Plaintiffs

Marion S. Mishkin Law Office, of counsel Noice of appearance to Sacks & SacksKathleen CartyYajaira StrohlArlene MontalvoColleen RyanJ. Richard RyanJulie MaisanoTheresa A. DavisBlanca GoffredoChristine JohnsonLouise NolanKathryn LaveryArlene McGillickGloria Elaine CarsonAndrea CavicchioDiane Hoch SankeyJessie K. HortonKevin J. O'BrienWilliam J. SankeyJerry O'ConnorVictoria O'ConnorDonald G. ThompsonRenee A. ThompsonLaura LeonardJo AndrusyczynJon Marie FisherSusan AllisonRosa CuberoJeanne KolarikArthur AlessandroPatrick D'AlliegroSue Ann AndersenMarcia DiazCatherine LangerinTeresita CayatanoDonna DonnellyDorothy ForisDelia BeccaTomiann JacksonDonna HaskellFrank HaskellChristine PlacideAnn Marie DuignanJill MiskanicAndrea McDonoughJudy CheccoJean ImparatoNancy MetroConcetta ZuccaroShirley BellChristine BroomeJeanette BussLaranie DevitaDiane DonovanDanielle EiversRosario GallagherRobert GarettCarol GavittJoseph GavittFrancesca GillamPatricia HawkinsAnna Maria HubnerVincent HubnerBarbara KadnarCatherine LangCaroline LavinMary Ellen LuchettiGail McConvilleMargret McHughCathy MongielloLaura MorelloCorinne MulhamCarolyn MundyNancy MurphyMaureen NoganCarol RetundieAlice RiveraMary Jane StrifflerRobin Van HoutenAndrea WeisenburgerTheresa WelshJacqueline CacchioliLouie CacchioliPatricia AguglairoSusan MedagliaMichelle PayetteIngrid QuagliarielloLois RiceMichelle SquicciariniSheila ComponoMichele HardinToni RosarioVirginia SchmittLenore RauscherTheresa SimonYvonne VilagosGeorge MoralesMarguerite PiotrowskiSharon AccettaGeraldine Martin more loading

Plaintiff - Appellee

Tier 4 Plaintiffs

Appellant

WTC Captive Insurance Company, Inc.

Defendants

City of New YorkAMEC Construction Management, Inc.Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.Evergreen Recycling of CoronaTurner/Plaza, A Joint VenturePlaza Construction Corp.Atlantic-Heydt CorporationTully Construction Co., Inc.Turner Construction CompanyBig Apple Wrecking & Construction Corp.Board of Education of the City of New YorkBreeze Carting, Inc.Breeze National, Inc.Brer-Four TransportationC.B. Contracting Corp.Component Assembly Systems, Inc.Eagle One Roofing Contractors, Inc.J.P Equipment & Rental Materials, L.L.C.Laquila Construction, Inc.MRA Engineering P.CManafort Brothers IncorporatedNew York City School Construction AuthorityNicholson Construction CompanySkanska Koch, IncorporatedThe City University of New YorkVollmer Associates LLPWeidlinger Associates, Consulting Engineers, P.C.Wolkow Braker Roofing CorporationWSP Cantor SeinukLucius Pitkin, Inc.Mazzocchi Wrecking, Inc.New York City Department of EducationNoah H. KushlefskySilverstein WTC, L.L.C.Berkel & Company, Contractors, Inc.A. Russo Wrecking, Inc.Cord Contracting Co., IncorporatedDakota Demo-Tech, Inc.Diamond Point Excavating Corp.DMT Enterprise, Inc.E. J. Davies, Inc.Executive Medical Services, P.C.Fleet Trucking Inc.Francis A. Lee CompanyGilsanz Murray Steficek, LLPHallen Welding Service, Inc.HP Environmental, Inc.Hudson Meridian Construction Group LLCLa Strada General Contracting CorporationLeslie E. Robertson Associates, R.L.L.P.Liberty Mutual Insurance CompanyLZA Technology, a division of Thornton TomasettiMueser Rutledge Consulting EngineersPeter Scalamandre and Sons, Inc.Pinnacle Environmental CorporationPro Safety Services IncorporatedPT&L Contracting CorporationRobert L. Gerosa, Inc.Robert Silman Associates, P.C.Rodar Enterprises, Inc.Safeway Environmental CorporationSilverite Contracting CorporationSkidmore Owings and Merrill, L.L.P.Thornton Tomasetti, IncorporatedTotal Safety Consulting, LLC2 World Trade Center LLC2 WTC Holdings, L.L.C.222 Broadway, LLC30 Broad Street Associates, LLC4 World Trade Center LLC4 WTC Holdings, LLC5 World Trade Center, L.L.C.5 WTC Holdings, L.L.C.American Building Maintenance Industries, IncorporatedAMEC Earth & Environmental, Inc.Anthony Cortese Specialized Hauling, LLC, IncorporatedBacou-Dalloz USA, IncorporatedBreeze Carting, Inc.Breeze National, Inc.Brer-Four TransportationBuro Happold Consulting Engineers, P.C.Canron Construction Corp.Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.Deutsche Bank Trust Company AmericasDiversified Carting, Inc.E.J. Davies, Inc.En-Tech Corp.Department of Environmental ProtectionEvans Environmental & Geological Science & Management, LLCEwell W. Finley, P.C.Executive Medical Services, P.C.Federal Emergency Management AgencyFrancis A. Lee CompanyFTI Trucking CorporationGilsanz Murray Steficek LLPGoldstein Associates Consulting Engineers, P.C.Grubb & Ellis Management Services, Inc.Hudson Meridian Construction Group, L.L.C.J.P. Equipment Rental & Materials, L.L.C.Laquila Construction, Incorporated more loading

Defendant - Appellants

AMEC Construction Management, Inc.AMEC Earth & Environmental, Inc.Evergreen Recycling of CoronaTurner Construction CompanyTurner/Plaza, A Joint VentureBovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.City of New YorkPlaza Construction Corp.Tully Construction Company, Inc.

Amicus Curiae

United States District Court Eastern District of New York