throbber
Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`ESTTA544384
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`06/21/2013
`
`Filing date:
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`85518756
`OMEGA VALLEY FARMERS, LLC
`THE 3 OMEGAS
`JOSEPH S. HEINO
`DAVIS & KUELTHAU, S.C.
`111 E KILBOURN AVE STE 1400
`MILWAUKEE, WI 53202-6613
`UNITED STATES
`jheino@dkattorneys.com
`Applicants Request for Remand and Amendment
`11530808.PDF(129743 bytes )
`11530693.PDF(1631039 bytes )
`Patrick M. Bergin
`pbergin@dkattorneys.com
`/Patrick M. Bergin/
`06/21/2013
`
`Proceeding
`Applicant
`Applied for Mark
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Submission
`Attachments
`
`Filer's Name
`Filer's e-mail
`Signature
`Date
`
`

`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE
`
`TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`Law Office 109
`
`Trademark Attorney:
`
`David Collier, Esq.
`
`)
`)
`)
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`) )
`
`\-1
`
`_
`In re Application of
`Agricultural Omega Solutions, LLC and
`Omega Valley Farmers, LLC
`
`Serial No. 85/518,756
`
`Filed: January 18,2012
`
`Trademark: THE 3 OMEGAS
`
`Trademark Trial and Appeal Board
`U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
`PO. Box 1451
`
`Alexandria, VA 22313-1451
`
`APPLICANTS’_ REQUEST TO REMAND FOR ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
`UNDER 37 CFR § 2.142(D) AND TBMP § 1207.02
`
`Introduction
`
`Agricultural Omega Solutions, LLC and Omega Valley Farmers, LLC (“Applicants”) have
`
`appealed from the Examining Attomey‘s final refusal to register the above-identified mark dated
`
`October 24, 2012, respectfully requesting that the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board reverse the
`
`Examining Attorney's decision.
`
`Applicants’ Trademark
`
`Applicants seeks registration on the Principal Register of their mark:
`
`THE 3 OMEGAS '
`
`'
`
`

`
`for “meat, namely, beef and pork; fish; poultry and game; eggs; and dairy products, namely,
`
`milk, buttermilk, non-alcoholic egg nog, half and half, whipping cream, yogurt, butter, sour
`
`cream, dry buttermilk powder, dry milk powder, cheese, cream cheese, and cottage cheese; all of
`
`the foregoing containing omega acids” in Int’l Class 29; for “ice cream, ice milk and frozen
`
`yogurt; flour; all of the foregoing containing omega acids” in lnt’l Class 30; and for “animal feed
`
`containing omega acids” in Int’l Class 31 (“Applicants’ Mark”).
`
`The Rejection
`
`The Examining Attorney refused registration of Applicant’s Mark contending that the mark
`
`as applied to the goods is “merely descriptive.” Office Action dated October 24, 2012.
`
`In that final Office Action, the Examining Attorney expounded his position contending the
`
`“there are three types of omega-3 fatty acids, specifically, ALA, EPA and DHA.” Indeed, the
`
`final Office Action is replete with references to the “omega-3” fatty acids and appears to be
`
`hopelessly entrenched
`
`the notion that fly “ornega-3” fatty acids are relevant and that there
`
`are “three types of omega-3” fatty acids.
`
`However, the final Office Action also states, in part, the following:
`
`Furthermore, according to the applicant’s (sic) website, “Agricultural Omega
`Solutions LLC (AgO3) supports financially strong, farm supply co-ops located in the Med-
`West with its core services providing specialty custom feed supply. Technologies increase
`the Omega 3 fatty acid content of the targeted animals daily ration which increase the
`Omega 3 content of the animal products for human consumption. The technology and
`application ofthe process naturally balance the Omega 6 to Omega 3 (emphasis added).
`
`Applicants respectfully submit that this is a tacit confirmation that the mark THE 3
`
`OMEGAS is not, and cannot be, construed as being limited to just omega-3 fatty acids, or to the
`
`“three types of omega-3 fatty acids,” because it also references omega—6 fag acids.
`
`In view of this reference in the final Office Action, and the major emphasis placed on omega-
`
`3 fatty acids by the Examining Attorney in issuing a final refusal to register, Applicants believe
`
`that there is good cause to supplement the record on this appeal.
`
`

`
`Applicant’s Request and “Good Cause”
`
`During the preparation of Applicants’ Main Brief under TBMP § 1203.01, Applicants have
`
`developed additional evidence that they believe should be considered by the Examining
`
`Attorney, which supplements the Examining Attorney’s reference to other omega-type fatty
`
`acids in the final Office Action. That evidence has not been previously presented to or
`
`considered by the Examining Attorney, nor is it cumulative.
`
`In an effort to establish a first ground for good cause, counsel for Applicants contacted the
`
`Examining Attorney by telephone on June 20, 2013 to determine if the Examining Attorney
`
`would be agreeable to a remand to consider the three (3) additional exhibits. The Examining
`
`Attorney refused.
`
`However, the Applicants are of the opinion that a second, and more compelling, reason for a
`
`remand exists. Specifically, Applicants believe that the Examining Attorney “opened the door”
`
`to supplementation of the record by making direct reference to omega-6 fatty acids via reference
`
`to an excerpt from the Applicants’ own website. Thus, although the Examining Attorney has
`
`focused exclusively on omega-3 fatty acids in the Office Action (thus effectively and unduly
`
`restricting Applicants’ use of the number “3” in the mark), the Examining Attorney himself
`
`referenced omega-6 fatty acids.
`
`Applicants wish to make of record the fact that a complete analysis of the world of fatty acids
`
`includes omega-3, omega-6, omega-7 and omega-9 fatty acids, which impacts the position taken
`
`in the final Office Action. The three (3) additional exhibits proposed by the Applicants identify
`
`the other types of fatty acids and supplement the record, but not cumulatively. To ignore the
`
`existence of omega-7 and omega-9 fatty acids in the analysis of the THE 3 OMEGAS mark
`
`places undue emphasis on omega-3 fatty acids to the prejudice of the Applicants. In short, since
`
`

`
`the Examining Attorney opened the door to mention omega—6 fatty acids, Applicants feel it only
`
`fair to mention the other fatty acid types that are recognized in the world of fatty acids. Focusing
`
`on only omega-3 fatty acids in the rejection analysis places undue emphasis on the number “3” in
`
`the composite mark, which mark should be considered as a unit and not improperly dissected.
`
`Lastly, the Applicants respectfiilly submit that a denial of this request will unduly prejudice
`
`the Applicants. There is but a thin line between the two types of marks (descriptive versus
`
`suggestive); where there is doubt whether a mark is descriptive or suggestive, that doubt should
`
`be resolved in favor of the applicant. In re Bel Paese Sales Co., I U.S.P.Q.2d 1233, 1986 WL
`
`83304 (T.T.A.B. 1986).
`
`Conclusion
`
`Applicants respectfiilly request that, because the present appeal is at its early stages and
`
`because the Examining Attorney opened the door by referencing another, but not all, omega fatty
`
`acids used in food products with which the current mark is to be used, review of the additional
`
`evidence by the Examining Attorney may be determinative of this matter and a remand to the
`
`Examining Attorney is respectfully requested.
`
`

`
`Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Applicants will also be filing their Main Brief today in
`
`View of the June 22, 2013 deadline for doing so in the event the request for remand is denied.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Agricultural Omega Solutions, LLC and
`Omega Valley Farmers, LLC
`By Their Attorneys
`
`Date:
`
`June 21, 2013
`
`ilwaukee, WI 53202
`414.225.1452
`
`414.278.3652
`
`jheino@dkattorneys.com
`pbergin@dkattorneys.com
`
`N:\DOCS\83032\00005\11526314
`
`

`
`
`
`Omega-7 Fatty Acids - The Essential Non-Essential Fatty
`Acids
`
`What is omega—7?
`
`Most of us have heard of ome-ga~3 essential fatty acids, and maybe o1nega—6
`
`essential fatty acids. There are also omega—9 fatty acids, which are not
`
`"essential," that is, you don't have to get them in your diet so you won't die,
`
`and there is yet another group of useful but non-essential fatty acids known as
`
`the omega—7's. Here are seven things you need to know about omega-7's and
`
`your health.
`
`1. Omega-7 fatty acids are a healthy form of trans- fat.
`
`Trans- fat gets a bad rap because some kinds of trans— fat increase
`
`cellular inflammation and irritate the linings of arteries. Omega—7 fatty
`
`acids like vaccenic {literally "cow") fatty acid found in dairy products is
`
`a trans— fat that helps your body overcome inflammation, if you don't
`
`eat too much of other fatty foods.
`
`2. Omega»? fatty acids are not found in non-fat foods.
`
`It may seem obvious, but you don't get your omega—7's in non—fat dairy
`
`products. Only dairy products made with whole milk or at least 2 per
`
`cent fat milk provide these fatty acids. Omega—7 fatty acids are in liquid
`
`milk, cheese, and yogurt.
`
`3. The omega-7 fatty acid in dairy products may actually lower
`
`cholesterol.
`
`Scientists at the University of Albert have found that feeding lab rats
`
`vaccenic acid for sixteen Weeks lowered total cholesterol, LDL
`
`cholesterol, and triglycerides. This is not, of course, the effect that you
`
`would expect by feeding yourself lots of cheese and butter.
`
`EXHIBIT D i
`
`

`
`4. The best vegetarian source of omega-7 fatty acids is sea buckthorn.
`
`"Sea buckthorn, despite its name, is not an ocean plant. The sea
`
`buckthorn is a plant that grows in high~salt conditions both along the
`
`ocean shoreline and in deserts, from western Europe to Mongolia. The
`
`berries are inedible unless they are "blotted," frozen to increase their
`
`sugar content, but they are a terrific source of vitamin C, containing 15
`
`times as much vitamin C as oranges. Sea buckthorn berries are also a
`
`rich source of omega—7 fatty acids used to make both nutritional
`
`supplements and skin care products.
`
`5. Macadamia nuts are also rich in omega—7 fatty acids.
`
`Macadamia nuts are rich in palmitoleic acid, an omega—7 fatty oil that
`
`provides the building blocks for the enzymes that control the burning of
`
`fat. Australian researchers have investigated palmitoleic acid as a
`
`treatment for obesity. Of course, you don't want just to eat lots of
`
`macadamia nuts to try to lose weight! Palmitoleic acid supplements are
`
`the appropriate weight loss tool.
`
`6. Too much omega—7 in the diet causes an unpleasant side effect.
`
`When omega»? fatty acids accumulate in the oily sebum that lubricates
`
`the skin, they are broken down into the chemical 2—noneal, which
`
`causes the phenomenon known as "old people smell." Frequent washing
`
`and specially formulated cosmetics eliminate the smell.
`
`‘7. You can get the benefits of omega-7's without the risk of old people
`
`smell by taking omega-7 supplements.
`
`Your body does not need omega—’7's to function. Certain, specific omegaf/‘s
`
`have desired health effects. Taking omega—7 supplements gives you the health
`
`benefits without causing accumulation of o1nega—'7's in your skin.
`
`And no matter what your age, ornega—7 supplements can provide essential
`
`health benefits, especially in weight loss and cholesterol control. Omega-7's in
`
`

`
`supplement form can be the non—essential fatty acid that is essential to your
`health.
`
`Selected References:
`
`0 Power, G.W., Cake, M.l-I. 8:. Newsholme EA. [1997} The influence of diet on the activity of
`
`camitine palrnitoyltransferase 1 toward a range of acyl COA esters. Lipids 32: 3.1w37 .
`
`Omega-zz Side Effects
`
`Does omega»? have any side effects?
`
`Omega—z Benefits
`
`What are the health benefits of Omega—'7?
`
`Read Our
`
`Guide
`
`Learn How
`
`To Choose
`a
`
`High
`Quality 85
`Safe
`
`Fish Oil
`
`Sugplement
`
`
`
`
`
`Related Articles
`
`o Omega—'7 Side Effect - The Problems You Can Encounter from Taking
`Too Much of the Wrong Omega—'7 Side Effects
`
`0 Omega-7 Benefit
`
`-~ Omega—7 Benefits — Could Consuming Fat Actually
`
`Help You Lose Weight?
`
`

`
`Bookmark or Share This! fwhatare these?)
`
`1
`
`.i..
`.1.
`
`JE
`
`

`
`.
`
`Our TOP 3 Recommended Fish Oil Brands
`
` ’~-,--..
`
`New Vitalig
`
`
`
`Fat Acids HubPriVac Polio ermsAdvertisin Contact UsSitema Ea
`
`© Copyright 2011, Fatty Acids Hub
`
`

`
`Effects of Fatty Acids on Reproduction in the Dairy Cow:
`'
`The Good and the Bad
`
`Helene V. Petit, Ph. D.
`_
`Dairy and Swine Research and Development Centre
`Agriculture and Agri—Food Canada
`P. O. Box 90, Lennoxville, QC JIM 1Z3
`Canada
`
`Introduction
`
`Recently, there has been a great deal of interest in feeding fat to dairy cows in
`order to increase energy density of the diet and improve reproduction. It is known that
`cows fed supplemental fat may experience improved energy balance and begin to cycle
`sooner because of enhanced follicular growth and development (Grummer and Carroll,
`1991). However, Lucy et al. (1992) suggested that it was fatty acids, and not the
`additional energy provided by the fatty acids, that stimulated ovarian fimction. Recently,
`new information has been published that demonstrates that the type of dietary fatty acids
`is important as individual fatty acids do not have the same effects on reproduction of the
`dairy cow.
`
`Fatty Acid Terminology
`
`A fatty acid molecule is shaped like a caterpillar with two different ends: a methyl
`group and a water-soluble end that is the carboxyl end." There ‘are '_different"_familieS—of
`"fatty acids in feed: _o_r'ne'ga-3, omega-6, omega-7, and oinega-.9.'_-The most common
`numbering system is called the omega system. This system numbers carbon atoms in
`sequence, starting from the methyl end. The other commonly used system, called the
`delta (d) system, starts at the acid end and numbers the carbon atoms in reverse direction.
`
`The omega-7 family of fatty acids is synthesized fi'om palmitic acid (C16:O) while
`the omega-9 fatty acid family is synthesized fi'om stearic acid (C1820) via oleic acid
`(C18: 1, Figure 1). These two families are not considered essential as they are produced in
`the body.
`
`The omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are essential because both are vital to
`health but cannot be made by our cells and must, therefore, be provided by foods.
`
`Linoleic acid (Cl 8:2) belongs to the omega-6 family while linolenic acid (C183)
`belongs to the omega-3 family (Figure 2). The system used to name fatty acids considers
`the number of carbons in the chain (e.g. 18 for linoleic acid), the number of double bonds
`in the chain (2 for linoleic acid) and where in the chain the first double bond is located
`from the methyl end (lst double bond between carbons 6 and 7 for linoleic acid): C18:2.
`
`EXHIBIT E
`
`

`
`Figure 1. Schematic pathway of omega-7 and omega-9 fatty acid synthesis.
`
`Ci-4:0
`
`C18:1
`
`I
`Palmitic Acid abr-
`C1620
`I
`Stearic Acid —I> Oleic Acid —>Omcga9
`C18:0
`
`Figure 2. Schematic pathway of omega-6 and omega—3 fatty acid synthesis.
`
`0mega—6 fatty acids
`
`Omega.-3 fatty acids
`
`C18:2n6 Linoleic acid
`
`Cl8:3n3 u~LinoIaic acid
`
`¢ -ta A6 Desaturase an- ‘
`
`Cl8:3n6 'y=~I;.inolenic acid
`
`C18:4n3 Stearidonic acid
`
`‘ «T Elongase an- *
`
`C20:3n6 Dihomo-7-Linolenic acid
`
`C20:4n3 Eioosateuaenoic acid
`
`J, «T A5 Desaturase ——e- {,
`C20:4n6 Arachidnnic amid
`'
`' C20:5n3 Eicosapentaenoic acid
`
`

`
`‘Sources of Fatty Acids
`
`The main sources of short chain fatty acids are cottonseed and palm oils. All
`sources of fat contain long chain fatty acids. The main sources of linolenic acid
`(C18:3n3) are flaxseed, hemp, canola, soybean, nuts and dark green forages. Ryegrass
`silage contains as much as 60% of Iinolenic acid as a percentage of total fatty acids
`(Dewhurst and King, 1998), which would encourage high forage systems to increase
`dietary linolenic acid content. Omega—3 fatty acids are found also in cold water and salt
`water fish (salmon,
`trout, mackerel, sardines). The main sources of Iinoleic acid
`(C18:2n6) are sunflower seed, safflower, hemp, soybean, nuts, pumpkin seeds, sesame
`seeds and flaxseed. Gamma-linolenic acid (Cl8:3n6) is found in evening prirnose oil,
`grape seeds and borage. Dihomogamma-linolenic acid (C20:3n6) is found in maternal
`milk while arachidonic acid (C20:-4n6) occurs mainly in meat and animal products. Oleic
`acid (C1821) is found in olive, almond, avocado, peanut, pecan, cashew, macadamia nut
`and butter. Omega 7 in the form of palrnitoleic acid (C16:l) is found in tropical oils
`(coconut, palm). Composition in C18 fatty acids of some edible vegetable oils is
`reported in Table 1.
`
`Adapted from Erasmus (1993).
`
`Fatty Acids and Fertility
`
`Supplementary fats are likely to affect fertility because fatty acids are the
`precursors both of prostaglandins (PG) and, via cholesterol, the steroid hormones. In
`general, feeding supplemental fat such as calcium soaps of long chain fatty acids, fish
`meal, and tallow increases conception rates. However, a lowered conception rate at first
`service has been reported when there was a paralleled increase in milk production (range
`
`

`
`of 2.2 to 4.5 kg/d). Thatcher and Staples (2000) wrote an excellent review on the subject.
`There are two main families of essential fatty acids, omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids,
`that could affect fertility. The main source of omega-6 fatty acids is dietary linoleic acid
`(Cl8:2n-6) and this is converted to arachidonic acid (C20:4n-6), which inter alia is the
`precursor of the dienoic (2-series) PG, such as PGF;;_.,. The same elongase and desaturase
`enzymes also convert the main dietary omega-3 fatty acids (oi-linolenic acid; C18:3n-3)
`-to eicosapentaenoie acid (EPA; C20:5n-3), the precursor of the trienoic (3-series) PG,
`such as PGF3.;, (Abayasekara and Wathes, 1999). Competition between omega-3 and
`omega-6 precursors for desaturation and elongation as well as at the site of PG synthetase
`means that increasing the Supply of omega-3 fatty acids will decrease production of
`dienoic PG (Barnouin and Chassagne, 1991). In many cases the trienoic PG have lower
`biological activity than the corresponding dienoic PG (Fly and Johnston, 1990) and this
`may directly affect aspects of fertility. For example, treatments that reduce ovarian and
`endometrial synthesis of PGF2a, at the expense of PGF3.,, may contribute to a reduction
`in embryonic mortality (Mattos er al., 2000). There is some evidence for different effects
`of oi-linolenic acid and the omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil (EPA and docosahexaenoic
`acid (DHA), C22:6n-3) on eicosanoid (interleukin) synthesis, perhaps because of
`differences in the way in which these fatty acids incorporate into cell membranes (Wu et
`al., 1996).
`
`Supplementary fats can also reduce the total synthesis of PG by affecting the
`activity of PG synthase (Thatcher et al., 1995). Diets rich in linoleic acid (C18:2)
`increase arachidonic acid concentration (C20:4) in tissues and diets rich in linolenic acid
`(C18:3) increase concentration of eicosapentaenoic acid (C20:5) (Béréziat, 1978).
`Moreover, eicosapentaenoic acid (C20:5) is a competitive inhibitor of the enzyme
`complex involved in the synthesis of prostaglandins from arachidonic acid (C20:4) (Leat
`and Northrop, 1979; Holman, 1986). Therefore, this would suggest that a diet with a low
`lirioleic to linolenic acid ratio (Cl8:2:C18:3, omega-6:omega-3) could decrease
`prostaglandin secretion or prostagiandin activity as suggested by Barnouin and
`Chassagne (1991), which would thus have important effects on reproduction and
`immunity in the dairy cow.
`
`Prostagladins Synthesis
`
`There are two main pathways (Figure 3) used to synthesize PG: one is used by
`most dietary fat (e.g. corn and soybean, sources of omega-6 fatty acids) and leads to
`series 1 and 2 PG while the other one is more specific to fish products and flax (sources
`of omega-3 fatty acids) and leads to series 3 PG. Thus, depending on the pathway used
`for PG synthesis, the type and role of the resulting PG will differ. PG of series 2 are
`"important at calving; they increase platelet agglutination and blood clot formation, they
`increase salt retention in kidneys, water retention, and blood pressure. PG of series 2 aiso
`cause inflammation, which leads to their role of “bad guys” among the different PG
`SBHCS.
`
`

`
`Figure 3. Metabolic pathway of series 1,2 and 3 prostaglandins.
`
`a ega—6 may adds
`
`
`o.i.ega;s ratiy ids
`
`
`
`C18:2n6 Lincleic acid
`
`C18:3r13 or-Linoieic acid
`
`C18:3n6 'g~Lino1cnic acid
`
`CI8:4n3 Stearidonic acid
`
`C20:3n6 Diliomo-ye-Linclenic acid
`# C Series 1
`Proshghmdim
`C20:4n6Aracl1idcnic acid
`cyclooxygenase If
`C
`pmgtaglandins H,
`Parrrsnaarm
`
`Saw: 2
`
`C20:4n3 Eiccsatetracncic acid
`V‘
`C20:5n3 Eicosapentacnoic acid
`
`C /‘Zn:-ostaglandhi synthasc
`
`Series 3
`
`improve the immune sytem of T cells, prevent platelet
`1
`PG of series
`agglutination and heart attack, contribute to remove the excess of Na and water in
`kidneys, decrease the inflarnrnatory responseand contribute in controling arthritis and
`decreasing cholesterol production. PG of the series" 3 have a very weak platelet
`agglutination power and they prevent fabrication of PG of the series 2; they also prevent
`heart attack, water retention, and inflammation. PG of the series 1 and 3 are thus
`considered as “good guys” contrary to those of the series 2. In fact, our preliminary
`results (Gagnon er al., 2000) showed that some immune parameters were affected by the
`type of dietary fatty acids at the time of embryo implantation.
`Some polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) can serve as a substrate for the
`synthesis of PGFM. These include cis-linoleic acid (Cl8:2) that is commonly found in
`natural fat sources. It can be desaturated and elongated to form arachidonic acid which
`serves as an immediate percursor for the series 2 PG of which PGF20, is a key member.
`Key regulatory enzymes
`for
`these conversions
`include A six desaturase and
`cyclooxygenase. These same fatty acids also can inhibit PG synthesis by competitive
`inhibition with these key enzymes. Linoleic acid has been shown to be an inhibitor of PG
`synthesis that is produced by the endometrium in response to the presence of a conceptus
`in order to perserve the integrity of the conceptus (Thatcher et al., 1994). Other fatty
`acids besides linoleic acid can play inhibitory roles. EPA and docosahexanoic acid
`(C22:6) have been shown to inhibit cyclooxygenase activity, which is an enzyme
`involved in the synthesis of PGF2o,+.
`
`Fatty Acids, Cholesterol, and Progesterone
`Cholesterol serves as a precursor for the synthesis of progesterone by ovarian
`luteal cells.
`Secretion of progesterone is the main funtion of the corpus luteum.
`Progesterone not only prepares the uterus for implantation of the embryo but also helps
`
`

`
`The successful
`to the conceptus.
`maintain pregnancy by providing nourishment
`establishment and maintenance of pregnancy (before day 16 post AI) requires the
`maintenance of progesterone secretion through the critical period of the maternal
`recognition of pregnancy when luteolysis occurs in the non-pregnant animal (Lamrning
`and Royal, 2001). Between 25 and 55% of mammalian embryos die in early gestation.
`Increased concentrations of plasma progesterone have been associated with improved
`conception rates of lactating ruminants. Similarily, progesterone concentration prior to
`AI has been associated with greater fertility.
`In a field study involving 426 lactating
`dairy cows, blood was sampled on 58d postpartum for rnultiparious cows and 72 for
`prirniparous cows and then analyzed for progesterone. Cows were bred approximately 3d
`later in a synchronized estrus scheme. Conception rate increased 1.44% for every 1
`ng/ml increase in plasarn progesterone (r2 = 0.11, Staples et al., 1997). The recovery of
`embryos 7d afier estrus increased as plasma progesterone concentration increased just
`prior to AI (Britt er al., 1996). In either association, dietary fat, which stimulates ovarian
`cyclicity or corpus luteum function, would contribute to increased fertility. Increased
`progesterone suggests that luteal fiinction is enhanced by dietary fat. Dynamics of
`maternal progesterone secretion also appear important for conceptus development and
`secretion of interferon-‘c, which is secreted by the embryo for gestation recognition by the
`mother.
`
`It has been suggested that improved conception rate could be a result of increased
`concentrations in plasma cholesterol (Spicer er al., 1993), although this hypothesis was
`not supported by our results. In fact, cows fed formaldehyde-treated flaxseed had lower
`plasma cholesterol concentration and better conception rate than those fed Megalac®
`(Petit et al., 2001). Other studies have reported no relationship between cholesterol
`concentrations in blood and reproductive measures (Ferguson et al., 1990; Spicer er al.,
`1990).
`
`The fatty acid profile of the dietary fat may influence the propensity of animals to
`increase plasma progesterone. Mature ewes were infused intravenously with saline,
`soybean oil, or olive oil for 5h on d 9 through 13 of an estrous cycle (Burke et al., 1996).
`Serum cholesterol was increased by fat infusates, and olive oil was more effective than
`soybean oil (127, 141, and 153 mg/dl for saline, soybean oil, and olive oil, respectively).
`However, soybean oil infusion resulted in greater progesterone response than did infusion
`of olive oil at 2.5h postinfusion.
`Therefore,
`the greatest concentration of serum
`cholesterol did not coincide with the greatest concentration of serum progesterone.
`
`Fatty Acids and Prostaglandins Secretion
`
`It is known that there is a negative relationship between concentration of PGFM
`and that of progesterone. For example, at calving, PGF2(, concentration increases while
`‘that of progesterone decreases. Similarly, during gestation, PGFM concentration
`decreases and that of progesterone increases. Progesterone is secreted by the corpus
`luteum and synthesized by steroids. Therefore, an increase in PGF2o, concentration is
`paralleled with a decrease in progesterone concentration and vice versa. In theory, it
`could thus be possible to modulate concentrations of PGFZO, and progesterone by different
`
`

`
`in the experiment we carried out in UK, we observed a
`feeding strategies! In fact,
`tendency (P = 0.09) for greater progesterone concentration in the blood of cows fed
`formaldehyde-treated flax compared to those fed Megalac (Petit at al., 2002). This may
`partly explain the greater gestation rate observed for cows fed formaldehyde—treated flax
`(87.5%) compared to those fed Megalac (50.0%) in a companion study (Petit er ai’.,
`2001).
`
`Better conception rate for cows fed formaldehyde-treated flaxseed compared to
`those fed Megalac® could result from different prostaglandins synthesis. In fact, linolenic
`acid in flaxseed uses the eicosapentaenoic acid metabolic pathway while fatty acids in
`Megalac uses partly the arachidonic acid pathway (Cunnane, 1995) and it is known that
`eicosapentaenoic acid inhibits prostaglandins synthesis (Spicer er al., 1993). Therefore,
`ingestion of linolenic acid contained in flaxseed could potentially inhibit PGFM synthesis
`(Curmane, 1995). Thatcher et al. (1997) has shown that PGFM secretion is decreased in
`dairy cows fed fish meal. In fact, fish meal, which would lead to eicosapentaenoic acid
`and docosahexaenoic acid formation, has been shown to increase gestation rate of dairy
`cows and to alter corpus luteum regression as shown by greater plasma concentrations of
`progesterone (Burke et al., 1997). This would agree with the tendency observed in one of
`our experiments (Petit et al., 2002)
`for greater milk progesterone concentration,
`expressed as the area under the curve, for cows fed formaldehyde—treated flaxseed
`compared to those fed Megalac®. However, it is not known if the greater conception rate
`observed for cows fed fonnaldehyde-treated flaxseed in the experiment of Petit er al.
`(2001) was a result of a decrease in embryo mortality or better fertilization of the ova as
`pregnancy was confirmed only once at d 45 post AI. More research is required to
`determine the reasons for better conception rate for cows fed a source rich in omega-3
`fatty acids. The potential
`to improve reproduction of dairy cows through dietary
`manipulation is an exciting concept and needs to be further addressed.
`
`One of the rate—limiting precursors for PGFM synthesis is arachidonic acid. It is
`known that the essential fatty acid linoleic acid acts as a competitive inhibitor of PG
`synthase (Thatcher et al., 1994) and that the uterus of pregnant cows at day 17 are
`enriched with non-esterified linoleic acid (Thatcher at al., 1995). An increase in the
`linoleic pool in blood would suggest that linoleic acid becomes a competitive inhibitor
`with arachidonic acid for the prostaglandin synthase enzyme system. In addition, linoleic
`acid can be converted to a shunt metabolite, eicosadienoic acid (C2012), rather than to
`arachidonic acid (Kaduce er al., 1982) when excess linoleic acid is present, thereby
`reducing synthesis of series 2 prostaglandins. A decrease in arachidonic acid biosynthesis
`by inhibition of A6 and A5 desaturase enzymes that are necessary for conversion of
`linoleic acid to arachidonic acid would decrease PGFM secretion. Duodenal infusion of
`yellow grease (enriched in linoleic acid) depressed peak plasma concentrations of PGFM
`(Oldick er al., 1997). Moreover, feeding diets containing 2.6, 5.2 and 7.8% Menhaden
`fish meal to lactating dairy cows reduced uterine secretion of PGF2a (Thatcher at al,
`2001a).
`
`Dietary supplementation with y-linolenic acid (C1823, n-6) or EPA reduced the
`
`

`
`synthesis in vitro of PGF2(1 and PGFg., from human endometrial samples collected 6
`months afier initiation of dietary treaments (Graham et al., 1994). Infusion of a fat source
`rich in linoleic acid (17%) into the abomasum of lactating‘ dairy cows resulted in a
`significant attenuation in the release of PGFM, as measured -in peripheral plasma, in
`response to an injection of oxytocin on day 15 of a synchronized oestrous cycle (Oldick
`et al., 1997).
`
`Dietary PUFAS can decrease PGFM synthesis by different actions, which include
`decreasing the availability of precursor arachidonic acid, increasing the concentration of
`fatty acids that compete with arachidonic acid for series 2 PG, and inhibiting PG
`synthase. Reduced availability of arachidonic acid in the uterine phospholipid
`membranes for conversion to series 2 PG can occur through a reduction in the synthesis
`of arachidonic acid or through displacement of existent arachidonic acid from the
`phospholipid membranes by other fatty acids. This can be achieved through dietary
`supplementation with fish oil (rich in EPA and DHA) or linseed oil as they are major
`inhibitors of desaturation and elongation in liver cells leading to arachidonic acid
`formation (Bezard et al., 1994). Moreover, as there is a preferential processing of n-3
`
`fatty acids by A6 desaturase at the expense of desaturation of n-6 fatty acids (Sprecher,
`1981), feeding n-3 fatty acids would lead to a reduction in arachidonic acid formation. In
`summary, inhibition of PG secretion can be achieved through: 1) reduced synthesis of
`arachidonic acid by A6 and A5 desaturase enzymes necessary for conversion of linoleic
`acid to arachidonic acid; 2) alteration in fatty acid profile in favour of omega-3 in
`membrane phospholipids which may or may not be precursors of other eicosanoids; 3)
`inhibition of synthesis and activity of cyclooxygenase enzymes responsible for the
`
`synthesis of PGFM; and 4) inbition of gene expression involved in the synthesis of series
`2 PG (Mattos er al., 2000).
`
`Maternal Recognition of Pregnancy
`
`to
`The dialogue between the conceptus and uterine endometrium leads
`maintenance of the corpus luteum. The ability of embryonic interferon-‘C to inhibit uterine
`secretion of PGF2u is critical to the establishment of pregnancy in cattle. Up to 40% of
`total embryonic losses are estimated to occur beween day 8 and day 17 of pregnancy
`(Thatcher et al., 1994). This high proportion of losses is coincident with the period of
`conceptus inhibition of uterine PGF;.x secretion, suggesting that some loss may be
`occurring because certain conoeptuses are unable to inhibit secretion of PGFM. Future
`strategies to improve embryo survival during this critical period will be based upon a
`thorough understanding of the factors regulating “a better communication between the
`embryo and the mother" at the embryo interface”.
`
`The success of early pregnancy in the mated cow is dependant on the successfill
`maternal recognition of pregnancy (Thatcher er al., 1995; Mann et al., 1999). To achieve
`this the embryo must prevent the demise of the corpus luteum by the timely production of
`interferon tau, the embryonic signal which acts to inhibit the development of the maternal
`luteolytic mechanism.
`Interferon tau acts
`locally in the uterus to suppress the
`development of oxytocin receptors in the endometrium and thereby suppress the secretion
`
`

`
`of luteolytic episodes of PGF20, generated by the binding of oxytocin to its receptors
`(Mann er al., 1999). It has been shown that the pattern and level of ovarian steroid
`hormones in early pregnancy can influence both embryo development an

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket