throbber
Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`
`ESTTA737054
`
`Filing date:
`
`03/31/2016
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Proceeding
`
`91218161
`
`Party
`
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Submission
`
`Filer's Name
`
`Filer's e-mail
`
`Signature
`
`Date
`
`Attachments
`
`Plaintiff
`Altadis U.S.A. Inc.
`
`CHARLES W GRIMES
`GRIMES LLC
`101 MERRITT 7, SUITE 300
`NORWALK, CT 06851
`UNITED STATES
`dize@gandb.com, uspto@gandb.com
`
`Testimony For Plaintiff
`
`Russell D. Dize
`
`dize@gandb.com
`
`/Russell D. Dize/
`
`03/31/2016
`
`Notice of Filing Continuation of Exhibit 30 to Testimonial Deposition.pdf(195183
`bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 6.1).PDF(4901360 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 6.2).pdf(5370710 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 6.3).pdf(5073686 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 6.4).pdf(5367754 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 6.5).pdf(2880585 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 7).pdf(4388660 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 8).pdf(1776171 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 9).pdf(1892175 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 10).pdf(3756181 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 11).pdf(3093340 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 12).pdf(2204115 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 13).pdf(1685582 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 14).pdf(976987 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 15).pdf(745093 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 16).pdf(3388613 bytes )
`Exhibit 30 - Rosenfeld (Part 17).pdf(1376718 bytes )
`
`

`

`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
`
`
`In the Matter of Application Serial No. 76/714,828
`Published in the Official Gazette on May 13, 2014
`--------------------------------------------------------------X
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`Altadis U.S.A. Inc.
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`Opposer,
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`v.
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`Garo Bouldoukian
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:
`
`
`
`Applicant.
`
`
`:
`---------------------------------------------------------------X
`
`
`
`Opposition No.: 91218161
`
`
`
`OPPOSER’S NOTICE OF FILING CONTINUATION OF EXHIBIT 30 TO THE
`TESTIMONIAL DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF JANELLE ROSENFELD
`
`
`Opposer, pursuant to 37 CFR § 2.123 and § 703.01(k) of the Trademark Trial and Appeal
`
`
`
`Board Manual of Procedure (“TBMP”), hereby gives notice of its filing of the continuation of
`
`Exhibit 30 to the Testimonial Deposition of Janelle Rosenfeld, taken on October 2, 2015.1
`
`A copy of the above-referenced exhibit was served on Applicant via overnight courier on
`
`November 2, 2015.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`1 Exhibit 30 to the Testimonial Deposition Transcript of Janelle Rosenfeld contains a total of 424 pages.
`Due to file size, pages 1 through 125 of Exhibit 30 were filed via a separate Notice of Filing. Pages 126
`through 424 of Exhibit 30 are being filed herewith.
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Dated: March 31, 2016
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/Russell D. Dize/
`Charles W. Grimes
`Russell D. Dize
`GRIMES LLC
`101 Merritt 7, Suite 300
`Norwalk, CT 06851
`Telephone No.: (203) 849-8300
`
`
`
`
`
`Attorneys for Opposer
`
`2
`
`

`

`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND MAILING
`
`This certifies that a copy of the foregoing Opposer’s Notice of Filing Continuation of
`
`
`
`Exhibit 30 to the Testimonial Deposition Transcript of Janelle Rosenfeld was served on the
`
`Applicant on the date indicated below via the Board’s electronic filing system and by depositing
`
`the same with the United States Postal Service, First-Class Mail, postage prepaid, to:
`
`
`
`
`
`Cindy N. Tran, Esq.
`Law Office of Cindy N. Tran
`225 S. Lake Ave., Suite 300
`Pasadena, CA 91101
`
`
`and further certifies that the aforementioned Testimonial Deposition Transcript and Exhibits
`
`were filed with the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board on the date indicated below online
`
`through the ESTTA system of the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Dated: March 31, 2016
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` /Russell D. Dize/
`
`Russell D. Dize
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`esseSra
`
`mi
`
`a
`
`

`

`
` E QUARTERLY REVIEW OF
`
` | 5|
`
`in
`
`*ny
`pzESSE}
`
`3>
`
`
`
` 0
`
`
`
` |
`
` |
`
`64836
`
`
`

`

`
`
`4 3
`
`2
`
`Ba.
`
`a
`
`
`
`gg
`
`
`
`86
`
`
`
`96
`
`Publisher & President
`Richard L. Elia
`Managing Director
`Harley MacKenzie
`Editor
`Randy Sheahan
`Associate Publisher
`William G. Lavelle
`Features Editor
`Mary Boyle
`Senior Editor.
`Lisa M:.Amore.
`Layout & Production ~
`LMY Studio,Inc.
`Staff
`Kathleen T. Gibbons
`Robert Gibbons:
`Elizabeth Lydon |
`Melanie, May —
`Sales & Circulation
`Beth Hamilton:
`Advertising
`Christopher R. Rule
`Barbara A. McGonagle. _
`Robert Bradley -**'
`ee
`
`
`
`The Quarterly Review of Winesis:published -
`Surety
`Ts: “Eleanor&Ray|Heald
`quarterly by Q.A.W. Inc., 24 Garfield ‘Avenue,
`1994Port: OnefortheAges a
`Winchester, MA 01890. ‘Subscription U.S.
`$14.95/Canadian $22.95 a year. Second class
`Po
`
`Peter Cobb™-.« %,
`postage rate at Winchester, MA 01890. Post-
`Port:The Churchill GrahamStory
`: 73
`master send address changes to The Quar-
`terly Review of Wines, 24 Garfield Avenue,
`Donald Breed. -
`Winchester, MA 01890. Volume 19, Number1
`Callaway Wines
`The Quarterly Review of Wines is copy-
`righted, and may not be: reproduced without
`Mary pore.ks
`written consent from the publisher. All rights
`Smoker: PuttingOnThe Ritz...Again
`reserved. Unsolicited manuscripts must be
`accompanied by proper return postage. The
`Quarterly Review of Wines assumes no
`Richard 1: Ella
`responsibility for loss or damage of such
`CigarTalk: Accessories
`material.
`Richard Carleton Hacker.
`© 1996 ISSN: 0740-1248
`The Quarterly Review of Winesis distributed
`All ThingsGrape & Small
`by Eastern NewsDistributors, Inc., One Media
`Way, 12406 RT. 250, Milan, OH 44846-9705.
`Printed in U.S.A.
`
`
`
`AuTUMN, 1996
`VoL, 19, No. 1
`
` THE QUARTERLY REVIEW OF
`INES©
`
` «
`
`The Real Truth About 1995 Claret
`Clive Coates, MW.
`Seduced by 1994 Red Burgundy
`Clive Coates, MW
`Value Wines from the Midi
`Eleanor & Ray Heald.
`Brolio’s Second Renaissance
`Richard L. Elia
`Immortal Zinsfrom De anne
`Larry Walker i
`California Tastings: Zins& Pinots
`Randy Sheahan
`Joseph,Phelps: Older, Wiser, Better
`- Richard PaulHinkle
`“Bating&Sleeping Bordeaux
`Wining.&Diningin NewZealand
`E ard & Mireille Guiliano
`
` California's‘Ss,BestPinotNioir?
`
`.
`
`....
`
`Serena Sutcliffe, MW >
`
`|
`
`;
`
`-
`
`Randy Sheahan ~
`Two Book Reviews
`
`Change of Address: Allow 4-6 weeks for
`change.Failure to inform us will result in
`missing copies. QRW, 24 Garfield Avenue,
`Winchester, MA 01890.. Phone: (617) 729-
`7132. Fax: (617) 721-0572.
`
`Cover: Shadows & Reflections: A Prelude © 1996 Jeffrey Titcomb
`
`128
`
`

`

`
`
`ay
`
`atu
`
`tsf“S
`
`AN.
`
`=)'s
`
`

`

`~ ns
`
`-
`
`: World’s Most Anirriated Polo Player
`
`Ma é¢HN
`
`“ea 4
`
`,Bare
`ainf‘
`
`

`

`
`
`Samuel Behar, circa 1917
`
`ul
`
`Cade wileCaytidiae
`
`Ike Behar shirts are featured at the most exclusive
`retailers in the United States, Japan, England,
`Canada, Italy, and his namesake stores in Miami
`and Shanghai, China. Many motion picture and
`television celebrities have made Ike Behar their
`shirt of choice on andoff thescreen.
`
`It is with greatpride that the Behar family
`presents La Confianza, an exquisite lineofshirts
`respectfully handcrafted in the United States to
`celebrate the 110th anniversaryof the man who
`set the standards of quality thatstill remain the
`strength of the firm today.
`
`Wear these shirts with confidence. Only the finest
`fabrics woven in the best mills throughout Europe
`were used, from two-ply Egyptian cotton to
`100% cashmere.
`
`Enjoy the distinctive details. Every seam is single-
`needle stitched with 22 stitches per inch. Every shirt
`has an authentic split yoke, a U.S, Patent diamond-
`quilted inner collar, and natural ocean pearl
`buttons, as well as hand-cut collars and cuffs,
`
`La Confianza. A shirt that can be worn bythe
`discerning gentleman with confidence thatthis
`meticulously tailored garmentwill stand thetests
`of time, elegance, and style—just as Samuel Behar
`
`always intended.
`
`— FZ Coch ae
`(800) 637-3013
`
`
`Eprror-IN-CHIEF & DesiGN DIRECTOR
`PUBLISHER
`Steve Connatser
`James D. Lonergan
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EDITOR
`Mariana Greene
`
`ASSOCIATE EDITOR
`Katy Foster
`
`DESIGNER
`Victoria Clary
`
`PROOUCTION MANAGER
`Tracy Thomas
`
`
`
`
`MARKETING MANAGER
`Yvonne Anguiano
`
`ADVERTISING COORDINATOR
`Sharon Burgher
`NORTHEAST ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
`Lisa M.Fields
`212-439-1770 © 212-439-1760 fax
`
`Mipwest ACCOUNT MANAGER
`Debra Caris
`;
`214-369-3445 © 214-369-7987 fax
`
`WESTERN ACCOUNT MANAGER
`A
`Renee Dauw
`EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT
`818-887-4830 © 818-887-4679 fax
`Pamiela Pressley
`
`
`
`
`
`SOUTHEAST ACCOUNT MANAGER
`
`Gregory G. Maddock
`RESEARCH EDITOR
`
`
`404-256-3800 * 404-255-7942 fax
`Nancy Myers
`
`
`DETROIT ACCOUNT MANAGER
`CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
`
`
`John Thornburgh
`
`Robert Bryce, Ralph DiGennaro, Jeffrey Hogrefe,
`248-360-6996 © 248-360-7196 fax
`Herbert Spencer, William Tomicki
`
`
`
`
`INTERNATIONAL PuBLIC RELATIONS
`CONTRIBUTING PHOTOGRAPHERS
`
`
`Valerie Halford
`
`
`Kent Barker, Jay Dickman, Bob Krist, Kip Lott,
`
`44-1344-873212 (London)
`Galen Rowell, Brian Smith, Patrick Ward
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EDITORIAL BOARD
`Adam Snow, Reid Slaughter, AmiShinitzky,
`Ed Scanlon, Peter Rizzo, Orrin Ingram,
`Memo Gracida, Meg Goodman, Rosemary Wayman
`FOUNDING Eprror: Ami SHINITZKY
`
`“PRESIDENTAND CEO
`John B. Goodman
`
`CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER
`Steven Sanit
`
`g
`
`ACCOUNTANT
`Anna Whittington
`
`ADVERTISING AND EpITorIAL OFFICES:
`CIRCULATION
`8214 Westchester Drive, Suite 850
`
`
`Jackie Prince
`Dallas, Texas 75225
`
`Circulation Specialists, Inc.
`
`214-369-3445 © 214-369-7987 fax
`
`
` For SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION:
`
`NEWSSTAND CONSULTANTS
`
`800-552-POLO
`Ralph Perricelli, Irwin Billman
`
` © Co yeight 1998 by Westchester Media Company, LP. All rights reserved. No part ofthis issue may be repro-
`
`y any means whatsoever without written permission of the publisher, POLO is published bimonthly.
`dui
`Color, scanning, retouching, and separations by The Peerless Grou , Little Rock, AR. Printed in the USAat
`Quad/Graphics. This magazineis not affiliated in any way with Ralph Lauren or any Polo Ralph Lauren entities.
`
` POLO HAGAZINE 410 SEPT/OCT 1998
`
`ADA
`
`

`

`a
`
`Teae
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`those reporting at least one drink of
`alcohol daily; but that “In most sub-
`groups, the rates of death from all
`causes were lowest among people
`whoreported one drink of alcohol
`daily.”
`
`eew
`
`Word has it that California’s dynamic
`Pinot Noir duo, Burt Williams and Ed
`Selyem, are looking to sell their win-
`ery, and that former San Francisco
`49er quarterback Joe Montanais eager
`to buy.
`
`e¢¢@
`
`The world’s most planted wine grape
`is the white Airén, whose vines cover
`a whopping1.2 million acres in Spain.
`
`¢¢e
`
`Tom Selfridge, former Winemaker
`and President of Beaulieu Vineyards
`and, more recently, Vice-President of
`Production at Kendall-Jackson, joined
`California’s Chalone Group as Presi-
`dent, effective January 1. Based in
`Napa, the Chalone Group not only
`owns and operates Monterey’s Cha-
`lone Vineyards, Carneros’ Acacia
`Winery and Sonoma’s Carmenet
`Winery, but owns a 50 percent interest
`in San Luis Obispo’s Edna Valley
`Vineyards, a 5] percent interest in
`Washington’s Canoe Ridge Winery
`and a 24 percent interest in the
`Bordeaux Fourth Growth Chateau
`Duhart-Milon. The hiring ofSelfridge
`could signal a new, more competitive
`direction for the Group. Stay tuned.
`{Editor's note: Selfridge’s hiring came
`barely a week before the tragic death,
`in a plane crash, of Chalone co-founder
`Dick Graff]
`
`¢e¢ fe
`
`According to The New Sotheby's Wine
`Encyclopedia (London: D K Publishing,
`Inc., 1997), 86 percent of a wine's con-
`tent is water, with “individual flavor-
`
`ing elements [representing] barely
`two percent of ... content.”
`
`@¢€e¢e
`
`Who produces the most Pinot Noir in
`California? Well, it’s none other than
`Sebastiani, whose August Sebastiani,
`Talus, Nathanson Creek and Ven-
`dange brands account for over 300,000
`cases of Pinot annually.
`
`@¢@e¢e¢
`
`Hospices de Beaune winemaker
`André Porcheret, who also owns
`Burgundy’s Domaine Monthélie-
`Douhairet
`(Monthélie, Volnay,
`Pommard and Meursault), has begun
`aging someof his wines in square bar-"
`rels. Traditional round barrels, he con-
`tends, exposetoo muchof the wine to
`harsh sediment, but square ones, by -
`lowering and compacting the sedi-
`ment, lessen the exposure, and lead to
`softer, fruitier wine. And we thought
`we'd heard everything...
`
`Spread over 24 acres and able to hold
`30 million gallons, the world’s largest
`wine cellar belongs to the South
`African wine cooperative K.W.V.
`
`¢¢e¢
`
`Good newsfor diet-conscious lovers
`of bubbly: An independent study con-
`ducted by California sparkling wine
`producer Gloria Ferrer shows that, on
`average, Champagne and methodé
`champenoise wines contain ten per-
`cent fewer calories than premium
`California Chardonnay.
`
`Good news, too, for lovers of Tuscan
`red wine: TheItalian government has
`just increased the permissible DOC
`acreage for Rosso di Montalcino —
`the younger-drinking, less-expensive
`“cousin” of Brunello di Montalcino —
`
`from 75 acres to 800.
`
`10 The Quarterly Review of Wines, Spring
`
`1998
`
`Publisher & President
`Richard L. Elia
`
`Managing Director
`Harley MacKenzie
`Editor
`
`Randy Sheahan
`Associate Publisher
`William G. Lavelle
`Features Editor
`
`Mary Boyle
`Senior Editor
`Lisa M. Amore
`
`Layout & Production
`LMY Studio,Inc.
`Staff
`
`Sheila Forsyth
`Kathleen T. Gibbons
`Robert Gibbons
`Melanie May
`Sales & Circulation
`Beth Hamilton
`
`Advertising
`Christopher R. Rule
`Barbara A. McGonagle
`Robert Bradley
`Communications
`Stephanie Gilbert
`Legal Counsel
`Wade M. Welch, Esq.
`
`Contributing Writers
`Burton Anderson
`Gerald D. Boyd
`Donald Breed
`Michael Broadbent, MW
`Clive Coates, MW
`
`Rosemary George, MW
`Edward & Mireille Guiliano
`
`Patrick Grubb, MW
`Richard Carleton Hacker
`
`Eleanor & Ray Heald
`lan Jamieson, MW
`Jan Read
`
`Serena Sutcliffe, MW
`Larry Walker
`
`Cover: Photo © 1998 Jeffery Titcomb
`
`The Quarterly Review of Wines is published quarterly by
`O.R.W. Inc., 24 Garfield Avenue, Winchester, MA 01890.
`Subscription U.S. $14.95/Canadian $22.95 a year; U.S.
`$28.95/ Canadian $36.95 for two years. Periodicals postage
`paid at Winchester, MA 01890. Postmaster send address
`changes to The Quarterly Review of Wines, 24 Garfield
`Avenue, Winchester, MA 01890. Volume 20, Number 3 The
`Quarterly Review of Wines is copyrighted, and may not be
`reproduced without written consent from the publisher. All
`rights reserved. Unsolicited manuscripts must be accom-
`panied by proper return postage. The Quarterly Review of
`Wines assumes no responsibility for loss or damage of such
`material.
`© 1998 ISSN; 0740-1248
`The Quarterly Review of Wines is distributed by Eastern News
`Distributors, Inc., One Media Way, 12406 RT. 250, Milan, OH
`44846-9705.
`Printed in U.S.A.
`Change of Address: Allow 4-6 weeks for change. Failure to
`inform us will result in missing copies. ORW, 24 Garfield
`Avenue, Winchester, MA 01890. Phone: (781) 729-7132. Fax:
`(781) 721-0572. E-mail: qrwine@tiac.net; Web site:
`http:/Avww.grw.com
`
`134
`
`:i
`
`|
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`Shopping & /
`Hote (5 f
`|
`
`et
`\
`
`\
`
` Restauranes,|
`
`re, | \
`j—-
`
`ee )
`-
`
`|
`
`/
`
`

`

`edal; IndyInternation
`
`1997.CALIFORNIA MERLOT :
`3
`:
`fem
`‘old:Medal,El Dorado County Fair
`1996 CALIFORNIA
`AUVIGNON BLANC
`‘Best Buy, Wine Spectator
`Gold Medal, El Dorado County Fair
`,
`Iver Medal,Indy International
`(bbe
`nat
`+
`os
`dies
`
`i
`j
`
` call Shiren Felicien,
`
`A Publication of
`M. Shanken Communications, Inc.OE
`Marvia R. Shanken
`Editor and Publisher
`Editorial
`Jordon Managing Editor
`
`¢ Harvey Steiman
`
`Laube, James Suckling, Per-Hemrik Mansson,
`Thomas M.
`
`Th
`Macthews
`New Trak i
`
`om Marcus
`
`stant Mhumagind
`inur: Ted Line
`
`cvase Ednur:
`lett Monsen
`
`
`nmeuting E.bur: Gordon Mott
`E.litur
`poth Exlender
`
`Media Coment: Brendan Vaunchan
`
`
`: Jane Shuter
`Manager
`
`
`Asutane Manager,
`Wine
`5
`Unah Mathabane
`Tratuencn Associate, NewMedia: fenniter Cia
`
`orexparuent: Peter D. Melecee 4
`
`Lucinure, Ben Bovinetens
`hee Meverson
`
`eatin
`Taseng Director: Bruce Sanderson
`
`Tasteng Couredinators: Jumes Molesworth, Sti. York:
`Thomas Garrett, San Francnco:
`
`Assocant Tasting
`~inatur: Molly Ferrell, Npw Yorks
`MaryAnn Worokiec, San Frinceso
`
`E.stonal Director. 8
`
`Marketing
`
`Jav Morris Senior
`Presudent, Marketing
`
`Lynn Rittenband
`Senior Vice Presulent. Event Marken
`
`Miki Singer Senor Vice President
`‘Allison Cuhen Munacer. New Media Busmess Development
`Event Markenng Dire
`Paulette Williams
`_——— >
`
`Evene Marketing Manager: Susannah Nalin
`
`Event Marketa
`Admurusirazar:
`Bisa Cinkbin
`rtisin|
`lex
`
`
`CenthiaA. MeGeegorVicePresdent,Wester heriungManager
`
`m Morgenstern Vice Present. DirectorAdeernsng
`
`Elizabeth Ferrero Vice President. Advertrng Ser}
`a”
`
`James J. ArchambaultJr. Adverming Muruget,
`Kim Asher Advertising Manager, Travel
`
`
`+, Mike McGoldrick Advertomg Manucer.

`Steven Weintraub Advertsing Munuges
`
`Party Whetzel Adverning Manager. Retad
`AdvernsingProduchonAssistant
`Don Gatterdam Drrector fof Custom Publishing:
`
`CasedaeraDieseToe
`
`Quenzer Intemational. Telephone: 1770) “406:
`Design
`and Production
`AgreeArtDirec:JonTheinps2n
`David A, Baver Art deea
`Donna Marianna Morris Pmducron Monger
`“Asnstare Ant Directors: Karen Salama. Michele Yoshee
`Producnon Systems Cuordinater: Kein Mullen
`Designer: Philip Ficks
`Photo Editor: Beas Hecox
`
`‘Assistant Phow Editor:
`Michael Janen-ch
`
`Circulation
`Laura Zandi Vice Prendent, Circuit
`Ciredanon Director: Sheryl Hankins
`Assnstant Circdanon Manager: Phylicra Anonowits
`Renu! Account Manager: Shuren Felicien
`‘Asustant Retail Sales Manager: Titfany Brecka-Navarro
`“Assurant Retail Marketing Manager: Mlelrssst Kunmel
`Cirewlanon Coordinator: Lucia Rose
`
`Editerial, Production and Corporate
`387 Park Ave. South, New York, NY 1X16
`
`Telephone: (212) 634-4224 Fax: (212) 6
`4,
`West Coast Advertising and Editorial Offices
`601 Van Ness Ave,. Suite 2032, San Francuco. CA 94102
`Telephone: (415) 673-2040 Fax: (415) 672-0105
`Vice President, Western Advernsing Munaget: CynthiaA. McGregor
`West Coass Account Managers: Kelly Meyers. Lindsey B. Ronald
`Advertising Coordinacn: Crisoin M. Donovan
`Editorial Group: Harvey Steiman, James Luube, Jeff Moruan
`Tasting Coordmawor: Thomas Garrett
`European Bureau
`Bureau Chief: James Suckling
`
`Frazione Boro No. 27, 52020 San Guisuno Vuldarna t AR), Italy
`Telephome: (C11) 39-55-977071 Fax: (O11) 39-55-97703!
`Seruor Editor: Per-Hennk Manson
`Chemun de Senaugin 7, CH-! 162 St.-Prex, Surtzerland
`Telephone: (O11) 41-21-SC6-+4850 Fax: (O11) 41-21 -306-4851
`Assisemn Edin: Julia Mann
`I6A Greenwich Marker, London SE1C 9H2, England
`Telephame: (O11) 4-181-853-2129 Fax: (CLT) 44-131 -305-2660
`
`
`7 inc.
`Shanken Communicatio:
`a
`-
`Marvin R. Shanken: Charman
`Michael D. Moaba: Vice Chairman
`Robert Beleson: President
`Jay Morrts: Senior Vice Presidene, Markenng
`Mel Mannion: Seruur Vice Presidenc, AdmimustranonyFinance
`Lynn Rittenband: SeniorVice Prendent, Event Murkeung
`Niki Singer: Senior Vice Presulent
`:
`
`Miriam Morgenstem: Vice Presdent. Advernsing Sules
`Marnn Leeds: Vice President, Creative Servwes
`Laura Zandi: Vice President, Circulanon
`Janice McManus: Assstant o the Charman
`» HOW TO CONTACT WINE SPECTATOR
`
`Lats to the Editor Lettersare always welcome.Metre write £0
`ters, Wine Spectator, 387 Park Ave. South, Mew York,
`NY 10016,fix
`at (212) 684-5424 or e-mual at einespecemshanken.cont. Mil letters
`must include the writer's name, city andstate. We reserve the right to
`ae sceioe length and style.
`lew Subscriptions To onder a newsubscnpriun te Wing Spectator, call
`(800) 752-7799 in the US. and Canada. Seine to Wine eae
`P.O.Box 37367, Boone, [A 30037-0567.
`Subscription Renewals, Inquiries, Change of Address ani
`
`Issues. Write Wine Specumar, P.O.
`‘or call (S00) 752-7799 in the U
`Canada: call (212) 654-4224of fax (212)
`a.
`
`
`Advertising For rites and information pleee call «
`Mongenstem, Vice President. Advertimng, Wine Speers
`
`Ave. South, New York, NY IWOIG, (212) 034-422
`
`egor, Western Advertising Mat
`Spectr.
`
`
`
`‘wite 2032. San Francisco,
`Got
`(415) 673-0105,
`(415) 673-2040
`
`Classified Advertising For rates and intonation, .c¢ the Clissitieds
`
`section in this neue, orcontact Hene Fader,
`Clooifial Advertsing
`Director, Wine Spectutar, $57 Park Ave, South, NewYork, NY 100Lo,
`(212) 694-4224, fax (QU) 451-072.
`be Tes Rall Wises Srcrennece Fre enterih
`
`
`
`Gu (ale
`Rele[scrate eeei aneee
`
`138
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`peene3
`
`

`

`epioaiRoan.
`
`ty
`ApiceeRtnayeui
`
`a|
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` piohaeeketLTaitMelaeBVanesulehopePeeSuluaeiiegstaesSvcdeH]feteceturneeblsaeBoefosheeyBsalRat
`
`
`ureSaar‘ete
`#?if5reLibi
`LoriemesaHOVEtadULLuse|F(
`
`
`1ee
`
`mee]a
`
`ae
`
`Paooewo
`
`nol=E—aaeer
`
`at—aas
`
`oe=osPl
`
`ff
`
`

`

`aS3
`
`CEAL|
`
`br
`
`fandaScea
`
`‘
`bs MOGUES,
`w)zar=ane
`THE MAYOR.
`
`>
`
`TASTEMA
`Lea
`7)
`KE
`SCENESTERS.-
`AND,
`a
`
`95 (Canada $4.95) 53
`
`

`

`eeeoe
`
`
`
`rTgraysthyerswoYS.
`
`haan
`
`Sanae
`
`reyciaaes
`
`=“eeaed
`
`ae
`
`
`ane
`
` nyparrniTe
`
`3ww|a
`
`fs
`EEC
`
`

`

`PERWTRmeeeMitaletsBilitePucca(sctlietyye
`
`
`
`
`
`PLEROLESbOMCLnGoloLAMM
`SraeneTee
`
`4é5
`
`

`

`ii
`
`

`

`aia
`
`
`
`traineebettorsaataeA
`
`ee ae oe
`
`kal MONTECRISTO 4.
`wwe
`q
`“A
`
`riedcefe ciesdheaadahaay oF
`
`:
`ee
`a
`a
`et
`FIeeVa
`BESSea
`aHe
`Bhaaavm
`eeeeee
`erelogLay Aoi
`
`

`

` _
`
`www,cigearaficlonade.c(
`
`CALADA $5.95-CUBAL UK
`
`
`Years¢
`Hemingwa
`
`Private Jets
`California’s Wine St
`18 Great Golf Courses
`Queen of Poke
`Finding Your Past
`103 Lonsdale:
`
`
`
`mo
`
`148
`
`

`

`es
`
`hk eAconscLaeNeo
`
`

`

`a Montecristo is mor
`
`255ch brandhas its own identity,tradi
`
`2
`
`te
`
`it's a world. The World of
`Montecristo includes
`a number of
`
`select, premium cigar brands that, like
`
`\Ivestovthe highest standardsofqualiyak
`
`A
`
`

`

` an one brand...
`
`rable, memorable smoking experiences.
`
`iM
`
`
`
`In addition to cigars;
`the World of
`ontecristo includes different places
`
`and memories. An attitude, Thetradi ¢
`
`tiong offine cigar making are an integral
`
`part of this remarkable world. Anyone
`
`can join. Simply light up and savor one
`
`
`of these superior handmadecigars.__a
`
`
` ae
`
`Aarts
`
`+
`
`oh
`
`
`
`

`

`an nigy
`
`:
`
`SARITA
`
`aA
`
`dpe
`AN LSD
`
`

`

`

`

`
`
`

`

`Oe7yeeMarkie
`
`FBXBOMCUSHX
`HHRK
`Hbarardlse
`hy
`hadbava
`I
`ht
`=
`SHARON2S

`ae
`HS
`
`5-
`are
`H1
`thal
`iH
`
`I
`r
`latte
`
`}
`
`lead
`
`

`

`1
`
`vsirtidy cll
`9a
`
`]!
`
`iltr
`
`~re
`
`hi
`
`|i
`
`ty
`bitin
`
`Hears
`
`

`

`Lacie assa Eve Mika
`
`alBaratieisporteKorhteeevecrea
`SomeES CU Cat Grbsiror)sec Lee
`
`eeouionihceils *
`feaetoateeePeeRenee Tas
`
`wy
`
`Tet SeeBAbend Lebel kit En ee
`
`Tan!
`
`

`

`Mousse Cake
`
`"Glanduta
`
`Ton
`
`

`

`KereertoadSePCy
`arl5=hie
`
`Bubpae
`
`eeapete
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`bttpd/www.winespectater.caim
`
`BAUME & MERCIER
`
`"EB, 28, 1999 / $395 CANADA $4.95 / £350
`
`
`
`The King of Luxury
`You dontBiew him, buthe’s oneoftherichestpeople on earth,
`An exclusive interview with the reclusive billionaire who parlayed
`- a passionfor wine into a luxury-goods empire.
`
`¢CULLeS’
`
`HACKETT
`ee
`
`ag
`PIAGET
`
`SU
`
`KOA
`
`_D_
`
`VACHERONCONSTANTIN
`
`ALFRED DUNHILL
`
`
`
`I)
`16
`|| (HMOINN Pak?
`
`MUU Unger veseergy
`
`
`
`

`

`
`54~m‘.|::feSEeeETEEeycereaeeDeegearLCLRPCEotcieaTirafeetereeeaeeneeeeeemercSectrrsoirPTCLENCRTCnite
`
`Seé:-es~‘ayesme==ki
`
`
`
`
`
`Cearerareteetha)
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`
`
`

`

`ceapaisYee ANS aanisaye
`
`al Wnaad pndanaads
`
`ati
`
`5) ont eaecae : ate Be ai Russians
`
`{|
`
`i 4
`
`)i
`
`Serr
`
`Neer)eeWni
`
`

`

`
`
`incheecleusunasgtceBretetthy
`
`eeemeicruaees,lillieMolMa)MeeeGlas]
`
`
`
`AGeRuteladalacontaeRoacyHOPE
`
`

`

`Copyright 1997 The Washington Post
`The Washington Post
`
`February 26, 1997, Wednesday, Final Edition
`SECTION: FINANCIAL;Pg. C11
`
`LENGTH: 1281 words ©
`
`HEADLINE:As a Symbol of Success, the Cigar Is on a Roll; Surprised by Demand, Stogie Makers Struggle To
`Feed the Fire
`
`BYLINE: Heather Salerno, Washington Post Staff Witer
`
`.
`BODY:
`Demi, Bruce and Armold have turned them into a pop culture icon. Tony restaurants hold special dinners to savor
`them. And there's even a magazine devoted to them.
`
`Sales of cigars are smoking, driven by a new imageofthe stogie as a symbol of prestige, success and luxurious
`living, It's hard to believe thatjust four years ago, cigar sales were so poor that experts were ready to write off the
`industry.
`
`Caught off guard by the sudden surge in sales ~ which analysts don't expect to slow for several years --
`manufacturers are finding it impossible to keep up with the overwhelming demand for cigars. The most popular
`cigars, the premium, hand-rolled variety, are exported to thé United States primarily from a fewaresis, including
`the Dominican Republic, the Canary Islands, Honduras and Spain. The boomhas led to back orders of 60 million
`to 80 million cigars.
`
`"There ig an argument over how many cigars are really on order with the companiés," said Norman Sharp,
`president of thé District-based Cigar Association of America, "But the fact is that whetherit's 60 or 80 million.it
`doesn't matter. You still can't get them."
`
`Industry éxperts say that demand for such highly rated cigars as Arturo Fuentes, Montecristos and Macanudos-
`far outweighs the number produced by mianufacturers. As a result, some veteran manizfacturers, retailers and
`industry trade associations say they are concerned tliat somestores -- primanlynéw entrants Uiat lack longstanding
`relationships with manufacturers or wholesalers -- are stocking products of questionable qualiry.
`
`"The retail community needsto fill their shelves with something, so there's a lendencytofill Lnkém with whatever
`they can get," said Dick DiMeola, chief dperdting afficér for Consolidated Cigar Corp. of Fart Lauderdale, Fla., the
`largest manufacturer and’marketer of cigars in the United Statés. "A guy like mie who's been in the business for 40
`years will walk in a store sometimes, and I think I'm in another world. I don't recognize any of the brands."
`
`*
`
`Last year, the demandfor cigars — especially hand-rolléd, premium ones -- leaped. Thé Cigar Association of
`America estimates that almost 3 billion cigars were sold in 1996, Based on figures compiled through October,
`more than 220 million were premium cigars, an unprecedented 67 percent increase from the same time penod in
`1995,
`
`Although the sales increase is viewed as a godsend by the once-dwindling industry, many longtime cigar
`manufacturers and retailers say the demandis giving rise to entrepreneurs with little knowledge of the business.
`
`60
`
`167
`
`

`

`Copyright 1996 Daily News, ue
`
`Daily News (New York)
`
`September 18, 1996, Wednesday
`SECTION:Business; Pg. 47
`
`LENGTH:317 words
`
`HEADLINE: WATCH THEIR SMOKE
`CHIC CIGAR CLUB SET TO LIGHT UP AT 'SIXES' SPOT
`
`BYLINE: By PETER GRANT
`
`BODY:.
`The Top of the Sixes, one of midtown's oldest restaurants; has closed its doors to make way for a super-enclusive
`cigar club whose miembers include Sharon Stone, Amold Schwarzenegger and Lee lacocca,
`
`of
`
`The Grand Havana Room, which openedits first private club in Beverly Hills last year, has takén over the space
`at the top floor of 666 Fifth Ave.
`
`The club will open here later this year after it renovates tle bar and diningroom andinstalls hundreds of
`humidors for members to store their Monte Cristos, Dunhills and Macanudos which sell for as much ag $ 20 edch.
`
`The club plans to have a limit of 1,000 members, Theywill pay annual dues of $ 3,000. Members of the Beverly
`Hills chub, including Met Gibson and Whoopi Goldberg, also will be able to use it when they're in town.
`
`"Most new members will be selected by private invitation," said Harry Shuster, chairman of L.A.-based United
`Restaurants, which owns Grand Havana.
`
`Théclub is opening at a time that the cigar craze is sweeping the city and the rest of the country. Numerous new
`cigar stores have dpenéd and a growing number of restaurants ‘are beginning to offer private cigar lounges.
`
`“Ever since smoking was banned in restaurants, we've seen more places opening that are dedicated to that," said
`Howard Rosen, a broker with Grubb & Ellis New York, who worked on the Grand Havana deal.
`
`Topof the Sixes, which offérs a 360-degree viewof the Manhattan skyline, had been operating for more than 40
`years. But it grew staid andtouristy in recent years. With business declining, its owner, Cléveland-based Select
`Restaurants, decided not to renew its soon-to-eXpire lease, The restaurantclosed Monday,laying off +4 employes.
`
`" said Arthur Bocchi of Sumitomo Realty, the building's owner. "It had tremendous
`'. "We're sorryto see them go,.
`sentimental value. "
`
`Notes: ILLUSTRATION BY RENEE LOLYA DAILY NEWS
`GRAPHIC: GRAND HAVANA CLUB members include (clockwisé, from top left) Amold Schwarzenegger,
`Whoppi Goldberg, Lee Iacocca and Sharon Stoné - who have helped promote increased cigar-smoking among
`young women.
`
`LOAD-DATE: September 18, 1996
`
`93
`
`168
`
`

`

`47TH STORY of Level
`
`1 printed in FULL format.
`
`Copyright 1998 UMI Inc.;
`Copyright Pittsburgh Business Times & Journal 1998;
`Business Dateline;
`Pittsburgh Business Times & Journal
`
`April 24, 1998
`
`SECTION: Vol 17; No 40; pg 3
`
`JENGTH: 982 words
`
`IEADLINE: Conspicuous consumption: Well-heeled Americans are spending more and
`lore on the good life
`
`SYLINE: Dave Yochum
`
`IATELINE: Pittsburgh; PA; US; Middle Atlantic
`
`ODY:
`
`Most people buy snow tires when it snows. Not Francois Bitz.
`
`the co-founder of FORE Systems
`When the first flakés fell a few years ago,
`ne.,went out and picked up a Hummér -- for about § 80,000.
`
`Such spontaneous purchases aren't unusual for Mr. Bitz, 36, who made millions
`hen FORE held its wildly successful initial public offering in 1995.
`
`Last year, he wanted a place Downtown where he could stay overnight after
`aking in the symphony or ballet. He
`found an idéal penthouse. But
`the apartment
`asn't for sale individually. So he shelled out $ 1.1 million to buy the entire
`dilding,
`a vacant, eight-story structure. He says he'll convert
`the rest of it
`ato loft apartments to improve the Cultural District, where it is located.
`
`Well-heeled Américans are spending more and more on the good lifé. As 401 (k)
`inds bulge with assets, as stock options are granted deeper into managément and
`:aff ranks, and small business ownérs prospér,
`there's a spending spree under
`iy.
`"A lot of people have made a lot of money in stocks, so what was expensive
`2fore is less expensive now," said consither spending guru. Roger Blackwell,
`tthor of a best-selling textbook,
`"Consumer Behavior."
`
`Meanwhile, both credit card debt and bankruptcies are mounting -- indications
`iat not everyone who.is living like a king can afford it.
`
`Spending, Mr. Blackwell explains, makes people féel good. The national.
`iopping spree runs wide and deep with ordinary Americans splurging on
`g-screen TVs; Tommy Hilfiger jackets and. the newest power screwdriver.
`
`SELF ~ INDULGENCE
`
`the 1.200-acre Farmington, Fayette County,
`Néemacolin Woodlands Resort & Spa,
`treat built by 84 Lumber Co.
`founder Joe Hardy, has continued to expand during
`@ past 11 years. The latest addition is Chateau Lafayette, 124-room hotel that
`ened last year. It's modeled after the Ritz in Paris.
`
`169
`
`

`

`Pittsburgh Business Times & Journal, April 24, 1998
`
`Palo
`
`13
`
`The cost to rest your weary head ranges from $ 275 to $ 1,500 a night. It is
`a little pricier than the resort's 98-~room lodge,
`a steal at $ 225 to $ 345 per
`night.
`
`Its French bistro offers a 10.000-bottle wine collection to quench
`high-priced thirsts. After all, a long day on Nemacolin's Mystic Rock’golf
`course -- or its polo field -- can leave one quite parched.
`
`to choose from more than 60 beauty treatments
`Or patrons can head to the spa,
`while awaiting a computer printout of a personalized fitness plan.
`
`People are spending more on places, as well. as things.Business is up 20
`percent at Trenton, N.J.'s exclusive Boehm Porcelain Studio, where U.S.
`presidents buy gifts for foreign heads of state and corporate presidents buy
`gifts for their homes. One CEO just bought a $ 150,000 porcelain flower
`arrangement.
`
`Mr. Blackwell said long-standing millionaires are moré likely to spend
`carefully on cars and clothes while the nouveau riche buy big, bright "badges"
`o£ prosperity.
`
`the former first lady's 40-karat
`the Jackie Kennedy auction in New York,
`At
`jiamond engagement ring from her second husband, Greek shipping magnate
`Aristotle Onassis, brought $ 2.5 million from a mystery bidder later revealed to
`se Tony O'Reilly, chairman of H.J. Heinz Co.
`
`the former Chryss
`the bauble for his second wife,
`Mr. O'Reilly bought
`joulandris, whose brother was briefly engaged to Christina Onassis.
`
`The O'Réillys wound up in W and People magazines for owning the rock.
`
`How does one reciprocate for such a gift? Mrs. O'Reilly, no slouch at giving,
`‘ound a way. A substantial donation in her husband's name mearis that the new
`jowntown home f

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket