`Page 1
`
`WARSAW2022
`NuVasive, Inc. v. Warsaw Orthopedic, Inc.
`Case IPR2013-00208
`
`

`

`(1-1...
`L“,
`, h “A I" I A ‘6 u—
`I
`'
`Dezrder imre - yon uuentrai: ne .6. ue"s u “s uul
`
`I
`
`1
`s-A . [minimums for naming [Wu
`2
`“”9"“ fl” ”mm“
`5-3
`Invoice fior implmt blocking
`3
`instalments dated 1042-94
`4 w.
`Cervical milling set
`,
`.
`5
`6-3 semi:$12032“, MINE,
`6
`6
`.
`.
`.
`‘
`-,
`'C ufi;§°jéfi’f§§"‘“‘ “M7
`8
`6-D 53313353?“ milling,
`9
`
`7
`
`7
`
`7
`
`Page 5
`
`
`
`1—“36 'r'
`
`
`
`1
`2
`3
`4
`5
`6
`7
`a
`9
`
`Friday. Ouubei 5. 2001. Fresno.Qliroruiu
`mot m. - 1:35 p.ln.
`4300.,
`.
`(Whereupm Exhibits 1 through 11
`were mllkld for idenfifimlion.)
`-oOo—
`,
`VIDEOGRAPEBR: Here begins Videotape No. 1 in the
`deposition of Dezide: Inn: in the mm of Medmmic
`Sofamor Dunk, lira, :1 IL, plaintiffs, vusus Osteotcch,
`
`I
`
`9-A
`n
`r-
`lO-A
`10—3
`
`7
`
`7
`
`7
`
`7
`
`I
`
`I
`I
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`10
`Inc.. detendlim, in me United sum District Court for
`10
`“"3
`“EDA/$351333“! ““87
`
`1;
`the Western District of Tennessee, Western Division, Civil
`11
`7-1;
`PLIF distractm instrumentation
`
`I “
`File. No.99-71556-6V.
`12
`'“ d,
`13
`Team am in Omaha siii Ind the time is 10:01
`13
`A
`,
`, ,
`,
`.
`’
`Disc space instrumentation
`a-A
`’
`_
`,
`_
`R.“
`mump- fur run.- (mum
`I
`14
`em. This deposition is being NW!) at the Marriott
`14
`15
`CourtyudAirport in Fresno. Califomln, and II was made
`15
`im
`ittatinn dated 104037
`16
`at the request ofDixk 1).an at the 11w Offices of
`16
`lumbar instruments with saw
`d
`,,
`,
`, A
`, ,
`,
`,
`_
`,,
`r.....i-. 1.. I....L... ..m. Amman:
`17
`Robin, Klplan 8: Miller. :1 ai.. Washington Dc The
`17
`"a e
`7
`rue
`he , U M
`wvvlw nu Ina-nun uvu-uuvuuvu
`19
`Deposition Servims located at 6222 Wilnliirc Boulevard,
`19
`Comet cleaner
`7
`18
`Vt oyap t is
`an:
`eye! here on helm! atWe
`115
`inst w dated 10-28-97
`7
`20
`i
`-
`Invoice for ALIF Limbar
`Second Floor. Las Angeles. California.
`20
`mi
`.
`a Pam": wed
`21
`Wauld Ill con-cl please idmtify themselves and
`21
`11-17-
`7
`21
`1 l-A Cervical milling machine
`state wharii you nyreseni‘l
`22
`twin w". mmm
`'
`.
`E
`SULLIVAN: Christ
`1143
`Invoice for
`‘cal
`23
`MR.
`cipher P Sullivan. immey
`
`
`M
`milling machine/twin wheel
`24
`for the plaintiff. Medtmiiic Sofamnr Duck.
`
`“3‘” “‘13‘97
`7
`3
`MR. THOMAS: 1m nouns also hucfonhe
`
`I
`
`I
`I
`I
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`1
`1 LC invoice for Lumbar disc
`1
`Fillmifi‘s-
`space shaper dated 8-12-98
`2
`MR YOUNG: Chrimphci Young appearing on bemir
`7
`I
`I
`I
`3
`cfasieom. Inc.,1he defendant.
`I
`5
`'vmmmh'fi'fi; Wfiiifi the wuli reporterpins:
`I
`5 m"mwitness?
`I
`I
`6
`W
`I
`7 DEZEERL‘JRE,
`I
`3
`Being rim auiy sworn by the
`I
`I
`9
`Certifiedsun-1mm Reporter,
`I
`1’.)
`teafied a: fella-:5:
`it
`4200-
`12
`MR. SULLIVAN: Before we begin the questioning,
`13 wewant ta desiyiaie this depositinn at the highesi level
`14
`of wnfidemixllty pursuant ID the wnfidentillily order
`is ‘emmdbymcuxmiuiiiis use.
`16
`MR YOUNG: Mutual.
`17
`THE WITNESS: I have I problem hearing.
`‘
`18
`EXAMINATION
`19
`BY MR. SULLIVAN:
`20
`0. lm gningto sycakvety slowly, md ilyuu don‘t
`21
`understand my question. tell —
`22
`A m fining to askyuu.
`23
`0. Youukmemdl‘llreplmiscit‘ Hyouliaveany
`24
`problem wiiii I quminn,eiiiicr my quuiimi or M1. Young's
`’25
`qua-“:65,,r- '15:ask thz: i": be chiiiEd rimil rt: an
`
`12
`13
`
`Vettebra mOdel
`"unflwritteii diagram of
`lumbar implant drawn by
`Dezider litre
`
`37
`
`‘74
`
`-
`
`I
`I
`I
`I
`
`10:03
`
`I
`‘om
`10:03 I
`I
`I
`
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`
`2
`3
`
`4
`5
`5
`7
`3
`10
`11
`12
`13
`14
`:2
`17
`13
`19
`I 20
`$12
`I 1,1
`I
`‘2‘;
`I 25
`
`Esquire Deposition Services
`
`.
`
`2 (Pages 5 to 8)
`
`1-800-441-32576
`
`Page 2
`
`
`Page 2
`
`

`

`Attorneys Eyes Only
`
`--- w, . ..... ..
`, new he”, was,
`A V“ _ M 1.11.: $53.51. ea .1. 1.-.
`and alter 1 said to Dr. Michaelson that was too heavy.
`0. Dr. Michelson told you that was too heavy?
`A. Yes.
`Q. Did he nsk you to make a lighter one?
`A. Yes,eltcr1n1arln thisone.
`Q. What is this piwe here?
`A. This is a hammer.
`0. Om you show us how that works?
`A. Youpot to the vertebra after you put this
`distnoter, you‘re going to hammer in until ilk going in.
`0. law.
`A. New 5
`remover for it, I did.
`0. And it clips on the end? We don't have one here.
`A. We 9'-
`'
`
`the same thing. They are the same. the shoulder is the
`same, you am just put it in.
`
`.1
`#1
`
`10:32
`10:32
`10:32
`10:32
`10.32
`1&32
`10:32
`10:33
`
`MR. YOUNG: 1 wouldjust like to go back. 1
`12
`forgot to inlerpose an objection. I'd hire to object to
`I 13
`the introduction of Exhibit 3-3 to not having been
`I 14
`previously producedto Osteotech in this litigation. and
`15
`I'd move to strike it.
`I 16
`MR. SULLIVAN: You eon have a continuing
`I 17
`objection.
`‘18
`MR. YOUNG: Okay.
`I 19
`BY MR. SULLIVAN:
`20
`0. Lot me show you that, Mr. Inne, which has been
`21
`22 marked rs Exhibit ALA. Let me see if] can gel the rubber
`23
`band off. It's two separate pieces and I'll ask you if
`24
`you can ldentify those? Funt, can we hold them up for
`25
`the camera.
`
`10:30
`
`tot»
`
`I 12
`13
`I 14
`I
`15
`15
`I 17
`18
`I
`19
`
`A. Yes, sir.
`
`
`Q, When you made these for Dr. Michaelson. did you
`
`
`give him an invoice?
`
`
`A. Always, yes.
`
`
`0. Let me show you that which tun bean marked as 4-8
`and ask you iiyou an recognize that document? Is that
`
`
`
`
`
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`
`I 2:.
`
`0. DidVet.___.
`
`-
`
`.- _..-.—.=m.
`
`A. oh. yes.
`1
`O. This has been muted rs 4-11. lwam to ask you
`2
`whether you can identify — can you tell me what thse
`3
`are?
`4
`A. These are coming from the side.
`5
`
`Q. That'sasiden
`a
`A. The: why the angle.
`7
`Q. The angle on it is to come in from the side?
`8
`A. Right.
`9
`Q. And can you tell me abut these two —
`10
`A. These are the dimmers.
`II.
`Q. Those are distractors. Can you tell me what the
`12
`diflerence between those two diameters are, beuuse they
`13
`look pretty much the same?
`14
`A. It‘s almost. They are :11: same, because the '
`1s
`16 measurement is the same.
`17
`Q. Ohy.
`18
`A. Only this is four times heavier than this one
`19
`because this Is hollow.
`20
`Q. So this one here, what does this weigh in kiloo?
`21
`Do you know howmuch that weight?
`I
`2-
`A. 1 don't know, bu: maybe an be pound, puumi and a
`I 23
`quarter and this one, half, something like thaL I never
`74 measured it.
`
`Page 26
`
`10:31
`1
`your signature on the document?
`10:31 I
`2
`A. Yes, that signature is mine. This is the three
`and this is the distractor.
`I
`3
`Q. The heavier district-1r?
`4
`A No, the Light one.
`10:31 I
`5
`0. Let me show you another document which has been
`10:31 I
`6
`10:31
`7
`marked as Exhibit 5-C and nsit you if you recognize that
`document?
`10:31 I
`8
`A. This I: 24 millimeter. yes.
`10:31 I
`9
`Q.
`'r'v'hai is the 24 miiiimeier refer to?
`1&3‘1
`18
`A. Outside diameter.
`10:31
`11
`Q. Outside diameter of these. There's another
`10:31
`12
`number that's right next to that, it snys 42. It says '24
`13
`X 42.“
`'
`.
`14
`15
`16
`17
`18
`19
`20
`I 21
`22
`
`23
`M
`
`l i l i I
`
`10:34
`1034
`10:34
`
`1&35
`
`
`10:35
`10:35
`10:35
`
`10:36
`10:36
`10:36
`
`i l i l
`
`A. 111;: is :11: length of the implant.
`0. On this, an you show what the length 3'!
`A. Like this one is 42 millimeter. This is 44 and
`this is 42, the length.
`Q. Did you make these for —
`A Yes, sir.
`Q. - Dr. Michaelson on or about the time you gave
`him the invoice?
`A Yes.
`Q. So that would have been in December of 1993'!
`11.2
`AArm
`
`10:31
`
`10:31
`10:31
`
`10:32
`
`10:“2
`
`M 25
`
`'7 (Pages 25 to 28)
`
`1-800-441-3376
`
`Page 3
`
` -.5?
`
`0. That Invoice is dated June Bid 1993. L. “Iva:
`1
`the date that you gave the invoice to Dr. Michelson? Do
`2
`you see this data here?
`3
`A. Yeah.
`4
`Q. This writing here. can you identify that?
`S
`A. That is my —
`6
`0. That's your signature?
`, 7
`A. Yes.
`B
`Q. Did you give Dr. Michaelson the bill for this
`9
`10 when you presented him with the work?
`11
`A. Yes, like always.
`
`10:29
`10:29
`10:29
`10:29
`10:29
`10:29
`
`10:30
`
`1
`2
`3
`4
`5
`6
`7
`8
`9
`10
`11
`
`
`Page 3
`
`

`

`Premiere Ave.
`”)1"!
`Ill
`
`Zea
`
`2 ea
`
`ea
`
`ea
`
`. biind inplent + insert
`
`.
`
`inplent ¢24x42 mm with qus
`
`inplenfi driver [24mm]
`outer sleév [6:24 mm] with cap
`
`inner sleev f$21 mm]
`
`drill 9 21 mm with driver
`
`distr=cter {9‘24mm1
`
`distractorj
`
`teethed distractor
`
`10,5hr
`
`3,5hr
`
`2,;hr
`
`1,5hF
`
`2,5hf
`
`4E“wi“9Vi68'6!
`
`. l
`
`M M U)
`
`787,50
`
`262;5o
`
`187,50
`
`112,50
`
`137,50
`
`112,50
`
`.J m‘ \l‘ ‘ on Or
`
`.4 _| N ~ 01 O
`
`
`(Hm
`
`
`
`Page4
`
`
`Page 4
`
`