\ Xi‘_SQ\SYebYS
`Xi‘UbSQ\SU]YQ gQc ‘b_‘_cUT$ Q\dX_eWX d_ TQdU dXU cQ]U
`US_^_]YS S_^cYTUbQdY_^c cX_e\T Q‘‘\i d_ dXUcU S_^TYdY_^c&
`6i SXU]YSQ\ fQbYQdY_^ _V
`dXU SQ\SY]Y]UdYS cdbeSdebU$
`dXU
`‘XQb]QS_\_WYSQ\ bUcUQbSX _RdQY^UT Q ^Ug S\Qcc _V S_]‘_e^Tc
`gYdX ^UWQdYfU Q\\_cdUbYS bUWe\QdY_^ _V 75HG$ Y&U& SQ\SY\idYSc& IXYc
`_bQ\\i QSdYfU TbeWc QbU QR\U d_ dbQ^cYU^d\i Y^SbUQcU EI= Q^T
`dXUi gUbU dX_eWXd d_ ]Y]YS dXU ‘b_VY\U _V bUS_]RY^Q^d EI=$
`gYdX_ed dXU ^UUT _V TQY\i Y^ZUSdY_^& 7Q\SY\idYSc gUbU dUcdUT Y^
`
`Q^Y]Q\ ]_TU\c _V ]U^_‘QecU gYdX W__T bUce\dc& 5 ‘XQcU + dbYQ\
`Y^ Q S_X_bd _V ‘_cd]U^_‘QecQ\ g_]U^ cX_gUT dXQd
`dXU
`SQ\SY\idYS b_^QSQ\UbUd Y]‘b_fUT VU]eb 6B8$ Red \Ucc dXQ^ dX_cU
`_RcUbfUT gYdX dUbY‘QbQdYTU$ ‘b_RQR\i TeU d_ Y^TeSdY_^ _V ]Y\T
`Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]& 7Q\SY\idYSc gYdX RUddUb ‘b_VY\U QbU Y^
`UfQ\eQdY_^&
`
`=DEDPDLBDQ
`
`)&
`
`*&
`
`+&
`
`,&
`
`-&
`
`.&
`
`/&
`
`0&
`
`1&
`
`6b_g^ 9B& 7\Y^YSQ\ \Ucc_^c Vb_] dXU SQ\SYe] cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b& CQd 7\Y^ EbQSd
`9^T_SbY^Y_\ BUdQR *((/3+2)**%++&
`6b_g^ 9B$ BQSAU_T G?& 9hdbQSU\\e\Qb SQ\SYe] cU^cY^W Q^T UhdbQSU\\e\Qb
`SQ\SYe] cYW^Q\Y^W& EXicY_\ GUf *(()30)2*+1%*1/& GUfYUg&
`DTQ N$ Ie 7A$ EY\\QY H$ Ud Q\& IXU SQ\SYe] cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Q^T Ydc Q\dUb^QdYfU\i
`c‘\YSUT V_b] Y^ [UbQdY^_SidU TYVVUbU^dYQdY_^& ? 6Y_\ 7XU] )1103*/+!+."2*++,,%
`-*&
`<QbbUdd ?9$ 7Q‘eQ^_ >K$ =Q]]Ub\Q^T A<$ Ud Q\& B_\USe\Qb S\_^Y^W Q^T Ve^S%
`dY_^Q\ Uh‘bUccY_^ _V Xe]Q^ ‘QbQdXib_YT SQ\SYe] bUSU‘d_b S8C5c& ? 6Y_\ 7XU]
`)11-3*/(!*)"2)*1)1%*-&
`=e ?$ H‘YUWU\ 5B& HdbeSdebU Q^T Ve^SdY_^ _V dXU Xe]Q^ SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bU%
`SU‘d_b2 Y^cYWXdc Vb_] ^QdebQ\ Q^T U^WY^UUbUT ]edQdY_^c Q^T Q\\_cdUbYS ]_T%
`e\Qd_bc& ? 7U\\ B_\ BUT *((/3))!-"21(0%**& GUfYUg&
`=eQ^W N$ OX_e N$ NQ^W L$ Ud Q\& >TU^dYVYSQdY_^ Q^T TYccUSdY_^ _V 7Q!*#"%
`RY^TY^W cYdUc Y^ dXU UhdbQSU\\e\Qb T_]QY^ _V 7Q!*#"%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b& ? 6Y_\
`7XU] *((/3*0*!*."2)1(((%)(&
`GQi @$ C_bdXe‘ ?& 9fYTU^SU V_b TYcdY^Sd SQdY_^ Q^T SQ\SY]Y]UdYS S_]‘_e^T
`!CEH -.0" bUS_W^YdY_^ T_]QY^c Y^ dXU dbQ^c]U]RbQ^U bUWY_^c _V dXU Xe%
`]Q^ 7Q*# bUSU‘d_b& ? 6Y_\ 7XU] *((*3*//!*)"2)01(0%)+&
`=Q]]Ub\Q^T A<$ @bQ‘SX_ @?$ <QbbUdd ?9$ Ud Q\& 8_]QY^c TUdUb]Y^Y^W \YW%
`Q^T c‘USYVYSYdi V_b 7Q*# bUSU‘d_bc& B_\ EXQb]QS_\ )1113--2.,*%.,0&
`=eQ^W 7$ BY\\Ub GI& C_fU\ 7Q bUSU‘d_b cYW^Q\Y^W ‘QdXgQic V_b S_^db_\ _V bU%
`^Q\ Y_^ dbQ^c‘_bd& 7ebb D‘Y^ CU‘Xb_\ =i‘UbdU^c *()(3)1!)"2)(.%)*& GUfYUg&
`)(& 6bQe^Ub%DcR_b^U =$ ?U^cU^ 55$ Ud Q\& IXU QW_^Ycd%RY^TY^W T_]QY^ _V dXU
`SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Yc \_SQdUT Qd dXU Q]Y^_%dUb]Y^Q\ T_]QY^&? 6Y_\
`7XU]* )1113/,2)0+0*%)0+0.&
`))& FeY^^ H?$ NU 7E$ 8YQj G$ Ud Q\& IXU 7Q*#%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b2 Q dQbWUd V_b
`‘_\iQ]Y^Uc& 5] ? EXicY_\ 7U\\ EXicY_\ )11/3*/+27)+)-%7)+*+&
`)*& ;U^W ?$ EUdUbcU^ 78$ 7_i 8=$ Ud Q\& 7Q\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Yc Q ‘Xic%
`Y_\_WYS ]e\dY]_TQ\ SXU]_cU^c_b bUWe\QdY^W WQcdbYS <%SU\\ Wb_gdX Q^T WQc%
`dbY^ cUSbUdY_^& Eb_S CQd\ 5SQT HSY J H 5& *()(3)(/!,)"2)//1)%.&
`)+& 7_^YWbQfU 58$ Be^ =7$ A_[ =7& 5b_]QdYS A%Q]Y^_ QSYTc QSdYfQdU dXU SQ\%
`SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b& ? Cedb *((/3)+/!. He‘‘\ )"2)-*,H%)-*/H&
`),& 6b_QTXUQT <@$ Be^ =7$ 5f\Q^Y K5$ Ud Q\& 5\\_cdUbYS ]_Te\QdY_^ _V dXU SQ\%
`SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Ri WQ]]Q%W\edQ]i\ ‘U‘dYTUc2 Y^XYRYdY_^ _V EI= cU%
`SbUdY_^$ ce‘‘bUccY_^ _V Y^dbQSU\\e\Qb S5BE \UfU\c$ Q^T Q S_]]_^ ]USXQ%
`^Yc] _V QSdY_^ gYdX A%Q]Y^_ QSYTc& ? 6Y_\ 7XU] *())3*0.!))"20/0.%1/&
`)-& IXU]Q^ I5$ 7_\\Y^c BI& IXU b_\U _V dXU SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Y^ R_^U
`RY_\_Wi Q^T ‘QdX_‘XicY_\_Wi& 7ebb EXQb] 6Y_dUSX^_\ *((13)(!+"2*01%+()&GU%
`fYUg&
`).& CU]UdX 9;$ HdUVVUi B9$ =Q]]Ub\Q^T A<$ Ud Q\& 7Q\SY]Y]UdYSc gYdX ‘_dU^d
`Q^T cU\USdYfU QSdYfYdi _^ dXU ‘QbQdXib_YT SQ\SYe] bUSU‘d_b& Eb_S CQd\ 5SQT
`HSY J H 5 )11031-!/"2,(,(%-&
`)/& =Q]]Ub\Q^T A<$ <QbbUdd ?9$ =e^W 67$ Ud Q\& 5\\_cdUbYS QSdYfQdY_^ _V dXU 7Q*#
`bUSU‘d_b Uh‘bUccUT Y^ hU^_‘ec \QUfYc __SidUc Ri CEH ,./ _b CEH -.0& B_\
`EXQb]QS_\ )1103-+2)(0+%)(00&
`)0& 7QfQ^QeWX 5$ =eQ^W N$ 6bUYdgYUcUb <9& 6UXY^T dXU SebdQY^2 SU\\e\Qb ]USX%
`Q^Yc]c V_b Q\\_cdUbYS ]_Te\QdY_^ _V SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_bc& 6b ? EXQb%
`]QS_\ *()*3).-!."2)./(%/& GUfYUg&
`)1& CU]UdX 9; Q^T ;_h ?& 7Q\SY]Y]UdYS S_]‘_e^Tc2 Q TYbUSd Q‘‘b_QSX d_ S_^%
`db_\%\Y^W ‘\Qc]Q \UfU\c _V ‘QbQdXib_YT X_b]_^U Y^ Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]&IbU^Tc
`9^T_SbY^_\ BUdQR )1113)(2..%/)&
`*(& CU]UdX 9;$ =UQd_^ L=$ BY\\Ub B$ Ud Q\& EXQb]QS_Ti^Q]YSc _V dXU di‘U >>
`SQ\SY]Y]UdYS S_]‘_e^T SY^QSQ\SUd =7\& ? EXQb]QS_\ 9h‘ IXUb *((,3+(02.*/%
`.+-&
`*)& =e ?$ GUiUc%7bej <$ Ud Q\& 5B& >TU^dYVYSQdY_^ _V QSYTYS bUcYTeUc Y^ dXU Uh%
`dbQSU\\e\Qb \__‘c _V dXU cUfU^%dbQ^c]U]RbQ^U T_]QY^ _V dXU Xe]Q^ 7Q*#
`bUSU‘d_b SbYdYSQ\ V_b bUc‘_^cU d_ 7Q*# Q^T Q ‘_cYdYfU Q\\_cdUbYS ]_Te\Qd_b&
`? 6Y_\ 7XU] *((*3*//!,0"2,..**%+)&
`**& EUdbU\ 7$ @Ucc\Ub 5$ 8QeRQ^ E$ Ud Q\& E_cYdYfU Q^T ^UWQdYfU Q\\_cdUbYS ]_T%
`
`!&$
`
`1JHLHB@J 1@QDQ HL 9HLDP@J @LC 0MLD 9DR@AMJHQK (&’). ’&!)"-’+($’+*
`
`

`
`#"(’ &-)40)*2/2,6
`
`e\Qd_bc _V dXU 7Q*#%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Y^dUbQSd gYdXY^ _fUb\Q‘‘Y^W Red ^_d YTU^%
`dYSQ\ RY^TY^W cYdUc Y^ dXU dbQ^c]U]RbQ^U T_]QY^& ? 6Y_\ 7XU]
`*((,3*/1!)0"2)011(%/&
`*+& @_]QRQ =$ @Q[edQ I$ ;e[QWQgQ B& 8YcUQcUc _V dXU ‘QbQdXib_YT W\Q^T Y^
`SXb_^YS [YT^Ui TYcUQcU& 7\Y^ 9h‘ CU‘Xb_\ *())3)-!."2/1/%0(1&
`*,& 8blU[U I6$ GYdj 9& IbUQd]U^d _V cUS_^TQbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc] Y^ 7@8
`‘QdYU^dc gYdX SY^QSQ\SUd Q^T’_b fYdQ]Y^ 8 TUbYfQdYfUc& 7\Y^ ? 5] H_S CU‘Xb_\
`*((13,!)"2*+,%,)&
`*-& HY\fUbRUbW H?$ GeRY^ BG$ ;QY]Q^ 7$ Ud Q\& 7Y^QSQ\SUd XiTb_SX\_bYTU bUTeSUc
`dXU cUbe] SQ\SYe] S_^SU^dbQdY_^ Y^ Y^_‘UbQR\U ‘QbQdXib_YT SQbSY^_]Q& ? 7\Y^
`9^T_SbY^_\ BUdQR *((/31*!)("2+0(+%0&
`*.& EUQS_S[ B$ 6_\_W^UcU B5$ 6_b_Vc[i B$ Ud Q\& 7Y^QSQ\SUd dbUQd]U^d _V ‘bY%
`]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]2 RY_SXU]YSQ\ Q^T R_^U TU^cYd_]UdbYS _edS_]Uc
`Y^ Q VYfU%iUQb cdeTi& ? 7\Y^ 9^T_SbY^_\ BUdQR *((131,!)*"2,0.(%/&
`*/& EUQS_S[ B$ 6Y\UjY[YQ^ ?E$ 6_\_W^UcU B5$ Ud Q\& 7Y^QSQ\SUd =7\ bUTeSUc Xi%
`‘UbSQ\SU]YQ Y^ ‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc] QSb_cc Q gYTU c‘USdbe] _V TYc%
`UQcU cUfUbYdi& ? 7\Y^ 9^T_SbY^_\ BUdQR *())31.!)"291%)0&
`*0& ;Q\SXUddY 5$ 7Y\_ddY 5$ KQWWU\\Y A$ Ud Q\& 5 ‘QdYU^d gYdX B9C)%Qcc_SYQdUT Xi%
`‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]$ bUc‘_^cYfU d_ SY^QSQ\SUd& CQd 7\Y^ EbQSd 9^T_SbY^_\ BUdQR
`*((03,2+-)%/&
`*1& B_iUc K?$ B_^c_^ ?E$ 7XUg HA$ Ud Q\& 7\Y^YSQ\ ecU _V SY^QSQ\SUd Y^ B9C)
`X‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]& >^d ? 9^T_SbY^_\ *()(& T_Y2)(&))--’*()(’1(.).+&
`+(& ;Y\_‘Q^dY B$ KUbWQ J$ 9b]UdYSY ;$ Ud Q\& B9C)%bU\QdUT Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]2
`bUc‘_^cU d_ SY^QSQ\SUd Q^T Ydc bU\QdY_^cXY‘ gYdX dXU SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b
`WU^U fQbYQ^d 5bW11(<\i& 9eb ? 9^T_SbY^_\ *()*3)./!*"2)-/%.,&
`+)& NQ]QeSXY B$ HeWY]_d_ I$ NQ]QWeSXY I$ Ud Q\& 5cc_SYQdY_^ _V ‘_\i]_b‘XYS
`Q\\U\Uc _V dXU SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b WU^U gYdX dXU S\Y^YSQ\ cUfUbYdi _V ‘bY%
`]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]& 7\Y^ 9^T_SbY^_\ *(()3--2+/+%+/1&
`+*& 7_bRUddQ H$ 9\\Ub%KQY^YSXUb 7$ ;Y\_‘Q^dY B$ Ud Q\& G11(< ‘_\i]_b‘XYc] _V
`dXU SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Q^T bU^Q\ SQ\SYe] UhSbUdY_^ Y^ ‘QdYU^dc gYdX
`‘bY]Qbi Xi‘Ub‘QbQdXib_YTYc]& 9eb ? 9^T_SbY^_\ *((.3)--2.0/%1*&
`++& G_dXU =B$ HXQ‘Yb_ L6$ He^ LN$ Ud Q\& 7Q\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_bWU^U ‘_\i%
`
`]_b‘XYc] G11(< Q^T Ydc ‘_ccYR\U UVVUSd _^ bUc‘_^cU d_ 7Y^QSQ\SUd =7\&
`EXQb]QS_WU^UdYSc Q^T <U^_]YSc *((-3)-2*1%+,&
`+,& IUbbQ^UWbQ 5$ ;UbbQbUdd_ 5$ 8_W\Y_ddY 9$ Ud Q\& 7Q\SY]Y]UdYS G%-.0 UVVUSdc _^
`QSdYfYdi _V G11(< ‘_\i]_b‘XYc] _V SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b& ? B_\ 9^T_SbY^_\
`*()(3,-!,"2*,-%-.&
`+-& IY]]Ubc =?$ @Qb‘UbYU^ B$ =Q]Ti C5$ Ud Q\& C_b]Q\YjQdY_^ _V cUbe] SQ\%
`SYe] Ri SY^QSQ\SUd Y^ Q ‘QdYU^d gYdX Xi‘UbSQ\SQU]YQ TeU d_ Q TU ^_f_ Y^%
`QSdYfQdY^W ]edQdY_^ _V
`dXU SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b& ? >^dUb^ BUT
`*((.3*.(!*"2)//%0*&
`+.& 6b_g^ 9B& 7\Y^YSQ\ edY\Ydi _V SQ\SY]Y]UdYSc dQbWUdY^W dXU UhdbQSU\\e\Qb SQ\SY%
`e]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b !7QHG"& 6Y_SXU] EXQb]QS_\ *()(30(!+"2*1/%+(/& GU%
`fYUg&
`+/& =Q^ HA$ LQ^ HA& 9VVUSd _V dUbY‘QbQdYTU _^ R_^U ]Y^UbQ\ TU^cYdi Q^T VbQS%
`debU Y^ ‘_cd]U^_‘QecQ\ _cdU_‘_b_cYc2 ]UdQ%Q^Q\icYc _V bQ^T_]YcUT S_^%
`db_\\UT dbYQ\c& >^d ? 7\Y^ EbQSd *()*3..!*"2)11%*(1& GUfYUg&
`+0& CU]UdX 9;& IXU cUQbSX V_b SQ\SYe] bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycdc !SQ\SY\idYSc"&? B_\
`9^T_SbY^_\ *((*3*12)-%*)&
`+1& CU]UdX 9;$ 8U\]Qb 9<$ =UQd_^ LA$ Ud Q\& 7Q\SY\idYS S_]‘_e^Tc2 ‘_dU^d
`Q^T cU\USdYfU 7Q*# bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycdc dXQd cdY]e\QdU cUSbUdY_^ _V
`‘QbQdXib_YT X_b]_^U& ? EXQb]QS_\ 9h‘ IXUb *(()3*112+*+%++)&
`,(& @e]Qb H$ BQdXU^i 7?$ =_VV]Q^ H?$ Ud Q\& 5^ _bQ\\i QSdYfU SQ\SYe]%cU^c%
`Y^W bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycd dXQd dbQ^cYU^d\i Y^SbUQcUc ‘\Qc]Q S_^SU^dbQdY_^c _V
`EI= Q^T cdY]e\QdUc R_^U V_b]QdY_^& 6_^U *()(3,.2-+,%-,*&
`,)& 5bUi 6?$ HUUdXQ\Q G$ BQ O$ Ud Q\& 5 ^_fU\ SQ\SYe]%cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycd
`dbQ^cYU^d\i cdY]e\QdUc ‘QbQdXib_YT X_b]_^U cUSbUdY_^ Y^ fYf_&9^T_SbY^_\_%
`Wi *((-3),.2*()-%*(**&
`,*& ;Ydj‘QdbYS[ A5$ 8QRb_gc[Y 79$ 7YSS_^UddY <$ Ud Q\& G_^QSQ\UbUd$ Q SQ\SYe]%
`cU^cY^W bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycd$ Y^SbUQcUc dbQRUSe\Qb Red ^_d S_bdYSQ\ R_^U Y^
`‘_cd]U^_‘QecQ\ g_]U^& ? 6_^U BY^Ub GUc *()*3*/!*"2*--%.*&
`,+& @e]Qb H$ BQdXU^i 7?$ =_VV]Q^ H?$ Ud Q\& 5^ _bQ\\i QSdYfU SQ\SYe]%cU^c%
`Y^W bUSU‘d_b Q^dQW_^Ycd dXQd dbQ^cYU^d\i Y^SbUQcUc ‘\Qc]Q S_^SU^dbQdY_^c _V
`EI= Q^T cdY]e\QdUc R_^U V_b]QdY_^& 6_^U *()(3,.2-+,%-,*&
`
`1JHLHB@J 1@QDQ HL 9HLDP@J @LC 0MLD 9DR@AMJHQK (&’). ’&!)"- ’+($’+*
`
`!&%

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket