throbber
BULKY
`
`DOCUMENT
`
`(FILED ON PAPER — ENTIRE DOCUMENT EXCEEDS 100 PAGES)
`
`Proceedin; No.
`
`85686787
`
`Filing Date
`
`12/23/2013
`
`*'U S33"8«—+
`
`r— O ""3 i
`
`85686787
`
`

`
`‘
`
`1
`
`**PF 1 we place on Upperfiight Corner**
`**of‘v<é.~3ponse to Office Action ONLY.”
`
`Examining Attorney: BLANDU, FLORENTINA
`Serial Number: 85/686787
`
`Docket No. 32TM-171237
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`In re Application of:
`
`Examining Attorney
`
`No Good Entertainment, Inc.
`
`Floremina Blandu
`
`Serial No: 85/686787
`
`Law Officez 117
`
`Design
`
`Filed:
`
`July 21, 2012
`
`Class:
`
`41
`
`Mark:
`
`FBA FANBOY ARMAGEDDON &
`
`RESPONSE TO OFFICE ACTION
`
`Commissioner for Trademarks
`P.O. Box 145 1
`
`Alexandria, VA 22313-1451
`
`Dear Commissioner:
`
`Applicant hereby responds to the Office Action of June 17, 2013.
`
`APPLICANT’S MARK IS ENTITLED TO REGISTRATION
`
`I.
`
`There is No Likelihood of Confusion with the Cited Registrations
`
`The Examining Attorney has issued a final refusal
`
`to register the mark FANBOY
`
`ARMAGEDDON & Design for “Pre-recorded DVD's featuring an on-going game show series;
`
`downloadable screensaver software for use on personal computers; computer and video game
`
`software; downloadable games, applications, ring tones and ring backs available via a global
`
`computer network and wireless devices; pre-recorded video clips and promotional spots on CDs,
`
`video tapes and DVDs featuring content relating to an on-going game show series; prerecorded
`
`

`
`video shorts and promotional spots on CDs, video tapes and DVDs featuring content related to
`
`an on-going game show series; digital materials, namely, downloadable pre—recorded audio files,
`
`Video files and graphics files for use in handheld wireless devices and all featuring content from
`
`or relating to an on-going game show series” in International Class 9 and “Entertainment
`
`services in the nature of live performances and games; an on-going game show series; interactive
`
`online entertainment
`
`in the nature of a website containing photographic, video and prose
`
`presentations, related film clips and other multimedia materials featuring an on-going game show
`
`series; Providing online computer, video and interactive electronic games via computer networks
`
`and global communications networks relating to an on-going game show series” in International
`
`Class 41 under Section 2(d) of the Trademark Act on the grounds of a likelihood of confusion
`
`with the following marks (“Cited Marks”):
`
`1. Reg. No. 4,158,541 — FANBOYNATION & Design for providing on-line magazines
`
`the field of comic books, science fiction, mixed martial arts, professional wrestling, music and
`
`movies, owned by Robert Samo.
`
`2.
`
`Reg. No. 3,761,586 — NICKELODEON FANBOY AND CHUM CHUM for
`
`entertainment services in the nature of television series, featuring animation, comedy, and drama;
`
`providing online information in the field of entertainment concerning television programs,
`
`owned by Viacom International, Inc.
`
`3. Reg. No. 3,143,958 — FANBOY RADIO for streaming of audio radio programs and
`
`other audio multimedia materials relating to the review and enjoyment of comic books via the
`
`Internet and entertainment services, namely, providing a website featuring information relating
`
`to review and enjoyment of comic books including reviews, drawings, photographs and
`
`interviews; production of radio programs, owned by Meteorite Entertainment, Inc.
`
`SMRH:4l4833991.l
`
`-2-
`
`

`
`Applicant requests that the Examining Attorney reconsider the final refusal to register
`
`under Section 2(d) of the Trademark Act, 15 U.S.C. § l052(d), and withdraw the refusal in light
`
`of the following remarks and attached evidence,
`
`in addition to the arguments presented in
`
`Applicant’s response of May 23, 2013 (“Office Action Response No. 1”), which are incorporated
`
`herein by reference.
`
`As explained in Applicant’s Office Action Response No. 1, the Office bears the burden of
`
`showing that a mark falls within the statutory bars of Section 2(d).
`
`J. Thomas McCarthy,
`
`McCarthy on Trademarks and Unfair Competition (Fourth Ed.) § 19:75 at 19-230. To refuse
`
`registration under Section 2(d), the Examining Attorney “must present sufficient evidence and
`
`argument that the mark is barred from registration.” Id. § l9:l28 at 19-383.
`
`In this case, the
`
`Examining Attorney, respectfully, still has not met her burden of demonstrating likelihood of
`
`conf11sion.
`
`To determine whether likelihood of confusion exists, the Examining Attorney must
`
`consider all of the DuPont factors that are relevant to a particular case. See In re E.I. Du Pont de
`
`Nemours & Co., 177 U.S.P.Q. 563, 567 (CCPA 1973); see also Recot, Inc. v. Becton, 214 F.3d
`
`1322, 1326 (Fed. Cir. 2000) (whether likelihood of confusion exists is determined “on a case-
`
`specific basis” using the DuPont factors). In continuing her refusal to register Applicant’s mark,
`
`the Examining Attorney has incorrectly focused only on certain of the DuPont factors. She also
`
`has discounted other crucial factors. An analysis of those DuPont factors previously overlooked
`
`or discounted by the Examining Attorney confirms that there is little likelihood of confusion
`
`between Applicant’s mark and the Cited Marks.
`
`SMRH:41483399l.1
`
`-3-
`
`

`
`A.
`
`Applicant’s Mark and the Cited Marks Are Completely Different
`Appearance, Sound, Connotation and Commercial Impression
`
`in
`
`As explained in Applicant’s Office Action Response No. 1, when determining likelihood
`
`of confusion under § 2(d) for word marks, marks are compared based on their appearance, sound,
`
`meaning, and commercial impression. See Du Pont, 177 U.S.P.Q. at 567.
`
`The Examining Attorney repeats her assertion that Applicant’s mark and the Cited Marks
`
`are similar simply because they share the word FANBOY. As before, however, it is not enough
`
`to simply note that Applicant’s mark shares a component with the Cited Marks. See Murray
`
`Corp. of America v. Red Spot Paint & Varnish Co., 280 F.2d 158, 161 (C.C.P.A. 1960)
`
`(“[A]1though appellee’s mark embodies appellant’s entire mark, when considering those marks
`
`in their entireties, as we must .
`
`.
`
`. we are of the opinion that the likelihood of confusion, mistake
`
`or deception contemplated by Section 2(d) of the Lanham Act does not exist”); see also General
`
`Mills, Inc. v. Kellogg Co., 824 F.2d 622, 627 (8th Cir. 1987) (“The use of identical, even
`
`dominant, words in common does not automatically mean that two marks are similar.’’).
`
`The Examining Attorney also misstates that Applicant asserts that the ARMAGEDDON
`
`portion of Applicant’s mark is more dominant than the FANBOY element. (Final Office Action
`
`at pg. 2.) Applicant in fact stated, “According leg weight to ARMAGEDDON is improper
`
`because it is equally as arbitrary as FANBOY and the addition of that word serves to distinguish
`
`Applicant’s mark from Registrants’ marks, none of which include the distinctive word
`
`ARMAGEDDON.” (emphasis added.) Applicant stressed that the ARMAGEDDON portion of
`
`Applicant’s FANBOY ARMAGEDDON & Design mark should be accorded §_q_1L1 weight as the
`
`FANBOY element.
`
`When compared in their entireties, Applicant’s mark FANBOY ARMAGEDDON &
`
`Design and the Cited Marks, FANBOYNATION & Design, NICKELODEON FANBOY AND
`
`SMRH:414833991.l
`
`-4-
`
`

`
`CHUM CHUM and FANBOY RADIO, are visually dissimilar because Applicant’s mark shares
`
`nothing in common with the Cited marks other than the word FANBOY.
`
`The word
`
`ARMAGEDDON is completely different from NATION, NICKELODEON AND CHUM
`
`CHUM, and RADIO.
`
`Most significantly, however, Applicant’s mark is completely different from the Cited
`
`Marks in connotation and commercial impression. The word “fanboy” means “an obsessive
`
`male fan, especially of something technological or from popular culture.” Attached hereto as
`
`Exhibit A are true and correct printouts from additional dictionary sites showing the definition
`
`for “fanboy”. The word FANBOY is a familiar term when used broadly in the entertainment
`
`context, as the Examining Attorney classifies the goods and services of the respective marks.
`
`Attached as Exhibit B are true and correct intemet printouts from third party websites using
`
`FANBOY as a trademark for “entertainment” goods and services. Attached as Exhibit C are
`
`true and correct news articles using the term “fanboy” to describe dedicated fans.
`
`In such a situation, consumers look to the other elements in the respective marks to
`
`differentiate between the marks. Stoufler Corp. V. Health Valley Natural Foods,
`
`1 USPQ.2d
`
`1900, 1903 (TTAB 1987) (no likelihood of confusion between the applied-for mark LEAN
`
`LIVING for “chicken crepes, lasagna and enchiladas” and the prior mark LEAN CUISINE used
`
`for a line of frozen prepared foods, because the shared element “Lean” was weak and the
`
`remaining features of the marks were sufficiently different to distinguish them in the minds of
`
`consumers.); Rocket Trademarks Pty Ltd. v. Phard S.p.A., 98 USPQ.2d 1066, 1076 (TTAB 2011)
`
`(Widespread third-party use and registration of the term “Element” in the clothing industry
`
`played a large role in the Board’s determination that there was no likelihood of confusion
`
`between the applied-for mark ZU ELEMENTS and opposer’s registered mark ELEMENT.)
`
`SMRH:414833991.l
`
`-5-
`
`

`
`When viewed as a composite mark, Applicant’s mark suggests a big battle between fans.
`
`None of the Cited Marks conveys this meaning. FANBOYNATION conveys a country of fans,
`
`NICKELODEON FANBOY AND CHUM CHUM conveys not only the brand NICKELODEON
`
`but also two buddies hanging out together. FANBOY RADIO conveys a radio station for fans.
`
`The connotations and commercial impressions of all four marks are all quite different.
`
`Applicant’s mark and the Cited Marks, therefore, are quite different in appearance,
`
`sound, connotation and commercial impression.
`
`B.
`
`The Cited Marks Are Not Famous Marks
`
`As explained in Applicant’s Response to Office Action No. 1, “[fjamous marks are
`
`accorded more protection precisely because they are more likely to be remembered and
`
`associated in the public mind than a weaker mark.” Recot, Inc. v. Becton, 214 F.3d 1322, 1327
`
`(Fed. Cir. 2000).
`
`In this case, the Examining Attorney has offered no evidence that the Cited
`
`Marks are famous or are likely to be remembered in the public mind.
`
`Indeed,
`
`the only
`
`documents attached to the Final Office Action focus on registrant Nickolodeon’s “Fanboy Chum
`
`Churn” and not the other two registrants. Furthermore, the attached documents appear to be
`
`comprised of some intemet printouts from registrant Nicolodeon’s own “Fanboy Chum Churn”
`
`website, some Wikia game webpages which do not provide information on the number of players
`
`or how recent the games are, a Huffpost TV article which references Nickolodeon’s game
`
`“Legends of the Hidden Temple” but makes no mention of “Fanboy Churn Chum,” and a
`
`Buzzfeed article about 12 old Nickolodeon t.v. shows but again makes no reference to “Fanboy
`
`Chum Chum”. Applicant respectfully submits that these documents do not prove the fame of
`
`any of the Cited Marks. The fact that there is no evidence concerning the fame of the Cited
`
`Marks strongly suggests that confusion between Applicant’s mark and the Cited Marks is
`
`unlikely.
`
`SMRH:4l483399l.l
`
`-6-
`
`

`
`C.
`
`The Existence of Third Pam Registrations Proves that Applicant’s Mark
`Can Co-Exist with other FANBOY Marks, Including the Cited Marks
`
`As explained in Applicant’s Response to Office Action No. 1, evidence of third party use
`
`on similar goods is relevant to show that a mark is entitled to only a narrow scope of protection.
`
`Palm Bay Imports, Inc. v. Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin Maison Fondee En 1 772, 396 F.3d 1369,
`
`1373 (Fed. Cir. 2005). The Examining Attorney states that the “[p]rior decisions and actions of
`
`other trademark examining attorneys in registering other marks have little evidentiary Value and
`
`are not binding upon the Office or the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.” (Final Office Action
`
`at 2.) (citations omitted.) To the contrary, third-party registrations can show that a commonly
`
`registered term has a suggestive or descriptive significance for particular goods such that
`
`differences in the remaining portions of the marks may be sufficient to render the marks as a
`
`whole distinguishable. Top Tobacco LP v. North Atlantic Operating Co., 101 USPQ.2d 1163,
`
`1173 (TTAB 2011) (third party registrations of CLASSIC marks for tobacco products sufficient
`
`to hold that such marks are only entitled to a narrow scope of protection); Red Carpet Corp. v.
`
`Johnstown American Enterprises Inc., 7 USPQ.2d 1404, 1406 (TTAB 1988); Tektronix, Inc. v.
`
`Daktronics, Inc., 534 F.2d 915, 917 (CCPA 1976) (third-party registrations of “TRONICS” and
`
`“TRONIX” marks conveyed the dictionary meaning thereof, namely, that their products are
`
`electronic in character, such that the suffix portions alone were insufficient to cause a likelihood
`
`of confusion, and that differences in the remaining portions of the marks were sufficient to
`
`render the marks as a whole readily distinguishable.)
`
`The PTO has not only allowed coexistence of the three Cited Marks, but also allowed the
`
`registration of U.S. Reg. No. 3,559,569 for FANBOY and U.S. Reg. No. 3,559,568 for
`
`FANBOY GET OUT OF THE BASEMENT & Design for “sketchbooks, sketchpads, art boards
`
`for drawing, and papers for the creation of manga and comic book drawings and art, all sold as a
`
`SMRH:41483399l.l
`
`-7-
`
`

`
`unit, and sketchbooks, sketchpads, art boards for drawing, and papers for the creation of manga
`
`and comic book drawings and art, sold individually” owned by Canson, Inc., and U.S. Reg. No.
`
`2,944,865 for CRAZED FANBOY for “Production of video cassettes, tapes and discs featuring
`
`original dramatic programming pertaining to science fiction and speculative fiction and true-
`
`lifestory documentaries” owned by Nolan Canova.1 True and correct copies of the foregoing
`
`registrations and status printouts from the PTO website are attached hereto as Exhibit D.
`
`The fact that the PTO has allowed multiple FANBOY marks, including the Cited Marks,
`
`to be registered in the PTO can only mean that the Cited Marks are only entitled to a narrow
`
`scope of protection. There is also no evidence that any of the Registrants have objected to the
`
`respective use and registration.
`
`In short, Registrants’ marks are each entitled to only a narrow
`
`scope of protection, and Applicant’s mark can coexist with the Cited Marks.
`
`II.
`
`CONCLUSION
`
`For the foregoing reasons, Applicant has demonstrated that no likelihood of confusion
`
`exists between Applicant’s mark and the Cited Marks. Accordingly, Applicant respectfully
`
`requests that the Examining Attorney withdraw the refusal to register under Section 2(d) of the
`
`Trademark Act and approve Applicant’s mark for publication. Applicant has filed a Notice of
`
`Appeal to the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board herewith.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Dated: December 17, 2013
`
`
`
`
`
`Susan Hwang
`SHEPPARD MULLIN RICHT
`333 South Hope Street, 43rd Floor
`Los Angeles, California 90071
`Tel: (213) 620-1780
`
`TON LLP
`
`U.S. Reg. No. 2,994,865 is now cancelled, but the registration of the mark demonstrates that the
`1
`PTO allowed coexistence of FANBOY marks.
`
`SMRI-l:4l4833991.1
`
`-8-
`
`

`
`CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
`
`I hereby certify that this correspondence is being deposited with the United States Postal
`Service as first class mail in an envelope addressed to: Commissioner for Trademarks, P.O. Box
`1451, Alexandria, VA 22313-1451, on December 17, 2013.
`
`Betty 1. Rodriguez
`
`8
`
`SMRH:414833991.l
`
`-9-
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`
`12/15/I3
`
`Fanboy « Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary
`
`’LEDBURY‘"
`
`YOUR NEUVFAVORITE SIIIRZL
`XH
`‘gimp Now
`
`Quizzes & Games
`
`Word of the Day
`
`Video
`
`New Womls
`
`My Favorites
`
`New!
`Spanish Central 5
`
` ~ ~.._e,.,,.../"t
`
`III-W.C0lX)
`
`“tutu
`
`<
`
`Quiz
`
`Narne That Thing
`Take Our 10-Question Quiz
`
`fan-boy
`
`Definition of FANBOY
`
`:.i3»l:
`
`Lziae;
`
`: a boy who is an enthusiastic devotee (as of comics or
`movies)
`
`First Known Use of FANBOY
`
`1919
`
`Browse
`
`Next Word in the Dictionary: fan brake
`Previous Word in the Dictionary: fan blower
`All Words Near: fanboy
`
`4;. Seen & Heard 39
`
`What made you want to look up fanboy? Please tell us where
`you read or heard it (including the quote, if possible).
`
`MORE QUIZZES
`
`Mi
`
`Spell it
`The commonly misspelled words quiz
`Hear lt, Spell it »
`
`Vocabulary Quiz
`How strong is your vocabulary?
`Take the Quiz »
`
`Qui'.I:1.it'ive: Our New App!
`The Vocab Quiz Game for iPhone & iPad
`
`aaeew "IncredibIy fun and addictive.
`And informative!" — User Fleview, iTunes
`Learn More is
`
`Bumfuzzle, Cattywampus,
`Gardyloo & More
`Top 10 Funny-Sounding 8. Interesting
`Words
`
`Piquant. Amlarnsial & More:
`Food Vvords Vvorth Savoring
`Top 10 Words About Food
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Post to F.'.i<:et)ook
`
`Posting as Andy Kim (Not you?)
`
`Follow
`
`Dave Ablebodz Peters '
`I decided to look up the term after being called a "fanboi" when I
`pointed out the negatives of Android Hardware and software in a Cult
`of Mac dlSCUSSl0l'1 on Google Plus.
`P,eply<
`‘x
`v Lake > Follow Post » July 9 at 12:04pm
`
`Maryltnne Moseley
`I read "fanbois“ in the closing comment on this link about tablets:
`http://wvwv.zdnetcom/how-to—decide-should-you-buy-an—ipad-mini-
`a—kindle~fire-hd-or—a—nexus-74000007137/.
`Reply - Liéie - Foiiow Post v April 29 at 8:03pm
`
`Adam Ekstrom < Utah Valley University
`
`SPECJAL FEATURE >
`
`the 3”‘ is free’
`
`.\l’l’\RE:L
`"»‘~'.'UMl‘ \".~.
`L," .\t.('.I;}~\tiRI [:5
`
`Buy 2 items and
`
`H w w .merriam«webster.com/dictionary/fanboy
`
`l/3
`
`
`
`fanboy
`
`fanboy
`
`Sponsored Links
`
`If you're logged into Facebook, you're ready to go.
`
`Save this word to your Favorites.
`
`Custom Holiday Cards
`Save up to 50% off on cards, promo code BESTlE. See site for...
`wvvvv.Shgtjerfly.ggm
`
`

`
`12/I5/13
`
`Fanboy — Definition and More from the Free Merriam—Webster Dictionary
`Saw the term used in a Youtube video. and wasn‘t sure what they
`meant.
`
`Reply ~ Like - Follow Post ~ March 21, 2012 at 11:42am
`
`Reply — Like v Follow Post February 12 at 10:05am
`
`Bill Hoyer - Santa Barbara Graduate institute
`l wondered if it referred to the servants of royalty who fanned their
`masters to keep them cool - often probably slaves, but always
`subsen/lent - and likely a status symbol to have one on hand.
`Plenty A L=.f«e- F«.)lir)w Post May 24, 2012 at12:50pm
`
`Top Commenter
`2 Walt French-
`Wanted to see if “pejorative" was part of the dein. Surprised that it‘s
`not.
`i
`
`
`
`The Year in W'nrds
`Words that spiked in Iookups
`because of events in the
`news.
`View the List »
`
`Get Our Free A pps
`Voice Search, Favorites,
`Word oi the Day, and More
`iPhone | iPad l Android | More
`
`
`
`Graham Cowles - Dunedin, New Zealand
`It does have that emphasis at times.
`
`Repiy - Like - November 7 at 6:16pm
`View 3 more
`
`Faceoook social plugin
`
`View Seen 8. Heard highlights from around the site »
`Mernam-Webster on Facebook
`
`
`
`
`Join Us on FB 8.: Twitter
`Get the Word ofthe Day and More
`F3C9b00k I Twine?
`
`J.CRE\Y/
`
`EN .‘§'l‘t )lli'IS &- ( l.\l.|.Nl'I:
`
`W
`O
`\\’l'l'H ('()lll". (il|"'l'.Vl)\V
`
`' 3 E 1? 5...!T..E.£9_B__|l.E..IélL._5
`
`/’i’tz>:. _f‘ri34.' .‘4!ii'p;>i':;_i; rm 1/” am/i.'i-x.
`
`The Merriam-Webster
`Unabridged Dictionary
`f
`Online access to a
`legendary resource
`Log In or Sign Up »
`
`Learning English?
`Q
`= We can help.
`Visit our free site designed
`especially for learners and
`teachers of English
`LearnersDictionary.com »
`
`Our Dictionary,
`On Your Devices
`’ Merriarm/Vebster,
`l/Wrh Voice Search
`Get the Free Apps‘ »
`
`E
`
`5 Merriam-Webster's
`Visual Dictionaries
`'
`.‘
`The new edition ofthe
`remarkable reference
`features 8 000
`illiistrations.
`Learn More »
`
`lNS'l‘Ultl'IS&UNIJNE:
`.‘it)‘}6 (ll’|"‘ Yl llilt l’URCII.\SI'I WITII Ctllllfi (Ill"'l‘.\'()W'
`f’!zr.~‘, ,i’irw ,wIii’;7i‘z':r.«l rm (:1! .r.»m’<»'rt<.
`
`'5*'j‘"s*'*—""“”E
`
`
`
`
`
`FOR DE*“**T“"'5' Join Us
`
`3 Merriam—Websler
`3 0" Twmel’ l’
`
`:.
`’
`
`Merriam~Webster
`0” Facebook ”
`
`:
`
`Bookstore: Digital and Print
`vlerriam«Webster references for Mobile,
`Kindle, print, and more. See all »
`
`=
`’
`
`Other Merriam-Webster Dictionaries
`‘./\/e'g5fer'5 Unabfidged Didgonary ,,
`Lgarnefs ESL Dicrionary »
`Wordcentral for Kids »
`Visual Dictionary »
`Spanish Central »
`
`Shop Advertising info DictionaryAPI
`Home Help Aboutus
`Pr:var;yPolicy About Cu-rAds Contact Us
`Bro-.~l<5er Tools
`
`w ww .merriam—we bstcr.c om/dictionary/fanboy
`
`Browsezheuicticinary
`Browsethe Thesaurus
`
`rd'7»
`
`

`
`1.‘./I5/13
`
`Fanboy — Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary
`
`I‘ 2313 Merriam-‘v\’ebster. Incorporated
`
`rowse the Spanish-Engzush Dictionary
`Browse the Mecmai Dnclaonary
`Browse the Concise Encyciopedia
`
`www .merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fanboy
`
`3/3
`
`

`
`12/15/13
`
`fanboy — Wiktionary
`
`fanboy
`
`Definition from Wiktionary, the free dictionary
`
`Contents
`
`I
`
`lEng1ish
`I
`1.1 Alternative forms
`
`I
`
`1.2 Noun
`
`I 1.2.1 Related terms
`
`I 1.2.2 Translations
`
`I 1.2.3 See also
`
`English
`
`Alternative forms
`
`I
`
`fanboi
`
`Noun
`
`fanboy (plural fanboys)
`
`1. (famlom slang) Someone (normally male) who is utterly
`devoted to a single subject or hobby, often to the point where it
`is considered an obsession.
`[quotations V]
`
`Related terms
`
`I
`
`fangirl
`
`Translations
`
`, .~..Ww....~.~................,.~»W.~~.~W.,..~....~,..,....,,~ .,.......w..._~..m hf’ ., IVV1 ..... ..._«.“«wW.w.~.wW~..m,.._»_.M.«..m.Mm.ymw.wwwwm W...“ ...M..~........~.~...l....,
`someone devotedito a single subject
`[show V]
`.,,..,,,..,,,.W,..,..,,....,,. .,.... ,,..,...M.W.............,....~..,......,.,..,.w...,,....,.2......4_.,..,.......m..,..~......W..., .... ...,,....,,M .......,.J
`
`See also
`
`I geek
`I nerd
`
`I otaku
`
`en .w iktionaryorg/wiki/fanboy
`
` »
`
`.3
`
`f Ninten
`
`do fanboy
`
`

`
`I2/15/13
`
`fanboy . Wiktionary
`
`Retrieved from "http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=fanboy&oldid=24l 14988"
`Categories: English nouns English countable nouns English fandom slang en:Fandom
`
`I This page was last modified on 11 December 2013, at 19:50.
`I Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; additional terms may
`apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
`
`c n .wiktionaryorg/wiki/fanboy
`
`2/2
`
`

`
`l2/I5/13
`
`C,£¥ ,;
`
`
`
`fanboy
`
`Einboyl Define Fanboy at Dictionary.com
`
`.:
`
`”
`
`‘.‘>’«}
`
`3::
`
`¥.;‘s:;»3t
`
`Related Searches
`Fa“”°V 3"“ °““"‘ °~r
`Fanboy movie
`Fanboy and chum c...
`Fanboy and churn c...
`Fanboy and chum cu.
`Fanboy and chum c...
`
`Fanbovs comic
`psp fanboy
`
`Nearby Words
`
`fanback
`fanbase
`fanboi
`f3"b°Y
`fanboy or fangirl
`fancied
`fancied up
`
`L E D B U
`YO UR MW’ F»! mre/rF SHIRT
`‘J
`A‘
`A
`,
`,
`‘ K
`
`
`
`‘
`
`fanboy
`
`Ine.w.Q:lQ_1sQhan9Lin.g
`www_fu5ion_net/Get—Fu5ion-Now
`Fusion. Not Everybody Gets It Do You? Get Fusion Network Now!
`539 people + 1‘d this page
`
`Ads
`
`Quote Of The Day
`,
`,
`,,
`.
`,
`Friendship, according to Proust, IS the
`negation of that irremediable solitude to
`which ev..."
`
`§how IPA
`fan'b0y [fan-boi]
`noun [7lf0f‘n1(‘11.‘ Often Disparaging.
`an obsessive male fan, especially of something technological or from
`popular Cglgyfg: Applcfcmboys lined up to buy the new phone.
`Often, fan-boi.
`
`--R.m'ni(:l l4<:cl~:::ti
`g-30:25;
`
`Origin:
`1915-20; ra_ni + b_0lL
`
`Explore Dictionary.com
`Previous Definition: fanboi
`
`Next Definition: fanboy or fangirt
`Words Near". fanboy
`
`More from Thesaurus.com
`Synonyms and Antonyms for fanboy
`
`More from Reference.com
`Search for articles containing fanboy
`
`More from Dictionary.com Translator
`Translate fanboy into French
`Translate fanboy into German
`Translate fanboy into ltalian
`Translate fanboy into another language
`
`Relevant Questions
`
`Dictionary.com Word FAQs
`Dictionary.com presents 366 FAQs, incorporating some of the frequently asked
`questions from the past with newer queries.
`Differences
`Etyrnologylorigins
`Grammar/Usagelstyie
`Spelling
`Trivia
`What is the Word For...? Where Can I Find...?
`I have a question that isn‘t answered here
`
`
`
`kllC tionaryreference .com/browse/fanboy
`
`

`
`12/15/13
`
`Fanboy I Define Pmboy at Dictionary.com
`
`SAVE 50%
`
`About [PRIVACY POLICY [Terms ]Careers [Am/enise with Us [comacws |SuggestaWord |He|p
`
`Copyright 2013Dictionaryxxxm,LLC.A!1righ2sreserved.
`
`dictionary.reference.com/browse/fanboy
`
`2/2
`
`

`
`I 2/15/13
`
`fanboy: definition of fanboy in Oxford dictionary (British & World English)
`
`Definition of fanboy in English
`
`fanboy
`
`710 L171
`
`informal
`
`a male fan, especially one who is obsessive abouticomics, music, film, or science fiction.
`
`fanboy in other Oxford dictionaries
`
`Definition of fanboy in the US Englisli dictionary
`
`u ww .o‘<forddicIionaries.com/definition/english/fanboy
`
`l/l
`
`

`
`EXHIBIT B
`
`

`
`12/15/13
`
`About» Fanboy.com
`
`Home
`A bout
`l')cI'mitiou
`("out-ac;
`
`About
`
`Welcome to fanboy.c0m.’ Here are a few words from the original mission
`statementfrom our publisher — Michael Pinto:
`
`.
`
`As long as I can remember I’ve always been a fanboy: While the other little
`boys always wanted to always play sports I lived to watch Star Trek (and
`later Space-'1999). A few years laterl discovered the anime series Star
`Blazers which changed my life when it went off the around 1980. Not
`being empowered with a VCR my favorite show had vanished — so 1 took
`my first step into fandom and started the Star Blazers Fan Club. Sadly the
`show never did come back on the air in New York, but it did launch my
`"career" as :1 f;mzine )ubl's er:
`
`
`
`f 8+1 "
`
`Star Trek
`
`..
`
`.
`DOCK)! who
`
`Cinema
`
`
`
`Video Ganuzs
`
`Television
`
`Comic Books
`
`Anunation
`
`K; 45-‘
`A"?
`
`‘E 2Iu€1«l‘LJUd‘Iil‘$
`
`I’Bfi lull“)
`
`ununooooqoooevqoaoa-uuoc-Iocoocaooooooacouatuaonouvvcouo-ovanotvooauoo
`
`u ohuwaoutn5athcan-Idaoonvcounnuooodohotvoqnoou -onus-noon ouaouo-an 4 -cu.
`inane ~,,2n2-are ’-mun-urn in nu ctrtcul nun lduor at up In ei».
`flu! V;-;}.»’o:nlan results and mono '41- euazlvuw flak»: vtvszu
`-<19uWB no nu of I1.l.C’.:r-t suwluorn Fm Club status - .ul:.:r<.
`with M» an pawl Q25 n;-2n.Hu: that no :1-Allan nu “Mu ta ta.
`u.lnn rmmlss ulll nun to r-:2:-nmwvur ‘at! :14 Mad '.h0€
`c’! not 5 «a
`lawn M4 tho Ha#2:a.1..-u VII-1 av‘ mu .9 undo uh: to was at. my Von-
`‘Ml: M ;v..;-12;;-rs so «:9 In the uflllifltj/€«?-U00 tun.-tan in gun i:'r:.'x:;.
`ran aunt; who cnrnnlqns will at rel: «$31 ’.:u Fnrwuy 33$» av-4 «‘a:-c'- Jim.
`
`:4; was ‘a 4- "won um qu an ran“ an mm (2: 2!:-525.1223) ms
`suit to 2. on 16
`‘*0 etmzrur -vu~u»;»vt.fi.Iaia al was all «wars tn oh» nun
`Hume! 5 oxpflxw I‘.-,F:aqru ?‘«v~nu.2$! nu Nth are-z,'n,vu y'2’.)r1..l¢\
`16-It hunt: um! colt ant
`-"€525
`to out no Meat: ‘act for Mu" non.
`uu..‘»‘\o
`Sun»; an‘. of mu tau: ‘av nnnlwrxo Know In uvtna to M! 3
`
`swanky: ta 1:: )"'§x‘l.'. an: an he an in :"| “NSXSGOXMV
`tut ta «Hue: nhtawriw Knoqui uunl iIvo..5<1Me& ii.‘ £3'I2J.i£u H’ Hm
`vO0II Hits to sun 0 cwnnlon n are usnnzluon but an was up in you
`nu rl£u.,:araZunI fan C3xoD,V!!’}1 Qlvvunt fivI.NIu.-.u,m 11555.
`:" 2-,; Has tn ..crHv~a an e in H1 1".x'.l’ unborn 712089 and
`can an nu at Hand.“ In ransom flu: you at not want your M!!! is
`anpunpiacu infant us.
`éil vx »scl<<.:.: mu Sesame rm:-a cones» in '-.~u:x".=1 =.'~-:--- ’W*-W
`wt}: zurbtuuu is an {no at I.» the tour an! nu»:-eats nut}
`Wu: 2: shared 1»: us Max M nnwno 1|-an .‘nr:un.M mu-not 5? sfli.?J.J-R
`any iufldtr ms: 5a:1m:uy.Mm~vn u.-MI tn:-x W bruuvl cvrnsr-II‘! ‘Ml «‘Il‘0"-
`rut. M‘ tho anon on §v:hnu Hcttommt. may no wrest"; Hletttaynlu
`rant. 2:! Um new thy an ma-u\:loo.!>ut savanna may no one.
`in my case -«adv tn rhivn Eaatoln it-Ha:k.wfl1e3I can uL!..>1 zrw I(‘¢0"'»kl’DQ
`of I noel elects.“ Pan I1!!! Mum nnv Inez mvmun an-teem. fin far rssw
`grams; in 1; :na.l;ng cyan»; o':l,.;nl:h In an av!‘ ;aum1:y-.uM.en in about
`museum was M112: tho Mach Gmrnt,-.Me2v In c nuns-in <ne.me.7M an a"~r
`. ..
`. my Y» —......
`.»...._.. an ..-«A». 1..
`.m~.9 a new un-an we 'ir"‘»s
`
`
`
`7
`
`'
`
`Ir
`
`‘
`
`V
`
`\\ ww .fanboy.com/about
`
`1/2
`
`

`
`12/I5/13
`
`About» Fanboy.com
`
`Z".,“{;‘§‘§,';.’....”''2.‘J32‘;13232:.‘é:II£;’f.§F.:§’I; i.'i:s.i;::
`for but at no um :30 anew an sanniy -mum than entuns
`‘Junta sing true: 1 guns sun at lam-so urseanlnev
`rnaxaza 2122:.» an «an
`I
`I
`the an to 0 seeds» culture the
`tnnhjtz ;::¥.¢‘4:;:.u:l:‘;omru: :?:;u|!!:¢ muss hr than I: no efkucn.
`mu we": m:s:n- in allowed to run an flit -6 act v!u.71nu ullil
`:21 an to -amt 29 may as no.n.n us an :I Dotitflahhut arr. wit u.
`was: In e.-«mun sat by new run." you mid “*0 0" -4 ‘° '=="§g;* ’
`
`5g..gx.,.', r... n.,a,7x-gas», ¢¢nt.!Il1 tvtwwlua tun. rental: 95! 11
`r
`-
`...-............................._..........._..
`rm ‘zezon or no turteinzns 1'» cm: -can unn melt the u tr--dc an
`chi nah ma} adult: (I suit our Haul innate and Mlasd to got this
`in»: wt.
` vvac
` - _n
`In; Cancun/fvvtnuv Crqoaiuuon nuda rah!-7 1°“ 5" *"W""" ’x''’‘'
`
`........_............_
`
`.711: ‘any \r.c_." has-nun scnohul. I-C.“ 96! 190'‘.....—..-.........1
`-~—----—-
`artng an AB‘/)‘q‘§.w In :54 ‘ion Val: 51!! Jfltsfiu“ 1'""' "'
`5f|y.g gm .nx~s was to as}: If 22¢ :, amt ntruculv ‘xv NM’!
`.............--.............-......-........—........-..—....._......~----........-.
`»‘»Mu- ‘|‘F,»:2¢s' ma ~mr:~.w:t an» N!!!
`
`Flash forward to the late 1990s: During the dawn of the dot.com era on a
`whim I decided to register fanboy.com. At first I only put a few links on the
`site, but in ;\’ovember of 200! I started using the website for reviews.
`However this wasjust a bit before the dawn of blogging software, so the
`didn't really take off until early 2006 when I starting doing updates on a
`regular basis.
`
`
`
`For a long time fanboy was a term that had a negative connotation - one
`of my main goals for this site is to reverse that association and make it a
`positive \vord. To me the tenn means loving a particular subject or genre
`regardless of it being high or low art (I’m channeling the spirit of Design
`Saint libor Kalman). In terms of coverage I aim to cover any topic that a
`fanzine would have been created for in the past -— and this means anything
`from science fiction to punk rock.
`
`Although our point of view is very much that of a geek (with acne), so
`there are some genres like sports that I'll gladly ignore (which isn’t to say
`that you can be a sports fanboy as portrayed by lack l;'lugmun in the Odd
`
`Couple TV show). Also this site should never be mistaken for a boys
`clubhouse — fangurls are not only welcome but encouraged to hang here.
`Lastly it should be noted that this site is very much a work—in-progress, so
`you can expect some change and with any luck some improvement.
`
`Thank you!
`
`Michael Pinto
`
`Publisher Fanboy.com
`
`P.S. I'm a dyslexic art school grad so apologies in advance for any typos or
`grammatical travesties.
`
`Copyright © 2013 Fanboy.com All rights reserved. Theme by Laptop Geek.
`
`w ww .fanboy.com/about
`
`

`
`12/15/13
`
`About Us « parttimefzinboycom
`
` iltzii
`
`CO?t!ilC.:’3 movies
`
`”i'Et_EVi5§0N
`
`l;‘~iTERViEWS
`
`;iir~iiiiii.ai"riot~i
`
`sisourus
`
`Kristian Horn
`
`Horn is the Founder/Editor/Producer of Part-Time Faiiboy.
`
`Discovered as a babe in an abandoned comic book storage box and
`bitten by a radioactive comic fan when he was a teenager, Kristian
`
`ABQUT US
`
`
`
`Kristian founded Part-l”ime Fanboy because. much like other aging
`ianboys. he was noticing that as time went by his ability to stay
`plugged in with everything fanboy culture provided was slowly waning
`duetoother responsibilities such as family, work.etc. Part-Time
`Fanboy was created as a place forfans of geekdom to commiserate over the things they enjoyed without
`feeling the pressure of having to keep up with whatwas supposedly “hip”. Pait~Time Fanboy is a refuge
`
`for nerds everywhere and a place wnere all ideas can come together and discuss the worlds of comics,
`television. movies, and beyond.
`Kristian has been a contributing writer and interviewer for the Ain‘t it Cool News comic book section and
`
`is a sometime cartoonistand designer Some ofhis work can be seen at his website (which really needs
`to be updated) www-kristianhorn-com.
`.
`.
`.
`,
`.
`.
`.
`_
`Kristian works as a Media Producer tor a large multi-media/retail company which he won tname here
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`(hint: rhymes with “Fizzney")and lives in Reseda. California with his wonderfully tolerant wife and
`daughter,
`
`You can contact Kristian by e—mailing ptf@parttimefanboy.com
`
`'
`
`2’:
`
`..»....
`;s;i{;g,v_«,.
`m'~;>;r
`
`'
`
`-
`,
`'">
`7
`.5‘:
`3
`F 5”b°Y gy Odcast Lt)
`I
`5
`
`it) top ten Comi
`‘toms
`That Blew Our fuiiiidst i—«i,:ii“t Cite?
`with the end of 2013 approaching it‘s time to
`
`reflect on the past so me Panvnme Fanboy
`Crew SHOW" ,3
`
`
`
`Fiégh and gioed 3 3 ;;q§V;(,3.Viy,i
`; FLESH AND BLOOD ii 3 written by: Robert
`-
`'1"
`.ll
`1. h
`d_P
`Th
`11
`and 8'00
`mnp F P5
`an we lusmted
`b '
`-
`v
`'
`S‘
`Y Ne" Vokes Operation ‘Mn »
`
`
`
`‘ Pnit—T£me iiznhoy Podztastt lip
`V 89 Podcasi oiihe i}o<:to-i‘€
`V Spoilers. darlingl Doctor Who‘s 50th
`anniversary 15 this year and the BBC pulled
`
`out all the stops to celebrate the it
`
`I
`
`S h 11
`an C e er
`lan Scheller is fascinated with the many differentfacets and workings
`
` exquisite meanings for his own presence on earth and his relationship
`
`of the human individual, society

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket