However, upon review of the allegations in the Amended Complaint and the submissions of the parties, the court finds that Plaintiffs have “reasonably employed knowledge at [their] command, made diligent inquiry, and exerted an honest and conscientious effort appropriate to the circumstances, to acquire information necessary to enable [them] to effect personal service on [Miscavige].” See Kirchik, 2021 WL 7451917, at *2.
Moreover, the Amended Complaint contains sufficient factual allegations that Miscavige operated or conducted a business venture in Florida in his individual capacity, i.e., outside of his role as a corporate director, officer, or shareholder of the Organizational Defendants, and for his own personal pecuniary gain.
9 Plaintiffs further allege that the “receipt of money and unpaid labor also enabled David Miscavige to maintain a façade of legitimacy, a luxurious lifestyle, power over every aspect of the organization’s global operations, and influence over members, including celebrities who joined and promoted Scientology publicly.” (Id. ¶ 2.)
Rather, the Organizational Defendants, including FSO, FSSO, and IASA, all of which have continuous and systematic business activities in Florida either through the purchase and management of real estate (Dkt. 79 ¶¶ 17, 20), the collection and disbursement of membership dues (id. ¶¶ 22–23), or the hosting of events and fundraising (id. ¶¶ 19–21), are alleged to be directly controlled by Miscavige individually and serve as his agents.
For example, Plaintiff Gawain Baxter alleges that as a child, “he was forced to provide five to ten hours a day of unpaid work at Flag Base [in Clearwater, Florida], including food preparation, trash removal, landscaping, and clerical work.” (Id. ¶ 91.)