From: Estrada, Linda
`
`
`
`Sent: 9/3/2014 2:07:40 PM
`
`
`
`To: TTAB EFiling
`
`
`
`CC:
`
`
`
`Subject: U.S. TRADEMARK APPLICATION NO. 85862951 - LYTNING - 00016-T0009A - Request for
`Reconsideration Denied - Return to TTAB - Message 1 of 8
`
`
`
`*************************************************
`
`Attachment Information:
`
`Count: 13
`
`Files: es-1.jpg, es-2.jpg, es-3.jpg, es-4.jpg, evsg-1.jpg, evsg-2.jpg, evsg-3.jpg, li-1.jpg, li-2.jpg, lig-1.jpg, lig-
`2.jpg, lig-3.jpg, 85862951.doc
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE (USPTO)
`OFFICE ACTION (OFFICIAL LETTER) ABOUT APPLICANT’S TRADEMARK APPLICATION
`
`
`
`
`
`*85862951*
`
`
`
`
`
`GENERAL TRADEMARK INFORMATION:
`
`http://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/index.jsp
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. APPLICATION SERIAL NO. 85862951
`
`
`
`MARK: LYTNING
`
`
`
`CORRESPONDENT ADDRESS:
` DAVID CHEN
`
` IP ATTORNEYS GROUP LLC
`
` 16 OXFORD RD FL 2
`
` MILFORD, CT 06460-3823
`
`
`
`APPLICANT: Columbia Insurance Company
`
`
`
`CORRESPONDENT’S REFERENCE/DOCKET NO:
`
` 00016-T0009A
`
`CORRESPONDENT E-MAIL ADDRESS:
`
`REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION DENIED
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`ISSUE/MAILING DATE:
`
`
`
`

`
`The trademark examining attorney has carefully reviewed applicant’s request for reconsideration and is
`denying the request for the reasons stated below. See 37 C.F.R. §2.64(b); TMEP §§715.03(a)(2)(B),
`(a)(2)(E), 715.04(a). The requirement(s) and/or refusal(s) made final in the Office action dated July 30,
`2014 are maintained and continue to be final. See TMEP §§715.03(a)(2)(B), (a)(2)(E), 715.04(a).
`
`
`
`In the present case, applicant’s request has not resolved all the outstanding issue(s), nor does it raise a
`new issue or provide any new or compelling evidence with regard to the outstanding issue(s) in the final
`Office action. In addition, applicant’s analysis and arguments are not persuasive nor do they shed new
`light on the issues. The examining attorney provides additional third party advertising evidence and
`third party registrations, which support the refusal and the finding that the goods identified by the
`parties are related and commonly travel in the same channels of trade.
`
`
`
`Accordingly, the request is denied.
`
`
`
`The filing of a request for reconsideration does not extend the time for filing a proper response to a final
`Office action or an appeal with the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (Board), which runs from the date
`the final Office action was issued/mailed. See 37 C.F.R. §2.64(b); TMEP §715.03, (a)(2)(B), (a)(2)(E), (c).
`
`
`
`If time remains in the six-month response period to the final Office action, applicant has the
`remainder of the response period to comply with and/or overcome any outstanding final
`requirement(s) and/or refusal(s) and/or
`to file an appeal with
`the Board.
` TMEP
`§715.03(a)(2)(B), (c). However, if applicant has already filed a timely notice of appeal with the
`Board, the Board will be notified to resume the appeal. See TMEP §715.04(a).
`
`
`
`

`
`/Linda M. Estrada/
`
`Trademark Examining Attorney
`
`Law Office 104
`
`(571) 272-9298
`
`(571) 273-9104 Fax
`
`Linda.Estrada@USPTO.gov
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.enviro5afet producta cornfpvc—and—rubber—boot5 ntml
`
`08f29f20l4 07 57 49 PM
`
`«9 envirosafety
`IDl'I!I\ £31’ Cfiflfl
`
`We carry Ilia lazgasl salentiu nfsalaty pnniunls
`all stamaei with uimstlrillkaalnl
`
`
`
`MY CART
`El mu have rr: Item: w your Shupplrlg cam
`
`Q
`
`Heme ‘V Fmtecrrl/9 (Jrtrmg
`
`>
`
`ProtettwgFrcrwenr , PVC And RubberB00ts
`
`5E;R:H ErmRE STORE HERE .
`
`PVC AND RUBBER BOOTS
`Here youll find a large selection of PVC and rubber boots perfect for manyjobs including farmings agriculture,
`dairies‘ lawn care‘ poultry and food protessing, mining, breweries‘ oil rigs‘ oil refineries‘ chemical plants.
`utilities. tonstruttinn. tontrete workand general maintenantel
`
`I BRAND
`Onguarcl Inciustties
`
`Tingley Rainwear
`
`Items 1 to 12 of 22 total Show
`Sort By
`
`HAZMAXKN[[BO0T- GIIGETGIZ
`
`13
`
`'
`
`V
`
`FL‘Ei1lDl1
`
`’
`STANDARDMKNS STIR TOE
`WORKSHOC - {JNGE5304
`
`MEN SWHTIE PVC EOOT -
`ONGBIOII
`
`NOWACCEPWNG
`
`Pa yPaI
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.enviro5afet producta comfpvc—and—rubber—boot5 mm!
`
`08f29f2014 07 57 49 PM
`
`$79.28
`Re The F\'r<l Tn Review Thu":
`Product
`
`$23.68
`
`$17.94
`
`1 RN|HNi5l
`
`5 RWIHNN
`
`
`MONJ\R(H MEN5 6]N(H §TE[l TOE
`WORISHOE-ONGB6604
`
`
`MONJ\R(H MENS 16 mm
`D]FI'[D NEOFRENE SNUGIEG
`KNEEBOOT-ONG86605
`BO0TS- '|'J'NMB92lB
`
`Muflarch Mens 6 Inch Steel
`Tne Wnrkzhne
`
`Muflarch Mens 16 Inch
`Kneehnm
`
`DiDDed Neuurene Snugleu
`Ram:
`
`j’
`
`$15.81
`
`1 “”'""'5’
`
`$13.77
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`$57.41
`
`1 “"""""5'
`
`
`TINGLEY HAHROOFBODTS —
`TINIIZEO
`
`
`15 m(H [(oNuMvPv( mu
`15 mm EETIIRGRAIJE w( KNEE
`BOOTS - '|'[N3ll5l
`BOOTS - '|'.|IN5H44
`
`Ting?ey HazPraof Boots
`
`Economy PVC Knee Scots
`Gnnd Perfnrmanre A1 An
`
`Our Better Grade PVC Knee
`Ham != Durahle On The
`
`ILL
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.envirosafet products cornfpvc—ahd—rubber—boots htmi
`
`08f29f20i4 07 57 49 PM
`
`$74.41
`
`5 “"""""5l
`
`$11.50
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`$22.01
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`.2?
`W?‘
`
`15 lN(H PREM]IR PV( mu BOOTS
`STANDARD KNEEB0l)T— ouamiau
`POLVBLLND MENS I6 INCH BOOT —
`- TlN!il45
`ONGfl6l0l
`
`,2‘
`
`The Premier Bout Line Sets
`The Standard For PVC
`
`Standard Kneeboot
`
`Pulyblend Mens 16 Inch Boat
`
`
`
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`$34.65
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`$21.08
`Be The First To Review This
`Product
`
`Items 1 to I 7 of 3') tntal Shrwv
`Sort
`
`._.r'
`
`Page:
`
`2
`
`.4»
`
`12
`
`'
`
`Pnsmnn
`
`V
`
`In your workplace, its imperative that you prevent slips and falls while protecting your employees’ feet from
`chemicals and toxic substances. At Envlro Safety Products, we know how important maintaining a safe
`workplace is to vou because it’s also important to us. We carrv a huoe selection of PVC and rubber boots that
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.envirosafet products comfpvc—and—rubber—boots html
`
`08f29f20f4 07 57 49 PM
`
`workplace is to you because its also important to us. We carry a huge selection OT WL and rubber boots that
`are ideal for a variety of applications so you can rest assured your workers are getting the highest level of
`protection available.
`Applications and Uses for Safety Bouts
`The protective boots in Enviro Safety Products’ extensive inventory are ideal for food processing, mining and
`chemical handling. Most of the safety boots in our catalog can be worn with other PPE, like disgsable
`coveralls and lab coats smocks and gowns. These cost-effective boots are also used in oil rig operations,
`dairies, breweries and other general industrial applications.
`The economical protective footwear and PVC boots in our catalog have superior resistance to animal fats
`(particularly poultry), acids, oils, greases and chemicals Some feature steel shanks for added arch support,
`while others have steel toes compliant with F2413-05. Some of our protective footwear comes with removable
`insoles, non—s|ip and se|f—c|eaning soles, and cutoff bands for height adjustment.
`Ideal for work in the food service industry, agricultural operations and laboratory work, the WC boots you'll
`find here meet or exceed federal regulations for protective footwear. Most are available in a wide range of
`sizes and colors, so you can choose the perfect protective foohivear for your workplace.
`Choosing the Right Protective Footwear for Your Operation
`When OSHA requires you to outfit your employees with protective footwear, protective clothing and other
`PPE, Enviro Safety Products is your one-stop shop. Our huge variety of affordable and economical WC boots
`makes staying compliant while protecting your workforce easy.
`
`APPROVED
`
`MT
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.enviro5afet products comfqioves—wori»<—qiove5 htmi
`
`09f02f20i4 02 09:16 PM
`
`9 envirosafety
`IDl'IfI\ £31 Cfiflfl
`
`WEIII1] tie lalgen sahltiul nfsalaty pnilms
`allstampal will llil Butkill harm!
`
`
`
`MY CART
`E mu have no Item: W your Shopping cart‘
`
`
`
`Home ‘V Work Gloves
`
`WORK GLOVES
`
`K \
`
`Chemical Resistant
`Gloves
`
`Coated Gloves
`
`Hiqh Temperature
`Gloves
`
`ility Traffic
`Hiqh Vis
`Gloves
`
`
`
`
`
`Arc Flash Gloves
`
`ATG lntelliqent Gloves
`
`Children Gloves
`
`i
`
`Disposable Gloves
`
`Fire 8: Rescue Gloves
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //www.envirosafet products comfqloves—worl»<—qloves wtml
`
`09f02f20l4 02 09:16 PM
`
`Insulated Work Gloves
`
`Knit Gloves
`
`Leather Gloves
`
`Mechanits Gloves
`
`Needle Stick Gloves
`
`Gloves
`
`Puncture Resistant
`
`
`
`Thirrsulate Gloves
`
`Police Gloves
`
`Performance Coated
`Gloves
`
`Weldig Gloves
`
`What kinds of genres do we stock’?
`As part of our commitment to our customers. we here at Enviro Safety Products continually strive to offer industry—|eading prices, products and
`customer service. Within our wide-spanning inventory, you can find some of the most trusted and respected glove manufacturers such as
`Hexarrrror, Maoa qloves , Whizard Gloves, Revco Industries and Slarrco. We carry the best brands because we want our customers to have acce§ to
`the best available products.
`Why you need safety gloves
`If you work in a field where gloves are indispensable, then you understand the importance of having the right protection for your hands. You rely
`on gloves to keep you — and those around you — safe. That’s why we have durable and reliable glove optiom for every person, no matter what their
`profession is. We have burn—resistant gloves that are ideal for welders and we also have disposable gloves that are an excellent solution for
`people that need basic hand protection Our disgosable gloves alone come in enough varieties to meet any of your needs. The selection we carry
`includes: latex, vinyl, powder-free, powdered, polyethylene and nitrile gloves
`Our extensive collection of gloves makes it easy for our customers to find products that meet their unique needs. If you have an atypical hand size,
`allergies or another unusual requirement. our abundant supply of assorted gloves makes it easy for you to find exactly what you need. We even
`carry gloves sized for children too.
`What are the benefits of safety graves?
`The technology that exists today makes it easy to create gloves that have a range of useful features. Some of today: gloves are able to resist
`punctures by needle: fend off flames thanks to bui|t—in fire—retardation properties and even protect the hands from heavy impacts.
`Functional as the human hand may be, without the proper protection, it is unable to withstand the demands of some grueling work environments.
`Everydayjob demands make it necessary for some people's hands to be continually gloved in order to avoid the risk of injury. Hands are
`vulnerable to an array of injuries that can be circumvented merely through the use of gloves. It always makes sense to have the correct pair of
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`09f02f20i4 02 09:16 PM
`http //wwwenvirosafet products comfqloves—wori»<—qloves ntml
`uu...=.au.= lu an array \Jl ...,u..=s uialxuii uc u.tu.i.uemeu metmy Ililuugli uic uaicui gluvca. .. alwnya ...a.m aicliac lu nave me LuirI:\l pan Ul
`safety gloves at the ready.
`How to pick the perfect pail of safety gloves
`When choosing gloves for your needs. there are a few guidelines and tips to always remember. First and foremost. understand that gloves are
`intended to serve varied purposes Do not assume that a heafl-d my glove will have the necessary flexibility you need to perform certain duties as
`part of yourjob. Similarly, a flexible and breathable glove may not work well if it is needed for heavy—duty work
`Another vital component of picking the right glove is about understanding how it will be used. Knowing which features in a glove you won't need
`can bejust as vital as knowing which features in a glove you will need. You can't always have the foresight necessary to spot gloverelated
`problems in advance, however. So if you feel that the glove that you're using for yourjob isn't performing as you had hoped it would, it's never too
`late to switch to a glove with different a different feature profile. It may end up being a worthwhile changeover. The perfect gloves are an
`investment that's not worth comprom'
`'ng on — you may be risking the safety of your hands when you fail to have a we||—se|ected set of gloves.
`Work gloves aren't designed to be fashionable. They're purpose—bui|t for the workers of the world who can't risk their safety (or the safety of
`others) on thejob. At Enviro Safety Products, we don't believe they should have to, either Work gloves are a precautionary measure designed to
`neutralize work hazards before they have an opportunity to cause harm or injury.
`Don't you want the best available protection for your hands?
`At Enviro Safety Producs, we carry a wide range of workgloves for every potential work-related need. Our gloves have the capacity to be used in
`a diverse set of applications, fromyobs that require dexterous hand movement to others that will test the strength of our gloves. No matter how
`you plan to test these gloves, we're confident that they will meet all of your requirements. We carry disposable gloves, leather gloves, cut resistant
`gloves, gloves for police, welding gloves and many other types of gloves. Whether you're looking for a glove that will let you safely workg
`extreme heat or you need one that will keep your hands secure while handling unsafe ob'ects we have an option foryou. Pairour high—
`temperature gloves with one of our flame-resistant shirts to get the ultimate in on-the-job safety.
`Don't let another day go by without the right form of protection for your hands. Having a we||—se|ected pair of work gloves can actually improve
`your performance on thejob by allowing you to workwithout the riskof injury lingering in your mind. And somegloves, like our an '
`ibration
`
`gloves, can actually make you more productiveon thejob. Our line of anti—vibration gloves is designed to reduced arm fatigue while handling
`Dower tools. allowing you to work harder and longer.
`As a company, Enviro Safety Products was built upon a handful of fundamental business principles. First and foremost is our commitment to our
`customers, which is evident in the way we keep our prices low and our wholehearted focus on customer satisfaction. We keep our customers happy
`with the basics: attentive service, fast shipping and the best available products. We believe that it doesn't take much else to create loyal customers.
`which is what everyone who shops with us becomes Buy from us today and experience what it means to shop with Enviro Safety Products.
`
`AFPROVED
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //ww/v.\abonviHe comlCham5aw—Work—Boots c 25 mm!
`
`09f02f2014 02 10:26 PM
`
`.e
`um.
`
`-
`L
`
`Ill
`
`Labonville Inc.
`
`Get more lime to pay
`
`CAIEGORV
`
`Hume > Chamsaw swam Bums
`
`Chainsaw &Work Boots
`
`*-. MA! JZJAL
`
`’.'.’nOLEE.F\LE
`
`Sub-Categnrles
`
`Carnhna Bums Bum Accessnnes
`Chainsaw sag); Bums
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`l
`
`LbGmrgm Bums Lam-nvme Bums. ‘Made m The us»
`
`NEW RELEASES
`
`Cmggewa Bums
`
`

`
`http //ww/v.\abonviHe comlCham5aw—Work—Boots c 25 mm!
`
`09f02f2014 02 10:26 PM
`
`MAILING LIST L.acm&§e Boots
`
`Pan Bootsa. Lmers FDrA\1u|ts&('.Inldren
`
`Rm: Boots
`
`LRubberwnrk Camn& Hurmng Bnuts nmmggnd Bums
`
`sum sum
`
`wuruenne Bums
`
`Dimst lmgrl mum
`
`watergmurWork Bnots
`
`Terms and {Dr
`
`
`
`Free currenqv
`aonversron by
`Dyna zcu veil:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //wwvv.labonville comlsearch asp7l»<e word:qloves&5earch:GO
`
`09/02/2014 02 11 27 PM
`
`Labon 1110 Inc. 1"
`
`'|:Fl:'‘g I:ar~—<:l mi
`
`EU inn
`warm try kaywnrd
`
`"TEIl:1Il scum
`
`’.'."nOLEEF\LE
`
`*T|ZJMEP.S l FALJa
`
`I
`
`L-5.l:‘!C-l'l\r'|LLE EL
`TOP SELLERS
`
`CATEGORY
`
`Yoursealch fol "gloves" returned the following Iasults...
`
`Search Results [I5 Matches found)
`
`|.Inmesm- [1]g MutPaga
`
`1s|An‘l crew Kit
`
`catannrv: safe;-1 clmmngsssear > Frvsmsn Kns& Pnucnes Fur (‘mags Belts
`25 Person Furst Ald Kit
`Your Pruze: $29.95
`EU €3.23
`Adam can
`
`Choku Extreme Immng Gloves — 962544)
`Category: clntmnga Acoaamria-.9 > Cllolm Snnwmnmle Cl|1lmng&Acu:L34ur>es
`Chuka ExtremeTauriHQ Gloves — 562540
`Your Pnce: $54.95
`EU €42.62
`
`Klnco Am: Lmeu PVC Gloves - B132
`Calagnry: Clmmnna Accessnms > Men Wnmen & K>ds's Glnves Mms Scarfsxx Lwlers
`Kmcu Arvlu: Lmed PVC Gloves — 3152
`Your PrH:e: $12.95
`EU €10.04
`
`Kinno Elna Sabra Weldlng Work Gluves—2DD15l?
`
`NEW RELEASES
`
`
`
`MAILING LIST
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //ww/v.\abonviHe comlsearch asmke word:q\oves&5earch:GO
`
`09/02/2014 02 11 27 PM
`
`calegnry: clolmnga Acoaawr > Men wnmen & K»ds's Gvnves Mms suarfsak Lmers
`Kmcu Blue Sabre Wa\dH1g Wnrk Slaves — 200159
`Your Pnce: $11.95
`EU ‘$1.21
`
`Add Cart
`
`Kumo Eoonugy Wnrk above — 14931.
`Calegnry: clolmnga Acoeuor > Men wnmen & K»ds's Ghves Mms Srzarfsfi Lmers
`Kmcu Ecunamy wurk Glove — 149fiL
`Your Pnue: 53.95
`EU €3.06
`
`KInDDGngErGlnves—1?7BL
`Category: cmmnga Acoessoms > Men Wnmen & Krcls's Gvnves rams scarfsa Lmers
`Kmcu Gflppar Ghnves — 177EL
`Your Pnce: $3.50
`EU €2.71
`
`Add Cart
`
`927
`Kmoo Insutatad Gbov
`Caleulvrv: QM > flfiE
`Kmcn ]n.su\ated Gmve - 1927
`Your Pnce: $15.95
`EU €12.37
`
`Kmoo Lmed Runner won: Gbuvcs — HTDL
`Kmau Lined RubberWurkG\uvss - a17uL
`Vuur Pnca: 55.95
`EU €11 G1
`
`
`Green Mesh Back-903
`km G|Dve5- 531
`Killoo P1
`categnrv: 5afe_ty Cmmng&Gear > sag-1 Gmves
`Kmccl Pxgskm Gmves — Safety Green Mash Back — sue.
`Yaw Pruzn-.: $10.95
`EIJ (31.49
`Add t4 can
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`
`http //ww/v.\abonviHe comlsearch asmke word:q\oves&5earch:GO
`
`09/02/2014 02 11 27 PM
`
`Kinoo P1
`
`km P.-awm lGreerI saf
`
`CulfG|uves-1919L
`
`catennrv: Safem Cvmmng ax Gear > sum Gvnves
`Kmcu Pwgskm Palm {Green Safety Cuff Gluvas - 1E19L
`Your Pnce: 512.95
`EU (1n.o4
`Add to cart
`
`Kmcn urunsmaten Cvmve — 1917
`categnry: clutmnua Acoeswries > Men Wnmen & Kns's Gvnves Mm Scarfsflz Lmers
`Kmcu Unmsmated Gluve - 1917
`Yum Pnce: 33.95
`
`Killcn Unirlsubated Gbovewnh Kmtcuff-1517K\N
`catannrv: CImmngaA:cessun:s > Men wnmen &K>as'sGvnves Mms 5carfs&Lmers
`Kmccl Umnsmatea Glclva Wlth Knit Curr - 1E1?KW
`Yuur Pnce: 53.95
`EIJ {G 94
`Add
`can
`
`‘A:
`lilnreresurtsz mg Next Pagg
`
`Term: and r
`
`Free currency
`aonversron
`[lynanllc Converter