July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`TGn Sync, WWiSE and Mitmot closing report
`Date: 2005-07-21
`Author
`Address
`555 Union Blvd.,
`Allentown, PA 18109, USA
`190 Mathilda Place,
`Sunnyvale, CA 94086
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-
`sur-Yvette 91193 France
`
`Phone
`
`Email
`
`+1 610 712 6616
`
`mujtaba@agere.com
`
`+1 408 543 3378
`
`chansen@broadcom
`
`+33 1 69352518 Marc.de.Courville@mot
`orola.com
`
`Name
`
`Syed Aon Mujtaba
`
`Christopher
`Hansen
`
`Company
`Agere
`Systems
`
`Broadcom
`
`Marc de Courville
`
`Motorola
`
`Notice: This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 802.11. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in
`this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
`
`Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE
`Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit
`others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 802.11.
`
`Patent Policy and Procedures: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE 802 Patent Policy and Procedures <http:// ieee802.org/guides/bylaws/sb-bylaws.pdf>, including the statement
`"IEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s), including patent applications, provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder or applicant with respect to patents
`essential for compliance with both mandatory and optional portions of the standard." Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is
`essential to reduce the possibility for delays in the development process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication. Please notify the Chair
`<stuart.kerry@philips.com> as early as possible, in written or electronic form, if patented technology (or technology under patent application) might be incorporated into a draft standard being
`developed within the IEEE 802.11 Working Group. If you have questions, contact the IEEE Patent Committee Administrator at <patcom@ieee.org>.
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 1
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`DELL-1029
`10,079,707
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Name
`Adrian P. Stephens
`Alek Purkovic
`Alexander L. Cheng
`Andrew Myles
`Andy Molisch
`Brian Hart
`Brian Johnson
`Chiu Ngo
`Daisuke Takeda
`Daqing Gu
`Darren McNamara
`David Bagby
`Dongjun (DJ) Lee
`Eldad Perahia
`Eldad Zeira
`Fatih Ozluturk
`Hiroshi Oguma
`Hiroyuki Nakase
`Huanchun Ye
`Hui-Ling Lou
`Isaac Lim Wei Lih
`J. Mike Wilson
`James Chen
`
`Additional Authors:
`
`Company
`Intel Corporation
`Nortel Networks
`C-cation, Inc
`Cisco Systems
`Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
`Cisco Systems
`Nortel Networks
`Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
`Toshiba Corporation
`Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
`Toshiba Corporation
`Calypso Consulting
`Samsung Electronic Co Ltd
`Cisco Systems
`InterDigital Communications Corporation
`InterDigital Communications Corporation
`Tohoku University
`Tohoku University
`Atheros Communications
`Marvell Semiconductor
`Panasonic
`Intel Corporation
`Marvell Semiconductor
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`email
`Adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
`apurkovi@nortelnetworks.com
`AlexCheng@C-cation.com
`amyles@cisco.com
`molisch@merl.com
`brianh@cisco.com
`brjohnso@nortelnetworks.com
`chiu.ngo@samsung.com
`daisuke.takeda@toshiba.co.jp
`dgu@merl.com
`Darren.McNamara@toshiba-trel.com
`david.bagby@ieee.org
`djthekid.lee@samsung.com
`eperahia@cisco.com
`eldad.zeira@interdigital.com
`fatih.ozluturk@interdigital.com
`oguma@wit.riec.tohoku.ac.jp
`nakase@riec.tohoku.ac.jp
`hcye@atheros.com
`hlou@marvell.com
`wllim@psl.com.sg
`james.mike.wilson@intel.com
`jamesc@marvell.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 2
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Jin Zhang
`Job Oostveen
`Joe Pitarresi
`John Ketchum
`Jon Rosdahl
`Jorg Habetha
`Joseph Levy
`Kiyotaka Kobayashi
`Li Yuan
`Luke Qian
`Mary Cramer
`Masahiro Takagi
`Monisha Gosh
`Morgan Miki
`Osama Aboul-Magd
`Paul Feinberg
`Pen Li
`Peter Loc
`Robert Stacey
`Ronald Rietman
`Sanjiv Nanda
`Seigo Nakao
`Sheung Li
`Stephen Shellhammer
`Subra Dravida
`Sudheer Grandhi
`
`Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
`Royal Philips Electronics
`Intel Corporation
`Qualcomm Incorporated
`Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
`Royal Philips Electronics
`InterDigital Communications Corporation
`Panasonic
`Institute for Infocomm Research
`Cisco Systems
`Agere Systems
`Toshiba Corporation
`Royal Philips Electronics
`Sharp
`Nortel Networks
`Sony Electronics
`Royal Philips Electronics
`Marvell Semiconductor
`Intel Corporation
`Royal Phiips Electronics
`Qualcomm Incorporated
`Sanyo Electric Co Ltd
`Atheros Communications
`Qualcomm Incorporated
`Qualcomm Incorporated
`InterDigital Communications Corporation
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`jzhang@merl.com
`job.oostveen@philips.com
`joe.pitarresi@intel.com
`Johnk@qualcomm.com
`jon.rosdahl@partner.samsung.com
`joerg.habetha@philips.com
`joseph.levy@interdigital.com
`kobayashi.kiyotaka@jp.panasonic.com
`liyuan@i2r.a-star.edu.sg
`lchia@cisco.com
`mecramer@agere.com
`masahiro3.takagi@toshiba.co.jp
`monisha.ghosh@philips.com
`miki@slab.tnr.sharp.co.jp
`osama@nortelnetworks.com
`paul.feinberg@am.sony.com
`pen.li@philips.com
`ploc@marvell.com
`Robert.j.stacey@intel.com
`ronald.rietman@philips.com
`snanda@qualcomm.com
`snakao@gf.hm.rd.sanyo.co.jp
`sheung@atheros.com
`sshellham@qualcomm.com
`subrad@qualcomm.com
`sudheer.grandhi@interdigital.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 3
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Sumei Sun
`Taekon Kim
`Takashi Fukugawa
`Takashi Shono
`Takushi Kunihiro
`Teik-Kheong (TK) Tan
`Tomoko Adachi
`Tomoya Yamaura
`Tsuguhide Aoki
`Won-Joon Choi
`Xiaowen Wang
`Yasuhiko Tanabe
`Yasuhiro Tanaka
`Yoshiharu Doi
`Youngsoo Kim
`Yuichi Morioka
`Yukimasa Nagai
`
`
`
`Institute for Infocomm Research
`Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
`Panasonic
`Intel Corporation
`Sony Corporation
`Royal Philips Electronics
`Toshiba Corporation
`Sony Corporation
`Toshiba Corporation
`Atheros Communications
`Agere Systems
`Toshiba Corporation
`Sanyo Electric Co Ltd
`Sanyo Electric Co Ltd
`Samsung Electronic Co Ltd
`Sony Corporation
`Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`sunsm@i2r.a-star.edu.sg
`taekon.kim@samsung.com
`fukagawa.takashi@jp.panasonic.com
`takashi.shono@intel.com
`kuni@wcs.sony.co.jp
`tktan@philips.com
`tomo.adachi@toshiba.co.jp
`yamaura@wcs.sony.co.jp
`tsuguhide.aoki@toshiba.co.jp
`wjchoi@atheros.com
`xiaowenw@agere.com
`yasuhiko.tanabe@toshiba.co.jp
`y_tanaka@gf.hm.rd.sanyo.co.jp
`doi@gf.hm.rd.sanyo.co.jp
`KimYoungsoo@samsung.com
`morioka@wcs.sony.co.jp
`yuki-n@isl.melco.co.jp
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 4
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Markus
`Muck
`Jean-Noel
`Patillon
`Sebastien
`Simoens
`Stéphanie
`Rouquette
`Alexandre
`Ribeiro Dias
`Karine
`Gosse
`Brian
`Classon
`Keith
`Blankenship
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Motorola Labs
`
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`Parc les Algorithmes, Gif-sur-
`Yvette 91193 France
`1301 E. Algonquin Rd,
`Schaumburg IL 60196 USA
`1301 E. Algonquin Rd,
`Schaumburg IL 60196 USA
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`+33 1 69352573 muck@crm.mot.com
`
`+33 1 69352522
`
`patillon@crm.mot.co
`m
`simoens@crm.mot.co
`m
`stephanie.rouquette@
`motorola.com
`+33 5 61191924 Alexandre.ribeirodias
`@motorola.com
`+33 1 69352520 Karine.Gosse@motor
`ola.com
`Brian.Classon@moto
`rola.com
`Keith.Blankenship@
`motorola.com
`
`+33 1 69352543
`
`+33 1 69354824
`
`+1 8475765675
`
`+1 8475381311
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 5
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`VK Jones
`Richard van Nee
`Ali Raissinia
`Allert van Zelst
`Bruce Edwards
`Matthew Fischer
`Chris Hansen
`Tushar Moorti
`Chris Young
`Takashi Ishidoshiro
`Masato Kato
`Dave Hedberg
`Cenk Kose
`Jim Petranovich
`
`Airgo Networks
`Airgo Networks
`Airgo Networks
`Airgo Networks
`Broadcom
`Broadcom
`Broadcom
`Broadcom
`Broadcom
`Buffalo
`Buffalo
`Conexant
`Conexant
`Conexant
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`vkjones@airgonetworks.com
`richardvannnee@airgonetworks.com
`aliraissinia@airgonetworks.com
`allertvanzelst@airgonetworks.com
`bedwards@broadcom.com
`mfischer@broadcom.com
`chansen@broadcom.com
`tushar@broadcom.com
`cyoung@broadcom.com
`doshir@melcoinc.co.jp
`mkato@melcoinc.co.jp
`dave.hedberg@conexant.com
`cenk.kose@conexant.com
`jim.petranovich@conexant.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 6
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Michael Seals
`Mark Webster
`Menzo Wentink
`Taehyun Jeon
`Sok-kyu Lee
`Heejung Yu
`Mustafa Eroz
`Lakshmi Iyer
`Lin-Nan Lee
`Feng-Wen Sun
`Marc de Courville
`Markus Muck
`Alexandre Ribeiro-
`Dias
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Conexant
`Conexant
`Conexant
`ETRI
`ETRI
`ETRI
`Hughes Network Systems
`Hughes Network Systems
`Hughes Network Systems
`Hughes Network Systems
`Motorola
`Motorola
`Motorola
`
`michael.seals@conexant.com
`mark.webster@conexant.com
`menzo.wentink@conexant.com
`thjeon@etri.re.kr
`sk-lee@etri.re.kr
`heejung@etri.re.kr
`feroz@hns.com
`liyer@hns.com
`llee@hns.com
`fsun@hns.com
`marc.de.courville@motorola.com
`markus.muck@motorola.com
`alexandre.ribeirodias@motorola.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 7
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Stephanie Rouquette-Leveil
`Sebastien Simoens
`Nico van Waes
`John Chang
`Sheng Lee
`Tom Pare
`David Tung
`Der-Zheng Liu
`Ravi Mahadevappa
`Stephan ten Brink
`Gabriella Convertino
`Mike Moreton
`Fabio Osnato
`Pratima Pai
`
`Motorola
`Motorola
`Nokia
`Ralink
`Ralink
`Ralink
`Ralink
`Realtek
`Realtek
`Realtek
`STMicroelectronics
`STMicroelectronics
`STMicroelectronics
`STMicroelectronics
`
`stephanie.rouquette@motorola.com
`sebastien.simoens@motorola.com
`Nico.vanWaes@nokia.com
`john_chang@ralinktech.com.tw
`shenghlee@ralinktech.com
`tpare@ralinktech.com
`dtung@ralinktech.com
`dzliu@realtek.com.tw
`ravi@realtek-us.com
`stenbrink@realtek-us.com
`gabriella.convertino@st.com
`mike.moreton@st.com
`fabio.osnato@st.com
`pratima.pai@st.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 8
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`Vincenzo Scarpa
`Massimiliano Siti
`George Vlantis
`Anuj Batra
`Srikanth Gummadi
`Dale Hocevar
`Richard Williams
`Keith Chugg
`Paul Gray
`Bob Ward
`Jeng-Hong Chen
`Pansop Kim
`Alfred Lin
`Wei-Chung Peng
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`STMicroelectronics
`STMicroelectronics
`STMicroelectronics
`Texas Instruments
`Texas Instruments
`Texas Instruments
`Texas Instruments
`TrellisWare
`TrellisWare
`TrellisWare
`Winbond Electronics
`Winbond Electronics
`Winbond Electronics
`Winbond Electronics
`
`vincenzo.scarpa@st.com
`massimiliano.siti@st.com
`george.vlantis@st.com
`batra@ti.com
`sgummadi@ti.com
`hocevar@ti.com
`richard@ti.com
`kchugg@trellisware.com
`pgray@trellisware.com
`bward@trellisware.com
`jhchen2@winbond.com
`pkim@winbond.com
`halin@winbond.com
`wcpeng0@winbond.com
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 9
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Abstract
`
` This document provides an update on the
`joint proposal effort this week among TGn
`Sync, WWiSE, and Mitmot
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 10
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Procedural Updates
`
` Adopted a process for creating the joint
`proposal
`■ Adopted a decision making procedure
`■ Agreed on web tools to help facilitate document
`sharing and conference calls
` Established a firm and aggressive schedule
`for F2F and conference calls
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 11
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`PHY/MAC Teams Update
`
` Created a sequence of discussion points
` Discussed motions for adding draft text to
`the joint proposal
` Fielded detailed technical presentations on
`topics of mutual interest
` Created tiger teams to accelerate technical
`progress
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 12
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Next Steps
`
` Weekly conference calls, starting next week
`■ One for the MAC, one for the PHY
` F2F meeting in Japan in August
` Will upload one week prior to IEEE in
`Anaheim either a draft joint proposal or a
`progress report
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 13
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Joint Proposal Timeline
`
`San Fran
`
`F2F
`
`Anaheim
`Goal to Submit
`Draft Joint Prop
`F2F
`
`Vancouver
`Final Joint Prop
`Confirm Vote
`F2F
`
`Hawaii
`Draft proposal
`owned by TGn
`
`JAP
`F2F
`
`EUR
`F2F
`
`Weekly Conference Calls between F2F Meetings
`
`JUL
`
`AUG
`
`SEP
`2005
`
`OCT
`
`NOV
`
`DEC
`
`JAN
`2006
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 14
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`

`

`July 2005
`
`doc.: IEEE 802.11-05/786r0
`
`Submission
`
`Slide 15
`
`S. A. Mujtaba (Agere), C. Hansen (Broadcom), M. de Courville (Motorola), et. al.
`
`