Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 1 of 141
`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 1 of 141
`
`D-3
`
`D-3
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 2 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`a link selection step that is one of a
`direct link to a server and an indirect
`link to said server through at least one
`of the remainder of said plurality of
`clients,
`
`Network 3000, Communications Users Guide (Feb. 5, 1993) (Network 3000)
`
`To the extent not inherent, it would have been obvious to use data buffers in the manner
`claimed in such a system. See Section V.C supra.
`
`“Buffering failures occur when a node does not have sufficient space to accept a data
`message.” Network 3000 at § 2.6.
`
`“The UP-ACK message is used by the master to inform the slave that it successfully received
`and buffered the message.” Network 3000 at § 3.1.
`
`“Therefore, alarms from the local master and/or one or more slaves may be placed in a single
`communication buffer for transmission to the next level of the network hierarchy.”
`Network 3000 at § 4.1.
`
`“In addition to receiving the TS/NRT message from the Master node, a Slave node will
`request a TS/NRT message following an initial download, or after a power-fail recovery”
`Network 3000 at § 4.5.
`
`“Each slave then uses the procedure described below to construct its NRT which it then
`passes to each of its slaves. Both the NRT global address field and UP/DOWN mask starts off
`as zero (i.e. the network master's global address and UP/DOWN mask are by definition zero).
`As the NRT is distributed each node determines its global address and UP/DOWN mask and
`fills in the appropriate field in the NRT. Therefore the global .address of a node is the
`concatenation of the local addresses of all previous local masters that the NRT has travelled to
`from the network master to that node.” Network 3000 at § 4.5.1.
`
`“Global data messages are those which must pass through at least one master before reaching
`their destination.” Network 3000 at § 3.2.
`
`“Local messages are those which do not have to pass through any nodes to reach their
`destination.” Network 3000 at § 3.2.
`
`
`
`
`-1005-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 3 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`wherein said server process further
`comprising the step of maintaining a
`client link tree having client link
`entries.
`
`
`15. A method as recited in claim 14,
`wherein said server process further
`comprises the steps of:
`
`comparing a selected link from said
`client to said server to a currect client
`link entry in said client link tree; and
`
`updating said client link tree when
`said comparison meets predetermined
`conditions.
`
`
`
`Network 3000, Communications Users Guide (Feb. 5, 1993) (Network 3000)
`
`“Peer to Peer is a mechanism for data transfer between nodes on the Network-3000. Peer to
`Peer uses the Master and Slave modules which should not be confused with the BSAP
`Master/Slave communication scheme. Peer to Peer allows any node to be a Peer to Peer
`Master and/or Slave. The determining factor is the presence or absence of the Peer to Peer
`Master and Slave ACCOL module(s}. A Master module is executed periodically at the
`request of the ACCOL task in which it is present.” Network 3000 at § 4.2.
`
`“The Time Synchronization/Node Routing Table (TS/NRT) combined message enables each
`node in a Network 3000 configuration to know what the topology of the network is, the node's
`unique global address and the current date and time. The TS/NRT emanates from the Network
`Master Device and "trickles" down from level to level until each node on the network has
`received it. There is NO application level acknowledgement to the TS/NRT message.”
`Network 3000 at § 4.5.
`
`“The NRT is created at the Network Master Device using the NETTOP utility program. The
`NRT may be modified at any time when a network configuration change has occurred. Once
`the NRT has been altered the new NRT is distributed to all nodes in the running system.”
`Network 3000 at § 4.5.
`
`
`
`
`It would have been obvious to compares links in a client link tree to links made available
`during operation and update the client link tree accordingly. See Section V.F supra.
`
`
`It would have been obvious to compares links in a client link tree to links made available
`during operation and update the client link tree accordingly. See Section V.F supra.
`
`
`-1006-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 4 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`
`
`16. A method as recited in claim 15,
`wherein said server process further
`comprises steps of:
`
`determining if said client is authentic;
`
`determining if said client is already in
`said client link tree if client is
`determined to be authentic;
`
`deleting said client from said client
`link tree if said client is already in
`said client link tree; and
`
`inserting said client into said client
`link tree if said client is authentic.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Network 3000, Communications Users Guide (Feb. 5, 1993) (Network 3000)
`
`
`
`
`
`It would have been obvious to implement authentication of clients and maintence of a client
`link tree. See Section V.G supra.
`It would have been obvious to implement authentication of clients and maintence of a client
`link tree. See Section V.G supra.
`
`
`It would have been obvious to implement authentication of clients and maintence of a client
`link tree. See Section V.G supra.
`
`It would have been obvious to implement authentication of clients and maintence of a client
`link tree. See Section V.G supra.
`
`
`
`-1007-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 5 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`2. A wireless network system
`comprising:
`
`a server including a server controller
`and a server radio modem,
`
`said server controller implementing a
`server process that includes the
`control of said server radio modem,
`said server process including the
`receipt and transmission of data
`packets via said server radio modem;
`and
`a plurality of clients each including a
`client controller and a client radio
`modem, said client controller
`implementing a client process that
`includes the control of said client
`radio modem, said client process
`including the receipt and transmission
`of data packets via said client radio
`modem,
`wherein said client process of each of
`said clients initiates and selects a
`
`
`
`Exhibit AQ- Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`Claim 1 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 1 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 1 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`Claim 1 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 1 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 1 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 1 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 1 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 1 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 1 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 1 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 1 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 1 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 1 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`
`-1008-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 6 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`radio transmission path to said server
`that is one of a direct link to said
`server and an indirect link to said
`server through at least one the
`remainder of said plurality of clients,
`wherein said server process further
`includes logic that maintains a client
`link tree having client link entries.
`
`3. A wireless network system as
`recited in claim 2, wherein said server
`process further comprises:
`
`
`
`logic that compares a selected link
`from said client to said server to a
`current client link entry in said client
`link tree; and
`
`logic that updates said client link tree
`when said comparison meets
`predetermined conditions.
`
`4. A wireless network system as
`recited in claim 3, wherein said server
`process further comprises:
`
`logic that determines if said client is
`authentic;
`
`
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 1 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`
`-1009-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 7 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`logic that determines if said client is
`already in said client link tree if client
`is determined to be authentic;
`
`
`logic that deletes said client from said
`client link tree if said client is already
`in said client link tree; and
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`
`
`
`-1010-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 8 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`logic that inserts said client in said
`client link tree if said client is
`authentic.
`
`
`6. A wireless network system
`comprising:
`
`
`
`
`server means providing a server
`process including receiving data
`packets via a server wireless
`communication means, sending data
`packets via said wireless
`communication means,
`
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`
`Claim 5 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claims 1 and 5 based on prior art on November 10,
`2010. Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 5 of the
`’062 patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 5 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 5 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 5 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`
`-1011-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 9 of 141
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`
`Claim 5 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 5 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 5 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 5 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 5 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 5 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`communicating with a network, and
`performing housekeeping functions;
`and
`
` a
`
` plurality of client means, each client
`means providing a client process
`including sending and receiving data
`packet via a client wireless
`communication means, maintaining a
`send/receive data buffer in digital
`memory, and
`selecting a link to said server means
`that is one of a direct link to said
`server and an indirect link to said
`server through at least one of the
`remainder of said plurality of client
`means,
`
`wherein said server process further
`comprises a means for maintaining a
`client link tree having client link
`entries.
`
`7. A wireless network system as
`recited in claim 6, wherein said server
`process further comprises:
`
`a means for comparing a selected link
`from said client to said server to a
`current client link entry in said client
`link tree; and
`
`
`
`-1012-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 10 of 141
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
` a
`
` means for updating said client link
`tree when said comparison meets
`predetermined conditions.
`
`8. A wireless network system as
`recited in claim 7, wherein said server
`process further includes:
`
`
`
`
`
`a means for determining if said client
`is authentic;
`
`
`a means for determining if said client
`is already in said client link tree if
`client is determined to be authentic;
`
`
`
`
`-1013-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 11 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`a means for deleting said client from
`said client link tree if said client is
`already in said client link tree; and
`
`
`a means for inserting said client in
`said client link tree if said client is
`authentic.
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`
`
`
`-1014-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 12 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`
`10. A method for providing wireless
`network communication comprising:
`
`
`providing a server implementing a
`server process including receiving
`data packets via r.f. transmission,
`sending data packets via r.f.
`transmission, communicating with a
`network, and performing
`housekeeping functions; and
`
`providing a plurality of clients, each
`client providing a client process
`including sending and receiving data
`packet via r.f transmission,
`maintaining a send/receive data
`buffer in digital memory, and
`
`selecting a transmission path to said
`server via that is one of a direct link
`to said server and an indirect link to
`said server through at least one of the
`remainder of said plurality of clients,
`wherein said server process further
`includes maintaining a client link tree
`
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`
`Claim 9 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 9 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 9 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`Claim 9 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 9 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 9 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 9 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 9 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 9 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 9 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 9 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 9 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`
`-1015-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 13 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`having client link entries.
`
`11. A method as recited in claim 10,
`wherein said server process further
`includes
`comparing a selected link from said
`client to said server to a current client
`link entry in said client link tree; and
`
`updating said client link tree when
`said comparison meets predetermined
`conditions.
`
`
`12. A method as recited in claim 11,
`wherein said server process further
`includes:
`
`determining is said client is authentic;
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`
`
`
`-1016-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 14 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`determining if said client is already in
`said client link tree if client is
`determined to be authentic;
`
`
`deleting said client from said client
`link tree if said client is already in
`said client link tree; and
`
`
`inserting said client in said client link
`tree if said client is authentic.
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`
`
`
`-1017-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 15 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`
`14. A method for providing wireless
`network communication comprising
`the steps of:
`
`
`
`
`a server process including a data
`packet reception step, a data packet
`transmission step, a network
`communication step, and a
`housekeeping step; and
`
`
`a plurality of clients each providing a
`client process including a data
`sending and receiving step, a send
`and receive data buffer maintenance
`step, and
`
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`
`Claim 13 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 13 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 13 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`Claim 13 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 13 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 13 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`Claim 13 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 13 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 13 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`Claim 13 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 13 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 13 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`-1018-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 16 of 141
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`
`Claim 13 of the ‘062 patent included this element. The Board of Patent Appeals and
`Interferences affirmed the rejection of claim 13 based on prior art on November 10, 2010.
`Brownrigg admitted that the prior art include this element by cancelling claim 13 of the ’062
`patent of December 8, 2010.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
` a
`
` link selection step that is one of a
`direct link to a server and an indirect
`link to said server through at least one
`of the remainder of said plurality of
`clients,
`wherein said server process further
`comprising the step of maintaining a
`client link tree having client link
`entries.
`
`15. A method as recited in claim 14,
`wherein said server process further
`comprises the steps of:
`
`comparing a selected link from said
`client to said server to a currect client
`link entry in said client link tree; and
`
`updating said client link tree when
`said comparison meets predetermined
`conditions.
`
`
`16. A method as recited in claim 15,
`wherein said server process further
`comprises steps of:
`
`determining if said client is authentic;
`
`
`
`
`-1019-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 17 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`determining if said client is already in
`said client link tree if client is
`determined to be authentic;
`
`
`deleting said client from said client
`link tree if said client is already in
`said client link tree; and
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`in the art. For example, the book, incorporated herein by reference, Algorithms in SNOBOL
`4, by James F. Gimpel, Bell Telephone Laboratories, John Wiley & Sons, a Wiley
`Interscience Publication, © 1976 by Bell Telephone Labs, Inc., ISBN 0-471-30213-9,
`describes authentication techniques using one-way seeds.” ‘062 patent at 15:18-25.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[t]he addition and removal of nodes from trees are well known to
`those skilled in the art. For example, in the book, incorporated herein by reference, SNOBOL
`4: Techniques and Applications, by Ralph E. Griswald, Department of Computer Science,
`University of Arizona, Prentiss-Hall, Inc., .COPYRGT. 1975, ISBN 0-13-853010-6,
`algorithms for placing and removing clients from trees are discussed.” ‘062 patent at 14:65-
`15:4.
`
`The ‘062 patent admits that “[a]uthentication techniques are well known to those skilled
`
`
`
`-1020-
`
`

`

`Case 1:16-cv-02690-AT Document 121-8 Filed 08/05/16 Page 18 of 141
`
`The ‘062 Patent
`
`inserting said client into said client
`link tree if said client is authentic.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Admitted Prior Art/Estoppel
`
`in the a