Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 1 of 6
`Case 5:18—md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 1 of 6
`
`APPENDIX 1
`APPENDIX 1
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 2 of 6
`
`-
`
`s ru ems
`1\LDERTO l' i &
`MAR l' IL!::S . LU'
`
`VIA E-ma il and l l.S. \ ·l AI L
`n i_c h, 1_!_~1_0Jee~[.arn11 It) pt)rt_cr. cnrn
`) 11 j Ch ;_i,:l .jl~!J;! <..( (' :m1u] lJ J)U rt i.:J'. ~· 1 Ill]
`
`Wesl ey Mon roe
`or Counsel
`Phone/Fax/Text
`Mobile
`E-Mail
`
`818.444.9279
`626.712.0571
`w111onroe@stubbsajdertcn &QIT1
`
`Septembe r 2-l 20 18
`
`Nichol as I I. I .cc
`AR~ OLD & PO lfff<: R KA YE
`SCII OL FR LL
`777 S. Fi gueroa Sin:cL 44th 1:1oor
`[ .u~ :\ngek s, CA 1/IJ( J I 7
`
`M iclwcl i\.. Berta
`ARNOLD & PORT ER l<A YE
`SCIIOL ER LLP
`Th ree I :mba rcadero Center, I 0th Fl oor
`San Francisc-o. CA 94 1 ! 1-4024
`
`Re :
`
`In Re: Persona/Web Tec!,110/ogies, Ill e., et al., Paten t litigation (Case N o:
`S:!8-111d-02834-HLI'): Perso11al 1Veh Tec/1110/ogies- Hero/iu, In c. (5-!8-Cl'-
`001 6:!- BLF)
`
`lk,1r Mr. I. cc and rvlr. 13crl,1:
`
`AL til e Pn.: li111 in.1ry CMC on Seplcm bcr 20, 201 8, Mr. Rcrta Lo ki th e Court th at I k roku is
`considering li li ng a ·'R uic 11 Motion to Dismiss" based on the all ega tio n, " [T]hcrc's li Lerall y not one
`l;1ct th.it's pkadcd in I Pcrsn11a lWcb ' s complain t agai nst I k rnku]."
`
`.1\ s lll l ini ti al 1rn1llcr. PersonalWl'h 's complaint aga inst I !ero ku meets and exceeds the pl eading
`r..::q ui rcmenb or th..: Fed..:: rnl Ru les as wel l as the requ irements set
`f"nrL h hy !qhal/ 'f im111h(r .
`l·\1rthcrmon.:. Pcrsn1 wl Web ·s comp laint agai nst I lcroku does reci te spec i fi e fact s regarding the
`111,111111: r in ,, hi ch its in l'ri11gi11 g wcbsi lc operates. Th e compl aint co 11 tains fo ct s alleg in g each ol' the
`ck111..:11ts ol' at lea st one c laim in each ol'th c fou r asserted patents in su it. While not rcq uircd to def'cat
`a Ruic 12 ll1Ptiun (m s,1t is l~1 Ru ic 11 rcquirc:men ts). the operati ve comp laint docs no t include spec ifi c
`ex amples or index fi les ("\\'..::bpagc base files" in the proposed amended complaint), asset fil es, and
`li11 gcrprints in lJR l's in vulvcd in the described in Cringin g acti vities.
`
`~ on ethcless. in an L' ffo rL to resolve th is issue, and avoid un necessa ry motion practice. thi s
`ld tn pro,·ick s I k ro ku wi th spcci fi e examples of' wcbpagc base fil es. asset li lcs, a11cl fin gerprin ts in
`l lRl's invo l\'l:d in I lcrnku 's in fri nging activity, Slll1l t: or whi ch wi ll be includ ed in the Secon d
`!\111<.:11d1.:d ( \ rn1pb i11 t tha t l'L·rs1 l11 al\Vd1 will be fi ling against I Ieroku. We ask that I lcrok u corrl'ct us
`i r it hd icvL:s we ha\'l' ,my o l' these li1cts incon ect.
`:'\s we have rel'ercncecl in open court, lht:re lrn vc
`h(·cn some Wcbsitc Operators who were sued and Pcrson,i! Wcb subsequentl y dismi ssed based on
`info rnrn ti on they pnw ickd us. We ,ire always willing lo hL·a r what Websit e Opcralors have to sa y,
`p;i nicula rl y il"th ;i t de l't:11danl dis.i grces with l~1cls alk ged .
`
`15260 Venlura OoLlevard, 20"' f oor • Shenr an Oaks. Ca!ifornia 91 403
`o:fice > 81f1444ASOO' lax> L18.44 4.4520
`
`13 16 Jd Sireet Promenade, Suite 107 • Santa Monica. Ca'.ifornia 90401
`office > 310.746.9800 • fax> 310.395.5292
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 3 of 6
`
`Nicholas H. Lee
`Michael A . Berta
`September 24, 20 18
`Page 2
`
`According to the archives at archive.org, by way of example: On December 25, 20 13 , Hcroku
`
`served a webpage base fil e substantially similar to the attached filc 1: Hcroku 2013 base file.html.
`This file was served hy host server "heroku.com''. When this file was served to archive.org on
`December 25, 2013, according to the headers archived by archive.org, it was served with an "etag"
`header with the value " '22f26b42b31065d3a9c4882c440129b6 "'. Our understanding is that this
`ETag was a contcnt-hased identifier of the webpage hase file served by hcroku.com.
`
`This December 25, 20 13 heroku.com webpage base file expressly included references to the
`asset files listed below. According to the archives at archive.org: Each of these asset files was served
`to archive.org on or about December 25, 2013. Copies of these asset files as they are archived by
`archive.org have l)l:en downloaded, some of which were modified by our litigation software
`programming referenced in footnote one and are attached. Each of these asset files was served by
`the host server at "d4yt8xl9b7in.cloudfront .net", with an "etag" header with the ETag value li sted
`below for the corres ponding asset file and with a "server type" header with the value "AmazonSJ".
`For each li sted asset fil e, the value of the "etag'' header served with that asset file is the MD5 hash of
`the contents or that asset file.
`
`According to the archives at archivc.org: This December 25,2013 heroku.com webpage base
`file included references to the asset files "placeholders-de90efD087cad3ac8e589a40312e4f8d.js" and
`"rctina-6aaf485cl 185c 125a62bd793d2c6ad419.js". Each of these asset file s was served to archive.org
`on or about December 25, 20 13 . Copies of these asset files as they are archived by archive.org have
`been downloaded, modified by our litigation software programming referenced in footnote one, and
`are attached. Both of th ese asset files were served by the host server at ''d4yt8xl9b7in.cloudfront.net".
`Both of these asset files were served with a "server type" header with the value "AmazonS3". The
`MD5 hash value of the asset file "placeholdersde90ef0087cad3ae8e589a40312e4f8d.js'' prepended
`with the seed stri ng "2 .2.2production-1.0" is "de90ef0087cad3ae8e589a40312e4f8d". The MD5
`hash value of the asset fi le ''rctina-6aaf485d 185cl 25a62bd793d2c6ad4 l 9.j s" pre pended with the seed
`string ''2.2.2production- l .0" is "6aaf485d I 85c 125a62bd793d2c6ad4 t 9".
`
`According to the archives at archive.org: On December 24, 20 14, Heroku served a webpage
`base file substanti al ly similar to the attached file (see footnote one): Hcroku_2014_base_file.html.
`This file was SL'.rved by host server ''heroku.com". When this fi le was served to archivc .org on
`December 24, 2014, according to the archives at archive.org, it was served with an "etag'' header with
`the value' W/"6c23585e273cd3c7da0a2 l ed28f942 f2'". This file was also served with a "server type''
`header of "Cowboy··. Our understand ing is that this 1-::'l'ag served was a content-based identifier of
`the webpage base file served by heroku.com.
`
`1 By ·'substantially simi lar" we arc referring to the fact that Archivc.org - while a reco rding/preservation service -
`modifies th e webpage base til e in order to re-create the experience of visiting the webpage at the archived time that
`most often appea r insignifi cant to someone with a general interest in see ing what a website looked like at some point in
`the past. Our spec ial ly written lit iga tion software programmi ng has removed as many of these mod ifications as can be
`cleterm ined fro m the mod ified file.
`
`481 1-8959-6005, V 1
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 4 of 6
`
`Nicholas H. Lee
`Michael A. Berta
`September 24, 20 I 8
`Page 3
`
`This December 24, 20 14 heroku.com webpage base file expressly included references to the
`asset files listed below. According to the archives at archive.org: Each of these asset files was served
`to archive.erg on or about December 24, 2014. Copies of these fi le files as they are archived by
`archive .org have been downloaded , some modified by o ur litigation software programming
`refe renced in footnote one and are attached. The asset files "screenshot-macys.png", "screenshot(cid:173)
`scoot.png", and "screenshot-lutron.png'' listed below were served hy the host server at heroku.com,
`with a "server type" header having the value "Cowboy". Each of the remaining asset files listed below
`was served by the host server at "d4yt8xl9b7in.cloudfront.net" and a "server type" header with the
`value "AmazonS3". Each of the listed asset files, whether served from "heroku.com" or
`"d4yt8xl9b7 in.cloudfront.net", was served with an "ctag" header having the ETag value listed below
`for the corresponding nsset fi le. For each listed asset files, the value of the "ctag" header served with
`that asset file is the MD5 hash of the contents of that asset fi le.
`
`These aforementioned examp les Jemonstrate Persona!Web's evidentiary support for the
`factual contentions a ll eged against Heroku in Persona!Web's operative complaint, which wi ll be
`further illuminated in the Second Amended Complaint. These examples support infringement of each
`of the four claims for relief asserted against Heroku.
`
`Again, we welcome comments, questions or disagreements.
`
`Si nn :1'l ly
`
`' / 1/ -----~
`
`, I /
`Wesley Monroe
`
`---
`
`4811-8959-6005, V. 1
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 5 of 6
`
`Nicholas H. Lee
`Michael A. Berta
`September 24, 20 18
`Page 4
`
`Selected 2013 Heroku Asset Files
`
`Name
`appl ication-2bJa070e5e7c_56d08fO I 682bc~cafbd4.js
`build-811 ec90c5592.56bc I c03b40b I 4b3 I 9b2 png
`rol I bar-a~?3 u6a§643acbc589~~c b64c3 h.:16. js
`app l icatiort-2e6213cd5ee8f20f6aJ I 49c0 I 9 I 7d702.css
`aaron-cc770f2 171i:3 I a I lfa I ca97c2t 6d57 13.png
`place hold e rs-de90ef008 7 ca d3a e Be 589a40312 e4f 8d.js
`retina -6aat485d 185c125a62 bd793d2c6ad419 .js
`rva n-48a4f951304b37e5ec52bb 7 807973f99.png
`sca le-e0e96966fd3 945c259 789e2c98898630. png
`rah u 1-61 fl 9 b8f79cb2 ef65044a 69 f07 l0033a. p ng
`code -tor-a me rica-54c b817 d00505598ff3cbfac 73c3e9ef. png
`~thub-ff96a3cca5ba3c650dc46a275c591 7a8 .png
`lyft-0407 4 92 7 cc b6506b0 b ScO 1834c b3 ~ ':~7. png
`logo-537c330ed59a42305b70bfa628 bac079.png
`navba r-togg le-b92a3af0ce 285c32e 25bdbcl 761d5d88. png
`ted-f2a !3dea 85e 10efd6~f5 f09 b6e 19f972 .png __
`m~ lchimp-6acdbe9 faa9e6_2fe~bfb914616c04ff.p_'.1g
`face boo k-49e 7 7 4 Sea3 lc bda 9 599eaf 1a2d52d 2 ba. png
`foo te r-b rand-logo-7 2 660c 80a8d08a e068 7 Sf509 7c5d63f7. png
`bentonsans-boo k- 520df8a5f03b6a45cbf79f2c7e40ebc2.woff
`be nto nsa n s-regu la r-f94699ea b9d b91 71_ba 064c99fe c l aef9. wo ff
`be nto n sans-med i u m-09c le b88a d 32a9ad8a a 3 7 b 19d8358 7 a 9. woff
`
`__ ETag_
`"c278d96f2b7c5066bbb7283bf863a 8d2"
`I "8eba2 104e8114859b336c737 bf6f3dcf"
`
`I "197a8ef8f 3927007c4827fa4f8e8063c"
`
`j7ao b 5f~f3 b 709eac852 lbef8f5775866"
`J "7025c67921a7c4c72d89c4e2b30ea64f"
`"3d314c301dc458 b9cee8blcc9317a1fa"
`"a9a89e3d 141ee304499325 7fc82cb84b"
`-
`-
`"cee4 9fa 3d02 bea 7 261 Bd 6d9 7 4e d 7 3 b4 c"
`- - - - - - - - --·-
`"ea3 187f364287e3f84565463465dfd4a"
`"3a75466b48200d99b13a6e55d47b59a5"
`"41cb3aa3abe841314b5591e4be26b9e b"
`"dff84 8 59e03 26D4e8f9d5cd55e d d bd9e"
`"14ba 28e645e9e01098 bca9 b9fd4.6625f"
`"6 7be5d3f41e42525232769de ffea69d9"
`"ead87c052 b468db46a3850b2986ce6bd"
`"5208787 be6ba 664c7c4663245d53c8c 7"
`"66a 7 c2c128cd 54cce l lc079f98a8241D"
`"e b8b9767cbd5cad614565819d9174f2 7"
`--·-····---
`-
`"cd bOd f77636 3d69 7 df3c28615bd 684 77"
`"cb4d66cf19b9c 2a84 7a296072 bb084b 7"
`"a 310 32 2 9fa 33543d 3 22 525a 5669d3 b2 7"
`-- - -
`-
`"682d fc4bcd67cb85 1fa3dad68f5 64 761"
`-
`--
`
`-
`
`I
`
`4811-8959-6005, V . 1
`
`

`

`__ ETag_
`"30fe53 4 ld257d5fadff150bf0cl4d255"
`"Sla6ea 30c3 bc4698a3436fd9cccb0e68"
`. '.'66e4 68~ 7899e390 1 lda 29e 5e53d 18e4 1"
`"114cec4 00 ld 259 3bdc21b71816bc4276"
`"9a02 8f 2 f d7a0f d80e bd48a49 7 b2 222e2"
`J_ ''_67be5d3~1e42525232769deffea69d9" _
`"ead 8 7c052 b468d b46a385Db2986ce6bd"
`"67Dc7307 f b0a4b28ed de3bf b316d2b7a"
`"4176ecfd794a bf3d285ab5198e61607 4"
`"d59a8D3e523a9936dce863162825a2b3"
`"53a9e37D56389678db0ald5ac9ef5786"
`--~- -- --
`" 35f66ccD599b4aaa lee5177fc9ff9be6"
`- -
`"06e330e482121f62edOf5f8fOad5a2e4"
`- - - -
`" e572475 122d6a0e30 1341a129f52c365"
`- ---
`--
`"4bf92383 b30 7c4d82f75b363 b48aflda"
`_ I "da40d0cf78c2263 18e325c4dfd8aaf4c"
`" 17ee60858 1cce61e972a5 1f9172 66123"
`"b2a la 2a b 7 a05a bf9D68 f5b44 2db4f4 27"
`"29ef8ea25f5bde80070178456ccfd481"
`_"03b39 4db0f45f21ebcf03c0323428~8'~ _
`" le 33 f8 lbe l e 733da4D298d0eaaa022 12"
`
`1
`
`1
`
`1
`
`, hero-backgr ound-grad ienl -da rk-8daa3 36§fea dc42 20ec7 28fb8cae945c.png
`he ro-bac kgro u n d -grad ie nt-l 1gh :-429e 15c8063a418cf 4a 4 2 9d997 2 4e09 f. p ng
`logo-4c063ddlcc4b58'196d0c69b66252a 083.png
`-
`navba r-togg le -3dff32fc3 dcc2088f58 l bdbea b27 l f3f.png
`icon-arrow- right -sm '1 b86ce 55 bd7997be09975344 464fccc7 .png
`d x -logos-dc9 30f9a d09005 7f89 1 fcc0998a~ be Sa. p ng
`dx-metrics-9f d 2f6846e bb40e538a b4ee260,:!a8eaa . png
`dx-dashboa rd-139c6l 7aca 1307a51f2d~05d 7_?- 7fef3.png
`dx-te rm i na 1-c 19644 7 d a 14 9f 5 6 l_Q 7_0fce 386e 54e99d. png
`logo- ma cys-e a8 2319 7 58c4 6f 3d4e 6e 3f 24 ~3 d932 7 2. pn g
`screens hot-ma cys. png
`logo-scoo t -4 2 3 5 be 7 8e9 3 9c0a '2 cf a982 ~3505ecc26. pn_g
`screen_shot-scoot.png
`logo-l u_tron -12d 108b6000196d 530539 27764 2778e5. png
`sc reenshot-lutron . png
`prop-reque sts- b 2 5 3 bd4cf88 d 7 4f cee664 9jJ69c902 9e. png
`prop-apps-c2f84f68ddbaf87l8t1 56756}d5~68c4.png
`prop-ad do ns-b99e83 756e0c64017 d 1 Of l 406ff 55ef 3. png
`logotype -he ro ku- 7e4 5d7bc74 7d430ec27adfd9ec060132.png
`logo-e I lo-6561 a 14a 4 deeOf d 28e9c 7 c3 b620 b9 2 2d. p ng
`f ea ture-dyn os-961a4b3217c84 9f lbf 7efd2df868 db 11. png
`fea ture-data ba se -8f2 0d8 7330b2 316297c 1d5c42897c6b0.png
`fea ture-ad do n s-a9 f8 283 04 7832 bcca 72 .!:_a60f 1489bbde .png
`fea ture- connect-ff0a2 72 f75d98f972ca 164 2b094ae 19a .png
`f ea ture-support-2b5f836 7bef92488becc969ac9a 517 11.png
`footer-bra nd-logo-64fc7d97 a d66 b21448d2_98_274652_5a30 . png
`he ro-bac kgr o u n d-gra die n t-d ark. p ng
`her o-ba<:_ kg ro u n d-g~a die n t -I igh t. p ng
`l bg- logo_s -9107c468b 7cc8 19 lb84b0e 7 34 7?a6398. png
`
`Case 5:18-md-02834-BLF Document 271-1 Filed 10/26/18 Page 6 of 6
`
`Nicholas 1-1. Lee
`Midmel A. Berta
`September 24, 20 ! 8
`Page 5
`
`Selected 2014 lleroku Asset Files
`
`Name
`1
`I appl ica t ion-e 7 la be229ef0 4 7f45 730aca25622e684.css
`1 mo dern iz r -07c66 4 73fb5 b20ff5 6038752 5 768338f.js
`I application -Sf 424d58a 3e 723 13338af07 14a 29 12fa. is
`
`I "Sa62c03e117938Dbd7603b2d44537a69 "
`"32e5682 16f9 Se3 ea26f 50f8fb 7cf5a 2f"
`--
`-
`" ddOaa b9450d37 la4 1 b lb3d5f140dcec2"
`"ad 39d39 5 2387246Db0c4 3a e0f693c 1 Of"
`"3 b59 2c8 7e 68e 79 Sac 1899c01 Oeccced 7"
`----
`--
`" 5 b2 d9 6e 7 c64 b 7 21 f9144c3 b 149 7 e9 6 f8"
`"efa45 5106f9 9a6f28233 90f 18ec0a 7fb "
`-
`"04 759 fe f94 16f a4 254ce f2ec48aea892"
`- ··-··---
`" 1l4cec40D ld 2593bdc2 lb 718 16bc42 76"
`I "9a028f2fd7a0fd8Debd48a497b2222e2"
`I "cb6eec6436642D289249ea4183ea9763"
`! ~ 56.3c63b87a91f677286df8f75969821"
`, "ea fOflcd2 290f7 315dd7 lf34b30ca5 dc"
`1 ·,;6dd 7a98456e98e90d 2d7 a 779485ede 73 .~
`;'cb4d66cf 19 b9c2a84 7a296072bb084b 7"
`"68 2 dfc4 bcd6 7 cb8 51 fa 3 da d 68f 564 761"
`"a 31032 2 9fa 33543d 3225 25a 5669d 3b2 7"
`"36455667726069aa32b8449bcl b10caa" .J
`
`I
`
`· ico n-arrow-right-1Db799c01 ec 4 b8d09Db0b2 2a6415 bl50.p ng
`quote open-I! le79 af63 a006b52a9a 39538971b990Lpng
`quote close-734acc 4 fb287b6b555840 bd 199b0c9a4. png
`be ntonsa ns- book-ad'11cd lea 1933084 759a35Seecdecee 7 .woff
`bento nsa ns-mediu rn -8cd4d6626b02fea 13e93cf9bf 109809a. woff
`bentonsans-regu la r -deca 32c616 f 3c2De88a9 75 7e lec9a b66. watt
`favicon-0565443fb43bbaacd5b7455e389384a0 .ico
`
`Enclosure(s): USB drive by U.S . Mail
`Atlacl1ed file s by E-mail
`
`4811-8959-6005 , V 1
`
`