throbber
To:
`Subject:
`Sent:
`Sent As:
`
`NATHANIEL L FINTZ(trademarkprosecution@zuberlawler.com)
`U.S. Trademark Application Serial No. 90975326 - A.F.C - 3004-1004
`February 13, 2024 06:24:48 PM EST
`tmng.notices@uspto.gov
`
`Attachments
`
`screencapture-www-niehs-nih-gov-health-topics-agents-essential-oils-17078648122901
`screencapture-www-webmd-com-vitamins-ai-ingredientmono-915-medium-chain-
`triglycerides-mcts-17078648689521
`screencapture-www-ncbi-nlm-nih-gov-pmc-articles-PMC5456241-17078649537561
`screencapture-onlinelibrary-wiley-com-doi-abs-10-1002-9781119829614-ch3-
`17078650740461
`screencapture-nclpub-wipo-int-enfr-17078651106371
`screencapture-nclpub-wipo-int-enfr-17078651416971
`screencapture-nclpub-wipo-int-enfr-17078651678911
`screencapture-www-fda-gov-drugs-drug-approvals-and-databases-drugsfda-glossary-terms-
`17078651997031
`screencapture-www-merriam-webster-com-dictionary-drug-17078652387811
`screencapture-www-oxfordlearnersdictionaries-com-us-definition-english-drug_1-
`17078652987231
`screencapture-www-ahdictionary-com-word-search-html-17078653264601
`screencapture-www-ahdictionary-com-word-search-html-17078653562001
`screencapture-www-merriam-webster-com-dictionary-salutary-17078653741101
`screencapture-www-nia-nih-gov-health-medicines-and-medication-management-taking-
`medicines-safely-you-age-17078654105951
`screencapture-www-ahdictionary-com-word-search-html-17078654668441
`screencapture-www-oxfordlearnersdictionaries-com-us-definition-english-accurate-
`17078654928411
`screencapture-www-ahdictionary-com-word-search-html-17078655123571
`screencapture-www-oxfordlearnersdictionaries-com-us-definition-english-explicit-
`17078655308351
`screencapture-www-merriam-webster-com-dictionary-tincture-17078655864401
`screencapture-www-ahdictionary-com-word-search-html-17078656436621
`screencapture-www-oxfordlearnersdictionaries-com-us-definition-english-tincture-
`17078656635771
`screencapture-advocatesforcannabis-com-collections-all-17078656837021
`screencapture-www-healthline-com-health-cbd-oil-vs-tincture-17078657069231
`screencapture-www-medicalnewstoday-com-articles-cbd-oil-vs-tincture-17078658543961
`screencapture-greatist-com-live-what-is-cbd-oil-and-cbd-tincture-17078658903991
`
`United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)
`Office Action (Official Letter) About Applicant’s Trademark Application
`
`U.S. Application Serial No.  90975326
`
`Mark:   A.F.C
`
`

`

`Correspondence Address:  
`NATHANIEL L FINTZ
`ZUBER LAWLER LLP
`260 MADISON AVE STE 8021
`NEW YORK NY 10016
`UNITED STATES
`
`Applicant:   AFC Collective LLC
`
`Reference/Docket No.  3004-1004
`
`Correspondence Email Address:   trademarkprosecution@zuberlawler.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION AFTER FINAL ACTION DENIED
`
`Issue date:   February 13, 2024
`
`Applicant’s request for reconsideration is denied.   See 37 C.F.R. §2.63(b)(3).  The trademark
`examining attorney has carefully reviewed applicant’s request and determined the request did not:  (1)
`raise a new issue, (2) resolve all the outstanding issue(s), (3) provide any new or compelling evidence
`with regard to the outstanding issue(s), or (4) present analysis and arguments that were persuasive or
`shed new light on the outstanding issue(s).  TMEP §§715.03(a)(ii)(B), 715.04(a).  
`
`The applicant's amendment to the Identification of Goods made in the Request for Remand on
`November 30, 2023 fails to clarify the goods.  Accordingly, the requirement to clarify the Identification
`the Office action dated February 14, 2022 is  maintained and
`of Goods made final
`in
`continued.   See  TMEP §§715.03(a)(ii)(B), 715.04(a).  
`
`
`I. The classification of the goods is not clear (TMEP §§1401 et seq.)
`
`As worded, the classification of the goods is not justified in Cl. 5 without further specification as they
`may encompass Cl. 3 goods. Specifically, it is not clear whether these goods are predominately
`comprised of essential oils or non-essential oils.
`
`“As of September 1, 1973, the international classification of goods and services is the controlling
`classification used by the United States, and it applies to all applications filed on or after September 1,
`1973, and their resulting registrations, for all statutory purposes.   See 37 C.F.R. §2.85(a).” TMEP
`§1401.02. “International trademark classification, and the headings of the international trademark
`classes, are established by the Committee of Experts of the Nice Union and set forth in the International
`Classification of Goods and Services for the Purposes of the Registration of Marks (Nice
`Classification) published annually by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) on its
`website.” TMEP §1401.02(a).
`
`Applicant identifies its goods as oils “derived from seed-producing plants” that are “accompanied by
`medium-chain triglyceride oil;” as “herb oil accompanied by medium-chain triglyceride oil;” and as
`“herb oil extracts accompanied by medium-chain triglyceride oil.” While medium-chain triglyceride
`
`

`

`oils are not essential oils, oils derived from seed producing plants, “herb oils” and “herb oil extracts” all
`encompass essential oils. “Essential oils, which are obtained through mechanical pressing or
`distillation, are concentrated plant extracts that retain the natural smell and flavor of their source.” See,
`NIH
`National
`Institute
`of
`Environmental
`Health
`Science,
`https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/agents/essential-oils;
`  https://www.webmd.com/vitamins/ai/ingredientmono-915/medium-chain-triglycerides-mcts.  They are
`extracted from “  Flowers, of course, including: orange, pink, lavender, and the (clove) flower bud or
`(ylang-ylang) bracts,  
` Leaves, most often, including: eucalyptus, mint, thyme, bay leaf, savory, sage,

`pine needles, and tree underground organs, e.g., roots (vetiver),  
` Rhizomes (ginger, sweet flag),  


` Seeds (carvi, coriander),  
`  Fruits, including: fennel, anise, Citrus epicarps, 
`    Wood and bark,

`including: cinnamon, sandalwood, rosewood.”  Essential Oils’ Chemical Characterization and
`(nih.gov),
`Investigation of Some Biological Activities: A Critical Review
`- PMC
`https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5456241/;
`https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/9781119829614.ch3#:~:text=Antimicrobial%20property%2C%20food%20security%2C%20extension,management%20are%20among%20the%20applications. 
`Under the Nice Classification, essential oils are Cl. 3 goods: “ Some products, however, are always in
`Class 3 regardless of purpose, such as essential oils….” The Nice Classification, Class 3 Info File,
`https://nclpub.wipo.int/enfr/?version=20240101&notion=information_files&class_number=3&lang=en.
`Thus, even though essential oils are used for Cl. 5 purposes they would remain in Cl. 3.
`
`If applicant’s goods are comprised predominantly of essential oils, the goods remain properly classified
`in Cl. 3. While the applicant indicates that its goods are accompanied by “medium-chain triglyceride
`oil,” “accompanied” is insufficient to indicate the proper classification of the goods. Under the Nice
`Classification, “When a product, whether finished or not, is classified according to the material of
`which it is made, and it is made of different materials, the product is in principle classified according to
`the material which predominates.”  The Nice Classification, General Remarks, Goods,
`https://nclpub.wipo.int/enfr/?gors=&lang=en&menulang=en&notion=general_remarks&version=20200101.
`If these goods are predominantly comprised of essential oils, these goods are properly classified in Cl.
`3.
`
`If applicant’s oil goods are not comprised predominantly of essential oils, they are classified by their
`function or purpose, per The Nice Classification, General Remarks, Goods (a), “A finished product is
`in
`principle
`classified
`according
`to
`its
`function
`or
`purpose.”
`https://nclpub.wipo.int/enfr/?gors=&lang=en&menulang=en&notion=general_remarks&version=20200101.
`The “function or purpose” of applicant’s goods has been identified as “intended for reducing risk of
`disease;” “for the purpose of promoting functions of the body;” “intended to affect the structure or
`function of the body;” “for the purpose of affecting the structure or function of the body;” “for the
`purpose of promoting the structure or function of the body;” and “for the purpose of having a salutary
`effect on the structure or function of the body.” The identified functions/purposes generally fall within
`the definitions/common understanding of that of a “drug” or as being “medicinal”  –
`
`
`DRUG
`MW/FDA
`https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-approvals-and-databases/drugsfda-glossary-
`terms#:~:text=A%20drug%20is%20defined%20as,any%20function%20of%20the%20body;
`https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/drug
`A substance recognized by an official pharmacopoeia or formulary.
`A substance intended for use in the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease.
`A substance (other than food) intended to affect the structure or any function of the body.
`
`
`

`

`OL: https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/drug_1
`a substance used as a medicine or used in a medicine
`
`AHD:  https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=drug
`A substance used in the diagnosis, treatment, or prevention of a disease or as a component of a
`medication.
`
`
`
`
`
`MEDICINAL
`MW: Salutary
`https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/medicinal
`
`SALUTARY
`AHD: https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=salutary
`1. Effecting or designed to effect an improvement; remedial: salutary advice.
`2. Favorable to health; wholesome: a salutary climate.
`
`MW: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/salutary
`1: producing a beneficial effect : REMEDIAL
`salutary influences
`2: promoting health : CURATIVE
`
`
`NIH: “What are medicines?
`Medicines, often referred to as drugs, are used to prevent or treat diseases and other health
`conditions. Medicines can be obtained by a prescription or over the counter (OTC).”
`https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/medicines-and-medication-management/taking-medicines-safely-
`you-age#:~:text=all%20your%20medicines.-
`,What%20are%20medicines%3F,over%20the%20counter%20(OTC). 
`
`
`Thus, if applicant’s goods are not comprised in substantial part of essential oils, the goods are properly
`classified in Cl. 5 because their function/purpose aligns with those in Cl. 5 of the Nice Classification.
`
`To that end, please note that if these goods are comprised of essential oils, prefacing the goods with the
`term “tinctures” does not change their classification as noted in TMEP §1401.05(c): “If a product is
`normally classified in a particular class, an applicant cannot obtain registration in another class merely
`by identifying an ultimate use of the product in goods that fall in the other class.  Example - Essential
`oils are classified in Class 3. This item cannot be classified in Class 1 with an indication that it is used
`in the manufacture of other finished products. Raw or unfinished materials that are used in the
`manufacture of other finished products may be classified in Class 1. However, an item like essential
`oils, which is always classified in Class 3 regardless of its ultimate use, cannot be transferred to Class 1
`by adding Class 1 qualifying language.”  TMEP §1401.05(c).
`
`
`
`II. Section 1402.01 states that an identification “must be specific, definite,
`clear, accurate, and concise,” identify the goods “in an explicit manner,” and
`“the language used to describe goods and/or services should be understandable
`to the average person and should not require an in-depth knowledge of the
`relevant field.” TMEP §1402.01.
`
`

`

`
`Please note the following definitions:
`
`
`“Accurate” –  Conforming exactly to fact; correct and true in every detail;  conforming exactly to
`truth or to a standard
`https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=accurate;
`https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/accurate
`
`“Explicit” -  clear and easy to understand, so that you have no doubt what is meant; Fully and
`clearly expressed; fully revealed or expressed without vagueness, implication, or ambiguity :
`leaving no question as to meaning or intent
`https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/explicit,
`https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=explicit
`
`
`Also, the “ordinary meaning” or “common understanding” of the term at issue, “tincture,” is also
`important to establish before moving on to the analysis. By the definitions of well known, reputable
`dictionaries, “tinctures” are defined as –
`
`
`MW: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/tincture
`1: a solution of a medicinal substance in an alcoholic solvent
`
`AHD: https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=tincture
`1. A coloring or dyeing substance; a pigment.
`2. An imparted color; a tint.
`3. A quality that colors, pervades, or distinguishes.
`4. A trace or vestige: "a faint tincture of condescension" (Robert Craft).
`5. An alcohol solution of a nonvolatile medicine: tincture of iodine.
`6. Heraldry A metal, color, or fur.
`
`OL: https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/tincture
`a substance dissolved in alcohol for use as a medicine
`
`Thus, we can see that tinctures are alcohol-based medicinal solutions. They are not comprised of oils. 
`Each of the 216 tincture IDs indicates that the goods are comprised of oils. By the definitions of well
`known, reputable dictionaries, tinctures are not comprised of oils, but of alcohol. Therefore, the 216
`tincture IDs are inaccurate because they do not conform to the standard of tinctures being alcohol-
`based as established by these dictionaries, and their categorization as oil-based goods is incorrect. Thus,
`the IDs are unacceptable per TMEP §1402.01.
`
`Additionally, the tincture goods have not been identified in an explicit manner. For this additional
`reason, the IDs do not satisfy TMEP requirements. As indicated, above, to be explicit the goods must
`be identified in a manner that is clear, easy to understand, and so there is no doubt as to the meaning of
`the goods.  Well-known, reputable dictionaries define and establish “tinctures” as alcohol-based
`solutions.  Thus, identifying “tinctures” as oils raises doubt as to the nature of the goods. The ID is no
`longer clear or easy to understand, but rather is confusing in light of the established meaning of these
`goods. As such, the goods have not been identified in the requisite explicit manner.  
`
`Section 1402.03(f) does allow for “widely used industry terminology” to be deemed sufficient to
`identify goods when the following conditions are met: (1) that terminology at issue is definite; (2) the
`
`

`

`terminology at issue is limited to a single class; (3) that terminology is supported by dictionary
`definitions or other authoritative references.  See, TMEP §1402.03(f), “Widely used industry
`terminology that is definite and limited to a single class should be recognized as sufficient to identify
`the goods or services when supported by dictionary definitions or other authoritative references.”
`TMEP §1402.03(f).  Given the above dictionary definitions, the term “tinctures” when further defined
`as oils, is not definite terminology because it is not accurate or explicit, as explained, above. Second, as
`discussed previously, it is not clear whether these goods are limited to a single class.  If the goods are
`comprised predominantly of essential oils, these goods are properly classified in Cl. 3. Third, dictionary
`definitions do not support the use of the term “tincture” to identify goods comprised of oils. Therefore,
`these IDs do not meet the requirements of TMEP 1402.03(f) to allow these goods to register under the
`“widely used industry terminology” standard.
`
`Applicant’s website indicates that it is a provider of cannabidiol goods. The use of the term “tinctures”
`to describe oil-based products is not uniformly adopted within the cannabidiol industry and the use of
`“tincture” to describe oil-based goods has been noted as “confusing.”  
`
`
`1. Healthline: CBD Oil vs. Tincture: What’s the Difference?
`https://www.healthline.com/health/cbd-oil-vs-tincture
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`What is CBD oil?
`CBD oil is most often a blend of CBD extract and an inert  carrier oil, like  medium-chain
`triglyceride (MCT) coconut oil.
`What is a CBD tincture?
`A CBD tincture is an alcohol-based extract. High proof alcohol is used as a solvent to extract the
`natural compounds of the cannabis plant, and its also used in the finished product.
`
`2. Medical News Today What to know about CBD oils and CBD tinctures
`https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/cbd-oil-vs-tincture
`
`CBD oil and tinctures are similar products that both contain CBD derived from  hemp or other
`plants in the  Cannabis sativa family. While people may interchange the terms “CBD oil” and
`“CBD tincture,” they are different products.
`
`The main difference between the two is the method of extracting CBD. For oil, manufacturers use
`carbon dioxide, but for tinctures, they utilize alcohol.
`
`Using heat and pressure, manufacturers use the carbon dioxide method to separate CBD from the
`plant. Manufacturers generally regard this as the quickest and most efficient way to extract the
`substance. It is also environmentally safe, while the  Food and Drug Administration (FDA) also
`note that the method is safe.
`
`The process of creating a CBD tincture typically involves soaking cannabis in alcohol and slowly
`heating the mixture. This infuses the alcohol with CBD, which the manufacturer then boils or
`dilutes.
`
`Through these different extraction methods, manufacturers end up with slightly different products:
`CBD oil contains CBD suspended in a carrier oil, while tinctures are typically glycerin- or alcohol-
`based solutions.
`
`

`

`
`Generally, CBD oils will also contain a higher potency of CBD, but tinctures will have a longer
`shelf life. Additionally, people can use CBD oil orally or topically, but it is not advisable to use
`tinctures on the skin.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3. Greatist: CBD Tincture vs Oil: What Do They Really Do?
`https://greatist.com/live/what-is-cbd-oil-and-cbd-tincture
`
`“CBD tinctures and oils are used to help ease many conditions. People use CBD for things like
`sleep and anxiety relief to things like help with pain and inflammation.
`
`Tinctures have a reputation for fast-acting results, which makes them a strong choice for those
`looking to relieve pain. A tincture also tends to live longer on your nightstand since its base is
`preserving alcohol and not oil.
`
`Unlike CBD oils, tinctures are more challenging to find. Most CBD brands have a good selection
`of CBD oils to choose from, but for those looking for a tincture, you may have to search across a
`good handful of brands before finding one that suits you.
`
`Plus, many brands use the term tincture to describe an oil and vice versa, so it can be annoyingly
`confusing.”
`
`
`As these articles indicate, oils containing CBD are recognized as non-tincture goods. Outside of the
`CBD industry and CBD consumers, the identification of a “tincture” as an oil product would likely
`cause even greater confusion to the average consumer because, as indicated by the dictionary
`definitions, they are widely known as alcohol-based goods. For this reason, this language used to
`describe applicant’s goods oil-based goods would not be understandable to the average person without
`an in-depth knowledge of the cannabidiol products field, and even then it appears that it may cause
`confusion amongst such consumers.
`
`
`III. Section 1402.05 indicates that an identification is unacceptable if the
`ordinary meaning of the identification language is at variance with the
`goods evidenced by any part of the record.
`
`TMEP Section 1402.05 states that “[a]n identification is unacceptable if it is inconsistent with the
`goods or services indicated by the specimens or if the ordinary meaning of the identification language
`is at variance with the goods or services evidenced by the specimens or any other part of the record.” 
`TMEP §1402.05.  
`
`
`IV. TMEP §1402.07
`
`
`When an ID is ambiguous, the ID must be amended to a definite ID within the scope of the applied-for
`wording. TMEP §1402.07(b).  The originally applied-for wording that is the basis of these amendments
`is “Tinctures; Herbal tinctures.” As has been addressed previously, the originally applied-for IDs are
`
`

`

`unacceptable.  Applicant has indicated the function/purpose of its goods and applicant has indicated
`their composition, which under the Nice Classification is problematic, as discussed above. As noted in
`the dictionary definitions, above, “tinctures” are alcohol-based medicinal goods, not oil-based goods.
`Therefore, because the amendments do not fall within the ordinary meaning of the term “tinctures,”
`these amendments are outside the scope of the initially applied-for wording.
`
`
`
`
`If applicant has already filed an appeal with the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, the Board will
`be notified to resume the appeal.   See TMEP §715.04(a).  
`
`If applicant has not filed an appeal and time remains in the response period for the final Office
`action, applicant has the remainder of that time to (1) file another request for reconsideration that
`complies with and/or overcomes any outstanding final requirement(s) and/or refusal(s), and/or (2) file a
`notice of appeal to the Board.  TMEP §715.03(a)(ii)(B).
`
`
`/Kelly Trusilo/
`Kelly Trusilo
`Examining Attorney
`LO107--LAW OFFICE 107
`(571) 272-8976
`Kelly.Trusilo@USPTO.GOV
`
`
`
`

`

` An official website of the United States government Here'shawyouknow ¥
`
`Nha
`
`National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
`Your Environment. Your Health.
`
`Search NIEHS
`
`ela atacs
`
`(eet eeelial at
`
`.
`
`NotaTe
`
`> Table of Contents
`
`Essential Oils
`within the sameplantspecies,or from plantto plant. Synthetic oils are not considered true essential oils.
`
`Health & Ed
`
`+
`
`Health & Education
`Environmental Health Topics
`Environmental Agents
`Acrylamide
`Air Pollution and Your Health
`Algal Blooms
`Allergens
`Aloe Vera
`Arsenic
`BisphenolA (BPA)
`Cell PhoneRadio Frequency
`Radiation
`Climate Change
`Cosmetics and Your Health
`Dioxins
`Electric & Magnetic Fields
`Endocrine Disruptors
`Essential Oils
`Flame Retardants
`Formaldehyde
`Hazardous Material/Waste
`Hexavalent Chromium
`Hydraulic Fracturing & Health
`IndoorAir Quality
`Lead
`Mold
`Nanomaterials
`
`Introduction
`Whatare essentialoils?
`
`Essential oils, which are obtained through mechanicalpressing
`ordistillation, are concentrated plant extracts that retain the
`natural smell and flavorof their source
`
`Each essentialoil has a unique composition of chemicals, and
`this variation affects the smell, absorption, and effects on the
`body. The chemical composition of an essential oil may vary
`
`Have researchers studied essentialoils?
`
`Previous studies 7 have shownthat lavender and tea tree oil may act as endocrine
`disrupting chemicals (EDCs), which have been associated with severalhealth issues
`EDCsare substances in the environment(air, soil, or water), food sources, personal
`care products, and manufactured products that interfere with the normal function
`of your body's endocrine system.Also,clinical research 7 found a possiblelink
`between the topical use of essential oils and the onset of male gynecomastia, or the
`developmentof breasttissue, in prepubescent boys. Since lavenderandtea treeoil
`are composed of hundreds of chemicals, NIEHS scientists wantedto find out which
`of these chemicals displayed hormonalactivity that could potentially lead to
`prepubertal gynecomastia
`
`What is NIEHS Doing?
`
`The scientists applied pure essential lavenderoil, tea tree oil, or eight of their
`chemical components to humancelllines in test tubes, known asin vitro
`
`

`

`Perfluoroalkyl and
`Polyfluorealky! Substances
`(PFAS)
`Pesticides
`Radon
`Safe Water and Your Health
`Smoking and Vaping
`Styrene
`Weather Extremes
`
`experiments. They found that the compoundsdisplayed a range of hormonal
`activities, which may stimulate prepubertal gynecomastia in boys.
`
`Whichessential oils and components were tested in the NIEHS study?
`
`The researchers tested pure essential lavender andtea tree oils, as well as four
`chemicals commonly foundin both: eucalyptol, 4-terpinenol, dipentene/limonene,
`and alpha-terpineol. These compounds wereselected becausethe International
`Standard Organization mandatedthat they beincluded in both lavenderand tea
`tree oils. The NIEHS research team also studiedlinalyl acetate and linalool, which
`are specific to lavenderoil, and alpha-terpinene and gammaz-terpinene, which are
`specific to tea treeoil,
`Doother essential oils contain these chemicals?
`
`According to an analysis - of the chemical componentsof 93 essentialoils, the
`eight chemicals selected in the NIEHS study appeared in most, as indicated in the
`list below. Each of the eight chemicalsis followed by the numberofoils in whichit
`appeared.
`
`¢ dipentene/limonene - 90
`¢ alpha-terpineol- 87

`linalool - 82
`e 4-terpinenol - 80
`* eucalyptol - 79
`* gamma-terpinene - 79
`* alpha-terpinene - 77

`linalyl acetate - 62
`
`What age range are boys atriskforgynecomastia?
`
`Male gynecomastia is a commonclinical symptom observed during infancy,
`adolescence, and older age. Some physicians theorize that periods of major
`hormonal change maylead to the condition. However, prepubertal gynecomastia is
`relatively rare due to lowercirculating hormonelevels. Some scientists suspect that
`boys in this range may be moresusceptible to hormonal changes and disrupting
`chemicals, which may lead to gynecomastia.
`
`is directskin exposure the main link to malegynecomastia orcan smelling or inhaling
`essentialoils, as in aromatherapy, be linked, too?
`
`Theclinical cases have only described using essential oils on skin or topical
`exposure and not aromatherapy.In the NIEHS study, the team described whether
`topical exposure to the chemicals led te hormonalactivity. Further studies are
`needed to determineif the same can be said about aromatherapy.
`
`

`

`Aregirls affected by lavenderandtea tree oils?
`
`Because breast growthis a natural process for pubescentgirls, it is more difficult to
`determine whether pure essential lavenderoil or tea tree oil have the sameeffect in
`females as males.A clinical case was reported in 2019 ~that described abnormal
`breast growthin prepubescentgirls who had continuous exposure to lavender-
`fragranced products. The premature breast growth resolved when exposureto the
`lavender-containing products stopped
`
`Whatwere the results of tests usingpure essentialoils?
`
`NIEHSresearchers created different dilutions of the two types of pure essential ails
`and the eight selected chemical components and tested their activity. They found as
`the dilution increased, the EDC activity of the oils and chemicals decreased.
`
`Should the public discontinuethe use of essential oils? Why or why not?
`
`Using essential oils is up to the individual. The researchers want the public to be
`awareofthe findings, since some essentialoils and their components display
`hormonalactivity and could be potential EDCs.
`
`Further Reading
`Stories from the Environmental Factor (NIEHS Newsletter)
`*
`Botanical Safety Taken on by New Consortium 7(April 2020)
`
`Last Reviewed: February 17, 2022
`
`Follow Us
`National Institute of
`+) x) in) © © 8
`Environmental Health Sciences
`BSSEtsTeli)
`Policies & Services
`Contact Information
`teelag ey
`
`PERI g EMEUIREMeeoc)elec aeEC)
`
`Luise)dalaaieLe
`itesWc LCLU RLeo}
`SIMPLELMAOCMaera
`icoueliLtel eal
`WebPolicies & Notices
`LedaUw tad ey
`TeTiaPrate
`Website Archive (7
`LESaefe)a ca
`Visiting NIEHS
`Sign Up for NIEHS Updates
`
`Other Languages
`
`aes
`
`

`

`| faeat ee
`
`WebMD conditions Drugs & Supplements Well-Being|SymptomChecker —FindaDoctor More
`
`
`
`
`
`MENU Y
`
`Vitamins & Supplements
`
`> Medium Chain Triglycerides (Mcts)
`
`Medium Chain Triglycerides (Mcts) - Uses, Side Effects, and More
`OTHER NAME(S); 1,2,3-Propanetriol Trioctanoate, AC-1202, Acide Ca... Show More v
`
`
`
`|overview|Uses Side Effects Precautions Interactions Dosing Reviews(19)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Overview
`Mediumchain triglycerides (MCTs) are fats that are made in a lab from coconut and palm kerneloils.
`Typical dietary fats are called long-chaintriglycerides.
`
`MCTsare a fat source for people who cannottolerate othertypesoffats. These fats might also
`improve weight loss because the body can moreeasily break them down into molecules called
`ketone bodies. These ketone bodies can be usedfor energy.
`
`People use MCTsfor involuntary weightloss called cachexia or wasting syndrome. MCTsare also
`usedforobesity, seizures, athletic performance, Alzheimer disease, and many other conditions, but
`there is no goodscientific evidence to support these otheruses.
`
`y References
`
`MORE SIVIOBIRS Eevee.
`1, Whatto Know Before You Take
`Herbal Supplements
`
`2 Vitamins and Minerals: How Much
`Should You Take?
`
`3 Signs You’re Low on Vitamin B12
`
`

`

`Search Vitamins
`
`Related Vitamins
`
`Enter vitamin or supplement
`
`CommonSearches: AlphaLipoicAcid Apple CiderVinegar BlackCohosh|Calcium=Chromium
` lore v
`
`You Might Also Like
`Krill Oil
`
`Preventing HIV: How PrEP Works
`
`
`
`BMI Calculator: What Your Numbers
`Mean
`
`Explore Medicare Advantage &
`Prescription Drug Coverage
`
` @ planor treatment
`
`
`
`Information from this
`jon,
`
`
`onnatural
` For professional medical information
`Professional Version
`
`
`
`Recommendedfor You
`
`1 St. John's Wortfor Depression
`
`Loss?
`2 Garcinia Cambogia: Is ItSafe forWeight
`
`3 Vitamin K: How Much DoYou Need?
`
`Sign up for our free WebMD Daily Newsletter
`Get doctor-approved health tips, news, and mor
`
`Download WebMD App.
`pp Store
`iscsi
`
`ce
`
`Subscribe
`
`oAReeserMtr)
`+ ae
`fo}
`
`

`

`MeroeTeLeeaCeeae
`
`Cortes
`
`Teteeat
`
`©2005-2024 WebMDLLC, an InternetBrandscompany. Allrightsreserved. WebMDdoes not provide medical advice, diagnosis ortreatment. S
`
`Dodageceiceaeeosge
`agrees
`
`ceao erentesoa Measaeeeee Le
`
`Byusing t
`
`ite, you agreewith ouruse ofcookies, See ourcool Does
`
`

`

`
`3%Anofficialwebsite ofthe United States government Here's how you know v
`
`
`eoMeeMemereue a nae
`NIH) National Library of Medicine
`
`
`PMCPubMedCentral® Advanced Search|User GuideSearch PMC Full-Text Archive ESETaaa(e4
`
`
`Journal List > Medicines (Basel) > PMC5456241
`Inclusion in an NLM database does notimply endorsement
`Asa library, NLM provides accessto scientific literature.
`of, or agreementwith, the contents by NLM orthe NationalInstitutes of Health.
`
`Learn more: PMCDisclaimer | PMC Copyright Notice
`
`OTHER FORMATS
`PDF(1.0)
`ACTIONS
`
`
`
`
`
`Medicines (Basel). 2016 Dec; 3(4): 25.
`Published online 2016 Sep 22. doi: 10.3390/medicines3040025
`
`PMCID: PMC5456241
`PMID: 28930135
`
`Essential Oils’ Chemical Characterization andInvestigation of SomeBiological
`Activities: A Critical Review
`Wissal Dhifi,’ Sana Bellil?* Sabrine Jazi? Nada Bahloul,2and Wissem Mnif®*
`
` Lutfun Nahar, Academic Editor, Norazah Basar, Academic Editor, and Satyajit D. Sarker, Academic Editor
`
`> Authorinformation + Article notes » Copyright and License informaticn
`
`PMC Disclaimer
`
`SHARE
`~“~ 800
`—
`This review coversliterature data summarizing, on one hand, the chemistry ofessentialoils and, on
`a
`RESOURCES
`8
`_
`as
`eel
`the otherhand,their most importantactivities. Essential oils, which are complex mixturesofvolatile
`compoundsparticularly abundantin aromatic plants, are mainly composedof terpenes
`biogenerated by the mevalonate pathway. These volatile molecules include monoterpenes
`(hydrocarbon and oxygenated monoterpens), and also sesquiterpenes (hydrocarbon and
`oxygenated sesquiterpens). Furthermore, they contain phenolic compounds, whichare derivedvia
`=
`*
`a
`the shikimate pathway. Thanks to their chemical composition,essential oils possess numerous
`biological activities (antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial,ctc...) of great interest in food
`
`
`
`+
`
`Similar articles
`Cited by other articles
`Links to NCBIDatabases
`
`

`

`a
`
`nop: >
`
`and cosmetic industries, as well as in the humanhealthfield.
`Keywords:essentialoils, chemical composition, biologicalactivities
`
`1. Introduction Goto: >
`
`Theattraction of medicinal and aromatic plants is continuously growingdueto increasing
`consumers demandandinterestin these plants for culinary, medicinal, and other anthropogenic
`applications.
`As consumers are becoming more and more informedaboutissuesof food, health, and nutrition,
`theyare also becoming awareofthe benefits and potential applications of medicinal and aromatic
`plants and their metabolites. Theseplants producea large variety of secondary metabolites; among
`thei, essentialoils.
`
`Despite their rich and complex composition,theuseof essentialoils remains wideandlimited to the
`cosmetics and perfumery domains.It is worthy to developa better understandingof their chemistry
`andthebiological properties of these extracts andtheirindividual com

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket