throbber
Nos. 18-587, 18-588, 18-589
`
`In the Supreme Court of the United States
`
`
`
`DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY, et al.,
`Petitioners,
`
`v.
`REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, et al.,
`Respondents.
`
`
`
`DONALD J. TRUMP, President of the United States, et al.,
`Petitioners,
`
`v.
`NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR THE ADVANCEMENT
`OF COLORED PEOPLE, et al.,
`Respondents.
`
`
`
`KEVIN K. MCALEENAN,
`Acting Secretary of Homeland Security, et al.,
`Petitioners,
`
`v.
`MARTIN JONATHAN BATALLA VIDAL, et al.,
`Respondents.
`
`
`
`On Writs of Certiorari to the United States Courts of Appeals
`for the Ninth, District of Columbia, and Second Circuits
`
`
`
`BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE CURRENT AND FORMER
`PROSECUTORS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT LEADERS IN
`SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS
`
`
`
`MARY B. MCCORD
` Counsel of Record
`JOSHUA A. GELTZER
`ANNIE L. OWENS
`DANIEL B. RICE
`INSTITUTE FOR CONSTITUTIONAL
`ADVOCACY AND PROTECTION
`GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY
`LAW CENTER
`600 New Jersey Ave., NW
`Washington, DC 20001
`(202) 661-6607
`mbm7@georgetown.edu
`
`
`
`
`
`MATTHEW J. PIERS
`CHIRAG G. BADLANI
`CARYN C. LEDERER
`HUGHES SOCOL PIERS
`RESNICK & DYM, LTD.
`70 West Madison St.
`Suite 4000
`Chicago, IL 60602
`(312) 580-0100
`
`
`
`

`

`i
`
`TABLE OF CONTENTS
`
`Page
`
`INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE .......................... 1
`
`SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ............................... 3
`
`ARGUMENT ......................................................... 5
`
`I. DACA FOSTERS EFFECTIVE LAW
`ENFORCEMENT ............................................ 5
`
`Is
`Policing”
`A. “Community
`Essential To Effective Law
`Enforcement ........................................ 5
`
`B. Trust And Respect Between
`Communities
`And
`Law
`Enforcement Officials
`Are
`Thwarted When
`Individuals
`Fear Removal Consequences Of
`Cooperation ......................................... 6
`
`C. DACA Promotes Cooperation
`With Law Enforcement .................... 13
`
`D. DACA Aids Law Enforcement
`By Facilitating Access To
`Identification ..................................... 16
`
`II. DACA HELPS LAW ENFORCEMENT
`PROTECT VULNERABLE INDIVIDUALS
`FROM CRIME AND EXPLOITATION ............. 18
`
`CONCLUSION .................................................... 23
`
`APPENDIX: LIST OF AMICI CURIAE ............ A-1
`
`
`
`

`

`ii
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
`
`Page(s)
`
`CASES
`
`City of Philadelphia v. Sessions,
`309 F. Supp. 3d 289 (E.D. Pa. 2018) .................. 10
`
`STATUTES
`
`8 C.F.R. § 274a.12(c)(14) .......................................... 17
`
`8 U.S.C. § 1324a(h)(3) .............................................. 17
`
`Violence Against Women Act, Pub. L. No. 106-
`386, 114 Stat. 1491 (2000) .................................. 14
`
`EXECUTIVE AND CONGRESSIONAL
`MATERIALS
`
`Hearing Before the S. Comm. on the Judiciary,
`114th Cong. 2 (2015) (statement of Tom
`Manger, Chief, Montgomery Cty., Md.,
`Police Dep’t & President, Major Cities
`Chiefs Ass’n),
`https://perma.cc/SKM2-QKV9 ........................ 5, 19
`
`Office of Cmty. Oriented Policing Servs., U.S.
`Dep’t of Justice, Enhancing Community
`Policing with
`Immigrant Populations:
`Recommendations
`from a Roundtable
`Meeting of Immigrant Advocates and Law
`Enforcement
`Leaders
`(2010),
`https://perma.cc/62JX-99KK .............................. 18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`iii
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Soc. Sec. Admin., SSA Publ’n No. 05-10096,
`Social Security Numbers for Noncitizens
`(2017), https://perma.cc/9RGJ-X8Y2 .................. 17
`
`U.S. Citizenship & Immigration Servs., U.S.
`Dep’t of Homeland Sec., OMB No. 1615-
`0040, Instructions for I-765 Application for
`Employment Authorization (last updated
`May 31, 2018),
`https://perma.cc/JW66-XQCG ............................ 17
`
`Victims of Criminal Activity: U Nonimmigrant
`Status, U.S. Citizenship & Immigr. Servs.
`(last
`updated
`June
`12,
`2018),
`https://perma.cc/P3AC-XTHG ............................ 14
`
`OTHER AUTHORITIES
`
`Angelica S. Reina et al., “He Said They’d Deport
`Me”: Factors Influencing Domestic Violence
`Help-Seeking Practices Among Latina
`Immigrants,
`29 J. Interpersonal Violence 593, (2014) ........... 21
`
`Anita Khashu, The Role of Local Police:
`Striking a Balance Between Immigration
`Enforcement and Civil Liberties, Police
`Found. (2009),
`https://perma.cc/KL5A-EQWR ................... 5, 8, 20
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`iv
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Bret Hauff, ICE Targets Immigrants at La
`Plata County Courthouse, Durango Herald
`(Mar. 23, 2019),
`https://perma.cc/8RFS-3YMW ............................ 10
`
`Cora Engelbrecht, Fewer Immigrants Are
`Reporting Domestic Abuse. Police Blame
`Fear of Deportation., N.Y. Times (June 3,
`2018), https://perma.cc/Q4HN-N5BX ................... 9
`
`Elizabeth Fussell, The Deportation Threat
`Dynamic and Victimization of Latino
`Migrants: Wage Theft and Robbery,
`52 Soc. Q. 593 (2011) .............................. 19, 20, 22
`
`Emma Whitford, Courthouse ICE Arrests Are
`Making
`Immigrants
`‘Sitting Ducks,’
`Lawyers Warn, Gothamist (June 22, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/XJT4-YQ4D.............................. 12
`
`Immigration
`et al.,
`Hannah Rappleye
`Crackdown Makes Women Afraid to Testify
`Against Abusers, Experts Warn, NBC News
`(Sept. 22, 2018),
`https://perma.cc/UB6S-RTE7 ................. 10, 12, 13
`
`Hans Johnson & Sergio Sanchez, Immigrants
`in California, Public Policy Institute of
`California (2019),
`https://perma.cc/W5RL-7ZZA ............................... 2
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`v
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Jacob Bucher et al., Undocumented Victims: An
`Examination
`of
`Crimes
`Against
`Undocumented Male Migrant Workers,
`7 Sw. J. Crim. Just. 159 (2010) .......................... 19
`
`James Fanelli, Father of Two Who Testified in
`Brooklyn Homicide Cases and Is Married to
`a U.S. Citizen Detained by ICE, N.Y. Daily
`News
`(Aug.
`2,
`2017),
`https://perma.cc/SBH8-BUGH ........................... 11
`
`James Queally, Fearing Deportation, Many
`Domestic Violence Victims Are Steering
`Clear of Police and Courts, L.A. Times (Oct.
`9, 2017), https://perma.cc/QR2S-FKX7 ................ 9
`
`Jessica Lipscomb, Miami Crime Victim
`Detained by ICE Warns Others About
`Calling Police for Help, Miami New Times
`(Apr. 23, 2019),
`https://perma.cc/9GG5-BKQQ ............................ 11
`
`et al., Latinas’
`Jill Theresa Messing
`Perceptions of Law Enforcement: Fear of
`Deportation, Crime Reporting, and Trust in
`the System,
`30 J. Women & Soc. Work 328 (2015) ............ 8, 20
`
`Katie Mettler, ‘This Is Really Unprecedented’:
`ICE Detains Woman Seeking Domestic
`Abuse Protection at Texas Courthouse,
`Wash.
`Post
`(Feb.
`16,
`2017),
`https://perma.cc/33UE-WC85 ............................. 10
`
`
`
`

`

`vi
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Leslye Orloff et al., Nat’l Immigrant Women’s
`Advocacy Project, U-Visa Victims and
`Lawful Permanent Residency
`(2012),
`https://perma.cc/53NZ-LCPF .............................. 15
`
`Letter from Mary E. Fairhurst, Chief Justice of
`the Supreme Court of Washington, to John
`F. Kelly, Sec’y of Dep’t of Homeland Sec.
`(Mar. 22, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/6358-7Z3H ............................... 13
`
`Letter from Seventy-Five Former State and
`Federal Judges to Ronald D. Vitiello, Acting
`Director
`of
`ICE
`(Dec.
`12,
`2018),
`https://perma.cc/LJE2-94P7 ............................... 13
`
`Letter from Stuart Rabner, Chief Justice of the
`Supreme Court of New Jersey, to John F.
`Kelly, Sec’y of Dep’t of Homeland Sec. (Apr.
`19, 2017), https://perma.cc/M2QA-FJYD ........... 13
`
`Letter from Tani G. Cantil-Sakauye, Chief
`Justice of California, to Jeff Sessions, Att’y
`Gen. of the U.S., and John F. Kelly, Sec’y of
`Dep’t of Homeland Sec. (Mar. 16, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/9C8T-QVET ............................. 12
`
`Maria Cramer, ICE Courthouse Arrests Worry
`Attorneys, Prosecutors, Boston Globe (June
`16, 2017), https://perma.cc/VZZ9-J7WE ............ 13
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`vii
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Mark Hugo Lopez et al., More Latinos Have
`Serious Concerns About Their Place in
`America Under Trump, Pew Res. Ctr.:
`Hispanic Trends
`(Oct.
`25,
`2018),
`https://perma.cc/R3TE-DMAD ............................. 6
`
`Matthew Haag, Texas Deputy Accused of
`Molesting 4-Year-Old and Threatening to
`Deport Her Mother, N.Y. Times (June 18,
`2018), https://perma.cc/682K-2ZR3 .................... 19
`
`Michael Corkery & Jessica Silver-Greenberg,
`Banks Reject New York City IDs, Leaving
`‘Unbanked’ on Sidelines, N.Y. Times (Dec.
`23, 2015), https://perma.cc/A5B7-X32D ............. 16
`
`Michael Morris & Lauren Renee Sepulveda, A
`New ICE Age, Texas Dist. & Cty. Attorneys
`Ass’n, The Texas Prosecutor, Vol. 47, No. 4
`(July/Aug. 2017),
`https://perma.cc/J2QH-AWV7 .............................. 9
`
`Min Xie & Eric P. Baumer, Neighborhood
`Immigrant Concentration and Violent
`Crime Reporting to the Police: A Multilevel
`Analysis of Data from the National Crime
`Victimization Survey, 57 Criminology 237
`(2019), https://perma.cc/QS5R-K867 .................... 7
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`viii
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Nat’l Immigrant Women’s Advocacy Project,
`Promoting Access to Justice for Immigrant
`and Limited English Proficient Crime
`Victims in an Age of Increased Immigration
`Enforcement: Initial Report from a 2017
`National
`Survey
`(2018),
`https://perma.cc/52MV-X8TG ..................... 8, 9, 21
`
`Natalia Lee et al., Nat’l Immigrant Women’s
`Advocacy Project, National Survey of
`Service Providers on Police Response to
`Immigrant Crime Victims, U Visa
`Certification and Language Access (2013),
`https://perma.cc/5SR9-VTWA ............................. 16
`
`Nawal H. Ammar et al., Calls to Police and
`Police Response: A Case Study of Latina
`Immigrant Women in the USA,
`7 Int’l J. Police Sci. & Mgmt. 230 (2005) ........... 21
`
`Nik Theodore, Insecure Communities: Latino
`Perceptions of Police
`Involvement
`in
`Immigration
`Enforcement
`(2013),
`https://perma.cc/XEE8-P42V ................................ 7
`
`Philip Jankowski, Deportation Fears Keep
`Victim
`from Cooperating
`in Domestic
`Violence Case, Travis DA Says, Statesman
`(Austin)
`(Mar.
`8,
`2017),
`https://perma.cc/9AYX-5FQP ............................. 11
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`ix
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Police Exec. Research Forum, Voices from
`Across the Country: Local Law Enforcement
`Officials Discuss
`the Challenges
`of
`Immigration
`Enforcement
`(2012),
`https://perma.cc/QKN8-QFJK ...................... 16, 17
`
`Roberto G. Gonzales & Angie M. Bautista-
`Chavez, Am. Immigration Council, Two
`Years and Counting: Assessing the Growing
`Power
`of DACA
`(June 16, 2014),
`https://perma.cc/6UBE-Z9AK ............................. 14
`
`Roberto G. Gonzales, Here’s How DACA
`Changed the Lives of Young Immigrants,
`According to Research, Vox Media (Feb. 16,
`2018), https://perma.cc/PB6B-9S9L ................... 14
`
`S. Poverty Law Ctr., Under Siege: Life for Low-
`Income Latinos
`in
`the South
`(2009),
`https://perma.cc/7GCY-V25L .................. 19, 20, 22
`
`S.P. Sullivan, Advocates Say ICE Courthouse
`Arrests in N.J. Are Hurting Immigrant
`Crime Victims, NJ
`(June 5, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/8VQW-TYD7 ............................ 12
`
`Sarah Stillman, When Deportation Is a Death
`Sentence, New Yorker (Jan. 15, 2018),
`https://perma.cc/TK4U-FKMY ........................... 12
`
`Steve Coll, When a Day in Court Is a Trap for
`Immigrants, New Yorker (Nov. 8, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/VMT5-75M5 ............................. 11
`
`
`
`

`

`x
`
`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
`
`Page(s)
`
`Tom K. Wong, Sanctuary Cities Don’t ‘Breed
`Crime.’ They Encourage People to Report
`Crime., Wash. Post
`(Apr. 24, 2018),
`https://perma.cc/EDW3-9SEQ .............................. 7
`
`Zenén Jaimes Pérez, United We Dream, A
`Portrait of Deferred Action for Childhood
`Arrivals Recipients: Challenges
`and
`Opportunities Three-Years Later (2015),
`https://perma.cc/AGE7-X5UH ...................... 14, 18
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`1
`
`INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE1
`
`Amici are current and former prosecutors and law
`enforcement leaders who have extensive expertise in
`law enforcement, prosecution, and cooperative fed-
`eral-state law enforcement activities. They are inti-
`mately familiar with the challenges of performing
`critical law enforcement and governance functions in
`communities where immigrants fear the police and
`are vulnerable to exploitation and crime. Amici rep-
`resent jurisdictions from across the country that un-
`derstand the challenges of protecting local community
`needs and public safety.
`
` Amici’s experience in keeping their communities
`safe has underscored the critical importance of bring-
`ing immigrants and their families “out of the shad-
`ows.” Community trust and cooperation are essential
`to public safety, and sound police work as well as suc-
`cessful prosecutorial efforts are undermined when un-
`documented immigrants and their communities fear
`interacting with law enforcement and the justice sys-
`tem. This dynamic leaves undocumented immigrants
`more vulnerable to crime and exploitation—and un-
`documented immigrant victims less likely to come for-
`ward or cooperate with investigations and prosecu-
`tions—leading to more violence in the communities
`
`
`1 Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.6, counsel for amici cer-
`tifies that no counsel for a party authored this brief in whole or
`in part and that no person or entity, other than amici and their
`counsel, made a monetary contribution intended to fund this
`brief’s preparation or submission. Counsel of record for all par-
`ties received timely notice of the filing of this brief and consented
`to its filing.
`
`
`
`

`

`2
`
`amici are and have been charged with protecting. In
`the State of California, where more than a quarter of
`the population are immigrants,2 these problems have
`a particularly profound impact.
`
`The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals
`(“DACA”) program has protected from removal nearly
`800,000 individuals brought to this country as chil-
`dren. Under DACA, these individuals—who have un-
`dergone background checks and lived continuously in
`the United States since 2007—have been permitted to
`live, work, and study in this country without fear of
`removal. Amici are aware that the DACA program
`has helped law enforcement officers and prosecutors
`keep their communities safe by reducing the fear of
`removal for these nearly 800,000 individuals who are
`active members of their communities.
`
`
`
`
`
`2 Hans Johnson & Sergio Sanchez, Immigrants in California,
`Public
`Policy
`Institute
`of California,
`1
`(2019),
`https://perma.cc/W5RL-7ZZA (in 2017, immigrants constituted
`27 percent of California’s population).
`
`
`
`

`

`3
`
`SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
`
`The lessons amici have learned in protecting their
`communities shed important light on the issues
`raised in this case. When community residents live
`in constant fear that interactions with local law en-
`forcement officials could result in removal, that fun-
`damental breakdown in trust threatens public safety
`and impedes justice system leaders from doing their
`jobs. Extensive evidence shows that, in such circum-
`stances, undocumented immigrants—and their law-
`fully present family and neighbors—fear that turning
`to the police and cooperating with prosecutors could
`bring adverse immigration consequences. As a result,
`immigrant communities are less willing to report
`crimes and cooperate with criminal investigations
`and prosecutions. This dynamic poses a major chal-
`lenge to the investigation and prosecution of individ-
`ual crimes and to the proper allocation of public safety
`resources.
`
`DACA ameliorates these problems by addressing
`an important reason that many individuals fear coop-
`erating with law enforcement. As experience with
`DACA has shown, when immigrants are permitted to
`step out of the shadows, they are much more willing
`to work cooperatively with police and prosecutors. As
`explained below, nearly two-thirds of DACA recipi-
`ents reported being less afraid of law enforcement,
`and 59 percent indicated that they were more likely
`to report crimes after having entered the program.
`DACA further aids law enforcement by facilitating ac-
`cess to identification, such as federal employment au-
`thorization documents. Lack of identification in im-
`migrant communities often leads to undue burdens on
`
`
`
`

`

`4
`
`police, potentially turning a simple traffic stop into an
`hours-long detour to fingerprint someone at the police
`station. When police are able to identify victims, wit-
`nesses, and potential suspects without those sorts of
`delays, valuable law enforcement resources are
`spared. Knowing the identity of individuals with
`whom law enforcement officers come into contact aids
`in the safety of law enforcement officers as well.
`
`DACA also promotes public safety by helping law
`enforcement to protect a population uniquely vulner-
`able to exploitation and violent crime. Numerous
`studies have shown that undocumented individuals’
`fear of interacting with law enforcement makes them
`attractive targets for many forms of crime and abuse.
`With limited access to bank accounts (in substantial
`part because of their lack of identification), they have
`been dubbed “walking ATMs” and are frequent tar-
`gets for robbery. Undocumented individuals are also
`especially vulnerable to domestic abuse because they
`often fear turning to law enforcement for help. And
`they face increased wage theft and other forms of ex-
`ploitation in the workplace.
`
`By eliminating an important reason to fear law en-
`forcement, enabling access to work authorization and
`to identification, and building trust between law en-
`forcement and immigrants with longstanding ties to
`the United States, DACA aids community policing
`and makes recipients less vulnerable to crime and ex-
`ploitation. In doing so, DACA provides vital support
`to police and prosecutors charged with protecting all
`members of their communities.
`
`
`
`

`

`5
`
`ARGUMENT
`
`I. DACA FOSTERS EFFECTIVE LAW ENFORCEMENT
`
`A. “Community Policing” Is Essential To Ef-
`fective Law Enforcement
`
`The experience of policing cities across the country
`has taught law enforcement officers that doing their
`jobs well requires “the trust and respect of the com-
`munities [they] serve.” Hearing Before the S. Comm.
`on the Judiciary, 114th Cong. 2 (2015) (statement of
`Tom Manger, Chief, Montgomery Cty., Md., Police
`Dep’t & President, Major Cities Chiefs Ass’n),
`https://perma.cc/SKM2-QKV9 [hereinafter Statement
`of Tom Manger]. To combat crime, police officers
`“need the full cooperation of victims and witnesses.”
`Id. This common-sense philosophy is sometimes
`called “community policing”—an approach to policing
`whereby local law enforcement organizations partner
`with communities to reduce crime and promote public
`safety. See Anita Khashu, The Role of Local Police:
`Striking a Balance Between Immigration Enforce-
`ment and Civil Liberties, Police Found. (2009),
`https://perma.cc/KL5A-EQWR.
`
`Community policing requires police to interact
`with neighborhood residents in a manner that builds
`trust and encourages cooperation. Id. at xiii. When
`that trust is missing—as it is when people believe
`that contacting police or cooperating with prosecutors
`could lead to removal for themselves or others—com-
`munity policing breaks down and the entire commu-
`nity suffers.
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`6
`
`B. Trust And Respect Between Communities
`And Law Enforcement Officials Are
`Thwarted When Individuals Fear Re-
`moval Consequences Of Cooperation
`
` The reality of everyday life for millions of undoc-
`umented immigrants living in the United States
`poses significant challenges to effective community
`policing. According to a recent Pew survey, 66 percent
`of Hispanic immigrants and 43 percent of all Hispanic
`adults in the United States worry about removal—of
`themselves, family members, or close friends. Mark
`Hugo Lopez et al., More Latinos Have Serious Con-
`cerns About Their Place in America Under Trump,
`Pew Res. Ctr.: Hispanic Trends (Oct. 25, 2018),
`https://perma.cc/R3TE-DMAD. This fear predictably
`hinders cooperation and communication with police
`and prosecutors. Immigrants often assume that in-
`teraction with law enforcement officials could have
`adverse consequences for themselves or a loved one.
`
`As a result, immigrant communities—and undoc-
`umented immigrants in particular—are less likely to
`trust and cooperate with local police and prosecutors.
`One recent study found that individuals living in com-
`munities of recent immigrants are less likely to report
`violent crime: in neighborhoods where 65 percent of
`residents are immigrants, there is only a 5-percent
`chance that a victim will report a violent crime, com-
`pared with a 48-percent chance in a neighborhood
`where only 10 percent of residents are born outside
`the United States. Min Xie & Eric P. Baumer, Neigh-
`borhood Immigrant Concentration and Violent Crime
`Reporting to the Police: A Multilevel Analysis of Data
`from the National Crime Victimization Survey, 57
`
`
`
`

`

`7
`
`Criminology 237, 249 (2019), https://perma.cc/QS5R-
`K867. The authors of the study specifically noted that
`“the development of trusting relationships between
`citizens and the police is often challenged by the pres-
`ence and application of local and federal immigration
`enforcement programs . . . that may dissuade resi-
`dents from calling on the police to help address crime
`problems.” Id. at 254.
`
`In addition, one survey of Latinos in four major cit-
`ies found that 70 percent of undocumented immi-
`grants and 44 percent of all Latinos would be less
`likely to contact law enforcement authorities if they
`were victims of a crime for fear that the police would
`ask them or people they know about their immigra-
`tion status; and 67 percent of undocumented immi-
`grants and 45 percent of all Latinos would be less
`likely to provide information about, or report, crimes
`because of the same fear. Nik Theodore, Insecure
`Communities: Latino Perceptions of Police Involve-
`ment
`in Immigration Enforcement 5-6
`(2013),
`https://perma.cc/XEE8-P42V; see also id. at 1 (“Sur-
`vey results indicate that increased involvement of po-
`lice in immigration enforcement has significantly
`heightened the fears many Latinos have of the police,
`. . . exacerbating their mistrust of law enforcement
`authorities.”). And a recent survey of undocumented
`individuals in San Diego County found that if local
`law enforcement officials were working together with
`ICE, 60 percent of survey respondents would be less
`likely to report a crime they witnessed, while 43 per-
`cent would be less likely to report being a victim of a
`crime. Tom K. Wong, Sanctuary Cities Don’t ‘Breed
`Crime.’ They Encourage People to Report Crime.,
`Wash. Post (Apr. 24, 2018), https://perma.cc/EDW3-
`
`
`
`

`

`8
`
`9SEQ. These studies (among others) highlight that
`fears of immigration enforcement result in damage to
`law enforcement cooperation from not only undocu-
`mented community members, but also individuals
`with citizenship or lawful status, particularly in
`“mixed-status” households.3
`
`This problematic atmosphere of mistrust poses a
`fundamental challenge for community policing. Po-
`lice cannot prevent or solve crimes if victims or wit-
`nesses are unwilling to talk to them or prosecutors be-
`cause of concerns that they, their loved ones, or their
`neighbors will face adverse immigration conse-
`quences. Law enforcement officers participating in
`one recent national survey reported seeing an across-
`the-board decline in immigrant communities’ willing-
`ness to cooperate with law enforcement. Nat’l Immi-
`grant Women’s Advocacy Project, Promoting Access to
`Justice for Immigrant and Limited English Proficient
`Crime Victims in an Age of Increased Immigration
`Enforcement: Initial Report from a 2017 National
`Survey 101
`(2018), https://perma.cc/52MV-X8TG
`[hereinafter NIWAP Report]. Roughly one-fifth of po-
`lice officers surveyed reported that, in 2017, immi-
`grants were less willing than they were in 2016 to
`make police reports, less likely to help police when
`
`
`
`3 An estimated 85 percent of immigrants live in mixed-status
`families. See Khashu, supra, at 24; see also Jill Theresa Messing
`et al., Latinas’ Perceptions of Law Enforcement: Fear of Deporta-
`tion, Crime Reporting, and Trust in the System, 30 J. Women &
`Soc. Work 328, 334 (2015) (“The results indicate that for each 1-
`point increase in fear of deportation [e.g., from ‘not much’ to
`‘some’ worry, or from ‘some’ to ‘a lot’], Latina participants were
`[15 percent] less willing to report being [a] victim of a violent
`crime to police.”).
`
`
`
`

`

`9
`
`they arrived at the scene of the crime, less likely to
`assist with subsequent investigations, and less will-
`ing to work with prosecutors. Id. at 42. As a result,
`more than half of the law enforcement officials sur-
`veyed reported that crimes such as domestic violence,
`human trafficking, and sexual assault became more
`difficult to investigate. Id. at 51.
`
`These trends have continued to worsen in recent
`years. See Cora Engelbrecht, Fewer Immigrants Are
`Reporting Domestic Abuse. Police Blame Fear of De-
`portation., N.Y.
`Times
`(June
`3,
`2018),
`https://perma.cc/Q4HN-N5BX. According to the Hou-
`ston Police Department, rape reporting by members
`of the Hispanic community fell over 40 percent from
`the first quarter of 2016 to the same period in 2017,
`despite an overall increase in city-wide crime reports.
`Michael Morris & Lauren Renee Sepulveda, A New
`ICE Age, Texas Dist. & Cty. Attorneys Ass’n, The
`Texas Prosecutor, Vol. 47, No. 4 (July/Aug. 2017),
`https://perma.cc/J2QH-AWV7. Los Angeles, San
`Francisco, and San Diego also witnessed lagging sex-
`ual assault and domestic violence reporting by Latino
`persons—but not other ethnic groups—in the first
`half of 2017. James Queally, Fearing Deportation,
`Many Domestic Violence Victims Are Steering Clear of
`Police and Courts, L.A. Times (Oct. 9, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/QR2S-FKX7. According to Los Ange-
`les County Sheriff’s Deputy Marino Gonzalez,
`“[t]hey’re afraid of us. And the reason they’re afraid
`of us is because they think we’re going to deport
`them.” Id.; see also NIWAP Report, supra, at 99 (find-
`ing that, in 2016 and 2017, fear of removal was the
`principal reason that immigrant victims did not call
`the police for help or file or follow through with a court
`
`
`
`

`

`10
`
`case). Law enforcement officials across the country
`have echoed that sentiment. See, e.g., Hannah Rap-
`pleye et al., Immigration Crackdown Makes Women
`Afraid to Testify Against Abusers, Experts Warn, NBC
`News (Sept. 22, 2018), https://perma.cc/UB6S-RTE7
`(“‘We rely very heavily at the local level on coopera-
`tion from our witnesses and from our victims to en-
`sure that cases can be prosecuted,’ said Denver City
`Attorney Kristin Bronson. ‘What we’ve found in Den-
`ver is people are not showing up because they’re
`afraid that they might get apprehended in the hall-
`ways.’”); see also City of Philadelphia v. Sessions, 309
`F. Supp. 3d 289, 341 (E.D. Pa. 2018) (“[Philadelphia]
`Police Commissioner Ross reiterated his earlier testi-
`mony that the City’s ability to fight crime is impaired
`when victims and witnesses are afraid to report
`crimes for fear of immigration consequences.”); Bret
`Hauff, ICE Targets Immigrants at La Plata County
`Courthouse, Durango Herald
`(Mar. 23, 2019),
`https://perma.cc/8RFS-3YMW (explaining that the
`tactic of courthouse arrests “deters people from mak-
`ing reports; it deters people from coming in” (quoting
`Colorado 6th Judicial District Chief Judge Jeffery
`Wilson)).
`
`Immigrants’ fear of interacting with law enforce-
`ment and prosecutors in light of potential removal
`consequences is not merely theoretical. In February
`2017, for example, an immigrant woman living in
`Texas arrived at a courthouse seeking a protective or-
`der against her abusive boyfriend, only to leave under
`arrest—likely due to a tip from her abuser. Katie
`Mettler, ‘This Is Really Unprecedented’: ICE Detains
`Woman Seeking Domestic Abuse Protection at Texas
`Courthouse, Wash. Post
`(Feb.
`16,
`2017),
`
`
`
`

`

`11
`
`https://perma.cc/33UE-WC85. In August 2017, fed-
`eral agents detained an undocumented immigrant
`who had provided key testimony in two homicide
`cases. James Fanelli, Father of Two Who Testified in
`Brooklyn Homicide Cases and Is Married to a U.S.
`Citizen Detained by ICE, N.Y. Daily News (Aug. 2,
`2017), https://perma.cc/SBH8-BUGH. Weeks later,
`ICE agents arrested a victim of domestic violence as
`he left a county courthouse. Steve Coll, When a Day
`in Court Is a Trap for Immigrants, New Yorker (Nov.
`8, 2017), https://perma.cc/VMT5-75M5. And in Feb-
`ruary 2019, ICE detained a 38-year-old mother of
`three who was cooperating with police in an open in-
`vestigation—and almost removed her to her native
`Nicaragua. Asked upon her release if she would think
`twice before interacting with law enforcement in the
`future, she answered without hesitation: “Sí.” Jessica
`Lipscomb, Miami Crime Victim Detained by ICE
`Warns Others About Calling Police for Help, Miami
`New Times (Apr. 23, 2019), https://perma.cc/9GG5-
`BKQQ.
`
` The underreporting of crimes by recent immi-
`grants is a problem for the entire criminal justice sys-
`tem. Precisely because victims and witnesses fear re-
`moval, violent crimes have gone unreported, and
`pending prosecutions have disappeared from courts’
`dockets. For example, a Texas district attorney con-
`firmed that a victim of domestic violence had become
`uncooperative because she feared removal. Philip
`Jankowski, Deportation Fears Keep Victim from Co-
`operating in Domestic Violence Case, Travis DA Says,
`Statesman
`(Austin)
`(Mar.
`8,
`2017),
`https://perma.cc/9AYX-5FQP. Denver prosecutors
`have been forced to drop 30 domestic violence cases
`
`
`
`

`

`12
`
`for similar reasons, Rappleye et al., supra, and in
`2017, more than a dozen Latina women in Denver
`dropped their own civil cases against domestic abus-
`ers, citing fear of removal. Sarah Stillman, When De-
`portation Is a Death Sentence, New Yorker (Jan. 15,
`2018), https://perma.cc/TK4U-FKMY. An immigrant
`mother in New Jersey, fearing that interaction with
`the court system could trigger removal, declined to re-
`port that her son had been assaulted on his way to
`school. S.P. Sullivan, Advocates Say ICE Courthouse
`Arrests in N.J. Are Hurting Immigrant Crime Vic-
`tims, NJ (June 5, 2017), https://perma.cc/8VQW-
`TYD7. And a victim of domestic violence in New York
`City “did not think it was in her best interest” to pur-
`sue a protective order. Emma Whitford, Courthouse
`ICE Arrests Are Making Immigrants ‘Sitting Ducks,’
`Lawyers Warn, Gothamist
`(June 22, 2017),
`https://perma.cc/XJT4-YQ4D. In addition to their
`particular removal concerns, undocumented immi-
`grant victims and witnesses may understandably re-
`coil more generally from a system that allows partici-
`pants to walk into a courthouse to fulfill a civic re-
`sponsibility to testify, only to be detained by immigra-
`tion authorities and prevented from walking freely
`out of that same courthouse.
`
`In response to these types of incidents, the chief
`justices of three state supreme courts—including the
`Supreme Court of California—wrote to federal au-
`thorities to emphasize that preserving trust with im-
`migrant communities is essential to the administra-
`tion of justice. Letter from Tani G. Cantil-Sakauye,
`Chief Justice of California, to Jeff Sessions, Att’y Gen.
`of the U.S., and John F. Kelly, Sec’y of Dep’t of Home-
`land Sec. (Mar. 16, 2017), https://perma.cc/9C8T-
`
`
`
`

`

`13
`
`QVET; Letter from Mary E.

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket