throbber
/glad
`
`Opposition No. 91 156821
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`Serial No. 78/105,321
`
`Mark: BIG "D" REAL ESTATE
`
`Filed: January 28, 2002
`
`Published: January 21, 2003
`
`HlllllllllIlllllllilllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
`
`’
`
`o4-09-2004
`u.s.Pa1nnt& TM01cITM Mail 1'-‘taut m. #22
`
`)
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`JUDY MCCUTCHIN,
`
`OPPOSER,
`
`v.
`
`JAN DUBELL,
`
`APPLICANT.
`
`“"""“—“”“—‘“""""""
`Commissioner for Trademarks
`2900 Crystal Drive
`Arlington, Virginia 22202-3514
`
`PP
`
`ER’ FIR T
`
`TI
`
`FRELIA
`
`Opposer, Judy McCutchin (“McCutchin”), in accordance with Rule 2.122(e) of the
`
`Trademark Rules of Practice, submits the following printout of an Internet website available to
`
`the general public through general circulation:
`
`1.
`
`Exhibit A: Printout from Applicant Jan DuBell’s website located at
`www.bigdrealestate.net.
`
`This website is relevant because it demonstrates the geographical descriptiveness of the
`
`term “BIG D” as used by Applicant to promote real estate brokerage services in Dallas, Texas.
`
` Dated: April 9 , 2004
`
`By:
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Elizabeth A. Linford
`
`KOENIG & ASSOCIATES
`
`Attorneys for Opposer
`220 East Figueroa Street
`Santa Barbara, CA
`Tel: 805-965-4400
`
`Fax: 805-564-8262
`Email: Kurt@IncIP.corn
`
`

`
`
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`ERTIFI
`
`E
`
`MAILI
`
`BY EXPRE MAI
`
`I hereby certify that the foregoing document is being deposited with the United States
`Postal Service as “Express Mail Post Office to Addressee” in an envelope addressed to:
`Commissioner for Trademarks, 2900 Crystal Drive, Arlington, VA 22202-3514, on the date
`identified below.
`
`Express Mail Mailing Label No. EVO66295711US
`
`Dated: April 9, 2004
`
`EL
`
`BETH A. LINF
`
`ERTIFI
`
`T
`
`F ER I E
`
`1, Elizabeth A. Linford, hereby certify that I caused a copy of the foregoing document to
`be served on April 9, 2004 by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed to:
`
`Jan DuBel1
`
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`
`Irving, Texas 75063
`
`Executed this 9th day of April 2004 at Santa Barbara, California.
`
` ETH A. LINFORD
`
`

`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`
`

`
`
`
`BIG D Real Estate" Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3.'30.’U4 9:25 AM
`
`RETURN TO TOP
`
`much land you need. we’ll find you the perfect match. We can walk you through
`all the intricacies of country property in Texas. Click on “Dallas Ranches” to see
`BlG D” properties we have sold or to browse the entire North Texas MLS
`system and review real estate listings at your leisure. Horse properties available.
`i’
`
`Dallas Sellers - We can showcase your property to millions of potential Buyers
`world-wide, 24 hours a day with our BIG Di” iP|X virtual tours. Request a free
`market analysis to determine what your property is worth.
`i’
`
`BEG D Mortgages- Information regarding current mortgage rates, qualification
`tools, market updates, and area tax rates are all available to help you make an
`informed decision.
`
`Around BlG “D" - Links to area statistics, mapping, weather information, area
`photos, school ratings, local news, and general State of Texas information.
`
`browse at your convenience.
`
`Dallas Recreation - Find out what is happening in Dallas from current events to
`Dallas Restaurants, Sports Teams and lakelfishing information. Use our links to
`
`i’
`
`Jan DuBell, GRI, ABR
`Steve DuBel|
`S23 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`Irving, Texas 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBel|. all rights reserved.
`
`http:1'r'www.bigdrcalestate net.’
`
`Page 2 of 2
`
`

`
`

`
`
`
`BIG D Real Estate; Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3/30l04 9:25 AM
`
`Southlake, Texas
`
`Connas
`(Irving), Texas
`
`Farmers Branch, Texas
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Click on any one of
`our sold properties
`
`for a closer look.
`788 Mas ell ‘
`Dallas, Texas
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 2816 Meadow
`Green Drive
`
`Flower Mound, Texas
`‘I’
`
`
`Our combined area Multiple Listing Service allows us access to every
`property listed for sale in North Texas. if you wish to browse these listings
`
`yourself, you may gain access to the NTREIS MLS database directly here
`by clicking below. You may simply view listings or, you may want to
`receive new property matches by email. To set up this free service, enter
`MLS below, go to "Property Wizard”. enter your desired criteria. and your
`name & email address. The software takes it
`from there!
`
`
`
`
`
`RETURN TO TOP
`
`
`Click here to access current listings
`
`Jan DuBel|, GRI, ABR
`Steve Dul3ell
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`Irving, Texas 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBell. all rights reserved.
`
`http:.'.'www.b:'gdreu|cs1ate,ne1."residenIialhornes.htm
`
`Page 2 of2
`
`

`
`

`
`
`
`3.’3U/U4 9:26 AM
`
`150+/— Ac. Pelzel Road
`Pilot Point, Texas
`
`3401 Fishtrap Road
`Aubrey, Texas
`
`563 CR 3404
`wills Point, Texas
`
`Crossroads, Texas
`
`. 712 Bandit Trail
`Kelier, Texas
`
`14830 Valley View
`Forney, Texas
`
`Click on any one of our
`sold properties for a
`closer look.
`
`28.6+/— Ac. CR 4060
`Scurry, Texas
`
`11.29+/- Ac.
`Anna, Texas
`
`Our combined area Multiple Listing Service allows us access to every
`property listed for sale in North Texas. If you wish to browse these
`listings yourself, you may gain access to the NTREIS MLS database
`directly here by clicking below. You may simply view listings or, you
`may want to receive new property matches by email. To set up this free
`service, enter MLS below, go to "Property Wizard", enter your desired
`criteria, and your name & email address. The software takes it
`from there!
`
`Click here to access current listings
`
`' BIG D Real Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`of Texas
`
`Dallas
`
`I
`
`Cotton-eyed Joe
`
`I
`
`I Don't Fence Me In
`
`I
`
`RETURN TO TOP
`
`
`Jan DuBell, GRI, ABR
`Steve DuBell
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`Irving, Texas: 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBe|l. all rights reserved.
`
`hup:i'i‘www.bigdrcalestaie .nel.i'ranChes. him
`
`Page 2 of2
`
`

`
`
`
`BIG D Real Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3.'30i'04 9:26 AM
`
`
`
`DALLAS, TEXAS REAL ESTATE WITH THE DUBELLS
`
`'
`
`' '. «.~-
`

`
`l
`
`4
`Real t:s1at'e,.
`
`Welcome
`
`7‘ fl
`
`Em“ Ra"'°"°3
`
`l
`
`Property Taxes
`Many people wish to compare area tax rates as a part of the research
`process when buying a home. For your convenience we have linked to the
` Dallas Coun A r
`i al District so you may view the latest tax statistics.
`
`
`
`
`Monthly Market Updates
`Click here to view economic updates, rates, and other useful information.
`Updated monthly.
`
`Mortgages
`Mortgage lending is a complicated field and should be entered into with care.
`You will probably be repaying your loan for a long time. The right lender can
`make or break your deal and it is important to know who you are aligned with
`from the start. Experience is essential. Your lender should be willing to spend
`whatever time it takes in order for you to feel comfortable and have a
`complete understanding of the entire process.
`
`Mortgage Rates
`
`Loan Officers
`
`
`
`mprint this page, click here
`
` youW|need:
`
`
`
`Listen to a Dallas Tune:
`
`817-858-0303 -Off.
`8 l7-946-5488 -Cell
`Email
`
`702 Don Tap,
`Ste. 130
`
`Coppell, TX 59
`
`17760 Preston Rd.
`Dallas, TX 75252
`
`Leslie Henry
`
`
`
`Lynn Lehman
`
`L
`St
`Moolrigagt, Inc.
`
`4222 Trinity Mills
`Rd., Ste. 200 Dallas
`TX 75287
`
`Qualifying
`
`One of the first questions every Buyer should ask is "What price property can
`
`hupJfwwwbigdrealestate.n.t:1.'financinl.hun
`
`Page I of2
`
`

`
`
`
`I.‘
`
`BIG D Real Estate: Dalia: Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3.'30/04 9:26 AM
`
`I afford?" The easiest way to answer that question is to spend about ten
`minutes by telephone with a loan officer and become pre-qualified. We always
`recommend speaking with more than one person initially for comparison
`purposes, then apply with one person who will work closely with you during
`the loan process.
`
`In general, the criteria will include:
`
`_ Your gross income
`. Cash liquidity for down payment, closing costs, and reserve requirements
`_ Current debts
`
`. Credit history
`. Type of mortgage loan you select
`. Current interest rates
`
`. Any company sponsored relocation assistance
`
`A very broad ratio for conventional approval would be no more than 28% of
`gross monthly income for your mortgage payment and no more than 36% of
`gross monthly income for debts. Your lender will calculate your total
`projected monthly housing expense: principal & interest, taxes, and
`insurance (PITI) plus any other fixed expenses such as home owner's
`association dues. The new ratio should fall between 28-33% with a debt ratio
`of 34-38% in most cases. Please note—every lender has their own criteria and
`program undewvriting which may call for specific numbers.
`
`Pre—qualil‘y yourself with the calculator below:
`
`lntructlons
`
`Monthly Income
`
`Salary &
`Wages
`
`-
`
`Monthly Housing Expenses
`
`Other
`Income
`
`Hazard
`Insurance
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Other Monthly Expenses
`Auto
`
`Payment
`Loan Term and Interest Rate
`
`Years In
`Loan Term
`
`Credit Cards &
`
`Other Payments
`
`Interest
`Rate
`
`You may qualify for maximum monthly mortgage
`payment (P+I) of:
`You may qualify for a maximum loan amount of:
`
`[-1
`
`RETURN TO TOP
`
`
`Jan DuBel|, GRI, ABR
`Steve DuBeII
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`Irving, Texas 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`http:.'lwww.bigdrea|esta1e.ne Ufinancialhtm
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBell. all rights reserved.
`
`Page 2 oI"2
`
`

`
`
`
`. BIG D R‘er.\| Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3.'3UlU4 9:27 AM
`
`Real t5Slai',r;.L
`

`
`'.:.«.~-
`
`DALLAS, TEXAS REAL ESTATE WITH THE DUBELL5
`
`welcome
`
`
`
`Much is happening in Dallas/Fort Worth. Use these links to help you
`become familiar with our area. Answer questions and view the wealth
`of information and photographs at your fingertips.
`
`Dallas Chamber of Commerce
`
`Enjoy Texas Hospitality
`
`Dallas Convention & Visitors Bureau
`
`BIG “D” Statistics. Demographics
`
`Locate Dallas Properties
`Maps & Driving Directions
`
`Search National flood mags
`View the Federal Emergency
`Management Agency (FEMA) site
`
`Dallas Area Aerial Photos
`
`Aerial Photos, Topographic Maps,
`Environmental Information, etc.
`
`Dallas Morning News
`Browse Dallas Headlines
`
`Dallas Photos
`
`View BIG “D” Skylines
`
`Dallas Schools
`
`Ratings for BIG “D" School Districts
`
`Listen to a Dallas Tune:
`
`
`
`http:l."www.bigdrealestate.neu'bigd.htm
`
`Page I of 2
`
`

`
` 2
`
`BIG D Real Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3!30.f04 9:27 AM
`
`Dallas Weather
`
`Check out BIG “D” temperatures
`
`State travel and tourism, general information RETURN TO TOP
`
`
`
`"Texas, Ou r Texas”
`
`Jan DuBeII, GRLABR
`Steve DuBe|l
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`irving, Texas 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBeH. all rights reserved.
`
`lmpjfwww. blgdreulcslate, netfbigdlhtm
`
`Page 2 M2
`
`

`
`
`
`7‘
`
`BIG D Real Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3130104 9:27 AM
`
`'
`
`' ; «.-~.
`
`-
`
`.
`
`
`
`DALLAS, TEXAS REAL ESTATE UVITH THE DUBELLS
`
`Welcome
`
`
`
`Dallas offers a diverse selection of entertainment and activities
`throughout the Metroplex area. Whether your tastes run in the Arts
`categories, or towards a rousing game of sports, you can be assured of
`a multitude of options. Explore the many attractions available.
`
`Southfork Ranch
`
`Filming location for the television series “Dallas” and home of “J R’'.
`Now a meeting/conference facility.
`
`Dallas Ballet
`
`Area renown, spectacular performances.
`See current engagements.
`
`Dallas Symphony
`Always a favorite with special performance events
`and ongoing schedules.
`
`Dallas Entertainment Guide
`
`Updated weekly. Calendar of events & activities including
`theater and concerts.
`
`Dallas Golf
`
`In-depth views and listings of area public courses.
`
`Dallas Horse Racing
`Enjoy a day at the races
`
`Dallas Lakes
`
`Area lake information with fishing, boating tips.
`
`Dallas Museum ofArt
`
`View current gallery displays and upcoming shows.
`
`Dallas Restaurants
`
`Select from fine dining to "Tex-Mex", sample the
`many choices available.
`
`Six Flags Over Texas
`
`Listen to a Dallas Tune:
`
`http:iiwww.bigdrealestateinellrecreation. htrn
`
`Page I of2
`
`

`
` ,
`
`.
`
`BIG D Real Estate: Dallas Homes and Ranches For Sale
`
`3130104 9:27 AM
`
`Amusement park fun for all ages. Special holiday
`theme events and festivities.
`
`Dallas Sports Teams
`
`Dallas Stars Hockey
`
`Dallas Cowboys Football
`
`Dallas Mavericks Basketball
`
`Dallas Texas Rangers Baseball RETURN TO TOP
`
`T.__T.
`
`Jan DuBe||, GR|, ABR
`Steve DuEJel|
`523 Ranch ‘Frail, Suite 142
`Irving, Texas 75063
`office 972.831.8568
`
`copyright 2000 Jan DuBell. all rights reserved.
`
`http:h‘www.bigdrealestate.neL’rn:creation. hlm
`
`Page 2 of 2
`
`

`
`
`
`A at
`
`Opposition No. 91 156821
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`Serial No. 78/105,321
`
`Mark: BIG "D" REAL ESTATE
`
`Filed: January 28, 2002
`
`Published: January 21, 2003
`
`llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
`
`04 _o9_20Q4
`Pm“; moicim mu Flcptbt. «:2
`
`“'5'
`
`)
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`)
`)
`
`JUDY MCCUTCI-IIN,
`
`OPPOSER,
`
`v.
`
`JAN DUBELL,
`
`—
`
`APPLICANT.
`
`Commissioner for Trademarks
`2900 Crystal Drive
`Arlington, Virginia 22202-3514
`
`PP
`
`R’
`
`N
`
`T E
`
`RELI N
`
`Opposer, Judy McCutchin (“McCutchin”), in accordance with Rule 2.122(e) of the
`
`Trademark Rules of Practice, submits the following copies of publications available to the
`
`general public through libraries and/or general circulation:
`
`1.
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`5.
`
`6.
`
`Exhibit A: Nexis printout of article dated November 25, 2001 from The Dallas
`Morning News’ Ideas at Work Column.
`
`Exhibit B: Nexis printout of article dated October 26, 2001 from The Dallas
`Morning News’ Real Estate Column.
`
`Exhibit C: Nexis printout of article dated October 12, 2001 from The Dallas
`Morning News entitled “KPMG Deal Reawakens Sleepy Dallas Oflice Real-
`Estate Market” by Steve Brown.
`
`Exhibit D: Nexis printout of article dated July 8, 2001 from The Dallas Morning
`News’ Ideas at Work Column.
`
`Exhibit E: Nexis printout of article dated June 20, 2001 from The Press
`Enterprise ‘s Andy McCue Column.
`
`Exhibit F: Nexis printout of article dated June 10, 2001 from The Dallas Morning
`News’ Ideas at Work Column.
`
`

`
`
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`Exhibit G: Nexis printout of article dated June 3, 2001 from The Dallas Morning
`News entitled “Irving, Texas, Takes a Look at Tourism Data” by Suzanne Marta.
`
`Exhibit H: Nexis printout of article dated May 6, 2001 from The Dallas Morning
`News’ Ideas at Work Column.
`
`Exhibit 1: Nexis printout of article dated April 11, 2001 from Tulsa World
`entitled “Leaders See Tulsa, Okla., Shifting toward Tech Emphasis” by Nicole
`Nascenzi.
`
`Exhibit J: Nexis printout of article dated March 6, 2001 from the Fort Worth
`Star-Telegram entitled “Dallas/Fort Worth Airport Uses Aviation Forum to Woo
`International Flights” by Bryon Okada.
`
`ll.
`
`Exhibit K: Nexis printout of article dated February 7, 2001 from The Dallas
`Morning New entitled “Amtrak Plans New York City-Dallas Route" by Tony
`Hartzel.
`
`Exhibit L: Nexis printout of article dated October 31, 2000 from The Dallas
`Morning News’ Robert Miller Column.
`
`13.
`
`Exhibit M: Nexis printout of article dated October 15, 2000 from The Dallas
`Morning News’ Ideas at Work Column.
`
`Exhibit N: Nexis printout of article dated September 24, 2000 from The Dallas
`Morning New entitled “Air Travelers Discover Benefits of Dallas Love Field" by
`Katherine Yung.
`
`Exhibit 0: Nexis printout of article dated September 24, 2000 from The Dallas
`Morning New entitled “Dallas-Based Magazine Aims to Portray City as High-
`Tech Mecha” by John Kirkpatrick.
`
`15.
`
`If
`
`If
`
`If
`
`I!
`
`II
`
`If
`
`

`
`
`
`.
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`These publications are relevant because each evidences the general public’s
`
`understanding of the phrase “Big D” to refer to the city of Dallas, Texas.
`
`Dated: April 9, 2004
`
`By:
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`\
`
`ig
`Kurt
`Elizabeth A. Linforcl
`
`KOENIG & ASSOCIATES
`
`Attorneys for Opposer
`220 East Figueroa Street
`Santa Barbara, CA
`Tel: 805-965-4400
`
`Fax: 805-564-8262
`
`Email: Kurt@IncIP.com
`
`

`
`
`
`’J
`
`c-
`
`Opposition No. 91156821
`
`RTIFI AT
`
`F MAI
`
`1
`
`BY XPRE
`
`I
`
`I hereby certify that the foregoing document is being deposited with the United States
`Postal Service as “Express Mail Post Office to Addressee” in an envelope addressed to:
`Commissioner for Trademarks, 2900 Crystal Drive, Arlington, VA
`22202-3514, on the date identified below.
`
`Express Mail Mailing Label No. EV066295711US
`
`Dated: April 9, 2004
`
`ERTIFI AT
`
`F ER I E
`
`I, Elizabeth A. Linford, hereby certify that I caused a copy of the foregoing document to
`be served on April 9, 2004 by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed to:
`
`Jan DuBell
`
`523 Ranch Trail, Suite 142
`
`Irving, Texas 75063
`
`Executed this 9th day of April 2004 at Santa Barbara, California.
`
`ELIZ
`
`H A. LINFORD
`
`

`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`
`
`
`2 of 89 DOCUMENTS
`
`Copyright 2001 Knight Rldder/Tribune Business News
`Copyright 2001 The Dallas Morning News
`The Dallas Morning News
`
`November 25, 200 l, Sunday
`
`KR-ACC-N0: DA-IDEAS-WORK-COL
`
`LENGTH: 1334 words
`
`HEADLINE: The Dallas Morning News Ideas at Work Column
`
`BYLINE: By Cheryl Hall
`
`BODY:
`
`Zola and Enzo have had all of the camera they can handle for the moment. There's only so much sit-and-stay even a
`well-mannered dog can stand.
`
`David Sutton, the man squatting behind the camera, senses this and gives them a happy, dismissive wave. The large
`Doberman mix and even larger Akita-Rottweiler dart off in grand abandon, turning an open area of the Dallas photo
`studio loft into an impromptu canine romping ground.
`
`“[ try to strike a balance and give the dogs a little play break to keep their spirits up," Mr. Sutton says as he
`summons Zola and Enzo back to modeling duty. "For the most part, good-natured dogs find this new and entertaining.
`There's a larger number of cats that would rather not be here at all."
`
`Mr. Sutton, owner of Sutton Studios in Evanston, Ill., has been dubbed the Dr. Doolittle of pet photography for his
`almost telepathic ability to communicate with animals. So much so that last summer, Forbes fyi Magazine, the quarterly
`lifestyles supplement to the financial publication, anointed him the best at his craft.
`
`He's in Big D to broaden his client base, having picked a handful of U.S. cities where he thinks his black-and-white
`portraits, which come with $ 4,000 to $ 5,000 price tags, will be appreciated. He intends to return several times a year to
`immortalize some of Dallas‘ most pampered pets.
`
`Stacey and Arnie Verbeek, who have no human children, plopped down the big bucks because they believe Mr.
`Sutton will capture the chemistry and personality of their beloved Zola and Enzo, foundlings from the Dallas SPCA.
`
`Mrs. Verbeek saw the Forbes fyi mention and wanted to mark the couple's eighth anniversary with a family
`portrait.
`
`"l went, ‘Wow! He's really able to record the bond,"' says the 37-year-old chief administrative officer for
`SnyderCapital Corp. and a local volunteer for the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. "In my mind, a
`portrait of my husband would be incomplete without his two shadows."
`
`The key to Mr. Sutton‘s success is the patience of Zen.
`
`While he professes love for both cats and dogs, he says canines are easier to photograph because most cats only
`travel to the veterinarian, so they're wired for sound when they get to the studio.
`
`Mr. Sutton was originally slated to begin a national tour in Dallas on Sept. 12, with subsequent photo shoots
`planned for San Francisco, New York, and Los Angeles. He was pulling up to Chicago's
`
`

`
`
`
`O'Hare International Airport in a limousine when he heard the first reports of a plane hitting the World Trade
`Center.
`
`"My itinerary now looks like scrambled eggs," he says. His and his wife's recent adoption of a baby girl has further
`complicated travel plans. But Dallas was a must.
`
`"lt's in the Texas State Constitution that you must have a dog to live here, isn't it?" he asks with a chuckle.
`"Besides, Dallas will be a really good, warm place to go to in April when we're about to lose our minds in Chicago
`because winter's never going to end."
`
`Mr. Sutton, you see, intends to mix pleasure with more pleasure.
`
`Once a free-lancer for corporate annual reports and publications such as Forbes, Newsweek, and PC Week, the 43-
`year-old native of South Bend, Ind., has traded the boredom of mug shots for the joy of mutt shots.
`
`His commercial work includes animal photos used in advertisements for Merck Phan'naceutical's heartworm and
`flea products and for Sky vodka. "Drugs and alcohol," he quips.
`
`For the third year, New York-based Walden Printing Co. has produced a dog calendar with all proceeds going to
`humane societies and animal protection leagues. Its president, Roger J ibboni (who brings his Boston terrier to work
`each day) saw Mr. Sutton's work in Forbes fyi and asked the Chicago photographer to donate his pictures toward the
`cause.
`
`Mr. Sutton immediately signed on with the stipulation that some calendars would go to shelters of his choice.
`
`As a result, Dallas’ Dog & Kitty City, the no-kill shelter run by the Humane Society of Dallas County, has 400 to
`sell at 3: 8.50 apiece, although Mr. Sutton is asking folks to pay at least 5; 10. "That way you don't have to worry about
`change, and come on, it's a worthy donation," he says.
`
`Becky Allison, who heads fund-raising for shelter, says that in addition to the money, she hopes it will entice
`people to adopt.
`
`"One of the dogs in the calendar looks just like one of our residents, Sinbad," she says of a 4-year-old
`Newfoundland mix who's been at the shelter since he was a pup. "And May looksjust like Rosie."
`
`Life changed for Mr. Sutton in 1993, when he got a mixed-breed cattle puppy named Zane.
`
`Mr. Sutton lived in a comer store in Evanston that he converted into a studio by pushing his desk and couch out of
`the way and setting up lights and a backdrop.
`
`One day, he'd quickly dispensed with photographing yet another suited executive for a magazine and got 4-month-
`old Zane to look incredibly dashing for the camera. A roll of film later, Mr. Sutton had a new passion.
`
`The next year, a local morning television show featured Mr. Sutton's work in a four-minute spot as part of Be Kind
`to Animals Week. The TV on-air personality thought David B. Sutton Photography sounded rinky-dink and asked if she
`could call it Sutton Studios.
`
`"So, she renamed my business," he says with a shrug. She also launched it.
`
`Since then, Mr. Sutton has photographed several thousand pets -- primarily dogs, and to a lesser degree cats, with
`an occasional rabbit, gerbil, guinea pig, or amphibian —- with or without their two-legged counterparts.
`
`"This one family had kids with terrible allergies to fur-bearing creatures, so they had furless pets," he says to
`explain the inclusion ofa toad and a lizard in the family lineup.
`
`His pet portraits now yield him $ 200,000-plus annually -- an amount that would have been inconceivable back
`when he was a free-lancer. "I thought if I could just gross $ 60,000, that would really be living," he says.
`
`Today, Mr. Sutton has more expansive plans with a greeting card company he named Semper Fido -- a play on the
`U.S. Marine Corp. motto semper fidelis, meaning always faithful.
`
`"Itjust popped into my head one day while washing dishes and thinking about where the name Fido comes from,"
`he says.
`
`

`
`
`
`Mr. Sutton, who has a degree in German language and literature from the University of California at Los Angeles,
`notes that it stems from the Latin root for loyalty.
`
`He'd like to model his business after William Wegrnan, who's made a fortune photographing dressed-up
`Weirnaraners, but Mr. Sutton wants to do it au naturel.
`
`‘ "Dogs and cats are already people; they're just not human," he says quite seriously. "Some people get a kick adding
`clothes or props. To me, that's like gilding a lily. Why? There's enough there already."
`
`His first Semper Fido sale was to Crate & Barrel, which is carrying a boxed set of note cards in its 80 stores. He
`landed that deal afier taking the portrait of an elderly golden retriever that belonged to the president of Crate & Barrel.
`
`Mr. Sutton just happened to bring along his portfolio when he dropped off the finished museum-quality prints of
`her dog.
`
`"That sale got Semper Fido going. We started with basically nothing, and they capitalized our business for us," Mr.
`Sutton says, the "us" being his partnership with Sutton Studio manager John Seden. "Most distributors didn't want to
`give John the time of day until he mentioned the boxed set going into Crate & Barrel. Then it was, 'Oh really? Send us
`some samples."'
`
`Mr. Sut-ton's pet portrait business has risen markedly since the terrorist attacks, beginning the day after.
`
`"People are thinking more about memories," he says. "The hardest thing about dogs is that they don't live nearly
`long enough. The whole time you have them, you're acutely aware that you'll outlive them."
`
`To see more of The Dallas Morning News, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.dallasnews.com/
`
`JOURNAL-CODE: DA
`
`LOAD-DATE: November 27, 200i
`
`

`
`
`
`EXHIBIT B
`
`

`
`
`
`4 of 89 DOCUMENTS
`
`Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News
`Copyright 2001 The Dallas Morning News
`The Dallas Morning News
`
`October 26, 2001, Friday
`
`KR—ACC-NO: DA—REAL—ESTATE-COL
`
`LENGTH: 905 words
`
`HEADLINE: The Dallas Morning News Real Estate Column
`
`BYLINE: By Steve Brown
`
`BODY:
`
`DALLAS IS LOW ON LIST OF ‘MARKETS TO WATCH’: Thank goodness for Detroit. And bless the folks in
`Indianapolis and Cleveland, too.
`
`If it weren't for those cities and a handful of others, the Dallas area would rank almost dead last in Lend Lease Real
`Estate Investment's annual survey of property investment and development locations.
`
`The "Markets to Watch" ranking has been a benchmark fixture of the annual Emerging Trends in Real Estate report
`for almost 20 years.
`
`Back in the late 1970s and early 19805, Dallas was a darling in this annual real estate beauty contest.
`
`Ofcourse, that was before the overbuilding and bank bailouts of the late 1980s and early 1990s.
`
`The real estate and finance folks Lend Lease interviews for this ranking of cities have never forgiven the Dallas
`area for past mistakes. The North Texas market is a perennial low ranker in the poll.
`
`The 2002 survey is no exception: Dallas places 23rd out of all the markets on investors’ and builders‘ wish lists.
`
`Even Baltimore and Philadelphia are better bets than Big D, if you buy the survey's results. Dallas also ranks
`behind all the other Texas cities in the survey.
`
`The report gives the Dallas area especially bad marks for sprawl -— even though it places Los Angeles in fourth
`place nationally.
`
`"The entire market suffers from weakening demand and pockets of oversupply," the report concludes. "Denizens
`wonder if the 9-to-5 downtown will ever recover."
`
`Gee, ain't it nice when outsiders state the obvious‘?
`
`But these criticisms can be tempered since all the biggest public real estate companies and institutional property
`investors such as pension funds continue to hang on to their assets in North Texas.
`
`At least St. Louis and Milwaukee got lower marks.
`
`SHOPPING CENTER LEASING: And now for some good news. Really.
`
`Expanding and relocating retailers leased more than 741,000 square feet of DaIlas—area shopping center space in the
`third quarter.
`
`

`
`
`
`The Dallas Morning News October 26, 2001, Friday
`
`Page 2
`
`That's after a decline of more than 1.1 million square feet in retail building occupancies in the second quarter,
`according to new statistics from Roddy Information Services Co.
`
`"The second quarter was I guess an anomaly clue to the Montgomery Ward closings and some other big ones," said
`company founder George Roddy. "Absorption was up overall for Dallas, but occupancy is continuing to go southward."
`
`Overall retail occupancy at the end of September was about 89 percent, down slightly from 90 percent at midyear.
`
`The increase in net leasing in the just-completed quarter is good given the large number of project openings.
`Almost 2.9 million square feet of new Dallas-area retail space opened in the third quarter. The biggest chunk of that was
`the new Shops at Willow Bend mall in West Plano.
`
`That brings the total retail building completions for the 12 months ending in September to almost 7 million square
`
`feet.
`
`RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY: Dallas‘ eastern suburbs continue to grow, with residential construction spreading
`into towns including Forney, Heath, and Fate.
`
`Developers have announced plans for a 550-acre residential community in the town of Crandall in Kaufman
`County.
`
`Called River Ridge, the $ 50 million project is being touted by developers as the largest mixed-use development in
`the State Highway 175 corridor.
`
`The first phase will kick off this spring with 100 lots.
`
`Located on the East Fork of the Trinity River, the development has been in the planning stages for more than a
`year. The project's developer, Northpark Phase I Ltd., also has other properties in the area.
`
`VILLAGE AT COLLEYVILLE: Developer Realty Capital Corp. has begun construction on the next phase of its
`Village at Colleyville project in Colleyville.
`
`Located on Main Street, the two three-story buildings will contain more than 60,000 square feet of retail and office
`space. Together the buildings will cost about $ 1 1 million.
`
`The developers also plan to build "upscale residential villas," according to developer Tom Wouters.
`
`Regions Bank provided the construction financing, and Archer-Western Co. is the general contract.
`
`Work on the buildings is scheduled for completion next summer.
`
`NEW OFFICE BUILDINGS: After working on the first two office buildings, Dallas-based Vector Project Services
`LLC has been hired to market four more buildings in the Mercer Crossing development at the northwest corner of LBJ
`Freeway and Interstate 3515.
`
`The assignment includes two new buildings with more than 320,000 square feet. The Three Hickory Centre and
`Four Hickory Centre office buildings will be completed during the new few months.
`
`"One Hickory Centre is already 100 percent leased, and Two Hickory Centre is more than 75 percent leased," said
`Wayne Swearingen, Vector Project Services founder.
`
`EXECUTIVE CHANGES: Staubach Co. has announced two major executive changes.
`
`Tom Lynn, who recently sold his family's independent industrial brokerage company, has joined Staubach as
`executive vice president in the industrial Southwest corporate services division. The operation serves industrial
`customers in five states.
`
`And Clay Smith has been promoted to director of the Southwest region retail services division. Mr. Smith was
`previously vice president of Staubach‘s Dallas retail services operation.
`
`To see more of The Dallas Morning News, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.dallasnewscoml
`
`JOURNAL-CODE: DA
`
`

`
`
`
`"
`
`The Dallas Morning News October 26, 2001, Friday
`
`Page 3
`
`LOAD—DATE: October 27, 2001
`
`

`
`
`
`EXHIBIT C
`
`

`
`
`
`5 of 89 DOCUMENTS
`
`Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News
`Copyright 2001 The Dallas Morning News
`The Dallas Morning News
`
`October 12, 2001, Friday
`
`KR-ACC-NO: DA—l{PMG-OFFICE
`
`LENGTH: I008 words
`
`HEADLINE: KPMG Deal Reawakens Sleepy Dallas Ofiice Real-Estate Market
`
`BYLINE: By Steve Brown
`
`BODY:
`
`KPMG's new office lease is a big addition to downtown Dallas‘ bottom line.
`
`The lease KPMG just signed for 200,000 square feet in the Maxus Energy Tower will move more than 1,100
`people to the city's core.
`
`"1 can't think of a recent deal this large downtown," said Tony Long, managing director for Trammell Crow Co.,
`which negotiated the seven-floor office lease. "It's not a bad deal for what's supposed to be a down market."
`
`The downtown rental deal is one of a string of major office leases in recent weeks that have livened up Dallas’
`sleepy commercial real estate market.
`
`Just a week before the KPMG transaction was announced, Crow Co. inked another five-floor lease in the Campbell
`Centre towers along North Central Expressway. Hotel service company Pegasus Solutions Inc. is taking 81,000 square
`feet.
`
`But statistics show that there's a long way to go before the office market is completely healthy.
`
`Rising vacancy rates and falling rents are a grim reality for landlords.
`
`During the third quarter alone, tenants moved out of almost 600,000 square feet of additional office space.
`
`And an additional 8 million square feet-plus of office space is being marketed for rent by companies that no longer
`need the facilities.
`
`All together, the amount of vacant and sublease space adds up to more than 34 million square feet that's going
`begging in Big D. That represents more than in all the office buildings in downtown Dallas.
`
`Leasing agents and building owners say that the economy will have to pick up before the acres of empty offices are
`filled.
`
`"Demand for offices has fallen off, just like demand for houses and cars and new suits," said developer Jeff Swope
`of Champion Partners. "Things had already slowed down before Sept. 11.“
`
`About the time of the terrorist attacks, Champion Partners was completing one of the biggest suburban office

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket