throbber
GRACE HAN STANTON
`
`P.O. BOX 2608
`
`SEATTLE, WA 98111
`
`September 21, 2023
`
`Opposition No. 91287300
`Serial No. 97451321
`
`
`
`AstroNova, Inc.
`v.
`
`Panasonic Avionics Corporation
`
`
`NICOLE KINSLEY, ESQ.
`FOLEY HOAG LLP
`155 SEAPORT BOULEVARD
`SEAPORT WEST
`BOSTON, MA 02210-2600
`
`
`ESTTA1311632
`
`
`NOTICE OF INSTITUTION
`The opposer (plaintiff) identified above has filed a notice of opposition to the
`registration sought by applicant (defendant) in the above-identified application.
`This notice of institution is forwarded pursuant to Trademark Rules 2.105(b) and
`(c), and constitutes service of the notice of opposition on applicant. An electronic
`version
`of
`the notice
`of
`opposition
`is viewable
`on TTABVUE at
`https://ttabvue.uspto.gov/ttabvue/. See Trademark Rule 2.105(a). The parties should
`diligently monitor this proceeding via TTABVUE.
`
`APPLICANT MUST FILE ANSWER THROUGH ESTTA
`As required in the schedule below, applicant must file an answer within forty
`(40) days from the date of this order. Failure to file a timely answer may result
`
`

`

`in the entry of default judgment and abandonment of the application. Regarding
`when a deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday or federal holiday, see Trademark Rule
`2.196. Applicant must file the answer through ESTTA - Electronic System for
`Trademark Trials and Appeals, unless ESTTA is unavailable due to technical
`problems or extraordinary circumstances are present. An answer filed on paper
`under these limited circumstances must be accompanied by a Petition to the
`Director (and the required fee under Trademark Rule 2.6). See Trademark Rule
`2.106(b)(1). In substance, applicant’s answer must comply with Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(b);
`it must admit or deny the allegations in the notice of opposition, and may include
`available defenses and counterclaims. Regarding the form and content of an answer,
`see Trademark Rule 2.106(b)(2) and TBMP § 311.
`
`DUTY TO MAINTAIN ACCURATE CORRESPONDENCE INFORMATION
`Throughout this proceeding, the parties, and their attorneys or representatives,
`must notify the Board of any correction or update of physical address and email
`address, and should use the ESTTA change of address form. See Trademark Rule
`2.18(b); TBMP § 117.
`
`SERVICE OF ANSWER AND OF ALL SUBMISSIONS
`The service of the answer, and all other submissions in this proceeding, and of all
`matters that are required to be served but not required to be filed in the proceeding
`record, must be by email unless the parties stipulate otherwise. Trademark Rule
`2.119(b). In the absence of a stipulation, service may be by other means only under
`the limited circumstances and in a manner specified in Trademark Rule 2.119(b).
`Regarding the signing and service of all submissions, see TBMP §§ 113-113.04.
`
`The answer, and all other submissions, must include proof of service. As noted in
`TBMP § 113.03, proof of service may be in the following certificate of service form:
`
`
`I hereby certify that a true and complete copy of the foregoing
`(insert title of submission) has been served on (insert name of
`opposing counsel or party) by forwarding said copy on (insert
`date of mailing), via email (or insert other appropriate method
`of delivery) to: (set out name, and address or email address of
`opposing counsel or party).
`
`Signature__________________________
`Date_______________________________
`
`
`SUBMIT ALL FILINGS ONLINE VIA ESTTA
`Submissions must be filed via ESTTA, the Board’s online filing system, unless
`ESTTA is unavailable due to technical problems or extraordinary circumstances are
`present. Trademark Rule 2.126(a). Submissions may be filed in paper form only
`under the limited circumstances specified in Trademark Rule 2.126(b), with a
`
`2
`
`

`

`required written explanation. ESTTA is accessible at the Board’s web page:
`https://estta.uspto.gov/. The page has instructions and tips. ESTTA offers various
`forms, some of which may require attachments and/or a fee. For technical questions,
`a party may call 571-272-8500 (Mon. - Fri. 8:30 - 5:00 ET) or email
`ESTTA@uspto.gov. This proceeding involves several deadlines, and due to potential
`technical issues, parties should not wait until the deadline to submit filings. The
`Board may decline to consider an untimely submission. Moreover, Trademark
`Rule 2.126 sets forth the required form and format for all submissions (e.g., page
`limitations), and the Board may decline to consider any submission that does not
`comply with this rule, including, but not limited to motions, briefs, exhibits, and
`deposition transcripts.
`
`CONFERENCE, DISCOVERY, DISCLOSURE AND TRIAL SCHEDULE
`
`
`
`Time to Answer
`Deadline for Discovery Conference
`Discovery Opens
`Initial Disclosures Due
`Expert Disclosures Due
`Discovery Closes
`Plaintiff's Pretrial Disclosures Due
`Plaintiff's 30-day Trial Period Ends
`Defendant's Pretrial Disclosures Due
`Defendant's 30-day Trial Period Ends
`Plaintiff's Rebuttal Disclosures Due
`Plaintiff's 15-day Rebuttal Period Ends
`Plaintiff's Opening Brief Due
`Defendant's Brief Due
`Plaintiff's Reply Brief Due
`Request for Oral Hearing (optional)
`Due
`
`10/31/2023
`11/30/2023
`11/30/2023
`12/30/2023
`4/28/2024
`5/28/2024
`7/12/2024
`8/26/2024
`9/10/2024
`10/25/2024
`11/9/2024
`12/9/2024
`2/7/2025
`3/9/2025
`3/24/2025
`4/3/2025
`
`
`
`PARTIES ARE REQUIRED TO HOLD DISCOVERY CONFERENCE
`The parties are required to schedule and hold a discovery conference by the
`deadline in the schedule in this order, or as reset by the Board. In the conference,
`the parties are required to discuss, at a minimum, 1) the nature and basis of their
`claims and defenses, 2) the possibility of promptly settling, or at least narrowing the
`scope of claims or defenses, and 3) arrangements for disclosures, discovery,
`preserving discoverable information and introduction of evidence at trial. For
`guidance, see Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(f), Trademark Rule 2.120(a)(2)(i) and TBMP §§
`401.01 and 408.01(a).
`
`
`3
`
`

`

`The parties must hold the conference in person, by telephone or by a means on
`which they agree. A Board interlocutory attorney or administrative trademark
`judge will participate in the conference either upon request of any party made no
`later than ten (10) days prior to the conference deadline, or when the Board deems
`it useful to have Board involvement. See Trademark Rule 2.120(a)(2)(i). A request
`for Board participation must be made either through ESTTA, or by telephone call to
`the assigned interlocutory attorney named on the TTABVUE record for this
`proceeding. A party requesting Board participation should first determine possible
`dates and times when all parties are available. A conference with a Board attorney’s
`participation will be by telephone in accordance with the Board’s instructions.
`
`For efficiency, the parties may stipulate to various procedural and substantive
`disclosure, discovery and trial matters (e.g., modification of deadlines and
`obligations) upon written stipulation and approval by the Board. Trademark Rule
`2.120(a)(2)(iv) provides a non-exhaustive list of matters to which parties may
`stipulate. The best practice is to reduce all stipulations to writing. If email service is
`not practical, such as for voluminous document production in discovery, the parties
`should discuss in the conference how production will be made. The parties, and
`their attorneys or representatives, have a duty to cooperate in the discovery
`process. TBMP § 408.01.
`
`PROTECTIVE ORDER FOR CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
`The Board's Standard Protective Order is automatically imposed in all inter partes
`proceedings, and is available at: https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks-application-
`process/appealing-trademark-decisions/standard-documents-and-guidelines-0.
`During their conference, the parties should discuss whether they will use an
`alternative or modified protective order, subject to approval by the Board. See
`Trademark Rule 2.116(g) and TBMP § 412. The standard order does not
`automatically protect confidential information; its provisions for designating
`confidential information must be utilized as needed by the parties. Trademark Rule
`2.126(c) sets forth the procedure for filing confidential submissions.
`
`ACCELERATED CASE RESOLUTION (ACR)
`During their conference, the parties are to discuss whether they wish to seek
`mediation or arbitration, and whether they can stipulate to the Board's Accelerated
`Case Resolution (ACR) process for a more efficient and cost-effective means of
`obtaining the Board’s determination of the proceeding. For details, and examples of
`see TBMP

`ACR
`proceedings,
`528,
`and
`the Board's webpage:
`https://www.uspto.gov/ttab.
`
`4
`
`

`

`INITIAL DISCLOSURES AND DISCOVERY
`Regarding the deadline for and contents of initial disclosures, see Trademark Rules
`2.120(a)(1) and (2)(i), and TBMP § 401.02. Regarding deadlines for serving and
`responding to discovery, see Trademark Rule 2.120(a)(3) and TBMP § 403.03.
`Certain provisions of Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 are applicable in modified form. Note that
`written discovery (interrogatories, requests for production, requests for admission)
`must be served early enough so that responses will be due no later than the close
`of discovery. Regarding the scope and limits of discovery, see TBMP 414;
`discoverable items may include documents, tangible things, and electronically
`stored information (ESI).
`
`MOTIONS
`Certain provisions of Fed. R. Civ. P. 11 apply to all submissions in Board
`proceedings. See TBMP § 527.02. Regarding available motions, see TBMP Chapter
`500. Regarding applicable deadlines to respond to motions, depending on the motion
`filed, see Trademark Rules 2.127(a) and (e)(1). When a party timely files a
`potentially dispositive motion the proceeding is suspended with respect to all
`matters not germane to the motion. See Trademark Rule 2.127(d). In addressing
`motions or other filings, if it appears to the Board that a telephone conference would
`be beneficial, or upon request of one or both parties, the Board may schedule a
`conference. See Trademark Rule 2.120(j)(1) and TBMP § 502.06(a).
`
`PRETRIAL DISCLOSURES, TRIAL AND BRIEFING
`Regarding the procedures and deadlines for pretrial disclosures and trial, and
`specifically the noticing, taking, serving and submitting of evidence and testimony,
`see Trademark Rules 2.120(k), 2.121, 2.122, 2.123 and 2.125, as well as TBMP
`Chapter 700. The parties should review these authorities. For example: witness
`testimony may be submitted in the form of affidavit or declaration subject to the
`right to oral cross examination; transcripts of testimony depositions, with exhibits,
`must be served on each adverse party within thirty (30) days after completion of
`taking the testimony; certified transcripts and exhibits must be filed, with notice of
`such filing served on each adverse party; and all notices of reliance must be
`submitted during the submitting party's assigned testimony period and must
`indicate generally the relevance the evidence and associate it with one or more
`issues.
`
`Main briefs shall be filed in accordance with Trademark Rules 2.128(a) and (b). An
`oral hearing is not required, but will be scheduled upon separate notice timely filed
`pursuant to Trademark Rule 2.129(a). Regarding briefs and oral hearings, see
`TBMP §§ 801-802.
`
`TIPS FOR FILING EVIDENCE, TESTIMONY, OR LARGE DOCUMENTS
`The Board requires each submission to meet the following criteria before it will be
`considered: 1) pages must be legible and easily read on a computer screen; 2) page
`
`5
`
`

`

`orientation should be determined by its ease of viewing relevant text or evidence,
`for example, there should be no sideways or upside-down pages; 3) pages must
`appear in their proper order; 4) depositions and exhibits must be clearly labeled and
`numbered – use separator pages between exhibits and clearly label each exhibit
`using sequential letters or numbers - and 5) the entire submission should be text-
`searchable. Additionally, submissions must be compliant with Trademark Rules
`2.119 and 2.126. Submissions failing to meet all of the criteria above may require
`re-filing. Note: Parties are strongly encouraged to check the entire document before
`filing.1 The Board will not extend or reset proceeding schedule dates or other
`deadlines to allow time to re-file documents. For more tips and helpful filing
`information, please visit the please visit the ESTTA help webpage.
`
`LEGAL RESOURCES AVAILABLE AT WEB PAGE
`For a general description of Board proceedings, see TBMP §102.03. Proceedings are
`governed by the Trademark Rules of Practice in Parts 2 and 7 of Title 37 of the
`Code of Federal Regulations. These rules, the Manual of Procedure (TBMP),
`information on Accelerated Case Resolution (ACR) and Alternative Dispute
`Resolution (ADR), and many Frequently Asked Questions, are available on the
`Board’s web page, at:
`https://www.uspto.gov/ttab. The parties should check the web page for important
`changes, announcements, etc., many of which apply to proceedings already in
`progress.
`
`PARTIES NOT REPRESENTED BY COUNSEL
`This proceeding is similar to a civil action in a federal district court and can be
`complex. The Board strongly advises all parties to secure the services of an
`attorney who is familiar with trademark law and Board procedure. The Board
`cannot aid in the selection of an attorney. See TBMP § 114.02. The Board requires
`strict compliance with all applicable authorities whether or not the party is
`represented by counsel.
`
`PARTIES WITHOUT A U.S. DOMICILE MUST SECURE U.S. COUNSEL
`Effective August 3, 2019, the USPTO amended its rules to require applicants,
`registrants or parties to a proceeding whose domicile is not located within the U.S.
`or its territories to be represented by an attorney who is an active member in good
`standing of the bar of the highest court of a state in the U.S., including the District
`of Columbia or any Commonwealth or territory. Attorney information requires
`applicant’s appointed attorney to provide email and bar information as follows: Year
`of admission, State or territory of admission and, bar number if one is issued. 84 FR
`31498 (Requirement of U.S. Licensed Attorney for Foreign Trademark Applicants
`and Registrants, July 2, 2019). Until ESTTA forms are available which will mask
`the bar information, an attorney may file the required information through ESTTA
`
`1 To facilitate accuracy, ESTTA provides thumbnails to view each page before submitting.
`
`6
`
`

`

`and select “confidential.” A filing under “confidential” is not made available for
`public viewing.
`
`NOTIFY BOARD OF ALL PENDING ACTIONS
`If the parties are, or during the pendency of this proceeding become, parties in
`another Board proceeding or a civil action involving the same or related marks, or
`involving any issues of law or fact which are also in this proceeding, they shall
`notify the Board immediately. See Trademark Rule 2.106(b)(3)(i). The Board will
`consolidate and/or suspend related Board proceedings, as appropriate. See
`Trademark Rule 2.117(c); TBMP §§ 510 and 511.
`
`7
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket