throbber
Nos. 18-587, 18-588, and 18-589
`In the Supreme Court of the United States
`
`
`
`DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY, ET AL.,
`PETITIONERS
`v.
`
`REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, ET AL.
`
`
`ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI
`TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
`FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
`
`
`JOINT APPENDIX
`(VOLUME 1)
`
`
`NOEL J. FRANCISCO
`Solicitor General
`Department of Justice
`Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
`SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov
`(202) 514-2217
`
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Petitioners
`
` ROBERT ALLEN LONG, JR.
`Covington & Burling, LLP
`One CityCenter
`850 Tenth St., N.W.
`Washington, D.C. 20001
`rlong@cov.com
`(202) 662-5612
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`Regents of the University
` of California and
` Janet Napolitano
`
`(No. 18-587)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`PETITIONS FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED: NOV. 5, 2018
`CERTIORARI GRANTED: JUNE 28, 2019
`Additional Captions and Counsel Listed on Inside Cover
`
`

`

`
`
`
`DONALD J. TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES,
`ET AL., PETITIONERS
`v.
`NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF
`COLORED PEOPLE, ET AL.
`
`ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI BEFORE JUDGMENT
`TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
`FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
`
`KEVIN K. MCALEENAN, ACTING SECRETARY OF
`HOMELAND SECURITY, ET AL., PETITIONERS
`v.
`MARTIN JONATHAN BATALLA VIDAL, ET AL.
`
`ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI BEFORE JUDGMENT
`TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
`FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
`
`Additional Counsel For Respondents
`
`THEODORE J. BOUTROUS, JR.
`Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher
` LLP
`333 South Grand Ave.
`Los Angeles, CA. 90071
`tboutrous@gibsondunn.com
`(213) 229-7804
`
`Counsel of Record
`
`for Respondents
` Dulce Garcia, Miriam
` Gonzalez Avila, Saul
` Jimenez Suarez, Viridiana
` Chabolla Mendoza, Norma
` Ramirez, and Jirayut
` Latthivongskorn
` (No. 18-587)
`
` MICHAEL JAMES MONGAN
`Solicitor General
`California Department of
` Justice
`455 Golden Gate Ave., Suite 11000
`San Francisco, CA. 94102
`michael.mongan@doj.ca.gov
`(415) 510-3920
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`States of California, Maine,
` Maryland, and Minnesota
`
`(No. 18-587)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`
`STACEY M. LEYTON
`Altshuler Berzon, LLP
`177 Post St., Suite 300
`San Francisco, CA. 94108
`sleyton@altshulerberzon.com
`(415) 421-7151
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`County of Santa Clara and
` Service Employees
` International Union
` Local 521 (No. 18-587)
`
`
`LINDSAY C. HARRISON
`Jenner & Block, LLP
`1099 New York Ave., N.W.
`Suite 900
`Washington, D.C. 20001
`lharrison@jenner.com
`(202) 639-6000
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`Princeton University,
` Microsoft Corporation, and
` Maria De La Cruz Perales
` Sanchez (No. 18-588)
`
`MICHAEL J. WISHNIE
`William O. Douglas Clinical
` Professor of Law and
` Counselor to the Dean
`Yale Law School
`127 Wall Street
`New Haven, CT. 06511
`michael.wishnie@yale.edu
`(203) 436-4780
`
`JAMES R. WILLIAMS
`Office of the County Counsel
`County of Santa Clara
`70 West Hedding St.
`East Wing, Ninth Floor
`San Jose, CA. 95110
`(408) 299-5900
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`County of Santa Clara
`(No. 18-587)
`
`
`
`
`JOSEPH M. SELLERS
`Cohen Milsten Sellers & Toll
` PLLC
`1100 New York Ave., N.W.
`Fif th Floor
`Washington, D.C. 20005
`jsellers@cohenmilstein.com
`(202) 408-4600
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`NAACP, American Federation
` of Teachers, and United Food
` and Commercial Workers
` International Union
` (No. 18-588)
`
`
`BARBARA DALE UNDERWOOD
`Solicitor General
`New York Attorney General’s
` Office
`28 Liberty St.
`New York, N.Y. 10005
`barbara.underwood@ag.ny.gov
`(212) 416-8016
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
`Martin Jonathan Batalla
` Vidal, et al. (No. 18-589)
`
`
`
`Counsel of Record
`for Respondents
` State of New York, et al.
`(No. 18-589)
`
`
`
`

`

`TABLE OF CONTENTS
`
`Page
`
`Volume 1
`Relevant docket entries (18-587):
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15068) .................... 1
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15069) .................. 28
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15070) .................. 55
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15071) .................. 82
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15072) ................ 108
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15128) ................ 136
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15133) ................ 162
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-15134) ................ 188
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05211) ................ 214
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05235) ................ 222
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05329) ................ 225
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05380) ................ 229
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05813) ................ 233
`Relevant docket entries (18-588):
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-5243) .................. 237
`District court docket entries (17-cv-01907) ................ 241
`District court docket entries (17-cv-02325) ............... 246
`Relevant docket entries (18-589):
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-122) .................... 258
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-123) .................... 262
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-485) .................... 267
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-488) .................... 292
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1313) .................. 314
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1314) .................. 317
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1521) .................. 320
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1525) .................. 327
`
`(I)
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`II
`
`Page
`Table of Contents—Continued:
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1985) .................. 333
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1986) .................. 338
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1987) .................. 343
`Court of appeals docket entries (18-1988) .................. 349
`District court docket entries (16-cv-04756) ................ 354
`District court docket entries (17-cv-05228) ................ 365
`
`Volume 2
`Relevant pleadings (18-587):
`Complaint (17-cv-05813) (Oct. 10, 2017) ...................... 376
`Complaint (17-cv-05380) (Sept. 18, 2017) .................... 416
`Complaint (17-cv-05329) (Sept. 14, 2017) .................... 480
`Complaint (17-cv-05235) (Sept. 11, 2017) .................... 504
`Complaint (17-cv-05211) (Sept. 8, 2017) ...................... 555
`Relevant pleadings (18-588):
`Complaint (17-cv-02325) (Nov. 3, 2017) ....................... 580
`Amended complaint (17-cv-01907)
` (Oct. 23, 2017) .......................................................... 630
`Relevant pleadings (18-589):
`Third amended complaint (16-cv-04756)
` (Dec. 11, 2017) ......................................................... 652
`Amended complaint (17-cv-05228)
` (Oct. 4, 2017) ............................................................ 706
`
`
`Excerpts from administrative record:
`Office of Legal Counsel, Memorandum on
`The Department of Homeland Security’s
`Authority to Prioritize Removal of Certain
`Aliens Unlawfully Present in the United
`States and to Defer Removal of Others
`(Nov. 19, 2014) .......................................................... 797
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`III
`
`Page
`
`Table of Contents—Continued:
`Memorandum on Enforcement of the
`Immigration Laws to Serve the National
`Interest (Feb. 20, 2017) ........................................... 857
`Memorandum on Rescission of Memorandum
`Providing for Deferred Action for Parents of
`Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents
`(June 15, 2017) ......................................................... 868
`Letter from State Attorneys General to
`Attorney General of the United States
`(June 29, 2017) ......................................................... 872
`Letter from Attorney General to Acting
`Secretary of Homeland Security
`(Sept. 4, 2017) ........................................................... 877
`
`
`Other materials from the record:
`Declaration of Maria De La Cruz Perales
`Sanchez in support of motion for summary
`judgment and motion for preliminary injunc-
`tion (17-cv-02325 D. Ct. Doc. 28-8)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) .......................................................... 879
`Declaration of Eliana Fernandez in support of
`motion for preliminary injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-13)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) .......................................................... 889
`Declaration of Carolina Fung Feng in support of
`motion for preliminary injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-13)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) .......................................................... 894
`Declaration of Martin Batalla Vidal in support of
`motion for preliminary injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-13)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) .......................................................... 902
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`IV
`
`Page
`
`Table of Contents—Continued:
`Declaration of Jirayut Latthivongskorn in
`support of motion for provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 118-1)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 915
`Declaration of Dulce Garcia in support of motion
`for provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 117)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 932
`Declaration of Mitchell Santos Toledo in support
`of motion for provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 119-1)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 953
`Declaration of Joel Sati in support of motion for
`provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 119-1)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 965
`Letter from President to House and Senate lead-
`ers, attached to motion for provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 124)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 981
`U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services,
`Number of Form I-821D, Consideration of
`Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, Fis-
`cal Year 2012-2017, attached to complaint
`(17-cv-05235 D. Ct. Doc. 1-3)
`(Sept. 11, 2017) ......................................................... 996
`Justice News: Attorney General Sessions Deliv-
`ers Remarks on DACA, attached to motion
`for provisional relief
`(17-cv-05211 D. Ct. Doc. 121-2)
`(Nov. 1, 2017) ............................................................ 999
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`V
`
`Page
`
`Table of Contents—Continued:
`Excerpt from deposition of Gene Hamilton, at-
`tached to motion for preliminary injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-9)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) ........................................................ 1005
`Excerpt from defendant’s objections and re-
`sponses to plaintiff s’ first set of requests for
`admission to Acting Secretary of Homeland
`Security, attached to motion for preliminary
`injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-4)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) ........................................................ 1008
`Excerpt from defendant’s objections and re-
`sponses to plaintiffs’ first set of requests for
`admission to Attorney General, attached to
`motion for preliminary injunction
`(16-cv-04756 D. Ct. Doc. 123-4)
`(Dec. 15, 2017) ........................................................ 1012
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
`FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
`
`
`
`Docket No. 18-15068
`REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF OF CALIFORNIA;
`JANET NAPOLITANO, IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS
`PRESIDENT OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,
`PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES
`v.
`U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY;
`KIRSTJEN NIELSEN, IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS
`ACTING SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
`HOMELAND SECURITY, DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS
`
`
`DOCKET ENTRIES
`
`DATE
`1/16/18
`
`1/17/18
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`DOCKETED CAUSE AND EN-
`1
`TERED APPEARANCES OF
`COUNSEL. SEND MQ: Yes.
`The schedule is set as follows:
`To be set. Preliminary Injunc-
`tion, C. R. 3-3 [10725634] (JBS)
`[Entered: 01/16/2018 01:25 PM]
`Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:
`SLL):
` The court sua sponte
`consolidates
`appeal
`Nos.
`18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071, and 18-15072.
` The
`Clerk shall update the dockets
`accordingly.
` Consolidated ap-
`peal Nos. 18-15068, 18-15069,
`
`2
`
`(1)
`
`

`

`2
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`18-15070, 18-15071, and 18-15072,
`filed on January 16, 2018, are
`preliminary
`injunction appeals.
`Accordingly, Ninth Circuit Rule
`3-3 shall apply. The mediation
`questionnaire is due three days
`after the date of this order. If
`they have not already done so,
`within 7 calendar days after the
`filing date of this order, the par-
`ties shall make arrangement3 to
`obtain from the court reporter an
`official transcript of proceedings
`in the district court that will be
`included in the record on appeal.
`The briefing schedule shall pro-
`ceed as follows:
` the consoli-
`dated opening brief(s) and ex-
`cerpts of record are due not later
`than February 13, 2018; the con-
`solidated answering brief(s) is
`due March 13, 2018 or 28 days af-
`ter service of the opening brief,
`whichever is earlier; and the op-
`tional consolidated reply brief(s)
`is due within 21 days after ser-
`vice of the answering brief. See
`9th Cir. R. 3-3(b). All parties on
`a side are encouraged to join in a
`single brief to the greatest ex-
`tent practicable. See 9th Cir. R.
`28-4. The parties are reminded
`that streamlined requests for ex-
`
`DATE
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`3
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`tensions of time are not available
`in preliminary injunction appeals.
`See http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/
`content/view.php?pk_id=0000000
`638. Any request for an exten-
`sion of time must be requested
`under Ninth Circuit Rule
`31-2.2(b). Failure to file timely
`the opening brief shall result in
`the automatic dismissal of this
`appeal by the Clerk for failure to
`prosecute. See 9th Cir. R. 42-1.
`[10726638] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070, 18-15071, 18-15072]
`(OC)
`[Entered:
`
`01/17/2018
`09:06 AM]
`
`1/26/18
`
`21
`
`* * * * *
`Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:
`MCD): The court sua sponte
`expedites appeal Nos. 18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134, and consoli-
`dates them with pending consol-
`idated appeal Nos. 18-15068,
`18-15069, 18-15070, 18-15071, and
`18-15072. The Clerk shall up-
`date
`the docket accordingly.
`The following briefing schedule
`shall apply to the consolidated
`appeals: the consolidated first
`brief on cross-appeal by Defen-
`dants is due February 13, 2018.
`The consolidated second brief on
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`4
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`cross-appeal by Plaintiffs is due
`March 13, 2018. The consoli-
`dated third brief on cross-appeal
`by Defendants is due April 10,
`2018. The consolidated optional
`fourth brief on cross-appeal by
`Plaintiffs is due within 21 days
`after service of the third brief on
`cross-appeal. All parties on a
`side are encouraged to join in a
`single brief to the greatest ex-
`tent practicable. See 9th Cir. R.
`28-4.
` This order
`is without
`prejudice to any party moving
`for appropriate relief following
`resolution of the petition for a
`writ of certiorari in Supreme Court
`Case No. 17-1003.
`[10740072]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134] (AF) [En-
`tered: 01/26/2018 11:43 AM]
`
`2/13/18
`
`31
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) First Brief on
`Cross-Appeal for review. Sub-
`mitted by Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen and USDHS in 18-15068,
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen, USA
`and USDHS in 18-15069, Appel-
`lants Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump and USA in 18-15070, Ap-
`pellants Kirstjen Nielsen, Don-
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`2/13/18
`
`5
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`ald J. Trump, USA and USDHS
`in 18-15071, Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen, Jefferson B. Sessions,
`III, Donald J. Trump and
`USDHS in 18-15072, 18-15128.
`Date of service:
` 02/13/2018.
`[10762501] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`—[COURT UPDATE: Attached
`corrected PDF of brief. 02/15/
`2018 by RY] (Stern, Mark) [En-
`tered: 02/13/2018 01:40 PM]
`Submitted (ECF) excerpts of
`record.
` Submitted by Appel-
`lants Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump, USA and USDHS
`in
`18-15128, Appellees Kirstjen
`Nielsen, Donald J. Trump, USA
`and USDHS
`in
`18-15133,
`18-15134.
` Date of
`service:
`02/13/2018. [10762529] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134]
`(Stern, Mark)
`[En-
`tered: 02/13/2018 01:50 PM]
`
`32
`
`3/13/18
`
`43
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Second Brief
`on Cross-Appeal for review. Sub-
`mitted by Appellees State of Cal-
`ifornia, State of Maine, State of
`Maryland and State of Minnesota
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`6
`
`44
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`in 18-15069, Appellants State of
`California, State of Maine, State
`of Maryland and State of Min-
`nesota
`in 18-15133, 18-15128.
`Date of service:
` 03/13/2018.
`[10797115] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15133,
`18-15128]—[COURT
`UPDATE: Spread docket text
`to 18-15070, 18-15071, 18-15072,
`18-15134. 03/14/2018 by RY]
`(Mongan, Michael)
`[Entered:
`03/13/2018 04:24 PM]
`Submitted (ECF) Second Brief
`on Cross-Appeal
`for review.
`Submitted by Appellees Janet
`Napolitano and Regents of the
`University
`of California
`in
`18-15068, Appellee City of San
`Jose in 18-15070, Appellees Janet
`Napolitano, Regents of the Uni-
`versity of California and City of
`San Jose in 18-15128, Appellants
`Janet Napolitano, Regents of the
`University of California and City
`of San Jose in 18-15133. Date of
`service: 03/13/2018. [10797237]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134] (Davidson,
`Jeffrey) [Entered:
` 03/13/2018
`05:14 PM]
`
`
`DATE
`
`3/13/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`7
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`Submitted (ECF) supplemental
`45
`excerpts of record. Submitted
`by Appellees Janet Napolitano
`and Regents of the University of
`California in 18-15068, Appellee
`State of California in 18-15069,
`Appellee City of San Jose in
`18-15070, Appellees Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Saul Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut
`Latthivongskorn
`and Norma
`Ramirez in 18-15071, Appellees
`County of Santa Clara and Ser-
`vice Employees
`International
`Union Local 521
`in 18-15072,
`Appellees Viridiana Chabolla
`Mendoza, City of San Jose,
`County of Santa Clara, Dulce
`Garcia, Saul Jimenez Suarez,
`Jirayut Latthivongskorn, Janet
`Napolitano, Norma Ramirez,
`Regents of the University of
`California, Service Employees
`International Union Local 521
`and State of California
`in
`18-15128, Appellants Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, City of San
`Jose, Dulce Garcia, Miriam Gon-
`zalez Avila, Saul Jimenez Suarez,
`Jirayut Latthivongskorn, Janet
`Napolitano, Norma Ramirez, Re-
`gents of the University of Cali-
`fornia and State of California in
`
`DATE
`3/13/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`8
`
`46
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`18-15133, Appellants Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, County of
`Santa Clara, Dulce Garcia, Mir-
`iam Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn,
`Norma Ramirez and Service
`Employees International Union
`Local 521 in 18-15134. Date of
`service: 03/13/2018. [10797304]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134] (Davidson,
`Jeffrey) [Entered:
` 03/13/2018
`05:53 PM]
`Submitted (ECF) Second Brief
`on Cross-Appeal
`for review.
`Submitted by Appellees Viridi-
`ana Chabolla Mendoza, Miriam
`Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn,
`Norma Ramirez and Dulce Gar-
`cia in 18-15071, Appellees County
`of Santa Clara and Service Em-
`ployees
`International Union
`Local 521 in 18-15072, Appellees
`Viridiana Chabolla Mendoza,
`County of Santa Clara, Miriam
`Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn,
`Norma Ramirez, Service Em-
`ployees
`International Union
`Local 521 and Dulce Garcia in
`18-15128, Appellants Viridiana
`
`DATE
`
`3/13/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`9
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul
`Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut Latthi-
`vongskorn and Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15133, Appellants Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, County of
`Santa Clara, Dulce Garcia, Mir-
`iam Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn,
`Norma Ramirez and Service Em-
`ployees International Union Lo-
`cal 521 in 18-15134. Date of
`service: 03/13/2018. [10797416]
`[18-15068, 18-15071, 18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`—[COURT UPDATE: Spread
`docket text to 18-15069, 18-15070.
`03/14/2018 by RY] (Boutrous,
`Theodore) [Entered: 03/13/2018
`08:41 PM]
`
`4/3/18
`
`134
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Third Brief on
`Cross-Appeal for review. Sub-
`mitted by Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen and USDHS in 18-15068,
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen,
`USA and USDHS in 18-15069,
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen,
`Donald J. Trump and USA in
`18-15070, Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen, Donald J. Trump, USA
`and USDHS in 18-15071, Appel-
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`10
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`lants Kirstjen Nielsen, Jefferson
`B. Sessions, III, Donald J. Trump
`and USDHS
`in
`18-15072,
`18-15128, Appellees Kirstjen
`Nielsen, Donald J. Trump, USA
`and USDHS
`in
`18-15133,
`18-15134.
` Date of service:
`04/03/2018. [10822811] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134]
`(Stern, Mark)
`[En-
`tered: 04/03/2018 01:55 PM]
`
`4/17/18
`
`139
`
`4/17/18
`
`141
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Cross-Appeal
`Reply Brief for review. Sub-
`mitted by Appellees State of
`California, State of Maine, State
`of Maryland and State of Minne-
`sota in 18-15069, 18-15128, Ap-
`pellants State of California, State
`of Maine, State of Maryland and
`State of Minnesota in 18-15133.
`Date of service:
` 04/17/2018.
`[10839746] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Mongan, Michael)
`[Entered:
`04/17/2018 12:02 PM]
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Cross-Appeal
`Reply Brief for review. Submit-
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`11
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`ted by Appellees Janet Napoli-
`tano and Regents of the Univer-
`sity of California in 18-15068,
`Appellee City of San Jose in
`18-15070, Appellees Janet Napo-
`litano, Regents of the University
`of California and City of San
`Jose in 18-15128. Date of ser-
`vice:
` 04/17/2018.
` [10840021]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134] (Davidson,
`Jeffrey) [Entered:
` 04/17/2018
`01:41 PM]
`
`4/17/18
`
`143
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Cross-Appeal
`Reply Brief for review. Sub-
`mitted by Appellees Dulce Gar-
`cia, Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul
`Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut Latthi-
`vongskorn and Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15071, Appellees County of
`Santa Clara and Service Em-
`ployees
`International Union
`Local 521 in 18-15072, Appellees
`County of Santa Clara, Dulce
`Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez Avila,
`Saul Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut
`Latthivongskorn, Norma Rami-
`rez and Service Employees In-
`ternational Union Local 521 in
`18-15128, Appellants Viridiana
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`12
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul
`Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut Lat-
`thivongskorn and Norma Rami-
`rez in 18-15133, Appellants Viri-
`diana Chabolla Mendoza, County
`of Santa Clara, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul
`Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut Lat-
`thivongskorn, Norma Ramirez
`and Service Employees Interna-
`in
`tional Union Local 521
`18-15134.
` Date of service:
`04/17/2018. [10840409] [18-15068,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134,
`18-15069,
`18-15070] (Boutrous, Theodore)
`[Entered: 04/17/2018 03:49 PM]
`
`4/25/18
`
`149
`
`* * * * *
`Filed (ECF) Appellees Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul Ji-
`menez Suarez, Jirayut Latthi-
`vongskorn and Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15071, 18-15128, Appellants
`Viridiana Chabolla Mendoza,
`Dulce Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez
`Avila, Saul Jimenez Suarez, Jira-
`yut Latthivongskorn and Norma
`Ramirez in 18-15133, 18-15134 ci-
`tation of supplemental authori-
`ties. Date of service: 04/25/2018.
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`13
`
`DATE
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`[10849629] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Boutrous, Theodore) [Entered:
`04/25/2018 08:55 AM]
`
`4/25/18
`
`151
`
`4/26/18
`
`152
`
`* * * * *
`Filed (ECF) Appellees Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul Ji-
`menez Suarez, Jirayut Latthi-
`vongskorn and Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15071, 18-15128, Appellants
`Viridiana Chabolla Mendoza,
`Dulce Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez
`Avila, Saul Jimenez Suarez,
`Jirayut Latthivongskorn
`and
`Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15133,
`18-15134 citation of supplemental
`authorities.
` Date of service:
`04/25/2018. [10851189] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134]—[COURT ENTERED
`FILING to correct entry [149].]
`(RY) [Entered: 04/25/2018 04:36
`PM]
`Filed (ECF) Appellees Janet Na-
`politano and Regents of the Uni-
`versity of California in 18-15068,
`18-15128, Appellants Janet Na-
`politano and Regents of the Uni-
`versity of California in 18-15133
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`14
`
`DATE
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`citation of supplemental authori-
`ties. Date of service: 04/26/2018.
`[10852623] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Davidson, Jeffrey)
`[Entered:
`04/26/2018 03:05 PM]
`
`5/1/18
`
`157
`
`* * * * *
`Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:
`OC): The parties are ordered to
`submit supplemental briefs of no
`more than fifteen double-spaced
`pages addressing the effect of
`Heckler v. Chaney, 470 U.S. 821,
`833 n.4 (1985), and Montana Air
`Chapter No. 29 v. FLRA, 898
`F.2d 753, 756–57 (9th Cir. 1990),
`on the question whether 5 U.S.C.
`§ 701(a)(2) bars judicial review of
`the Department of Homeland
`Security’s rescission of the De-
`ferred Action for Childhood Ar-
` The parties
`rivals program.
`should consider whether the re-
`scission is judicially reviewable
`as a general enforcement policy,
`rather than as a single-shot non-
`enforcement decision.
` See
`Crowley Caribbean Transp., Inc.
`v. Pena, 37 F.3d 671, 676 (D.C.
`Cir. 1994); NAACP v. Trump,
`Nos. 17-1907 & 17-2325, 2018 WL
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`DATE
`
`15
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`1920079, at *11–17 (D.D.C. Apr.
`24, 2018) (interpreting the stan-
`dard in Crowley). The briefs
`shall be filed on or before May
`11, 2018. [10857346] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134, 18-80037] (OC) [En-
`tered: 05/01/2018 12:58 PM]
`
`5/11/18
`
`166
`
`5/11/18
`
`167
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Supplemental
`Brief for review. Submitted by
`Appellees Viridiana Chabolla
`Mendoza, Dulce Garcia, Miriam
`Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn
`and Norma Ramirez in 18-15071,
`18-15128, Appellants Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Dulce Garcia,
`Miriam Gonzalez Avila, Saul Ji-
`menez Suarez, Jirayut Latthi-
`vongskorn and Norma Ramirez
`in 18-15133, 18-15134. Date of
`service: 05/11/2018. [10870059]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Boutrous,
`Theodore) [Entered: 05/11/2018
`02:28 PM]
`Submitted (ECF) Supplemental
`Brief for review. Submitted by
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen and
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`16
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`USDHS in 18-15068, Appellants
`Kirstjen Nielsen, USA
`and
`USDHS in 18-15069, Appellants
`Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump and USA in 18-15070, Ap-
`pellants Kirstjen Nielsen, Don-
`ald J. Trump, USA and USDHS
`in 18-15071, Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen, Jefferson B. Sessions,
`III, Donald J. Trump and USDHS
`in 18-15072, 18-15128, Appellees
`Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump, USA and USDHS
`in
`18-15133, 18-15134.
` Date of
`service: 05/11/2018. [10870142]
`[18-15068, 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133, 18-15134] (Stern, Mark)
`[Entered: 05/11/2018 03:04 PM]
`Submitted (ECF) Supplemental
`Brief for review. Submitted by
`Appellees Janet Napolitano and
`Regents of the University of Cal-
`ifornia in 18-15068, Appellee City
`of San Jose in 18-15070, Appel-
`lees City of San Jose, Janet Na-
`politano and Regents of the Uni-
`versity of California in 18-15128.
`Date of service:
` 05/11/2018.
`[10870151] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`
`
`168
`
`DATE
`
`5/11/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`17
`
`DATE
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`(Davidson, Jeffrey)
`05/11/2018 03:11 PM]
`
`[Entered:
`
`5/11/18
`
`172
`
`5/15/18
`
`179
`
`* * * * *
`Submitted (ECF) Supplemental
`Brief for review. Submitted by
`Appellees State of California,
`State of Maine, State of Mary-
`land and State of Minnesota in
`18-15069, 18-15128, Appellants
`State of California, State of
`Maine, State of Maryland and
`State of Minnesota in 18-15133.
`Date of service:
` 05/11/2018.
`[10870452] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`—[COURT UPDATE:
` At-
`tached corrected brief. 5/14/2018
`by TYL] (Mongan, Michael) [En-
`tered: 05/11/2018 05:10 PM]
`
`* * * * *
`ARGUED AND SUBMITTED
`TO KIM MCLANE WARD-
`LAW,
`JACQUELINE
`H.
`NGUYEN and JOHN B. OW-
`ENS.
`
`[10873596]
`[18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134]
`(Witt, Dusty)
`[En-
`tered: 05/15/2018 04:18 PM]
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`18
`
`DATE
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`
`5/21/18
`
`182
`
`6/22/18
`
`184
`
`* * * * *
`Filed
`(ECF) Appellees Dulce
`Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez Avila,
`Saul Jimenez Suarez, Jirayut
`Latthivongskorn, Norma Rami-
`rez and Viridiana Chabolla Men-
`doza in 18-15071, 18-15128, Ap-
`pellants Dulce Garcia, Miriam
`Gonzalez Avila, Saul Jimenez
`Suarez, Jirayut Latthivongskorn,
`Norma Ramirez and Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza in 18-15133,
`18-15134 citation of supplemental
`authorities.
` Date of service:
`05/21/2018. [10880216] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15071,
`18-15070,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134]—[COURT UPDATE:
`Attached searchable version of
`letter.
` 05/21/2018 by RY]—
`[Edited 05/21/2018 by RY] (Ros-
`enbaum, Mark)
`[Entered:
`05/21/2018 02:59 PM]
`
`* * * * *
`Filed (ECF) Appellants Kirstjen
`Nielsen and USDHS in 18-15068,
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen, USA
`and USDHS in 18-15069, Appel-
`lants Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump and USA
`in 18-15070,
`Appellants Kirstjen Nielsen,
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`19
`
`185
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`Donald J. Trump, USA and
`USDHS in 18-15071, Appellants
`Kirstjen Nielsen, Donald J.
`Trump, Jefferson B. Sessions,
`III and USDHS
`in 18-15072,
`18-15128 citation of supplemental
`authorities.
` Date of service:
`06/22/2018. [10919589] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134] (Wright, Abby) [En-
`tered: 06/22/2018 04:04 PM]
`Filed
`(ECF) Appellees USA,
`USDHS, Donald J. Trump and
`Kirstjen Nielsen
`in 18-15133,
`18-15134 citation of supplemental
`authorities.
` Date of service:
`06/28/2018. [10925146] [18-15068,
`18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128,
`18-15133,
`18-15134] (Wright, Abby) [En-
`tered: 06/28/2018 08:29 AM]
`Filed (ECF) Appellees Regents
`of the University of California
`and Janet Napolitano in 18-15068,
`18-15128, Appellants Regents of
`the University of California and
`Janet Napolitano
`in 18-15133
`citation of supplemental authori-
`ties. Date of service: 07/02/2018.
`[10928492] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`
`186
`
`DATE
`
`6/28/18
`
`7/2/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`20
`
`187
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Davidson, Jeffrey)
`[Entered:
`07/02/2018 09:51 AM]
`Filed (ECF) Appellees State of
`California, State of Maine, State
`of Maryland and State of Minne-
`sota in 18-15069, 18-15128, Ap-
`pellants State of California, State
`of Maine, State of Maryland and
`State of Minnesota in 18-15133
`citation of supplemental authori-
`ties. Date of service: 07/02/2018.
`[10928647] [18-15068, 18-15069,
`18-15070,
`18-15071,
`18-15072,
`18-15128, 18-15133, 18-15134]
`(Mongan, Michael)
`[Entered:
`07/02/2018 10:39 AM]
`Filed
`(ECF) Appellees Dulce
`Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez Avila,
`Saul Jimenez Suarez, Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Norma Rami-
`rez and Jirayut Latthivongskorn
`in 18-15071, Appellants Dulce
`Garcia, Miriam Gonzalez Avila,
`Saul Jimenez Suarez, Viridiana
`Chabolla Mendoza, Norma Rami-
`rez and Jirayut Latthivongskorn
`in 18-15134 citation of supple-
`mental authorities.
` Date of
`service: 07/02/2018. [10928704]
`[18-15068, 18-15071, 18-15134]
`—[COURT UPDATE: Spread
`
`188
`
`DATE
`
`7/2/18
`
`7/2/18
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`21
`
`189
`
`DOCKET
`NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
`to
`cases 18-15069, 18-15070,
`18-15072, 18-15128, and 18-15133.
`7/2/2018 by TYL]
`(Boutrous,
`Theodore) [Entered: 07/02/2018
`10:58 AM]
`Filed (ECF) Appellees Janet Na-
`politano and Regents of the Uni-
`versity of California in 1

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket