throbber
Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 1 of 21 PageID# 21016
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 1 of 21 Page|D# 21016
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT 1
`
`
`EXHIBIT 1
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 2 of 21 PageID# 21017
`
`Page 1• • • • • • • • • • •CONFIDENTIAL•1• • • • • • • • • • ROBERT L. RIPLEY•2• • • • • •IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT•3• • • • • FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA•4• • • • • • •Civil Action No. 1:20-cv-00393•5•6• •____________________________________•7• •RAI STRATEGIC HOLDINGS, INC., et al.)•8• • • • • Plaintiffs,•• • • • • • • • •)•9• • • • • v.• • • • • • • • • • • • • •)10• •ALTRIA CLIENT SERVICES LLC, et al., )11• • • • • Defendants.• • • • • • • • • )12• •____________________________________)131415• • • • • • • • • • CONFIDENTIAL16• • • • • • •DEPOSITION OF ROBERT L. RIPLEY17• • • • • • TAKEN REMOTELY BY VIDEOCONFERENCE18• • • • • • • • • • •MARCH 15, 2021192021222324• •Reported by:• Goldy Gold, RPR25• •Job No. 191169
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 3 of 21 PageID# 21018
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 3 of 21 PageID# 21018
`
`Index: $300..560
`
` 3
`
`5
`
`3 39:11,12,15 68:5
`72:13 75:8 97:24
`
`5 91:14,15129:2,9
`140:13150:12176:3
`
`121 :8,11,17 122:10
`127:5145:3,14
`198:21 204:3
`
`190:14198:24199:3,
`6,18 200:20 201:8
`221 :10
`
`30 5:18187:22
`
`30(b)(6) 9:24 34:2,4
`
`300 53:17
`
`30C 206:16,17,20,24,
`25
`
`37 123:8,12
`
`374 36:11
`
`5,388,594 64:2
`
`5-VOIt 200:7,8,10,19
`201 :2,23
`
`5-volts 200:12
`
`5.2 198:16
`
`52 142:13
`
`529 21 :25
`
`37BCC 123:4
`
`52976 138:5
`
`39 35:10
`
`52979 138:8
`
`3:19 219:15
`
`5388594 63:15
`
`3:40 219:9,10
`
`3:43 219:18
`
`54 106:2
`
`Confidential
`
`2,000-millisecond
`225:18
`
`2-cell 174:7,24
`
`2-millisecond
`187:23 225:17,24
`
`2-second 187:16,22
`224:24
`
`20 12:2413:3,15
`
`200-page 153:8
`
`2000 16:16150:18
`151 :20 167:12
`
`2002 129:6,9,11
`131 :2 143:3,4,13
`148:20 176:8,24
`177:3189:15 209:25
`217:3
`
`2004 209:25
`
`2007 23:11,12 24:3
`28:4 209:23 216:20
`
`217:3,10
`
`$
`
`$300 15:4
`
`--if 40:10
`
`--now 151:6
`
`14678 152:19,24
`
`14784 153:14,15
`166:12
`
`14794 153:15
`
`148 77:25 78:3,13
`
`14888 152:20,24
`
`15 6:416:8,12 219:3,
`5
`
`--who 164:14
`
`16223231 166:22
`
`0
`
`00/‘01 166:7
`
`1 5:24 31 :24 32:10,24
`33:2,24 52:2 65:15,
`20 67:20112:2
`
`16223259 166:18
`
`18 73:14,17
`
`195 52:6
`
`1971 18:15
`
`1975 19:5
`
`1978 19:8,11
`
`1990 176:22188:18
`
`19905 20:2 23:5,6
`
`1991 68:24
`
`
`
`1992 19:15,17 20:5,
`17 21 :8 69:5 70:7
`
`185:11,15188:19
`189:15 224:20
`
`1993 70:13
`
`1995 74:17
`
`1998 144:22146:4,7
`
`1999 173:14174:11,
`15
`
`2008 14:21 16:18
`17:22 18:6 21 :9 23:8
`216:13
`
`2021 6:4
`
`228 6:8
`
`23 126:25
`
`23113 7:14
`
`2427 7:13
`
`4
`
`4 63:24,25 73:16
`90:13,19,21 91:6
`92:6,8 95:15 97:19
`99:10101:11,12,14,
`24104:11 144:24
`
`4-millisecond 78:19
`
`25-minute 218:25
`
`4.3 198:21
`
`118:11,13,14,17
`120:2 125:20 126:7,
`11,15151:20156:15
`185:11,15191:22,23
`221 :10,11
`
`10 130:4139:8
`170:15,16,20173:20
`
`10-year 130:5
`
`10:00 32:20
`
`11 118:13151:21,23
`152:5153:10,14
`165:12,15185:8,9,14
`221:15
`
`11/2/99 170:17
`173:12
`
`11:18 84:14
`
`11:30 84:17
`
`12 173:20175:19
`198:21
`
`12:17 128:17
`
`13 35:8198:21 199:2,
`12,18 200:9,14,16,20
`201 :3,5,7
`
`13-VOIts 201:22
`
`14 166:12199:12
`
`545 36:10,18,24,25
`37:15 81 :17 82:2,3
`84:22 88:19,22 90:2,
`9,22 91 :6,18 92:2
`96:22 99:7104:13
`
`105:17,18106:20,22
`107:9,17108:12,22
`112:23 113:4,6,24
`114:13,23115:19
`116:11,21,22118:2,
`11,12 120:5 121 :8,
`12,17122:10125:20
`126:7,11 127:5
`129:2,11 132:21
`140:10,24 141 :4
`147:8,13,14148:3,11
`149:4,9150:13
`152:18,23 155:2
`157:10164:4,9,15
`176:3,9 179:23
`190:12,17,20,24
`196:4,13 203:21
`204:3,8 205:2,5
`206:2 214:17 215:25
`
`220:12,20 221:11
`223:2,18 224:3 228:6
`233:22 234:23,24
`235:3
`
`560 40:10,13,20 41:6
`42:10 47:9 51 :22
`55:18 60:23 61:25
`
`1:00 128:8,15
`
`255 199:10,12200:13
`
`1:15 128:19
`
`1:26 137:18
`
`1:32 137:21
`
`1C131:13154:14,17
`155:2,12,21 156:2,20
`157:8158:13 203:14
`
`2
`
`2 31 :25 34:2,4 52:2
`65:15,20 78:19
`126:8,12,16127:5,12
`145:11,14146:2
`173:13
`
`27 123:5,7 221:15
`
`28 118:13
`
`29 126:15,16
`
`2:19 219:8
`
`2:20 219:8
`
`2:40 219:9
`
`2:43 197:21
`
`2:56 197:24
`
`2C 156:15
`
`40 13:16,19 41:4
`
`400 93:5,6,7,19 94:20
`
`401(k) 22:2
`
`401(k)s 21:25
`
`406 94:5
`
`45 128:9,10
`
`45th 6:8
`
`48 141:14
`
`49 35:4,11,12,18,24
`36:3
`
`4:01 236:15
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 4 of 21 PageID# 21019
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 4 of 21 PagelD# 21019
`
`62:20 63:13 68:6
`
`6803545 92:4
`
`69:22 70:23 72:13,20
`73:5,19 74:8 75:6,9,
`19 76:4,9,14 78:13,
`21,25 79:10 81 :5,11,
`19 84:20 88:23 89:17
`90:3 104:17105:22
`
`106:2,7,8,16,19
`107:18108:12,22
`112:20,22113:3
`114:13117:25119:2,
`14,16 120:3,21
`121 :9,13,18 122:10
`126:8,13127:6
`162:22 163:6,8,9
`190:7,9194:17,19,20
`195:6,7,15196:5,12
`198:12,13 203:22
`204:9 205:12,18,24
`212:16 213:13
`
`220:11,19 222:22,24
`227:3,8,15 228:6,7
`229:2,10,11
`
`57 37:7,10
`
`58 37:7,10
`
`59 67:23 81 :6 141 :15
`
`7
`
`7 51 :15,17,22,24
`53:22 119:16 121 :8,
`12,18122:11 123:9,
`11 152:15,22 204:5
`
`75 9:819:5
`
`8
`
`8 53:4 80:9152:15,16,
`17,23 200:17
`
`8-puff 80:5
`
`9
`
`9 166:4,5,6,19169:6
`
`90 70:12
`
`905 115:4
`
`92 16:16
`
`926 69:2
`
`960 78:20
`
`Confidential
`
`83:10,11 85:3,14,23
`103:10170:4175:11
`178:25 207:23 209:6
`232:23
`
`account 110111
`111 :18
`
`16 203:20,25 204:6,
`22
`
`ahead 17:11,13
`28:16 56:5122:7
`149:23158:4164:12
`215:6 228:19
`
`accounts 2t17
`
`aid 82:13
`
`accuracy 148:10,20
`149:8
`
`allowed 80:12
`115:19
`
`accurate 12:25 31 :4
`60:21 99:10 143:4
`
`144:6167:5,6 207:19
`222:15
`
`achieve 47:10,11
`
`acquired 138:21
`139:3,5
`
`Acrobat 32:4
`
`actual 26:18 44:20
`49:18 66:2,3 121 :22
`126:21
`
`add 76:20
`
`added 70:7 76:21
`90:2
`
`allowing 76:16
`
`Altria 6:3,1817:6
`21:15 23:19 33:19
`
`34:11 36:4,9 43:17
`138:22139:6 231 :10
`234:19
`
`amount 108:16
`
`115:14131:8142:18,
`21 147:17
`
`amplitude 225:7,8
`
`analysis 189:3
`
`analyzing 42:7
`108:17
`
`Index: 57..back
`
`art 76:5
`
`article 144:18146:4
`147:21 148:16
`
`ASIC 94:6
`
`aspects 61:12
`
`assembly 127:13
`
`asserted 36:4,10
`
`assist 141:9
`
`association 5:5 6:11
`
`assume 8:22 131 :16
`171 :25
`
`assuming 24:9
`173:13
`
`attention 51 :14
`73:13144:24153:9
`
`attorney 9:3
`
`attorneys 14:6
`
`audio 120:4
`
`authored 173:6
`
`answers 8:18
`
`average 77:7
`
`anytime 17:15 28:19
`
`
`
`594 65:16 67:24
`68:10 72:11,18,19
`73:11,15,17,20,21,22
`74:9 75:10 76:5 77:8
`81 :8
`
`5C 187:11,19,20
`188:21 189:2 224:22
`
`6
`
`6 40:10112:3140:14,
`18166:20 198:20
`
`199:18,21,22 200:17
`
`6,040,560 39:13
`
`6,803,545 91:16
`
`60 9:8
`
`603545 92:3
`
`6040560 39:16
`
`61 38:5,7,10,19
`
`64 38:6,7,10,20
`
`650 198:11
`
`99 175:13
`
`9:17 6:5
`
`9:46 32:17
`
`A
`
`a.m. 6:5 32:17,20
`84:14,17
`
`abnormality 97:2
`
`absolutely 150:5
`
`abstract 191 :21 ,22
`
`access 231:6
`
`accommodate 86:5,
`19110:3,21,23111:9
`197:3198:4 214:18
`233:4
`
`Accord 19:23,24
`23:4,19 24:13 26:14
`27:8,9,11,15 31 :6
`47:3 49:23 55:20
`
`62:11 65:19 81 :12,23
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`addition 10:24
`109:14 195:6
`
`additional 37:5
`52:13
`
`address 7:11
`
`adequate 189:20
`
`adjust 77:5,6195:23
`
`adjusted 198:4
`
`adjustment 110:10
`
`administer 6:21
`
`apologize 17:9,12
`29:11 103:21
`
`appearance 126:22
`
`appearing 33:18
`
`application 68:18,
`22,24 94:13 132:24
`141:10164:4177:18
`189:10
`
`applications 98:13
`148:17 206:14
`
`admissible 5:16
`
`apply 182:6
`
`advantages 36:18
`
`approval 14:16
`
`advice 22:23
`
`affect 8:14 83:6
`
`approximately 6:5
`13:3,4,1816:14
`19:17 27:3
`
`afternoon 128:22,24
`
`area 55:13170:11
`
`agree 10:20 63:13
`73:3109:15118:19,
`25126:13139:24
`
`146:3147:7,12
`181:18183:8189:14,
`
`211 :12 217:5,6 229:2
`
`argue 192:22
`
`arrow 68:22
`
`aware 146:13,15,18
`147:4 223:16,25
`225:25 228:21,22
`234:25
`
`B.C. 185:14
`
`B.J. 69:14
`
`B1 92:24 93:2 97:20,
`22
`
`BZ 92:24 93:2 97:20,
`22
`
`B3 92:24 93:2 97:22
`
`Bachelor 18:8
`
`bachelor's 18:12,21
`
`back 12:917:11 30:7
`32:19 68:5 69:9
`
`72:12,16 73:11 74:22
`84:16 86:3 88:5
`
`115:3 128:8,15,20
`137:14,20140:10,24
`145:10,25150:11
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 5 of 21 PageID# 21020
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 5 of 21 PagelD# 21020
`
`165:7,10166:11
`171 :5 175:12 176:6
`188:19197:23 201 :4
`202:19 219:17 234:5
`
`background 18:2,3,
`7 58:17 62:24
`
`bank 226:25
`
`based 26:4 45:4
`137:25 139:22
`
`166:15 217:14,19
`227:6
`
`basic 7:21
`
`basically 21 :8 58:20
`141 :5 180:6 200:5
`
`basis 54:5
`
`Bates 136:9,11,14,15
`138:5152:13,18
`153:13166:17,21
`
`Bates-numbered
`138:3
`
`batteries 82:20
`83:12,20 86:5,10,19
`87:24 88:9 89:16
`
`90:15,16 92:16,19,
`20,24 93:9,13 96:20
`97:9,17,23 99:21 ,23,
`25 100:2,4114:21
`115:5,17131:6,8
`132:3,7,11 141:17
`142:15,21 143:14,21
`145:9 146:5,17,21
`147:14149:21,25
`150:4,9,18,22 151 :4,
`20 155:16,20 156:5,
`7,8159:8,16,18
`160:2,5 161 :15
`162:23 163:5,7,11
`166:7168:14170:5
`
`175:11,15,23177:11,
`12,16,21 178:5,17,19
`179:6,25180:4,10,
`15,18,24 181 :7
`182:6,10183:20
`187:2,8,10,11 188:21
`189:15196:14,18
`198:5,14199:4
`206:10,12,14,25
`207:12 208:4,10,13,
`20 212:10 223:13
`226:15 228:15 229:3
`
`battery 47:15,16,17
`52:24 76:8,11 79:16
`80:16,17,25 81 :2
`82:5,9,12,13,14,15,
`16 83:4 85:15,24
`88:16,25 89:2,8,18,
`23 90:2,6,8,11,12,19,
`22 92:13,14,15,21
`93:3,5,9,12,14,19
`94:11,12,17,19,20
`95:3 96:8,19 97:13,
`24,25 98:5,11,13,16
`99:8,9,15,17100:11,
`13,14,17,19,25
`101 :3,9,24 102:15
`103:11 104:11,12,15
`105:5,7,17,23,25
`108:3109:12110:14,
`17114:11115:11,22,
`25116:4,5,7,10,15
`117:17 120:4 131 :22
`
`134:13,20135:9
`141:6142:22153:9
`
`155:3,8156:20 157:9
`159:7,14,15160:16,
`19,24162:17163:22,
`24164:15168:15
`
`174:7,14,24 176:25
`178:22,24 179:15
`181:11,14,23182:19
`184:8,15185:16
`190:25 191 :2 192:2,
`6,7,10,19193:6,8,11,
`20,21 194:18,22
`195:11,25197:11,12
`203:6,13 205:14,21
`207:7,8,13,14 208:6,
`11,19 209:7 211:23
`213:3 215:10 216:7
`
`223:17 224:2,14,18
`225:13,24,25 227:25
`229:13,14
`
`battery-powered
`144:1 1
`
`bear 18:4 91:11
`
`Confidential
`
`Bernard 69:15
`
`Bernie 185:24
`
`Beta 16:11,12,25
`19:16,18,19,22,25
`20:4,8,17,24 21 :7
`26:21 28:10,24
`29:13,20 30:3,20,22
`47:21 ,22,24 48:5
`55:25 58:19 61 :7
`68:20 69:4 70:18
`
`85:2 87:25 88:9,17
`94:21 ,25 115:6
`151:14160:16
`
`161:15162:17165:3,
`4170:16173:11
`175:11 178:18179:2
`186:2 207:23 208:4
`211 :22 212:6 216:16
`
`217:3 226:8,10,12,14
`
`big 11:19 121 :3
`229:20
`
`Bill 6:14 7:517:9 21 :4
`35:14 69:17 73:24
`84:4105:10122:7
`125:21 135:25136:5
`139:4197:16 235:11
`
`Billet-hallowell
`18:25
`
`Billy 69:14
`
`bit 7:23 17:25 18:2,6
`30:10 42:7 48:12
`
`51 :12 63:4,7,14 64:6,
`10,11 65:10 66:18,
`19,23 67:20 68:17,
`22,23 69:9 91 :20
`92:11 97:21 122:23
`129:5145:16196:25
`198:3 199:6 200:3
`
`218:16,22 223:9
`232:21
`
`black 51 :24 52:5
`73:18
`
`bears 152:13166:17,
`21
`
`blade 53:11
`
`beginning 49:4 88:5
`190:21
`
`behalf 25:14 34:11
`157:5,13,20
`
`bell 75:3 186:6
`
`blades 47:12 53:9,10
`229:18
`
`Blake 159:6,8,14,16,
`19160:10,13184:2
`227:21,22,23 228:4,5
`
`Blake's 134:11
`
`170:15 220:22
`
`Index: background..chance
`
`blank 217:5,6
`
`block 65:25 121:21
`123:13,22 204:19
`
`called 6:24 22:10
`28:6 85:2 93:5 94:6
`173:19 231 :21
`
`blow 62:25 63:2
`68:16 77:21 97:20
`
`118:14122:23123:6,
`7,10141:16168:5
`
`blown 65:10
`
`blowup 155:16
`
`board 50:6170:13
`176:22 202:6,7
`
`Bob 10:512:2 59:15
`158:21 165:6170:17
`173:16
`
`bonded 97:25
`
`bottom 53.6 65.10
`77:21 126:24167:11,
`14
`
`break 9:912:13 84:7,
`9,19125:25127:24,
`25128:2130:12,19
`197:14,15 218:17,22,
`25
`breaks 9:8
`Brian 235:17
`.
`brlng 32.3 58.21
`broad 58:17
`
`Bruce 43:3 57:9
`
`bUIId 48:9 86:9
`building 29:25
`
`built 24:25 25:3
`90:12 94119724
`100:14 203:3
`
`bullet 174:5
`
`burned 31-3
`burns 115:11
`
`business 210:23
`
`C
`
`calculations 200:16
`
`call 29:5 86:15
`
`calls 9:20,21 41:8
`77:16 78:7 98:22
`105:20109:17
`
`114:14,15116:3
`119:4,19120:8
`130:13134:6143:6
`144:8 146:9147:9
`
`148:23177:7180:11,
`25181:17182:7
`
`183:2,11 184:10,22
`189:22 192:25
`
`194:23 213:7,19,20
`214:10 215:12
`217:25 222:7 223:4
`
`canceled 217:13
`
`cancelled 27.25
`
`capable 180:19,20
`201:7
`
`capacity 34:10180:9
`-
`.
`carbm' 55'16
`carefully 108:19
`221:6
`carrler 225:6,8
`case 5:20 24:14
`127:14 23023
`
`casual 56:8
`
`catch 142:23
`
`category 222:3
`caused 176:9
`
`.
`.
`.
`cautlon 12.2133.13
`cell 175:17184:5
`
`2157
`cells 97:18144:20
`168:14,15175:17,19
`192:2,6198:21
`213:1o,11,14,17
`224:21
`
`center 154:4
`
`Central 231 :21
`
`chance 17:18 37:9
`116:6142:5186:20
`236:10
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 6 of 21 PageID# 21021
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 6 of 21 Page|D# 21021
`
`change 76:10 82:7,9
`83:5,21,24 89:6,9
`100:2,12104:23,24
`107:12109:11,16
`111:22117:10
`195:14199:15 200:5
`
`209:4 212:3,9 213:4,
`12,24 214:2,8
`215:21,24 216:7,9
`
`changed 83:9 90:5
`94:7 98:2 99:20
`
`104:25 109:14,25
`189:15196:12,15
`212:18 214:3,24
`
`changing 22:4 90:7
`108:2175:16 213:2
`
`Characteristics
`144:19
`
`characterizations
`235:1 1
`
`characterize 138:18
`
`charge 47:16 57:11,
`23 76:8,10 79:17
`108:3 198:18
`
`Chuck's 210:7
`
`cigarette 19:14,20
`28:11,25 29:16,20
`30:23 31 :2,8,9,13,14,
`20 47:14 57:12,14,
`16,17 61:1179:19
`126:25127:2,14
`141 :7 217:11
`
`cigarettes 31 :10
`
`circuit 49:11 50:4,6,
`17,21 51 :7,25 52:6,
`11,16,21 53:2,7,16,
`20 73:18 89:18 91 :2
`99:9 101 :23 195:25
`
`199:18 201 :24,25
`202:6,7,10 204:4,7
`
`circuitry 50:17 52:13
`53:21 54:18 82:13
`
`83:5,21 88:25 89:7,
`11,12 90:8,12,19,22
`92:13,14,17 93:4,10,
`14 96:12 99:9,10
`100:12,14,17,20
`101:4,9,25102:8,15
`104:12,13114:12
`1152311720
`
`Confidential
`
`159:13178:4 219:22
`223:11 227:5
`
`Client 6:3
`
`Clint 159:6 228:4
`
`clock 52:15
`
`close 100:8110:7
`125:13184:5 205:15
`235:12
`
`closeout 23:17
`
`closing 23:11
`
`collaborative
`202:23
`
`college 18:7
`
`color 166:20
`
`column 62:20 63:3,
`10 66:18 72:16,19
`75:9 77:21 118:12,13
`141:13142:6174:5
`190:16 221 :15
`
`Index:
`
`change..controlling
`
`comparing 127:19
`
`consult 203:12,14
`
`compensate 82:4,8,
`11 99:22109:12
`
`consultant 14:23,25
`15:17 58:20
`
`compensated 47:18
`81 :4
`
`consulting 15:19
`155:13
`
`complete 165:18
`
`completely 147:20
`
`components 50:5
`53:3 82:7125:11
`202:8
`
`Compound 61 :20
`208:7
`
`computer 6625
`
`concept 29:23
`44:18,21 46:4116:25
`117:4,5134:23
`176:14195:9,13
`
`conception 37:14
`
`consumer 18:10,19
`48:8
`
`consumers 48:10
`
`contact 54:8,10
`168:16
`
`contest 169:16
`
`continuation 29:14
`
`continue 175:24
`
`continuous 183:10
`184:7 187:6
`
`contract 15:14
`
`contractor 22:21
`
`concepts 29:18
`
`contrary 147:20
`
`combination 212:17
`
`concerned 172:6
`
`combust 31:3
`
`conclusion 77:16
`98:23 120:8
`
`contributed 56:7
`157:7,9
`
`225:5
`
`Constance 69:16
`
`controlling 105:2
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`charging 52:24
`
`Charles 10:1420:14
`42:24 54:14 69:13
`117:3
`
`chart 74:14
`
`check 179:15
`
`chemical 192:16
`193:13
`
`chemically 181 :20
`
`chemist 57:10
`192:17,20 193:9
`
`chemistry 61 :11
`
`Chester 70:24
`
`chip 50:22,25 51 :2,7
`94:5
`
`Chuck 10:1416:21
`20:14 24:18 25:5
`27:7 42:25 43:2
`54:14 55:5 71 :13
`85:17 86:14 87:4
`116:24117:3130:3
`151:17176:13
`210:12 217:7 232:20
`
`121 :19,22,23 122:2,
`10,11 197:11 200:25
`201:18,23 205:23
`207:14 208:20,25
`214:20
`
`circuits 19:13 51:5
`96:18 204:2
`
`Civil 5:19
`
`claim 67:20118:11,
`12,14,17120:2
`176:24 221:10,11,13
`
`claimed 158:9,11,12
`
`claiming 160:23
`161 :10
`
`claims 133:4 220:14
`
`clarification 22:17
`57:5 76:24 109:7
`110:12
`
`clarify 231 :17
`
`clarifying 219:21
`
`clear 38:12 46:16
`49:4 59:14 61:13
`84:23 85:11 130:10
`
`comment 87:4
`
`comments 58:16
`86:15
`
`commercial 97:16,
`22
`
`condition 47:17 76:8
`79:17 192:3
`
`conditions 89:4
`
`conferred 36:18
`
`commercially 147:3
`
`confide 71:24
`
`communication
`41 :8
`
`communications
`12:5133:15,16
`
`company 6:16 87:21
`157:5,13,16,20,24
`158:25 164:23 211 :9
`
`Company's 33:8
`
`comparable 225:16
`
`compare 121:6
`126:7
`
`compared 108:22
`111:10114:13
`117:25120:3183:9
`
`184:7 198:5 204:15,
`19
`
`confidential 235:24
`
`confirmed 124:2,12
`
`confused 45:18
`106:5
`
`connection 16:19
`68:3 153:20 171 :8
`
`conserve 184:8
`
`Considerably
`1 1 0:1 9,20
`
`considered 220:5
`
`consistent 47:12,13
`76:12 79:16,19,21
`80:12,15,19,20
`112:13
`
`contribution 37:17
`56:14 58:7134:12,18
`158:8,10,15
`
`contributions 157:6
`158:1 1
`
`control 34:21 35:5
`36:17 39:21 40:16
`
`51 :7,25 54:18 63:5
`64:8,13,14,17,20
`65:7 83:4,21 88:25
`89:13117:20119:10,
`12,22 121:19,22,23
`122:2,9,11 135:22
`163:10190:15191:8
`
`221:18,22 222:19
`229:17
`
`controlled 120:17
`
`controller 50:13,15,
`18 51 :3,6,21 52:3,7,
`10 82:10 94:5
`
`119:10,12,16,22
`120:13192:4 202:2,
`4,8 203:25 204:2,4,6
`221:18,21 229:11
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 7 of 21 PageID# 21022
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 7 of 21 PagelD# 21022
`
`Confidential
`
`Index:
`
`controls..development
`
`D
`
`definition 41 :20 52:9
`
`DEFI'S 152:19
`
`describing 25:6
`186:24 220:24
`
`description 31 :5
`112:25170:16 221:2,
`3
`
`descriptions 173:12
`
`descriptive 168:12
`
`design 22:23 49:19,
`23 50:4,23 61:17
`82:21 86:4 93:23,25
`98:5,11,16 99:24
`101:3,8,13102:7,12,
`17,20,24 103:25
`122:3 195:24 199:25
`
`203:15 214:16 229:2,
`10,11
`
`designated 34:15
`37:6 158:7
`
`designed 50:9,11,
`12,16 80:5 94:12,21,
`24 95:3,7,25 96:11,
`15194:13 202:10
`203:2
`
`designing 50:24,25
`94:9
`
`controls 119:17
`
`conversations 14:5
`210:16
`
`cooler 181 :23 182:2,
`20,22,25183:10,16
`
`cooling 218:9
`
`coordinated 22:21
`
`coordination 56:23
`57:6
`
`coordinator 20:19
`56:16
`
`copied 188:12
`
`copy 165:18
`
`cordless 142:17,19
`147:16,19
`
`corner 53:18
`
`corporation 87:19
`
`correct 8:213:6,7,
`10,11 16:22,2317:22
`19:16,17 21 :9,10
`26:12 28:12 29:2,21
`30:23 31 :3,12,13
`33:20 34:17 36:24
`
`conespondence
`10:919:2185:7,10
`
`counsel 6:12 7:22
`8:20,2512:2213:9,
`20 36:21 41 :24 49:5
`
`98:10130:11,19
`133:16140:21 141:9
`
`152:7166:15167:4,
`19 234:4
`
`D-E-F 138:4
`
`D4 165:23166:2,17
`
`damage 120:10,14
`191 :25 192:7,10
`193:8,18194:18
`
`degree 18:9,17
`
`deliver 62:4 80:12
`142:22
`
`delivered 78:4
`112:13
`
`counselor 8:19
`
`dangerous 175:20
`
`delivering 79:13
`
`count 200:13,14
`201 :6
`
`counter 199:17
`
`counts 69:10 73:22
`
`199:8,12
`
`couple 12:8,14,15
`13:5 27:2 32:24
`
`171 :5 218:6,7 219:21
`230:14 234:15
`
`court 6:9 8:5128:13
`
`235:20 236:2,7,13
`
`courtroom 5:17
`
`cover 150:13,15
`
`covered 210:2
`
`data 10:7148:21,25
`149:13183:17,24
`184:14
`
`database 171 :17
`172:15 231 :22 232:3
`
`date 74:17 87:15
`144:22 172:25 173:3,
`4174:12179:24
`
`dated 6:4185:11,15
`230:15
`
`dates 20:3 68:17
`167:8
`
`Dave 58:12
`
`David 43:10,11 58:11
`
`delivery 80:20 81:10
`
`demonstrated
`131 :10,11
`
`density 44:23 45:2,
`16,20,24 46:5,8,11,
`18,22,24 47:4,5
`76:23 77:2,10 81 :21
`88:4 97:3104:14,16
`105:5,16106:10,14,
`18107:19108:21
`
`112:19113:2,5
`115:9,21,22,24
`117:6,7120:15,18,22
`134:24135:8141:8
`
`
`
`46:25 52:8,19 54:19
`55:3 56:20 61:23
`
`65:16 68:12 79:14,25
`80:21 82:22 83:12
`
`88:20 90:23 91 :6,18,
`23 92:17,25 93:10,
`14,20 94:21 95:4,16
`96:2,12 99:21 100:15
`101 :11,14,20 102:2
`105:18106:11
`
`108:14,15,17110:4,
`18111:11112:23
`
`113:6,13114:24
`115:6117:8119:3
`120:6122:12125:3
`133:5 142:9149:21
`
`165:15,16172:17
`173:14175:14178:7
`180:19182:17
`
`184:20 187:8,12
`188:22189:10190:8
`
`208:10,13,21 209:4
`213:23 214:8 215:17
`
`216:3,13,14 220:3
`223:15,24 224:15
`227:20 228:15
`234:20
`
`cycling 180:5
`
`Defendant's 153:13
`
`describe 62:8
`
`Defendants 138:4
`
`define 36:9163:24
`
`describes 75:10
`190:25
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`COVID 72:10
`
`COVID-19 5:6
`
`creating 142:22
`
`credit 205:24 206:2
`
`curious 122:25
`123:2 147:3
`
`current 7:11 21:24
`
`94:3,5 98:2142:18,
`20147:17155:25
`
`180:15,19,21 183:5
`206:14 217:15,21,23
`
`currents 97:12
`
`cushion 199:13
`
`custody 36:17
`
`cut 103:20
`
`cycle 78:18,19
`
`day 6:15129:22
`202:15 219:24
`234:13
`
`December 12:10
`13:9 70:13 171 :5
`
`decided 189:20
`
`deciding 175:18
`
`decision 71:10
`209:20
`
`decisions 99:3
`
`declaration 42:19
`133:7,9153:6
`
`deep 58:17
`
`Deevie 69:11
`
`DEF 138:4
`
`DEF_PUB_EDVA
`153:14
`
`177:10,23180:7
`195:10 220:3,6,18,24
`221 :4,24 222:23
`223:7,8
`
`Department 144:21
`
`depending 212:8
`215:3
`
`depends 52:9
`215:14,16
`
`deposed 7:15
`
`deposition 5:10,25
`7:6 9:1510:311:2
`12:1113:1716:20
`
`26:12 33:2,8,18 34:3,
`4,9,17 41 :5 68:3
`104:6108:13140:5
`
`153:21 160:20 171:9,
`19188:4194:9
`210:13 229:23
`
`230:22 232:10,20,25
`233:20 235:13
`
`depositions 231:22
`
`designs 22:22
`168:15 202:11
`
`detail 106:21 114:8
`193:25 194:5
`
`detailed 193:13
`211 :10 221:3
`
`details 49:11 129:18,
`23 184:5 226:4
`227:11 228:10 235:6
`
`determination
`169:2
`
`determine 116:17
`
`develop 178:5,16,22
`207:20,23
`
`developed 48:7
`90:15,18 92:15
`113:21 177:12190:7
`
`207:12,13,14 208:2,
`6,9,11,19,24
`
`developing 54:23
`227:3
`
`development 19:19
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 8 of 21 PageID# 21023
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 8 of 21 PagelD# 21023
`
`Confidential
`
`Index:
`
`device..electrical
`
`109:3114:18122:21,
`25123:16125:7
`
`distinguishing
`45:16
`
`127:8,11,17
`
`distortion 120:4
`
`drives 52:14
`
`driving 142:19
`147:18
`
`divestiture 210:23
`
`divide 201:21
`
`drop 81:2
`
`Due 5:6
`
`divulge 133:14
`
`duly 6:24
`
`document 23:15
`33:10,14 34:21 35:6,
`9 39:10 72:23 93:16
`
`duration 78:18,20
`
`Duty-cycle 53:17
`
`103:2,3,9,12104:4,5
`108:6122:14133:25
`
`135:18136:2,18,19
`137:23 138:9,13,20
`139:2,5,19140:6
`144:25145:3146:13
`
`151:7,24 152:2,7,8,
`21 153:5,8154:2,12,
`24155:11,24157:2
`165:19,21,24166:14,
`21 167:3,4,18
`168:18,22 169:7,22
`170:15,22,24 171:3,
`11,12,22,23 172:5,
`21,22 173:5,7,11
`174:13 175:5 181 :10
`
`185:4,21 188:2,3,10,
`11 194:7 224:20
`
`229:8,22 231:3
`234:2,3,4,6,10
`
`documentation
`13:2 49:20
`
`documents 9:18,19
`10:24 13:20,22,25
`15:22,23 16:3,5
`25:11 ,22 26:5,6,7,9,
`11 39:4 42:16162:24
`
`172:7,10,11 230:20,
`24 231:7,12,15,19
`232:2,9,12
`
`E
`
`e-liquid 217:11,15,22
`
`e.g. 142:16,19
`
`earlier 77:8 83:10
`106:7154:25190:8
`219:24
`
`early 115:3 217:10
`
`easier 65:4
`
`East 6:8
`
`Eastern 128:8,15
`
`educate 157:20
`
`educational 18:7
`
`EDVA 138:5152:19
`
`effect 53:5
`
`effects 192:16
`
`efficiency 184:15
`
`efficient 203:19
`206:22
`
`effort 54:8,22 56:6
`202:24
`
`EHCSS 135:9 226:23
`
`Donald 69:16
`
`electric 142:20
`
`doubt 148:6,10
`149:4,8 175:4
`
`dozen 60:8
`
`draft 143:25
`
`drafting 141:10
`
`draw 183:5
`
`electrical 18:9
`19:10,12,13 20:19,
`20,22,23 54:11,15,
`16,17 55:2,7,12 56:9,
`22,25 58:13,14,25
`59:15,19 60:6 61 :18
`73:11 109:23118:21,
`23119:11,13,23,25
`147:19148:14
`161:12192:5 204:23
`
`217:20 218:6,7
`
`difference 45:19,21
`73:7110:3111:18
`
`discussing 72:18,19
`231:3
`
`113:12,17120:2
`121:3122:17123:17
`125:15169:8 203:24
`205:11 229:20
`
`discussions 48:14
`135:10181:11
`
`distancing 5:8
`
`drill 142:20147:19
`
`differences 45:23
`
`distinction 219:25
`
`drink 75:21
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`22 139:7,16,23
`140:10,20,23 141 :16,
`20143:12,22144:15,
`17,23145:7146:14
`147:11 148:5,9
`149:2,14,17,19
`150:2,11,14 151 :2
`152:12153:2,12,16,
`24 154:8,21 156:3
`157:3 158:5,24
`159:11 160:3,8
`161:3,7,19,25
`162:12,25164:13,25
`165:7,9,22 166:5,9
`167:13,16169:15,20
`170:2,14,19 171 :21
`172:4,12,20 173:2
`175:25176:5,18
`177:15178:3,15
`179:11 180:17 181 :5
`
`182:4,12183:7,18
`184:18185:2,13,18
`187:18188:16189:7
`
`190:4,13,19191:7,11
`192:18193:4194:3
`
`195:4,22196:10,17,
`20197:13,17,25
`201 :13 203:16
`204:14 205:9 206:8
`
`207:21 208:8,18
`209:2,13 210:10
`211 :7 213:9,22
`214:11 215:5,15
`216:10 218:5,14,19
`219:3,6,12,19,20
`220:25 221 :9,16
`222:11 223:6,22
`230:17 231 :2,8,16,25
`232:8,16 233:7,12,24
`234:9 235:14,17
`236:9
`
`diagram 51 :25 52:5
`73:18 97:18121:21
`123:13 204:19
`
`diagrams 123:23
`
`died 155:20
`
`differently 66:4
`82:15
`
`difficulties 32:23
`
`direct 51 :14 73:13
`144:24 153:9
`
`directed 152:7
`165:19
`
`direction 225:15
`
`directions 65:8
`
`disagree 172:16
`235:10
`
`discharge 157:9
`158:13180:2,9,19,
`21,23181:13185:17
`186:25 187:5,6,22,23
`192:3
`
`discharged 187:11
`188:21
`
`discharges 180:16
`
`discharging 155:16
`187:19
`
`disclose 78:4
`
`disclosed 192:21
`204:25 205:5
`
`disclosure 134:4
`135:19137:2,24
`139:18140:18,22
`193:18 233:22
`
`discuss 11:4 139:19
`179:21 202:23
`
`discussed 11:3
`42:25 88:2 104:21
`
`106:7107:2117:15,
`17140:25194:16
`195:21 196:23
`204:13
`
`44:19 48:19 54:8
`
`55:2 56:15,17 57:13
`146:20175:16
`178:11 222:22
`232:24
`
`device 48:7 52:18,
`21 ,23,25 79:18100:3
`161 :12
`
`devices 94:10
`127:20142:17
`146:24147:17
`193:11 204:18
`222:20
`
`Devitt 5:21 6:14 7:3,5
`10:2,11 12:1217:14,
`19 28:23 29:8 31 :22
`
`32:5,8,15,21 33:5,23
`34:6,20 35:2,15,23
`36:20,22 38:17 39:9,
`14 41 :9,15,22 42:13
`46:14 48:23 49:2
`
`50:8 51 :4,13 54:6,24
`55:22 56:12 59:12
`61:22 62:18 63:21
`
`64:3 65:2,6,14 66:5
`73:2 74:6,7,22 75:5
`76:2,3 77:19 78:11,
`23 79:9 80:4,10 81 :7,
`18 83:8,18 84:8,11,
`18 86:11,24 87:12
`89:24 90:14 91 :4,9,
`17 92:5,7,22 93:18
`94:18 95:2,9,21
`96:10,17 97:14 98:8,
`25 99:18100:9,23
`101 :10,19 102:6,13,
`22103:17,24104:10,
`22105:14106:3,17
`107:3,10,22108:10
`109:2,21 110:9
`111:6,16,24112:11,
`18113:11,19114:4,
`9,19116:9,19
`117:19,24118:8,10,
`15119:8,20120:12
`121 :4,7,12,14 122:8,
`19123:10,15,24
`124:7,16,25 125:8,
`19,22 126:3,6,9
`127:4,7,23 128:4,9,
`14,21 ,25 129:15
`130:17,23 133:20
`134:10135:12,16,17
`136:6,14,21 137:10,
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 9 of 21 PageID# 21024
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 9 of 21 PagelD# 21024
`
`entitled 9:3 39:16
`135:19144:18
`176:24
`
`equipment 19:14
`59:3134:19142:16
`147:15 212:24
`
`equipped 159:2
`
`errata 236:10
`
`essentially 31 :7
`204:8 225:10
`
`et al 39:16
`
`evaluated 24:21
`
`evaluation 207:7
`
`eventually 19:23
`48:10
`
`EXAMINATION 7:2
`234:16
`
`examined 6:25
`
`227:19 230:8,10
`
`electrically 19:20
`96:9 97:3 141 :6
`195:11 217:12
`
`electro 192:20
`
`Electrochemical
`144:19
`
`electronic 26:15
`49:18,23 50:17
`
`electronics 18:10,19
`
`element 60:25
`118:21,24119:25
`192:6
`
`elements 49:13 50:5
`61 :2
`
`Ellen 69:10
`
`employed 14:22
`43:16
`
`employees 21 :24
`43:21 44:3
`
`enabled 96:7177:24
`
`Confidential
`
`79:20,22,23 80:6,13,
`20131:7148:15
`149:5 217:14 227:12
`
`experienced 228:17
`
`expert 78:7 105:21
`109:18,19114:15
`116:3,5,10,16119:5,
`19139:10143:6
`144:8146:10147:10
`148:23164:16177:8
`
`180:12181:2,17,19
`183:3,12184:11,23
`189:23192:19
`194:24 215:12 218:2
`220:22 222:7 223:4
`
`experts 164:20
`181 :11
`
`explain 44:25 45:22
`49:17 198:10
`
`explode 142:23
`
`explodes 115:11
`
`explosion 230:3
`
`explosions 228:23
`
`Index:
`
`electrically..form
`
`13:21 14:7,8 42:6,8,9
`46:11,24 47:21
`48:13,19 79:3108:16
`131:8143:15156:21
`
`157:17,25 160:25
`161 :4,8,15 170:6
`188:17193:9195:17
`198:5 201:8 212:25
`223:23 232:21
`
`fairly 31 :4 102:25
`108:18109:15
`
`fall 222:3
`
`familiar 35:17 36:25
`37:4 39:5,7 40:8
`69:18 77:24 78:2
`85:20
`
`feasibility 135:4,6
`
`190:3 209:24
`
`fill 18:2
`
`find 17:25 25:19 39:4
`123:2 167:4,20
`169:17,21 172:13
`190:17
`
`finding 146:5,23
`
`fine 30:7 36:20,21
`40:4 71 :22 84:9
`126:5130:20 168:3
`
`finished 105:9
`118:17
`
`finishing 122:7
`
`fire 142:23
`
`fired 230:2
`
`feasible 174:8,25
`
`firm 11:9 207:10
`
`Federal 5:18
`
`feedback 225:4
`
`firmly 225:19
`
`firmware 50:22 51 :2
`52:16 82:10
`
`fits 52:5
`
`99:11 172:14
`
`exceed 131:12
`142:21 154:14,17
`155:2,12,21 156:13
`157:8158:13180:9,
`23 181 :13 203:14
`
`exceeding 156:20
`
`excuse 75:21 170:10
`
`exhibit 31 :24,25
`32:10,24 33:2,24
`34:2,4 39:11,12,15
`63:22,24,25 68:5
`72:12 73:16 75:8
`
`91 :10,12,13,15 92:8
`129:2135:13140:12,
`13,14,18144:16
`150:12152:13,14,15,
`16,17,22,23 166:2,6,
`19169:6170:15,16,
`20 176:3 185:8,9,14
`190:14 221 :10
`
`exhibits 31 :23 32:24
`
`exist 26:6
`
`existed 62:10 78:25
`
`enables 181 :21
`
`enabling 177:10
`
`end 17:13 66:20 67:5
`111 :21 140:8 221 :12
`
`ended 216:18,19
`
`energy 76:7 88:4
`144:21 163:17
`184:16199:24
`
`229:17,20
`
`engineer 19:10
`20:20,22 22:11 55:12
`58:13,25 98:18
`109:23148:15
`204:23 217:20
`
`engineering 18:9
`49:13,16,21 54:10,11
`58:14
`
`engineers 20:24
`218:7
`
`ensure 8019
`
`existence 29:6
`
`entire 57:24 152:6
`168:22
`
`entirety 153:5
`
`expect 26:5153:4
`
`expensive 176:16
`
`experience 57:15
`
`extend 193:12
`
`extensive 180:4
`
`extent 9:21 28:13,14
`41 :7 77:15 78:6
`83:14114:15116:2
`120:7138:21 141:3
`143:5177:6181:16
`183:13 201 :9 203:9
`213:20 215:11
`220:21 222:6 223:3
`
`external 105:2
`109:13
`
`F
`
`face 144:21 150:12
`160:13162:15164:9
`
`facility 228:11
`
`fact 97:6115:3
`119:14123:25147:6
`
`factor 177:10
`
`failure 172:5
`
`fair 8:23,2410:22
`
`feel 40:13,14 47:13
`62:6,7 74:15 76:10,
`14 79:12,24,25
`116:16
`
`Ferry 7:13
`
`field 53:4,5
`
`figure 51 :15,17,22,24
`52:17 53:22 65:20
`
`73:14,17 90:13,19,21
`91 :5,6 92:6 95:15
`97:19 99:10101:11,
`12,13,24104:11
`119:16121:8,11,12,
`17,18122:10,11
`123:9,11 125:19
`126:6,8,11,12,14,15,
`16,24 127:5,12
`137:12145:6 204:5
`233:3
`
`figures 52:2 65:15
`74:23126:19127:9
`204:3
`
`file 132:23 152:17,23
`153:3,6176:9179:2
`189:20 205:3
`
`filed 68:18,24 70:12
`74:20 79:11 114:23
`129:6 143:3 146:8
`164:3177:17189:9
`
`fixed 45:4,25 77:5
`220:7 225:12,13
`
`Fleischhauer 39:16
`42:22 60:24 61 :9
`68:6 69:11
`
`Fleischhauer's
`56:14
`
`flip 66:24
`
`Florida 231 :22
`
`flow 119:10,12,17,23
`183:16 221:19,22
`
`focus 30:20142:12
`
`focused 30:3 221:14
`
`folks 61:5
`
`follow 48:17 65:7
`230:19
`
`font 125:9
`
`fool 201:4
`
`form 50:2,19 53:25
`54:20 80:3 86:7
`87:10 90:10 92:18
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 10 of 21 PageID# 21025
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 10 of 21 PagelD# 21025
`
`Index:
`
`forms..identification
`
`127:13 203:21
`206:22 229:18
`
`heater-resistant
`53:12
`
`hired 70:16 207:10
`
`histogram 112:21
`
`history 152:17,23
`153:4 180:5
`
`heaters 56:18 79:14
`83:25 84:2 89:11
`94:11 222:19
`
`hits 77:7
`
`hold 30:16
`
`Confidential
`
`184:2
`
`Hairfield's 134:17
`
`Hajalogol 69:12
`
`half 84:5
`
`hand 39:24126:10
`
`Handbook 166:7
`
`handle 89:7 94:3,4
`98:2131:6194:13
`
`198:13,23
`
`handled 82:15
`
`handling 198:20
`
`Hang 60:12
`
`forms 47:6 50:17
`
`found 90:19171:16
`185:6
`
`foundation 42:12
`46:13 51 :9 56:4 59:9
`62:13 63:18 65:23
`
`80:8,24 81 :15 89:21
`94:15,23 96:14100:6
`102:19104:19
`105:20 106:24
`116:14117:13118:5
`134:7146:10147:10
`
`148:8,23 150:25
`154:20 156:24
`
`159:10 161 :6,23
`164:18178:9187:14
`205:8 209:10 211:4
`223:20
`
`frame 13:1015:14
`225:3
`
`Fran 186:11 211:19,
`20,21 226:16
`
`Francis 211 :19
`
`116:5126:3,4134:25
`137:14145:9179:24
`190:14 191 :7
`
`giving 8:9166:15
`
`goal 47:8 77:7 79:21
`
`Gold 5:11 6:10
`
`Goldy 5:11 6:10
`128:11 235:17
`
`good 5:2 7:4 16:4
`21 :22 39:20 55:11
`
`63:9 64:7,10,12
`67:12,17 72:9 75:15
`84:6125:25128:12,
`22,24 132:8176:14
`177:17178:24179:7,
`8187:24 201 :12
`
`218:12,13 219:10,11
`
`gosh 18:24 20:10
`21 :4
`
`grade 209:21
`
`Grant 11:14 88:10
`
`graph 163:17
`
`heating 29:20 30:22,
`25 60:24 61 :2
`
`118:21,24119:25
`192:6 217:15 218:10
`
`heavily 57:12
`
`helped 216:21
`
`helpful 74:5
`
`happen 175:8 181 :21
`193:15
`
`hesitate 24:4 70:14
`
`happened 39:4
`210:7
`
`happening 148:13
`
`hard 29:10 56:10
`66:24135:10168:10
`
`hey 84:4160:23
`178:23 218:14
`225:15
`
`Higgins 10:14,15,17
`16:21 20:14,15 24:19
`25:5 27:7 42:24,25
`43:2 54:14 55:3,8
`56:21 59:20 69:13
`
`Holdings 6:2,15 33:7
`
`honest 8:9
`
`hooked 229:13
`
`hoping 175:23
`
`hot 142:23
`
`Houck 69:14
`
`hour 15:4 84:5
`125:24 210:14
`
`hourly 15:3
`
`hours 12:22,24 13:3,
`15,16,19 41 :4,16
`42:5 194:9
`
`huge 189:17 209:7
`
`
`
`64:16,17 76:6 91:11
`
`Hairfield 160:4,14
`
`TSG Reporting — Worldwide
`
`877—702-9580
`
`front 40:14 95:10,12
`129:7137:24150:13,
`15
`
`full 8:9 47:16 76:7
`169:21 176:25
`199:17
`
`fulsome 172:7
`
`future 174:17,22
`175:5,9
`
`fuzzy 74:2
`
`G
`
`gave 22:22,24 25:21
`102:23 143:23
`
`general 15:16 220:15
`
`generally 168:12
`
`generation 24:14
`81 :24 174:17
`
`generations 62:17
`
`generous 21 :21
`
`give 8:18 34:20 36:2
`41 :19 47:13 49:11
`
`great 142:18147:17
`
`greater 187:5
`
`grew 47:20
`
`hardware 117:16
`196:25
`
`harm 191:2
`
`Harry 135:15
`
`Grier 42:22,23 69:11
`
`hate 156:11
`
`ground 7:21
`
`Hayes 69:12
`
`71 :13,15,17 85:17
`87:13116:24117:3
`
`131:5,17134:22
`151:17160:14
`176:13 202:18 217:7
`
`232:18,20 235:2
`
`hundred 78:17
`
`Hutch's 211:21
`
`hypothetical 213:8
`
`hypothetically
`213:6
`
`head 20:18 219:23
`
`Higgins' 86:14 87:4
`232:19 233:19
`
`group 23:12 29:25
`56:2,6 59:11,13,15,
`19134:4 226:13,16
`229:6 230:8,11
`
`guarantee 168:13
`230:3
`
`guess 12:916:17
`148:12162:5172:15
`173:20191:12 224:8
`226:11
`
`guessing 161:21,24
`
`guy 216:21
`
`guys 219:12 231 :6,
`18,19
`
`H
`
`heading 20:8
`
`headquartered 6:8
`
`health 71:18 233:2,6
`
`healthy 233:20
`
`hear 18:17 29:10
`103:17182:14
`
`heard 71:19
`
`heat 31:3,11 56:19
`183:16 217:21,22,24
`
`heated 19:20 96:9
`97:4141:6195:12
`217:12
`
`heater 47:12,18 53:9,
`10,1156:15,17 61 :10
`81 :3 83:4125:11
`
`Higgins's 20:16
`
`I-CAD 82:16
`
`Higginsin 210:12
`
`high 89:3 97:12
`177:25180:15,19,20
`185:16192:3199:23
`206:14
`
`higher 82:8,11 89:8,
`15 94:3,5 98:2
`109:12110:18,19,20,
`21111:9197:3
`198:19199:10
`201 :20 229:18
`
`higher-level 49:12
`
`highlight 144:25
`145:5
`
`highlighting 146:2
`
`idea 25:25 27:17
`30:15 62:2 78:24
`81:20 88:16 99:19
`114:21 140:2168:24
`175:10176:21
`187:25 217:18 218:3
`
`ideally 141 :18
`
`identical 106:21
`107:4,6,17,24,25
`120:20122:17
`
`123:18,23124:2,12
`125:3,14127:21
`203:21
`
`identification 33:4
`34:5 39:13 64:2
`91:16140:19152:25
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 11 of 21 PageID# 21026
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LO-TCB Document 782-1 Filed 07/09/21 Page 11 of 21 PagelD# 21026
`
`Index:
`
`identified..layout
`
` J
`
`L
`
`Confidential
`
`interruption 32:12
`
`introduce 6:12 32:24
`
`Introduction 145:11
`
`J.E. 185:15
`
`L12 144:16,18
`
`invent 95:23
`
`invented 104:17
`113:3161:11195:7
`
`invention 37:15
`62:24 96:5 97:15
`106:8115:8131:3
`
`134:4135:19137:2,
`23 140:18,22 141 :4,5
`222:4 233:21 235:4
`
`inventor 40:22,24
`44:11 51:1168:12
`
`71 :2 91 :22,24 95:14,
`20 96:2 98:21 116:21
`161:14162:16
`
`inventor's 37:17
`55:19 158:8
`
`Jack 43:6,7 57:20,21
`
`L2 170:15
`
`January 150:18
`151 :20 167:12
`
`Japan 43:25 130:25
`202:18
`
`JLR 229:2
`
`joined 20:4,9,13
`68:20 70:15
`
`joint 54:22
`
`Jones 6:14
`
`Judy 55:16
`
`June 129:6,9,11
`185:11,15188:18,19
`
`K
`
`Keen 69:14
`
`L8 185:2,4
`
`LA 87:19,21 207:11
`
`lab 22:22
`
`labeled 5:24
`
`Labs 144:20147:21
`
`lacks 42:11 46:12
`51 :8 56:3 59:8 62:12
`
`63:17 65:22 80:

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket