Courthouse 111 South 10th Street, Room 24.329 Saint Louis, MO 63102

1 The two Engel & Völkers entities are identified as Defendants-Appellees because their “affiliate” Engel & Völkers New York Real Estate LLC did not enter a separate appearance in the Western District of Missouri and has not been separately identified as a party in this appeal.

Appellate Case: 24-3478 Page: 1 Date Filed: 01/14/2025 Entry ID: 5474884

The National Association of Realtors (“NAR”), while currently identified in the caption of this case (No. 24-3481), is not a party to this appeal.

Given the substantial overlap between the factual and legal issues presented in this case, Case No. 24-3450, Monty March v. Rhonda Burnett, et al, and the two appeals captioned as Robert Friedman v. Don Gibson, et al. 24-3481 and Robert Friedman v. Rhonda Burnett, et al v. 24-3451 (collectively, the “March Appeals”), March and the Objector-Appellant in the Friedman Appeals intend to move this Court for consolidation or joinder of the four separately docketed appeals pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 3(b) should the Court not consolidate those matters sua sponte.

In response to this Court’s December 31, 2024 letter, Appellant James Mullis makes the following statement regarding the designation of appellees in this matter.

 Charles Rutenberg Realty – Orlando, LLC was a party to the settlement, but it was not a named or served defendant in the district court case.

 Premiere Plus Realty, Co. was a party to the settlement, but it was not a named or served defendant in the district court case.

The following parties are Plaintiff-Appellees:  Don Gibson;  Lauren Criss;  John Meiners; and  Daniel Umpa.

The following are Defendants in the matter who are not appellees before this Court in this case:  National Association of Realtors;  eXp World Holdings, Inc.;  Weichert Co.;  Howard Hanna Real Estate Services;  Berkshire Hathaway Energy Co.  HomeServices of America, Inc. Appellate Case: 24-3473 Page: 3 Date Filed: 01/14/2025 Entry ID: 5474836

Courthouse 111 South 10th Street, Room 24.329 Saint Louis, MO 63102

1 The two Engel & Völkers entities are identified as Defendants-Appellees because their “affiliate” Engel & Völkers New York Real Estate LLC did not enter a separate appearance in the Western District of Missouri and has not been separately identified as a party in this appeal.

Appellate Case: 24-3478 Page: 1 Date Filed: 01/14/2025 Entry ID: 5474884

The National Association of Realtors (“NAR”), while currently identified in the caption of this case (No. 24-3481), is not a party to this appeal.

Given the substantial overlap between the factual and legal issues presented in this case, Case No. 24-3450, Monty March v. Rhonda Burnett, et al, and the two appeals captioned as Robert Friedman v. Don Gibson, et al. 24-3481 and Robert Friedman v. Rhonda Burnett, et al v. 24-3451 (collectively, the “March Appeals”), March and the Objector-Appellant in the Friedman Appeals intend to move this Court for consolidation or joinder of the four separately docketed appeals pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 3(b) should the Court not consolidate those matters sua sponte.

Courthouse 111 South 10th Street, Room 24.329 St. Louis, MO 63102 Re: Don Gibson, et al v. Robert Friedman, Case No. 24-3481 Dear Ms. Gornik: Pursuant to your letter dated December 31, 2024 requesting input from the parties regarding the identification of proper appellees in each case, Appellant Robert Friedman (“Friedman”) proposes that the following parties be designated as appellees in the above-referenced case: Don Gibson – Plaintiff-Appellee; Lauren Criss – Plaintiff-Appellee; John Meiners – Plaintiff-Appellee; Daniel Umpa – Plaintiff-Appellee; Compass, Inc. – Defendant-Appellee; Douglas Elliman, Inc. – Defendant-Appellee; Engel & Völkers GmbH – Defendant-Appellee; and Engel & Völkers Americas, Inc. – Defendant-Appellee.1

1 The two Engel & Völkers entities are identified as Defendants-Appellees because their “affiliate” Engel & Völkers New York Real Estate LLC did not enter a separate appearance in the Western District of Missouri and has not been separately identified as a party in this appeal.

Maureen W. Gornik Acting Clerk of Court January 14, 2025 Page 2

The National Association of Realtors (“NAR”), while currently identified in the caption of this case (No. 24-3481), is not a party to this appeal.

Given the substantial overlap between the factual and legal issues presented in this case, Case No. 24-3451, Rhonda Burnett, et al v. Robert Friedman, and the two appeals captioned as Don Gibson, et al v. Monty March, et al. 24-3478 and Rhonda Burnett, et al v. Monty March, et al. 24-3450 (collectively, the “March Appeals”), Friedman and the Objector-Appellant in the March Appeals intend to move this Court for consolidation or joinder of the four separately docketed appeals pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 3(b) should the Court not consolidate those matters sua sponte.

For absolute clarity, I will list the appellees that we both have and then list the one appellee that I believe needs to be added: We both have Don Gibson; Lauren Criss; John Meiners; Daniel Umpa; Compass; Redfin Corporation; United Real Estate; Douglas Elliman, Inc.; Five D I, LLC., Premiere Plus Realty, Co., and Charles Rutenberg Trealty - Orlando, LLC; Douglas Elliman Realty, LLC; At World Properties; The Real Brokerage; Real Broker, LLC.

; Realty ONE Group, Inc.; HomeSmart International, LLC.

; Engel & Volkers GmbH; and Engel & Volkers Americas, Inc.; I believe that Engel & Volkers New York Real Estate LLC., while a subsidiary, settled in its own name and, as such, should be listed as an appellee as well.

If we can be of more assistance, please let us know.

Cited in Do No Harm v. Pfizer, Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.

This document is protected by copyright.

Cited in Do No Harm v. Pfizer, Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.

This document is protected by copyright.

Do No Harm is a Virginia-based, nationwide membership organization whose stated mission is “to protect healthcare from radical, divisive, and discriminatory ideologies, including the recent rise in explicit racial discrimination in graduate and postgraduate medical programs.” Id. at 9.

It disputes the district court’s conclusion that associations like Do No Harm lack standing to sue on behalf of their members under § 1981, and it challenges the court’s assessment of the merits of its Title VI and ACA claims.

Consequently, to establish standing for a preliminary injunction, “a plaintiff cannot rest on such mere allegations as would be appropriate at the pleading stage but must set forth by affidavit or other evidence specific facts, which for purposes of the summary judgment motion will be taken to be true.” Id. (cleaned up).

Circuit subsequently endorsed the majority view from Klayman, holding that “an inability to establish a substantial likelihood of standing requires denial of the motion for preliminary injunction, not dismissal of the case.” Food & Water Watch, Inc. v. Vilsack, 808 F.3d 905, 913 (D.C. Cir. 2015).

In Murthy, the Supreme Court considered whether the individual and state plaintiffs had Article III standing to secure a preliminary injunction enjoining federal government officials from urging social media platforms to remove or suppress content.

The Clerk will enter my appearance as Counsel in Appeal No. _______________for the following party(s): (please specify)

Please compare your information below with your information on PACER.

Any updates or changes must be made through PACER’s Manage my Account.

United States Court of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit Thomas F. Eagleton U.S.

Courthouse 111 South 10th Street, Room 24.329 St. Louis, Missouri 63102 Maureen W. Gornik

In an attempt to define more clearly the proper appellees in each case prior to briefing, we are asking for input from the parties.

cc: Alexander Aiken MaryAnn T. Almeida Scott Eric Anderson Robert James Anello Bryon Patrick Becker Steve Berman Matthew Robert Berry Timothy R. Beyer Craig P. Bloom Brandon J.B. Boulware Robert Abraham Braun Benjamin D. Brown Leo Caseria Maureen W. Gornik Acting Clerk of Court Appellate Case: 24-3564 Page: 1 Date Filed: 12/31/2024 Entry ID: 5470955

Kenneth R. David Eric L. Dirks Karen L. Dunn Helen Cho Eckert Nathan Emmons Jeannie Evans Eric Fanchiang Beatrice C. Franklin Matthew W. Geary Martha Goodman Emilee L. Hargis Christopher Michael Harper William A. Isaacson Daniel Patrick Johnson Lindsay Sklar Johnson Michael Judy Marc E. Kasowitz Michael S. Ketchmark Amanda Pennington Ketchum James D. Lawrence Christopher M. Loveland Brian J. Madden Jacob Scott Madsen Robert J. Maguire David Marroso Scott A. McCreight Molly K. McGinley Stephen McIntyre Sabrina Merold John Lavelle Mullen Ann O'Brien Robert J. Palmersheim Constantine Z. Pamphilis Timothy G. Parilla Emily Parsons Rio Pierce Cameron N. Regnery Trina Ricketts Daniel Allen Sasse Marc M. Seltzer Mathew W. Shealy Floyd Short Michael L. Sibarium Daniel Hershey Silverman Mitch Slade Chahira Solh Edward M. Spiro Eyitayo St. Matthew-Daniel Gerald A. Stein Jeremy Suhr Kenneth W. Taber Hector Torres Appellate Case: 24-3564 Page: 2 Date Filed: 12/31/2024 Entry ID: 5470955

United States Court of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit Thomas F. Eagleton U.S.

In an attempt to define more clearly the proper appellees in each case prior to briefing, we are asking for input from the parties.

Once that deadline passes, the appellees are asked to review the designations and response from appellants and notify this court in writing by January 21, 2025, whether they agree with the proposed caption and appellants submission.

The consolidated briefing schedule will be established once the parties clarify the appellees in these cases.

Leo Caseria Kenneth R. David Eric L. Dirks Karen L. Dunn Helen Cho Eckert Nathan Emmons Jeannie Evans Eric Fanchiang Beatrice C. Franklin Matthew W. Geary Martha Goodman Emilee L. Hargis Christopher Michael Harper William A. Isaacson Daniel Patrick Johnson Lindsay Sklar Johnson Michael Judy Marc E. Kasowitz Michael S. Ketchmark Amanda Pennington Ketchum James D. Lawrence Christopher M. Loveland Brian J. Madden Jacob Scott Madsen Robert J. Maguire David Marroso Scott A. McCreight Molly K. McGinley Stephen McIntyre Sabrina Merold John Lavelle Mullen Ann O'Brien Robert J. Palmersheim Constantine Z. Pamphilis Timothy G. Parilla Emily Parsons Rio Pierce Cameron N. Regnery Trina Ricketts Daniel Allen Sasse Marc M. Seltzer Floyd Short Michael L. Sibarium Daniel Hershey Silverman Chahira Solh Edward M. Spiro Eyitayo St. Matthew-Daniel Gerald A. Stein Jeremy Suhr Kenneth W. Taber Hector Torres Lauren E. Tucker McCubbin Appellate Case: 24-3473 Page: 2 Date Filed: 12/31/2024 Entry ID: 5470943

United States Court of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit Thomas F. Eagleton U.S.

Maureen W. Gornik Acting Clerk of Court This case has been consolidated for briefing.

In an attempt to define more clearly the proper appellees in each case prior to briefing, we are asking for input from the parties.

The consolidated briefing schedule will be established once the parties clarify the appellees in these cases.

Kenneth R. David Eric L. Dirks Karen L. Dunn Helen Cho Eckert Nathan Emmons Jeannie Evans Eric Fanchiang Beatrice C. Franklin Matthew W. Geary Daniel Z. Goldman Martha Goodman Steven L. Groopman Emilee L. Hargis Christopher Michael Harper William A. Isaacson Daniel Patrick Johnson Lindsay Sklar Johnson Michael Judy Marc E. Kasowitz Michael S. Ketchmark Amanda Pennington Ketchum James D. Lawrence Christopher M. Loveland Brian J. Madden Jacob Scott Madsen Robert J. Maguire David Marroso Scott A. McCreight Molly K. McGinley Stephen McIntyre Sabrina Merold John Lavelle Mullen Ann O'Brien Robert J. Palmersheim Constantine Z. Pamphilis Timothy G. Parilla Emily Parsons Rio Pierce Cameron N. Regnery Trina Ricketts Daniel Allen Sasse Todd A. Seaver Marc M. Seltzer Floyd Short Michael L. Sibarium Daniel Hershey Silverman Chahira Solh Edward M. Spiro Eyitayo St. Matthew-Daniel Gerald A. Stein Jeremy Suhr Kenneth W. Taber Appellate Case: 24-3481 Page: 2 Date Filed: 12/31/2024 Entry ID: 5470949

United States Court of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit Thomas F. Eagleton U.S.

In an attempt to define more clearly the proper appellees in each case prior to briefing, we are asking for input from the parties.

The consolidated briefing schedule will be established once the parties clarify the appellees in these cases.

Leo Caseria Kenneth R. David Eric L. Dirks Karen L. Dunn Helen Cho Eckert Nathan Emmons Jeannie Evans Eric Fanchiang Beatrice C. Franklin Matthew W. Geary Martha Goodman Emilee L. Hargis Christopher Michael Harper William A. Isaacson Daniel Patrick Johnson Lindsay Sklar Johnson Michael Judy Marc E. Kasowitz Michael S. Ketchmark Amanda Pennington Ketchum James D. Lawrence Christopher M. Loveland Brian J. Madden Jacob Scott Madsen Robert J. Maguire David Marroso Scott A. McCreight Molly K. McGinley Stephen McIntyre Sabrina Merold Marvin Alan Miller John Lavelle Mullen Drew Anthony Navikas Ann O'Brien Robert J. Palmersheim Constantine Z. Pamphilis Timothy G. Parilla Emily Parsons Rio Pierce Cameron N. Regnery Trina Ricketts Daniel Allen Sasse Marc M. Seltzer Floyd Short Michael L. Sibarium Daniel Hershey Silverman Chahira Solh Edward M. Spiro Eyitayo St. Matthew-Daniel Gerald A. Stein Jeremy Suhr Kenneth W. Taber Appellate Case: 24-3478 Page: 2 Date Filed: 12/31/2024 Entry ID: 5470946

Hector Torres Lauren E. Tucker McCubbin Matthew Van Tine Elizabeth Anne Vasseur-Browne Jennifer Bowen Wieland Michael Anthony Williams Michael Wilson District Court/Agency Case Number(s): 4:23-cv-00788-SRB