throbber
Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. htfQJ/estta.usQto.gov
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
`
`77219819
`
`Apple Inc.
`MULT|—TOUCH
`
`THOMAS R. LA PERLE
`APPLE INC.
`1 INFINITE LOOPMS: 3TM
`CUPERTINO, CA 95014
`UNITED STATES
`
`Iaper|e@app|e.com
`
`Appeal Brief
`
`13 pages )(6685412 bytes)
`MULT|—TOUCHAPPEALBR|EF.pdf
`Apple MULT|—TOUCH Appeal Brief —— Exhibits A and B.pdf ( 49 pages )(5211727
`bytes)
`Apple MULT|—TOUCH Appeal Brief —— Exhibit C.pdf ( 101 pages )(4794222 bytes
`
`) A
`
`pple MULT|—TOUCH Appeal Brief -- Exhibits D-L (F|NAL).pdf ( 107 pages
`)(9843466 bytes )
`
`Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Electronic Filing System. http://estta.uspto.gov
`ESTTA352813
`ESTTA Tracking number:
`06/14/2010
`
`Filing date:
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`77219819
`Apple Inc.
`MULTI-TOUCH
`THOMAS R. LA PERLE
`APPLE INC.
`1 INFINITE LOOPMS: 3TM
`CUPERTINO, CA 95014
`UNITED STATES
`laperle@apple.com
`Appeal Brief
`MULTI-TOUCHAPPEALBRIEF.pdf ( 13 pages )(6685412 bytes )
`Apple MULTI-TOUCH Appeal Brief -- Exhibits A and B.pdf ( 49 pages )(5211727
`bytes )
`Apple MULTI-TOUCH Appeal Brief -- Exhibit C.pdf ( 101 pages )(4794222 bytes
`
`)A
`
`pple MULTI-TOUCH Appeal Brief -- Exhibits D-L (FINAL).pdf ( 107 pages
`)(9843466 bytes )
`Thomas R. La Perle
`laperle@apple.com, glenn.gundersen@dechert.com
`/Thomas R. La Perle/
`06/14/2010
`
`Proceeding
`Applicant
`Applied for Mark
`Correspondence
`Address
`
`Submission
`Attachments
`
`Filer's Name
`Filer's e-mail
`Signature
`Date
`
`

`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`BEFORE THE TRADEMARK TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`In re Application of
`Apple Inc.
`
`Mark: MULTI-TOUCH
`
`Serial No.:
`Filing Date:
`
`78/219,819
`June 30, 2007
`
`.
`:
`
`April K. Roach
`Law Office 115
`
`APPLICANT’S APPEAL BRIEF
`
`

`
`Index of Cited Cases
`
`Hunter Publishing Co. V. Caulfield Publishing Ltd.,
`1 USPQ2d 1996, 1999 (TTAB 1986) ......................................................................................... ..12
`
`Selchow & Righter Co. V. Decipher, Inc.,
`598 F.Supp. 1489 (E.D.Va. 1984) .............................................................................................. ..12
`
`

`
`INTRODUCTION
`
`Applicant Apple Inc. (“Apple”) seeks to register the mark MULTLTOUCH for
`
`“Handheld mobile digital electronic devices with electronic mail, digital data transmission, audio
`
`player, video player, handheld computer, personal digital assistant, electronic organizer,
`
`electronic notepad, telephone, computer gaming, and camera functions” in International Class 9.
`
`The Examining Attorney has refused registration of MULTI-TOUCH under Section
`
`2(e)(l) of the Trademark Act, on the grounds that the mark merely describes Apple’s goods, and
`
`has refused to accept Apple’s claim of acquired distinctiveness under Section 2(f). As the
`
`following arguments and evidence will show, MULTI-TOUCH is entitled to registration on the
`
`Principal Register based on acquired distinctiveness.
`
`As indicated in Apple’s Amendment to Allege Use, Apple has been using the mark
`
`MULTI-TOUCH since 2007 in connection with its iPhone and iPod touch mobile devices. The
`
`identification of goods in this application to register MULTI-TOUCH contains only one item-—
`
`“handheld mobile digital electronic devices with electronic mail, digital data transmission, audio
`
`player, video player, handheld computer, personal digital assistant, electronic organizer,
`
`electronic notepad, telephone, computer gaming, and camera functions.” This identification is
`
`essentially identical to the goods identified in Apple’s Class 9 registrations of IPHONE (RN
`
`3,669,402) and IPHONE and Design (RN 3,746,840). This pending application does not cover
`
`other goods, and therefore does not claim trademark rights in MULTI-TOUCH generally. Thus,
`
`the question of whether MULTI—TOUCH is entitled to registration is limited to whether Apple’s
`
`mark has acquired distinctiveness with respect to the handheld mobile digital electronic devices
`
`identified in the application.
`
`

`
`I.
`
`The Success of Apple’s MULTI—TOUCH Devices
`
`ARGUMENT
`
`Since 2007, Apple has used the trademark MULTI-TOUCH in reference to its iPhone and
`
`iPod touch devices, which are among the most successful and celebrated consumer products in
`
`recent history. Apple first used the mark MULTI-TOUCH at its January 2007 announcement of
`
`the iPhone device, and the mark has been included in Apple’s advertising and marketing ever
`
`since the product was first offered in June 2007. Millions of Apple customers use MULTI-
`
`TOUCH devices on a daily basis. As a result, consumers associate the mark with Apple’s
`
`products.
`
`A.
`
`Pre-Launch Publicity
`
`When Apple formally announced its plans to introduce the iPhone digital mobile device
`
`on January 9, 2007, it drew a remarkable level of interest from the media and the public at large.
`
`The iPhone appeared on the front pages of The New York Times, USA Today, and many other
`
`newspapers, and in stories on national television news and in magazines. In the month of
`
`January 2007 alone, Apple’s iPhone was mentioned in over 2l00 articles in the NEXIS news
`
`database, and those reports represent only a portion of the media coverage. The public
`
`announcement included a demonstration of Apple’s innovative touchscreen interface, branded
`
`MULTI-TOUCH. The mark MULTl—TOUCH appeared in a large number of news stories about
`
`
`the iPhone device. §_eg Exhibits A B and C.
`
`As the materials in Exhibit C indicate, the profile of Apple’s product only grew from
`
`there :
`
`

`
`A June 27, 2007 article in The New York Times, published just prior to the product’s
`
`launch, reported that “[i]n the last six months, Apple’s iPhone has been the subject of
`
`11,000 print articles, and it turns up about 69 million hits on Google.”
`
`According to independent research by measurement firm Nielsen//NetRatings, the
`
`iPhone section of Apple’s web site received more than 1.79 million unique visitors in
`
`January 2007 alone, and more than 980,000 unique visitors in each of February and
`
`March. The MULTI—TOUCH mark appeared on the website.
`
`An officer at Nielsen Buzzmetrics reported that the Internet traffic generated by the
`
`iPhone product was “higher than any product we’ve monitored,” who indicated that
`
`the number of online “blog” posts about iPhone was higher than posts about Super
`
`Bowl commercials, the finale of The Sopranos, or announcements about Nintendo’s
`
`Wii and Microsoft’s Zune and Vista.
`
`Reuters reported that by late March 2007, more than one million emails seeking
`
`information about iPhone had been sent to AT&T, the exclusive telecom carrier for
`
`the product.
`
`By April 2007, an independent survey by measurement firm M:Metrics, Inc. revealed
`
`that nearly two-thirds (64%) of American mobile phone users were aware of the
`
`iPhone product, and a projected 19 million Americans had a strong interest in buying
`
`it. M:Metrics analyst Mark Donovan remarked, “That kind of latent demand is
`
`something I don’t think we’ve ever seen before.”
`
`In another April 2007 survey by the independent firm ChangeWave Research,
`
`Apple’s iPhone was tied with another company’s long-established brand, BlackBerry,
`
`

`
`as the top choice in a survey of people who planned to buy an advanced mobile phone
`
`within the following three months.
`
`° According to Professor David Yoffie of Harvard Business School, attention to the
`
`iPhone product from newspapers, web sites, and other sources was “unprecedented,”
`
`equating to $400 million in free advertising in the months following Apple’s
`
`announcement. Professor Yoffie observed that “no other company has ever received
`
`that kind of attention for a product launch.”
`
`As the launch date neared, USA Today referred to the “mania” for the iPhone, The
`
`Philadelphia Inquirer said “Buzz is big,” and The Los Angeles Times called it “the hottest
`
`product.” fig Exhibit C.
`
`A commentator from CNET News described the iPhone marketing campaign as “Apple’s
`
`best marketing campaign ever, and maybe one of the best ever in American business.” Similarly,
`
`a commentator on Bloomberg.com said that the campaign “may be the most successful
`
`marketing effort ever, surpassing the drive the promote Ford Motor Co.’s 1964 Mustang and
`
`Microsoft Corp.’s Windows 95.” §_e§ Exhibit C.
`
`Thus, Apple’s product had garnered extraordinary public attention even before it was
`
`actually in consumers’ hands.
`
`B.
`
`The Launch of iPhone
`
`Apple introduced the iPhone mobile digital device and services to consumers on June 29,
`
`2007 at approximately 160 Apple stores and 1800 AT&T stores nationwide. Many consumers
`
`camped out in front of retail stores for days beforehand. The launch was a leading story on all
`
`three network newscasts that evening, as well as countless cable and local news broadcasts.
`
`

`
`Once again, the iPhone device appeared on the front page of The New York Times and USA
`
`Today, and received extensive press coverage in other publications across the nation. S_ee_
`
`Exhibit D. Interest was so high that The New York Times alone ran more than a dozen stories
`
`each in June and in July 2007, and tech columnist David Pogue created a humorous video for the
`
`site, which was re-posted on YouTube and received another 800,000 viewings. CBS News "A
`
`Closer Look at the iPhone" received over 6 million viewings on YouTube.
`
`The product was an immediate success. 270,000 units of the iPhone device were sold in
`
`the first two days. Apple continued intensive television and print advertising for the product
`
`before, during, and after the launch. Although Apple’s specific advertising expenditures on the
`
`iPhone are not public, the company spent $338 million on advertising in its fiscal year 2006,
`
`$467 million in 2007, and $486 million in 2008.
`
`Within 74 days after the product’s launch, Apple had already sold one million units of the
`
`iPhone device. The device was featured in myriad “Best of 2007” lists, and Time named the
`
`device “Gadget of the Year” and “Invention of the Year.” E Exhibit C.
`
`C.
`
`iPhone 3G and iPhone 3GS
`
`The success story continued in June 2008, when Apple announced that it would release
`
`“iPhone 3G,” a new version of the iPhone device with increased network speeds and new
`
`features that would be sold at half the price of the original model. The public’s reaction to the
`
`announcement was reminiscent of its reaction to the announcement of the original iPhone device,
`
`as fans and the media speculated about the product and its improvements. Indeed, USA Today
`
`told readers to “Get ready for iPhone-mania 2.0.” §fi Exhibit C.
`
`Apple sold one million units of the iPhone 3G device the very first weekend the product
`
`

`
`was available. Since the launch, the product has continued to be wildly successful. In its fiscal
`
`fourth quarter of 2008 alone, Apple sold 6.9 million units of the iPhone 3G model. By the end of
`
`2008, Apple had sold over 30 million MULTI-TOUCH devices.
`
`In June 2008, Apple announced that it would begin selling downloadable applications for
`
`the iPhone 3G, such as games, books and productivity tools, through its new “App Store,”
`
`accessible through the existing iTunes Music Store. The online App Store opened for business
`
`on Friday, July 11, 2008, and Apple sold 10 million applications in the very first weekend the
`
`product was available. The press proclaimed the iPhone App Store “another home run,”
`
`observing that "Apple has already profoundly changed the technology landscape again”—“the
`
`iPhone App Store simply makes the old way of distributing software seem primitive.” The App
`
`Store currently offers over 65,000 applications. Users downloaded 1 billion applications in the
`
`first 9 months, and had downloaded 1.5 billion by July 2009. E Exhibit C.
`
`In July 2009, Apple launched the iPhone 3GS, selling one million units of the product in
`
`its first three days on the market. E Exhibit C.
`
`D. Ongoing Success
`
`The exposure of the iPhone product and the MULTI-TOUCH interface has only grown
`
`since the time that Apple initially submitted its claim of acquired distinctiveness. In the first
`
`quarter of 2010 alone, Apple sold 8.7 million iPhone devices, and sales of the product doubled
`
`from 2008 to 2009. The iPhone is the second best-selling smartphone in the United States,
`
`holding an estimated 28% share of the market. As of January 2010, consumers had downloaded
`
`over 3 billion applications from Apple’s App Store, and by June 2010, the number had risen to 5
`
`billion. See Exhibit D. All of these iPhone owners use the MULTI—TOUCH interface. The
`
`

`
`continued success and sales growth of the iPhone device means that more and more consumers
`
`have encountered the MULTI-TOUCH mark in advertising, user manuals, and in-store product
`
`demonstrations, which reinforces the fact that they View MULTI-TOUCH mark as an indicator
`
`of source for Apple’s products.
`
`II. Recognition of the MULTI—TOUCH mark
`
`In deeming Apple’s evidence of acquired distinctiveness to be insufficient, the
`
`Examining Attorney has asserted that “applicant’s product may have achieved great popularity
`
`and awareness generally, [but] applicant has not presented evidence showing that MULTI-
`
`TOUCH has achieved similar recognition as a source indicator for applicant’s goods.” However,
`
`the recognition of the mark MULTI-TOUCH goes hand in hand with recognition of the iPhone
`
`device, because virtually all purchasers and prospective purchasers of the product are exposed to
`
`the mark MULTI-TOUCH.
`
`Contrary to the Examining Attorney’s suggestion, Apple’s MULTLTOUCH interface is
`
`not merely a “feature” of its products, but is one of the prime reasons why the iPhone device has
`
`been considered groundbreaking—~and why it has been such a success with consumers. Because
`
`the MULTI-TOUCH interface is a new way for consumers to interact with a mobile device, they
`
`will inevitably learn about the interface when using or researching the product, and will
`
`encounter the mark MULTI-TOUCH via in-store demonstrations, advertisements, product
`
`reviews, or online manuals.
`
`Reporters and consumers alike have raved about the iPhone device’s MULTI-TOUCH
`
`interface. For example, The Washington Post has noted that the MULTI—TOUCH interface “sets
`
`

`
`the iPhone apart,” and PC Magazine has hailed the interface as “revolutionary.” When Apple
`
`released the iPod touch, a new version of its popular iPod digital media player, reviewers were
`
`quick to note that the device features the same MULTI-TOUCH interface that helped to make
`
`the iPhone so popular. gee Exhibit E.
`
`As shown in the attachments at Exhibit F, leading publications refer to “Apple's Multi-
`
`Touch technology” when comparing new smartphones to the iPhone. Apple’s national television
`
`commercials have demonstrated the touchscreen interface of MULTI-TOUCH devices, and the
`
`interface has also been highlighted on Apple’s website. E Exhibit G.
`
`From 2007 through 2009, the three years following Apple’s announcement of the iPhone
`
`device, the term MULTI-TOUCH appeared in more than 2,200 news articles referencing Apple
`
`or iPhone. 3 Exhibit H. As a result, the term is now closely associated with Apple and
`
`recognized as Apple’s mark.
`
`III. Duration of Use
`
`In refusing the claim of acquired distinctiveness, the Examining Attorney has asserted
`
`that “a mere two and half years of use is not sufficient to establish the acquired distinctiveness of
`
`the mark,” given that the mark is “highly” descriptive. Apple respectfully submits that both
`
`assertions are highly subjective.
`
`In fact, there is no legal rule stating the minimum amount of time necessary for a mark to
`
`achieve acquired distinctiveness. §e_e McCarthy on Trademarks, 15:55 (2007). Professor
`
`McCarthy states that public recognition of a mark can be established “comparatively overnight”
`
`and that a trademark user can acquire secondary meaning “almost immediately after launching a
`
`10
`
`

`
`new product.” l_d. E ali Hunter Publishing Co. v. Caulfield Publishing Ltd., 1 USPQ2d
`
`1996, 1999 (TTAB 1986); Selchow & Righter Co. V. Decipher, lnc., 598 F.Supp. 1489 (E.D.Va.
`
`1984) (mark TRIVIAL PURSUIT and accompanying trade dress had acquired distinctiveness
`
`based on “unprecedented success in the marketplace,” including sale of 1,000,000 units during
`
`the first year of use, 13,000,000 units during the first three quarters of the second year of use and
`
`numerous newspaper and magazine articles written about the product).
`
`There is also no rationale for concluding that MULTI-TOUCH is “highly descriptive”
`
`rather than merely “descriptive”, and therefore requires a longer period of use to establish
`
`distinctiveness. Apple’s MULTI-TOUCH devices rely on an input technology that is identified
`
`generally as “touchscreen” interface, which allows the user to enter commands directly via the
`
`display screen rather than using a keyboard or mouse (see Exhibit 1). More specifically, Apple's
`
`devices incorporate a “capacitive” touchscreen, distinguishable from other touchscreen
`
`technologies. A capacitive screen recognizes changes in electrical currents rather than pressure
`
`points, reacting to finger gestures without requiring the screen to be pressed. While
`
`“touchscreen” and “capacitive” are the generic terms for Apple's input technology, MULTI-
`
`TOUCH is a mark that identifies Apple as the source of the products.
`
`MULTI-TOUCH is not a term found in the dictionary, but a coined term. Even if the
`
`mark is understood to indicate that Apple's device is operated by touching its screen, the phrase
`
`MULTI-TOUCH does not clearly and immediately convey to the average purchaser the
`
`functionality of the device —— namely, the fact that the display can be manipulated by moving two
`
`fingers on the screen at the same time, or that images on the screen can be enlarged or reduced
`
`by moving the edges of the images with one's fingers.
`
`ll
`
`

`
`MULTI-TOUCH is not a term of art for smartphones or similar mobile devices. As
`
`shown in Exhibit J, other smartphone makers offer some form of touchscreen interface, but their
`
`sellers use different marks to refer to their touchscreen technology—e.g., HTC uses the mark
`
`TOUCHFLO, RIM uses the mark SUREPRESS, and Samsung uses the mark TOUCHWIZ.
`
`Apple has successfully registered the mark MULTI—TOUCH in 37 different jurisdictions,
`
`including Canada, Mexico, the European Union, and other jurisdictions, as shown in the attached
`
`Exhibit K. While Apple recognizes that the decisions of other trademark offices are not
`
`dispositive as to how the Trademark Office should examine this application, they nevertheless
`
`demonstrate that others who evaluated the registrability of the term MULTI-TOUCH did not
`
`perceive the mark as merely descriptive, much less “highly” descriptive.
`
`Apple’s marks have historically acquired distinctiveness extremely quickly, due to the
`
`popularity of Apple’s products and the media attention they receive. The Trademark Office
`
`recognized that the mark IPHONE mark had acquired distinctiveness less than a year after its
`
`launch, when the Office withdrew a Section 2(e)(l) refusal against application SN 77/975,076 on
`
`May 15, 2008. That application covered the same handheld mobile devices that are described in
`
`the application for MULTI-TOUCH. Moreover, in an Office Action dated November 5, 2007 on
`
`another application for IPHONE (SN 77/078,496), the Office noted that IPHONE is “highly
`
`descriptive”—but Apple’s Section 2(f) claim in that application was nevertheless accepted in an
`
`Office Action dated November 4, 2009. E Exhibit L.
`
`Thus, Apple respectfully submits that if the IPHONE mark could acquire
`
`distinctiveness in less than 11 months on the market, the MULTI-TOUCH mark could achieve it
`
`12
`
`

`
`in the period between its January 2007 announcement and June 2007 introduction, and the
`
`present.
`
`CONCLUSION
`
`In summary, Apple has presented substantial evidence showing not only that its iPhone
`
`device has achieved a remarkable degree of commercial success, but also that the mark MULTI-
`
`TOUCH is closely associated with the product. As such, consumers recognize MULTI-TOUCH
`
`not as a descriptive term, but as Apple’s brand. For this reason, Applicant submits that the
`
`refusal to register is unjustified, and respectfully requests that this mark now be approved for
`
`registration under Section 2(f).
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Thomas R. La Perle
`
`Apple Inc.
`
`13
`
`

`
`Exhibit A
`
`

`
`_Dis_cn\'e:i:_:g Apple !
`
`- Micrusolt lalgrngl Elalnrgr
`eflack ' Q '
`Q
`"
`Search *J"'Favorltes "1
`v
`I
`L V
`
`:
`
`'
`
`hi 55? Q] httgfldiscoverapplelblogsputxornf
`Tuesday. January 09. 200?
`
`V
`
`(30
`
`.‘
`
`”
`
`Apple OFFICIALLY Releases lPhone
`
`finaly yes Hn.1lI_.v my wall is wen. Aflel mole tlmn two years In the nmkilg.
`Apple CEO Steve Jobs ‘mesilay .mnounceil the company‘s intention to elite: the
`Iuolfle Ilantlsoi malkm. IIIMel'lil|I_| the new Apple I'PI1une. The iPlloue blillgs
`togelluer seueml feilllles or the iPml. digital camoia. sman plumes mul even
`polmlale computing to one device. with .1 widescleen display anal an innovative
`inpll metlnml.
`
`"Ewly unce in .1 while .1 aevoiurionmy plmluct comes alang than clmnues
`eveiymlmj.“ Jolrs said.
`
`
`
`__,
`
`Discussions‘
`
`X
`Q]
`
`% .Ird:en1el:
`
`3 lrrterrr-_=t E.-pix:-rer
`
`0 {=3-
`
`E 5 MI-:u:Is::.ft
`
`'
`
`ll
`
`3 ."
`
`:DT!'aC|--,Bt
`
`‘;»‘le ~ IF‘ dlhgence rm...
`
`

`
`'3 Discovering Apple ! - Microsoft Internet Explorer
`
`File
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Tools
`Help
`
`‘NJ Q
`eaack ' 6 V
`
`-271‘
`IE] http1ffdiscuverapaplablagspot.Cami
`
`Search
`
`Favorites p
`
`v
`
`_f_
`
`:3 ' Q
`
`
`
`caled°-MuItiJnucI:"tI1e1PImneteatmesonly
`Ill Iecluaolot
`Featllllu anewil
`
`.1 single physical button. called "home.“ You comm! the phone by siding .1
`finger across its touch-sensitive 3.5-inch display. which has a Iesolutlonnf 320-
`Iry-430 pixels :1 160 pixels-|:eI-Inch «lisp!-1y.
`
`fllltl Call
`ITIIIIGS IIIIGQIEIIOII
`IIIIIS M06 05 X. has TIIII
`The IPIICIIIQ. WIIICII
`semillessly sync clam with .1 Mac. PC. or lmellial sewica. lncllkllng music and
`wleos num mines. conlacts. calemlals. photos. notes. lrookinaa K-5. .1: ul e-in
`JICCGIIIIIS.
`
`The 0.-I6-inch I11.6-mlllmetei nhlck device weighs 4.3 ounces H35 g]l'u'|IIlS| and
`spans a 2-inouapixel camom. volume cc-mol. ling-silent switch. 3.5.miIli|nateu
`lna.1clsa1~mul|o lack. SIM 1| any. "sleep-wake" switch. spealm. mlci oplnone. and .1
`J0-pln Iliad «lock conneciol. The quad-lmml GSM (850MHz. 900MHz. 1800|'u1Hz.
`and 1900M!-izl 0 EDGE phone also has 8fl2.11lrg WI-Fl and Bluetootlu 2.0
`crvpabilltles. Jobs noted 36 cmmhililies will come in the full" e.
`
`Dis|:ussinr:s'
`
`
`
`}
`‘
`
`X
`-ti
`
`start
`
`E ‘*3
`
`fs
`
`3 Intrsrru-at E
`
`E S f'-1:crc-scft'C1f"|‘I1:e-D..‘
`
`V
`
`CL‘|YIa-:4-Ler
`
`33 ‘Male -- IF‘ ddsqer-ce n‘-...
`
`

`
`My Corner — Blog — Microsoft Imernel Explorer
`
`File
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Too\s
`Help
`
`K
`Search if Favorites
`‘:3
`GBack '
`-
`-= E http:flwww.jneacevedn.cornfdn:sfmya:ornerffilagfffles,I'archJve-jan-EDD?.htm|
`‘.t‘J'h81'3 NEW
`Comic Z0112
`Custom Zone
`
`,
`
`
`
`-’.:'1_J
`
`Femforce Zone
`
`Figurezorze
`
`M.‘ II ::v:ner- Ellog
`
`Go
`
`lurk:
`
`v
`
`
`an 200
`‘
`.»
`>:m«‘_|-w_1 _‘,\_.'|:H,|
`
`_- ‘Ir
`
`I J
`
`
`
`Dec 2003
`NW 2IJEJE
`Oct 2008
`Sen EUDS
`:'-\.LI§] 2003
`Jul EDIJB
`
`
`N13‘! IIJEIE
`
`Appl_e int_ro_du_ces ft_he _iPI_‘}__O_l__1_E.‘_
`
`
`
` -
`
`IF‘ -jnliq-:-.rnu:e n1 .
`
`‘
`
`3 ]l'4[E-.rE'I+:-I E .- plmrgr
`
`

`
`
`'3 My Corner — Blog — Microsoft Internet Explorer
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Tools
`Help
`
`
`
`
`
`May 200?
`Apr zoo?
`Mar EDI]?
`liar:
`
`
`
`0 ', 1l1DL|i"':
`
`'9’
`4‘
`’
`Search
`'*Favorloes
`I
`If}
`{'1
`93"“"'
` I‘--‘E-.‘
`EL hl:l:p:.r,fwww.jooaoevedo.cornfdocsflmycornerlfllogffieslarchlve-jarr2DD7.html
`
`v
`
`d
`
`
`
`rPhone combines three products — a revolutionary mobile phone, a widescreen Pad with touch controls, and
`a breakthrough Internet communications device wlth desktop-class email, web browsing, maps. and searchlng — into
`one small and Iightweloht hanoheld device. iPhone also introduces an entlrelv new userlnterlace based on a large multi-
`touch display and pioneering new soflware, letting you control everything with lustyour fingers. So ll ushers in an era of
`software power and sophistlcatlon never before seen in a mobile device, completely redefining whalyou can do on a
`mobile phone.
`
`"Every once in a while a revolutionary product comes along that changes evemhing,"Jobs said.
`
`Featuring a newinpultechnologv called "Mult'rTouch"the iF'hone features only a single physical button, called "home "You
`control the phone byslicling a finger across tls touch-eensllive 3.5-inch display, which has a resolution of32D-by-4B0
`
`pixels at 1 Bill pixels-per-inch display.
`
`fig
`
`The lPhone. which runs Mac 05 K, has full lTunee integration and can seamlessly sync data with a Mac, PC, or Internet
`service, including music and videos from JTLIFIQS, contacts, calendars, photos, notes, bookmarks and email accounts.
`
`The D 46-inch {1 1 .6»milIimeter) thick device weighs :13 ounces (135 grams) and sports a Zarnegapirrel Camera, volume
`control, ring-silent switch, 3.5-millimeterheedsetfaudlo jack, SIM lrav,"eieep-wake‘ switch, speaker, microphone, and a
`30-pin iPod dockconhector. The quad-band GSM (35flMHz, QEIEJMHZ, 1SEI£IMHz, and ‘l9EIUMHz) + EDGE phone also has
`BEl2.11brg WrFi and Bluetooth 2.0 capabllrtles. Jobs noted 30 capabllities will come in the future.
`
`'
`
`, _@DIscussions not available on t1l:tp:lj'mn-rw.joaa:evado.com,r'
`
`
`‘Ell l ,1‘:-.‘IZIlJ‘3
`
`' start
`
`@108’.
`
`I!
`
`a? i:|“«
`
`E S l'-1:»:rr_-soft '.'.'rl7FIi:e 0...
`
`v
`
`CDli'a-:|-.r:-.r
`
`'3 Irrterrlet E -Ellurer
`
`3:36 PM
`M'.Y‘rd&'}."
`
`

`
`C|¢n'1o|' of Ihe Mind - Miclosofl Inlernel lxploter
`File
`Edit
`‘flew
`Favorites
`Tools
`Help
`
`oaack '
`J.
`fl ’!"Search *FavorIbes
`‘___v
`.5 V Q "a ti
`fl hI|:p:ffb|shvk.wnrdpr3ss.:om,f
`
`H Iwant an !Ph0ne'
`F'|'J:1téJLI\-‘ blghuk | _1.g,r:_.an. gt" 3:30;
`
`:1
`
`Apple just un‘-ma:‘\ed their ruew pnroduct 2 weal-'5 ago which is the
`xF‘h-:m'-.
`ltrvzallv :-3 a coal phone and the -Jnh thiF|I'_1 rnismrng is. 3-3
`w:.:1p.3bn|it‘,-. Here’: an amnla Fr:-rr: rrsdc.\-‘-.uJr’ld regarding the |F‘h::uma.
`
`http:/fwww.mau:wor|d.r;c-rn.-’news.c’2UD7.'“Cl1iB9f:phone/index.php
`
`Apple unveils i5-hone
`
`Sr Ma-then.» Hanan
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:fl_D,D:".-3 ~i'.'.:"'O S'2‘c’-V-.= J-:1.-’:~s I"ur:-:'Q':iy a.1n»:~r.-n-:ea'
`flflea‘ r.wore- than two re-3".-‘ «re the rnal mg,
`
`the Cr:-H‘.-‘u:»-r:rr»|/5 .".d-.fer»..'."cm £0 entv:-.-' 23’“.«5- H.-abs"!-5 h-3.':d5e-3 n‘ra.'i:-H.
`:.ar.u.-'
`.~'{ng :.‘n-:-
`.1-ew .flpp.’n~:-
`
`1.-“hone-. The Phone .5: mg; to;3eme:' several feature-5 cw.-"t.nc= .fF'c»a‘,
`- miter’ -;ama‘-'5. smanf
`
`.=:-hon-r:—s an-:2’ eu.;:—.-2 ,':I-o."-?a£«’E- comoufing 24: one deLr.'?:e, u;.*-ti? 5 w.«‘a'e-5‘,
`-3-.‘—!‘! a'."5p:'ay am’ a
`nnnouar.-we Jnput method,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“a3?
` air‘-pn ar.-If cg
`‘r; has r1.e.~'f (Tune: rntr:
`The .'F‘h::rne-, um.-ch .>'=..'.=7-.= Ma:
`
`.:*‘a-ta mm .5 Mac, PC. Jr‘ I.":.'.‘e.~n-‘us! 5c'!r'W>:c?,
`.-n-:~.-‘uufing m-
`.: am:-' L-idea-5 frorn {TU-F'r3>]
`-:-int-iczs, -:'aIen-:‘s.»'.~'.
`..'.'s.*-.-pt us,
`rs»:-5-:-.-',
`.f‘c-ofirmarias and e-~rraa:‘." actaunts,
`
`“Ewe.-‘Lr ancxs (re .9 wh:'f6- a .-'evo:‘ux.-‘onary ,EJr'»Jdur."f c.~o.'n_E-5 aiong that changes euer5»r.*:.=ng4 ‘
`Jobs saw‘.
`
` ta-ucrh-5e-nsaime 3 2‘-arm-.h :3‘.L«'p4'ap,
`
`I-«.*a:'c.h has a ‘-"ego,-’:_.-4:.-.:».n gr‘ 325--by -330 pp 9.-'5 a: 1.50
`
`r:.~:':cc-I": ~pc?-“‘.'.'1C. 4 r:'r.vp.’ay .
`
`E 0 E
`
`E5.
`
`

`
`'3 ikpple | where beauly and geek bloggers meel: March 200? — Microsofl Internal Explorer
`
`File
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Tools Heb
`3
`
`6 Back '
`
`“I
`
`If]
`
`:1
`
`I
`
`Search * Favorites
`
`v
`
`7.
`
`.3 v H fl
`
`”
`'.ir.i
`Go
`V
`4::u::== E] httpdfthhk-apple.b|ogspot.coml2BCI7_D3_EI1_archive.htn1l
`— T—'
`
`Get ‘Free’ New i_Pl_1n[3c 3G
`Get a Free {Phone sent To Your Door
`Limited Quantity - Almost Gone.
`i-.'\»‘\-I.‘ I}»;-HE" -.ri-,—F--:1.-,--.1.-iv--.
`
`NQ3 l_’Ia}v_-er; — (heal;
`809%: of people pal; way too much For
`mp3 players. Compare prices to Sam:
`.'~"r f.Ee.-.-
`--2 an-.
`
`New Whom: 3|’: Cases Sale
`Find Everything Bcfinyfhing You Are
`Looking For at 75% OFF Retail Prize
`‘4““l_'E‘:-'/:’V:.:.>">F"i‘
`
`< >
`
`Ad: by Googlz
`
`
`
`— ”°"'“°"° '““' “""‘ —
`V 2::-:1‘? (5)
`5‘!-Wti;r_= (21
`V -hplll (4)
`Hr-hue (1)
`*‘_‘J5““ "*7" '—'.'r:3
`5.,-,;ut=." £7)
`i-_—..g._~ _:
`-,-r w_.r, (2)
`Em;
`iFI‘2 [1]
`-, an (1)
`
`
`
`. Ir‘ If H U]
`
`I. M“ (15)
`.' km]. (2?!
`A... ....l"nru-ulo
`
`’‘
`
`Discu5siDns'
`
`{£1 IE '3
`
`4;
`
`« _éDiscus5ions not availableonl-ttp:HtHnk-app|e.b|oospat.comJ
`
`5!-Hjzoog
`
`Q? IZDTr'a:l;e|
`
`5J' W3:-le -- EF‘ diligence nm ..
`
`Internet E:-zplc-re:
`
`'<
`
`Monday
`
`-QJT 3.».-‘,:.',
`_ -
`‘.'.:_ (3)
`
`.- (1!
`,.
`~..
`— 1r
`|7.i,'i'ilC-‘-7: [9]
`FillT‘ [31
`
`V
`
`Q
`
`

`
` iilpple l where beauty and geek bloggers meal: March 2007 - Microsoll Internet Explor
`File
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Tools
`Help
`
`Search ~i{Favorites
`’,
`I] Q
`eflack -
`Alli.
`E. http:fl'think—apple.blogspot.com.l2ClEl?_U3_D1__arcliive.html
`
`-
`
`‘_
`
`it -
`
`‘:1
`
`V
`
`Go
`
`1
`
`2
`
`A
`
`Featunstic iPhune
`
`notes, bookmark: and e-mail accounts. lu
`
`
`the iPl'n:ne brings
`reported that
`»'_.u.-J
`.\.I..a-
`together several features oi’ the iPod, digital
`camera,
`smart phones
`and even portable
`computing to one device, with a widescreen
`display
`and an innovative
`input method.
`
`Featuring a new input technology called “EE-
`Tifi.
`e i
`one features only a single physical
`outton, called “home.” You control the phone by
`
`inch display, which has a resolution of 320-by»
`sliding a finger across its touch—sensiti\re 3.5-
`430 pixels at 169 pixels—par-inch display.
`
`The iPnone, which runs Mac OS X, has full iTunes
`integration and can seamlessly sync data with a
`Mac, PC, or lnternet service, includingrnuslc and
`videos from iTunes, contacts, calendars, photos,
`
`thick device
`The 0.46-inch (11.6-niiimeterj
`weighs 4.6 ounces [135 grams) and sports a 2-
`megapixel camera, volume control,
`ring-silent
`switch, 3.5-milirieter headsetfaudio jack, SIM
`tray, “sleep-wake” svaitch, speaker, microphone, and a 30-pin ii‘-‘oo dock connector. The
`quao—lJand GSM {8SOMH2, 900MHz,
`1SDE|lulH2, and 1*?IJ0MH2J
`4- EDGE phone also has
`BlJ2.11D!g W"ivFi and Elluetooth 2.lJ capabilities. Jobs noted 3G capabilities will come in the
`luture.
`
`!
`
`’‘
`
`Discussions '
`
`'_“_; ‘Q _
`
`. _6Disu.is:.ions not available onl:tIp:1,fthl:ik-apple.bloqspot.comf
`
`%
`
`-V
`
`Q;
`
`51-[H3009
`
`3: 3'13 PM
`
`I‘/ln:.¢r»d.3y
`
`_
`
`E3 Il'\-"yin: ‘~ IF‘ dilloerite ni. ..
`
`3 Intezrlef, E.-.p
`
`:
`
`

`
` Ffle Edit View Favorites Tools Help
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Search if Favorites ‘7
`I
`g 7"
`)1
`efiack '
`:
`-_-_::http:,I',I’iphone.c|ick2creatLon.corn,i20EL9J'D4,a’app|e-announced-3g-iphone}
`
`-
`
`_r
`
`._vJ
`
`'
`
`3
`
`‘fig
`
`Il"HuM N3 CA5!-
`:1
`___,(LlHL EU LDIILUN)
`
`F'wHn‘
`
`IMP vm TW-'\II»w
`11:: T‘|i_ -41>.‘
`'J.‘IH‘_1
`
`Enter -.-mu »:-mm! _‘_‘dJ-9-52
`
`

`
`
`
`3,~_;,¢:'3-;~':‘—.:-.'4u::: \-c-@_».pu..‘r
`’;4:_w_’_‘-‘-.'..'.;‘. :I|,.\1J-5I’:_igI.t.:_V__('
`View
`Favorites
`FHE
`Edit
`Tools Heb
`’II!
`
`-.1
`4.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`"
`
`
`
`-
`
`’—'._J D,-.
`
`0 Back
`
`-
`
`:1
`
`(7!
`Search %( Favorites
`__. httpJfiphane,clnckzcreatxon.:om,i2009,I‘D4fappl5-announced-3g-Iphonej
`
`Lel's1ake a Inuk a! me design. GPS and the new teatules like Mobileme.
`
`Design
`
`-I §|||JI'l'IiF'IIJIrI‘ It
`.II'\L1I>?|fH UIJ
`.
`
`|lI|J|I.1l'It‘IcIJ
`|'|:=|'1-.|T'I[l
`
`_
`
`9 DH the [':|fu'w
`H wll1FH'JlHI.%U‘_Fi
`
`:|.=\u,.ue pr»:-
`I Fx_ ,1lIu‘|
`
`'1I|
`Hflruj
`1:,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`n'n"n"s‘r"u's"a"'6"n'i'n"I5-."bIn'o'I‘n'v'n'o',h'I'r"c’*|7’I‘a's"u"I”in',i7r'-o‘i'i*I-5a"i's'o'i7i'n's'Lu‘n"I‘i’i'.'|"n'_
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`nil-_1ir?Iraru
`
`er um:
`
`iPh
`
`
`
`

`
`iPod touch — Mulli-touch intetfdce. Wi—Fi. and more v Microsoft Internet Explorer
`Fule
`Edut
`View
`Favorites
`Tools
`Help
`
`I
`-
`‘-1
`‘i(Fav0rites
`Search
`_
`9:
`eBack '
`-‘
`. Q]http:Htheappleblog.cnmj2DDFjI39;'D5hpad-touchvrnultlvtouch-unterface-wlvfi-and-mare}
`
`1_
`
`V
`
`
`
`articles
`submit
`
`forums
`
`archives
`
`reviews
`
`“
`
`v -) Go
`
`i_3m;: ”
`
`iPod touch — Multi-touch interface, Wi-Fi,
`I and more
`'
`'
`'
`
`H 5-ubmi, “P5 \ R55 Fm,
`
`Readflaelpplefllogvia email:
`
`
`
`Today Apple announced a majur addrtiUntutheIr1F'0rJ lane called IPDU touch . It bears
`Significant slmiiarities to the |Phnne With touch screen capatulities. wide screen display, and
`more
`
`Sign Up
`
`
`
`..i ..::-‘.x --n
`-.-‘
`,-I--1:‘
`' Put Cloud (_Z0mpuli_ng to Work
`
`‘El ICIIICJ
`
`2 Day Sale
`
`SAVE UP TO 5562
`"mum": uspuflounam
`
`V
`
`Q
`
`Discussions’
`X
`. Internet
`%
`Q] Dune
`
`Stan
`Q Q!
`E 5;?‘ i:|
`c(-
`-
`3:-I5!-"M
`I\1ond-by
`
`
`f‘__; 1.}
`
`‘ Qbiscussians not available on i‘rttp:,f,ftheaJpleb|og.cam_i
`
`5 Mniruj-Jujft Dffxce. O...
`
`-
`
`‘_
`
`IDTI1-mil-'.Er
`
`-
`
`‘ It " IP ::I|I|gr5rn;c rn. . .
`
`3 Irltemet E-. ;.].3;.:—:-
`
`5“ “song
`
`

`
`iPod touch — Mul|i—touch interface, Wi-Fi. and more - Microsoft Internet Explorer
`File
`Edit
`View
`Favorites
`Tools
`Heip
`:g
`
`R.
`-
`Search ‘*Fworlws
`I
`g]
`_
`Gflack v
`
`. {lhtto:,i'i’theapi:ilebEog.:oI11i'Z13U?,iD9f05,iipod~tou(:h-mu|ti—touch-interface-wi-fi-and—moref
`
`.5 V
`
`Included in a previous iPoi:l. Multi-touchzinterface end Wi-Fi access.
`_
`Multi-touch Interface
`
`’ Locum.
`
`V —) Go
`HULLU'lI:H rut-I Mun: ‘,
`
`Liris ”
`‘
`
`kl,r;.t'.lr
`
`Feahmrig miniipaa itznn. 'ni:.i: ai

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket