`
`
`
`Exhibit B
`
`
`
`Case 2:12-cv-02826-JPM-tmp Document 32-4 Filed 02/14/13 Page 2 of 3 PageID 387
`
`CALIFORNIA NORTHERN
`
`Numerical
`Standing
`Within
`U.S.
`Circuit
`
`4
`
`6
`3
`
`14
`
`11
`4
`4
`7
`10
`
`7
`3
`
`7
`
`9
`
`25
`
`
`
`23
`12
`
`76
`
`40
`33
`9
`23
`63
`
`43
`11
`
`63
`
`66
`
`U.S. District Court — Judicial Caseload Profile
`12Month Periods Ending
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`2008
`2009
`2010
`2011
`7,468
`7,790
`7,590
`7,980
`7,595
`7,573
`8,824
`8,471
`9,240
`8,959
`7,665
`7,039
`
`Sep 30
`2007
`8,070
`6,966
`9,394
`
`Sep 30
`2012
`8,426
`7,875
`7,348
`
`4.4
`14
`0.0
`576
`505
`
`40
`
`31
`671
`624
`498
`8
`
`12.8
`14
`5.9
`533
`441
`
`54
`
`38
`660
`592
`543
`6
`
` 12.3
`6.7
`
` 11.2
`7.7
`
`24.9
`
`393
`4.7
`
`1.2
`
`53.8
`
`41.9
`
`30.0
`
`488
`6.0
`
`1.3
`
`64.1
`
`42.1
`
`8.2
`14
`22.0
`556
`433
`
`79
`
`44
`640
`607
`541
`6
`
` 6.7
`9.4
`
`24.5
`
`1,220
`15.7
`
`1.3
`
`77.5
`
`48.5
`
`11.0
`14
`33.9
`542
`435
`
`64
`
`43
`548
`593
`630
`12
`
`5.6
`14
`18.7
`570
`471
`
`66
`
`33
`503
`631
`605
`17
`
`
`14
`29.7
`602
`510
`
`64
`
`28
`525
`675
`563
`16
`
` 8.7
`9.8
`
` 9.4
`8.0
`
` 8.5
` 6.4
`
`21.5
`
`837
`12.8
`
`1.2
`
`62.1
`
`39.4
`
`34.3
`
`516
`8.8
`
`1.4
`
`64.5
`
`35.5
`
`32.7
`
`476
`7.8
`
`1.4
`
`65.8
`
`43.6
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`From Filing to
`Disposition
`
`Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Pending
`Percent Change in Total
`Filings Current Year
`Over Earlier Year
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ²
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ²
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`Felony
`Civil ²
`From Filing to Trial ²
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ²
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
` or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`2012 Civil Case and Criminal Felony Defendant Filings by Nature of Suit and Offense
`J
`Total
`A
`B
`C
`D
`E
`F
`G
`H
`I
`Type of
`68
`869
`543
`29
`7,145
`126
`476
`1,376
`612
`797
`753
`296
`Civil
`30
`22
`12
`117
`885
`26
`247
`175
`144
`41
`31
`14
`Criminal ¹
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ Filings in the "Overall Caseload Statistics" section include criminal transfers, while filings by "Nature of Offense" do not.
`² See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`K
`
`L
`1,200
`26
`
`
`
`Case 2:12-cv-02826-JPM-tmp Document 32-4 Filed 02/14/13 Page 3 of 3 PageID 388
`
`TENNESSEE WESTERN
`
`Numerical
`Standing
`Within
`U.S.
`Circuit
`
`4
`
`6
`8
`
`3
`
`1
`3
`7
`5
`2
`
`8
`8
`
`1
`
`4
`
`41
`
`
`
`60
`58
`
`33
`
`17
`25
`50
`50
`19
`
`89
`75
`
`11
`
`48
`
`U.S. District Court — Judicial Caseload Profile
`12Month Periods Ending
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`Sep 30
`2008
`2009
`2010
`2011
`2,076
`2,279
`2,174
`2,243
`1,947
`2,161
`2,219
`2,149
`2,603
`2,749
`2,711
`2,820
`
`Sep 30
`2007
`2,040
`2,145
`2,446
`
`Sep 30
`2012
`2,286
`2,325
`2,813
`
`12.1
`5
`0.0
`408
`226
`
`147
`
`36
`489
`410
`429
`49
`
`10.1
`5
`0.0
`415
`243
`
`139
`
`32
`521
`424
`389
`42
`
`0.3
`5
`0.0
`456
`242
`
`171
`
`42
`550
`442
`432
`39
`
`5.2
`5
`0.0
`435
`266
`
`132
`
`36
`542
`439
`444
`42
`
`1.9
`5
`0.8
`449
`300
`
`99
`
`49
`564
`429
`430
`39
`
`
`5
`9.3
`457
`295
`
`113
`
`50
`563
`450
`465
`27
`
` 12.6
`11.9
`
` 13.6
`11.8
`
` 13.4
`11.3
`
` 12.4
`10.3
`
` 14.9
`11.5
`
` 15.4
` 10.6
`
`23.5
`
`26.4
`
`28.5
`
`29.0
`
`22.6
`
`18.8
`
`66
`5.2
`
`1.4
`
`56.2
`
`50.5
`
`62
`4.4
`
`1.3
`
`42.8
`
`41.4
`
`55
`3.9
`
`1.4
`
`38.7
`
`35.9
`
`64
`4.4
`
`1.3
`
`43.5
`
`47.7
`
`71
`4.1
`
`1.4
`
`48.6
`
`55.6
`
`86
`4.8
`
`1.6
`
`65.7
`
`58.5
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`From Filing to
`Disposition
`
`Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Pending
`Percent Change in Total
`Filings Current Year
`Over Earlier Year
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ²
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ²
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`Felony
`Civil ²
`From Filing to Trial ²
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ²
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
` or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`2012 Civil Case and Criminal Felony Defendant Filings by Nature of Suit and Offense
`J
`Total
`A
`B
`C
`D
`E
`F
`G
`H
`I
`Type of
`2
`347
`38
`94
`49
`20
`98
`90
`1,474
`386
`143
`112
`Civil
`8
`13
`23
`12
`61
`129
`231
`24
`563
`13
`26
`4
`Criminal ¹
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ Filings in the "Overall Caseload Statistics" section include criminal transfers, while filings by "Nature of Offense" do not.
`² See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`K
`
`L
`
`95
`19