Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 1 of 32 PageID#
`39669
`
`Exhibit 14
`Public Redacted
`Version
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 2 of 32 PageID#
`
`39670
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
`WASHINGTON, D.C.
`
`Before the Honorable Clark S. Cheney
`Administrative Law Judge
`
`
`
`
`In The Matter Of
`
`CERTAIN TOBACCO HEATING ARTICLES
`AND COMPONENTS THEREOF
`
`
`
`Investigation No. 337-TA-1199
`
`RESPONDENTS ALTRIA CLIENT SERVICES LLC’S, ALTRIA GROUP, INC.’S, AND
`PHILIP MORRIS USA INC.’S EIGHTH SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSES AND
`OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINANTS RAI STRATEGIC HOLDINGS, INC.’S, R.J.
`REYNOLDS VAPOR COMPANY’S, AND R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY’S
`FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES (NOS. 1-19)
`
`Pursuant to the United States International Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice and
`
`Procedure, 19 C.F.R. §§ 210.27 and 210.29, Respondents Altria Client Services LLC, (“ACS”)
`
`Altria Group, Inc., (“AGI”), and Philip Morris USA Inc., (“PM USA”), (collectively, “Altria”),
`
`by their undersigned attorneys, hereby supplement their responses to Complainants’ RAI
`
`Strategic Holdings, Inc., (“RAI”), R.J. Reynolds Vapor Company (“RJRV”), and R.J. Reynolds
`
`Tobacco Company’s (“RJRT”), (collectively, “Complainants”) First Set of Interrogatories Nos.
`
`1-191 as follows:
`
`
`1 As acknowledged in the Parties’ correspondence of May 20 and 21, 2020, Complainants have
`withdrawn their Interrogatory No. 20, originally served on May 18, 2020. As such, Respondents
`do not provide any response to that Interrogatory.
`
`1
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 3 of 32 PageID#
`
`39671
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`that penetrates the tobacco stick, including any research and development efforts undertaken by
`
`You relating to the use of such a heating blade. Include in Your response the Identity of each
`
`Document by production number that supports Your answer.
`
`RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
`
`Altria incorporates all of its general objections and reservations of rights as if specifically
`
`alleged herein. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks information protected from
`
`disclosure by the attorney-client privilege, work product immunity, common interest, or any other
`
`applicable privilege or protection. Altria objects to this Interrogatory because it seeks information
`
`that is outside the scope of the investigation, and is not relevant to the claim or defense of any
`
`party, to the extent it requests information regarding products other than heat-not-burn systems.
`
`Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks material subject to third-party
`
`confidentiality restrictions. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent the documents or
`
`information requested are publicly available and/or equally available to the requesting party.
`
`Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent the documents or information requested are not in
`
`Altria’s possession, custody, and/or control. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as overly broad,
`
`unduly burdensome, vague, and ambiguous as to the phrase “Your decision.” Altria objects to this
`
`Interrogatory as overly broad, unduly burdensome, vague, and ambiguous as to the phrase “heating
`
`element” and “heating blade.” Altria objects to this Interrogatory as overly broad and unduly
`
`burdensome on the grounds that it is unbounded in time. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as
`
`prematurely seeking disputed legal and factual contentions. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as
`
`premature to the extent it seeks claim construction or expert opinions before the appropriate
`
`deadlines.
`
`Response: Subject to the foregoing exceptions and without waiving its objections, Altria
`
`14
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 4 of 32 PageID#
`
`39672
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`states:
`
`
`
` Altria has not yet completed its investigation of the facts, and Altria reserves the right
`
`to supplement and/or amend this response as further information becomes available.
`
`INTERROGATORY NO. 4:
`
`
`
`Identify all patents and/or patent applications that include patent claims that You contend
`
`cover any aspect of the IQOS® system, including the system itself, components of the system,
`
`and/or the use of either of the foregoing. Include in Your response the Identity of each Document
`
`by production number that supports Your answer.
`
`RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 4:
`
`Altria incorporates all of its general objections and reservations of rights as if specifically
`
`alleged herein. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks information protected from
`
`disclosure by the attorney-client privilege, work product immunity, common interest, or any other
`
`applicable privilege or protection. Altria objects to this Interrogatory because it seeks information
`
`that is outside the scope of the investigation, and is not relevant to the claim or defense of any
`
`party. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks material subject to third-party
`
`confidentiality restrictions. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent the documents or
`
`information requested are not in Altria’s possession, custody, and/or control. Altria objects to this
`
`Interrogatory as overly broad, unduly burdensome, vague, and ambiguous as to the phrase “use”
`
`of the IQOS® system.
`
`Response: Subject to the foregoing exceptions and without waiving its objections, Altria
`
`states:
`
`Altria is willing to meet and confer to determine what relevant information, if any,
`
`15
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 5 of 32 PageID#
`
`39673
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Complainants are seeking with this Interrogatory.
`
`FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 4 (JUNE 16, 2020):
`
`Objections: Altria incorporates by reference its Specific Objections to this Interrogatory,
`
`served on May 28, 2020, as if fully stated herein.
`
`Response: Altria further responds to this Interrogatory as follows:
`
`Altria confirms that the IQOS® system has not been marked with any identification of
`
`patents covering the system.
`
`SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 4 (JULY 13, 2020):
`
`Objections: Altria incorporates by reference its Specific Objections to this Interrogatory,
`
`served on May 28, 2020, as if fully stated herein.
`
`Response: Altria further responds to this Interrogatory as follows:
`
`
`
`
`
`Altria reserves the right to supplement and/or amend this response as further information
`
`becomes available, and/or after responsive, non-privileged documents are otherwise produced.
`
`INTERROGATORY NO. 5:
`
`
`
`For each Product identified in response to Interrogatory No. 1, Identify all entities that sell
`
`or offer for sale each said Product for importation into the United States, import said Products into
`
`the United States, and/or offer for sale or sell said Products after they have been imported into the
`
`United States, and state the place of business of each entity and geographical location where each
`
`of the foregoing activities is or has been performed. Include in Your response the Identity of each
`
`Document that supports Your answer, as well as the individuals most knowledgeable thereof.
`
`RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 5:
`
`Altria incorporates all of its general objections and reservations of rights as if specifically
`
`alleged herein. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks information protected from
`
`16
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 6 of 32 PageID#
`
`39674
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`disclosure by the attorney-client privilege, work product immunity, common interest, or any other
`
`applicable privilege or protection. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent it seeks material
`
`subject to third-party confidentiality restrictions. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent
`
`the documents or information requested are publicly available and/or equally available to the
`
`requesting party. Altria objects to this Interrogatory to the extent the documents or information
`
`requested are not in Altria’s possession, custody, and/or control. Altria objects to this Interrogatory
`
`as overly broad, unduly burdensome, vague, and ambiguous as to the phrase “all entities.” Altria
`
`objects to this Interrogatory as overly broad and unduly burdensome to the extent it is duplicative
`
`of Interrogatory Nos. 6, 8, and 9. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as prematurely seeking
`
`disputed legal and factual contentions. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as overly broad, unduly
`
`burdensome, vague, and ambiguous for seeking “individuals most knowledgeable” regarding each
`
`subpart of this Interrogatory. Altria objects to this Interrogatory as including multiple subparts.
`
`Response: Subject to the foregoing exceptions and without waiving its objections, Altria
`
`states:
`
`-
`
`. Philip Morris USA Inc. is located at 6601 West Broad Street, Richmond, VA 23230. On
`
`
`
`information and belief, PMP is located at Quai Jeanrenaud 3, 2000 Neuchâtel, Switzerland.
`
`Further, the IQOS® system has been sold through the e-commerce website operated by
`
`PFSweb. The IQOS® system has also been sold at IQOS retail stores located at: i) Lenox Square
`
`Mall, 3393 Peachtree Rd., Unit 3107, Atlanta, GA 30326; ii) Mall of Georgia, 3333 Buford Drive,
`
`Space 1004, Buford, GA 30519; and iii) 3402 W. Cary St., Richmond, VA 23221.
`
`
`
`
`
`.
`
`17
`
`

`

`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 7 of 32 PageID#
`39675
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`The IQOS® system has also been available for purchase by employees and visitors at select
`
`tempora1y mobile locations, including: i) Little 5 Points, 323 Moreland Ave. NE, Atlanta, GA
`
`30307; ii) Altria (Headquarters Annex) , 6603 West Broad Street, Richmond, VA 23230; iii) Altria
`
`(Center for Research & Technology), 601 East Jackson Street, Richmond, VA 23219; and iv)
`
`Altria (Manufacturing Center), 3601 Commerce Road, Richmond, VA 23234. The compatible
`
`tobacco sticks are sold nationally through commercial retailers.
`
`Pursuant to Rule 210.29(c), Altria further expects to produce non-privileged documents
`
`from which infon nation requested by this InteITogatory may be asce1iained or derived. Altria
`
`reserves the right to supplement and/or amend this response as fu1ther infonnation becomes
`
`available, and/or after responsive, non-privileged documents are othe1wise produced.
`
`FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY N O. 5 (JUNE 162 2020):
`
`Objections: Altria incmporates by reference its Specific Objections to this InteITogatory,
`
`served on May 28, 2020, as if fully stated herein.
`
`Response: Altria fuiiher responds to this InteITogatory as follows:
`
`The compatible tobacco sticks have been sold or offered for sale in the Richmond, VA and
`
`Atlanta, GA areas through the below commercial retailers:
`
`Retailer
`Walgreen Co.
`Wal green Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Wal green Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Wal green Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Atlanta Retailers
`
`Address
`2444 Dallas Hwy SW
`4075 Cherokee St NW
`2988 Shallowford Rd
`2779 Cobb Pkwy NW
`695 W Crossville Rd
`6120 Old National Hwy
`4535 Roswell Rd
`12305 Crabapple Rd
`2711 Metropolitan Pkwy SW
`7530 Roswell Rd
`
`18
`
`County
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`Postal Code
`30064
`30144
`30066
`30152
`30075
`30349
`30342
`30004
`30315
`30350
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 8 of 32 PageID#
`
`39676
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Murphy USA
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Circle K Procurement and
`Brands Ltd.
`Walgreen Co.
`Circle K Procurement and
`Brands Ltd.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`173 S Main St
`5510 Windward Pkwy
`2990 Five Forks Trickum Rd
`5985 Peachtree Pkwy
`5435 Five Forks
`1065 Duluth Hwy
`4865 Old Hwy 5
`1135 Highway 92
`9665 Knox Bridge Hwy
`155 Hames Rd
`7944 Highway 92
`9765 Highway 92
`1465 Riverstone Pkwy
`1470 Towne Lake Pkwy
`6090 Highway 92
`443 Olde Rope Mill Park Rd
`1490 Riverstone Pkwy
`110 Old Doss Dr
`1556 Riverstone Pkwy
`6665 Highway 85
`5675 Jonesboro Rd
`2464 Roswell Rd
`2337 Canton Rd
`2670 Cobb Pkwy SE
`7039 Mableton Pkwy SE
`1625 Old 41 Hwy NW
`2550 Spring Rd SE
`2390 S Cobb Dr SE
`1461 Veterans Memorial Hwy
`SE
`600 S Marietta Pkwy SE
`1350 S Cobb Dr SE
`5001 Cherokee St
`4290 E West Connector SE
`
`4706 Lower Roswell Rd
`5000 Floyd Rd SW
`
`1760 Bells Ferry Rd
`2491 Macland Rd SW
`640 Franklin Gtwy SE
`5191 S Cobb Dr SE
`
`19
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Cherokee
`Clayton
`Clayton
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`30009
`30004
`30044
`30092
`30047
`30043
`30188
`30102
`30114
`30188
`30189
`30188
`30114
`30189
`30102
`30188
`30114
`30115
`30114
`30274
`30260
`30062
`30066
`30080
`30126
`30152
`30080
`30080
`
`30126
`30060
`30060
`30101
`30082
`
`30068
`30126
`
`30066
`30064
`30067
`30080
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 9 of 32 PageID#
`
`39677
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`Murphy USA
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Murphy USA
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Murphy USA
`
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`7130 Mableton Pkwy SE
`2671 Spring Rd SE
`692 Powder Springs St
`2761 Cobb Pkwy NW
`105 Barrett Pkwy
`2466 Delk Rd SE
`3111 Cobb Pkwy Nw Musa
`District 10639
`5350 Floyd Rd SW
`3033 Johnson Ferry Rd
`3350 Dallas Hwy SW
`3299 Canton Rd
`1900 Lower Roswell Rd
`2732 Powder Springs Rd SW
`671 Cobb Pkwy N
`2580 Sandy Plains Rd
`2975 Delk Rd SE
`2691 Chastain Meadows Pkwy
`Musa District 10639
`855 Veterans Memorial Hwy
`SE
`23 S Marietta Pkwy SW
`3888 Cobb Pkwy NW
`4350 Wade Green Rd NW
`4340 Bells Ferry Rd NW
`825 Sandy Plains Rd
`4331 Bells Ferry Rd NW
`2180 Windy Hill Rd SE
`4495 S Cobb Dr SE
`3964 Floyd Rd
`2804 Paces Ferry Rd SE
`4371 S Cobb Dr SE
`4455 Wade Green Rd NW
`1787 Cobb Pkwy S
`1400 Ernest W Barrett Pkwy
`NW
`4635 Woodstock Rd
`3110 Roswell Rd
`4410 Canton Rd
`840 Church St NE
`900 Whitlock Ave NW
`3103 Roswell Rd
`
`20
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Cobb
`
`30126
`30080
`30064
`30152
`30066
`30067
`
`30101
`30126
`30062
`30064
`30066
`30068
`30064
`30062
`30066
`30067
`
`30066
`
`30126
`30064
`30101
`30144
`30144
`30066
`30144
`30080
`30080
`30106
`30339
`30080
`30144
`30060
`
`30152
`30075
`30062
`30066
`30060
`30064
`30062
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 10 of 32 PageID#
`
`39678
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Pilot
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`Murphy USA
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`
`Dekalb
`2945 Panola Rd
`Dekalb
`6671 Covington Hwy
`Dekalb
`5448 E Ponce De Leon Ave
`Dekalb
`2035 Candler Rd
`Dekalb
`585 Dekalb Industrial Way
`Dekalb
`2065 S Hairston Rd
`Dekalb
`2746 Clairmont Rd NE
`Dekalb
`3356 Lawrenceville Hwy
`Dekalb
`4765 Redan Rd
`Dekalb
`2154 Johnson Ferry Rd NE
`Dekalb
`3830 Rockbridge Rd
`Dekalb
`4086 Pleasantdale Rd
`Dekalb
`3249 Buford Hwhy NE
`6901 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Dekalb
`3584 Wesley Chapel Rd
`Dekalb
`3317 Lawrenceville Hwy
`Dekalb
`2781 Lavista Rd
`Dekalb
`5511a Chamblee Dunwoody
`Dekalb
`Rd
`Dekalb
`5500 Buford Hwy NE
`Dekalb
`4113 Covington Hwy
`Dekalb
`5347 Peachtree Indus
`5373 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Dekalb
`4050 Buford Hwy NE
`Dekalb
`4330 Chamblee Tucker Rd
`Dekalb
`2601 Bouldercrest Rd SE
`Dekalb
`1999 Mountain Industrial Blvd Dekalb
`2805 Chamblee Tucker Rd
`Dekalb
`2375 N Druid Hills Rd NE
`Dekalb
`5320 Memorial Dr
`Dekalb
`3858 Covington Hwy
`Dekalb
`3630 Clairmont Rd
`Dekalb
`1836 Briarcliff Rd NE
`Dekalb
`9294 Highway 5
`Douglas
`5415 Atlanta Hwy Musa
`District 10632
`1655 Buford Hwy
`888 Buford Rd
`2830 Keith Bridge Rd
`510 Peachtree Pkwy
`3611 Peachtree Pkwy
`3310 Buford Hwy
`
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`
`21
`
`30038
`30058
`30083
`30032
`30033
`30035
`30329
`30084
`30088
`30319
`30083
`30340
`30329
`30360
`30034
`30084
`30033
`
`30338
`30340
`30032
`30341
`30341
`30345
`30084
`30316
`30084
`30341
`30329
`30083
`30032
`30341
`30329
`30134
`
`30004
`30041
`30041
`30041
`30041
`30024
`30041
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 11 of 32 PageID#
`
`39679
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Circle K Procurement And
`Brands Ltd.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`Fulton
`3003 Old Alabama Rd
`Fulton
`4395 Kimball Bridge Rd
`Fulton
`2429 Bolton Rd NW
`Fulton
`761 Sidney Marcus Blvd NE
`Fulton
`1180 Virginia Ave
`595 Piedmont Ave Ne Ste 100 Fulton
`420 E Crossville Rd
`Fulton
`3658 Roswell Rd NW
`Fulton
`3800 Princeton Lakes Pkwy
`SW
`7884 Roswell Rd
`10920 State Bridge Rd
`8200 Dunwoody Pl
`11877 Douglas Rd Windwood
`Village
`2645 Old Milton Pkwy
`3740 Cascade Rd SW
`6410 W Johns Xing
`20 E Crossville Rd
`2893 Peachtree Rd NE
`1545 Mansell Rd
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`280 Rucker Rd
`11700 Haynes Bridge Rd
`3190 Old Milton Pkwy
`910 Mcfarland Pkwy
`25 Peachtree St SW
`855 Peachtree St NE
`1590 Mansell Rd
`1678 Howell Mill Rd NW
`5604 E Lawrenceville Hwy
`3205 Stone Mountain Hwy
`2075 Lawrenceville Suwanee
`Rd
`3747 Lawrenceville Hwy
`2682 Buford Dr
`2008 Scenic Hwy N
`2705 Buford Hwy
`1556 Lawrenceville Hwy
`181 S Clayton St
`624 Buford Dr
`3940 Atlanta Hwy
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`22
`
`30022
`30022
`30318
`30324
`30344
`30308
`30075
`30342
`
`30331
`30350
`30022
`30350
`
`30005
`30009
`30331
`30097
`30075
`30305
`30009
`
`30004
`30009
`30005
`30004
`30303
`30308
`30009
`30318
`30047
`30078
`
`30024
`30044
`30043
`30078
`30096
`30044
`30046
`30046
`30052
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 12 of 32 PageID#
`
`39680
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`
`
`
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`
`Murphy USA
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`
`Murphy USA
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`
`Murphy USA
`
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`
`Murphy USA
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`Murphy USA
`
`Murphy USA
`
`Murphy USA
`Racetrac Petroleum
`
`23
`
`1565 Pleasant Hill Rd
`3490 Centerville Hwy
`4006 Buford Hwy
`3255 Sardis Church Rdmusa
`District 10638
`741 W Pike St
`3405 Sugarloaf Pkwy
`1490 Pleasant Hill Rd
`3844 Satellite Blvd
`1515 Beaver Ruin Rd
`6182 S Norcross Tucker Rd
`1385 Grayson Hwy
`5795 Jimmy Carter Blvd
`444 W Pike St
`6065 Singleton Rd
`3229 Peachtree Corners Cir
`4080 Buford Dr
`3495 Satellite Blvd
`6590 Sugarloaf Pkwy Side
`2500 Old Norcross Rd
`2365 Buford Dr
`1912 Main St
`200 S Clayton St
`17 Satellite Blvd Nemusa
`Gwinnett
`District 10638
`1075 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`5296 Jimmy Carter Blvd
`Gwinnett
`3840 Highway 78 W
`Gwinnett
`1090 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`3950
`Lawrenceville Hwy
`Nwmusa District 10638
`3359 Lawrenceville Suwanee
`Rd
`2625 Pleasant Hill Rdmusa
`District 10638
`2592 Pleasant Hill Rd
`1759 Rockbridge Rdmusa
`District 10639
`1410 Lawrenceville Hwymusa
`District 10638
`3425 Centerville Hwymusa
`District 10639
`906 Pleasant Hill Rd
`
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`
`Gwinnett
`Gwinnett
`
`30096
`30039
`30096
`
`30519
`30045
`30044
`30096
`30096
`30093
`30084
`30045
`30071
`30046
`30093
`30092
`30518
`30096
`30097
`30044
`30043
`30078
`30046
`
`30024
`30024
`30093
`30039
`30024
`
`30047
`
`30024
`
`30096
`30096
`
`30087
`
`30044
`
`30039
`30044
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 13 of 32 PageID#
`
`39681
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`Walgreen Co.
`Quik Trip Corp Hq
`
`Murphy USA
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`Speedway L.L.C. H.Q
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Murphy USA
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Independent
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Walgreen Co.
`Kroger Corporate
`Walgreen Co.
`Walgreen Co.
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Gwinnett
`6140 Jimmy Carter Blvd
`Gwinnett
`2949 Five Forks Trickum Rd
`5700 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`5050 Sugarloaf Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`6875 Jimmy Carter Blvd
`Gwinnett
`2211 Scenic Hwy N
`Gwinnett
`5255 Peachtree Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`765 Buford Dr
`Gwinnett
`1094 Duluth Hwy
`Gwinnett
`3195 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`2571 Satellite Blvd
`Gwinnett
`1055 Old Peachtree Rd
`Gwinnett
`1930 Scenic Hwy N
`Gwinnett
`1750 Winder Hwy
`Gwinnett
`2900 Buford Dr
`Gwinnett
`2040 Beaver Ruin Rd
`Gwinnett
`2460 Hamilton Mill Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`5455 Lawrenceville Hwy Nw Gwinnett
`5065 Stone Mountain Hwy
`Gwinnett
`3853 Buford Drmusa District
`Gwinnett
`10632
`2180 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`5670 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`3120 Sugarloaf Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`1800 Beaver Ruin Rd
`Gwinnett
`315 Fairview Rd
`Henry
`2850 Jimmy Lee Smith Pkwy
`Paulding
`5882 Wendy Bagwell Pkwy
`Paulding
`55 Hillside Trce
`Paulding
`4597 Jimmy Lee Smith Pkwy
`Paulding
`915 Mcfarland Road
`N/A
`4414 Austell Rd
`Cobb
`5201 Lavista Rd
`Dekalb
`3251 Highway 5
`Douglas
`4617 Jonesboro Rd
`Fulton
`4397 Sudderth Rd
`Gwinnett
`1100 Hillcrest Pkwy
`Laurens
`6199 Highway 92 Ste 176
`Cherokee
`6766 Hickory Flat Hwy
`Cherokee
`8020 Cumming Hwy
`Cherokee
`4045 Marietta Hwy
`Cherokee
`
`24
`
`30071
`30044
`30071
`30044
`30071
`30078
`30092
`30043
`30043
`30097
`30096
`30043
`30078
`30019
`30519
`30071
`30019
`30047
`30087
`
`30519
`30097
`30071
`30045
`30093
`30294
`30141
`30141
`30157
`30141
`30004
`30106
`30084
`30135
`30291
`30518
`31021
`30102
`30115
`30115
`30114
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 14 of 32 PageID#
`
`39682
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Walgreen Co.
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Racetrac Petroleum
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Cherokee
`12050 Highway 92
`Cherokee
`2295 Towne Lake Pkwy
`Cobb
`3162 Johnson Ferry Rd
`Cobb
`2140 Roswell Rd
`Cobb
`3240 S Cobb Dr SE
`Cobb
`4875 Floyd Rd SW
`Cobb
`4880 Lower Roswell Rd
`Cobb
`3600 Dallas Hwy SW
`Cobb
`3595 Canton Rd
`3330 Cobb Pkwy Nw Ste 200 Cobb
`2960 Shallowford Rd
`Cobb
`4715 S Atlanta Rd Se Ste 100 Cobb
`4150 Macland Rd
`Cobb
`4400 Brownsville Rd
`Cobb
`3300 Cobb Pkwy SE
`Cobb
`1000 Whitlock Ave Nw Ste 200 Cobb
`1720 Mars Hill Rd Nw Frnt
`Cobb
`3895 Cherokee St
`Cobb
`720 Commerce Dr
`Dekalb
`2320 N Druid Hills Rd NE
`Dekalb
`1160 Moreland Ave SE
`Dekalb
`3959 Lavista Rd
`Dekalb
`4498 Chamblee Dunwoody Rd Dekalb
`1799 Briarcliff Rd NE
`Dekalb
`2036 Johnson Ferry Rd NE
`Dekalb
`3559 Chamblee Tucker Rd
`Dekalb
`1225 Caroline St NE
`Dekalb
`2205 Lavista Rd NE
`Dekalb
`3479 Memorial Dr
`Dekalb
`4357 Lawrenceville Hwy
`Dekalb
`3871 Peachtree Rd NE
`Dekalb
`3875 Chapel Hill Rd
`Douglas
`2655 Freedom Pkwy
`Forsyth
`5665 Atlanta Hwy
`Forsyth
`3651 Peachtree Pkwy Ste P
`Forsyth
`2325 Bethelview Rd
`Forsyth
`10945 State Bridge Rd
`Fulton
`120 Piedmont Ave NE
`Fulton
`3330 Piedmont Rd NE
`Fulton
`4920 Roswell Rd
`Fulton
`3000 Old Alabama Rd
`Fulton
`
`25
`
`30188
`30189
`30062
`30062
`30080
`30126
`30068
`30064
`30066
`30101
`30066
`30339
`30127
`30127
`30339
`30064
`30101
`30144
`30030
`30329
`30316
`30084
`30338
`30306
`30319
`30341
`30307
`30329
`30032
`30084
`30319
`30135
`30041
`30004
`30024
`30040
`30022
`30303
`30305
`30342
`30022
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 15 of 32 PageID#
`
`39683
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Walgreen Co.
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`227 Sandy Springs Pl
`570 E Crossville Rd
`2090 Dunwoody Club Dr
`12460 Crabapple Rd
`8465 Holcomb Bridge Rd
`12870 Highway 9 N Windwood
`Commons
`2300 Holcomb Bridge Rd
`800 Glenwood Ave SE
`2542 Morosgo Pl NE
`2121 Lawrenceville Suwanee
`Gwinnett
`Rd
`Gwinnett
`6001 Cumming Hwy
`Gwinnett
`505 Dacula Rd
`3455 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`2100 Riverside Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`4155 Lawrenceville Hwy NW Gwinnett
`1911 Grayson Hwy
`Gwinnett
`455 Grayson Hwy
`Gwinnett
`3300 Hamilton Mill Rd
`Gwinnett
`1227 Rockbridge Rd
`Gwinnett
`3093 Steve Reynolds Blvd
`Gwinnett
`6050 Singleton Rd
`Gwinnett
`1475 Buford Dr Ste 300
`Gwinnett
`400 Peachtree Industrial Blvd Gwinnett
`910 Athens Hwy
`Gwinnett
`2700 Braselton Hwy
`Gwinnett
`6555 Sugarloaf Pkwy
`Gwinnett
`1670 Scenic Hwy N
`Gwinnett
`3035 Scenic Hwy S
`Gwinnett
`3050 Five Forks Trickum Rd
`SW
`1750 Hudson Bridge Rd
`5339 Old Highway 5
`1122 Powers Ferry Rd SE
`1690 Powder Springs Rd SW
`2875 N Decatur Rd
`2595 Peachtree Pkwy
`1595 Peachtree Pkwy Ste 115
`1715 Howell Mill Rd NW
`590 Cascade Ave SW
`1700 Monroe Dr NE
`
`Gwinnett
`Henry
`Cherokee
`Cobb
`Cobb
`Dekalb
`Forsyth
`Forsyth
`Fulton
`Fulton
`Fulton
`
`26
`
`30328
`30075
`30350
`30004
`30022
`
`30004
`30076
`30316
`30324
`
`30024
`30518
`30019
`30096
`30043
`30047
`30017
`30046
`30519
`30087
`30096
`30093
`30043
`30024
`30052
`30019
`30097
`30078
`30039
`
`30047
`30281
`30188
`30067
`30064
`30033
`30041
`30041
`30318
`30310
`30324
`
`

`

`
`Case 1:20-cv-00393-LMB-WEF Document 1462-14 Filed 04/05/23 Page 16 of 32 PageID#
`
`39684
`CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION
`SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
`
`
`
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`Kroger Corporate
`
`900 Marietta Hwy Coleman
`Fulton
`Village
`Gwinnett
`950 Herrington Rd
`Baldwin
`2809 N Columbia St
`Bartow
`125 E Main St
`Bibb
`4650 Forsyth Rd
`Bibb
`220 Tom Hill Sr Blvd
`Bibb
`4628 Presidential Pkwy
`Bibb
`5928 Zebulon Rd
`Bryan
`53 Exchange St
`Carroll
`1355 S Park St
`Chatham
`311 Habersham St
`Clarke
`191 Alps Rd
`Clayton
`7125 Highway 85
`Clayton
`5664 Jonesboro Rd
`Clayton
`3618 Highway 138 SE
`1751 Newnan Crossing Blvd E Coweta
`48 Bullsboro Dr
`Coweta
`3150 Highway 34 W
`Coweta
`378 Marketplace Pkwy
`Dawson
`1232 S Hairston Rd
`Dekalb
`3855 Buford Hwy NE
`Dekalb
`2385 Wesley Chapel Rd
`Dekalb
`4919 Flat Shoals Pkwy
`Dekalb
`8501 Hospital Dr
`Douglas
`630 Thornton Rd
`Douglas
`134 Banks Xing
`Fayette
`564 Crosstown Dr
`Fayette
`1476 Turner Mccall Blvd SW
`Floyd
`5550 Bethelview Rd
`Forsyth
`4550 Jonesboro Rd
`Fulton
`6055 Old National Hwy
`Fulton
`2685 Metropolitan Pkwy SW
`Fulton
`3425 Cascade Rd SW
`Fulton
`136 W Belmont Dr
`Gordon
`4025 Winder Hwy
`Hall
`7380 Spout Springs Rd
`Hall
`1931 Jesse Jewell Pkwy SE
`Hall
`3630 Thompson Bridge Rd
`Hall
`5900 E Lake P