Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 1 of 19 PageID #: 19450
`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 1 of 19 PageID #: 19450
`
`EXHIBIT 17
`
`EXHIBIT 17
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 2 of 19 PageID #: 19451
`
`From:
`To:
`Cc:
`Subject:
`Date:
`
`Ameet Modi
`Messing, Alessandra C.; Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Rubino, Vincent J.; D"Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`Thursday, August 9, 2018 6:16:42 PM
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Thanks for following up. None of the individuals listed in your email is an Apple employee. Mr. Siegel has been retained as an expert consultant in this matter, but
`my firm will accept service of a subpoena directed to him for the purpose of providing factual testimony with respect to the functionality and public availability of
`the FBCB2 prior art system and its predecessor systems.
`
`Apple has not made any final determinations on who it will or will not call at trial in this matter. Apple will make those disclosures consistent with the Court’s
`scheduling order. Likewise, to the extent Apple serves subpoenas on any of the individuals listed in your email, we will of course provide appropriate notice to
`AGIS, consistent with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
`
`Regards,
`Ameet
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Thursday, August 9, 2018 7:34 AM
`To: Ameet Modi <AModi@desmaraisllp.com>; Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Ameet, Kerri-Ann,
`
`We have not heard back regarding the additional deposition witnesses discussed in my email below sent on August 2. AGIS is requesting this information so it has
`a fair opportunity to depose the individuals Apple intends to present for trial testimony during the fact discovery period. Please respond by COB today so we have
`sufficient time to make any necessary arrangements.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Sent: Thursday, August 02, 2018 4:00 PM
`To: 'Kerri-Ann Limbeek'
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We are working to secure deposition locations in either San Jose or Redwood City and will confirm as soon as possible.
`
`For the following individuals identified in Apple's Second Amended Initial and Additional Disclosures, please inform us by next Wednesday, August 8, 2018,
` whether Apple is in control of each individual, intends to present testimony of said individual at trial, and will accept service of a deposition notice: Daniel
`J. Burns, Joann J. Ordille, Thomas A. Petsche, John Roujinsky, Lawrence R. Sweeney, James D. Maloy, Claudine Astorri, Linda Boyle, Marcellino
`Tanumihardja, Gregory A. Brown, Steven L. Zimmers, Daniel W. David, Samuel H. Altman, Nicholas T. Sivo, Richard D. Haney, Joseph F. Karam, Ronald Leon
`Poulin, Kevin Thomas Buckham, Anthony Luigi Melli, Karon A. Weber, Jonathan Trevor, Edward Ho, Samantha Tripodi, Kulbir S. Sandhu, Roderic C. Fan,
`David Mleczko, Kenny Nguyen, Carey Fan, Michael A. Sheha, Angie Sheha, Stephen Petilli, Aaron T. Emigh, James A, Roskind, William Griswold, and Neil
`Gilbert Siegel.
`
`Alternatively, please let us know if Apple intends to serve subpoenas on any of these individuals. To the extent there are any third parties identified in
`Apple's Second Amended Initial and Additional Disclosures and not listed above, please provide the requested information. To the extent that Apple
`intends to present at trial any witnesses not listed in this correspondence, identified in its Second Amended Initial and Additional Disclosures, or designated
`as Apple corporate witnesses pursuant to Rule 30(b)(6), we request that you identify such individuals no later than Wednesday, August 8, 2018.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 3 of 19 PageID #: 19452
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Wednesday, August 01, 2018 5:53 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Counsel,
`
`Please see the attached correspondence regarding depositions.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Tuesday, July 31, 2018 8:03 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`AGIS accepts Aug 21 for Mr. Krasts's deposition.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Friday, July 27, 2018 6:04 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Evan Krasts is available to be deposed on August 21, 2018 in or around Cupertino, CA. Here is a list of the topics for which he is designated:
`40-43, 53-54 (with respect to marketing, promotion, and advertisement), 60-62, and 71-72 (with respect to the topics for which he is
`designated).
`
`Please confirm that date and provide a location for the deposition.
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 4 of 19 PageID #: 19453
`
`Thanks,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Sent: Wednesday, July 25, 2018 12:29 PM
`To: 'Messing, Alessandra C.' <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`We confirm that we will be designating one or more witnesses for topics 40-43 and 60-62, subject to Apple’s objections. That witness will
`be Evan Krasts, and he will be available for deposition in or near Cupertino, California. Mr. Krasts will also be designated for topics 53-54
`(with respect to marketing, promotion, and advertisement), and 71-72 (with respect to the topics for which he is designated). We are in
`the process of confirming Mr. Krasts’s availability for deposition within the dates you have indicated a preference, and we will do our best
`to confirm his availability by the end of this week.
`
`With respect to topics 37, 38, 44, and 49, as we stated on the meet-and-confer, Apple has already designated one or more witnesses to
`testify in response to numerous other topics concerning the design, development, distribution, and/or importation of the accused software
`features, and the marketing of the accused software features. On the meet and confer, you were unable to provide any information about
`what non-cumulative testimony AGIS is seeking with respect to topics 37, 38, 44, and 49, how that testimony would be relevant to this
`case, or how any relevance would outweigh the substantial undue hardship on Apple of preparing witnesses to testify on those topics
`concerning each of the nearly 100 hardware “Accused Products” or “each and every hardware portion of the Apple Accused Servers.” On
`those bases, Apple stands by its objections, and based on our call we understand AGIS will not pursue these topics. If that is not correct,
`and if AGIS is willing to narrow these topics, we are willing to further discuss.
`
`We appreciate AGIS’s willingness to tentatively withdraw topics 48, 51, 52, or 57. We have asked AGIS to explain how those topics are
`relevant and not cumulative of AGIS’s other discovery requests, including topics for which Apple has already designated one or more
`witnesses to testify, and we can be available if AGIS intends to move forward on those topics.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2018 4:36 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Thanks for speaking with me and accommodating the time change. Our understanding is that Apple will be designating a witness for Topic
`Nos. 40-43 and 60-61. Please identify the witness and propose a deposition date for these topics by the end of the week. Please also
`clarify whether Apple will designate a witness to testify regarding Topic No. 62.
`
`Regarding Topic Nos. 37, 38, 44, and 49, our understanding of Apple's position is that testimony responsive to these topics, as it pertains
`to the accused technology, is already covered by other topics and that testimony related to hardware is not relevant. Apple is standing on
`its objections that documents, information, and testimony related to hardware is irrelevant and unduly burdensome. Please confirm.
`
`Regarding Topic Nos. 48, 51, 52 and 57, AGIS is willing to tentatively withdraw these topics dependent upon how facts develop at the
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 5 of 19 PageID #: 19454
`
`depositions and contingent upon Apple's agreement not to use information related to components in support of any of its claims or
`defenses.
`
` will provide an update as to timing on production of source code and AGIS's supplemental interrogatory responses as soon as possible.
`
` I
`
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2018 1:52 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
` apologize that was my scheduling mix-up. I am available any time today until 4 pm or tomorrow starting at noon.
`
` I
`
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2018 1:50 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`We waited on the line for 15 minutes and no one on your team joined. Please let us know what the issue was and whether you can
`reschedule.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2018 1:35 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 6 of 19 PageID #: 19455
`
`Alessandra,
`
`We are on the line at the dial-in I provided. Will someone from your team be joining?
`
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2018 4:09 PM
`To: 'Messing, Alessandra C.' <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Thanks. We can do the call at 1:30 pm on Tuesday using the dial-in below:
`
`(866) 809-5359
`Conference code:
`8954054179
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2018 3:26 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Tomorrow at 4 pm does not work. I am available Tuesday any time between 11 am and 3 pm.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2018 2:50 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Those times do not work for us. Are you available tomorrow at 4 pm ET? Otherwise, what is your availability between 10:00 am
`and 3 pm on Tuesday?
`
`Thanks,
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 7 of 19 PageID #: 19456
`
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2018 11:47 AM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Those times do not work. Please let me know if you have availability on Monday between 12pm and 2 pm or between 3 pm and
`5:30 pm.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2018 11:40 AM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Cc: Rubino, Vincent J.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: Re: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`We are not available at 1:30 pm tomorrow. We are available before 1:30 pm tomorrow or anytime on Friday (7/20).
` Please let us know when in those timeframes works for you.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`On Jul 18, 2018, at 11:35 AM, Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com> wrote:
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We are no longer available tomorrow at 2:30 pm Eastern. Please let me know if 1:30 pm works as an alternative.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image004.jpg>
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2018 5:34 PM
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 8 of 19 PageID #: 19457
`
`To: 'Kerri-Ann Limbeek'; Rubino, Vincent J.
`Cc: D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We are not ignoring your correspondence. As I stated previously, we are working on addressing the statements made
`in your recent letters. We will provide a written response this week and will also be producing documents this week.
`
`We can be available to meet and confer on Thursday at 2:30 pm. Please use the following dial-in.
`
`877-211-3621
`Passcode: 549224
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image003.jpg>
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2018 5:26 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.; Rubino, Vincent J.
`Cc: D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`External E-mail. Use caution accessing links or attachments.
`
`Alessandra,
`
`AGIS continues to ignore our correspondence regarding deficiencies in its discovery in this case. On the meet and
`confer, please be prepared to discuss each of the issues identified in my correspondence of July 13, before we turn to
`the 30(b)(6) topics.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2018 4:49 PM
`To: 'Messing, Alessandra C.' <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>; Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service <AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>;
`Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Thanks. Please also confirm Mr. Lopatin’s deposition on August 17, 2018.
`
`As stated in my email of July 10, Mr. Suparna is designated for topic 11. We will provide a date for the designee on
`topics 40-43, 60, and 61 as soon as we have that information.
`
`1:30 tomorrow does not work for us for the proposed meet and confer. We are available tomorrow (7/18) after 4 pm
`ET or on Thursday (7/19) at 2:30 pm ET. Please let us know if those times work for AGIS.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 9 of 19 PageID #: 19458
`
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2018 3:12 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>; Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>; Apple AGIS Service <AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>;
`Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We accept August 9 and 10 for the depositions of Mr. Jayne and Mr. Suparna, respectively, as well as August 28 for
`Mr. Garcia. Apple has not yet designated a witness for Topic Nos. 11, 40–43, 60, and 61. Please provide a date for
`Apple's designated witness on these topics by the end of the week.
`
`We would also like to meet and confer regarding the topics for which Apple has refused to designate a witness,
`including Topic Nos. 37, 38, 44, 48, 51, and 57. Please let us know if you are available tomorrow at 1:30 pm.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image003.jpg>
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com
`www.brownrudnick.com
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2018 2:46 PM
`To: Rubino, Vincent J.
`Cc: Messing, Alessandra C.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; Melissa Smith; AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Vincent,
`
`Please confirm Mr. Jayne’s deposition on August 9 and Mr. Suparna’s on August 10.
`
`In addition, Roberto Garcia is available to be deposed on August 28, 2018. Here is a list of the topics for which he is
`designated: 5, 12, 31, 71-72 (with respect to the topics for which he is designated). Please confirm that this date
`works for AGIS.
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Sent: Wednesday, July 11, 2018 10:24 AM
`To: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>;
`Apple AGIS Service <AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit
`<agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Vince,
`
`As requested, we could switch those two dates so that Mr. Jaynes is on August 9 and Mr. Suparna is on August 10.
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 10 of 19 PageID #: 19459
`
`Please confirm that this will work for AGIS.
`
`Thanks,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`DESMARAIS LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com
`
`From: Rubino, Vincent J. <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>
`Sent: Tuesday, July 10, 2018 10:14 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek <KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`Cc: Messing, Alessandra C. <AMessing@brownrudnick.com>; D'Aquila, Danielle <DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>;
`Apple AGIS Service <AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>; Melissa Smith <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>; AGIS-Lit
`<agislit@brownrudnick.com>
`Subject: Re: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Is it possible to switch the days for Mr. Suparna and Mr. Jaynes so that Mr Jaynes is on August
`9 and Mr. Suparna is on August 10? If so, we may be able to make these dates work.
`
`thanks,
`Vincent
`
`On Jul 10, 2018, at 9:51 PM, Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`<KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>> wrote:
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Mr. Suparna is not available on August 13 or 14, but he is available on August 9, 2018. Here is
`an updated list of the topics for which he is designated: 4, 9, 10, 11, 13-15, 18-19 (with respect
`to server-side source code for FindMyFriends and FindMyiPhone), 21-25, 32-35, 50, 71-72
`(with respect to the topics for which he is designated).
`
`Mr. Jaynes is not available on August 13, 14, 16, or 17, but he is available on August 10, 2018.
`Here is an updated list of the topics for which he is designated: 36, 39, 45-47, 53-54 (with
`respect to sales, offers for sale, distribution, and importation), 55, 56, 59, 63, 64, 69, 70, 71-72
`(with respect to the topics for which he is designated).
`
`Additionally, Scott Lopatin is available to be deposed on August 17, 2018. Here is a list of the
`topics for which he is designated: 1-3, 6-8, 16-17, 18 (with respect to client-side source code for
`FindMyFriends and FindMyiPhone), 19 (with respect to client-side source code for
`FindMyFriends and FindMyiPhone), 20, 26-30, 71-72 (with respect to the topics for which he is
`designated).
`
`Please confirm that these dates work for AGIS.
`
`Thanks,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Desmarais LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`<AMessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:AMessing@brownrudnick.com>>
`Sent: Monday, July 9, 2018 5:59 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`<KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>>; D'Aquila, Danielle
`<DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com<mailto:DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>>; Apple AGIS
`Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>>;
`'Melissa Smith' <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com<mailto:melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>>
`Cc: AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com<mailto:agislit@brownrudnick.com>>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 11 of 19 PageID #: 19460
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We will review Apple's Amended Objections and Responses to AGIS's Rule 30(b)(6) Notice
`and reach out if it appears that it does not accurately represent the parties' agreements and that
`we need to confer further on these issues.
`
`I've indicated on more than one occasion that we are not available on August 7 or 8 due to a
`hearing in one of the other consolidated cases. Please let us know if Mr. Suparna can instead be
`available on August 13 or 14.
`
`Please let us know if Mr. Jaynes can be available on either August 13, 14, 16, or 17, on a date
`that Mr. Suparna is not scheduled to be deposed. We already have another deposition scheduled
`on August 15.
`
`We can accept August 30 for Mr. Ankenbrandt's deposition.
`
`Providing availability of additional witnesses over the next several weeks is unacceptable given
`that AGIS's corporate deposition notice was served on Apple on January 19, 2018 and that
`AGIS has been consistently requesting deposition dates for at least two months. Please provide
`Apple's designees for the remaining topics and dates for each by the end of this week and
`confirm that Apple's 30(b)(6) designees will cover all fact witnesses identified in Apple's initial
`disclosures that it intends to call at trial.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image002.jpg>
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:amessing@brownrudnick.com>
`www.brownrudnick.com<http://www.brownrudnick.com/>
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Monday, July 09, 2018 4:26 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; 'Melissa Smith'
`Cc: AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`Attached are Apple’s Amended Objections and Responses to AGIS’s 30(b)(6) Notice, which
`reflect the agreements reached on the meet and confer regarding this notice.
`
`Your allegation of delay lacks merit. Apple has been working as diligently as possible to
`coordinate witness availability for the 72 topics in AGIS’s 30(b)(6) notice, many of which
`cover multiple distinct product groups. To that end, Apple has been working to provide a
`comprehensive schedule of witnesses that the parties could meaningfully discuss. That said,
`below are current availabilities that we have been able to secure for three Apple witnesses, with
`the topics for which they are designated in parentheses. We are continuing to coordinate
`schedules and will provide the availability of additional witnesses over the next several days
`and weeks.
`
`• Navin Suparna (topics 4, 9-11, 13-15, 18-25, 32-35, 50, 71, 72): August 7 or 8, 2018
`• Michael Jaynes (topics 36, 39, 45-48, 52-56, 59, 63, 64, 69, 70, 71, 72): August 15, 2018
`• Brian Ankenbrandt (topics 58, 65-68, 71, 72): August 30 or 31, 2018
`
`Regards,
`Kerri-Ann
`
`Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`Desmarais LLP
`230 Park Avenue
`New York, NY 10169
`T: (212) 351-3400 | F: (212) 351-3401
`D: (212) 808-2962 | E: klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:klimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`<AMessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:AMessing@brownrudnick.com>>
`Sent: Monday, July 9, 2018 1:38 PM
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 12 of 19 PageID #: 19461
`
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek
`<KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com>>; D'Aquila, Danielle
`<DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com<mailto:DD'Aquila@brownrudnick.com>>; Apple AGIS
`Service
`<AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com<mailto:AppleAGISService@desmaraisllp.com>>;
`'Melissa Smith' <melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com<mailto:melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com>>
`Cc: AGIS-Lit <agislit@brownrudnick.com<mailto:agislit@brownrudnick.com>>
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Apple's delay in providing deposition dates is becoming unreasonable. We are approaching the
`2-month mark since AGIS first requested dates yet Apple has yet to provide anything more than
`a general timeframe of July or August.
`
`We are now unavailable for the remainder of July, August 7-8, and August 14-17. We can be
`available the week of August 27. Please provide firm dates by COB today.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image002.jpg>
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:amessing@brownrudnick.com>
`www.brownrudnick.com<http://www.brownrudnick.com/>
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2018 10:44 AM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; 'Melissa Smith'
`Cc: AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`Please advise regarding the Apple witnesses' availability for depositions by the end of this
`week. Our availability is becoming thin due to other depositions being scheduled with the
`consolidated defendants in this matter as well as others.
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image002.jpg>
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:amessing@brownrudnick.com>
`www.brownrudnick.com<http://www.brownrudnick.com/>
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Messing, Alessandra C.
`Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2018 2:17 PM
`To: Kerri-Ann Limbeek; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; 'Melissa Smith'
`Cc: AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Kerri-Ann,
`
`We are unavailable July 10-11, July 23-24, August 7-8, August 14-17, and the week of August
`27 due to depositions and hearings that have been previously scheduled for this case and other
`matters. Please let us know as soon as possible when Apple's witnesses will be made available.
`We have been requesting deposition dates for about 6 weeks at this point and expect scheduling
`conflicts to continue to arise.
`
`

`

`Case 2:17-cv-00513-JRG Document 309-2 Filed 01/18/19 Page 13 of 19 PageID #: 19462
`
`Thanks,
`Alessandra
`
`<image002.jpg>
`
`Alessandra Carcaterra Messing
`Counselor at Law
`
`Brown Rudnick LLP
`Seven Times Square
`New York, NY 10036
`T: 212.209.4871
`F: 212.938.2990
`amessing@brownrudnick.com<mailto:amessing@brownrudnick.com>
`www.brownrudnick.com<http://www.brownrudnick.com/>
`
`Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
`
`From: Kerri-Ann Limbeek [mailto:KLimbeek@desmaraisllp.com]
`Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2018 1:51 PM
`To: Messing, Alessandra C.; D'Aquila, Danielle; Apple AGIS Service; 'Melissa Smith'
`Cc: AGIS-Lit
`Subject: RE: AGIS v. Apple - 30(b)(6) Notice
`
`Alessandra,
`
`We are looking into the availabilitie