throbber
Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 1 of 42 PageID #: 1135
`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 1 of 42 PageID #: 1135
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`EXHIBIT A
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 2 of 42 PageID #: 1136
`
`Case No. 2:17-cv-00513-JRG
`(Lead Case)
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`Case No. 2:17-CV-00517-JRG
`(Consolidated Case)
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`AGIS SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT
`LLC,
`
`
`
`v.
`
`HUAWEI DEVICE USA INC., HUAWEI
`DEVICE CO., LTD. AND HUAWEI
`DEVICE (DONGGUAN) CO., LTD.,
`
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`Defendants.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`v.
`
`
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`MARSHALL DIVISION
`
























`
`AGIS SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT,
`LLC,
`
`
`
`
`
`ZTE CORPORATION, ZTE (USA) INC.,
`AND ZTE (TX), INC.,
`
`
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`Defendants.
`
`
`
`
`ZTE (USA) INC.’S AND ZTE (TX) INC.’S OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO
`PLAINTIFF’S FIRST SET OF COMMON INTERROGATORIES (NOS. 1-10)
`
`Pursuant to Rules 26 and 33 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Defendants ZTE
`
`(USA) Inc. and ZTE (TX) Inc. (“ZTA” and “ZTX” respectively, and collectively “ZTE”)1
`
`hereby serve their objections and responses to Plaintiff AGIS Software Development LLC
`
`(“Plaintiff’s”) First Set of Common Interrogatories (1-10) to ZTE.
`
`
`1 Defendant ZTE Corporation (“ZTE Corp.”) has not yet been served or appeared in this matter.
`
`1
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 3 of 42 PageID #: 1137
`
`These responses are made solely for the purposes of Civil Action no. 2:17-cv-00517
`
`captioned above (referred to herein as the “Action”)2. The following responses are based on
`
`ZTE’s present state of recollection, knowledge, and belief. The responses are at all time subject
`
`to additional or different information that discovery may disclose and, while based on the present
`
`state of recollection, are subject to such refreshing of recollection and such knowledge or facts as
`
`may result from further investigation by ZTE or its attorneys and/or further discovery from
`
`Plaintiff and/or third parties. ZTE reserves the right to supplement these responses.
`
`ZTE’s objections and responses are made without in any way waiving or intending to
`
`waive, but to the contrary, are intended to preserve:
`
`1.
`
`All questions as to the competency, relevancy, materiality, privilege, and
`
`admissibility as evidence for any purpose of the response or subject matter thereof, in this Action
`
`or any subsequent proceeding associated with this Action or any other matter;
`
`2.
`
`The right to object on any ground to the use of said responses, or the subject
`
`matter thereof, in any subsequent proceeding with this Action or any other action; and
`
`3.
`
`The right to object on any ground at any time to the other requests or other
`
`discovery procedures involving or relating to the subject matter of these interrogatories.
`
`GENERAL OBJECTIONS
`
`
`
`The following general objections apply to each and every interrogatory contained in
`
`Plaintiff’s interrogatories, including its definitions and instructions, and each of the general
`
`objections is incorporated by reference into the specific objections to each interrogatory,
`
`regardless of whether the specific objections overlap or repeat the general objection.
`
`1.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definitions and instructions to the extent they are
`
`unreasonably vague, overly broad, repetitious, unduly burdensome, or seek to impose any
`
`2 Unless indicated otherwise, all docket citations will reference the ZTE case.
`
`2
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 4 of 42 PageID #: 1138
`
`obligations beyond those imposed by the applicable rules and law, including the Federal Rules of
`
`Civil Procedure, the Local Rules of this Court, the Docket Control Order, and the Discovery
`
`Order.3
`
`2.
`
`ZTE objects to the interrogatories to the extent that they seek documents and
`
`information subject to (a) attorney-client privilege, (b) work product immunity, (c) joint defense
`
`privilege, (d) common interest privilege, or (e) any other applicable privilege, immunity, or
`
`protection. ZTE does not intend to provide such information or produce such privileged or
`
`protected documents or things, and the inadvertent production of such is not to be deemed a
`
`waiver of any privilege. ZTE expressly reserves the right to object to the introduction at trial or
`
`any other use of such documents or things that may be inadvertently disclosed. An objection
`
`based on the attorney-client privilege and/or the work product doctrine shall not be construed as
`
`a representation that information called for in the interrogatory exists or existed. Such objections
`
`indicate only that the interrogatories are of such a scope as to embrace subject matter protected
`
`by the attorney-client privilege, the work product doctrine, or other protection or privilege.
`
`3.
`
`ZTE objects to the interrogatories to the extent that they seek documents,
`
`information, and things (a) not relevant to the subject matter of this investigation, (b) not
`
`proportional to the needs of the case, considering the importance of the issues at stake in the
`
`action, the amount in controversy, the parties’ relative access to relevant information, the
`
`parties’ resources, the importance of the discovery in resolving the issues, and whether the
`
`burden or expense of the proposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit, or (c) otherwise not
`
`within the scope of relevant discovery.
`
`4.
`
`ZTE objects to the interrogatories to the extent that they seek to impose an
`
`
`3 ZTE will follow the Docket Control Order and Discovery Orders entered in 2:17-cv-00514
`(Dkt. Nos. 38 and 39) until new ones are entered in the lead case 2:17-cv-00513.
`
`3
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 5 of 42 PageID #: 1139
`
`improper or undue burden on ZTE, or duties and responsibilities greater than those imposed by
`
`the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and the Local Rules. ZTE objects to the interrogatories to
`
`the extent they seek information or documents and things that do not exist or are beyond ZTE’s
`
`possession, custody, or control. ZTE further objects to the interrogatories and to the definitions
`
`and instructions therein to the extent they seek documents, information, and things from
`
`corporate parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, divisions or joint ventures that are not within the
`
`possession, custody or control of ZTE.
`
`5.
`
`ZTE objects to the interrogatories to the extent they seek information
`
`or documents and things that are subject to a claim of confidentiality from a third
`
`party.
`
`6.
`
`ZTE’s responses or failure to object to any of Plaintiff’s Definitions or
`
`Instructions are not intended to be, and shall not be, construed as admissions as to the meaning
`
`of words or phrases at issue in the action, and shall have no binding effect on ZTE in this or in
`
`any other proceeding.
`
`7.
`
`ZTE’s responses and objections are for discovery purposes only, and are not
`
`to be construed as limiting or reflecting Plaintiff’s positions in this case regarding claim
`
`construction.
`
`8.
`
`ZTE’s agreement to respond to these interrogatories shall not be deemed as
`
`an admission regarding the relevance of the interrogatory nor is it intended to waive any right
`
`to object the admissibility of such at trial.
`
`9.
`
`ZTE have not yet completed their investigation, collection of information,
`
`discovery, and analysis relating to this action. The following responses are based on
`
`information known and available to ZTE at this time. Discovery in this litigation is ongoing.
`
`
`
`
`4
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 6 of 42 PageID #: 1140
`
`ZTE reserve the right to amend, supplement, or otherwise change their response to these
`
`interrogatories should any additional information become available to them. ZTE also reserve
`
`the right to produce additional evidence at trial.
`
`10.
`
`ZTE, i.e. ZTA and ZTX, object to Plaintiff’s definition of “ZTE,” “You,”
`
`“Your,” and “Defendants.” As addressed above ZTE Corp. has not yet been served or appeared
`
`in this matter, and is thus not a party subject to 30(b)(6) discovery. ZTE further objects to
`
`Plaintiff’s definition of “ZTE,” “You,” “Your,” and “Defendants” on the ground that these
`
`definitions (i) are vague, overly broad, and unduly burdensome; (ii) seek information that is not
`
`relevant to any claims or defenses of any party and/or is not reasonably calculated to lead to the
`
`discovery of admissible evidence with respect to any such claim or defense; (iii) seek
`
`information that ZTE cannot reasonably be expected to be aware of or have knowledge of; and
`
`(iv) to the extent they seek information from persons or legal entities that ZTE neither employs
`
`not controls.
`
`11.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “ZTE Accused Products” to the extent it
`
`is directed at devices beyond the scope of the Complaint in this action and beyond the time
`
`period relevant to this case. ZTE objects to any discovery beyond the scope of any right
`
`Plaintiff may have to recover damages for infringement. ZTE further objects to Plaintiff’s
`
`definition of “ZTE Accused Products” on the grounds that it is vague, overly broad, and unduly
`
`burdensome, especially to the extent that the definition is unlimited in time and encompasses
`
`systems or products not made, used, sold, offered for sale, or imported by ZTE. ZTE further
`
`objects to the definition to the extent that it includes products alleged of infringing patents that
`
`are not asserted in this case. ZTE also objects to the definition to the extent it attempts to
`
`characterize the asserted patents or ay patent claim terms. Claim construction and expert
`
`
`
`
`5
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 7 of 42 PageID #: 1141
`
`discovery has not yet occurred in this case, and ZTE reserves its rights to provide expert
`
`testimony and claim construction positions in accordance with this Court’s Local Patent Rules,
`
`Docket Control Order, and any other applicable rules or orders. ZTE also objects to this
`
`definition to the extent it implies that any ZTE system or product practices any claim of any
`
`Asserted Patents; ZTE specifically denies any alleged acts of infringement. ZTE also objects to
`
`this definition to the extent it implies that any accused ZTE products are interchangeable or
`
`representative of any others for the purposes of this case. In responding to Plaintiff’s
`
`Interrogatories, ZTE will limit its responses to products and systems identified in Plaintiff’s
`
`Complaint (Dkt. No. 1), Amended Complaint (Dkt. No. 32), and Infringement Contentions,
`
`including any court-approved supplements or amendments thereto, and reasonably related
`
`products, without conceding that any such products are representative or share any similar
`
`characteristics for the purposes of Plaintiff’s burden of establishing infringement.
`
`12.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “This Action.” ZTE are not Defendants
`
`in AGIS Software Development LLC v. Huawei Device USA Inc., et al., 2:17-cv-00513-JRG
`
`(E.D. Tex.).
`
`13.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “documents” as vague, overly broad, and
`
`unduly burdensome. ZTE further objects to this definition to the extent it exceeds the scope of
`
`the parties’ agreed Discovery or E-Discovery Orders.4
`
`14.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “communications” as vague, overly
`
`broad, and unduly burdensome. ZTE further objects to this definition to the extent it exceeds
`
`the scope of the parties’ agreed Discovery or E-Discovery Orders.
`
`
`4 To be proposed respectively on April 9, 2018 and April 23, 2018. See AGIS Software
`Development LLC v. Huawei Device USA Inc., et al., 2:17-cv-00513-JRG (Dkt. No. 101) (E.D.
`Tex.).
`
`
`
`6
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 8 of 42 PageID #: 1142
`
`15.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “things” as vague, overly broad, and
`
`unduly burdensome. ZTE further objects to this definition to the extent it exceeds the scope of
`
`the parties’ agreed Discovery or E-Discovery Orders.
`
`16.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “persons” as vague, overly broad, and
`
`unduly burdensome, and to the extent it seeks information outside of ZTE’s possession,
`
`custody, or control and not proportional to the needs of the case. ZTE further objects to this
`
`definition to the extent it exceeds the scope of the parties’ agreed Discovery or E-Discovery
`
`Orders.
`
`17.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “identify” as vague, overly broad, and
`
`unduly burdensome, and to the extent it seeks information outside of ZTE’s possession,
`
`custody, or control and not proportional to the needs of the case. Where applicable, ZTE will
`
`provide detail sufficient to ascertain the identity of the person, place, or thing sought, if that
`
`detail is within ZTE’s possession, custody, or control.
`
`18.
`
`ZTE objects to Plaintiff’s definition of “describe” as vague, overly broad, and
`
`unduly burdensome, and to the extent it seeks information outside of ZTE’s possession,
`
`custody, or control and not proportional to the needs of the case, especially as it seeks the
`
`identity of “all” persons or documents.
`
`19.
`
`ZTE objects to the definition of the terms “relate,” “reflecting,” and
`
`“concerning” as being vague, overly broad, unduly burdensome, and as seeking information
`
`not in ZTE’s possession, custody, or control. ZTE will identify individuals by name, and
`
`documents by Bates number, where applicable.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`7
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 9 of 42 PageID #: 1143
`
`SPECIFIC OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES
`
`
`
`INTERROGATORY NO. 1
`
`
`
`Identify all ZTE Accused Products sold to customers and made available for purchase
`by customers in the United States from January 2011 to the present, providing at least the
`following information: (i) the internal and external name(s) and model number(s) of the ZTE
`Accused Products; (ii) each Entity to whom the ZTE Accused Products were offered for sale or
`sold, and the supplier of each ZTE Accused Product and components thereof, as well as an
`identification of which components are supplied by each supplier.
`
`RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
`
`
`In addition to the General Objections stated above, ZTE objects to this interrogatory on
`
`the basis that it includes at least four (4) distinct interrogatories. ZTE further objects to this
`
`interrogatory to the extent it is vague, ambiguous, overly broad, and unduly burdensome because
`
`the terms “all” and “each,” as used in this interrogatory, are not clear and potentially encompass
`
`an unreasonably board range of topics or calls for information that is not relevant or proportional
`
`to the needs of this case. ZTE additionally objects to this interrogatory to the extent it calls for a
`
`legal conclusion. Further, ZTE objects to this interrogatory because the terms “purchase,”
`
`“internal,” “external,” “model,” “offered,” “sale,” “sold,” “supplier,” and “components” are
`
`vague, ambiguous, overly broad, and undefined. ZTE also expressly incorporates its General
`
`Objection to Plaintiff’s definition of “Accused Products.” ZTE also objects to this interrogatory to
`
`the extent it seeks information which ZTE is under a duty to third parties not to disclose. ZTE
`
`further objects to this interrogatory to the extent it requests that ZTE provide customer
`
`information that is not relevant or proportional to the needs of this case; ZTE will not provide
`
`personal information about each of its customers.
`
`Subject to the foregoing general and specific objections, ZTE responds as follows:
`
`
`
`
`8
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 10 of 42 PageID #: 1144
`
`ZTE produced documents that detail technical aspects of the Accused Products and their
`
`operation, and directs Plaintiff to those documents at the following bates numbers pursuant to
`
`Rule 33(d):
`
`ZTE-AGIS-00000001 - ZTE-AGIS-00000011; ZTE-AGIS-00000012 - ZTE-AGIS-00000015;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000016 - ZTE-AGIS-00000020; ZTE-AGIS-00000021 - ZTE-AGIS-00000026;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000027 - ZTE-AGIS-00000032; ZTE-AGIS-00000033 - ZTE-AGIS-00000035;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000036 - ZTE-AGIS-00000038; ZTE-AGIS-00000039 - ZTE-AGIS-00000042;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000043 - ZTE-AGIS-00000045; ZTE-AGIS-00000046 - ZTE-AGIS-00000194;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000195 - ZTE-AGIS-00000266; ZTE-AGIS-00000267 - ZTE-AGIS-00000351;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000352 - ZTE-AGIS-00000364; ZTE-AGIS-00000365 - ZTE-AGIS-00000367;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000368 - ZTE-AGIS-00000371; ZTE-AGIS-00000372 - ZTE-AGIS-00000373;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000374 - ZTE-AGIS-00000377; ZTE-AGIS-00000378 - ZTE-AGIS-00000419;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000420 - ZTE-AGIS-00000425; ZTE-AGIS-00000426 - ZTE-AGIS-00000428;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000429 - ZTE-AGIS-00000430; ZTE-AGIS-00000431 - ZTE-AGIS-00000435;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000436 - ZTE-AGIS-00000438; ZTE-AGIS-00000439 - ZTE-AGIS-00000441;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000442 - ZTE-AGIS-00000443; ZTE-AGIS-00000444 - ZTE-AGIS-00000444;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000445 - ZTE-AGIS-00000490; ZTE-AGIS-00000491 - ZTE-AGIS-00000493;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000494 - ZTE-AGIS-00000496; ZTE-AGIS-00000497 - ZTE-AGIS-00000498;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000499 - ZTE-AGIS-00000548; ZTE-AGIS-00000549 - ZTE-AGIS-00000682;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000683 - ZTE-AGIS-00000691; ZTE-AGIS-00000692 - ZTE-AGIS-00000694;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000695 - ZTE-AGIS-00000697; ZTE-AGIS-00000698 - ZTE-AGIS-00000701;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000702 - ZTE-AGIS-00000703; ZTE-AGIS-00000704 - ZTE-AGIS-00000709;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000710 - ZTE-AGIS-00000810; ZTE-AGIS-00000811 - ZTE-AGIS-00000813;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000814 - ZTE-AGIS-00000817; ZTE-AGIS-00000818 - ZTE-AGIS-00000820;
`ZTE-AGIS-00000821 - ZTE-AGIS-00000837; ZTE-AGIS-00000838 - ZTE-AGIS-00001010;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001011 - ZTE-AGIS-00001013; ZTE-AGIS-00001014 - ZTE-AGIS-00001016;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001017 - ZTE-AGIS-00001018; ZTE-AGIS-00001019 - ZTE-AGIS-00001022;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001023 - ZTE-AGIS-00001027; ZTE-AGIS-00001028 - ZTE-AGIS-00001031;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001032 - ZTE-AGIS-00001133; ZTE-AGIS-00001134 - ZTE-AGIS-00001183;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001184 - ZTE-AGIS-00001188; ZTE-AGIS-00001189 - ZTE-AGIS-00001192;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001193 - ZTE-AGIS-00001197; ZTE-AGIS-00001198 - ZTE-AGIS-00001372;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001373 - ZTE-AGIS-00001550; ZTE-AGIS-00001551 - ZTE-AGIS-00001556;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001557 - ZTE-AGIS-00001559; ZTE-AGIS-00001560 - ZTE-AGIS-00001562;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001563 - ZTE-AGIS-00001565; ZTE-AGIS-00001566 - ZTE-AGIS-00001567;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001568 - ZTE-AGIS-00001571; ZTE-AGIS-00001572 - ZTE-AGIS-00001581;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001582 - ZTE-AGIS-00001586; ZTE-AGIS-00001587 - ZTE-AGIS-00001590;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001591 - ZTE-AGIS-00001594; ZTE-AGIS-00001595 - ZTE-AGIS-00001771;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001772 - ZTE-AGIS-00001795; ZTE-AGIS-00001796 - ZTE-AGIS-00001851;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001852 - ZTE-AGIS-00001855; ZTE-AGIS-00001856 - ZTE-AGIS-00001861;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001862 - ZTE-AGIS-00001868; ZTE-AGIS-00001869 - ZTE-AGIS-00001880;
`ZTE-AGIS-00001881 - ZTE-AGIS-00002040; ZTE-AGIS-00002041 - ZTE-AGIS-00002044;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002045 - ZTE-AGIS-00002049; ZTE-AGIS-00002050 - ZTE-AGIS-00002056;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002057 - ZTE-AGIS-00002119; ZTE-AGIS-00002120 - ZTE-AGIS-00002129;
`
`
`
`
`9
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 11 of 42 PageID #: 1145
`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 11 of 42 PageID #: 1145
`
`ZTE-AGIS-00002130 - ZTE-AGIS-00002139; ZTE-AGIS-00002140 - ZTE-AGIS-00002155;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002130 - ZTE-AGIS-00002139; ZTE-AGIS-00002140 - ZTE-AGIS-00002155;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002156 - ZTE-AGIS-00002159; ZTE-AGIS-00002160 - ZTE-AGIS-00002161;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002156 - ZTE-AGIS-00002159; ZTE-AGIS-00002160 - ZTE-AGIS-00002161;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002162 - ZTE-AGIS-00002166; ZTE-AGIS-00002167 - ZTE-AGIS-00002318;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002162 - ZTE-AGIS-00002166; ZTE-AGIS-00002167 - ZTE-AGIS-00002318;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002319 - ZTE-AGIS-00002327; ZTE-AGIS-00002328 - ZTE-AGIS-00002333;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002319 - ZTE-AGIS-00002327; ZTE-AGIS-00002328 - ZTE-AGIS-00002333;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002334 - ZTE-AGIS-00002338; ZTE-AGIS-00002339 - ZTE-AGIS-00002342;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002334 - ZTE-AGIS-00002338; ZTE-AGIS-00002339 - ZTE-AGIS-00002342;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002343 - ZTE-AGIS-00002346; ZTE-AGIS-00002347 - ZTE-AGIS-00002519;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002343 - ZTE-AGIS-00002346; ZTE-AGIS-00002347 - ZTE-AGIS-00002519;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002520 - ZTE-AGIS-00002575; ZTE-AGIS-00002576 - ZTE-AGIS-00003093;
`ZTE-AGIS-00002520 - ZTE-AGIS-00002575; ZTE-AGIS-00002576 - ZTE-AGIS-00003093;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003094 - ZTE-AGIS-00003097; ZTE-AGIS-00003098 - ZTE-AGIS-00003253;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003094 - ZTE-AGIS-00003097; ZTE-AGIS-00003098 - ZTE-AGIS-00003253;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003254 - ZTE-AGIS-00003255; ZTE-AGIS-00003256 - ZTE-AGIS-00003311;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003254 - ZTE-AGIS-00003255; ZTE-AGIS-00003256 - ZTE-AGIS-00003311;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003312 - ZTE-AGIS-00003313; ZTE-AGIS-00003314 - ZTE-AGIS-00003317;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003312 - ZTE-AGIS-00003313; ZTE-AGIS-00003314 - ZTE-AGIS-00003317;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003318 - ZTE-AGIS-00003321; ZTE-AGIS-00003322 - ZTE-AGIS-00003325;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003318 - ZTE-AGIS-00003321; ZTE-AGIS-00003322 - ZTE-AGIS-00003325;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003326 - ZTE-AGIS-00003360; ZTE-AGIS-00003361 - ZTE-AGIS-00003531;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003326 - ZTE-AGIS-00003360; ZTE-AGIS-00003361 - ZTE-AGIS-00003531;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003532 - ZTE-AGIS-00003535; ZTE-AGIS-00003536 - ZTE-AGIS-00003538;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003532 - ZTE-AGIS-00003535; ZTE-AGIS-00003536 - ZTE-AGIS-00003538;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003539 - ZTE-AGIS-00003709; ZTE-AGIS-00003710 - ZTE-AGIS-00003725;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003539 - ZTE-AGIS-00003709; ZTE-AGIS-00003710 - ZTE-AGIS-00003725;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003726 - ZTE-AGIS-00003738; ZTE-AGIS-00003739 - ZTE-AGIS-00003912;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003726 - ZTE-AGIS-00003738; ZTE-AGIS-00003739 - ZTE-AGIS-00003912;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003913 - ZTE-AGIS-00004078; ZTE-AGIS-00004079 - ZTE-AGIS-00004080;
`ZTE-AGIS-00003913 - ZTE-AGIS-00004078; ZTE-AGIS-00004079 - ZTE-AGIS-00004080;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004081 - ZTE-AGIS-00004084; ZTE-AGIS-00004085 - ZTE-AGIS-00004089;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004081 - ZTE-AGIS-00004084; ZTE-AGIS-00004085 - ZTE-AGIS-00004089;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004090 - ZTE-AGIS-00004162; ZTE-AGIS-00004163 - ZTE-AGIS-00004264;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004090 - ZTE-AGIS-00004162; ZTE-AGIS-00004163 - ZTE-AGIS-00004264;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004265 - ZTE-AGIS-00004268; ZTE-AGIS-00004269 - ZTE-AGIS-00004274;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004265 - ZTE-AGIS-00004268; ZTE-AGIS-00004269 - ZTE-AGIS-00004274;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004275 - ZTE-AGIS-00004281; ZTE-AGIS-00004282 - ZTE-AGIS-00004286;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004275 - ZTE-AGIS-00004281; ZTE-AGIS-00004282 - ZTE-AGIS-00004286;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004287 - ZTE-AGIS-00004460; ZTE-AGIS-00004461 - ZTE-AGIS-00004464;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004287 - ZTE-AGIS-00004460; ZTE-AGIS-00004461 - ZTE-AGIS-00004464;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004465 - ZTE-AGIS-00004467; ZTE-AGIS-00004468 - ZTE-AGIS-00004471;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004465 - ZTE-AGIS-00004467; ZTE-AGIS-00004468 - ZTE-AGIS-00004471;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004472 - ZTE-AGIS-00004474; ZTE-AGIS-00004475 - ZTE-AGIS-00004626;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004472 - ZTE-AGIS-00004474; ZTE-AGIS-00004475 - ZTE-AGIS-00004626;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004627 - ZTE-AGIS-00004658; ZTE-AGIS-00004659 - ZTE-AGIS-00004820;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004627 - ZTE-AGIS-00004658; ZTE-AGIS-00004659 - ZTE-AGIS-00004820;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004821 - ZTE-AGIS-00004824; ZTE-AGIS-00004825 - ZTE-AGIS-00004829;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004821 - ZTE-AGIS-00004824; ZTE-AGIS-00004825 - ZTE-AGIS-00004829;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004830 - ZTE-AGIS-00004906; ZTE-AGIS-00004907 - ZTE-AGIS-00004910;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004830 - ZTE-AGIS-00004906; ZTE-AGIS-00004907 - ZTE-AGIS-00004910;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004911 - ZTE-AGIS-00004915; ZTE-AGIS-00004916 - ZTE-AGIS-00004920;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004911 - ZTE-AGIS-00004915; ZTE-AGIS-00004916 - ZTE-AGIS-00004920;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004921 - ZTE-AGIS-00004924; ZTE-AGIS-00004925 - ZTE-AGIS-00004925;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004921 - ZTE-AGIS-00004924; ZTE-AGIS-00004925 - ZTE-AGIS-00004925;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004926 - ZTE-AGIS-00004998; ZTE-AGIS-00004999 - ZTE-AGIS-00005004;
`ZTE-AGIS-00004926 - ZTE-AGIS-00004998; ZTE-AGIS-00004999 - ZTE-AGIS-00005004;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005005 - ZTE-AGIS-00005009; ZTE-AGIS-00005010 - ZTE-AGIS-00005013;
`ZTE-AGIS-OOOOSOOS - ZTE-AGIS-00005009; ZTE-AGIS-OOOOSOIO - ZTE-AGIS-00005013;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005014 - ZTE-AGIS-00005185; ZTE-AGIS-00005186 - ZTE-AGIS-00005270;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005014 - ZTE-AGIS-00005185; ZTE-AGIS-00005186 - ZTE-AGIS-00005270;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005271 - ZTE-AGIS-00005368; ZTE-AGIS-00005369 - ZTE-AGIS-00005470;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005271 - ZTE-AGIS-00005368; ZTE-AGIS-00005369 - ZTE-AGIS-00005470;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005471 - ZTE-AGIS-00005553; ZTE-AGIS-00005554 - ZTE-AGIS-00005644;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005471 - ZTE-AGIS-00005553; ZTE-AGIS-00005554 - ZTE-AGIS-00005644;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005645 - ZTE-AGIS-00005676; ZTE-AGIS-00005677 - ZTE-AGIS-00005683;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005645 - ZTE-AGIS-00005676; ZTE-AGIS-00005677 - ZTE-AGIS-00005683;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005684 - ZTE-AGIS-00005686; ZTE-AGIS-00005687 - ZTE-AGIS-00005688;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005684 - ZTE-AGIS-00005686; ZTE-AGIS-00005687 - ZTE-AGIS-00005688;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005689 - ZTE-AGIS-00005721; ZTE-AGIS-00005722 - ZTE-AGIS-00005722;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005689 - ZTE-AGIS-00005721; ZTE-AGIS-00005722 - ZTE-AGIS-00005722;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005723 - ZTE-AGIS-00005726; ZTE-AGIS-00005727 - ZTE-AGIS-00005731;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005723 - ZTE-AGIS-00005726; ZTE-AGIS-00005727 - ZTE-AGIS-00005731;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005732 - ZTE-AGIS-00005788; ZTE-AGIS-00005789 - ZTE-AGIS-00005791;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005732 - ZTE-AGIS-00005788; ZTE-AGIS-00005789 - ZTE-AGIS-00005791;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005792 - ZTE-AGIS-00005798; ZTE-AGIS-00005799 - ZTE-AGIS-00005801;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005792 - ZTE-AGIS-00005798; ZTE-AGIS-00005799 - ZTE-AGIS-00005801;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005802 - ZTE-AGIS-00005803; ZTE-AGIS-00005804 - ZTE-AGIS-00005805;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005802 - ZTE-AGIS-00005803; ZTE-AGIS-00005804 - ZTE-AGIS-00005805;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005806 - ZTE-AGIS-00005853; ZTE-AGIS-00005854 - ZTE-AGIS-00005856;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005806 - ZTE-AGIS-00005853; ZTE-AGIS-00005854 - ZTE-AGIS-00005856;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005857 - ZTE-AGIS-00005859; ZTE-AGIS-00005860 - ZTE-AGIS-00005862;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005857 - ZTE-AGIS-00005859; ZTE-AGIS-00005860 - ZTE-AGIS-00005862;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005863 - ZTE-AGIS-00005866; ZTE-AGIS-00005867 - ZTE-AGIS-00005868;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005863 - ZTE-AGIS-00005866; ZTE-AGIS-00005867 - ZTE-AGIS-00005868;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005869 - ZTE-AGIS-00005871; ZTE-AGIS-00005872 - ZTE-AGIS-00005874;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005869 - ZTE-AGIS-00005871; ZTE-AGIS-00005872 - ZTE-AGIS-00005874;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005875 - ZTE-AGIS-00005878; ZTE-AGIS-00005879 - ZTE-AGIS-00006028;
`ZTE-AGIS-00005875 - ZTE-AGIS-00005878; ZTE-AGIS-00005879 - ZTE-AGIS-00006028;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006029 - ZTE-AGIS-00006192; ZTE-AGIS-00006193 - ZTE-AGIS-00006198;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006029 - ZTE-AGIS-00006192; ZTE-AGIS-00006193 - ZTE-AGIS-00006198;
`
`
`
`
`10
`10
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 12 of 42 PageID #: 1146
`Case 2:17-cv-00517-JRG Document 83-1 Filed 09/24/18 Page 12 of 42 PageID #: 1146
`
`ZTE-AGIS-00006199 - ZTE-AGIS-00006209; ZTE-AGIS-00006210 - ZTE-AGIS-00006212;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006199 - ZTE-AGIS-00006209; ZTE-AGIS-00006210 - ZTE-AGIS-00006212;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006213 - ZTE-AGIS-00006215; ZTE-AGIS-00006216 - ZTE-AGIS-00006217;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006213 - ZTE-AGIS-00006215; ZTE-AGIS-00006216 - ZTE-AGIS-00006217;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006218 - ZTE-AGIS-00006307; ZTE-AGIS-00006308 - ZTE-AGIS-00006397;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006218 - ZTE-AGIS-00006307; ZTE-AGIS-00006308 - ZTE-AGIS-00006397;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006398 - ZTE-AGIS-00006401; ZTE-AGIS-00006402 - ZTE-AGIS-00006406;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006398 - ZTE-AGIS-00006401; ZTE-AGIS-00006402 - ZTE-AGIS-00006406;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006407 - ZTE-AGIS-00006488; ZTE-AGIS-00006489 - ZTE-AGIS-00006492;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006407 - ZTE-AGIS-00006488; ZTE-AGIS-00006489 - ZTE-AGIS-00006492;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006493 - ZTE-AGIS-00006495; ZTE-AGIS-00006496 - ZTE-AGIS-00006577;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006493 - ZTE-AGIS-00006495; ZTE-AGIS-00006496 - ZTE-AGIS-00006577;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006578 - ZTE-AGIS-00006581; ZTE-AGIS-00006582 - ZTE-AGIS-00006585;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006578 - ZTE-AGIS-00006581; ZTE-AGIS-00006582 - ZTE-AGIS-00006585;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006586 - ZTE-AGIS-00006589; ZTE-AGIS-00006590 - ZTE-AGIS-00006688;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006586 - ZTE-AGIS-00006589; ZTE-AGIS-00006590 - ZTE-AGIS-00006688;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006689 - ZTE-AGIS-00006731; ZTE-AGIS-00006732 - ZTE-AGIS-00006735;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006689 - ZTE-AGIS-00006731; ZTE-AGIS-00006732 - ZTE-AGIS-00006735;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006736 - ZTE-AGIS-00006740; ZTE-AGIS-00006741 - ZTE-AGIS-00006744;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006736 - ZTE-AGIS-00006740; ZTE-AGIS-00006741 - ZTE-AGIS-00006744;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006745 - ZTE-AGIS-00006802; ZTE-AGIS-00006803 - ZTE-AGIS-00006805;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006745 - ZTE-AGIS-00006802; ZTE-AGIS-00006803 - ZTE-AGIS-00006805;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006806 - ZTE-AGIS-00006807; ZTE-AGIS-00006808 - ZTE-AGIS-00006811;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006806 - ZTE-AGIS-00006807; ZTE-AGIS-00006808 - ZTE-AGIS-00006811;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006812 - ZTE-AGIS-00006816; ZTE-AGIS-00006817 - ZTE-AGIS-00006820;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006812 - ZTE-AGIS-00006816; ZTE-AGIS-00006817 - ZTE-AGIS-00006820;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006821 - ZTE-AGIS-00006821; ZTE-AGIS-00006822 - ZTE-AGIS-00006879;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006821 - ZTE-AGIS-00006821; ZTE-AGIS-00006822 - ZTE-AGIS-00006879;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006880 - ZTE-AGIS-00006883; ZTE-AGIS-00006884 - ZTE-AGIS-00006886;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006880 - ZTE-AGIS-00006883; ZTE-AGIS-00006884 - ZTE-AGIS-00006886;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006887 - ZTE-AGIS-00006954; ZTE-AGIS-00006955 - ZTE-AGIS-00006958;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006887 - ZTE-AGIS-00006954; ZTE-AGIS-00006955 - ZTE-AGIS-00006958;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006959 - ZTE-AGIS-00006961; ZTE-AGIS-00006962 - ZTE-AGIS-00006965;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006959 - ZTE-AGIS-00006961; ZTE-AGIS-00006962 - ZTE-AGIS-00006965;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006966 - ZTE-AGIS-00006967; ZTE-AGIS-00006968 - ZTE-AGIS-00007063;
`ZTE-AGIS-00006966 - ZTE-AGIS-00006967; ZTE-AGIS-00006968 - ZTE-AGIS-00007063;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007064 - ZTE-AGIS-00007099; ZTE-AGIS-00007100 - ZTE-AGIS-00007161;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007064 - ZTE-AGIS-00007099; ZTE-AGIS-00007100 - ZTE-AGIS-00007161;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007162 - ZTE-AGIS-00007163; ZTE-AGIS-00007164 - ZTE-AGIS-00007212;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007162 - ZTE-AGIS-00007163; ZTE-AGIS-00007164 - ZTE-AGIS-00007212;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007213 - ZTE-AGIS-00007240; ZTE-AGIS-00007241 - ZTE-AGIS-00007243;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007213 - ZTE-AGIS-00007240; ZTE-AGIS-00007241 - ZTE-AGIS-00007243;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007244 - ZTE-AGIS-00007246; ZTE-AGIS-00007247 - ZTE-AGIS-00007314;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007244 - ZTE-AGIS-00007246; ZTE-AGIS-00007247 - ZTE-AGIS-00007314;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007315 - ZTE-AGIS-00007315; ZTE-AGIS-00007316 - ZTE-AGIS-00007385;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007315 - ZTE-AGIS-00007315; ZTE-AGIS-00007316 - ZTE-AGIS-00007385;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007386 - ZTE-AGIS-00007389; ZTE-AGIS-00007390 - ZTE-AGIS-00007393;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007386 - ZTE-AGIS-00007389; ZTE-AGIS-00007390 - ZTE-AGIS-00007393;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007394 - ZTE-AGIS-00007397; ZTE-AGIS-00007398 - ZTE-AGIS-00007398;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007394 - ZTE-AGIS-00007397; ZTE-AGIS-00007398 - ZTE-AGIS-00007398;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007399 - ZTE-AGIS-00007544; ZTE-AGIS-00007545 - ZTE-AGIS-00007547;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007399 - ZTE-AGIS-00007544; ZTE-AGIS-00007545 - ZTE-AGIS-00007547;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007548 - ZTE-AGIS-00007550; ZTE-AGIS-00007551 - ZTE-AGIS-00007552;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007548 - ZTE-AGIS-00007550; ZTE-AGIS-00007551 - ZTE-AGIS-00007552;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007553 - ZTE-AGIS-00007572; ZTE-AGIS-00007573 - ZTE-AGIS-00007755;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007553 - ZTE-AGIS-00007572; ZTE-AGIS-00007573 - ZTE-AGIS-00007755;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007756 - ZTE-AGIS-00007758; ZTE-AGIS-00007759 - ZTE-AGIS-00007761;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007756 - ZTE-AGIS-00007758; ZTE-AGIS-00007759 - ZTE-AGIS-00007761;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007762 - ZTE-AGIS-00007763; ZTE-AGIS-00007764 - ZTE-AGIS-00007785;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007762 - ZTE-AGIS-00007763; ZTE-AGIS-00007764 - ZTE-AGIS-00007785;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007786 - ZTE-AGIS-00007789; ZTE-AGIS-00007790 - ZTE-AGIS-00007963;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007786 - ZTE-AGIS-00007789; ZTE-AGIS-00007790 - ZTE-AGIS-00007963;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007964 - ZTE-AGIS-00007966; ZTE-AGIS-00007967 - ZTE-AGIS-00007968;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007964 - ZTE-AGIS-00007966; ZTE-AGIS-00007967 - ZTE-AGIS-00007968;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007969 - ZTE-AGIS-00008008; ZTE-AGIS-00008009 - ZTE-AGIS-00008037;
`ZTE-AGIS-00007969 - ZTE-AGIS-00008008; ZTE-AGIS-00008009 - ZTE-AGIS-00008037;
`ZTE-AGIS-00008038 - ZTE-AGIS-00008040; ZTE-AGIS-00008041 - ZTE-AGIS-00008044;
`ZTE-AGIS-00008038 - ZTE-AGIS-00008040; ZTE-AGIS-00008041 - ZTE-AGIS-00008044;
`ZTE-AGIS-0000804

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket