throbber
Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`ESTTA84979
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`06/12/2006
`
`Filing date:
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`91163191
`Plaintiff
`Zabar's & Co., Inc.
`
`Zabar's & Co., Inc.
`2245 Broadway
`New York, NY 10024
`UNITED STATES
`Stephen L. Baker
`Baker & Rannells PA
`626 North Thompson Street
`Raritan, NJ 08869
`UNITED STATES
`b.gaynor@br-tmlaw.com
`Plaintiff's Notice of Reliance
`John M. Rannells
`jmr@br-tmlaw.com, a.kosar@br-tmlaw.com
`/john rannells/
`06/12/2006
`91166191 Not Rely 23.pdf ( 78 pages )(2810353 bytes )
`
`Proceeding
`Party
`
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Submission
`Filer's Name
`Filer's e-mail
`Signature
`Date
`Attachments
`
`

`
`
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`__-_____-__-_--__-______________--_-__-___-_____________x
`
`Zabar's & Co., Inc.
`
`Opposition No. 91163191
`
`Opposer
`
`Marks:
`
`ZABA'S
`Z/-\BA'S AND DESIGN
`
`v.
`
`Zaba's Grill, LLC
`
`Serial No.: 78358762
`
`78358819
`
`Respondent
`_--_____---_______________-_____--__-___-_-_-___________x
`
`OPPOSER’S TWENTYTHIRD NOTICE OF RELIANCE
`PURSUANT TO 37 CFR §2.122le)
`
`Please take notice that Opposer, Zabar's & Co., Inc. (“Zabar's"), pursuant to 37
`
`CFR §2.122(e) is hereby noticing its reliance on various relevant excerpts from printed
`
`publications downloaded and printed from Nexis. The excerpts are comprised of
`
`representative examples of English language third party articles from the year 2002 that
`
`reference Opposer and/or Opposer's goods and services.
`
`Each of the excerpts are relevant to the renown and fame of Opposer and its
`
`services and products, use by Opposer of the mark and name ZABAR’S, the goods and
`
`services marketed and sold by Opposer, the channels of trade through which Opposer’s
`
`goods and services are and have been, offered and sold, and the simiiarity of the
`
`parties‘ respective marks, goods and services, and the legal similarity in channels of
`
`trade.
`
`

`
`
`
`The excerpts are identified in the annexed summary by date, name of
`
`publication, page, and article headline.
`
`Copies of
`
`the excerpts are attached
`
`immediately following the summary.
`
`Dated: June 12,2006
`
`R
`
`
`ectfully submitted,
`
`
`
`
`
`626 N. hompson St.
`Rarita ,New Jersey 08869
`(908
`22-5640
`
`' @br—tmlaw.com
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`i hereby certify that a true and complete copy of the foregoing OF-‘POSER’S
`TWENTYTHIRD NOTICE OF RELIANCE PURSUANT TO 37 CFR SECTION 2.122(e)
`in re Zabar's & Co., Inc. V. Zaba's Grill, LLC, Opposition No. 91163191 was forwarded
`
`by first class postage pre—paid mail this 12th day of June, 2006 to the Applicant at the
`following address:
`
`Moye White LLP
`Leigh Augustine, Esq.,
`Charles F. Luce, Jr., Esq.
`16 Market Square, 6th Floor
`1400 Sixteenth Street
`
`Denver, CO 80202-1fix
`
`DATED:
`
`.lL111e 12, 2006
`
`
`
`//_....._
`
`23"’ Notice Reliance Zabar's Opp. No. 91153191
`
`Page 2
`
`

`
`
`
`Zabar’s
`
`Third Party Articles
`
`
`
`
`
`1/19/2002 Hamilton Sectator
`
`
`
`
`
`2002
`Iii Publication
`j_ —
`New Yorkers: stronger
`than ever
`Outside the heart-shaped
`box: creative valentine ifts
`Food will kee us toether
`Whole foods makes big
`slash in the Bi A le
`The Film: don't sa aword
`Black and White, Eaten all
`over
`Broadcast News
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Travel; P. T 05
`Personal Finance;
`Life & Mone
`Food; P. E 2
`Business & Financial
`News
`Features
`Food; Part 8;Features
`Desk; P. 1
`o o
`
`
`
`
`
`211 5/2002
` 2/24/2002
`_
`4/17/2002
`4/25/2002
`
`1/28/2002 Marketwatch
`2/1312002
`The Boston Globe
`The Dallas Morning
`News
`Sunda Times (London
`
`Los Aneles Times
`Seattle Weekl
`
`
`
`-
`
`6/16/2002
`
`Sunda Times London
`Star Tribune
`6/27/2002 Minneaolis, MN
`Press Enterprise
`
`
`
`Features
`Taste; Fork on the
`Road; P.‘l'i'
`Entertainment;
`
`Uptown, downtown-get out
`
`on the town
`
`Fork on the Road
`Places you must see to
`
`8/20/2002
`
`Cleveland Jewish News
`
`-
`- Courier News
`
`8/21/2002
`
`Bridewater. NJ
`
`lndia in New York
`8/23.12002
`The New York Sun
`9/412002
`The Miami Herald
`9/21/2002
`10/21/2002 Peole
`
`The Oreonian
`11/8/2002
`11 /1 0/2002 The New York Times
`11/10/2002 The New York Times
`
`Vol. 85; No. 12; P. 18 Gotham
`
`Golems, ghost stories and
`A grape stomping good time
`
`in Belvidere
`Hot Sufi! Don't know what
`sauce to choose?
`With Glass in Hand
`
`Lifest le; P. 1 B
`
`Vol. 6, No. 7, P. 28
`Food & Drink; P. 11
`.
`Udate; P. 86
`
`Yada Yada Dada
`Friday Surprise Giuliani and
`Rockefeller
`Streetscaes/Zabar’s
`Gadets a Go-Go
`
`Local Stories;P. A 20
`Sect. 11, Col. 1, P. 9
`Sect. 6, Part 2; Col. 1
`Winter in the City;
`P. 28 X
`11/17/2002 The Journal News
`F79th St.
`Food & Drink; P. 15 fl
`11/20/2002 The New York Sun
`11/21/2002 Hartford Courant @ Food Notes
`Kapiti looks set to become a
`bi cheese in US
`Globe North 2
`St ie & Culture; New York
`Women of Words
`Big Apple has lodgings for all
`tastes, budets
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`11/25/2002 New Zealand Herald
`12/8/2002
`The Boston Globe
`12/9/2002
`Los Aneles Times
`12/15/2002 CBS News Transcrits
`
`12/22/2002
`
`The Seattle Times
`
`
`
`
`462 words
`Globe North; P. 10
`Calendar; Part 5; P. 1
`Profile; 1590 Words
`Rop Zone; Travel; Pg.
`M 3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`
`Search - 281 Results - Zabars
`Page 1 of 3
`
`Source: News 3: Business :- Combined Sources > News, All (English, Full Text) IE}
`Terms: zabars and date(geq {1.l1i20U2) and leq (1 2i31l2002))
`(Edit Search | Suggest Terms for My Search)
`
`~FSelect for FOCUSTM or Delivery
`El
`
`New Yorkers: stronger than ever Hamilton Spectator (Ontario, Canada) January 19, 2002 Saturday Final
`Eo’r'tr'on
`
`Copyright 2002 Toronto Star Newspapers, Ltd.
`Hamilton Spectator (Ontario, Canada)
`
`January 19, 2002 Saturday Final Edition
`
`SECTION: TRAVEL; Pg. T05
`
`LENGTH: 1132 words
`
`HEADLINE: New Yorkers: stronger than ever
`
`SOURCE: Special to The Hamilton Spectator
`
`BYLINE: Shirley Plicard «
`
`BODY:
`
`Everyone remembers where one was on September 11. I can remember and recall peoples‘ faces and
`reactions.
`
`Some people at work needed to call their families here in Canada and in the United States. Working at my
`workstation, a friend came by and told us the awful truth. We had neither Internet connection nor
`television at work at that time. At noon hour, people went out to their cars. Some of us stayed and listened
`very sadly to the radio during our lunch. But no one at that time could say Osama bid Laden correctly. I
`had a vague idea of his name but that was it. I hurried home, after lunch and of course, tuned into CNN.
`After a few hours I left and went to the gym where every television tuned into live coverage of the tragedy.
`Back at my house, I turned to my photos of my summer holiday in New York in July, hoping that I had
`pictures of the World Trade Center. I did indeed. Since that terrible Tuesday, I have concerned myself
`about returning to the city that I personally love. I made the decision in November that I would visit again,
`but this time with different eyes and totally different emotions.
`
`Last July, New York was busy, beautiful, and boisterous. The summer heat was oppressive but exhilarating.
`The pretzels and bottled water that I purchased in Central Park satisfied my hunger and thirst as I hiked to
`the MET. I never felt so well as I did that day. Indeed I Love New York.
`
`I needed desperately to visit New York again and come closer to ali the other heroes of that terrible day. I
`had read reports of tourists being unable to visit Ground Zero. Many New Yorkers had complained that the
`tourists had been gawking. After all it is a cemetery and sacred ground to those families. I kept all of these
`important perceptions near my heart as I planned my journey to New York. I felt Christmas would be a
`perfect time for renewal and a time to remember. Boxing Day for me signals the end of the stress of
`Christmas. I pianned to arrive late Christmas Day.
`
`Before leaving for New York, I contacted the Big Apple Greater: a not—for-profit program supported
`primarily by grants and private donations.
`
`It is a service free to New York visitors. The Big Apple Greeter is a civic—minded volunteer friends selected
`for their enthusiasm and love of New York City, not professional tour guides.
`
`The Web site www.bigapp_i_egreeter.com (phone: 1-800-692-8474) is available for anyone who wishes to
`
`http://www.lexis.com/researcli/ret1'ieve‘?_n1=5ee667d236070050743253b400752344&docnun1=264&_fints... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search - 281 Results — Zabars
`Page 2 of 3
`
`use the service. I completed the form and e~mailed the information straight away and waited to hear from
`them. The next day I learned that my Big Apple Greeter was Hannah Horn, a bank comptroller from
`Brooklyn, N. Y. When I arrived at my hotel a fax was waiting for me. I quick call and we decided to meet at
`my hotel the following day at 10 a.m. Since I had no particular area I wanted to visit, she volunteered the
`Upper West Side. She would previously visit the Financial District but the attack had changed her itinerary
`and her life forever. She was indeed devastated with the events of 9/11. She spoke kindly of her mayor
`who led her great city out of the tragic events. She was proud to be born in this great city. After lunch at a
`dell near Lincoln Square, we walked around Fordham University. Upstairs (elevators are available outside)
`we walked around a garden dedicated to Robert Moses. He was responsible for all of the urban
`development in New York during the 50s and 605. Following a tour around St. Paul the Apostle Church on
`Broadway, we walked around Strawberry Fields, Tavern on the Green, Bow Lake, Bethesda Fountain, and
`Belvedere Castle. Zabars the famous grocery was busy with tourists and residents of the Upper West Side.
`The walk ended with quick run into H&H bagels and finally a subway ride down Broadway to 53rd Street.
`The end of a perfect day culminated with a quick dash to the nearby deli for a healthy salad eaten before
`the final stop at the SPA in the hotel.
`
`Two days later after hearing about the platform being built, I left early on that Sunday expecting to one of
`the first. The line was already two blocks long at 8: 30 a.m. Tourists love to talk in line and indeed people
`came to New York and Ground Zero out of respect for the heroes who died that horrible day. As we
`approached the platform, people became very quiet. The walk up the incline was still. The wind was cold
`and one observer in the Daily News later mentioned the vertical blinds from the World Trade Center still
`attached to the limbs of a tree in St. Paul's cemetery rattling in the wind. Some people took pictures, some
`cried and some wrote notes on the platform rail. The walk down back to the street was the saddest of all. I
`spent nine days in New York and everyone who spoke about that terrible day could not speak coherently.
`They hesitated and walked away orjust shook their heads. Their city was assaulted. They were assaulted.
`At his final speech at St. Paul's chapel, mayor Guiliani noted the church had withstood the attack just as
`New Yorkers had withstood the attack. They would be confident and stronger than ever after that horrible
`day of 9/11.
`
`Shirley Picard is a freelance writer. She can be reached at shir|ey_p2000@yahoo.ca
`
`Tickets (free) required
`
`for Ground Zero
`
`The South Street Seaport has become the first stop for those who wish to view the World Trade Center
`ruins. That is where free tickets are being distributed by New York City for half—hour time slots on the
`viewing platform at the Trade Center site. The tickets are distributed daily 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. (or until the
`day's supply runs out) at a booth on Pier 16, at the foot of Fulton Street. The viewing platform -- about a
`15-minute walk along Fuiton Streetjust off Broadway -- is open from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily. Each day, the
`tickets are distributed chronologically for the noon to 8 p.m. siots that same day and the 9 to 11:30 a.m.
`slots the next day. Each half—hour block has 250 tickets; each person on line can take a maximum of two
`tickets. On a mild weekday afternoon in early January, the line stretched most of the way along Pier 16 but
`moved quickly because no money was changing hands. At 1 p.m. that day, the tickets for 6:30 p.m. were
`being handed out. Visitors must take whatever time slot is available when they reach the window, but
`unscientific calculation indicates that those who arrive after 3 p.m. will be getting tickets for the next
`morning. The line usually starts forming at 8 a.m. For information: (212) 732-7678. For those looking for
`some background before going to the ruins, the South Street Seaport Museum is offering "The World Trade
`Center: A Historical Perspective" at noon, 1, 2 and 3 p.m. daily; the 35-minute tour, led by historians
`connected with the museum, covers the 11—block South Street Seaport Historic District.
`
`GRAPHIC: Photo: Photo by Shirley Picard, Special to the Hamilton Spectator; Tourists come to New York
`and Ground Zero out of respect for the heroes who died Sept.11, 2001 when the World Trade Center was
`attacked. Thoughts from Ground Zero
`
`LOAD-DATE: January 19, 2002
`
`http://wwwlexis.com/1'eseaIcl1/retrieve?_m=5ee667d236070050743253b40O752344&d0cnum:264&_fi11ts... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search — 281 Results — Zabars
`Page 1 of 3
`
`Source: News 8. Business > Combined Sources > News, All (English, Full Text) LEE
`Terms: zabars and dateigeq (1l1l2002) and Ieq (12i31i2DD2))
`(Edit Search | Suggest Terms for My Search)
`
`~ll'-‘Select for FOCUST” or Delivery
`D
`
`Outside the heart-shaped box: Creative Valentines gifts CBS Ma-rketwatch January 28, 2002 Monday
`
`Copyright 2002 MarketWatch.com Inc., All Rights Reserved
`
`Market etch
`
`
`ran
`
`CBS Marketwatch
`
`January 28, 2002 Monday
`
`SECTION: PERSONAL FINANCE; LIFE Si. MONEY
`
`LENGTH: 1388 words
`
`HEADLINE: Outside the heart—shaped box: Creative Valentines gifts
`
`BYLINE: Alisa Weinstein, CBS.iVlarketWatch.com; mailto:aweinstein@marketwatch.com
`
`BODY:
`
`SAN FRANCISCO (CBS.MW) —~ When it comes to a buying a gift for your sweetie this Valentine's Day, try
`thinking outside the heart-shaped box.
`
`Flowers and candy might have made a girl swoon in simpler times, but with everything from personalized
`songs to hot air balloon rides avaiiable online, it's easy to get more creative and sophisticated in your
`expressions of love.
`
`"When you give a gift to someone, you're communicating what makes them unique or interesting and how
`much you care about them," said Darrell Benatar, president of Paio Alto, Calif.-based
`l;i_t_tp_:[/www.surprise.com[ Surprise.com, a database of user-submitted gift ideas. "Price can show that, but
`so can how much thought you put into it."
`
`Look for a gift that connects you with that person, whether it's something touching, personal or humorous,
`said Julie Gilhart, vice president of fashion at Barney's, New York. "Take an extra minute and think about
`something that is a little special or a little different."
`
`To get you on your way, CBS Marketwatch spoke to shopping experts and combed the Web to come up
`creative gift ideas for the budget—conscious and big spenders alike:
`Give him or her the stars —— or at least one. You can name a star for the one you love at
`http_:_/jwww.starwis"l1i_r_1_g.com/_ Star Wishing from EcoP|anet. Gift packages include an entry in the Internet's
`online Millennium Chronicle Star catalog, a greeting letter telling you about the registration, a parchment
`paper certificate with the name of your star, date of registration, the constellation and your wish, the Star
`Gazette with scientific data about your star, and a customized map with your star marked on the center for
`$39.95.
`A personalized romance novel. i_1_ttp_:jjwww.yournove|.com/_ Yournove|.com will customize a love story,
`making you and your sweetheart the main characters. Choose a "mild" version with only hugging and
`kissing, or the "wild" version with more detailed love scenes. Get written into stories like Another Day In
`Paradise, set on a Caribbean island, or Island of Love, which takes place in Tahiti and the South Seas for
`$54.95.
`A homemade gourmet meal. Take a cooking class and iearn how to make your Valentine a romantic dinner.
`For instance, Sur La Table offers hands—on culinary classes that teach students how to prepare a multi-
`
`http://www.lexis.c0111/resea1°c11/retrieve?_1n=4e8689eee7acb5 829053fdd8da3 c7c04&c1oc11u111=260&_frntst1'... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search - 281 Results - Zabars
`Page 2 of 3
`
`course meal from start to finish. This year, it's offering special Valentine's Day classes on cake decorating
`for $75 in Newport Beach, Calif. and "Cupid's Kitchen" for $180 in Houston. Couples can learn to cook a
`romantic meal of Duck Confit Roulade with Roquefort Vinaigrette Smoked Salmon and Lemon Risotto with
`Jumbo Prawns. Peruse their culinary programs ht,tp:[Lw_vvw.surlatable.comjcool5Mii3g/index.cfm online by
`store.
`
`Take a mini—course in massage therapy and then let your fingers express your love.
`htt_p:1/www.naturalhea|ers.cgm[ Naturaihealers.com lists massage therapy schools across the country.
`Body Therapy Center in Paio Alto, Calif., for instance, offers a five~hour back, neck and shoulders course for
`$75 or a five—hour aromatherapy course for $60.
`A one—of a—kind love song. Write one and sing it yourself, or for the tonally impaired, enlist some help. Go
`to __http:[Lv_v_,ww.personalizedsg_gg.corn_[ personalizedsongcom to work with professional musicians to create
`a song and have them record it on a CD. The cost is $197 for a male vocalist and $217 for a female
`vocalist. http:flwww.asongforyou.corri[ Asongforyou.com will create a custom song from information you
`provide for $299.00.
`Go for a joyride. Find out what kind of car your mate has always wanted and rent it for a day. To make it
`extra special, pack a picnic and whisk your love off to a romantic location in his or her dream car. Luxury
`doesn't come cheap: At Miami—based httpm;/_/www.excellence|uxury.com[ Excellenceiuxury.com, a Corvette
`convertible costs $325 a day, while a Ferrari F360 Modena coupe is even pricier, at $2,000. But it's still less
`than buying one of your own. Find an agency in your area that rents luxury cars by going to
`http;[/www.exoticcarguicle.com[ Exoticcarguide.com.
`Breakfast in bed. What could be more romantic than not getting out of bed at all on Valentine's Day, or
`maybe the following Saturday? There's hope even if you aren't a whiz in the kitchen. Ready-made baskets
`come with everything you need —— from pancake mix to a whisk ~- to create the perfect morning meal.
`Martha Stewart's version comes with heart-shaped pancake, butter and sugar molds for $138. Or, if you
`want to leave the cooking to someone else, Zabar's, the world—famous New York food store, will deliver a
`crate of freshly baked bagels, Nova salmon, plain and scallion cream cheese, freshly baked cinnamon
`rugeiach and coffee to your doorstep for $129.
`A living love poem. Body Talk Tattoos are like the magnetic poetry you can play with on your refrigerator,
`only for your body instead. The kit, available at ljjgtp:[[www.redenvelope.cong[ redenveiope.com for $20,
`contains more than 800 words and letters that you can combine to create your own romantic sonnets. For
`more traditional poets who'd rather see their words on paper, the gift site offers a Secret Love Letters kit.
`The $48 kit contains standard, rose-scented ink and invisible ink that appears when you hold the paper up
`to a heat source, and then disappears again when you take it away.
`Foreplay. It's always an appreciated romantic overture. For the uninspired, try The Hot and Bothered
`Game, a version of spin the bottle for the R-rated crowd. The spinner is full of different moves you can put
`on your partner. Also available at redenveiope.com for $20.
`i-lot air balloon ride. Float for an hour over vineyards, fields or mountains for $150 to $200. Find
`information at http:1/www.ba|loonridesusa.i Ba|!oonRidesUSA.corn and
`http_;/_/www.ushotairballoon.cog3L US Hot Air Balloon Team.
`If you must give flowers... http_:[jwww.800flowers.corgj_ 1—800—F|owers.com will deliver a different kind of
`rose, or one of a variety of blooms like freesia, calla lilies or double peony tulips to your sweetheart each
`month for three, six or 12 months. The flower club runs $134.99 pius $16.99 shipping for three months of
`flowers to $492.99 plus $44.99 shipping for one year. Roses are little more costly, at $149.99 plus $16.99
`in shipping for three months to $559.99 plus $44.99 in shipping for one year. Endless Flowers’
`httpgj/www.flowermonthclub.com[ Flower of the Month Club has gift memberships that range from two
`months for $77.90 to one year for $460.65 for a monthly delivery of fresh—cut flowers.
`
`1997-2002 MarketWatch.com, Inc. All rights reserved. See details at
`ljttp:/jcustom.marketwatch.com/custom/docs/useragreementasp .
`
`LOAD-DATE: January 3, 2003
`
`Source: News 8. Business > Combined Sources > News, All (English, Full Text)
`Terms: zabars and datelgeq (1i"ll2002) and leq (1 213112002” (Edit Search I Suggest Terms for My Search)
`View: Full
`
`hitp://wwwlexis.com/researcll/1'etrieve‘?_n1=4e8689eee7acb5829053ttld8da3c7c04&docnum=260&_fmtstr... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search — 281 Results — Zabars
`Page 1 of 2
`
`Source: News 8. Business > Combined Sources > News. All (English, Full Text) IKE
`Terms: zabars and date(geq (1I1i'2002) and Ieq (1 2l31l20D2)} (Edit Search | Suggest Terms for My Search)
`
`~FSe|ec:t for FOCUSTM or Delivery
`iii
`
`FOOD WILL KEEP US TOGETHER The Boston Globe February .13, 2002, Wednesday
`
`Copyright 2002 Globe Newspaper Company
`The Boston Globe
`
`February 13, 2002, Wednesday ,THIRD EDITION
`
`SECTION: FOOD; Pg. E2
`
`LENGTH: 549 words
`
`HEADLINE: FOOD WILL KEEP US TOGETHER
`
`BYLINE: By Jill Casey, Globe Correspondent
`
`BODY:
`
`Sushi isn't for everyone. I knew I was in love with my boyfriend when I realized that our weekend dates at
`the sushi bar weren't exactly mutually pleasing.
`
`After gorging on spicy tuna, unagi, and yellowtail rolls on several occasions, the truth came out: Ingesting
`raw fish doesn't agree with him. I guess that explains why his face would turn wasabi—green after the meal.
`He was trying something new because he knew how much I liked it.
`
`Whether you look at food as an invitation to adventure or simply as a a means of survival, it plays a role
`in intimate relationships. The things someone eats, a special dish he or she cooks, or the way someone
`thinks of food can tell you a lot about potential compatibility as a mate. Could it also signal what someone
`is like in other parts of the relationship?
`
`Who hasn't experienced a loss of appetite upon falling in love? You run on nervous energy, and feel certain
`that love is all you need to sustain yourself. Of course that only lasts for a iittle while. After you both drop a
`couple of pounds and regain some consciousness, your [over will ask, "So, what do you want for dinner
`tonight?"
`
`As one of you starts daydreaming of sharing plates of sizzling tapas and drinking sangria, the other is
`thinking hot pizza, cold beer, and the comforts of the couch.
`
`Food, which some people overlook in the first few months of a relationship, ends up having a lot to do with
`whether a relationship lasts, says Antonette Galasso, who teaches Italian cooking teacher at the Cambridge
`Center for Adult Education.
`
`"I can't deny the part of me that wants every meal to be an experience. I don't think I could be with
`someone who didn't have an open mind about food," she says.
`
`Galasso learned to cook in Italy and understands the array of emotions that Italian food can provoke. Both
`men and women take her class for the same reason, she says. They "want a few good dishes under their
`belts to impress or win someone over.
`
`"This generation attaches women in the kitchen to a setback in feminism," she says. "For me, it's not a
`weakness, its total power."
`
`At Claremont Cafe in the South End, owners Manuel Signuel and Paula Spina, who are husband and wife,
`
`http://www.lexis.com/resea1'chfretrieve?_111=dff5d2e4995108 149t740c1c7c9021 98a6&doc11u111=243&mf111tst1'.. . 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search — 281 Results - Zabars
`Page 2 of 2
`
`can be found going through all the motions of running a restaurant.
`
`But even on busy nights, Spina pulls up a stool in the kitchen to talk to her husband while he cooks his
`comforting style of Mediterranean food. Hot plates sail past them and smoke rises from the pans as the two
`share conversation amid the bustle of a busy night.
`'
`
`When asked about how they like to spend their time off, Spina mentions a trip to New York. "We went to
`Zabar's, the gourmet superstore, and got tons of stuff Manuel likes and tons of stuffl like and just took it
`back to the hotel and had a bed picnic."
`
`Can two people who like completely different foods coexist?
`
`Ellen Albertson, who hosts a radio show, "The Cooking Couple" on WBNW (1120—AM) with her husband,
`Michael, also her collaborator on two books, "Food as Foreplay" and "Temptations: Igniting the Pleasure
`and Power of Aphrodisiacs," thinks so.
`
`“When you love someone, it's about compromise," she says. "Football was not always fun for me, but I
`grew to like it because of my husband. It's all about exploring and trying new things."
`
`LOAD-DATE: February 14, 2002
`
`Source: Naws_& Business > Combined Sources > News, All (English, Full Text)
`Terms: zabars and date(geq (#112002) and leq (12l31I2002))
`(Edit Search [ Suggest Terms for My Search)
`View: Full
`Datei'Tirne: Monday, June 5, 2006 — 6:40 PM EDT
`
`'
`‘
`About LexisNexis
`| Terms & Conditions
`W Le-KISNEXI5 Qpyright Q 2006 LexlsNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
`
`1111])://www.lexis.oo1n/researc11/retrieve?_n1=c1ff5d2e499a08 1 49f740dc7c90219Sa6&doc1m1n=243&_fi11tslI... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search - 281 Results - Zabars
`_
`Page 1 of 4
`
`Source: News 8. Business > Combined Sources > News, All (English, Full Text) Iii
`Terms: zabars and datelgeq (1I1l2iJ02) and leq (12I31i2DD2)) (Edit Search | Suggest Terms for My Search)
`
`~FSelect for FOCUSTM or Delivery
`E]
`
`Whole Foods makes big splash in the Big Apple The Dallas Morning News February 15, 2002, Friday
`
`Copyright 2002 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service
`Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service
`The Dallas Morning News
`
`February 15, 2002, Friday
`
`SECTION: BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL NEWS
`
`KR-ACC—NO: K5474
`
`LENGTH: 1806 words
`
`HEADLINE: Whole Foods makes big splash in the Big Apple
`
`BYLINE: By Maria Halkias
`
`BODY:
`
`NEW YORK _ This is the food capital of the world. It is the home to Balducci's, Dean 8: DeLuca and Zabar's,
`among other specialty food stores.
`
`If you can't get it here, you can't get it anywhere.
`
`So how did a laid-back, Texas grocery run by a libertarian baby boomer whose mother routinely served up
`TV dinners impress a metropolis of culinary elite?
`
`Whoie Foods Market's first Manhattan store, located in the Chelsea neighborhood, has ranked among the
`chain's top 10 revenue producers since it opened in February 2001.
`
`The chain's acceptance back East is proof that this 21-year-old Austin, Texas—based company has come of
`age _ no longer a funky niche seller of natural and organic tofu and apple juice.
`
`"Ten years ago, I wouldn't have said we were Main Street, but today we are," said John Mackey.
`
`Whole Foods‘ founder, chairman and chief executive said: "I didn't foresee us ever being this big. But the
`market continues to grow as more people care more about the food they're eating."
`
`Whole Foods slowly built up to this store. The chain's Northeast division is headquartered in Edgewater,
`N.J., and is led by a woman who could have gone into her family's Italian bakery business, but instead
`made her own career.
`
`"We have to do a few things different than you would see in the Texas stores," said Christina Minardi, vice
`president in the Northeast. One major difference comes with how New Yorkers get their groceries home.
`
`"We have a tremendous amount of home delivery. So we have delivery carts and people who push them.
`Our in-store carts are smailer. We have S—rings on the ends of our baskets so people can hang their own
`folding carts while they're shopping that they pull their groceries home in."
`
`One million people live within a mile of Whole Foods‘ 30,000-square—foot Manhattan grocery store and a
`separate 3,D00—square-foot Whole Body shop, a personal care products center that has its own entrance.
`
`http://www.lexis.com/research/retrieve?__1n=dff5d2e4995108149f740dc7c9D2198a6&docnum=241&__fintst1'... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search — 281 Results - Zabars
`Page 2 of 4
`
`They're on the ground floor of an early 1900s building that was recently renovated into 354 luxury units,
`including 26 penthouses. Similar residential projects are going up across the street and up a block.
`
`Linnae Hamilton of the Soho neighborhood visits the Whole Foods market once a week. On a recent
`Tuesday afternoon, she was placing $183 worth of groceries into her van.
`
`She was bemoaning the fact that recent retail development in Soho has left her with "Chanel and Cartier
`and every other store you can think of, but no place to get natural and organic groceries."
`
`"There's really nowhere we can get this kind of selection," Hamilton said.
`
`Whole Foods shopper Jose Lugo has several reasons for shifting from D'Agostino Supermarket two blocks
`away.
`
`His No. 1 reason may be surprising:
`
`"Whole Foods is a lot cheaper," Lugo said. "And I'm trying stuff that's not in all the other supermarkets. I
`wanted to buy stock, but it was too expensive for me."
`
`The stock closed Thursday at $37.86.
`
`Otto Leuschel, manager of the Manhattan store, said the goal is to be middle-priced, but "Often we're the
`lowest in a city where its residents are used to paying 30 percent more for everything."
`
`A 10—ounce box of Cheerios at D'Agostino costs more than $5; Whole Foods‘ version, under its 365 house
`brand, costs $1.99.
`
`Across the Hudson River in New Jersey are several more Whole Foods stores, including a 50,000-square-
`foot unit built in 2000 in a former mail-bag repair center that has a full—length view of the Manhattan
`skyline from its parking lot.
`
`The store is among the chain's largest and a real testament to how ubiquitous natural and organic goods
`are today.
`
`Mark Wilkins, manager of the Edgewater store, said the growth of natural products is "really obvious in the
`cereal aisle. Years ago we had granola. Now we have 40 feet of cereal boxes" with names such as Health
`Valley, Nature‘s Path, Mother's and, of course, 365.
`
`Whole Foods Market operates 130 stores from coast to coast and opened its first store outside the country
`in Toronto last year.
`
`By 2004, the company expects to operate 200 stores and have sales of $4 billion. By 2010, the numbers
`are projected to grow to 400 stores and $10 billion in annual sales.
`
`"We're only in 30 of the top 50 U.S. metro markets, and we haven't reached complete saturation in any of
`our existing markets," said Walter Robb, the chain's executive vice president of operations.
`
`I13 stock has been publicly traded for 10 years and has performed at a compounded annual growth rate of
`27 percent, including a gain of more than 60 percent in the last year.
`
`It is the nation's biggest seller of organic foods, having swallowed up rivais including Boston's Bread &
`Circus, California's Mrs. Gooch's and Fresh Fields in Washington, D.C.
`
`Last year, it purchased Harry's Farmers Market in Atlanta, whose founder, Harry A. Blazer, was a
`consultant to San Antonio's H.E. Butt Co. H-E—B learned a few tricks from him before opening its food-
`
`http://wwwlexis.com/1'esea1'ch/retrieve?_1n‘£dff5 d2e499a08 149f740dc7c9O2198a6&c1oc11um=241&__fi11tstr... 6/5/2006
`
`

`
`
`Search - 281 Results — Zabars
`Page 3 of 4
`
`focused Centre! Market concept, which is now entering the Dallas-Fort Worth area.
`
`With 2001 sales of $2.3 billion and profit of $63 million, Whole Foods is almost the size of Starbucks, but
`not nearly as well-known. Not yet anyway, said Mackey.
`
`Granted, Starbucks coffee appeals to a broader audience.
`
`"Everybody gets coffee, but they don't all get Whole Foods," Mackey said. "Starbucks is a much better-
`known brand despite the fact that we're both consumer products companies with similar growth patterns."
`
`Whole Foods has diluted its brand over the years by continuing to operate in some markets under the
`names it acquired, such as Fresh Fields and Bread & Circus.
`
`Over the next two to three years, the plan is to operate under the Whole Foods name exclusively. "I would
`think, for example, in the Boston market, any fears customers may have had about our acquisition of the
`company have dissipated," Macl<ey said.
`
`It's a true story that Mackey's mother was thrilled with prepared frozen foods. When he went off to college,
`joined a co—op and saw buik bins of fabulous fresh foods, it moved him to entrepreneurship. He founded the
`chain in 1978.
`
`"Back then, there wasn't enough product to fill the store, s

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket