throbber
TTAB
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`Opposer
`
`V.
`
`Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
`
`Applicant
`
`\/x4‘/\/\/\/\-’\z¢
`
`Mark: THE ARCHITECTURE OF
`
`SAFETY EXCELLENCE
`
`Ser. No.
`
`78/217042
`
`Opposition No. 91172334
`
`OPPOSERS RESPONSE TO APPLICANT’S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT FOR
`
`FAILURE TO TAKE TESTIMONY AND OFFER EVIDENCE
`
`Opposer, L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc. hereby responds to Applicant’s (Liberty Mutual
`
`Insurance Company) April 15, 2008 Motion for Judgment for Failure to Take Testimony
`
`and Offer Evidence as follows:
`
`1. Opposer contends that Applicant’s April 15, 2008 Motion to Dismiss is premature
`
`and irrelevant as Opposer in fact completed development and preparation of
`
`documentary evidence within its allocated time frame, and submitted same (attached)
`
`to Applicant and the USPTO TTAB on April 18, 2008, well within the 30-day time
`
`limit specified by Trademark Rule 2.125
`
`2. WHEREFORE, due to the circumstances and proper timing cited, and for the
`
`foregoing reasons, Opposer respectfully requests that the Board accept Opposer’s
`
`documentary evidence as timely, deny Applicant’s motion, and allow the proceedings
`
`to continue.
`
`Illllllllllllllllllllllllllllllillllllllllllllllll
`
`04-22-2008
`
`U.S. Patent &TM0lcITM Mail Rcpl D1. #934
`
`

`
`Dated: April 18, 2008
`
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`11 High Banks Drive
`Fulton, New York 13069
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`Lawrence L. Hansen, CSP, ARM President
`
`n/m%w
`
`

`
`PROOF OF SERVICE STATEMENT
`
`I hereby declare that the attached Opposer’s Response to Applicant’s Motion for
`Judgment for Failure to Take Testimony and Offer Evidence was served on Applicant at
`the address below by U. S. First Class Mail on this 18th day of April 2008.
`
`John C. Filosa
`
`Paula J. Krasny
`Baker & McKenzie
`
`130 East Randolph Drive
`One Prudential Plaza
`
`Chicago, ILL 60601
`
`By Lawrence L. Hansen, President
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`/wflw /
`
`Date: April 18, 2008
`
`

`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`Opposer
`
`V.
`
`Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
`
`Applicant
`
`\—/\/\’\./\./\/¥’\./\/
`
`Mark: THE ARCHITECTURE OF
`
`SAFETY EXCELLENCE
`
`Ser. No.
`
`78/217042
`
`Opposition No. 91 172334
`
`OPPOSERS SUBMITTAL OF TESTIMONY
`
`Pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and 37 C. F. R. Part 2 Rules of Practice in
`
`Trademark Cases, Opposer, L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc. hereby submits the following
`
`Testimony and Notices of Reliance on matters of evidence establishing Opposer’s First
`
`Use’ and ‘First Use in Commerce’ of the mark ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’, evidence confirming ’Confusion in a Shared Marketplace’, and
`
`evidence that Applicant’s mark fails to meet ‘Criteria for Trademark’ to Applicant,
`
`Liberty Mutual Insurance Company.
`
`TESTIMONY
`
`Opposer offers the following testimony from individuals in professional capacity, and
`
`evidences in form of Notices of Reliance establishing Opposer’s ‘First Use’ and ‘First
`
`Use in Commerce’ of the mark ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’
`
`as early as May 25, 1994, prior to Applicant’s claimed ‘First Use’ in April, 00,2002 as
`
`originally filed, and subsequently as amended to June 23, 1999, evidence confirming
`
`confusion in a shared marketplace, and evidence establishing that Applicant’s use of the
`
`

`
`mark in support of its insurance operations fails to satisfy the ‘Criteria for Trademark’ set
`
`forth in USPTO Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP) Sections 1301.01,
`
`l30l.O1(a), and 1301.01(a)(ii).
`
`EVIDENCE OF OPPOSER’S FIRST USE
`
`EXHIBIT #1 AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID S. THELEN, Executive Director (retired) of
`
`The Minerva Education Institute (TMEI) and Minerva International, Inc., confirming
`
`Opposer’s use of the phrase ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ in a
`
`presentation at a national safety conference hosted by the Minerva International, Inc.
`
`organization in Scottsdale Arizona in May (25 -27) 1994.
`
`EXHIBIT #2 AFFIDAVIT OF WAYNE L. SALEN - Corporate Director of Risk
`
`Management for Labor Finders International, Inc., confirming use of the phrase ‘THE
`
`ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ in a presentation to the Upstate New
`
`York Chapter of the Risk and Insurance Management Society (RIMS) in Canandaigua,
`
`New York in March, 1995.
`
`EXHIBIT #3 AFFIDAVIT OF DONALD J. ECKENFELDER — Principal of Social
`
`Operating Systems Ltd., confirming use of the phrase ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF
`
`SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ in a shared presentation to the ASSE Central New York
`
`Safety Conference in Syracuse, New York in April 1995.
`
`EXHIBIT #4 AFFIDAVIT OF HAL D. LARSON — President of the Quad Cities
`
`Chapter of the Risk and Insurance Management Society, confirming a presentation on
`
`

`
`‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ to Chapter membership in
`
`February 1999.
`
`EXHIBIT #5 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to Opposer’s ‘Date of First
`
`Use’).
`
`Copy of executed Copyright Agreement between Opposer, Larry L. Hansen and Susan
`
`Trebswetter, Editor of Professional Safety magazine, DATED JUNE 9,1999 accepting
`
`publication of a manuscript exactly titled: “THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’, prior to Applicant’s claimed ‘first use’ date(s) of April 00,2002 and
`
`June 23, 1999.
`
`EVIDENCES OF CONFUSION IN A SHARED MARKETPLACE
`
`EXHIBIT #6 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to ‘Likelihood of
`
`Confusion in a Shared Market’).
`
`Copy of pages #1, # 14, and #26, through #30 from the USPTO Lesis - Nexis Search &
`
`Evidence List 78217042 conducted on April 17, 2004 and on record in this USPTO file
`
`identifying (twice) Opposer’s titled work ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’.
`
`EXHIBIT #7 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to ‘Likelihood of
`
`Confusion in a Shared Market’).
`
`

`
`Copy of ‘Page 1’ of a GOOGLE web browser search of the phrase ‘ARCHITECTURE
`
`OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ conducted on March 23, 2008 identifying Opposer’s
`
`predominant marketplace association with this mark.
`
`EXHIBIT #8 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to ‘Likelihood of
`
`Confusion in a Shared Market’).
`
`Copy of the 2007 Best Practice Literature Search findings conducted by the United States
`
`Office of Inspector General (OIG) under directive from the Secretary of Defense, U.S.
`
`Department of Defense (DoD), published by the National Safety Council citing the L2H
`
`Speaking of Safety, Inc. ‘ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ safety
`
`management system.
`
`EXHIBIT #9 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to ‘Likelihood of
`
`Confusion in a Shared Market’).
`
`Copy of a May 2000 Spanish translation of Opposer’s work: ‘ARQUITECTURA DE
`
`LA EXCELENCIA EN SEGURIDAD’ (THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE) from a reader in the country of Columbia establishing Opposer’s
`
`international recognition and association with this mark.
`
`EXHIBIT #10 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to ‘Likelihood of
`
`Confusion in a Shared Market’).
`
`Copy of Australia’s Safe At Work (SAW) magazine article entitled: ‘The Real
`
`Drivers of Safety’ citing Opposer’s work ‘THE ARCHICETURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’ establishing Opposer’s international recognition and association
`
`

`
`with the mark.
`
`EVIDENCE OF OPPOSER’S ‘FIRST USE IN COMMERCE’
`
`EXHIBIT # 11 AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL D. ALBEE, Systems Engineer and Partner of
`
`ATServices of Central New York, Inc. web site developer and Webmaster of the L2H
`
`Speaking of Safety, Inc. web site confirming development, launch and continuous
`
`oversight of the L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc. web site offering ‘ For Fee’ Organizational
`
`Learning Services including seminars entitled ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’, in October 2001, six months prior to Applicant’s originally filed (April
`
`2002) application and Specimen confirming use as a Loss Prevention service in support
`
`of its commercial insurance operations, and 5 years prior to Appli.cant’s ‘For Fee’ sale of
`
`such services under the name of Liberty Mutual Safety Solutions created in November
`
`2006.
`
`EXHIBIT # 12 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to Opposer’s ‘First Use
`
`in Commerce’)
`
`Copy of a ‘Technical Data Screen Grab’ from the L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc. web site
`
`establishing the October 2001 launch and continuous sale of ‘For Fee’ services entitled:
`
`‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’.
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT # 13 NOTICE OF RELIANCE (Evidence relevant to Opposer’s ‘First Use
`
`in Commerce’).
`
`Copy of the Liberty Mutual web site page entitled: ‘Liberty in the News’ posted
`
`November 2, 2006 announcing creation of Liberty Mutual Safety Solutions, a ‘For Fee’
`
`consulting unit to market safety services identified as ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF
`
`SAFETY EXCELLENCE’, five years after ‘ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE’ services were marketed by Opposer on its L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`web site in October 2001.
`
`EVIDENCES OF APPLICANT’S MARK FAILING TO MEET CRITERIA FOR
`
`TRADEMARK
`
`EXHIBIT # 14 NOTICE OF RELIANCE - (Evidence relevant to Applicant’s mark
`
`failing to meet ‘Criteria for Trademark’)
`
`Copy of Applicant’s October 2004 brochure entitled ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF
`
`SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ containing (back page) disclaimer identifying this material as
`
`‘advertising for its insurance operations’, and specifically directing readers to the ‘Terms
`
`and Conditions’ of their insurance contract as follows:
`
`“This brochure isfor marketing purposes only and is not a contract. It provides
`
`a general description of these programs. Only your policy or contract can give
`
`actual terms, conditions and exclusions. ”
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT # 15A & 15B NOTICES OF RELIANCE — (Evidences relevant to
`
`Applicant’s mark failing to meet ‘Criteria for Trademark)
`
`EXHIBIT 15A - Copy of published article:
`
`“Insurers' Potential Liability to Third Parties for Negligent Inspections”
`
`© Thomas M. Bower 1994
`
`EXHIBIT 15B - Copy of published article:
`“Inspection by Insurer is Valuable but Doesn't Constitute a Warranty”
`
`Rough Notes, Jan 2003 by McCormick Roy C
`
`Articles summarizing ‘Negligent Inspection Case Law’, and identifying the rational for
`
`and common practice of Commercial Insurance Carriers protecting themselves against
`
`Negligent Inspection lawsuits through inclusion of ‘disclaimer clauses’ (Applicant’s
`
`cited below) in Insurance Policy Declarations specifically identifying Loss Prevention
`
`services provided under their insurance contracts as activities undertaken primarily for
`
`the benefit of the insurer,_(i.e., underwriting standards, risk selection, and pricing
`
`decisions, etc.).
`
`APPLICANT ’S WORKERS COMPENSA TION POLICY CLA USE
`
`TERMS AND CONDITIONS
`
`Part Six — Conditions
`
`A. Inspection
`We have the right, but are not obliged to inspect your workplaces at any time.
`Our inspections are not safety inspections. They relate only to the insurability of
`the workplaces and the premiums to be charged. We may give you reports on the
`conditions we find We may also recommend changes. While they may help reduce
`losses, we do not undertake to perform the duty ofany person to provide for the
`health or safety ofyour employees or the public. We do not warrant that your
`workplaces are safe, healthful or that they comply with laws, regulations, codes
`or standards. Insurance rate service organizations have the same rights we have
`under this provision.
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT # 16 NOTICE OF RELIANCE - (Evidenced relevant to Applicant’s mark
`
`failing to meet ‘Criteria for Trademark’).
`
`Copies of pages from the USPTO Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP)
`
`citing Section 1301.01 — ‘What is a Service’; Section 1301 .0l(a) — ‘Criteria for
`
`Determining What Constitutes a Service’; and Section 1301 .0l(a)(ii) — ‘For the Benefit
`
`of Others’.
`
`These sections establish that a service to qualify for trademark must be a service designed
`
`primarily for the benefit of others, and not a service that provides benefit primarily for the
`
`benefit of applicant offering the service.
`
`In that Applicant’s ‘ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ services are
`
`advertised and claimed as Loss Prevention services in support of its commercial
`
`insurance operations, and specifically provided for the primary benefit of the Applicant’s
`
`(insurer’s) own self-interest, they fail to meet the Criteria for Trademark established
`
`under USPTO sections cited above.
`
`SUMMARY
`
`Given to the above, Opposer affirms its claim of intellectual property rights, and
`
`entitlement to the mark ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXCELLENCE’ by
`
`evidence of its ‘First Use’ of the mark as early as May 1994, in advance of Applicant’s
`
`claimed first use on June 23, 1999; Opposer’s ‘First Use in Commerce’ in October, 2001,
`
`five years prior to Applicant’s offering a non-insurance ‘For Fee’ service under the name
`
`of Liberty Mutual Safety Solutions in November 2006; also due to confirmed confusion
`
`

`
`in the marketplace created by exact same wording of the marks, and further to
`
`App1icant’s mark failing to meet the ‘Criteria of Trademark’ requirement of ‘For the
`
`Primary Benefit of Others’ due to its ‘non-qualifying’ use as an insurance Loss
`
`Prevention service conducted primarily for the benefit of its own commercial insurance
`
`interests, thereby failing to satisfy the requirements established under ‘Criteria for
`
`Trademark’ Sections 1301.01, 1301.01(a), and l301.01(a)(ii) of the Trademark Manual
`
`of Examining Procedure (TMEP).
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`,,§&,4g_.~__\
`
`Lawrence L. Hansen, CSP, ARM President
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`Date: April 18, 2008
`
`

`
`PROOF OF SERVICE STATEMENT
`
`I hereby declare that the attached Opposer’s Submittal of Testimony to Applicant was
`served on Applicant at the address below by U. S. first Class Mail on this 18th day of
`April, 2008.
`
`John C. Filosa
`
`Baker & McKenzie
`
`130 East Randolph Drive
`One Prudential Plaza
`
`Chicago, ILL 60601
`
`By Lawrence L. Hansen, President
`
`L2H Speaking of Safety, Inc.
`
`Date: 1 ’”/J/-"d f
`
`

`
`Exhibit #1
`
`/«"7 /Uc/éy
`State of
`County of fig £49
`
`AFFIDAVIT BEFORE NOTARY
`
`BEFORE
`
`, the undersi
`‘
`
`d ota
`
`this
`affidavit is sworn],
`[month], 20 personally appeared
`[name of affiant], known to me
`'
`to be a credible person and of lawful age, who being by me first duly sworn, on é /5
`[his or
`her] oath, deposes and says:
`
`[name f Notary before whom
`ay of month] day of
`
`My name is David Thelen and I currently reside at 9 Geisen Avenue, Lakeside Park, Kentucky
`41017.
`
`I am the Executive Director (retired), of The Minerva Educational Institute (TMEI), domiciled within the
`Xavier University School of Business, and its successor organization Minerva International, Inc. Both of
`these organizations were chartered with the mission of introducing safety and health education into our
`nation’s business schools and executive suites to ‘sensitize’ business leaders concerning the value
`contribution of safety and health to American management process and business results.
`
`In 1993 as Director of TMEI, I invited Mr. Larry Hansen to join the Board of Directors of the Minerva
`Education Institute due to his perspectives and writings on safety management in the business process. Mr.
`Hansen's employer (Wausau Insurance Co.) was contacted concerning TMEI sponsorship, and confirmed
`no interest in supporting the Institute, due to other existing sponsorships. Mr. Hansen independently
`accepted the appointment and served on the TMEI Board of Directors from 1994 until the lnstitute's
`dissolution in 1997.
`
`In May (25 — 27) of 1994, Minerva International sponsored a national EHS conference entitled: “Managing
`the Work Environment in the 21*‘ Century” at the Wyndham Paradise Conference Center in Scottsdale,
`Arizona. This conference was attended by over 200 representatives of Industry and Academia. At this
`conference, Mr. Hansen gave a keynote presentation introducing the ‘Architecture of Safety Excellence’ a
`strategic step-change model developed by him identifying and linking the multiple strategies that lead an
`organization to safety excellence perfonnance.
`
`[set forth affiant's statement of facts]
`
`/<
`
`[signature of affiant]
`CDMg/ J‘. fleet:
`[typed name of affiant]
`E £6/keg Eu 1;
`[address of affiant, line 1]
`
`«[3 games Pg flkag
`
`[address of affiant, line 2]
`
`fig/2
`
`

`
`Subscribed and sworn to before me, this 2 4+“
`[month], 20 02 .
`
`[day of month] day of
`
`‘V\Ok‘FC‘.\(\
`
`K‘ [Notary SeaI:]‘
`
`[signature ofEtaryj
`A “
`[typed n
`e of Notary]
`
`NOTARY PUBLIC
`
`/L..\\"\’
`
`My commission expires:
`
`\s0~\r\. 2-3 , 20 \Z
`
`

`
`Exhibit #2
`
`State of Florida
`
`County of Palm Beach
`
`AFFIDAVIT BEFORE NOTARY
`
`BEFORE ME, the undersigned Notary,
`/
`.
`'
`[name of Notary before whom
`affidaviti sworn], on this
`1
`[day of month] day of /77422 5
`[month], 20 Q1 , personally appeared édgag 4 . Qka
`le person and of lawful age, who being by me first
`[name of affiant], known to me to be a credi
`duly sworn, on 4 [g
`[his or her] oath, deposes and says:
`
`My name is Wayne Salen, and I am currently the Corporate Director of Risk Management
`for Labor Finders International, Inc. a staffing services firm headquartered at 11426 North
`Jog Road, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33418. Prior to my relocation to Florida, I lived in
`Western New York and held positions as Corporate Risk Manager for a food distribution
`company, Director of Risk Management for a multi-state Nursing Home organization, and
`as Risk & Insurance Manager for the County of Niagara. Due to my interests and
`background in both safety and risk management, I also was an active member and officer
`of the Upstate New York Chapter of the Risk and Insurance Management Society, Inc.
`(RIMS). One of my duties as a Chapter Officer was to arrange for speakers on material
`relevant to our membership. Due to Larry Hansen’s writings in Professional Safety
`magazine, I invited him to speak on safety management at our March 1995 Chapter
`meeting held the third Tuesday of that month at the Quality Inn in Canandaigua, New York.
`This meeting was attended by 40+I- Risk, Insurance and Safety managers representing
`companies located in the Western & Central New York area. Mr. Hansen gave a
`presentation on a step-change safety management model he had developed called the
`‘Architecture of Safety Excellence’. This session helped participant’s recognize the
`multiple operational and organizational strategies that must be employed for an
`organi
`‘on to move from the SWAMP (Safety Without Any Management Process) up to
`Wor
`-Clas
`(Safety as
`value system) to achieve peak performance.
`{ a ant 's stat ment offacts
`
`
`
`Wayne L. Salen
`405 SW Sa inaw Avenue Port St. Lucie Florida 34953
`
`Subscribe? and sworn to before me, this
`
`[month], 202,2.
`
`[day ofmonth]day of
`
`[Nota
`
`SeaI:]
`
`
`Z2
`1
`
`eof Notary]
`
`[typedn
`
`NOTARY PUBLIC
`
`My commission expires:
`
`[/22
`
`, 20 (2 .
`
`:
`
`I
`
`MARILYN L. WILSON

`¢.....‘-.;.,,,,’
`Commit 000503715

`g
`E §“§'$ I’
`Expires 1/3/2010
`"'3
` ’?om ~
`3 "
`Bonded l\ru(B00)432-42545
`Inc 3
`.
`a....”.':-:-:-:‘:‘.“..... .fJ.°.':?:*.:t?:e:x:§§:a......:
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT“
`
`AFFIDAVIT BEFORE NOTARY
`
`State of New York
`
`County of Warren
`
`BEFORE ME, the undersigned Notary, Mary E. West, on this 12th day of March, 2008, personally
`appeared Donald J. Eckenfelder, known to me to be a credible person and of lawful age, who being by
`me first duly sworn, on his oath, deposes and says:
`
`I am the principal of Social Operating Systems Ltd., an international
`My name is Donald J. Eckenfelder.
`culture measurement and management firm located at Post Office Box 499, Glens Falls, New York
`12801.
`
`I am also the principal of Profit Protection Consultants, a safety and health consulting company. While
`pursuing this practice, I had numerous experiences that caused me recognize the power that an
`organization's culture (beliefs and values) had on shaping its operational outcomes called accidents,
`injuries and loss costs. Due to articles I had written on culture and its impact on safety, Larry Hansen,
`asked if I would speak with him at an American Society of Safety Engineers Professional Development
`Conference at the Drumlins Country Club in Syracuse, New York in April of 1995. Approximately 200
`Safety and Operations managers in the Central New York area attended this conference.
`
`Mr. Hansen and I provided a two-part presentation at this conference. Mr. Hansen opened with a
`presentation on a step-change safety management model he had developed called the ‘Architecture of
`Safety Excellence’ that identified the multiple strategies an organization needed to develop and employ to
`move safety out of the SWAMP (Safety Without Any Management Process) through the NORM (Naturally
`Occurring Reactionary Management) in which safety is a program comprised of operational strategies
`(Education, Engineering and Enforcement) to World-Class wherein safety becomes a ‘belief system
`based on Values, Leadership and Organization’.
`I followed Mr. Hansen's presentation with a
`complimentary session identifying how an organization’s value system forges its culture which either
`empowers or compromises its safety performance and loss outcomes.
`
`From this initial meeting to present, our philosophies on safety excellence and organizational culture have
`evolved in very complimentary ways. When Mr. Hansen further evolved his ‘Architecture of Safety
`Excellence’ concept in a Professional Safety magazine article of the same name, I requested his
`permission to display that concept in a model I have labeled as ‘The Bridge Metaphor’. This model
`equates the process and key components of Bridge Construction to that of Building a solid Culture for
`Safety
`-- a = ed of both the Operational strategies and Organizational strategies of safety.
`
`
`
` P.O. Box 49
`
`
`lens F
`s, New York 12801 or 24 Fort Amherst Road, Queensbury, New York, 12804
`
`Subscribed and sworn to before me, this 12"‘ day of March 2008.
`
`Mary E.
`est
`NOTARY PUBLIC .
`
`"i ‘:37.-*4“-§~
`
`T’
`
`My commission expires:
`
`9
`
`, zofl.
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT #4
`
`State of Iowa
`County of Muscatine
`
`AFFIDAVIT BEFORE NOTARY
`
`O/Luri 5 6 WW "'
`BEFORE ME, the undersigned Notary,
`[day of month] day of
`[name of Notary before whom affidavit is sworn], on this
`I39‘
`Iflarcg
`[month], 20 03 , personally appeared Hal D. Larson [name of affianfl, known to me
`to be a credible person and of lawful age, who being by me first duly sworn, on b :5
`[his or her] oath,
`deposes and says:
`
`My name is Hal D. Larson, and I am the wee President, Corporate Risk Manager for Muswtine Foods, Inc.
`headquartered at 1600 Oregon Street, Muscatine, Iowa 52761.
`
`As a compliment to my employer responsibilities, I am active in and have held all offices, including President
`of the Quad Cities Chapter of the Risk and Insurance Management Society (RIMS).
`
`One of the duties of a Chapter Officer is to anange for speakers on material perceived valuable to our membership.
`Due to Larry Hanscn’s expertise on safety management, I invited him to speak on his ‘Architecture of Safety
`Excellence’ step-change strategy model at our February 1999 Quad Cities Chapter meeting Thirty plus Risk and
`Insurance professionals attended this dinner meeting from organizations in the Quad Cities area This session
`addressed the multiple operational and organizational strategies that must be employed for an organization to impact
`organizational behavior and achieve safety excellence results.
`[setforth aflianfs statement offacts]
`
`Z4L%
`
`[signature of afliant]
`
`Hal D. Larson, CPCU
`[typed name of affiant]
`
`1600 Oregon Street
`Muscatine, Iowa 52761
`
`lat“
`
`[day of month] day of
`
`mg 5
`WC,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.
`Subscribed and sworn to before me, this
`[month], 20 oi .
`
`”‘’°’a’Y 393*]
`
`CHRIS BROW.”
`‘g\AL 6;‘
`COMMISSION NO. mes?

`7.
`MY COMMISSION EXPIRES
`"
`‘
`
`IowA
`_|u|_v 3 300%’
`
`
`&/\/OL~"'V\—/
`
`[signature of Notary]
`
`BVDLQ ”\
`H ri
`[typed name of Notary]
`
`NOTARY PUBLIC
`
`My commission expires:
`
`.7 [ 3
`
`, 20 0 8.
`
`

`
`NOTICE OF RELIANCE
`
`ISSUE OF RELEVANCE: Evidence establishing Opposer’s ‘First Use’ of the mark
`
`‘ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY EXC3ELLENCE’ as early as June 9, 1999 prior to
`
`Applicant’s claimed/filed ‘First Use’ date of June 23, 1999.
`
`EXHIBITS # 5 -See attached copy of executed copyright agreement
`
`between Opposer, Larry L. Hansen, and Susan Trebswetter, Editor of Professional
`
`Safety Magazine — Journal of the American Society of Safety Engineers, dated June 9,
`
`1999 accepting for publication a manuscript titled ‘THE ARCHITECTURE OF SAFETY
`
`EXCELLENCE submitted four months earlier for peer review.
`
`This document establishes Opposer’s use of the mark ‘THE ARCHITECTURE
`
`OF SAFETY EXCELENCE’ prior to and on June 9,1999 prior to Applicant's
`
`claimed/filed ‘First Use’ date(s) of April 00, 2002 and June 23, 1999.
`
`

`
`TRANSFER OF COPYRIGHT AGREEMENT
`
`Periodical: Professional Safety ('P.S.'). Official Publication of the
`American Society of Safety Engineers (‘ASSE’)
`
`1/
`
`’
`
`of Article:
`
`.
`Working Title
`.
`Author(s).
`
`'
`
`: ,
`-
`,
`
`L
`’ ‘: C.
`I -
`-
`I442‘ -
`
`4
`
`I F .
`‘” f 1
`
`_
`
`5
`
`y
`
`_ ..‘.’r.__
`
`The undersigned hereby grant(s) and assign(s) exclusively to ASSE all rights of whatsoever kind or nature
`now or hereafter protected by the Copyright Laws of the United States (common or statutory) and all foreign
`countries in all languages in and to the above-named article. including all subsidiary rights. subject to the
`nonexclusive rights reserved by Author(s) in paragraph 2 hereof. Without limiting the generality of the
`foregoing, Author(s) hereby further grant(s) and assign(s) to ASSE the sole and exclusive right to obtain
`registration of the copyright of the article.
`
`The Au.thor(s) reserve(s) the following:
`
`(1) '
`
`(2)
`
`(3)
`
`The nonexclusive right to use all or part of the article in his (her. their) own
`future works. such as lectures. press releases. reviews. text books, or reprint books.
`after the article's first publication in P.S., subject only to his (her. their) giving proper
`credit in such work to the original publication of the article in P.S.
`
`The nonexclusive right to reproduce the work in copies and to grant or refuse
`permission for such reproduction by third parties. subject only to his (her. their)
`causing to be inserted on the first page of each such copy a .p’roper copyright
`notice. consisting of (1) the word ‘Copyright.’ the abbreviation 'Copr..' or the
`copyright symbol (the letter C in a circle). (2) the year of first publication of the work.
`and (3) identification of ASSE as the owner of copyright in the work.
`
`The nonexclusive right to permit third parties to republish all or part of the article.
`after the article's lirst publication in P.S.. subject only to such third parties giving
`proper credit to the original publication of the article in P.S.
`
`The undersigned hereby warrant(s) that the above-named article contains no matter libelous or otherwise
`unlawful or which invades individual privacy or which infringes any proprietary rights. The undersigned
`hereby further warrant(s) that the above-named article is an original work. of which he (she. they) is (are)
`the sole Author(s) and in which he (she. they) is (are) the sole owner of copyright. and that he (she. they)
`has (have) full power to make this assignment.
`
`Author's Signat
`
`Co-author's Signature‘
`
`Date
`
`’
`
`Date
`
`ACCEPTED AND APPROVED:
`
`American Society of Safety Engineers.
`Publisher
`‘
`4
`
`—___—
`/
`4/‘/77 (-
`Date
`
`
`Co-author's Signature‘
`
`By:
`
`‘if applicable
`(This signed statement must be received by the Editor of P.S. before the manuscript can be Published-)
`
`

`
`NM82><E
`
`
`
`Eaewmuwwuwnhmv.e.=.=e85._uw:5EeU
`
`.ww:m£u
`
`
`
`
`
`.:mr:\_m:o_>mr_...5__m:e:S_:mw._eemctoec
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.9n._mz_uzm>h.:<m.._D>550.»Z<UEm=4<
`
`
`
`
`
`auuudemmmew?..=£=u«Emwmcmmr.
`
`
`
`
`
`Hmtwtmmi...v>:umn_w._wn_SE.
`
`.5mmmmmuea3m:2:.bwwmmw=_.$=_w5
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`wu:m.:mwm.u_u_oew.mou_>£uu_Eecem._u.m_m
`
`.w=::§wa&._wc.c8
`
`
`uum:«:UAu>_.n>e::=u>=«u._Uum_u>w.._
`
`..meEw€|.:v:www=uEH599.2.058OD
`
`.?_eE.:wwcmzuwemax.ufintwnzm
`
`
`
`eu:o:ouxubowam=3m.5_umEEu:eh
`
`.:=ewE5.mfimw$22:m=_.$.__w=m
`
`bmwnmrumwEv.:wm:..:uEu_m_n:e:u_u
`
`
`
`ww>u_wfiwimwmu>22,29553E38:
`
`bwmm_mu_m~¢wm«Emw:w._wu:_w:ubuwumwe
`
`
`
`«Emwcwuumswmwmm.ow£:m>un_nu_:§wumE
`
`
`.mw:uEmmommuxmmwu_Ee:em._ou_u=_uc_
`
`
`
`mwdmqsmfim:.uum_...r_..e>>2:Ewifiamzw
`wuofiufivie?.mu_Ee:ew._uiezmfiewsm
`
`
`
`fiwumwuwwcwm:.EumE\:ev_:e>>csowwvie?
`
`
`muzumw:oEEeuQEOm.:w_m%mmmuekw
`.>wr£mBe:V195ecmwmmvm::e.:591e3
`
`
`
`
`
`.93:25:.E:5..E5%..»PF.
`
`
`«Sow:~85wimfiuvun«Enw:§w=:wE
`
`.E_Bw:EwUm=e...:=:eUN_u>u.._
`
`mm.33xium:EwUu>wuv:eU"H_u>u._
`
`
`owcmzuu>_m:o;....:.wEeumm9::_um._=m:emmo._
`
`
`
`we2:.vu.n_uuun...neEw£|.»._:23m>En_
`
`we25:e:.:.:eu..meEu.=|I:9_e.5
`bm>_mmm.nwoRa9:2zudo$56wemwo
`
`
`.a_$2.miss.mE%=smafiaa88
`
`
`.wO9:we.55=m.ou.£_Em2:8:«Ea
`
`
`
`mfluoi£2.BmmufiumEs.wcolxwmfibm
`
`
`
`”w:=mE_m:enEunwe:e.umnwE_Swmflw
`
`
`.33:m5mwwu:m:Eew..wn_bwwmuewnuaw
`
`.e::52.0.322:emwswzwmmwe:32
`
`m.u3m:a_nm.8>_::.8m:o_.=_89.55»26
`
`
`9:.we:m._eucuzmuxwbwwwm...uw..=o:a
`
`
`mwamflweEdhvvmm_une.3nmmouumwumzmnwn
`
`van..m£e:a«Ea:m£e:acan..w2.£.A
`
`
`$5._uuw::uo.e¢e.u_:wu..$32.58a
`
`
`mvmmfivvuwar:o:o.|E=::_w:ou$22:
`aweufieuwzo9:M.8:m=wuxwbuwmm
`
`
`.5_.§§ma:m:E._3Eetmwmm:ecu
`
`
`uznuu:w_muvmwwwfifizmu_.w£:Ewe
`
`
`
`EHEEM.e==§3
`
`ham.3...ma=._.__i3».
`
`Hmwmzuxw:eEEou.ee.y=mmfiem:ebe:
`
`$21.2:=&..._wucmvuceuomm£._..
`
`
`
`m:.uuE«=m:.Su..¢ewn_:ww..mw:w2.,..a
`
`
`Auewzwfimwe_w>ww15:58aw:._w:5wu
`w:_>e:E_:em_mauewwzw..mu:m=n_Eeu
`
`
`fitswucmuueuuaEw:o:Ee:>:umac?
`an.u>e.RwE_E3m:=mm._bowmm322:
`
`
`95U5223.33.wmz=._umw\m:eEu:eu
`
`
`.EoU.m2mu:mE~¢3£:wm._E=Ew:_E
`
`
`ficezuommfibflumwuwuzwuiwuuuu.:9:
`
`
`
`
`.SE9wuufismm_o>u_cozum«EmBEE
`
`
`.w:=wum..E=Ew5Emmw:_u_umE5mEn._me.:w
`
`
`«Em.m:w=e.:.=e=m3.mEu=m3:m=mEeu
`
`
`
`
`.mmw:n:enw_u:amwzww.m:e=
`
`
`.59“..2:m_bwwmfi9:$.335.Ao_u::mw2w:EuEe.E2.:952:8:
`
`vzmEzuuufim:owEmwmumwv.Ew3Em9:Eumomxewmfie£9.03.5505.mmuEN£
`
`
`
`we59:_..m:emuEveow:mm;muanfieewuwm
`
`
`
`
`wmewmvum9:B9wefin..3w:._x:_£fism
`
`mmmm>u:wn:wwmmuueummso>o:wE_3.6:
`.33:0._...=_u_>=uE9:E.we:nlmmwue.&
`
`
`.mmo:u>::ut«:_.mmo:m.u.u_B88.595.
`us.we:e.smu_w:ueEecu:e:m.:m_:wE_uw
`.w=E.:_:9:E.:w._o£:_Eu:uE.$
`
`53.a_.§_ama:<=dmwuusmEuwufimne
`
`
`.we=a:mw:waEw:o=£5EmE:._iwwmmv
`
`
`E...:8mumanummdueaummfiw:.:m:_E:o
`
`
`nmuvw2=82..u.$2.wEmu:8»m.mmawh5flhxu>155.2.
`
`
`
`
`3.:owwcmeuauwm:Ew.o:e_.:Um.:wbuwmm
`Rev.2.2._m>ouwwue.anemonenewvume.
`
`mw:ESw.u=O53>w.cw:§w<wéaumm2.0
`
`E5:e=NN=_>_u_8:_8_:5we22Eat
`
`.uw:amp:Eflwm_u._a>>era2v:<§...s._S
`
`
`.5322:9:3w=mm._._.5..:mwe:mmmmuuusm
`
`
`.u_:...w_$_u:m.:oEEu>em_m_uomweE._ew
`
`32$._><3in20oz2222.?.2.=o_._:wo§
`
`_am.$>..:=m|..><3moz<._.2:we35
`
`
`
`oz...as:ucumtowwu._._m£ammo...P529
`
`
`
`9:.mmn:=aw.35:«Enwwanmv:u=E..Bw<
`
`
`
`>umEEu=u_=__..E
`
`.mu:m=wuxuwrmwmmEats.cenmflriwuo
`
`
`
`
`
`u:O|o5mm_:_.u:N=cm._o;wm._wan.A.5£o:~
`
`25V389mmwm._wwm:mE.332
`
`
`«EmwEu:Bm._mu:=:65:wune.Ewm:E
`
`key:._um2m:w.:ewwmu=—uwit0.muoimcm
`
`
`
`
`dmcmzu2au:2m._m..:.__o£cwwwem
`
`
`=~mw:u_u_uumo>m.._van
`
`
`mwm:e_mmowe.:wbuwmmfioouuame..:e_:Ee
`
`
`
`.A+w~mmwtuwn.wEm:enm_o._ow.o>:_:m_uuE.=w
`
`
`
`
`
`9:w_xwuwmhmwmcenmufiaewBE93.
`
`538:bwwumumwfiuhwm:.EEm2n_buwam
`
`
`
`...==>‘E339:E3:...E353::
`
`
`
`mw:w_u_uumonmw..u3m:mufidewfinwemhefizn«E5....8..._&_a3E:E._=UUO
`
`
`.33:”:owmmwwo.=wbwwmmmiwe:e:mo:wu
`
`
`
`
`.mm5._nE.m>wmuwcrwuew.m:_.$:_m5.m>
`
`
`
`:ewwmu=_uu.mEunwe.:w.m>wu:m=mEcuis
`
`
`m:eteuwm:e:a>u.w.w..:D€NNfi3o&mwfiwe
`
`>E.EEu3.5::5:53;tflfi
`
`
`
`buwmmwewwawuse.e55.mmwmwwhwugh
`
`_uu=_._u..moE9:wmfluvmewmw8:o=uuxu
`
`wcuwxu9:%_§.:%bwaw2m_mF:.e.w_u
`
`.:e_m.muwe.Rww:_u3_Euewwvmwe:3@832
`
`._tmow>e_m:5wimzurwu332%..E3
`
`
`
`emdfl2:8:.m:.$|Eew>m;one_m_.._..m
`
`
`
`
`bfimwemuwmA_a.=:_=u.m>_Ee_>m:un_w:wE
`
`u>n:nwE._ow{E23.w2.Emnew....89:
`
`
`
`
`
`.wmbmbwwnmwe.33wxuc9.:we:mw:o_.>5w
`
`
`
`w:w:wm=....we:>m.$.899:9.:2:v:wwu_u
`
`.__&.ww:P_5mmu§._u3mbownm8.§mEu
`
`
`
`«Eamafia.$585.wr=.:u.uuEm.86
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.5:wuanfiuewuwmweEmfiuwo_3E.G2.5m.._e.5§,_om._u>o_2mEE=9:m_w.awe
`
`
`um:m:uxo.85:E\_u:mou:u=ouxubwwam
`
`.525wens:
`
`
`
`.mw_u=enw.¢m:=&um€
`
`m>mEumE.$u._e:wvwmmfiuumen.m=E
`
`
`
`.2:m>w=un92.5emu.mcecummmmfi.
`
`.5§§~Buuu=_u:_menus:oEEeU
`
`
`
`
`weman»on5.5Eewzducmnuuxubowmm
`
`
`
`3:3mzwwuumwmuwwnqxo.5Eo2m~£3:
`
`.=uo:U:Esme::e_.fl=ww._e.m—m=:u:_we
`
`
`
`yfiwwwEe._w|.:ecm>:wmneu:nzvuuwmvu
`
`
`._wux~bwwnmw>mEume.w:evw:5.5::
`
`.m_uu>wm$._w2m_u:aw5=E.2\w5=_Ewe
`
`
`
`E::enuumwmem.mEEwo.&.¢m_.£n__u
`
`
`
`LE:m.Eo.:=n_2amnion»;32mlut
`
`uwmm:=E5E.:w:eu|mmuuu:m12$.
`umofiwe::mm._9:u.23.uu:u_.ahm..:w«Ea:ewm=w:euwe32mwatsnum<a.mu._mn_u
`
`
`
`.::.E8:32mm:w:w:_m.:wem8:u>_w8wwu
`
`.B:uE...umE9:5_vo>_e>:_Emw.ew>.£un
`
`
`.o.:.wbmwnmm<.:ewmmwwo.:w9:55?::2.
`
`muwwmeuUfld8.3Ewfiuum:e85::me
`
`.e:.=._w§:§:..|:enu:zm=umi292
`
`
`
`:ewwu:mEuu«émmmuucwuomwm_n:ewmmww
`
`wefiwefl9:.3.€=.mu>_m:m:u._n_Eee
`
`:enwo=w9.3oz..Eoww.§FK:3:53:
`
`mmuuusme.93352.9:.m::m.w.._2m2m
`
`.:eu>=n3unmoanvmwvmwum:e.$§.m
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.m_mwmm::Um2:8:em.~E>>:.mE.aEE
`
`
`
`mzeéaa9:Eumewummmwvfieumnv>5.~
`
`
`
`u>oEumEvmvam:mwwwuwmhm$92ea..._u>u_mmouusm3.8.»
`
`
`uw:§wuofiufiwuu:u£.:eEme..w.:w::um:2.§§waanmmomm<
`
`
`
`fi:wEEmwu>£
`min85.5%emmflmwenwu:w:wuxwbbwmmw:_::..=mwe“$85up:moSwwDAm
`
`fimmuusmwemxuewnm:§_.5933:2
`
`2:.9:%&a_____s#2::
`
`.9.»bwwmmus.we$>:uwEe
`
`
`HF:._uS_um;u:=.3.:e_m
`
`..8ms_5._
`
`emu:>_:eU8:0:0.:e_mmow
`
`mmwwmwahmor:m:.=:uEu_m:::m£>>
`
`
`wemufiuuwweflumam285e.Em:vw:=u:e
`
`hasweeauzzua5nafimcou:
`
`
`
`
`Aux...mxeew~u:e=wuxw.53;uu:u=uuxu
`
`2:wseawsebcwfimwnm
`mw:o_m:umm_uwe.

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket