throbber
EXHIBITS
`
`Proceeding/Serial No: 91184978
`
`Filed:
`
`2/22/2011
`
`Title: EXHIBITS TO THE JAN. 13, 2011
`
`DEPOSITION OF ROHINISH HOODA FILED
`
`WITH ESTTA ON 2/22/2011
`
`Part: 2
`
`of
`
`3
`
`
`
`

`
`His team's failure to disclose the biopsy in February, while McCain was still fending off primary
`rivals, and the minor surgery this month reflected the campaign's sensitivity to questions about
`the 71-year-old candidate's age, health and abilities to carry out presidential duties.
`
`"Sen. McCain enjoys excellent health and displays extraordinary energy," Eckstein said, and "I
`and my colleagues can find no medical reason or problems that would preclude Sen. McCain
`from fulfilling all the duties and obligations of the President."
`
`The conference call with the medical team followed the limited disclosure of more than 1,000
`pages of medical records to a pool of reporters, who were allowed access to them for three hours
`but not permitted to make copies.
`
`Following the limited document dump at the start of a long holiday weekend, the campaign also
`released the top two pages of the 2006 tax returns of his wife, Cindy McCain, showing she made
`more than $6 million from her family's beer distributorship and paid $1.7 million in taxes. The
`couple file their taxes separately. rsisk@nydai|ynews.comWHAT'S AILING JOHN AGE:
`71 HEIGHT: 5-feet- 9WE|GHT:163 poundsvertigolnvasive melanoma removed fromleft temple in
`2000Cataract surgeryArthritis in both shoulders, likely to need artificial jointsMelanoma removed
`from left shoulder in 1993Me|anoma removed upper left arm in 2000Melanoma removed from his
`nose in 2002Kidney stonesPo|yps removed from colon earlier this yearSurgery to reduce
`enlarged prostateArthritis in right kneeSquamous cell carcinoma removed from right shin earlier
`this yearBLOOD PRESSURE: A robust 134 over 84 CHOLESTEROL: A healthful 192BODY
`MASS INDEX: A healthful 24He was a two-pack-a-day smoker until quitting in 1980WHAT HE'S
`TAKlNGSimvastatin to lower cholesterolHydrochlorothiazide to prevent kidney stonesAmiIoride to
`preserve potassium Baby aspirin to ward off heart attackZyrtec/ Claritin/Flonase for nasal
`allergiesAmbien CR to help him sleep when trave|ingA multivitamin tablet
`
`
`The Monterey County Herald Online (Monterey, CA)
`Headaches, allergies a bad mix
`May 23, 2008
`
`Dear Dr. Gott: I suffer from headaches associated with allergies and have tried numerous
`medications without much success. With spring here, the grass growing and flowers blooming,
`I'm really in a bind to find something I feel safe taking. Do you have any suggestions?
`
`Dear Reader: Allergies and headaches can be difficult to deal with and seem to affect us all at
`some point in our lives. Worse still, they seem to occur only at important occasions or other
`inappropriate times. You don't indicate what you have taken for relief, so I hope I can point you in
`the right direction.
`
`Visit your local pharmacy to see what is available over the counter. There are several allergy
`products on the market. You may want to try Claritin, formerly a prescription medication now
`approved for over-the-counter sale. The newest prescription-turned-OTC is Zyrtec. If you stop the
`allergies, you should be able to prevent the headaches.
`
`If you prefer homeopathic choices, I recommend Sinol, which is the first headache nasal spray
`registered with the Food and Drug Administration. It is purported to relieve headache pain and
`also comes in an aIIergy—re|ief spray. It supposedly reduces, prevents and/or stops sinus pain, as
`well as congestion and inflammation. It is nonaddictive and free of harsh side effects.
`
`If you need some guidance, speak with a pharmacist, who may be able to provide more
`information about the types of medication that will best control your symptoms and provide
`prompt relief. If you still have questions, make an appointment with your primary-care physician
`for his or her recommendations.
`
`McNeil 000393
`
`

`
`Dear Dr. Gott: My husband is suffering from nerve damage caused by knee surgery. He is
`currently using Lidoderm patches and Neurontin to help control the pain. The patches cause him
`to have a bad taste in mouth, and the Neurontin makes him very drowsy. He would rather use
`something natural and stop the prescription medications. Do you have any suggestions?
`
`Dear Reader: Nerve damage is a common consequence ofjoint surgery. in most cases, it is
`minor and short-lived. Your husband, however, appears to have severe damage with resulting
`pain. His doctor has taken appropriate steps to help him, but nerve pain can be very difficult to
`treat. Also, your husband needs to return to his physician to report the side effects of the
`medications.
`
`I have received many letters from people with nerve pain in their feet caused by diabetes. I often
`recommend Neurontin. However, your husband is currently taking it and would prefer a
`nonprescription, so l recommend Vicks VapoRub rubbed onto the affected area as often as
`needed. Many patients have had stunning success, but it doesn't work for everyone. If this is the
`case, I recommend you return to the surgeon for further advice.
`
`Write to Dr. Gott c/o United Media, 200 Madison Ave., 4th fl., New York, N.Y. 10016.
`
`
`Associated Press
`A look at McCain's health records
`
`May 23, 2008
`
`Republican presidential candidate John McCain's campaign allowed The Associated Press to
`review his medical records, spanning 2000 through May 2008. Highlights of the records:
`
`--His most recent complete physical was in March; his latest checkup was last week.
`
`--Blood pressure was 134 over 84. Optimal is below 120 over 80, and high blood pressure begins
`at 140 over 90. An in-between reading is sometimes called prehypertension, but McCain's doctor
`said other recent readings were lower and his blood pressure is normal.
`
`--Total cholesterol is a healthy 192, below the worrisome 240 level. His so-called bad or LDL
`cholesterol is a healthy 123. But his so-called good or HDL cholesterol is 42, below the
`recommended 60.
`
`--He weighs 163 pounds and is 5 feet 9 1/2 inches tall.
`
`--His BMl, or body mass index, was just under 24, which puts him at upper end of normal; 25 or
`higher is oven/veight.
`
`--He has had four separate melanomas removed, in 1993, 2000 and 2002. Most were very early
`stage forms but one, a spot on his temple in 2000, was invasive cancer deemed "intermediate-
`stage" melanoma. He has had no sign of melanoma since 2002, but has his skin checked every
`three or four months. Doctors frequently remove precancerous lesions and in February removed
`a small, early squamous cell carcinoma, an easily surgically cured skin cancer.
`
`--Doctors removed common benign growths called polyps during a routine colonoscopy in March.
`Doctors often screen patients with polyps more frequently, as they can be precancerous.
`
`--He has suffered occasional bouts of dizziness, usually when standing suddenly, since 2000 that
`repeated tests concluded were harmless vertigo.
`
`--In 2001, he had successful minimally invasive surgery to reduce an enlarged prostate, common
`in older men, and shows no sign of prostate cancer.
`
`McNeil 000394
`
`

`
`--His medications include simvastatin, part of the popular statin family of anti-cholesterol drugs; a
`baby aspirin, commonly prescribed starting in middle age to prevent heart attacks; Claritin, Zyrtec
`or Flonase as needed for seasonal allergies; the sleeping pill Ambien as needed during travel;
`and HCTZ, or hydrochlorothiazide, to prevent kidney stones.
`
`--McCain's stress test showed no signs of blockages, and his ejection fraction, a measure of the
`heart's pumping strength, was a very healthy 60 percent.
`
`--He has small kidney stones and benign kidney cysts that don't impact his kidney function, which
`is normal.
`
`
`CNN.com
`
`McCain in ‘excellent health,‘ doctor says
`May 23, 2008
`
`FOUNTAIN HILLS, Arizona (CNN) -- -- There's no medical reason to prevent Sen. John McCain
`from being president, the doctor for the presumptive GOP nominee said in a statement the
`McCain campaign released Friday.
`
`"At the present time, Sen. McCain enjoys excellent health and displays extraordinary energy,"
`said Dr. John D. Eckstein, an internal medicine specialist at the Mayo Clinic who has treated the
`candidate for 16 years.
`
`"While it is impossible to predict any person's future health, today I can find no medical reason or
`problems that would preclude Sen. McCain from fulfilling all the duties and obligations of
`president of the United States."
`
`McCain, who turns 72 in August, would be the oldest person to be elected to a first term as
`president if he wins in November. He has been treated for skin cancer three times and was a
`prisoner of war in the Vietnam War for 5‘/2 years.
`
`McCain has had no recurrence of skin cancer since it was surgically removed in 2000, Eckstein
`said.
`
`"We continue to find no evidence of metastasis or recurrence of the invasive melanoma as we
`
`approach the eighth anniversary of that operation," he said.
`
`"This was most recently confirmed with his comprehensive examination and tests" in March, he
`noted,andwith Dr. Suzanne M. Connolly's skin examination on May 12.
`
`"The prognosis for Sen. McCain is good because the time of greatest risk for recurrence of
`invasive melanoma is within the first few years after the surgery."
`
`Dr. Sanjay Gupta, CNN's chief medical correspondent who reviewed the medical records, found
`new details about the 2000 operation.
`
`The surgeon, Dr. Michael Hinni, wrote in the records that "through an abundance of caution," the
`surgery was aggressive, removing some of the senator's lymph nodes as well as the tumor.
`
`McCain developed swelling beneath the skin and had to be taken back for a second operation.
`
`Hinni said the prominence of the senator's left jaw is not a sign of cancer.
`
`McNeil 000395
`
`

`
`"This is a result of an absence of soft tissue on the face in front of his ear that makes the
`
`masseter (the chewing muscle) over the jaw appear more prominent," he said in the statement
`the campaign issued. "To be clear, the swelling is not due to any evidence of cancer."
`
`McCain is checked for skin cancer every three to four months, Connolly said in the statement.
`
`He has been treated for bladder stones and has kidney stones, the clinic said, but they do not
`affect urologic function. He has no evidence of cardiovascular disease.
`
`The senator has used the Mayo Clinic in Arizona since 1992. He checks in under a pseudonym.
`
`McCain's cholesterol levels are potentially worrying, Gupta found, but his blood pressure is good.
`
`Heart disease, the leading cause of death in America, could be a risk factor for McCain because
`of his age and family history, making his blood pressure and cholesterol levels relevant.
`
`His father, Adm. John S. McCain Jr., died of a heart attack at age 70.
`
`The statement listed the medications McCain takes:
`
`- Simvastatin, a cholesterol-lowering medicine
`
`- Hydrochlorothiazide, for kidney stone prevention
`
`- Amiloride, which preserves potassium in the bloodstream
`
`- Aspirin, for blood clot prevention
`
`- Zyrtec, an antihistamine, which he uses as necessary for nasal allergies
`
`- Ambien CR, used as necessary to help him sleep when traveling
`
`- A multiple-vitamin tablet
`
`He does not take pain medication to deal with the after-effects of his Vietnam injuries, which
`resulted after his ejection from a plane in 1967 and torture as a POW, the clinic said.
`
`A leg and both his arms were broken when a Vietnamese missile shot down his U.S. Navy A-4E
`Skyhawk over Hanoi. He also was stabbed with a bayonet and punched by a mob that discovered
`him.
`
`McCain is releasing his medical records voluntarily. He did the same when he ran for president in
`2000.
`
`The two Democratic presidential candidates, Sens. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, haven't
`released their doctors’ files.
`
`McNeil 000396
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT 68
`
`

`
`Zyrtec Press Clippings
`November 2007 — October 2008
`Part 2
`
`CNN: CNN Newsroom
`
`Obama Courts Cuban Americans; Fire Erupts on U.S. Aircraft Carrier; Hagee Controversy
`Continues
`
`May 23, 2008
`By Barbara Starr, Jeffrey Toobin, Susan Candiotti, John Zarrella, Don Lemon, Brianna Keilar, Dr.
`Sanjay Gupta, Abbie Boudreau, Wolf Blitzer, Susan Lisovicz
`
`LEMON: Yes. Well, the release of John McCain's medical records puts a spotlight on presidential health.
`Being president is one of the most powerful and most stressful jobs in the world.
`
`Dr. Connie Mariano has a unique perspective on all this. She was White House physician for President
`Clinton and both President Bushes. And she joins us now from Fountain Hills, Arizona.
`
`Thank you very much forjoining us here today.
`
`OK, so we have been looking at the medical records. And real quickly, just up front, I want to show you,
`these are the stats from John McCain's medical records. It has his age —- 71 years old; his height -- 5'6"
`tall, although we heard from Sanjay Gupta at one point it said he was 5'9"; 170 -- 163 pounds; and his
`B.P. would be 134 -- which is his blood pressure -- 134 over 84.
`
`How does that seem to you?
`
`Does that seem fairly normal for someone of his age?
`
`DR. CONNIE MARIANO, FORMER WHITE HOUSE PHYSICIAN: For his age, it appears appropriate.
`
`LEMON: It appears appropriate. OK, what is it, real quick, is he 5'6" or is he 5'9?"
`
`(AUDIO GAP)
`
`LEMON: Can you hear me, doctor?
`
`MARIANO: Go ahead.
`
`LEMON: Yes. I'm saying what's with the discrepancy in height here?
`
`Is that just something that's not a big deal?
`
`MARIANO: You know, I don't know whether or how they recorded it and whether the different records
`have varied according to that. So, you know, what was the current one and depending on what it was,
`you know, 10, 20 years ago, he's going to lose some height. You worry about osteoporosis -— osteopenia,
`thinning of the bones. So there will be variations in height over time. LEMON: OK. So he may have gone
`from 5'9" to 5'6" depending on how his body reacted to age.
`
`MARIANO: Yes.
`
`LEMON: OK, we've heard...
`
`MARIANO: My...
`
`LEMON: Go ahead.
`
`,N,,,,,,,,,,,Tmm
`max 1-mm. up _
`BEFORE rm: Tuna.“ “TENT MD TRADEMAM‘ °"'CE
`McNeil-PPC, rm,
`3 ‘W’
`,.,
`Opp. No, 91 134973
`Walgreen Co,
`
`°°"°“"-
`
`Applicant.
`
`Rolninish Hooda; Opposer Test Dcp Ex 63
`
`McNeil 000397
`
`

`
`MARIANO: My question is whether his physician, his internist, has noted this, whether he had back pain
`and other things that come to mind, certain conditions that can cause sudden accelerated height loss. So
`that's something that unless his physician has noted at, that should be looked at.
`
`LEMON: When we had when we spoke to our Dr. Sanjay Gupta here, as well, there were a litany of, you
`know, ailments that seemed minor that were listed off here. And it also talked about his cholesterol, which
`was 192; LDL bad cholesterol, 123; HDL, good cholesterol, 42. And then it talked about the medications,
`doctor, that he was on and it listed a whole, you know, thing from Zyrtec to Ambien to multi- vitamins to
`Hydroclorazide -- all kinds of things taken here. And all you say, or would you think, pretty normal for
`someone with his medical condition, right?
`
`MARIANO: They're fairly common medications. I think they had also mentioned he does take Ambien for
`sleep occasionally.
`
`My question is how often he takes that? Is it on a regular basis?
`
`LEMON: OK. The big question here is should John McCain be elected president, should the American
`people be worried, from anything that you have found in these medical records?
`
`MARIANO: I did look over the records that the Mayo Clinic has released and there wasn't anything there
`that worried me. The only thing I would question or ask his doctors to clarify or go on the record is the
`issue of any prior history of substance abuse, alcohol use, whether they're concerned about that; whether
`there's in question of neurological deficit, whether there are mental status changes, whether there's any
`evidence of mood disorder that may become a problem in the future.
`
`LEMON: OK. Now we know about the melanoma, which many Americans suffer from. And we tell people,
`you know, to wear their sunscreen and what have you, to take care of your skin, to make sure you're not
`out in the sun a lot. That would not appear -- or would it appear to be something that is of -- that is of
`concern here?
`
`MARIANO: No. He's pretty much clear. His physicians did a sentinel node biopsy at the time of his
`surgery. He's been followed very closely by an excellent dermatologist, Dr.
`
`Suzanne Connolly, who I know very well, at Mayo. And he's essentially clean of recurrence of that
`melanoma. And he gets very, very good surveillance on that. So I don't think that's an issue.
`
`LEMON: OK. And the other concern here that, you know, prisoner of war. He has gone through a lot.
`
`Mental health -- in the records, what can you tell us about that and what do you know about that?
`
`MARIANO: You know, I have not seen his prisoner of war records. I think what people need to look at is
`how is he at this current time. You know, I think the biggest test in terms of mental status is really the
`campaign in and of itself.
`
`When they're on the road, they're doing 18-hour days. They're constantly answering questions. You
`members of the press are hammering them for questions, trying to catch them, whether or not they are
`astute enough to listen to the questions and answer it correctly. So that's a tremendous mental status
`test, if anything, is to survive a presidential campaign, and then ultimately to go to the convention.
`
`How are they in terms of their speaking? Are there any lapses of memory?
`
`And then how well do they think on their feet?
`
`I think that's a very good test as to how they're operating mentally.
`
`LEMON: Dr. Connie Mariano is a former White House physician.
`
`McNeil 000398
`
`

`
`We thank you for joining us in the CNN NEWSROOM.
`
`MARIANO: Thank you.
`
`LEMON: And a reminder, you can see more on this topic this weekend. Doctor Gupta explores the health
`demands of being commander- in-chief and the challenges facing presidential doctors. It's a one hour
`special report, "The First Patient: Health and The Presidency." You can catch that Saturday and Sunday,
`8:00 p.m. and 11:00 p.m. Eastern on CNN.
`
`KEILAR: Talk about the school of hard knocks, that is the teacher giving a student the smackdown.
`
`(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
`
`KEILAR: A major agreement has been reached in the fight against what some people view as human
`slavery. This is the end of a long battle between advocates for migrant workers and a major fast food
`chain.
`
`And here to tell us more about this now is CNN's Abbie Boudreau with our Special Investigations Unit.
`
`What's going on here?
`
`ABBIE BOUDREAU, CNN SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS UNIT CORRESPONDENT: Well, Burger King
`has agreed to pay a penny more per pound for tomatoes. That may not seem like much, but advocates
`say it will help make a huge difference for those that work in the Florida's fields.
`
`The Burger King increase follows similar increases by McDonald's and Yum! brands, which operates
`Taco Bell, KFC and other restaurants. Burger King also says it will ensure it will not buy from growers with
`poor working conditions.
`
`Now, this is a story we told you about when went to Immokalee, Florida few months ago. Police told us
`how some workers were held as slaves living and working in deplorable conditions, making hardly
`enough money, if any, to survive.
`
`Today's decision is being applauded by Senator Bernie Sanders, who announced the agreement between
`Burger King and the Florida-based Immokalee workers.
`
`(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
`
`SEN. BERNIE SANDERS (I), VERMONT: With poverty in America increasing, with millions of people
`working longer hours for low wages, with a race to the bottom taking place, it was important for some of
`us to find out where that bottom was. And I expect that bottom is in Immokalee, Florida.
`
`AMY WAGNER, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, BURGER KING: We, along with other industry leaders,
`recognize that the Florida tomato harvesters are in need of better wages, working conditions and respect
`for the hard work that they do every day.
`
`(END VIDEO CLIP)
`
`BOUDREAU: Burger King also says it will work in the Coalition of Immokalee Workers to improve labor
`conditions.
`
`When we were in Florida, police showed us how some of the workers lived in these primitive migrant
`camps. We've learned at least seven investigations into slavery are undewvay right now.
`
`KEILAR: Wow. And one penny a pound. I mean that's just -- it's amazing to even think about it.
`
`McNeil 000399
`
`

`
`CNN's Abbie Boudreau -- you're with our Special Investigations Unit.
`
`Thanks for that.
`
`BOUDREAU: Thank you.
`
`KEILAR: Don.
`
`LEMON: Well, check this out. There it is. That's a teacher and he's giving a student the smackdown. The
`video, next.
`
`(COMMERCIAL BREAK) LEMON: OK. Now it's time for Caught on Camera. And this one was caught on
`a cell phone camera. That's a Florida middle school teacher giving a 14-year-old student the old
`classroom smackdown. The teacher resigned after the video came out, though. He says it was playful
`wrestling that went just too far. The principal calls it inappropriate. The 14-year-oId's family doesn't want
`to prosecute. He says itjust went a little bit too far.
`
`Time now to check in with CNN's Wolf Blitzer.
`
`KEILAR: He is standing in "THE SITUATION ROOM" to tell us what's coming up at the top of the hour --
`Wolf.
`
`WOLF BLITZER, CNN ANCHOR: It did go a little bit too far.
`
`KEILAR: Yes.
`
`BLITZER: All right, guys.
`
`Thanks very much.
`
`Coming up, the former John McCain supporter, the pastor, John Hagee, he makes a public statement, as
`we just saw, about the news media, the candidate and what he wants to happen next. We're following
`through on this story.
`
`And John McCain's medical records released. Our own Dr. Sanjay Gupta pored through hundreds of
`pages and he learned some new details about the candidate's health. We're going to have complete
`coverage coming up.
`
`Also, it's a weapon and a video recorder. Some officers hope it will help sort out exactly what happens
`during police shootings. We're going to demonstrate exactly how this new technology works.
`
`All that, guys, and a lot more coming up right here in "THE SITUATION ROOM."
`
`KEILAR: Thanks, Wolf.
`
`LEMON: Thanks, Wolf.
`
`KEILAR: And when we come back, we're going to chat with Susan Lisovicz. She's all that and a bag of
`chips.
`
`But how much are those chips, anyway, in this era of rising prices?
`
`(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
`
`KEILAR: Let's head to Wall Street now and Susan Lisovicz.
`
`McNeil 000400
`
`

`
`SUSAN LISOVICZ, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Hey, Brianna.
`
`Well, the barbecue index is something that's very upsetting.
`
`(STOCK MARKET REPORT)
`
`LISOVICZ: I'll see you guys next week. Have a great long holiday weekend.
`
`LEMON: You enjoy, Susan. Have a fantastic time, whatever you do.
`
`KEILAR: And let's head now to "THE SITUATION ROOM" --
`
`LEMON: -- and Mr. Wolf Blitzer.
`
`Take it away, Wolf.
`
`Content and programming copyright 2008 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
`Prepared by Voxant, Inc. ( www.voxant.com) No license is granted to the user of this material other than
`for research. User may not reproduce or redistribute the material except for user's personal or internal
`use and, in such case, only one copy may be printed, nor shall user use any material for commercial
`purposes or in any fashion that may infringe upon Cable News Network LP, LLLP's copyright or other
`proprietary rights or interests in the material; provided, however, that members of the news media may
`redistribute limited portions (less than 250 words) of this material without a specific license from CNN so
`long as they provide conspicuous attribution to CNN as the originator and copyright holder of such
`material. This is not a legal transcript for purposes of litigation.
`
`
`Paso Robles Press Online (Paso Robles, CA)
`Allergy season in full bloom
`May 22, 2008
`By Julia Bluff
`
`Those who are suffering from an itchy and scratchy throat, watering eyes and frequent sneezing can take
`comfort in the fact they are not alone — it is allergy season on the Central Coast.
`
`According to Templeton-based allergist and immunologist Dr. Shields Abernathy, allergies tend to peak
`from the end of February through early July while the blooming period is in full swing. Tiny grains of
`pollen, especially from oak trees and grasses, are currently drifting in the air, wreaking havoc on those
`who are genetically predisposed to allergies.
`
`“An allergic person is just the opposite of an AIDS patient in that an allergic person has too good of an
`immune system," he said. “When foreignness, like oak pollen or mite material settles in our nose or our
`lungs, we all go to destroy it so it won't destroy us. Allergics destroy it so forcefully because of a genetic
`coding, that not only do they destroy it like normal, but the attack spills over and they hurt themselves."
`
`The immune overreaction leaves the sufferer with a runny nose and a stopped up nasal passage,
`sneezing, itchy and watering eyes and an itchy throat. In addition, some people experience tightness in
`the chest, wheezing and shortness of breath. These symptoms are often mistaken by the allergy sufferer
`as a common cold and are subsequently ignored in hopes that they will go away on their own, Abernathy
`said.
`
`“The way you differentiate is that a cold will last seven days and then stop, whereas allergies will continue
`on," he said.
`
`McNeil 000401
`
`

`
`Additionally, many who have long suffered with allergies tend to forego treatment options in favor of
`toughing out the symptoms. Many patients go through what Abernathy refers to as “denial, minimization
`and accommodation.” The patient in denial refuses to believe that they even have allergies; the minimizer
`pretends that allergies aren‘t a big problem and the accommodator insists that they have had the
`symptoms so long that they have gotten used to them, he said.
`
`Allergies are incredibly common —— as many as one in five Americans suffer from them. Though allergies
`are rarely life threatening, they do have some very real consequences, Abernathy said.
`
`“There are plenty of studies that show that whereas allergies aren't life taking per se, they do cut down on
`somebody’s quality of life not being as effective at his or her work or school," he said. “So it is a big cost
`economically there.”
`
`Severe allergies lead to a number of direct complications, Abernathy said. Allergy sufferers may develop
`“Allergic Tension Fatigue Syndrome“ due to fighting the allergies all the time and literally lack of sleep.
`This makes students not perform at their maximum academically, athletically, or socially and places
`adults operating any heavy machinery or getting behind the wheel of a car into a risky situation. In
`addition, allergies may lead to life threatening complications as sinusitis, asthma, and frank anaphylaxis
`or an acute allergic reaction.
`
`Still, it is the annoyance of constant allergy symptoms that has most allergics concerned.
`
`“A non-allergic person just doesn't understand how totally affecting in bad way allergies can be to a
`person," Abernathy said.
`
`But there are a variety of very effective treatment options that cut down on the needless suffering
`resultant of allergies. The cornerstone of the al|ergic’s defense against airborne irritations is avoidance,
`Abernathy said. He recommends that those who have allergies try to stay indoors except in the early
`morning hours, after the dew has settled allergens in the air and before the wind has kicked them up
`again.
`
`‘‘If you stop that overactive immune system in the first place, then you would never have the inflammation
`engendered,” he said. “But you can’t live in a plastic bubble, so it never can be done perfectly enough."
`
`There are a number of over-the-counter medicines that are available to relieve those who are allergic to
`the symptoms that they suffer. Non—sedating anti-histamines, such as Claritin and Zyrtec, can be helpful
`for those over the age of 12. Sudafed, which can be purchased over the counter with a patient signature,
`can aid sufferers, provided they do not have any history of high blood pressure or heart disease. If
`symptoms don't improve with over-the-counter-remedies, patients should consult their doctor for more
`prescription medication options, Abernathy said.
`
`Still, for one out of four allergy patients, medication may not be enough. If the symptoms do not improve
`or the problem is chronic — meaning that a patient suffers from allergies more of the year than less —
`Abernathy suggests allergy shots.
`
`“By giving you gradationally larger amounts of what you are allergic to, we teach your body that it is a
`friend, not a foe, so you don't mount as aggressive of an attack or the attack cuts down to normalcy," he
`said.
`
`Eighty percent of those who undergo allergy shots get a positive response in terms of the severity of their
`symptoms.
`
`‘‘It is remarkable how many of that 80 percent say it is one of the best things they have ever done for
`themselves or their children,” Abernathy said.
`
`Allergy sufferers are advised to consult a doctor before beginning any treatments.
`
`McNeil 000402
`
`

`
`
`
`News10.net (ABC; Sacramento, CA)
`Allergy Sufferers Pay the Price
`May 21, 2008
`By Karen Massie
`
`A few people were out in the Rose Garden at Sacramento's McKinley Park Wednesday. The blustery
`wind kept many people inside because they suffer from allergies.
`
`Allergist Dr. Stephen Nagy knows the swirling wind will stir up pollen and spell agony for his patients.
`
`"|'|| probably hear from them tomorrow and Friday," Nagy said. "They're going to have a lot of symptoms,
`eye itching, runny nose, especially some cough and wheezing."
`
`Some of his patients get allergy shots for long term relief. But not everyone can afford them.
`
`"The insurance co-pays will range anywhere from $5 to $15 for a shot. We ask patients to stick with them
`for at least year to see how they'll do. And usually that means one shot a week for 52 weeks," Nagy said.
`
`Allergy shots are tailor-made for each patient. They also have to pay for the antigen in the injection which
`is a combination of pollens and other things to which they're allergic.
`
`"The antigen charge is $200 to $600 per year. Based on your insurance, the cost may be 50 percent,"
`Nagy said.
`
`The cost forces many people to turn to over—the-counter (OTC) medications. If they want to use Zyrtec,
`one of the antihistamines on the market, they have to be prepared to pay.
`
`"For the brand-name Zyrtec, the cost is about 80 cents a pill. The generic version cost about 50 cents a
`pill," Nagy said.
`
`Zyrtec at a one local pharmacy sells for $23 for 30 pills. The dosage is one pill a day.
`
`"That leaves patients trying to control allergy symptoms with other less expensive OTC medicines," Nagy
`said. "We also tell patients to avoid what is that they're allergic to. Keep the house closed up and drive
`around with the windows up."
`
`Nagy pointed out avoiding allergens also comes at a cost. Allergy sufferers will have to either pay more
`for rising gas prices if they drive around with the air condition on and their windows closed or they'll have
`to pay for higher electricity bills to keep their homes cool.
`
`
`Globe Gazette Online (IA)
`Weather swings bring on allergies
`May 20, 2008
`By Kristin Buehner
`
`MASON CITY — Allergy season in Iowa is coming on strong, thanks to big swings in the weather this
`spring, experts say.
`
`Dr. James Oggel of Sioux City Allergy and Asthma says spring can be pretty intense for allergy sufferers,
`especially with a wild swing in temperatures —— 80 degrees one day, 40 degrees the next.
`
`He also says windy weather makes people miserable because the wind carries pollen farther.
`
`McNeil 000403
`
`

`
`Dr. Tim Dettmer, allergist at Mercy Medical Center-North lowa, said tree pollen count is high and grasses
`and molds are a big problem, too.
`
`“We've had a lot of people come in over the last couple weeks,” he said. ‘‘It’s really picking up, in
`correlation to changes in the weather.”
`
`Tree pollination occurs primarily in April and May, with grass pollen and mold high from spring through
`fall.
`
`Ragweed becomes a problem in the fall — August and September, Dettmer said.
`
`Allergy sufferers should be tested to determine what they are allergic to “so they know what to avoid
`and/or take medications for," he said.
`
`Medications range from allergy shots, which are the most effective alernative for people with severe
`allergies, to oral medications, such as Zyrtec or Claritin-D, over-the-counter medications.
`
`Another newer option is drops that go under the tongue.
`
`Dr. Alan Li, resident with Mercy's Family Practice Residency Program, also advises patients to wash out
`their nostrils with a saline solution whenever they come in from outdoors.
`
`To reduce exposure to pollen, it is important to keep house windows closed, especially in the early-
`morning hours, limit outdoor activities and be cons

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket