11/17/23, 2:29 PM
`
`Docket Navigator - Binder
`
`PATENT RESEARCH TOOLS ©
`
`TimetoTrial
`
`@DocketNavigator
`
`
`
` Courts Judges
`
`Average Months
`
`Median Months
`
`Maximum Months
`
`Minimum Months
`
`>. West Virginia Northem District
`
`Date Range to Include
`
`January 1, 2008 — November 17, 2023
`
`Date Range to Exclude
`
`x
`
`x
`
`S
`
`National:
`
`32
`
`®
`
`National:
`
`29
`
`48
`a
`
`National:
`
`81
`
`20
`cs
`
`National:
`
`10
`
`TIME TO TRIAL FOR NDWV1
`:
`ya
`2
`
`TIME TO TRIAL COMPARISON2
`
`BB all Courts/Judges
`BB Selected Court/Judge
`
`: z
`
`0.5
`
`e
`
`e
`
`e
`
`Exclude cases with transfers
`
`Exclude cases with Stays
`
`Exclude Outliers?
`Exclude cases with Consolidations
`
`Case Size*
`
`
`
`20
`40
`60
`{| Small [—) Medium[} Large
`Numberof Months
`Number of
`Months
`
`Jury and Bench Trials®
`{_] Bench Trials [| Jury Trials
`
`1. A histogram bins numeric data into groups, so you can compare the size of each group.In this chart, each bar shows the number oftrials during each 6-month period after the case filing date.
`2. This chart shows how widely or narrowly distributed time to trial was in the selected courts. A shorter box indicates that trial timing was more consistent, while a longer box indicates that trial timing was more
`varied. The box itself represents the middle 50% ofthe data, while the quickest 25% and slowest 25% of trials are represented by the lines extending from the box.
`3. Data points outside the 3rd and 97th quantiles are considered outliers and are excluded when this switch is toggled on (On by Default).
`4. Small, Medium, and Large cases are defined by the number of patent infringement Accusations therein. Small cases are those with 4 or fewer accusations. Medium cases have between 5 and 9 accusations.
`Large
`have 10 or more accusations.
`5. Bench trials are defined as those resulting in Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law issued by a judge. Jury trials are defined as trials resulting in a Verdict returned by jurors.
`6. Data on this page is based on the time from the filing date of a case (or the earliest case in a groupof transferred/consolidated cases) to the time of the earliest document indicating that a trial occurred such as a
`Verdict (indicating a jury trial) or Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (indicating a bench trial).
`
`https://search.docketnavigator.com/patent/binder/0/0?print=true&e=false
`
`Biocon Exhibit 1065 Page 1
`
`Biocon Exhibit 1065 Page 1
`
`