Trials
`Kamholz, Scott; Trials
`John Bauer; Kongsik Kim; Andrew Schultz; Jane Remillard; Amy Mandragouras; PGR2019-00002; Robbins,
`Jennifer L
`RE: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`Thursday, March 26, 2020 10:58:55 AM
`
`From:
`To:
`Cc:
`
`Subject:
`Date:
`
`[EXTERNAL]
`Counsel,
`
`You are authorized to file this email chain as an exhibit.
`
`Regards,
`
`Andrew Kellogg,
`Supervisory Paralegal
`Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`USPTO
`andrew.kellogg@uspto.gov
`(571)272-7822
`
`From: Kamholz, Scott <SKamholz@cov.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2020 9:38 AM
`To: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: John Bauer <john.bauer@nelsonmullins.com>; Kongsik Kim <kongsik.kim@nelsonmullins.com>;
`Andrew Schultz <andrew.schultz@nelsonmullins.com>; Jane Remillard
`<Jane.Remillard@nelsonmullins.com>; Amy Mandragouras
`<Amy.Mandragouras@nelsonmullins.com>; PGR2019-00002 <PGR2019-00002@cov.com>; Robbins,
`Jennifer L <jrobbins@cov.com>
`Subject: RE: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`
`Dear Mr. Kellogg,
`
`Yes, a clean corrected transcript is available. Are the parties also authorized to file this
`email chain as an exhibit, in order to establish for the record that the Board authorized the
`clean corrected transcript? Alternatively, we can supply the clean corrected transcript for
`the Board to enter into the record itself.
`
`With thanks,
`Scott Kamholz
`
`From: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2020 9:25 AM
`To: Kamholz, Scott <SKamholz@cov.com>; Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: John Bauer <john.bauer@nelsonmullins.com>; Kongsik Kim <kongsik.kim@nelsonmullins.com>;
`Andrew Schultz <andrew.schultz@nelsonmullins.com>; Jane Remillard
`<Jane.Remillard@nelsonmullins.com>; Amy Mandragouras
`<Amy.Mandragouras@nelsonmullins.com>; PGR2019-00002 <PGR2019-00002@cov.com>; Robbins,
`
`1/6
`
`

`

`Jennifer L <jrobbins@cov.com>
`Subject: RE: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`
`[EXTERNAL]
`Mr. Kamholz,
`
`Please file a clean transcript if possible.
`
`Regards,
`
`Andrew Kellogg,
`Supervisory Paralegal
`Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`USPTO
`andrew.kellogg@uspto.gov
`(571)272-7822
`
`From: Kamholz, Scott <SKamholz@cov.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2020 9:17 AM
`To: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: John Bauer <john.bauer@nelsonmullins.com>; Kongsik Kim <kongsik.kim@nelsonmullins.com>;
`Andrew Schultz <andrew.schultz@nelsonmullins.com>; Jane Remillard
`<Jane.Remillard@nelsonmullins.com>; Amy Mandragouras
`<Amy.Mandragouras@nelsonmullins.com>; PGR2019-00002 <PGR2019-00002@cov.com>; Robbins,
`Jennifer L <jrobbins@cov.com>
`Subject: RE: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`
`Dear Mr. Kellogg,
`
`Should the corrected transcript be in clean or marked-up format?
`
`With thanks,
`Scott Kamholz
`
`From: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2020 9:12 AM
`To: Kamholz, Scott <SKamholz@cov.com>; Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: John Bauer <john.bauer@nelsonmullins.com>; Kongsik Kim <kongsik.kim@nelsonmullins.com>;
`Andrew Schultz <andrew.schultz@nelsonmullins.com>; Jane Remillard
`<Jane.Remillard@nelsonmullins.com>; Amy Mandragouras
`<Amy.Mandragouras@nelsonmullins.com>; PGR2019-00002 <PGR2019-00002@cov.com>; Robbins,
`Jennifer L <jrobbins@cov.com>
`Subject: RE: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`
`[EXTERNAL]
`Counsel,
`
`2/6
`
`

`

`In an email to the Board dated March 23, 2020, the parties requested permission to file a corrected
`transcript of the oral hearing to address various transcription errors listed in the email. The request is
`granted. The parties are authorized to file a corrected transcript, The corrections in the corrected
`transcript shall be limited to the errors listed in the March 23 2020 email.
`
`Regards,
`
`Andrew Kellogg,
`Supervisory Paralegal
`Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`USPTO
`andrew.kellogg@uspto.gov
`(571)272-7822
`
`
`
`From: Kamholz, Scott <SKamholz@cov.com>
`Sent: Monday, March 23, 2020 2:04 PM
`To: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: John Bauer <john.bauer@nelsonmullins.com>; Kongsik Kim <kongsik.kim@nelsonmullins.com>;
`Andrew Schultz <andrew.schultz@nelsonmullins.com>; Jane Remillard
`<Jane.Remillard@nelsonmullins.com>; Amy Mandragouras
`<Amy.Mandragouras@nelsonmullins.com>; PGR2019-00002 <PGR2019-00002@cov.com>; Robbins,
`Jennifer L <jrobbins@cov.com>
`Subject: PGR2019-00002 / transcript corrections
`
`To the Board,
`
`Petitioner and Patent Owner jointly request leave to submit a notice of corrections to the
`transcript entered as Paper 37 in the record of PGR2019-00002. The parties have
`conferred and agree on the following list of corrections to the transcript. Given the large
`number of corrections, and in the interest of preserving an accurate record of the
`proceeding, the parties also request leave to submit a corrected transcript. A marked-up
`version of the transcript is attached to this email and shows all the corrections the parties
`jointly propose.
`
`
`Correction
`Replace “MINTZ, LEVIN, COHN, FERRIS GLOVESY AND POPEO, P.C.
`701 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE NW,
`Suite 900
`WASHINGTON, DC 20004
`202-434-7399”
`with
`NELSON MULLINS
`280 PARK AVENUE
`NEW YORK, NY 10017
`646-428-2615
`
`replace every occurrence of “Kamholtz” with --Kamholz--
`
`replace “patent consultant” with --backup counsel--
`
`Location
`2
`
`Pages 2, 3,
`33–38, and 85
`3:21-22
`
`3/6
`
`

`

`6:7
`8:14
`8:18
`8:26
`10:18
`11:6
`11:7
`11:17
`12:17
`12:26
`13:4
`13:5
`13:12
`13:17
`14:6
`15:15
`15:20
`16:21
`18:24
`
`21:23
`Pages 24, 48,
`77–79, and
`83–84
`29:8
`30:3
`33:12
`33:21
`35:15
`36:17
`37:5
`38:3
`38:4
`38:7
`40:17
`40:19
`42:1
`42:5 and 42:8
`43:14
`43:16
`44:18
`45:13
`47:8–9
`48:11
`48:25
`48:26
`49:1
`50:1
`50:13, 50:20,
`50:25, and
`
`Replace “qualification” with --qualifications--
`Replace “acknowledge” with --acknowledged--
`Replace“Order” with --Owner--
`Replace, delete “I’m”
`Replace “sort of” with --in short--
`Replace “that that” with --that--
`Replace “any” with --anti--
`Replace “sort of” with --in short--
`Replace “expressed” with --express--
`Replace “incidents” with --incidence--
`Replace “incidents” with --incidence--
`Replace “AMO” with --AOM--
`Replace “incidents” with --incidence--
`Replace “Kupathi (ph)” with -- Boopathy --
`Replace “19” with --18 --
`Replace “suppression” with --expression--
`Replace “dong” with --Dong--
`Replace “show” with --say--
`Replace “any cancer activity of Korman, any cancer” with --anti cancer activity
`of Korman, anti cancer--
`Replace “does who that” with --demonstrate--
`replace every occurrence of “O’Mahoney” or “Mahoney” with --O’Mahony--
`
`Replace “is” with --it’s--
`Replace “times’ with --kinds--
`replace “approach the slides” with --approach with slides--
`replace “suppose” with --support--
`replace “TI” with --I--
`insert --is-- before “that”
`replace “could then” with --art couldn’t--
`replace “MR.” with --JUDGE--
`replace “an angle” with --enablement--
`replace “enabled” with --nonenabled--
`Insert --of-- before “cancer”
`delete “(ph)”
`replace “Kendoth (ph)” with --Kandoth--
`replace “Kendoth” with --Kandoth--
`replace “therapist” with --therapies--
`replace “therapizes” with --therapies--
`replace “disturbed” with --disturbing,--
`replace “Nobel Price” with --Nobel Prize--
`replace “A and P244 (ph), A and P514 (ph)” with --AMP244, AMP514--
`replace “heterogenous” with --heterogeneous--
`replace “invitro” with --in vitro--
`replace “affect” with --effect--
`replace “ration” with --ratio--
`replace “read” with --reach--
`replace “perimetric” with --parametric--
`
`4/6
`
`

`

`51:6
`52:26
`53:10
`53:18
`54:5
`54:6
`57:16
`58:25
`59:11
`60:19
`60:20
`60:22
`
`61:21 and
`62:22
`61:22
`
`61:24
`62:18
`62:19
`62:20
`63:4
`63:6
`63:7
`64:18
`64:19
`64:25
`65:1, 66:3, and
`66:4
`65:22
`65:23
`65:23–24
`66:2
`67:22
`68:11
`70:10
`71:7
`73:1
`77:13
`78:3-4
`78-11
`79:5
`79:6
`79:25
`80:3
`81:3
`82:2
`
`82:4
`82:14
`83:21
`
`replace “there” with --they’re -- --
`replace “conclude” with --conclusion--
`replace “demonstrative” with --demonstratives--
`replace “prime facia” with --prima facie--
`replace “requires” with --required--
`replace “apriority” with --a priori--
`replace “JUDGES” with --JUDGE--
`replace “In” with --It is--
`replace “way I they” with --way if they--
`replace “that POSA” with --that the POSA, --
`replace “that it stated, do not support” with --that what it stated does not support-
`-
`replace “Persse” with -- Perše--
`
`replace “"That” with --that-- and place quotation marks around
`“chemopreventative treatment”
`insert “--” and open quotation mark before “can”
`replace “"First”” with --first--
`replace “dahi” with --Dahi--
`delete quotation mark after “carcinogen.”
`replace “tough” with --touch--
`replace “prevail in” with --prevail on--
`replace “round” with --ground--
`replace “reproduceable” with --reproducible--
`replace “briefly” with --brief--
`replace “a reproducible” with --irreproducible--
`replace “opposer” with --POSA--
`
`place quotation marks around “several possibilities,” and “may be probable.”
`place quotation marks around “may suggest”
`place quotation marks around “may account for anti-tumor mechanisms.”
`replace “date” with --data=
`replace “Yews” with --Yes--
`replace “Eposa” with --A POSA--
`Replace “any” with --anti--
`Replace “Wang’s” with --Wands--
`Replace “wanted to find” with --defined--
`Replace “Many’s (ph) ” with --Mani’s--
`Replace “and Al (ph)” with --et al.--
`Replace “suppressing in” with --suppression--
`Replace “next” with --net--
`Replace “3564” with --35624--
`Replace “thought” with --taught--
`Replace “number” with --Namely--
`replace “We” with --If we--
`replace “Dr. Braun gainsayed Dr. Mohania and” with --Dr. Braun gainsaid Dr.
`Mani on--
`replace “Manny’s” with --Mani’s--
`replace “as” with --is--
`replace “backline” with --black-line--
`
`5/6
`
`

`

`83:22–23
`94:17
`
`replace “part data” with --probative--
`delete “, kind of,”
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`/s/ /s/
`John A. Bauer, Reg. No. 32,554 Scott E. Kamholz, Reg. No. 48,543
`Nelson Mullins Covington & Burling LLP
`Lead Counsel for Petitioner Lead Counsel for Patent Owner
`
`
`Scott E. Kamholz, M.D., Ph.D.
`Of Counsel, Covington & Burling LLP
`One CityCenter, 850 Tenth Street, NW
`Washington, DC 20001-4956
`Direct +1 202 662 5339 | Mobile +1 617 678 0222
`skamholz@cov.com | Bio | LinkedIn | www.cov.com
`
`
`
`6/6
`
`