llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
`
`1 0-08-1999
`UISI Patent & TMOfc/TM Mall fiwt D1. #40
`
`_g
`'1‘;
`US. Express Mail Label No. .EL450973107US
`i hereby certify that mis paper is being deposited with the United States Postal Service "Express Mail Post (3,ffie_e to Addressee'$.;"CD
`service under 37 CFR 1.10 on October 8, 1999 and is addressed to the Assistant Commissioner of TrademarKs_, 2900’gystaI
`D '
`Arlington, \firginia 22202-3513.
`ffi
`‘'4
`
`«V Dctobers 1999
`(Date)
`
`Applicants: E1Encanto, Inc.
`
`Trademark Law Office: 011
`
`Serial No.2 75/590,297
`
`Filed: Nov. 17, 1998
`
`Mark: BUENO
`
`Trademark
`Attorney: J.A.Holland-Chapman
`
`'
`
`Int. Class 029
`
`RESPONSE TO ACTION NO. 1
`
`Box: RESPONSES - NO FEE
`
`Assistant Commissioner for Trademarks
`2900 Crystal Drive
`Arlington, Virginia 22202-3 513
`
`This is in response to Action No. 1 dated April 9,1999.
`
`AMENDED RECITATION OF GOODS
`
`Please amend the recitation ofgoods as suggested by the Examiner, with changes noted
`
`(underline for additions):
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`Vlwfl
`«/
`\/
`£/Dry shreddedymp, whole shrimp, cracked sweet processed corn,
`
`\
`
`dehydrated sweet corn, dehydrated red chile pods, lentils, processed green
`
`chile, whole green stuffed chile rellenos, processed [edible] corn husk; frozen
`
`red chile puree, vegetable stew with chicken or beef, frozen jalapeno peppers,
`
`roasted jalapeno peppers, garlic, namely whole and dehydrated garlic, habas,
`
`namely dried beans, processed edible anise seed, and peppers, namely whole
`
`dehydrated peppers [SEE COMMENTS BELOW] in International Class
`
`029. :[
`
`MISCLASSIFICATION OF GOODS
`
`The recitation of goods was amended as suggested by the Examiner. The amended
`
`application includes the following additional goods which we request be transferred to this
`
`Application as follows: "habas, namely dried beans," which was filed in Application
`
`SN 75/590,292; and "processed edible anise seed," "garlic, namely whole and dehydrated garlic,"
`
`and "peppers, namely whole dehydrated peppers," which were filed (with amendments noted
`
`below) in Application SN 75/590,291. The 291, and '292 Applications were submitted on the
`
`same day as this Application.
`
`The Applicant originally filed "garlic (whole, granulated and powder)" in Application
`
`SN 75/590,291 (Int. Class 030). The Examiner suggested that the description be amended to
`
`"minced garlic and powdered garlic" in International Class 03 0, and "fresh garlic" in International
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`Class 031. However, the Whole garlic marketed by the Applicant is not fresh garlic, but
`
`dehydrated garlic cloves. Therefore, Applicant requests that "garlic, namely whole and
`
`dehydrated garlic," be transferred to the SN 75/590,297 Application.
`
`The Applicant originally filed "piquin (small, thin pungent peppers, whole and crushed)" in
`
`Application SN 75/590,291 (Int. Class 030). The Examiner suggested that the description be
`
`amended to "whole small thin peppers" in International Class 029, and "dried crushed small thin
`
`peppers" in International Class 030. Therefore, Applicant requests that "peppers, namely whole
`
`dehydrated peppers" be transferred to the SN 75/590,297 Application.
`
`The Examiner suggested that Applicant classify the following goods in International
`
`Class 030/gxln accordance with the Examiner's suggestion, Applicant requests that these goods be
`
`transferred to Application SN 75/590,291 in International Class 030 filed on the same date of this
`
`Application]
`
`burritos
`
`sausage and egg burritos
`
`dried jalapeno peppers for use as seasoning
`
`rolled enchiladas
`
`rolled tacos
`
`tamales
`
`hominy with smaller portions of other ingredients, namely cooked corn
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`\/I‘heExaminer requested a translation ofthe termBUENO. The termBUENO translates / P7224
`
`to "good" in English.
`
`/l
`
`OWNERS OF PRIOR REGISTRATIONS
`
`The Examiner requested a statement of ownership registrations. Applicant is the owner of
`
`U.S. Registrations 1,533,311, 1,553,045, 1,874,071, 2,190,265, 2,209,480, 2,167,011,
`
`2,234,721, 2,263,393,§2ind.other pending applications 75/590,291, 75/590,292, 75/590,293, and
`5.
`
`75/590,296.
`
`’
`
`LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION REJECTION
`
`The Examiner has refiised registration under Trademark Act Section 2(d), 15 U.S.C.
`
`Section 1052(d) and TMEP 1207, likelihood of confusion, based on U.S. Registration Nos.
`
`1,513,748 and 1,336,168. These two registrations are owned by Calavo Growers of California
`
`("Calavo Growers") for "Frozen fruits, namely frozen avocados and guacamole" and for "Fresh
`
`fruits, namely avocados."
`
`A likelihood of confusion does not exist between the products sold by Applicant, El
`
`Encanto, Inc. ("El Encanto"), and the avocado products sold by Calavo Growers because:
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`1) Calavo Growers does not use the term "Bueno" at all on products that compete with El
`
`Encanto's products; 2) When Calavo Growers does use the use the term "Bueno", the use is
`
`merely descriptive and is not used to identify the product's source of origin; 3) The sole product
`
`manufactured by Calavo Growers with the term "Bueno" (which as stated above is used
`
`descriptively, and is a non—trademark use) is sold as a grade No. 2 food product, and El Encanto
`
`does not sell grade No. 2 food products; and 4) In Applicant's forty—eight (48) years of selling
`
`products under the BUENO mark, there has never been a single instance of actual confiision
`
`between any Calavo Growers products and E1Encanto's products (See Declaration of Jacqueline
`
`Baca, President of E1 Encanto). These points are discussed below.
`
`The mere fact that the marks share elements, even dominant elements, does not compel a
`
`conclusion of likelihood of confusion. General Mills v. Kellogg C0,, 824 F.2d 622, 627 (8"‘ Cir.
`
`1987). The proper test is the overall commercial impression of the marks, as consumers review
`
`and rely upon them in regards to both source of origin and to a known degree of quality. §
`
`Uno v. Temple, 747 F.2d 1522 (4“‘ Cir. 1984).
`
`With regard to Calavo Grower's use of the term "Bueno" there is no commercial
`
`impression because Calavo Growers does not use the term "Bueno" to identify its avocado
`
`products in commerce. As demonstrated by the photocopies of the container labels and the fifteen
`
`(15) Internet pages (enclosed), Calavo Growers uses the trademark CALAVO®, rather than
`
`BUENO, to identify its avocado and guacamole products.
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`A protectable trademark is established when a mark is adopted and used to identify a
`
`product. C.L.A.S.S. Promotions, Inc. v. DS. Magazines, Inc., 753 F.2d 14, 16 (2"d Cir. 1985).
`
`Applicant has found only one instance in which Calavo Growers does use the term "Bueno" on a
`
`container label for guacamole. However, Calavo Growers does not use the term "Bueno" as a
`
`trademark to identify the source of the product. Rather, Calavo Growers uses the term "Bueno"
`
`as a mere descriptive word in combination with the other descriptive words, namely "frozen
`
`fresh", to describe the characteristics of the food product. The public does not associate the term
`
`"Bueno" with the source of the product, but merely as it is used, i.e., as a descriptive term.
`
`The last page of the enclosed Internet pages demonstrates how Calavo Growers uses the
`
`term "Bueno." Calavo Growers use the term "Bueno" or "Buenoa" to describe a specific grade,
`
`namely No. 2 grade, of avocado or guacamole product. Thus, the term "Bueno" is used as a
`
`descriptive term and not as a trademark. El Encanto does not make, nor plan to make, a No. 2
`
`grade food product. This helps explain why, in 48 years, there has never been a single instance of
`
`actual confusion between the Calavo Growers and El Encanto products. As such, El Encanto is
`
`willing to limit its description of goods to grade No. 1 food products, if required by the Examiner.
`
`Instead, it is apparent that Calavo Growers has made the conscious choice to identify its
`
`food products by use of the mark CALAVO®, and no longer (we question if ever) uses the term
`
`"Bueno" as an indication of source of origin. Highlighted in the Internet pages are specific
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Oflice
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`examples demonstrating how Calavo Growers markets its products to wholesale and retail
`
`consumers.
`
`"you can always count on Calavo .
`
`.
`
`.
`
`. Just ask your local grocer or restaurant for
`
`Calavo "
`
`"Calavo offers several varieties of avocados"
`
`"Calavo's Line of Premium Guacomole"
`
`"Take a look at the different types of Calavo guacamole available at your local
`
`grocery store. .
`
`.
`
`. Look for these in the freezer section at your local grocery
`
`store."
`
`The consumer certainly does not look for the term "Bueno" to identify Calavo Growers products
`
`at the local grocery store, because the term is not printed on any label or container of food
`
`product. Also, the term "Bueno" is not used at all in Calavo Growers's Spring 1999 newsletter to
`
`its customers.
`
`In the one label that Calavo Growers does use the term "Bueno", the first and largest
`
`word, CALAVO®, along with the word "AVOCADO," exercise a visual dominance over the
`
`trailing lower case word "Bueno". The word "Bueno" is in the same font and size as the word
`
`"Guacamole." Such use only indicates to the public a specific standard quality of guacamole is in
`
`the can, and not guacamole of a specific known origin. Instead, the mark CALAVO
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`GROWERS® dominates the label. CALAVO® is present on the label in much larger font size
`
`and identifies the guacamole with Calavo Growers.
`
`In contrast, El Encanto, Inc. uses the mark BUENO to designate the origin of its prepared
`
`food products. The mark BUENO is prominently displayed on labels and product containers. El
`
`Encanto has used the mark BUENO in commerce for over forty-eight (48) years as an indicator
`
`of its hundreds of food products. E1Encanto's annual sales and distribution of food products in
`
`the United States and internationally total approximately $18,000,000. The annual marketing
`
`budget, including advertising of El Encanto, is approximately 3-6% of gross annual sales, or
`
`approximately $540,000 to $1,080,000. The BUENO Mark is advertised in television and radio
`
`commercials, on billboards, in El Encanto's Internet website, newspaper inserts, and coupons.
`
`Also, the BUENO Mark is co-op advertised by McDonalds, Pizza-Hut, and Subway Sandwiches,
`
`along with numerous other companies.
`
`El Encanto is one of the largest Hispanic-owned businesses in the United States, and is
`
`one of the largest (perhaps the largest) distributor of Southwestem-style foods in the United
`
`States. Please see the attached Declaration and Exhibits in support of the above facts.
`
`

`
`Trademark Law Office
`
`Ser. No. 75/590,297
`Mark: BUENO
`
`It is submitted that the present application is in condition for publication and registration,
`
`and such action is requested.
`
`Dated: October 8, 1999
`
`\ Deborah A. Peacock
`Reg. No. 31,649
`
`Attorneys for Applicant
`PEACOCK, MYERS & ADAMS, P.C.
`PO. Box 26927
`
`Albuquerque, New Mexico 87 125-6927
`Telephone: (505) 998-1500, Direct Line (505) 998-1501
`Facsimile: (505) 243-2542
`File: 30642-1001
`E‘: \Mike\trademark\Bueno\OA_2 97 . doc
`
`

`
`TRADEMARK APPLICATION
`
`U.S. Express Mail Label No. EL450973107US
`I hereby certify that this correspondence is being deposited with the United
`States Postal Service 8$ fFfiil in an envelope addressed to: Assistant Commissioner
`for Tr
`emarks, 2900 Crystal Drive, Arlington, VA. 22202-3513 on October 8 , 1999.
`71/n,¢,ZK,
`.
`October
`8 , 1999
`Date
`_
`Deborah A. Peacock, Reg. No. 31,649
`Annette M. Turk, Legal Ass1stant
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`Applicants: El Encanto, Inc.
`
`Trademark Law Office: 011
`
`Serial No.: 75/590,297
`
`Filed: Nov. 17, 1998
`
`Mark: BUENO
`
`Trademark Attorney :
`Jan A. Holland-Chatman
`
`'
`
`Int. Class 029
`
`.\/' DECLARATION
`
`Assistant Commissioner for Trademarks
`
`2900 Crystal Drive
`Arlington, Virginia 22202-3513
`
`I, Jacqueline Baca, declare:
`
`That I am President of El Encanto, Inc. ("El Encanto"), applicant corporation, and I am
`
`authorized to make this declaration on behalf of said corporation;
`
`I verify that:
`
`1) El Encanto has used the Mark BUENO in commerce for over forty—eight (48) years as
`
`an indicator of its food products and services. El Encanto‘s annual sales and distribution of food
`
`products in the United States and internationally total approximately $18,000,000. The annual
`
`marketing budget, including advertising of El Encanto, is approximately 3—6% of gross annual
`
`sales, or approximately $540,000 to $1,080,000. The BUENO Mark is advertised in television
`
`

`
`and radio commercials, on billboards, in El Encanto's Internet website, newspaper inserts, and
`
`coupons. Also, the BUENO Mark is co-op advertised by McDonalds, Pizza—Hut, and Subway
`
`Sandwiches, along with numerous other companies.
`
`2) To my knowledge there has never been a single incident of actual confusion between
`
`the food products marketed by El Encanto and the products marketed by Calavo Growers, Inc.
`
`3) To my knowledge all food products marketed by Calavo Growers, Inc. that compete
`
`with El Encanto do not have the BUENO Mark on the label or packaging.
`
`4) To my knowledge the only food product that Calavo Growers, Inc. markets with the
`
`g term "Bueno" on the label or packaging is No. 2 grade guacamole (see enclosed Internet pages).
`
`E1 Encanto does not make, sell, or distribute a No. 2 grade food product.
`
`I declare further that all statements made herein are true and that these statements were
`
`made with the knowledge that willful false statements and the like are punishable by fine or
`
`imprisonment, or both under Section 1001 of Title 18 of the United States Code and that such
`
`willful false statements may jeopardize the validity of this document and any registration
`
`resulting therefrom.
`
`El Encanto, Inc.
`
`F: \Mi ke\trademark\Bueno\baca_dec]._LC_2 97 . doc
`
`

`
`‘ Calavo Information for Consu
`
`Page 1 of!
`
`.,.,,....,.-.,,,.,..;;-,:~.. nsuln
`
`gonsumers
`
`~. 3313!! Buyers
`*
`
`F
`
`I
`d
`0-0 Se" Ce
`
`‘boutns
`
`Gtowersv »
`
`A,
`
`Th-15
`Section
`
`g
`
`V
`
`'
`
`-
`
`j'
`~ '
`
`'
`
`Since 1924 Calavo has been
`"The First Name in Avocados."
`
`Pwducts
`Ayocado. Recipes
`Fun Sniff
`.
`ggggmghouse
`
`~
`
`Gfuestbook
`A
`_
`
`A
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`.
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`‘ll
`
`_ ~
`~
`'
`’:
`,
`
`f_
`
`~
`
`"
`
`*
`
`,
`
`L
`
`'.
`
`V
`
`,
`
`(
`
`'
`
`I
`
`a company run by growers, for growers.
`._ With ‘more than 1,600 growers in prime
`V. growing regions throughout California and
`-u
`the world, §‘/‘t75’t1i‘:'c"an‘a|wa‘ys~count on C-aiat/o
`’
`31333;‘ for the finest avocados, guacamole and
`papayas. J1:i'st‘a‘sk"your |oica1I>'-g’roce‘r‘;or~‘~
`_,
`restau-ran~t for Calavofi
`
`Be sure to look for pro_q_uct__i,n_fo,rm,ation, recipes, nutrition,
`games and contests in this web site.
`
`H ‘I".Topics of interest ,
`
`.
`
`V’
`
`"
`
`M 0 th e..r....l}J.a...t.ur.e's . C.o..m.fo.r.t. food
`
`Technology That Bl_9w.s....E.e_st$.. Away
`
`Uruapan, Mexico Pac.kin..g._hou.s.e Qpene.d.i..n .1998
`
`Consumers - Retaii_8uyers - Fo_od_s_er_vice - Growers v About__Us v Guestbook o Site__$e_a_rch
`
`( Calafo.)uuunu
`
`The First Name in A:-'oc:ulus~
`
`imp: C'.i]'.1\'0.C0li1 consuzncrs
`
`-1 3‘) W
`
`

`
`Avocados, Guacamole and Pa
`
`as from Calavo
`
`Page I of 1
`
`rbexvalrmv.-....;.,;.m.:..~t
`
`V
`
`l
`
`gonsumers
`~»aa
`
`n
`*
`'
`Jzetan Buyers ‘
`'
`'
`"
`
`F
`
`I,
`at
`°° 5"" °°
`
`V
`
`1;
`A ‘“'°"‘ '4.‘
`Growers,’
`
`A¥.0..G.3..d.9..S..
`Papayas
`
`VA-V°cad° Recipes
`Fun Stuff
`
`Avocados: e.C{a?la'vo -offersseveral varieties of avocados‘
`year-round. Here you can find information about
`seasonality, ripening, nutrition and more.
`
`04,,
`
`‘ -.. 3-,‘ ,
`
`‘
`
`Guacamole: Want the taste of homemade guacamole,
`but don't have time to make it from scratch? Check out our
`complete line of premium guacamole products.
`
`Ea Qayas: G§:aKlaMo'offerstseveral varieties- of papayasr
`year-round. Here you can find information about
`seasonality, ripening, nutrition and more.
`
`Consumers - Retail Buyers - Foodservice - Growers - About Us - Guestbook - Site Search
`
`( Calaio. )uuuuu
`
`The first Name in AI-'0C.'tdD3"‘
`
`lmp: C‘.llL1\'O.COm consumers protlucts
`
`

`
`Calavo Guacamole
`
`I,
`
`Pzlgc l Of‘ 1
`
`Avocados
`
`P393.‘/3S
`Guacamole
`
`History of G_uac._a_mo_l.e_
`Where it all started and how.
`
`Guacamole ._P.ro_d u..c.ts
`Calav_o's -Line_v1of:Premium Guacamole
`
`Nutrition Information
`Delicious and good for you.
`
`Consumers a Retail Buyers - Foodservice v Growers - About Us - Guestbook - Site Search
`
`”C‘§1E%’.’Haunt:
`
`The First .'\'.':me in .11.-uc.'4dus-
`
`;;:l;m>.c-um .‘v-:1sL:n2c:‘s :*:"odL:.-z.~: :u;:c;x1nolc imlv.‘\.l'2::*.~..
`
`

`
`Calavo Guacamole Product L.
`
`T
`
`Page 1 of 2
`
`/
`
`I
`
`....................;;;;;:.+- consum
`
`Consumers
`
`Retail Buyers
`
`Foodservice
`
`ADO“! Us
`
`Growers
`
`In This
`sec-non Guacamole Products
`
`Guacamole
`
`Pmducts
`A_y_g_g;_§dq§
`_E_qp_a1§_
`Guacamole
`
`.
`
`AV°cad° Recipes
`fun stuff
`
`Packinghouse
`Tour
`
`Guestbook
`
`The retail guacamole category grew by over 12% last year in
`supermarkets according to A.C. Nielsen and is projected to
`double by the year 2000. All thanks to consumers like you. In
`the spirit of continuous improvement, we've recently completely
`re-packaged and reformulated our refrigerated and frozen retail
`items. We've improved our guacamole products with better color,
`texture and overall flavor. So when you are at the grocery store
`you know you are_ getting the best guacamole on the shelf. .Sl:a*kes‘
`-a look at the different types of Calavo guacamole available at
`yo‘u.“loca'l grocery store.
`‘ ”
`
`"
`
`8 oz. Refrigerated Mild,
`Medium and Spicy Avocado
`Guacamole
`
`A‘zesty combination of choice
`avocados and delicious
`authentic seasonings. Each one
`a litter spicier. Use as a full-
`flavored dip or as a topping on
`salads, sandwiches and entrees.
`
`Look for these near the dips and cheeses in your local grocery
`store.
`
`6 oz. Frozen Original and
`Mexican-Style Guacamole
`Each of these guacamole
`products are a blend of
`delicious top quality avocados
`with subtle mixture of spices.
`
`Look for these in the freeze"r section at"your’ local grocery store. 3
`
`_
`1 lb. Western Style
`Guacamole —.
`
`http:.¥»'calavo.com/consumers/products/guacamole/1inehtml
`
`4/29/99
`
`

`
`v Calavo Guacamole Product Li
`
`Page 2 of 2
`
`The country's most popular
`guacamole flavor is available in
`an appealing two—pack or as a
`single 1 lb. pack. The western-
`style flavor is perfect for
`sandwiches, omelets, Mexican
`foods and on it's own as a dip.
`
`Check your local warehouse club store.
`
`Coggmers o Retail Buyers o Foodservice - Growers ~ About Us - Guestbook - Site Se_ag;n
`
`/
`
`I
`I
`
`- “
`lloullll
`159 First Name In Anocndos"
`
`http://calavo.com/consumers/products/guacamole/1ine.html
`
`4/29/99
`
`

`
`Avocado History
`
`,
`
`Page I OH
`
`Armada nl-llistory & iragtts
`
`~
`
`-.
`
`. ~
`.
`.
`Avocados
`papayas
`G.ya9am.ole
`
`-A The name applied to avocado by the Aztecs was "aoacatl," or
`"ahuacatl," later called by the Spanish and Mexicans "ahua_cate"
`or "aguacate." The fruit is first known to English speaking people
`as "midshipmen's butter" and "alligator pear," the word
`"avocado" appearing for the first time in the plant catalog of Sir
`Hans Sloane, secretary and later president of the Royal Society
`in 1696.
`
`The first introduction of the avocado in the United States was
`probably in 1833, when judge Henry Perrine sent trees from
`Mexico to his land grant in Lower Florida. In California, the first
`successful introduction was by Judge R.B. 0rd of Santa Barbara,
`who secured his trees from Mexico in 1871.
`
`In 1926 the best of these fruits were known as Calavos. In
`actuality, "Ca|avos" were not a variety of avocado, but a brand of
`avocado. Calavo was and still is the largest grower and shipper
`of avocados, and back in 1926, two years after Calavo formed,
`the avocado industry was referred to as the "Calavo" industry.
`Galavofssnavmev was formed from Cal ifornia and avo cado -as a"
`“r"'e“sti‘lt ofafnatiionwide contest in 1924. =*
`
`California is by far the leading avocado producing area in the
`United States. The actual growing area is limited to the coastal
`regions between San Luis Obispo and San Diego. Calavo also
`imports avocados from Chile, New Zealand and Mexico.
`
`Consumers ~ Retail Buyers - Foodservice - Growers - About Us - Guestbook - Site Search
`
`5. Calafffllion 1911
`
`The First :'~'3me in .~lvuc.'uIos'-
`
`l:'.!.j.>: c;i!;:m.cnm :=»::.<;:ni-.'r.~; prot‘;=.:cz.~: Limcudos l1isLor}.l11:‘n.i
`
`

`
`4 Tour ot‘Ca1avo's Temecula A\"
`
`do Packinghouse
`
`ggtall auyggg”
`
`?a@E§i3tgRii.%@Ei1$@ TQEEE
`¢srue+e..r.e¢...apackitgriirota.
`
`
`Fun stuff
`Packinghouse
`='.l'our
`‘
`léuestbook
`
`Before we begin the tour we must first understand how the fruit
`is harvested and delivered to the packinghouse.
`i
`A Our Field Managers are in contact with our Growers to schedule
`deliveries of fruit to meet market dem_ands. Growers who want
`their fruit picked up in the groves will schedule transportation
`with the Field Manager. Many Growers elect to deliver the fruit to
`the packinghouse themselves.
`
`A
`
`The fruit is gradually pre-cooled before packing. This allows the
`fruit to cool down over a 12 hour period from the ambient
`temperature at delivery time, to 40-45 degrees before packing
`the next morning.
`
`1
`
`‘
`,
`
`'
`
`Calavo has a built in system that allows full
`bins to be weighed before packing. Empty bins
`_ are then weighed so that the Grower is given
`” credit for every pound of fruit delivered to the
`packinghouse.
`
`Fruit), and Culls. The fruit
`is then placed into tight fill
`cartons by the Durand Wayland Sizer. The
`fruit is labeled with PLU labels (Product Look
`Up numbers) during the process. The sizer
`insures not only that the correct number of
`fruit is packed into the cartons by size, but
`also that the weight of the carton is correct.
`
`All cartons of fruit are checked once
`more by a Quality Control person
`before the carton is sealed and placed
`in a cooler until shipment time. The
`L cartons of fruit are stacked on pallets
`and these pallets are placed in a
`
`‘£2529:
`
`-.'ul;i'.o coin L‘0I‘i.<Llll‘;‘c‘l‘5 1oLir..‘:‘.:*.il
`
`

`
`Tour ofCalavo's Teinecula Ax
`
`do Packinghouse
`
`/,
`
`Page I or 2
`
`shipping cooler, where temperature is
`maintained between 40 and 42
`
`Prior to Shipping
`
`degrees.
`
`Caiavo has the capability to pack
`specialty packs. We pack bags for club stores as well as grocery
`stores, flats for other customers, and also have the ability to
`trigger and ripen fruit.
`
`CaIavo‘s shipping departments are open from 8:00 AM to 7:30
`PM Monday through Friday and from 8:00 AM to Noon on
`Saturdays.
`
`Consumers - Retail Buyers - Foodservice - Growers 0 About Us - Guestbook ~ Site Search
`
`( Calaio.)Haunt:
`
`Tbe First Name indvocadusr
`
`htiz‘: L.‘2l[L|'»\‘.C\‘I‘iI c:)i“.s'.in1cx‘< I-.v.::‘_%:::t:I
`
`

`
`‘_ CLlld\’0 Retail Buyer lnfornmt'
`
`T
`
`Page 1 oil
`
`:« Neg“
`
`V About ug;
`V,
`T yvfooidsetvleei
`...,.t.I §f°wef—s':‘;"‘
`T
`k
`I
`
`ftomotiog News
`
`Global Sourcing
`
`‘f<_s..v?,;'s_'- For 75 years Calavo has been
`"The First Name in Avocados."
`Since 1924 we've been a company run by
`0'
`.‘-'yu'v,’.‘.,s)‘:‘ growers, for growers. With more than
`1,600 growers in prime growing regions
`throughout California and the world,
`y can always count on Calavo for the finest
`
`'
`
`The retail portion of our web site is
`designed to help retail buyers become _a_v.Q;.a_<iQ, g.ua_c_a.mo.le and
`pace»,/,a experts. Not only will you find our entire product line in
`here with storage and ripening tips, but you will also find
`promotion ideas, information on EDI, you can also meet your
`Calavo sales rep, have access to our the weekly market update,
`as well as see what we are doing globally.
`
`Topiesnf Intia}:est.:.l‘i'f’l"
`
`° "
`
`U ruapan, Me.x.is;.o Pa.cls.i.n.g.h9.i4s.e Open..ed.. .in.....A.ugu.s.t_. 19.98
`
`Guacamole _M,a_r,ket $_,_h__are_ L_e,a,d,ers
`
`Technology That Blows Pe_$.t_s_ Away
`
`Taking the Le_a._d_,in Consumer Knowledge
`
`Market Outlook
`
`Consumers - Retail Buyers - Foodservice - Growers - About Us - Guestbook - Site Search
`
`Calaxfilloir I511
`
`Tbe F1’rs! Name in .ix.'uczndos'-
`
`3121;». c;i.l;:m_ci>in l‘li‘.Cl':~
`
`

`
`T
`
`iiificado Leader
`
`,,,a newsletter for our valued customers
`
`Sis.-r;‘.«5”sa
`Calavo FSI Increases Retail Sales
`I n September 1998, Calavo
`
`Calavo dropped another FSI that
`reached more than 20 million
`
`households in markets throughout
`the Western states and in
`
`Vol. 1, No. 3
`
`Changes at
`Calavo Strengthen
`Cooperative
`
`ecent changes at Calavo Growers
`are helping the cooperative
`strengthen its focus on two impor-
`tant objectives — maintaining the high
`quality of its grower relations and
`expanding market opportunities for
`avocados.
`
`Lee Cole, a 30-year avocado
`grower and current Chairman of the
`Board and Chief Executive Officer
`of Calavo Growers of California, has
`replaced Ron Bennett as Calavo’s
`President. Cole will serve as President
`in an interim capacity and has
`assumed all responsibilities handled
`by Bennett. Since the 1970s, Cole has
`championed the needs of his fellow
`growers and Calavo customers with
`his advocacy of market expansion
`and adoption of progressive growing
`practices.
`New roles for other Calavo execu-
`
`tives also support the cooperative’s
`focus on global sourcing as a means
`to meet the dynamic requirements of
`customers in the U.S., Europe and
`Asia. Kathryn Courtney recently was
`promoted to Director of Marketing.
`Calavo Select, overseeing the intema—
`tional sourcing of product. Jedd
`Bennett was transferred into the
`newly-created position of Intema-
`tional Sales Manager, and Dionisio
`Ortiz filled a new post at Calavo as
`the organizations Managing Director,
`Calavo de Mexico. To ensure the
`smooth operation of Calavo's world-
`wide systems, Bruce Clark was hired
`as Director of Logistics.
`
`dropped an FSI (free standing
`insert) in regional newspapers
`in the Southern
`5 California area.
`The FSI (shown
`here) contained a
`coupon that
`offered 40 cents
`:3 off any variety of
`,5 Calavo refrigerated
`guacamole. The
`insert reached
`more than 3.7
`million households
`and sales spiked
`77 percent in the
`weeks following
`distribution.
`Repurchase rates
`also were higher than pre-FSI levels.
`Then just prior to the Superbowl,
`- - - o - u u - o u - - c - o u u o - ¢ n u - - u - - ¢ - - u o ¢ - - u on
`
`E
`
`.
`
`the Washington D.C.,
`Chicago, Atlanta. New
`Orleans and Minneapolis
`metro areas. This FSI
`
`promoted sales of Calavo
`refrigerated and frozen
`guacamoles. Another FSI
`will drop April 25 prior
`to Cinco de Mayo. To
`ensure you do not run
`short on Calavo refrigerat-
`ed and frozen guacamoles
`for the widely-celebrated
`Mexican holiday, contact
`your Calavo sales rep at
`l—800—4-Calavo or visit
`our web site at www.calavo.com
`
`for the sales rep nearest you.
`o - u - o u u - - c - - u - u - u - ¢ u u - o u -anon-u-oonuco
`
`-
`CalaVo'5 September FSI reached
`more than 3. 7 million households.
`
`Brrr. . .Fri id Winter Weathe
`Impacts rops
`
`Many avocado and citrus growers
`remember waking up on the morning
`of December 22 with an uneasy
`feeling, wondering how their crops
`faired with the overnight frigid
`temperatures. Fortunately, most
`§ groves were only slightly to
`moderately affected.
`In order to lessen the freeze's
`impact on customers, Calavo imple-
`§ mented a program at the packing-
`houses to cull chill—damaged fruit.
`This program assured customers that
`the internal quality of Calavo fruit
`
`would be maintained at its usual high
`level. However, overall avocado vol-
`
`umes were impacted, with as much as
`a 10 percent reduction in this year's
`crop due to freeze damage.
`Calavo also initiated a program
`to help growers harvest all of the
`good-quality fruit that suffered stem
`damage. Without such a program.
`stem—damaged fruit would drop to
`the ground in the spring, impacting
`crop volumes further.
`
`For more details, please contact
`Calavo at l—800—4-Calavo.
`
`

`
`Challenges of Farming Are N0 Match
`For Santa Paula Avocado Grower
`
`vocado grower Ben Curtis has a
`sense of humor about his job.
`l-le’s been known to joke about
`how growers need gambling blood to
`stay in the farming business. “Every
`year you start out fresh and you can
`make nothing or you can do really
`well," says Curtis. Curtis, who man-
`ages 56 acres of avocado groves in
`the Timber Canyon region East of
`Santa Paula, California, has been
`farming avocados as well as citrus
`for more than 40 years. Since_ the
`1950s, Curtis has known all too well
`
`the challenges that test farmers.
`Consider the test Curtis received
`
`three years ago. He almost lost his
`livelihood when an Edison power line
`shorted near an oil well and started a
`
`fire many growers will remember for
`a lifetime. The fire quickly spread six
`miles along the foothills to Timber
`Canyon. burning everything in its
`path including 350 of Curtis’ avocado
`trees and threatening to take his life.
`“It was so hot, probably 120 — 130
`degrees (F), with lots of smoke. I
`guess it just got the best of me," says
`Curtis, who lost consciousness while
`
`trying to put out one of the many
`fires. With the help of his neighbors,
`whose groves were also damaged. the
`next six hours were spent putting out
`fires with rakes and shovels. Today.
`the effects of this fire are still appar-
`ent for many growers including Cur-
`tis, who is in the process of replacing
`the fire-damaged trees that finally
`died this season.
`
`urtis never shies away from the
`
`C excitement farmingoffers.
`
`Every day he’s found hauling
`most of his fruit and supervising the
`busy workers all around him. He
`loves the outdoors and never with-
`draws from the challenges nature can
`present. Fofexample, 1990 brought a
`freeze that literally halted the growth
`of his avocado business for three
`
`years. Curtis and his employees pre-
`vailed by working steadily to cut the
`
`freeze-damaged trees and start the
`§ growing process again.
`
`§ Q ome might saythat there are
`
`much easier ways to make a
`living, but Curtis believes the
`gratification of watching a grove
`grow and mature makes it all worth-
`while. “lt's great when all your hard
`i work produces a big crop. That doesn't
`§ necessarily mean you get the most
`money for your crop either. It's just a
`feeling you get when every tree is
`loaded with high-quality fruit. It's a
`f feeling you just can't beat,"
`claims Curtis.
`From the early days of the 20th
`§ century, Curtis’ family belonged to
`the Sunkist cooperative. As a result,
`E he was taught to believe that joining
`§ a co-op business was the only way to
`become successful. Curtis joined
`Sunkist in the ‘50s, and wanted to
`§ belong to an avocado co-op that
`could duplicate his family’s successes
`with Sunkist. In 1968, he joined Calavo,
`a cooperative that Curtis believes
`lives up to the standards of Sunkist,

`§ but also has some nice features
`unique to Calavo. For instance, Calavo
`is very attached to its growers and
`g
`§ seeks ways to foster close individual
`E relationships with them.
`A
`‘ he business practices Curtis
`appreciates most from Calavo
`include the organization's high-
`standards. In addition, he respects
`Calavo for understanding that actual
`growing practices should be left in
`the hands of the experts - the growers.
`i For Curtis, not only is this perfect, it
`is equivalent to success.
`Like many growers, Curtis enjoys
`the opportunity to meet and work
`with a wide variety of people. The
`i environment Calavo creates allows
`each grower access to all levels of the
`5 organization. Individuals Curtis
`relies on most include Calavo‘s field
`representative. Paul Romero, and
`Calavo Director of Marketing for
`5 Member Avocados. Rob Wedin.
`;2v
`
`l 1Q
`
`,
`
`
`
`......~o«~».--cw-I--‘V--«~'w-:-‘~v--v-v~.v.~<=-r--w-av-ww—-nu-w--c-aw--u—~vy
`
`Ben Curtis, 40-year veteran farmer, cultivates a
`5 56-acre grave in East Santa Paula, California.
`
`g
`5
`

`'
`
`"Paul visits and watches over my
`picking crew and keeps an eye on the
`status of the fruit. He may have
`ideas on how to get my fruit out of
`the grove and in general, he helps
`§ me with pruning and fertilizing,"
`says Curtis.
`ob Wedin also plays a key role
`in the lives of growers. Wedin
`sets the marketing strategy
`each season for the growers and gives
`advice on harvesting plans. “This
`teamwork between Calavo and
`myself. as well as the other member
`§ growers, ensures that we match our
`end products with returns."
`says Curtis.
`Summarizing his years as an
`avocado grower, Curtis says, “I'm
`proud to be a Calavo grower because
`it's a successful organization that
`takes every single avocado and finds
`the best place to sell it. That's all I
`can ask for."
`

`
`_
`
`'
`
`As for his other business partner
`- Mother Nature — well, that's the
`area where gambling blood comes
`in handy.
`
`

`
`
`
`wasting time sc
`material.
`
`anning irrelevant
`
`AA web Site I)esigned for Easy
`Navigation
`Withsomanywebsitestovisit.
`theyareseeking. Withmultiple
`thejourney online canbe
`topicsto choose from.thevisitor is
`exciting,but also extremelytime
`boundto immediatelyfind the
`akes these online
`‘information they are seeking without
`con

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.

We are unable to display this document.

PTO Denying Access

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket