New England Greens, LLC v. Optimal Vibrancy, LLC, 91266583, No. 29 (T.T.A.B. Oct. 18, 2022)

Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. https://estta.uspto.gov
`
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`
`ESTTA1242418
`
`Filing date:
`
`10/18/2022
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Proceeding no.
`
`91266583
`
`Party
`
`Correspondence
`address
`
`Submission
`
`Filer's name
`
`Filer's email
`
`Signature
`
`Date
`
`Attachments
`
`Defendant
`Optimal Vibrancy, LLC
`
`CHRISTIAN SANCHELIMA
`SANCHELIMA & ASSOCIATES PA
`235 SW LE JEUNE ROAD
`MIAMI, FL 33134-1762
`UNITED STATES
`Primary email: tm@sanchelima.com
`Secondary email(s): chris@sanchelima.com, jesus@sanchelima.com, leg-
`al@sanchelima.com, legalassist@sanchelima.com, paralegal@sanchelima.com
`305-447-1617
`
`Testimony For Defendant
`
`CHRISTIAN SANCHELIMA
`
`chris@sanchelima.com, estevez@sanchelima.com, assist4@sanchelima.com
`
`/CHRISTIAN SANCHELIMA/
`
`10/18/2022
`
`221018le.SignedDeclMoceguiFinal_Part1.pdf(5236880 bytes )
`221018le.SignedDeclMoceguiFinal_Part2.pdf(5048762 bytes )
`221018le.SignedDeclMoceguiFinal_Part3.pdf(1677775 bytes )
`
`

`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
`
`
`NEW ENGLAND GREENS, LLC
`Opposer,
`
`
`v.
`
`
`
`
`
` Opposition No. 91266583
`
`OPTIMAL VIBRANCY, LLC
`Applicant,
`________________________________________)
`
`
`DECLARATION OF ANTHONY MOCEGUI
`
`The undersigned declares, under penalty of perjury, that the following matters to which he
`
`has personal knowledge are true:
`
`1.
`
`I am the sole member of Optimal Vibrancy LLC (“OV”). I have full access to
`
`OV’s corporate records.
`
`
`
`2.
`
`I actively participate in, and I am primarily responsible for, the daily operation of
`
`OV including the marketing and sales of OPTIMAL VIBRANCY branded products.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`OV is limited liablity company founded and organized in Florida in 2020.
`
`OV serves as a holistic shop specialized in the sale of dietary and nutritional
`
`supplements bearing the OPTIMAL VIBRANCY mark.
`
`5.
`
`I selected the trademark OPTIMAL VIBRANCY by brainstorming different
`
`words combinations that were both appealing and suggestive of the types of products intended to
`
`be sold by OV. To avoid using another’s mark, I then conducted searches on the major online
`
`search engines (e.g. Google, Yahoo, Bing etc.) and no results appeared with the name OPTIMAL
`
`VIBRANCY.
`
`
`
`

`6.
`
`OV has used in commerce the mark OPTIMAL VIBRANCY for dietary and
`
`nutritional supplements (“OV’s Products”) since March 2020. See Exhibit 1, corresponding to a
`
`representative sample of OV’s invoices; see also Exhibit 2, corresponding to images depicting
`
`OV’s Products.
`
`7.
`
`All of OV’s Products are organic or wildcrafted and are without additives,
`
`preservatives, fillers, or other artificial ingredients.
`
`8.
`
`OV’s Products come in various forms: capsules, herbal tea blends, liquid elixirs,
`
`raw herbs, raw powders, and sea moss gels.
`
`Advertising and marketing for OV’s Products has solely been through:
`• OV’s website (www.optimalvibrancy.com)
`• Etsy shop (https://www.etsy.com/shop/OptimalVibrancy)
`• Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/optimalvibrancy)
`Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/optimalvibrancy/?hl=en)
`
`OV’s Products are sold only online—they are not sold through physical stores or
`
`•
`
`9.
`
`10.
`
`locations.
`
`11.
`
`OV’s Products are sold through OV’s website (www.optimalvibrancy.com) and
`
`Etsy shop (https://www.etsy.com/shop/OptimalVibrancy). See Exhibit 3, corresponding to
`
`screenshots from OV’s website (date of access: 11-05-2021); and Exhibit 4, corresponding to
`
`screenshots from OV’s Etsy shop (date of access: 11-05-2021).
`
`12.
`
`OV’s Products are not sold through third-party retailers, wholesalers, or any other
`
`third parties.
`
`13.
`
`14.
`
`OV’s Products have not been promoted or offered at trade shows or events.
`
`OV filed a trademark application for the mark OPTIMAL VIBRANCY on July 2,
`
`2020, with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, based upon our first use in commerce date of
`
`
`
`
`
` 2
`
`

`March 15, 2020, the date of OV’s first sale of dietary and nutritional supplements bearing the
`
`OPTIMAL VIBRANCY mark.
`
`15.
`
`OV’s mark application for OPTIMAL VIBRANCY did not receive any Office
`
`Actions—the examining attorney searched the USPTO’s database of registered and pending
`
`marks and found no conflicting marks that would bar registration under Trademark Act Section
`
`2(d).
`
`16.
`
` On October 28, 2020, the USPTO found that OPTIMAL VIBRANCY appeared
`
`to be entitled to registration, and the mark was published on November 17, 2020.
`
`17.
`
`I have reviewed the Notice of Opposition filed by Opposer, New England Greens,
`
`LLC (“Opposer”) in this matter.
`
`18.
`
`I understand that Opposer believes there is a likelihood of confusion between its
`
`various VIBRANCE and VIBRANT HEALTH marks and our mark OPTIMAL VIBRANCY. To
`
`the contrary, there is no likelihood of confusion between the marks especially because:
`
`a. the marks OPTIMAL VIBRANCY and Opposer’s marks are dissimilar
`
`because OPTIMAL—not present in Opposer’s marks—is the dominant and
`
`first component of OV’s mark which immediately draws in customers;
`
`b. there are a significant number of third parties using trademarks for nutritional
`
`or dietary supplements and related pharmaceutical goods and services that
`
`contain the words “VIBRANCY” or “VIBRANT” or VIBRANCE” as part of
`
`their mark; and
`
`c. Because of the ubiquity of the terms VIBRANT, VIBRANCE, and
`
`VIBRANCY in the field of dietary and nutritional supplements as well as in
`
`related pharmaceutical goods and services, customers have become so
`
`
`
`
`
` 3
`
`

`conditioned to marks with these terms that they have been educated to
`
`distinguishing between products bearing these terms in their brands.
`
`19.
`
`I am aware of the following third parties using marks that contain the words
`
`“VIBRANCY” or “VIBRANT” or VIBRANCE” and have reviewed and accessed the following
`
`webpages, for which screenshots are attached:
`
`a. Eu Natural’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANCE
`URL: https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins -
`Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp (Date accessed: 07-22-
`2021)(Bates Nos. 000104-113); URL: https://www.iherb.com/pr/eu-natural-
`vibrance-biotin-msm-60-vegetarian -capsules/105133 (Date accessed: 07-22-
`2021)(Bates Nos. 000114-118)
`
`b. Man Man Sports’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANCE
`URL: https://mansports.com/products/vibrance-60-caps (Date accessed: 07-
`22-2021)(Bates Nos. 000119-122)
`
`c. Muscle Marketing USA’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT
`WOMAN. URL: https://mmusa.com/product/vibrant (Date accessed: 07-22-
`2021)(Bates Nos. 000123-127)
`
`d. Natura Health Product’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT
`MIND. URL: https://www.professionalsupplementcenter.com/Vibrant-Mind-
`by-Natura-Health-Products.htm (Date accessed: 07-22-2021)(Bates Nos.
`000128-129); URL: naturahealthproducts.com/vibrant-mind.html (Date
`accessed: 07-22-2021)(Bates Nos. 000143-144)
`
`e. Vibrant Metabolism’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT
`METABOLISM. URL: https://vibrantmetabolism.com (Date accessed: 07-22-
`2021)(Bates Nos. 000130-133)
`
`f. Vibrant Nutraceutical’s vitamins and dietary supplements using the mark
`VIBRANT. URL: https://www.vibrantnutra.com/products (Date accessed: 07-
`22-2021)(Bates Nos. 000134-135)
`
`g. Markit Health LLC’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT &
`CLEAR. URL: https://www.amazon.com/Vibrant-Clear-Youthful-Vibrancy-
`Delicious/dp/B00FYUSBOI/ref=sr_1_1?dchild= OV-000136
`1&keywords=vibrant+and+clear+energy+wafer&qid=1627567091&sr=8-1
`(Date accessed: 07-22-2021)(Bates Nos. 000136-142)
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 4
`
`

`h. Vibrant Lotus Product’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT
`LOTUS. URL: https://www.ecwid.com/store/store1146375/Sleep-Formula-
`Retail-Grade-Best-Sleep-Ever-p11508534 (Date accessed: 07-29-2021)(Bates
`No. 000217)
`
`i. Honey & Sage Co.’s tonics and herbal teas using the mark VITAMIN-C
`URL: https://honeyandsageco.com/products/holy-wellness-tea-vibrant-c (Date
`accessed: 07-29-2021)(Bates Nos. 000218 – 223)
`
`j. Vibrant Wellness Trading Corp.’s dietary supplements, food supplements, and
`herbal beverages using the marks VIBRANT and VIBRANT WELLNESS.
`URL: https://lemiapp.com/allaboutvibrant/products/vibrant-vitamin-c-e3214
`(Date accessed: 07-29-2021)(Bates Nos. 000224 – 225)
`URL: https://vibrantwellnesscorp.com/beverages (Date accessed: 11-05-
`2021)(Bates Nos. 000217-220)
`
`k. Vitality Now LLC’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT LIFE
`GREENS. URL: https://vitalitynowshop.com/collections/products/
`products/vibrant-life-greens (Date accessed: 07-29-2021)(Bates Nos. 000226
`– 229).
`
`l. Vibrant Market LLC’s online retail services featuring vitamins and
`supplements using the mark VIBRANT MARKET. URL:
`https://thevibrantmarket.com/collections/supplements-pantry-goods (Date
`accessed: October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos. 000269-271).
`
`m. Professional Health Products’s dietary supplements using the mark VIBRANT
`YOUTH. URL: https://professional-health-products.com/product/vibrant-
`youth (Date accessed: October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos. 000256-257)
`
`n. Shop Vibrant Life’s online retail services featuring vitamins and supplements
`using the mark SHOP VIBRANT LIFE. URL: https://shopvibrantlife.com/
`(Date accessed: October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos. 000258-261)
`
`o. Vibrant Health’s healthcare and medical care services using the mark
`VIBRANT HEALTH. URL: https://vibranthealthkc.org (Date accessed:
`October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos. 000266-268)
`
`p. Vibrant Health & Wellness Center’s healthcare and medical care services
`using the mark VIBRANT HEALTH & WELLNESS CENTER. URL:
`https://vibrant-hlth.com (Date accessed: October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos.
`000264-265)
`
`q. Vibrant Health Care’s healthcare and medical care services using the mark
`VIBRANT HEALTH CARE. URL: https://www.vibranthealthcare.org
`(Date accessed: October 14, 2022)(Bates Nos. 000262-263)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 5
`
`

`QNEFAXEASTn1
`
`10/17/2022 4:46:21 PM PAGE
`
`6/006
`
`888-294-5658
`
`All the dbove-listed ssreenshots have been combined into composite Exhibit 5, attached,
`Bach websitehasbeen bates stamped with a sumber aad the URL has been added to the footer or
`
`
`
`header ofthefistpage per website. No other matter has been added to the sereenshots,
`
`For all the reasons discussed above, Opposer's marks and OPTIMAL
`20.
`VIBRANCYazp se differentthat « reasonable gonsumer would not associate them with each
`
`other.
`
`J declarg
`
`under penalty ofpeciury under the lawsof the United States ofAmerice that the
`
`foregoing is tru and serrect,
`
`
`
` OR fe iePf
`
`
`
`Optimal Vibraney LLC
`Authorized Member
`
`
`
`

`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing document is being filed electronically with the
`United States Patent and Trademark Office utilizing the Electronic System for the Trademark
`Trial and Appeal Board and has been sent via electronic mail to counsel of record for Opposer on
`this 18th day of October 2022.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`/s/ Christian Sanchelima
`Christian Sanchelima, Esq.
`Florida Bar No.: 107751
`Email: chris@sanchelima.com
`Liany Estevez, Esq.
`Florida Bar No.: 1024902
`Email: estevez@sanchelima.com
`Sanchelima & Associates, P.A.
`235 S.W. Le Jeune Road
`Miami, Florida 33134-1762
`Telephone: (305) 447-1617
`Fax: (305) 445-8484
`Attorneys for Applicant
`
`Ellen S. Simpson
`Simpson & Simpson PLLC
`5555 Main Street
`Williamsville, New York 14221
`United States
`Primary Email: TrademarkEFS@idealawyers.com
`Secondary Email(s): esimpson@idealawyers.com, asimpson@idealawyers.com
`
`

`Exhibit “1”
`Exhibit “1”
`
`

`OV-000091
`OV-000091
`
`Oi nlm lf
`
`March 14,
`2020
`
`$27.02
`ORB,
`
`$1.08
`CRB,
`
`From:
`
`Transaction date:
`
`Transaction amount:
`
`Transaction fee:
`
`1B} OV-000091
`
`Your
`transaction
`
`1U748303NP8173806
`
`OV-000091
`
`

`Keiara Rayford
`rayford_keiara@yahoo.com
`
`OV-000093
`OV-000093
`
`Brim
`Jul 5, 2020
`
`
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206334066712320
`
`USPS
`
`Net Collected
`
`Ship to
`Keiara Rayford
`11881 gulf pointe drive
`ee
`Houston, TX 77089
`
`
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Wildcrafted Sea Moss - 8 oz x2
`
`
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`OV-000093
`OV-000093
`
`

`QVM ian
`cynO11.cs.cs@gmail.com
`
`OVv-000096
`OV-000096
`
`Dia
`
`Aug 2, 2020
`
`
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206335278551253
`
`USPS
`
`Net Collected
`
`Ship to
`GV mS ian
`8459 S Kedzie Ave
`
`Ui ayieel ele
`Chicago, IL 60652
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Wildcrafted Sea Moss - 40zx1
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`OV-000096
`oNeee)
`
`

`Robert Prugger
`robertprugger17@yahoo.com
`
`OV-000100
`OV-000100
`
`Dea
`
`Oct 31, 2020
`
`
`
`Shipping Information
`
`94.05528206334146631602
`
`OSs
`
`Ship to
`Robert Prugger
`21 Rogers street
`Dover, NH 03820
`
`
`
`Net Collected
`
`Parasite, Candida, and Yeast Power Cleanse x $68.87
`1, Natures Force Strength Compound x 1
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`Bari
`OV-000100
`
`
`
`

`OV-000102
`OV-000102
`
`Kyron Williamson
`kyron1993@gmail.com
`
`Dra
`
`Dec 30, 2020
`
`Shipping Information
`
`94.05528206534195649979
`
`USPS
`
`$43.69
`
`Sn] om m
`Kyron Williamson
`3 Bonnie Park Dr
`Pine Bluff, AR 71601
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with Soursop - 16 oz x 1$37.08
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`Net Collected
`
`OV-000102
`OV-000102
`
`Ts Be,
`
`-$1.61
`
`

`Kirsten Berkness
`kirstenberkness@gmail.com
`
`OV-000079
`OV-000079
`
`
`
`Date
`
`Jan 4, 2021
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206554196803365
`
`USPS
`
`
`
`Net Collected
`
`lrish Sea Moss,Bladderwrack & Burdock Root $66.75
`Capsules x 1, Parasite, Candida, and Yeast
`Power Cleanse x 1
`
`
`
`Ship to
`Kirsten Berkness
`520 6th Ave SE
`Waseca, MN 56093
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`OV-000079
`OV-000079
`
`

`Dela
`Feb 8, 2021
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206334225060316
`
`USPS
`
`Ship to
`Azhia Cotton
`15314 Hugh Torance Pkwy
`Huntersville, NC 28078
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`
`
`OV-000081
`[>20]210Ooymme)
`azhiacotton@gmail.com
`
`
`OV-000081
`
`lrish Moss, Bladderwrack & Burdock Root
`Capsules x 1
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`Net Collected
`
`tsa
`
`-$1.55
`
`$41.63
`OV-000081
`
`

`Sabrina Santana
`Sabrina.santana.90@gmail.com
`
`
`
`OV-000082
`OV-000082
`
`Dea
`
`Feb P28 War ab Pas B
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206334254156521
`
`USPS
`
`Ship to
`Sabrina Santana
`
`270 Union Ave
`
`A-10
`Rutherford, N|J 07070
`
`Amount Received
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Net Collected
`
`Sea MossGel Infused With Elderberry - 16 oz $37.08
`x1
`
`
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`OV-000082
`
`

`Sylvanaah Dean
`sylvanaahdean@gmail.com
`
`OV-000085
`OV-000085
`
`Date
`
`Apr 8, 2021
`
`Shipping Information
`
`94.05528206535462446/96
`
`USPS
`
`OV-000085
`
`Ship to
`Sylvanaah Dean
`25040 Hyde Park Blvd
`Land O Lakes, FL 34639
`
`PNoatelelaiam .<stq-)hVicte
`
`
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`Men's Supreme Vitality x 1, Heart Vitality
`Pressure Stabilizer x 1
`
`$63.57
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`Net Collected
`
`ome mel
`
`eee
`
`vey
`OV-000085
`
`

`Hella Conversations
`jasminljprice@gmail.com
`
`OV-000086
`OV-000086
`
`
`
`Date
`
`Apr 18, 2021
`
`Shipping Information
`
`9405528206334280129621
`
`USPS
`
`Ship to
`eile aaa
`6140 E Shelby Dr
`Memphis, TN 38141
`
`$102.34
`
`Sea MossGel Infused with Bladderwrack &
`Burdock Root - 32 oz x 1, Heart Vitality
`Pressure Stabilizer x 1
`
`Amount Received
`
`oe hemes
`
`PURCHASE DETAILS
`
`
`
`Shipping Amount
`
`PayPal Fees
`
`Sake nc ys
`
`Cw
`
`OV-000086
`OV-000086
`
`Net Collected
`
`

`Exhibit “2”
`Exhibit “2”
`
`

`OV-000021
`OV-000021
`
`
`
`OV-000021
`OV-000021
`
`

`OV-000022
`OV-000022
`
`
`
`OV-000022
`OV-000022
`
`

`OV-000023
`OV-000023
`
`
`
`
`
`OV-000023
`OV-000023
`
`

`OV-000024
`OV-000024
`
`
`
`OV-000024
`OV-000024
`
`

`OV-000025
`OV-000025
`
`
`
`OV-000025
`OV-000025
`
`

`OV-000026
`OV-000026
`
`Fr
`
`a
`
`ee
`
`ee _
`
`Nee
`wt Tae hae Veena
`WADPOUENTS: Ebdertarnp
`eae
`ererncn, ene
`eve, Ghupe, Ram Hite
`“+ '
`' onracy™™ ELDERBERRY stunurom
`=
`ELIXIR
`
`‘en
`
`OV-000026
`OV-000026
`
`

`OV-000027
`OV-000027
`
`NEapedLahtemery orme eR NineHoeee
`
`ommmae Lalas ret awe
`
`OV-000027
`OV-000027
`
`

`OV-000028
`OV-000028
`
`—
`
`
`
`Pete nee
`—-
`
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`arn Wanagemst!
`
`_ HEART VITALITY
`WESSURE STABILIZER
`
`OV-000028
`OV-000028
`
`

`OV-000029
`OV-000029
`
` 3 pital Vilrrancy
`MMUNE SHIELD WALL ©Sime"
`
`
`Or ee
`ee eas
`wenn
`
`a WE Menrih Monagertet!
`
`-
`
`.
`
`mented
`
`OV-000029
`OV-000029
`
`

`OV-000030
`OV-000030
`
`
`
`OV-000030
`OV-000030
`
`

`OV-000031
`OV-000031
`
`
`
`OV-000031
`OV-000031
`
`

`OV-000032
`OV-000032
`
`|
`
`
`whee
`
`e e:= ‘ eee eee Sn eninee
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`=
`Cire Health Dee gamer!
`SSS“liver
`
`Jseesee
`
`DOWERCLEANSE=
`
`.
`
`OV-000032
`OV-000032
`
`

`OV-000033
`OV-000033
`
`;
`
` Ontimal ¥ibrancy
`
`MINE HearManageme’
`
`— Ugg SS —nee
`© BD es herons
`\e
`- WNG & RESPIRATORY ©Seren
`FENSE —
`
`=~
`
`DEFEN
`
`}
`
`——
`
`—
`
`OV-000033
`OV-000033
`
`

`OV-000034
`OV-000034
`
`(eee mute Health Wanagerer
`a I VITALITY
`t
`
`Optima! Vibrancy
`sine
`:
`SISAMEN'S SUPREME = Gee
`
`OV-000034
`OV-000034
`
`

`OV-000035
`OV-000035
`
`
`
`OV-000035
`OV-000035
`
`

`OV-000036
`OV-000036
`
`
`
`OV-000036
`OV-000036
`
`

`OV-000037
`OV-000037
`
`NATURES FORCE =F
`
`Sa —
`5
`TRENGTH COMPOUN)
`ne
`
`4
`
`OV-000037
`OV-000037
`
`

`OV-000038
`OV-000038
`
`
`
`OV-000038
`OV-000038
`
`

`OV-000039
`OV-000039
`
`
`
`OV-000039
`OV-000039
`
`

`OV-000040
`OV-000040
`
`
`
`OV-000040
`OV-000040
`
`

`OV-000041
`OV-000041
`
`woes =
`»* e
`|
`Co
`°
`'*
`
` “5
`ee ee
` Dynal Vibrwncy
`© peemerteett Reommemete
`oTTT
`soei
`”
`~
` aeaeianee
`S==SS= sca MOSS eteaetee
`SESS
`
`)
`
` Sabrereace 8 meMbOce FOr
`
`<=
`
`OV-000041
`OV-000041
`
`

`OV-000042
`
`OV-000042
`
`

`OV-000043
`
`OV-000043
`
`

`OV-000044
`
`OV-000044
`
`

`OV-000045
`
`ELDERBERRY
`
`SEA MOSS GEL
`
`OV-000045
`
`

`OV-000046
`
`OV-000046
`
`

`OV-000047
`
`OV-000047
`
`

`OV-000048
`
`OV-000048
`
`

`OV-000049
`
`OV-000049
`
`

`OV-000050
`
`OV-000050
`
`

`OV-000051
`
`OV-000051
`
`

`OV-000052
`
`OV-000052
`
`

`OV-000053
`
`OV-000053
`
`

`OV-000054
`
`S0URSOf
`
`SEA MOSS GEL
`
`OV-000054
`
`

`OV-000055
`
`OV-000055
`
`

`OV-000056
`
`WILD BLUEBERRY
`
`SEA MOSS GEL
`
`OV-000056
`
`

`OV-000057
`OV-000057
`
`
`
`OV-000057
`OV-000057
`
`

`OV-000058
`OV-000058
`
`
`
`OV-000058
`OV-000058
`
`

`OV-000059
`OV-000059
`
`eee Wvtee jee!
`
`'* eee wan eer ene
`
`Yptitsal Vibrance
`he Heol anamarre
`= SOURSOP LEAR © S=—=—=—
`
`GRAVIOLA LEAF
`
`3
`
`OV-000059
`OV-000059
`
`

`OV-000060
`OV-000060
`
`OV-000060
`OV-000060
`
`

`Exhibit “3”
`Exhibit “3”
`
`

`FriNovS 6:125
`
`OV-000241
`
`&
`
`@e
`
`fH
`
`<
`
`©
`
`i optimalvibrancy.com
`
`:
`
`© Oo
`
`+ ©
`
`¥ Optimal Vibrancy — Holistic Health Management
`
`
`
`6
`REGISTER
`
`info@optimalvibrancy.com
`CONTACT US
`ABOUT US
`ca SHOP
`LOG IN
`Pag eRSe
`
`| arate
`
`
`
`LIX!
`peOERBEER
`
`aaa?
`
`Elderberry Elixir
`$17.99 - $31.00
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`
`WERane
`“OWERCLEANS
`UNESHIELDWat
`
`PARASITE
`
`-
`
`Liver Power Cleanse
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`Parasite, Candida, and Yeast
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`mmune Shield Wa
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`Sign Up To Receive 10% Off & Exclusive E-Mails!
`
`
`
`OV-000241
`
`
`
`

`
`
`OV-000242
`
`e optimalvibrancy.com
`
`2g Products
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`
`info@optimalvibrancy.com
`
`oo
`
`HOME Ea ABOUTUS
`
`CONTACTUS
`
`LOGIN
`
`REGISTER
`
`
`
`kaline Detox
`
`$12.00 - $22.00
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`
`
`
`
`$21.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`
`
`Breathe Easy Coug
`$12.99 - $22.99
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`
`
`
`
`$12.99 - $22.99
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`
`
`ne Feminine R
`
`Div
`
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`
`
`
`
`ality Pres
`
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`
`
`¥
`ELDERBEROY
`euxIR
`
`Elderberry Elixir
`$17.99 - $31.00
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`
`
`immune§
`
`
`
`$29.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`
`
`CATEGORIES
`
`=
`
`H
`
`Raw
`
`Vv
`
`Te
`
`
`He
`
`jer
`
`PRICE
`
`e
`
`SIZES
`
`-
`
`a
`
`-
`
`FEATURED
`
`<>?
`
`ay
`:
`=
`
`$29.99
`
`$29.99
`
`
`
`B28
`
`mE
`$12.99-$22.99
`SEA MOSS
`SEA MOSS
`
`
`
`nmmune Suppor
`$12.99 - $22.99
`
`SELECT OPTIONS
`
`HM
`
`{
`oss, Biadde
`
`$34.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`rish Moss,8ladder
`$32.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`ADD 10 CART
`
`LOAD MORE..
`
`Sign Up To Receive 10% Off & Exclusive E-Mails!
`
`
`
`OV-000242
`
`

`OV-000243
`
`
`
`# optimalvibrancy.com
`
`Natures Forse Strenath Compound — Optimal Vibrancy
`
`OO +
`
`OY
`
`
`
`Info@optimalvibrancy.com
`
`eo
`
`HOME
`
`SHOP
`
`ABOUT US
`
`CONTACT US
`
`LOGIN
`
`REGISTER
`
`
`
`Nag
`eae
`
`;
`
`Natures Force Strength
`Compound
`$34.99
`
`RAW POWDERS
`
`=
`
`3
`
`+4
`
`fa Re
`
`>
`
`FEATURED PRODUCT
`
`>
`
`—
`as
`
`:
`
`7
`
`«(9.09
`N
`
`*
`
`$29.99
`
`{irish Me
`
`NATURES FORCE
`STRENGTH COMPOUND
`f# vinGc&
`312.99»$22.99
`
`
`
`
`
`
`==3 :
`
`DESCRIPTION
`
`RELATED PRODUCTS
`
`:
`3EAMOSS
`
`sh Moss.
`
`f
`
`$34.99
`
`ADD TO CART
`
`
`OV-000243
`
`

`Exhibit “4”
`Exhibit “4”
`
`

`FriNov 5 5:13 PM
`
`OV-000234
`
`ese f)
`
`<
`
`G
`O
`
`& etsy.com
`
`gy
`
`@mh+B
`
`Signin
`QO
`Etsy Search for anything
`
`Holiday Sales
`
`Jewelry & Accessories
`
`Clothing & Shoes
`
`Home & Living
`
`Wedding & Party
`
`Toys & Entertainment
`
`Art & Collectibles
`
`Craft Supplies
`
`Vintage
`
`EB] Holistic Health Management by OptimalVibrancy on Etsy
`
`1} Favorite Shop (182)
`
` Florida, United States
`
`OptimalVibrancy
`Holistic Health Management
`
`1580 Sales Yeo kk &
`
`Items
`
`2 Buyersare raving! This shop got multiple 5-star
`reviews in the past 7 days.
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`
`© Contact
`
`Sort: Most Recent +
`
`OQ
`
`
`
`
`:=
`
`SEA MOSS
`GEL
`
`=
`
`ee
`
`100% Wildcrafted Sea Moss Gel
`81.40
`
`100% Wildcrafted Sea Moss
`65.11
`4 people havethis in their cart
`
`Breathe Easy Cough Away (Herbal...
`42.31
`
`Parasite, Candida, and Yeast Pow...
`91.17
`20 people have this in their cart
`
`OV-000234
`
`45
`
`2
`
`1
`
`1
`
`1
`
`1
`
`1
`
`Search items
`
`All
`
`Elderberry
`
`Sea mossgel
`
`Detox Cleanse
`
`Sea Moss Gel Elderberry
`
`Sea moss Bladderwrack
`
`Burdock Root
`
`Contact shop owner
`
`1580 Sales
`
`182 Admirers
`
`io
`this shopto Etsy
`
`Report
`
`t
`
`;
`;
`Organic Echinacea Purpurea Her...
`19.51
`
`’
`.
`Organic Rosehip C/S
`19.51
`
`LIVER
`POWER CLEANSE
`
`:
`Alkaline Detox Cellular Cleanse (H...
`42.31
`13 people havethis in their cart
`
`.
`:
`Liver Power Cleanse & Protection ...
`91.17
`4 people havethis tn their cart
`
`—_—.
`
`—_——.
`
`Comegee
`coon
`MENTAL POWED
`
`==
`
`100% Wildcrafted Jamaican Sarsa...
`35.83
`Over 20 people havethis in their
`cart
`
`Organic Burdock Root C/S
`22.80
`17 people havethis in their cart
`
`Mental Power 8 Powerful HerbsF...
`91.17
`3 people havethis in their cart
`
`>
`ee
`
`Risto
`et}
`Optimal Vibe
`MEN'S SUPREME -
`
`VITALITY
`Ea
`
`Men’s SupremeVitality 100 Vegan...
`97.69
`
`Ee,
`
`5
`=
`PARASITE
`POWERCLEANSE
`
`

`FriNov5 5:14PM
` “ae gy
`
`
`STRENGTHCOMPOUND —
`SEAMOSS
`
`OV-000235
`
`0 8
`
`@ etsy.com
`
`(
`
`Holistic Health Management by OptimalVibrancy on Etsy
`
`SEA MOSS GEL
`10 BLUEBES®
`
`=
`
`2 NATURES FORCE
`
`SEA MOSSGFL
`tLoEnacney
`
`&
`
`ree
`
`Sea MossGel Infused with Wild BI... Sea Moss Gel Infused With Elderb...|Organic Irish Sea Moss, Bladderw...Natures Force Strength Compound
`
`
`97.69
`113.97
`97.69
`97.69
`
`.
`
`:
`
`3
`
`=
`
`2
`
`rs
`ELDERBERRY
`ELIXIR
`
`=—
`
`fee,
`
`=.
`SEA MOSS GE
`
`——>
`
`ahs.
`
`A
`SEA MOSSGFL
`:
`
`
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with Soursop
`97.69
`
`ay
`SEA MOSS GEL
`
`
`SEA MOSSGEL
`
`All Organic Elderberry Elixir-
`52.08
`
`Imm...
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with Maca
`97.69
`
`All Organic Elderberry Syrup Kit- L...
`M65.11
`
`
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with Mullei...
`97.69
`
`Organic Moringa Leaf C/S
`19.54
`3 people havethis in their cart
`
`Wildcrafted Irish Moss(Chondrus...
`65.11
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with Ceylon...
`97.69
`
`Reviews
`
`Average item review yexkok kw & (195)
`
`Sort by: Recommended ¥
`
`See reviews that mention:
`
`aneene =
`
`Weronika on Oct 18, 2021
`
`kkkkek
`Helpful seller @ G
`
` od quality product
`
`
`
`100% Wildcrafted Jamaican Sarsaparilla Root (Smilax Ornata) C/S
`
`Marilyn on Oct 11, 2021
`
`
`
`OV-000235
`
`

`FriNov5 5:14PM
`
`OV-000236
`
`*
`
`©
`
`:
`
`s etsy.com
`
`>
`
`© m+
`
`& Holistic Health Management by OptimalVibrancy on Etsy
`
`Reviews
`
`Average item review yew (195)
`
`Sort by: Recommended w
`
`See reviews that mention:
`
`Quality
`
`30
`
`Shipping
`
`48
`
`Customer service
`
`20
`
`Weronika on Oct 18, 2021
`
`Fok
`Helpful seller @ Good quality product
`
`
`
`100% Wildcrafted Jamaican Sarsaparilla Root (Smilax Ornata) C/S
`
`Marilyn on Oct 11, 2021
`
`Kkkkek
`use thesetotreat natural
`will
`
`sures for everyday problems
`
`EA Organic Burdock Root C/S
`
`Marilyn on Oct 11, 2021
`
`kkk kk
`'
`
`vitamin
`
`
`
`
`100% Wildcrafted Jamaican Sarsaparilla Root (Smilax Ornata) C/S
`
`Teana on Sep 30, 2021
`
`kkk kk
`Excellent quality,product was just as it was described.and my expectations were definitely met. 100%Satisfaction Guaranteed
`
`Organic Echinacea Purpurea Herb C/S
`
`Asia on Jul 9, 2021
`
`
`
`OV-000236
`
`

` ©
`
`OV-000237
`
`«
`
`etsy.com
`
`Holistic Health Management by OptimalVibrancy on Etsy
`
`Alkaline Detox Cellular Cleanse (Herbal Tea Blend)
`
`
`
`Angela on Sep 12, 2021
`
`kkk kk
`Great product andfast shipping! Thank you
`
`100% Wildcrafted Jamaican Sarsaparilla Root (Smilax Ornata) C/S
`
`About OptimalVibrancy
`
`Holistic Health Management
`
`OnEtsy since
`
`We
`
`
`elieve that mother nature is the true key to overall wellness and longevity. Our
`
`number onepriorityis to always provide our customers with clean, fresh and organic
`
`products. All of our products are handmadeandmz
`freshly when ordered. We make
`our productswith love, and as if we were making it for our own families. We donot
`believe in taking shortcuts for profit and believe in working with small farmers to deliver
`products rich in antioxidants as it was intended. We will never use any GMO'S
`preservatives,
`fillers or binders. All of our products are truly 100%natural
`
`Instagram
`
`Ej Facebook
`
`Shop members
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`Owner
`
`Shoppolicies
`
`Last updated on Jan 26, 2020
`
`Processing time
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`OV-000237
`
`

`
`
`OV-000238
`
`eee f <
`
`Oo
`
`®@
`
`@ etsy.com
`
`é
`
`®©®
`
`fh + ©
`
`
`
`B Holistic Health Management by OptimalVibrancy on Etsy
`cannat auarantee them,
`Actual
` sates, but
`
`delivery
`
`time will
`
`Customsand import taxes
`
`Buyers are responsible for any customs andimport taxes that mayapply,
`responsible for delays due to customs.
`
`I'm not
`
`Payment options
`
`@ Secure options
`
`Pewee
`Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card
`information
`
`Returns & exchanges
`
`| gladly accept cancellations
`Request a cancellation: before item has shipped
`
`| don't accept returns or exchanges
`
`But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
`
`Yes! Send me exclusive offers, unique gift ideas, and personalized tips for shopping andselling on Etsy.
`
`Enter your email
`
`Subscribe
`
`
`
`Shop
`
`Gift cards
`
`Sitemap
`
`Etsy blog
`
`T=I
`
`Sell on Etsy
`
`BsTur)
`
`Forums
`Pvc
`
`About
`
`Etsy, Inc.
`
`Policies
`
`acece16
`OrTat16)
`
`ago
`
`Impact
`
`lerMlasislelatt
`
`Privacy
`
`@ 'srael
`
`| English(US)
`
`| W (ILS)
`
`5
`
`act)
`
`ateeMOr-Tal Cie
`
`Trust and safety
`
`Privacy settings
`
`Downloadthe Etsy Ap
`
`1G} Ei @ . Le]
`
`OV-000238
`
`

`
`OV-000239
`
`eee < >
`
`oO
`
`@ etsy.com
`
`ou
`
`41
`
`Holistic Health Management by OptimaiVibrancy on Etsy
`
`CameASAP, prepared the whole thing.....now |
`need more,...tol
`
`
`
`100% Wildcraftedtrish Sea Moss
`
`kemmitrig on Apr 10,2020
`
`eat and the smell oma fresh not toc fishy!
`
`
`
`100% Wiidcrafted Irish Sea Moss
`
`About OptimalVibrancy
`
`Sales
`
`On Etsy since
`
`1,580
`
`2020
`
`Holistic Health Management
`
`We believe that mother nature is the true Key to overall wellness and longevity. Our
`number onepriorityis to always provide our customers with clean, fresh and organic
`products. All of our products are handmade and made freshly when ordered. We
`make our products with love, and as if we were making it for our own families. We do
`not believe in taking shortcuts for profit and believe in working with small farmers to
`deliver products rich in antioxidants as it Was intended. Wewill never use any GMO'S,
`preservatives, fillers or binders. All of our productsare truly 100% natural
`
`(©) Instagram
`
`Ei Facebook
`
`Shop members
`
`Optimal Vibrancy
`Owner
`
`Shoppolicies
`
`Last updated on Jan 26, 2020
`
`
`OV-000239
`
`

`OV-000240
`FriNov5 6:16PM
`
`*
`
`eee fH)
`
`<
`
`>
`
`Oo
`
`& etsy.com
`
`Co
`
`EB) Holistic Health Management by Optimalvibrancy on Etsy
`— 4 CC
`Sea Moss GelInfused with Mullein L.... Organic Moringa Leaf C/S
`Wildcrafted Irish Moss (Chondrus C...
`97.69
`19.54
`65.11
`3 people have this in their cart
`
`Sea Moss Gel Infused with CeylonC...
`97.69
`
`i)
`
`+
`
`Peal
`
`Reviews
`
`Average item review tek k*& (195)
`
`Sort by: Newest ¥
`
`See reviews that mention:
`
`
`
`Pamella on Apr 20, 2020 a MOss gel andit goes g
`
`J with anything.
`recommendthis store!
`
`| feel
`
`en
`
`
`eat in my smoothie. Tasteless so
`Tefits from sea moss.
`| highly
`
`100% Wildcrafted Irish Sea Moss
`
`kemmitria on Apr 19, 2020
`
`kkk kk
`
`100% Wilderafted Irish Sea Moss
`
`Denise on Apr 16, 2020
`
`kkkkk
`| absolutely Jove it
`Thank you a
`
`| will be ordering again
`
`aa
`
`é
`
`100% Wildcrafted Irish Sea Moss
`
`OV-000240
`
`
`

`Exhibit “5”
`Exhibit “5”
`
`

`OV-000104
`
`URL: https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-
`Vitamins -Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`Date: 07-22-2021
`
`0V-000104
`
`

`OV-000105
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000105
`
`

`OV-000106
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000106
`
`

`OV-000107
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000107
`
`

`OV-000108
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000108
`
`

`OV-000109
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000109
`
`

`OV-000110
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000110
`
`

`OV-000111
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000111
`
`

`OV-000112
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000112
`
`

`OV-000113
`
`https://www.amazon.com/Vibrance-Hair-Growth-Vitamins
`-Vegetarian/dp/B07S41MK5G?ref_=ast_sto_dp
`
`0V-000113
`
`