throbber
Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`
`ESTTA1003365
`
`Filing date:
`
`09/19/2019
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Proceeding
`
`92071454
`
`Party
`
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Submission
`
`Filer's Name
`
`Filer's email
`
`Signature
`
`Date
`
`Attachments
`
`Defendant
`Richardâ##s Rainwater
`
`DAVID E. ARMENDARIZ
`PIRKEY BARBER PLLC
`1801 EAST 6TH STREET, SUITE 300
`AUSTIN, TX 78702
`UNITED STATES
`akuhn@pirkeybarber.com, darmendariz@pirkeybarber.com,
`eolson@pirkeybarber.com, tmcentral@pirkeybarber.com
`512-322-5200
`
`Other Motions/Papers
`
`David E. Armendariz
`
`akuhn@pirkeybarber.com, darmendariz@pirkeybarber.com,
`eolson@pirkeybarber.com, tmcentral@pirkeybarber.com
`
`/David E. Armendariz/
`
`09/19/2019
`
`Motion for a More Definite Statement.pdf(107057 bytes )
`Exhibit A.pdf(6180316 bytes )
`Exhibit B.pdf(1772069 bytes )
`Exhibit C.pdf(260918 bytes )
`Exhibit D.pdf(344984 bytes )
`Exhibit E.pdf(1555653 bytes )
`
`

`

`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`THIS CAN BE DONE, LLC,
`
`Cancellation No.: 92071454
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Petitioner,
`
`Mark: CLOUD JUICE
`
`v.
`
`Registration No.: 4,770,355
`
`
`
`RICHARD’S RAINWATER, LLC,
`
`Registered: July 7, 2015
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Registrant.
`
`MOTION FOR A MORE DEFINITE STATEMENT
`
`Pursuant to Rule 12(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Section 505 of the
`
`Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Manual of Procedure (“TBMP”), Registrant Richard’s
`
`Rainwater, LLC moves the Board to order Petitioner This Can Be Done, LLC (“Petitioner” or
`
`“TCBD”) to provide a more definite statement in the form of an Amended Petition for Cancellation
`
`regarding the basis for its claim of standing.
`
`BACKGROUND
`
`According to Petitioner, the mere prospect that Registrant’s CLOUD JUICE registration
`
`(the “Registration”) might be cited by a trademark examiner against its as-yet hypothetical
`
`trademark application is enough to give it standing to seek cancellation of the Registration.
`
`However, even ignoring the fact that TCBD’s claimed interest in the action and perceived potential
`
`harm is entirely theoretical, the recitations in the Petition obscure critical facts regarding TCBD’s
`
`goods that are potentially dispositive on the question of standing. TCBD claims that it intends to
`
`file a trademark application for CLOUD WATER in Class 032 only for “bottled drinking water,”
`
`
`
`1
`
`

`

`but it is clear from sources referenced by TCBD in its Petition that the goods that TCBD sells and
`
`would have to identify in its eventual application consist not of plain drinking water, but of
`
`drinking water infused with cannabidiol, commonly known as “CBD.” Because trademarks for
`
`ingestible CBD products cannot be registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (“PTO”),
`
`Petitioner would be unable to register the mark CLOUD WATER for its CBD products
`
`notwithstanding the Registration, and as such, Petitioner can point to no harm caused by the
`
`continued registration of Registrant’s mark. However, because the Petition as presented lacks
`
`specificity regarding the goods for which Petitioner intends (and intended at the time of filing its
`
`Petition) to seek registration, Registrant is unable to fully and fairly respond in good faith to its
`
`claims, including its claim of standing.
`
`Accordingly, Registrant moves the Board to order Plaintiff to describe with specificity the
`
`goods for which it intends to seek registration of the purported mark CLOUD WATER, including
`
`whether such goods include ingestible CBD.
`
`ARGUMENT
`
`
`
`A motion for a more definite statement is appropriate where a pleading is “so vague or
`
`ambiguous that the movant cannot make a responsive pleading in good faith or without prejudice
`
`to itself.” TBMP § 505.01. “The motion must point out the defects complained of, specify the
`
`details which the movant desires to have pleaded, and indicate that the movant is unable to frame
`
`a responsive pleading without the desired information.” Id.
`
`Petitioner claims that it has a real interest in seeking cancellation of the Registration, and
`
`thus standing to bring this action, because it intends to file an application to register CLOUD
`
`WATER in Class 32, which Petitioner argues is similar to Registrant’s CLOUD JUICE mark. See
`
`1 TTABVUE ¶¶ 11, 13. Petitioner also claims that the goods it offers under its purported mark
`
`
`
`2
`
`

`

`are similar to the goods listed in the Registration, and that it “anticipates that the [PTO] will issue
`
`an Office action [sic] refusing registration . . . on the basis of likelihood of confusion with
`
`Respondent’s registered CLOUD JUICE mark.” Id. ¶ 13. Petitioner describes its own goods
`
`merely as “bottled water” and “bottled drinking water.” See, e.g., id. ¶¶ 5, 10, 11 However,
`
`Petitioner does not identify with specificity the description of goods for which it intends to apply
`
`to register its purported mark. This is critical because it is undeniable that what Petitioner sells
`
`under its purported mark is not ordinary bottled drinking water, but water infused with CBD.
`
`CBD “is a chemical constituent of the cannabis plant that is encompassed within the
`
`[Controlled Substances Act]’s definition of marijuana.” See USPTO, Examination Guide 1-19,
`
`Examination of Marks for Cannabis and Cannabis-Related Goods and Services after Enactment
`
`of
`
`the
`
`2018
`
`Farm
`
`Bill,
`
`May
`
`2,
`
`2019,
`
`available
`
`at
`
`https://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/Exam%20Guide%201-19.pdf. According to
`
`the examination guide, while some CBD products may be lawful, “registration of marks for foods,
`
`beverages, dietary supplements, or pet treats containing CBD will still be refused as unlawful
`
`under the [Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act], even if derived from hemp, as such goods may
`
`not be introduced into interstate commerce.” Id. (emphasis added).
`
`TCBD conveniently limits mention in its Petition of the fact that its business is offering
`
`ingestible food, beverage, and supplements containing CBD for which registration is unavailable
`
`according to the Examination Guide, including its “Cloud Water” bottled water. However, in
`
`touting its press coverage, TCBD references articles about its “Cloud Water” product in
`
`publications such as “BevNET, TrendHunter, Culinary Epicenter, and High Sobriety.1” 1
`
`
`1 This is likely a typo and intended as a reference to the publication “High Snobiety”
`(https://www.highsnobiety.com/), as TCBD’s website links to two articles from that site. See
`https://cloudwaterbrands.com/press (screenshot attached as Exhibit D).
`
`
`
`3
`
`

`

`TTABVUE ¶ 7. Attached as Exhibit A are articles from those publications about TCBD’s “Cloud
`
`Water” product, all of which make clear that the product is a CBD beverage.2 A review of social
`
`media for “Cloud Water,” which is referenced in Paragraph 6 of the Petition, confirms the same.
`
`See Exhibit B (screenshot of https://www.facebook.com/cloudwatercbd/) and Exhibit C
`
`(screenshot
`
`of
`
`https://www.instagram.com/cloudwatercbd/),
`
`both
`
`at
`
`the
`
`username
`
`@cloudwatercbd. Additionally, all of the TCBD’s applications mentioned in Paragraph 12 of the
`
`Petition identify ingestibles containing CBD in their descriptions of goods.3
`
`If TCBD’s intended goods for its hypothetical application consist of ingestible CBD
`
`products—as all reasonable evidence and inferences suggest—then it is the nature of its own goods
`
`that would prevent registration of its mark, and its claim that the CLOUD JUICE Registration
`
`causes it harm is wholly without merit. Because TCBD’s mark would be unregistrable regardless
`
`of the status of the Registration, TCBD would have no real interest in seeking cancellation of the
`
`Registration, and thus no standing. However, the current lack of specificity in the Petition
`
`regarding TCBD’s goods disguises the true nature of its products, unfairly preventing Registrant
`
`from adequately responding to the pleading in good faith.
`
`CONCLUSION
`
`Given the PTO’s clear guidance on ingestible CBD products, it is understandable that
`
`TCBD would seek to obscure the fact that its “Cloud Water” products contain CBD, as that
`
`completely negates TCBD’s stated basis for standing in this action. However, TCBD’s tactics in
`
`this regard make it impossible for Registrant to adequately respond to its allegations, including its
`
`
`2 TCBD’s own website at https://cloudwaterbrands.com/faq explains that “Cloud Water is a
`delicious sparkling CBD beverage” and that “each bottle contains 25mg of CBD.” Screenshots
`from TCBD’s website for “Cloud Water” are attached as Exhibit E.
`3 And of course, it is difficult to ignore the fact that the acronym for Petitioner’s name, “This Can
`Be Done,” contains the letters “CBD.”
`
`
`
`4
`
`

`

`allegation that it has standing to bring this action at all.
`
`Based on the foregoing, Registrant respectfully requests that the Board order TCBD to
`
`amend its pleading to state with specificity the goods it sells and intended, at the time it filed its
`
`Petition, to cover in its trademark application for the mark CLOUD WATER, including whether
`
`such goods contain CBD. Registrant further requests that the Board grant any and all other relief
`
`to which it deems Registrant entitled, including, in the alternative to an order for a more definite
`
`statement, dismissal of the action for lack of standing.
`
`
`
`This the 19th day of September, 2019.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully Submitted
`
`
`
`/David E. Armendariz/
`Anna Kuhn
`David E. Armendariz
`PIRKEY BARBER PLLC
`1801 East 6th Street, Suite 300
`Austin, Texas 78702
`Telephone: (512) 482-5223
`Facsimile: (512) 322-5201
`akuhn@pirkeybarber.com
`darmendariz@pirkeybarber.com
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`
` I certify that a copy of this document was served by email on September 19, 2019 on
`Petitioner’s counsel of record:
`
`Olivera Medenica
`DUNNINGTON BATHOLOW & MILLER LLP
`230 Park Avenue, 21st Floor
`New York, NY 10169
`omedenica@dunnington.com
`jfrank@dunnington.com
`Idale@dunnington.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/David E. Armendariz/
`David E. Armendariz
`
`5
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`

`BevNET Article
`
`BeVNET Article
`
`

`

`Title: Cloud Water CBD | BevNET.com Product Reviews | BevNET.com
`Lin k: https :yiylwww . bevnet.comfr'eviewsy’cloud-water
`
`
`BEVNE Io
`NEWS REVIEWS PDDCAST EVENTS JOBS SCHCICIL MAGAIINE DIRECTORIES |
`f E]
`if n | Q :
`
`JUST ANNDUNCED
`
`From Startup to National Player, Brew Dr. Kombucha CEO to Speak at BevNET Live This December - Learn More so»
`
`TAKING APPLICATIONS
`
`NEW BEVERAGE SNOWOOWN
`
`DEC. 9 8-10 I SANTA MONICA. CA
`
`:EP
`
`HOME l REvIEWE. a torus wrote {as
`
`CID "[l wate r c B D
`
`by Clnurlwater OBI]
`
`é? https:lr'cloudwaterbrandscoml
`
`fl Edit Contact info
`
`
`
`all!
`
`B EVE RAG E IN DU STRY JOBS
`
`Associate Brewmaster - Rogue Ales at Spirits
`
`Brewer — Rogue Ales a Spirits
`
`Cellar Workers — associate 3: lead roles availabl...
`
`Operations Manager Guru - Eclipse Foods
`
`On Premise Beer Sales Representative - San B...
`
`I: LOU D WAT E R B R A H D 5
`
`Cin Premise Beer Sales Representative . San B...
`
`Share this Page: n n a n a
`
`NEWEST REll'IEl'll
`
`ALL PRODUCTS
`
`ALL IMAGES
`
`BRAND DETAILS
`
`ORDER ONLINE
`
`Operations Manager — Yai’s Thai
`
`View All - 442 Jobs
`
`1 Post a Job
`
`Subscribe to BevNET's Daily Newsletter
`
`Review: Cloud Water Natural Sparkling CBD
`
`Posted: Mar 26. 2019 at 12:29 PM [Last Updated: Mar 26. 2019 at 2:01 PM}
`
`Covers Products: Blood Orange lit Coconut. Grapefruit Gr Mint Basil
`
`«r I
`
`Cloud Water is a line of sparkling water beverages enhanced with 25 mg of CBD. The product line currently consists of
`
`two flavors. Grapefruit 8r Mint 3: Basil and Blood Orange 8; Coconut. both of which are lightly sweetened with raw honey.
`
`As we do with any brand that’s jumping into the CBD beverage
`
`game. were always asking ourselves whether or not the product has
`
`merit beyond the ingredient itself. After all. there will eventually be a
`
`point when adding CBD isn’t an advantage or an excuse for poor
`
`flavot
`
`Fortunately. Cloud Water passes this test with flying colors. Both
`
`products are well crafted and enjoyable. with a flavor profile that sits
`
`somewhere between a sparkling water and soda. With 40 calories
`
`and 10 g of sugar per bottle. the mellow sweetness and flavor note of
`
`honey provide a very nice backdrop to each flavor.
`
`Both varieties start with raw honey and then feature a touch of lemon
`
`I.
`
`'I l
`
`ire
`~
` £1
`
`-
`r
`_- 7- .«
`
`
`RECENT ARTICLES
`
`FEATURES
`
`NEWSWIRE
`
`SPIRITS
`
`BEER
`
`Waiakea Water Releases New “Pahu Nunui" Ba...
`
`Daytrrp Expands CED Sparkling Water Lille to
`
`CRUNK!!! Energy Adds Sour Apple Flavor to Lin...
`
`Raw Generation Introduces Limited Edition Fall...
`
`Better Booch Launches Nationally on Amazon
`
`juice {percentage not disclosed]: and natural flavors. We particularly enjoyed the summery flavor of Grapefruit 8: Mint 8:
`
`Little West Launches :Clean Labei" CBDrlniused...
`
`Basil. which has some impressively accurate flavor. Blood Orange & Coconut is quite good as well, although it's more
`
`Harmless HPWE‘SI Launches New PEPPERS“
`
`clearly from flavoring as coconut is tough to nail.
`
`What we ultimately really like about these products is that they provide sweetness without adding zero calorie sweeteners
`
`view All
`
`1 Submit News
`
`or going beyond the modest level of calories and sugar. This creates a really clean and simple formulation that is a nice fit
`
`for a CBD drink since this is a category that is very much skewing towards natural products.
`
`UPCOMING EVENTS
`
`BevNET Live Winter 2019
`
`Santa Monica. CA . Dec. 9-1-10. 2019
`
`Early Registration Open
`
`Cannabis Forum Winter 2019
`
`Santa Monica. CA - December 6th.
`
`2019
`
`Register Now
`
`
`LEARN HDFIE III-J
`
`CANNABIS FORUM
`
`Dec. 6 r Santa Monica
`
`Exploring risk
`and upside in
`food & beverage
`
`Cln the outside. Cloud Water has taken a pretty unique twist on a classic 12 oz. glass soda bottle. The brand has painted
`
`the bottle glossy white to the point where it’s clearly opaque and you cannot see the liquid inside. The branding is clean
`
`and simple. using an image of a cloud with a single oversized raindrop as its logo. Finally. there's some text. which is
`
`simple. intuitive. and easy on the eyes. We’re fans of what Cloud Water has created.
`
`in conclusion. Cloud Water is a very worthy and well-executed product that's launching in a category where a lot of CBD
`
`action appears to be happening {sparkling}. While we’d love to see another SKU or two. what the brand is introducing first
`.
`.
`.
`,
`.
`.
`feels like worthy competition ror other brands In this nascent space.
`
`PRODUCT RATINGS
`
`I...
`"
`
`I:
`
`Blood Orange 3:
`Coconut
`
`Grapefruit 8. Mint
`Basil
`
`tote
`
`tote
`
`COMMENTS
`
`0 Comments
`
`
`
`fl FREE-SUCK Comments Plugin
`
`BEVNET
`
`Sort by oldest :
`
`CONTACT
`
`FOLLOW
`
`RESOURCES
`
`NAVIGATE
`
`-'_.-.
`2'-:-..2-
`
`.
`'.
`
`'t'...:.
`r-;-."-..r;: Full
`.
`.
`LN
`
`p—r
`
`J
`
`I'
`
`,
`
`-r.
`
`-.—
`
`,--..
`.'4"""-.-" "-'.\.'r
`-
`.-_.
`!--:-.-:-'«=::-r.:=__'-1'-'
`
`-Ir.
`
`"-c-
`I'd-d]
`-—
`.
`
`'13,
`k 3
`
`no.1
`
`."J'."..
`'
`
`i'::.'.:.'
`-
`'
`
`.
`
`'lx'
`
`...........
`
`-.-..
`
`.-
`
`...
`
`i'vi-
`
`I"
`
`'I.
`
` Captured by FireShot Pro [19-09-2019, 12:DQ:D6]
`
`

`

`TrendHunter Article
`
`TrendHunter Article
`
`

`

`Title: Honev-Sweetened CBD Beverages : cloud water
`Link: https:ffwww.trendhunter.comftrendsfcloud-water
`
`WERE,“ E TH1.- FUT'Ll'F-E
`
`TRENDHUM'ER
`
`|CONTENT
`
`TOOLS
`
`ADVISORY
`
`KEVNOTES
`
`EVENTS
`
`ABOUT
`
`LOGIN < Q
`
`ALL
`
`FASHION
`
`TECH
`
`LIFE
`
`CULTURE
`
`DESIGN
`
`ADS
`
`BUSINESS
`
`ECO
`
`GOOD
`
`LUJIIUR'tl
`
`BIZARRE
`
`KEYNDTES
`
`Honey-Sweetened CBD Beverages
`
`Set of
`
`Related
`
`Ideas
`
` Previous
`
`.‘U '
`
`4"”
`
`'
`
`Next
`
`Set of
`
`Related
`
`Ideas
`
`All-Natural Social Tonics
`
`Zero-Calorie CBD Beverages
`
`Energy-Regulating CBD Shots
`
`Calming CBD Beverages
`
`CBD-EnrlcgfijdlkRsestaurant
`
`”An intellectual
`
`can of Red Bull"
`
`-....--.| Jam; Gutsche
`
`Pro Services '
`
`fill
`
`.
`
`.
`
`I
`
`-
`
`.
`
`_
`
`“13hr:
`H
`
`:
`
`-
`
`.
`
`2 Similar
`PhOIIOS
`
`Sparkling ”Cloud Water' Comes in Flavors Like Blood Orange 8! Coconut
`
`Laura IVIcQuarrie — April 1, 22019 — Lifestyle
`
`References: cloudwaterbrands 8t bevnet
`
`000$
`
`lCloud Water is a line of sill-calorie sparkling CBD beverages with unique flavors and natural sweetness that comes from a
`touch of raw honey. With flavors like Blood Orange S Coconut and Grapefruit 8: Mint S Basil, Cloud Water boldlv sets itself
`apart with "intellectually engaging" flavors.
`
`Thanks to the addition of honey, these beverages need not rely on zeroncalorie sweeteners and only boast 10 grams of
`sugar per bottle. In terms of texture, the refreshing beverages are said to be a cross between sparkling water and soda.
`helping to satisfy consumers who are looking for betterwfor-vou beverages with enhanced benefits.
`
`Both Cloud Water beverages are packaged in conventional glass soda bottles with crimped metal caps—although theyF
`are finished in an opaque white coat that creates a sense of curiosity about the drinks.
`
`
`
`POLOUIlEiI'IlIBrf —IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`ACthity —IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`FFEShHESS —IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`dd 9 Q
`
`If W
`
`VIEW MORE STflTS
`
`OET fit CUSTOM REPORT
`
`
`
`SUBSCRIBE TO li'tIIiVISOR‘l‘r
`
`
`
`
`
` "-th ola- ‘1 ullll '. 43
`
`I & I”'IIII.|
`
`F2!“
`
`CBD-Infused Coconut ll'tlater
`
`CBD Lemonade Shots
`
`All-Natural CBD Sodas
`
`Hemp-Infused Canned Coffees
`
`Vita Coco is Launching a Sparkling,
`Enriched Coconut Water with CBD
`
`4Pure is Introducing '420Pure' in Small,
`Single—Serve Bottles
`
`Drink 420's Low—Calorie, Low—Sugar Soft
`Drink is Infused with Cannabidiol
`
`Abracadabra Coffee Co's 'Chill Brew'
`Features a Complementary CBD
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`20 Calming CBD Products
`
`20 Cannabis-Infused Alcohoi Innovations
`
`From Mood—Specific CBD Drops to Hemp~infused Suppiement Drops
`
`These Ideas Explore the Future of Cannabis and Alcohol
`
`
`
` IIIIIII
`
`IIIIIIIIII
`
`Related
`
`
`
`D R E A M
`
`CATQHER
`
`1
`
`Nourishing 030 Oil Supplements
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`The Daliv Hlt CBD Ull Is a Nourishing Salad
`Dressing Substitute
`
`Relaxing CED-Infused
`Refreshments
`
`The Mariev+CBD Mellow de Drinks Have
`a Premium Recipe
`
`Sparkling CBD Beverages
`I
`I
`I
`I
`I
`.
`I
`GTs lelng Foods Dream Catcher iS an All-
`New "Wellness Water"
`
`Sparkling CBD Water
`.
`I
`DRAM s Lemongrass CBD Sparkling 1Water
`Assists with Daily Stress Management
`
`
`
`
`
`Functional CBD Drinks
`
`CED-Infused Coffee
`
`BBB-Infused Lattes
`
`Hemp-Enriched Coconut Bites
`
`VYBES Makes Organic Beverages with
`Hemp Cannabidiol
`
`Flower Power Coffee Co. Offers Coffee
`Infused with CBD Dii
`
`Dliver Coffee is Offering Soothing Drinks at
`Its Unique NYC Location
`
`Weller's Bites with Hemp Extract Help to
`Reduce Stress & Inflammation
`
`
`
`a
`
`" C '
`
`'27—”:
`..ri-H-
`_. _._
`’
`-
`
`-
`it” "P
`
`i Future Product
`: Development:
`. Sober Up wlth CBD
`
`'w‘nlr-
`
`':~'_-t_n_:-r
`
`'JL'
`
`-.'Jl “rid-..- +.;. 1-;
`
`-;-1_r Iemr- I.-
`
`gunned-J non-mg 1.1 The Tull-h;-
`
`A Eng :r-orulv -:-I We owe-net,- r-J-ae-J :-r- Ind-verb
`1'. w-II re jov-_-'e-fll |
`;- eth-I-Fg rose-error and
`
`run-1.. pm; 1.3.31 mgr
`.-_1r|-: Han-r
`' -.
`1+».oi-3r-rrm-nt
`;.-r-urr:ruur_ int-nu -,|r.. -.‘In ”TED
`
`
`
`Fl} I- u---- -.-......d 1]..“ .— r-l an..." ..1, 1r- .1 ..h...
`".i"".'|I"'
`.le'I 1'II'4‘J'-'.'I.-11.'r"lll.--‘f-
`:fiul'F-ll'fi't rm 1-
`'upl
`jl'Fl'I‘lL I"|..-:I‘-—;|
`u 'I-II'II.
`il'fi1I-._lCl:|'
`.I": ale-nah“ -~',1"-|.
`'J
`ire-r -|
`IIflh'L-ZII' horn ||-'..--
`Putna-
`'v|""' :‘Iu'llq -._..
`I
`.1
`--_-J-r-'.
`
`.-
`
`-,....
`...
`H-.- t'd-r-Jufl.” 3-}...14 II- -.n-
`P-
`:'1.--r
`'|-."-|Iq---II- cit-'11
`is.
`'
`...- In-Imr
`-
`—'r
`1
`*1-
`Il""'-. alt-211”“ -_-u-I
`I-II u-u:-I- -'
`|-'
`-r -r Ira-.1 'Di- ray-rr- -:I-'-- I- hr“-
`1 .- will“
`
`1.1!
`I
`
`I'l-
`351'},
`.3" -- _.II
`.. .I.;
`.r.|
`w. turner-..
`: r- 'I.""
`I1
`'.'.p1rII-.IIII-l-:.-u~ 'rl; --
`rlu f’li'
`I .|-.|J
`||.II 'qh.1i..dq Ii. Pall-[..qlu'hu-
`'f
`..j-.'l.
`l1, l"|l' l:"ll"'l l. -' u-ihg— 1n: -.- h'Jr HI. - '.
`
`a.
`
`
`
`
`
`.c .
`
`l
`
`II
`
`ll i I I
`
`.
`
`I
`
`Boosted CBD Beverages
`
`Detoxifving CBD Shots
`
`Tropical CBD Elixirs
`
`Recess' Ali—Natural Canned Drinks Feature Adaptogens and
`Cannabidiol
`
`'Sober Up' Supports Liver Health and Mental Clarity
`
`Dirtv Lemon's Cannabis Blend includes CBD from the Cannabis
`Plant
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`Effervescent CBD Drinks
`
`CED-Infused Matcha Teas
`
`Sweet Reason Beverage Co. Creates FivenCalorie CED—infused Sparkling Water
`
`The Matcha Now CBD Tea Keeps ingredients Separate Until Consumption
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`CED-Infused MOT Oils
`
`CED-Infused Honeyr Blends
`
`CBD Wellness Shots
`
`‘Feais' Pairs CBD with MCT Oil to increase its Bioavailability to
`the Bod},r
`
`Beekeeper's Naturals' B. Chill Honev Alleviates Stress and
`Anxiety
`
`Navitas Crganics' 2.5—0unce Bottles Provide a Functional
`Hemp CBD Shot
`
`
`
` ill our
`
`Non-Alcoholic Social Tonics
`
`Sparkling Stress Relief Drinks
`
`CBD-lnfused Coffee Pods
`
`Kin Euphorics' High Rhode is Made with Adaptogens 3.
`Nootropics
`
`Bimble Has Double the Cannabidiol of Manyr CBD Drinks on the
`Market
`
`The Diamond CBD Chill Coffee Capsules Contain 25mg of CBD
`
`
`
`l.ll"l'E-'.li1'l_'l{-
`
`H -
`
`Colombia-Inspired Non-Alcoholic Spirits
`
`Low-Calorie CBD Beverages
`
`Nostalgic Hemp Sodas
`
`'Calefio' is Targeted at Heaith—Conscious Millennials
`
`Jovbird Wellness' Full—Spectrum CBD Beverages Maximize
`Absorption
`
`Cannabinoid Creations Makes Cartoon Cereal Crunch and
`Orange Cream Flavors
`
`
`
`
`HEALTH WATER
`
`immune
`
`Immune-Boosting lMater Beverages
`
`Hemp-Based Energy Drinks
`
`Pervida Makes Immune Health Water Powered by Pomegranate Seed Oil
`
`The Healthyr Hemp Energy.r Shots are a Natural Wav to Boost Vitality
`
`
`
`.
`
`-
`
`L
`
`- I
`g— C
`.- :4
`7:
`
`«In—luau-
`
`
`
`

`

`LEMON-flail?
`
`*lii‘ti‘i
`
`CED-Infused Maple Sweeteners
`.
`_
`Maple Sugar s CBC—Infused Product Is
`100% Organic
`
`
`
`Refreshing CED-Infused
`Lemonades
`
`The Honevdrop Cold-Pressed CBD
`Lemonades are Premium
`
`CED-infused Seasonings
`_
`_
`_
`Cured Nutrition Offers Enhanced Pumpkln
`Spice, Smoky BBQ 3* MD“?
`
`Cannabis-Infused Sparkling
`Water
`
`Lagunitas Brewing Company’s 'Hi-Fi Hops“
`is an 1PA—lnspired Brink
`
`.m—h
`
`
`I -arr-"—
`
`uh
`
`® G.» 3
`Will? ifU iii9. {via
`
`
`
`C C
`
`...
`
`CED-Infused Musician Coffees
`
`CED-Infused Pet Beverages
`
`CED-Infused Juice Shots
`
`Willie’s Remedv Coffee is Made in Small Batches with CBD Oil
`
`TruLife CBD Enhances the Wellness of Animals with Beneficial
`Ingredients
`
`Project Juice's New Tonic Wellness Shots Will Contain
`Cannabinoids
`
`
`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`_IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
`
`
`Functional CBD Shots
`
`BluePrint Organic's Cold—Pressed Juice Shots Support Cut Health 31 Sleep
`
`Making Health Simple
`
`An Interview With John and Leah Garrad—Coie of Sproos and
`Love Child Organics
`
`
`
`9.
`
`PM
`_
`
`I
`
`4
`
`-- —
`
`E__F
`
`.4
`
`fig-I
`
`‘h
`-.
`
`
`
`Hydrating Hemp Drinks
`
`Coffee-Centric CBD Oils
`
`PLNT's iced Tea and Fruit Water Beverages Contain an Active
`Hemp Extract
`
`Minor Figures“ CBD Oil Drops Replenish the BodyI After
`Consuming Coffee
`
`
`
`N.
`
`i!
`
`_I
`
`

`

`
`
`discos random—'5”
`
`‘
`
`Full-Spectrum CBD Supplements
`
`Organic CBD Chocolate Bars
`
`The Coromega Max CBD 10mg Comes in Convenient Squeeze Shots
`
`The Pure Hemp CBD Bars Boast Relaxing Effects and a Great Taste
`
`
`
`
`
`THC-Infused Beers
`
`Flving Dog and Green Leaf Medical are Collaborating on 'Hop Chronic”
`
`
`
`Lifestyle
`
` :9...
`
`lllv'ork Balance-Themed Sneaker
`Remakes
`
`RUDE-GA and New Balance Launch the NC
`BAD DAYS Revival
`
`Half-Mouth Toothbrushes
`.
`The Design of the Encompass Brush
`Cleans Half ofthe Mouth at Once
`
`Apple Cinnamon-Flavored
`Cheeses
`
`The New Apple Cinnamon Boursin Cheese
`Launched in Time for Fall
`
`Kid-Specific Nutrition Initiatives
`,
`_
`.
`Nestle Canada Supports Childrens Health
`W'lh Food Banks Canada
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`E M PA N A D A S
`
`crease...
`
`inn-mm
`
`”mar-'-
`
`IATAMIH‘S
`
`IATAIAIH'S
`
`IATAE Alli”!-
`
`Global Winter Games Mascots
`.
`Beulng 2022 Introduce the Olympic and
`Paralvmplc Mascots
`
`
`
`Tender Prepackaged Meat
`Snacks
`
`The New Jack Link's Peperami Tender
`Jerkv Comes in Two FEavors
`
`Chocolate-Filled Fried Turnovers
`_
`_
`_
`Polio Troplcal s New Nutetla Empanada Is
`Cozmg W'th Chocoiate
`
`Internationally Flavored Rice
`Mixes
`
`Zatarain Created Better—forv‘r’ou Bean 8:
`Brown Rice Mixes
`
`III AC! H‘PPT “"1-
`
`a.
`
`_/
`
`'l
`
`1)
`
`a l
`
`r'
`
`l
`
`Qfls-Referencing Soccer Kits
`
`Vintage Band Graphic Tees
`
`Free-From Cookie Dough Bars
`
`Nil“:- 1 Introilc the: Thirri k'it fnr fltlptir‘n Marlrirl Porallinn Rptrn
`
`Ennrlhnnrl Tamra-Error nnr‘l lmnno {7|th lTl‘l Wnrlr Tnnothrnr nn 9
`
`lhlhnn finilnh'c Fir—ire finntain Mn mute-n fininr Ffine nr Rm:
`
`

`

`III-n..- Milli-unu- urn...- Ilnlu-Iu-L
`
`I r11|uluuurrL-mullurtuuuilllluI-quu
`
`uuumlluuuy IMMJLr-I'IMIJMILM “unnum- :4:qu L—IIJ Ilvll'l IuHu-uru-I urn-u
`
`IIIIUM ”UL-It’ll” uuLuuu-II-Lunlluv "IJ-IUI'Ln-IIJ Hull}. Luau U: ”V:
`
`Design
`
`Exhibition
`
`
`
`.
`
`I‘M-n "T
`
`_-
`
`'.-1
`
`."'
`
`_- i
`
`-
`
`—----
`
`-_- .-
`
`- “ml-a
`
`1
`
`avg-Ill?"
`
`'7‘
`
`no“ '
`
`s“
`
`|
`
`I.
`
`-
`
`_
`.fi
`I.
`.1
`'x ..
`,
`..
`1
`_
`All r
`.- .-:_I
`1': Fir iii
`
`ill.
`.—-— 1111'
`
`1
`
`r
`
`-
`"
`
`I
`
`*
`ll 43'“ 15‘
`Hg; 1!
`L; “r“ tin- Jr“ -
`L
`.‘Ir
`.-
`'4“ fl.
`-
`‘Ir‘T-Lfi.
`--
`Ifllhi"
`I
`Llfliifi'q‘
`l'
`
`*
`
`'
`
`ll "
`
`— —
`
`Co-Working Wedding Services
`
`Mattress Brand CBD Gummies
`
`Cornerstone Studies is a Co—Working Space for Wedding Professionals
`
`Casper Launched Its Own CBD Gummies for Sleep
`
`: I g“;$' J.
`
`‘-
`
`
`
`Jicama Holiday Cocktail Recipes
`
`Highly Durable Running Shoes
`
`Fried Chicken-Themed Wedding Services
`
`With the Popularity of the Ingredient! Xicama Beasts a New
`Recipe
`
`ASICS Launches Two New CEL—KAYANC 5 360 Sneakers in
`Bright Colorways
`
`KFC Australia Recently Launched a KFC Wedding Service
`
`
`
`)
`
`Jig!
`
`(F
`
`Children's Daily Exercise Programs
`
`Organic Artisan-Style Condiments
`
`Cupcake-inspired Candies
`
`The Daily lvliie Promotes Kids Activity and Will Launch in the
`US
`
`The New Tessernae‘s Condiments Include Five Fiavor Options
`
`The Jelly Belly Candy Cupcakes Come in Five Flavors
`
`
`
` 3 xl.‘
`
`J
`:3
`
`I)
`
`.- A,
`“. x .r
`’ i
`
`=1
`i" "
`
`J
`
`'
`
`i
`
`I
`
`1 £1
`
`a;
`
`r: E -: O
`
`Donut-Paired Fried Chicken
`
`Brain-Boosting Cherry Shots
`
`Plant-Based Digestive Tonics
`
`The Kentucky Fried Chicken S Donuts is Being Text Marketed
`
`Cherry BoEmb Gives Sustainable Brain Energy Without Sugar
`or Caffeine
`
`Waku Plant—Based Tonics Have Anti—Inflammatory B Digestive
`Benefits
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`
`
`Camper Van Rental Services
`
`24 Sustainable Beer Innovations
`
`Honest Camper Provides Retro and Modern ‘v‘ans for Off-Grid Travel
`
`From Anti-Plastic Beer Packaging to Climate-Frier‘ldlyr Craft Ales
`
`
`
`Keynotes & Workshops
`
`Ignite innovation with
`
`Award-Winning Author, CEO & Innovation Expert
`
`'
`
`.
`DEIOIttE.
`Ehiragviribmio
`
`.
`
`~ 7.“
`
`*‘HH
`
`u
`
`lH'r
`
`H-W-T
`”fl“ 3“"
`llxlefi?‘ l: m ll"; m mum-v
`“5:9 ’55;- ENEStlE
`”mm OROGERS KFMG W
`
`..
`
`3.x"
`
`ru-
`
`1.
`
`
`
`e 4
`
`"mm"
`gag“?
`
`annaloo
`_...a....s_
`see [5:
`Hem-Te: if.“ m m Google
`
`.L
`
`‘F
`
`Captured bv FireShot Fro [1'I-JI-CI'EJI-2019F 12:09:53]
`
`

`

`Culinary Epicenter Article
`
`

`

`Title: The CED Industry: An Incredible Edible Struggle | CulEpi
`Link: https:l,lwww.c-ulinaryepicenter.comlthe-cbd-industry-an-incredible-edible-strugglel
`
`
`
`E©OO
`
`Talk to Me | Elog
`
`Publish Me | Submissions
`
`Employ Me
`
`About CulEpi
`
`Make Contact
`
`Sign In | Sign Up
`
`m chfitlE Dela Cruz
`The CED Industry: An Incredible Edible
`
`Struggle
`
`G April 3, 2319
`
`3‘ rn-nuzss read
`
`This week the FDA announced it will hold a public hearing on CED on May 3lst, simultaneously sending
`
`out warning letters to CED businesses about health claims. Many CED companies in the food and
`
`beverage space are currently struggling to keep up with unpredictable government regulations — local,
`
`state and federal — so the FDA hearing couldn’t come soon enough.
`
`.e-cTIvIs—cHE: :ov luau; cost-a "cen—
`
`
`
`-;_.g«;E,.3|:~lDLI=;.-ev-;ee.ggegm -
`Ul
`
`I
`
`m III Cl UJ
`
`I
`
`m
`
`St) ;_I 53:: _E
`
`,, [Sftalteholders are looking to the FDA for clarity on how our authorities apply to such
`products, what pa th ways are available to market such products lawfully under these
`authorities, and how the FDA is carrying out its responsibility to protect public health
`and safety with respect to such products. ~ Statement from FDA Commissioner Scott
`Gottlieb, MD.
`
`Although CED is legal as a prescription drug, the FDA restricts its use as a food additive or dietary
`
`supplement. Prior to the FDA announcement, the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene had
`
`already started banning all CED-infused edibles. Some local cafes and bakeries have already felt the
`
`blow of this ban by having their cookies confiscated and croissants kidnapped, including C.J. Holm of Fat
`
`Cat Kitchen in the East Village.
`
`Ti—' El" C wove IE'I SWASTI KAE :N -l E .3
`
`DEETAUFJANT. AND ”Er-HE FCIIJGHT EACH.
`
`
`
`lsl GUT H '
`the punches” when working in the CED industry.
`
`Cookies and catmabls colic tit-:13 tin-o I"'L'.o-;.-.r':esv of Caffeine -"_.-'.-Itier'or"o-:..-odl
`
`1»!
`'
`5.
`
`Those we’ve talked to about their experiences repeatedly compare each day in the cannabinoid market
`
`to a boxing match. Marc Siden, CEO of Cloud Water Brands, said in an interview with CulEpi founder
`
`Regina Varolli, “everyday is unpredictable and it punches you in the face. It either wakes you up or
`
`knocks you down." And Ian Ford, owner of Brooklyn’s Caffeine Underground, advises to, “just roll with
`
`U 3E. E LLl N =2]
`
`"I-"-.-'
`
`' N E TC) _'~lE ‘3 E {II UTE {LOU L C]
`
`E 3] D 'I-"-.-' lTl-l A {SC-5t K H "r’Cl'cl Ct
`
`'3 Till—ES LCIlv'E SDDll‘JHLES' AT T:_:S
`
`a ooo P» nil FEl-xili‘llST aw EET sno-
`
` _
`
`_ ,___
`
`3‘ :ET i—l-I: utilitl'in RAIL-Cl C u" CClCirii-“nil Ill
`
`
`._-'._,'
`-
`—..—-.-'——
`-...-.
`a
`I.._'_" .'—-'-'IT;~I:-'.'I_.'.- E-th'n l..._-!s'
`
`.-.--,-
`-—..-".-.—_
`——' ——._.——.-.-.'
`-'-'|-I'.J.':-':Is
`-.'I:'_L.-'E.'-' Eli-:IKf-llu 'e'JG'LC.'-
`
`.
`. —_'.— —-
`I"_-.-..—'..-...--..--.—-
`I_'-'I'-.':_:Is"-.-'.I :::IJ- h-T' 3-3-1:
`I_-_'.'I. =.5'-""'.:-1'
`
`'
`
`.
`
`Flawed (Cinch-"teas: or flood Heater Eran-d5}
`
`Although CED edible restrictions are still a grey area, recent reports say that the New York City
`
`Department of Health will soon be issuing violations to eateries selling CED-infused food or drink, and
`
`according to an email sent by the DOH, July 1st will be the commencement of embargoing cannabinoid
`
`edibles for good. After that, store owners will be required to return their shipments back to suppliers or
`
`just toss them.
`
`Subsequently, when October 1st comes around, cafes that aren’t following these regulations could be
`
`hounded by inspectors with violations, including fines and/or deducting points from the restaurant’s
`
`health letter grade. This came as a complete shock to business owners in the CED industry, and upon
`
`_,.,
`
`I:
`
`

`

`asking health inspectors the reasoning behind this, business owners were met with vague responses.
`
`“It’s still unclear in their language," explained a frustrated Ford. “It’s unclear whether or not we’ll be
`
`able to sell food that already has CBD in it. We just don’t know."
`
`This lack of consistency and clarity in regulations is also one of Siden's biggest concerns. “What my
`
`team is craving for is real information,“r he emphasized. “We're trying to understand what is really the
`
`concern and issue here."
`
`0@°O
`
`uwr
`
`
`
`Flo-rte." Power Coffee Co.
`
`,IJrc-vrdes L'Isffetoe l_f.".li3lE'-“'§i'-'_'.'tl.i'.'t'.l I-vlth lovely CBD mfused calJ.oL-'cc.'.-1os
`
`and moo-Has {Courtesy {Jr—Ca fire-ine- Lion's-lg roost-d}
`
`Siden also explained that he has an understanding and belief that there needs to be some regulation in
`
`this space, and that the frustration is coming from the amount of time it's taking these regulatory
`
`bodies to make up their minds. “We're just caught in a little process," Siden said. “The government
`
`Share YOUR
`
`CulEpiI
`
`‘v‘oice on
`
`Dons LAD sot—2s
`
`Smash Server Stereotypes &
`
`Show Some Respect
`
`One Solution to Fight CD2
`
`Emissions, Food Waste &
`
`Hunger
`
`Sustainable Alternatives to
`
`the Big, Bad Meat Biz: Some
`
`Facts You May Not Know
`
`PX+ Festival: Celebrating 8L
`
`Challenging Hospitality
`
`Dominique Crenn on
`
`Activism, Politics at Influence
`
`Food Photography Shouldn't
`
`*Fakeil‘ With Mother Nature
`
`doesn’t do things in a day. If they feel things are getting out of control, they'll put a yellow flag up and
`
`Baking the “Bread of
`
`tell everyone to slow down and stop so they can get comfortable before going again.”
`
`FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, M.D. addressed this issue with almost the same sentiment.
`
`“[Sjtakeholders are looking to the FDA for clarity on how our authorities apply to such products, what
`
`pathways are available to market such products lawfully under these authorities, and how the FDA is
`
`Inclusion" with Holy Water
`
`We Took Our Support for
`
`Sustainable Seafood to
`
`Capitol Hill
`
`carrying out its responsibility to protect public health and safety with respect to such products,“ he
`
`Bread 8-: Beer: Women
`
`wrote in this we

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket